Skip to main content

Resultados relacionados

Resultados totales (Incluyendo duplicados): 8
Encontrada(s) 1 página(s)

DAU Arxiu Digital de la Universitat Ramon Llull
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

The pitfalls of co-creation: reflections from Health CASCADE facilitators on critical events, consequences and preventive and mitigating strategies

  • Verloigne, Maïté
  • Chastin, Sebastien F. M.
  • An, Qingfan
  • Anand Kumar, Vinayak
  • de Boer, Janneke
  • Dall, Philippa
  • Delfmann, Lea Rahel
  • Giné-Garriga, Maria
  • Goh, Kunshan
  • Lippke, Sonia
  • McCaffrey, Lauren
  • Pappa, Dimitra
  • Schreier, Margrit
  • Vogelsang, Mira
  • Wadell, Karin
  • Altenburg, Teatske
Objectives Co-creation is increasingly applied in public health research, particularly to develop solutions. Due to the unpredictable and ‘messy’ nature of co-creation, co-creation processes often do not go as planned. To inform facilitators of co-creation research, we aimed to identify critical events in planning, conducting, evaluating and reporting of co-creation and to provide strategies to prevent or mitigate them, by reflecting on co-creation projects within the Health CASCADE project. Study design Qualitative study design. Methods Online or in-person reflection sessions were held with facilitators of six co-creation projects, across various sectors, in different populations, and addressing diverse topics. Facilitators were asked to reflect on critical events in their project that could have negatively impacted the co-creators, the co-creation process, or the co-created solution, and to identify preventive and mitigating measures. Two researchers analysed meeting summaries using inductive thematic analysis. Results We identified 16 overarching themes, representing critical events from planning to reporting, including not recruiting the 'right' participants, low engagement, lack of motivation for implementation, and biased evaluations. These can result in insufficient inclusion of diverse opinions and reduced co-creation time, which in turn can lead to less effective solutions and lack of trust in co-creation. We identified various preventive (e.g., scheduling reflection meetings beforehand) and mitigating (e.g., having a co-facilitator in case of difficulties) strategies. Conclusions The results highlight the crucial role of facilitators in making co-creation an effective approach in public health. Allocating ample time for facilitator training beforehand and ongoing reflection during the co-creation project is essential., info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion
DAU Arxiu Digital de la Universitat Ramon Llull
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Cocreating a digital patient preparedness tool for international students accessing primary care in Germany: A convergent methods study within the health CASCADE network

  • Anand Kumar, Vinayak
  • Schreier, Margrit
  • Giné-Garriga, Maria
  • Ortmann, Maria
  • Belmokhtar, Fatima
  • Grineviciute, Simona
  • Quan, Tran Ngoc-Huong
  • Aluru, Likhita
  • Lippke, Sonia
Digital health interventions (DHIs) are a potential tool to address communication challenges in primary care medicine by improving patient participation, treatment adherence, and self-management of chronic diseases. However, Germany’s digital health infrastructure remains underdeveloped compared to other Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) countries. Designing tailored, context-sensitive tools requires a deep understanding of patient needs, particularly for underserved populations navigating complex health care systems. Participatory approaches that actively involve end-users and stakeholders can help ensure that digital health tools are responsive to these needs. Behavioral science frameworks such as the Behavior Change Wheel (BCW), which incorporates the Capability, Opportunity, Motivation–Behavior (COM-B) model, can further support this process. Such technologies, developed using cocreation and behavior change frameworks, may improve health outcomes for underserved patient populations by addressing context-specific needs. This study explores how cocreation and behavioral science can inform the adaptation of a digital patient preparedness tool for international students accessing primary care in Germany. Objective: This study aimed to gain insight into international students’ experiences with primary care in Germany and explore whether adapting an existing digital patient preparedness intervention could address communication challenges and improve the standard of care. Using cocreation methods and the Behavior Change Wheel (BCW), we identified key design specifications and behavior change levers to inform tool development. Methods: A mixed methods design was used to identify design specifications for a DHI across 4 cocreation workshops with 12 students at an international university in Germany. Quantitative data were used for descriptive insights, and qualitative data were analyzed using qualitative content analysis. Workshops were informed by the BCW and the Health CASCADE cocreation methods selector tool. Results: Cocreators reported feeling misunderstood, anxious, and ill-informed during primary care interactions, with system-level barriers compounding communication difficulties. Despite this, many engaged in preparatory behaviors (eg, note-taking) to manage uncertainty and structure their consultations. Feedback on an existing digital intervention was mixed: while cocreators appreciated its intent, structured lesson formats were seen as too time-consuming. Cocreators preferred a concise, interactive design. Communication prompts, appointment scheduling, and personalized feedback were frequently requested features, though tool adoption was seen as contingent on addressing broader system-level frustrations. Conclusions: International students’ negative health care experiences, often stemming from unclear communication, perceived indifference, and difficulty navigating an unfamiliar medical system, may be mitigated through codesigned, personalized digital interventions. Frequently requested features, such as appointment scheduling, clinic directories, test result access, and interactive tools like chatbots, may help address barriers related to system navigation, communication, and access. This study demonstrates how cocreation methods can be integrated with the BCW to inform the development of context-sensitive digital health tools for specific target groups., info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion
DAU Arxiu Digital de la Universitat Ramon Llull
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Evaluating the co-creation process in public health interventions: the PROSECO framework

  • Longworth, Giuliana R.
  • Agnello, Danielle Marie
  • Chastin, Sebastien F. M.
  • Davis, Aaron
  • Senabre Hidalgo, Enric
  • Villanueva Baselga, Sergio
  • McCaffrey, Lauren
  • Zapata-Restrepo, Jorge Raul
  • Coll-Planas, Laura
  • Giné-Garriga, Maria
Objectives To date, there is a lack of evaluation frameworks to guide the planning and conducting of the evaluation of co-creation in public health. This study aims to identify and set the components of the PROSECO framework (PROcesS Evaluation framework for CO-creation) to support the evaluation of co-creation processes in public health interventions. Study design A multi-step, iterative approach combining the outcomes of two scoping reviews, expert validation, and design refinement. Methods The PROSECO framework was developed in three steps. Firstly, collecting results from two scoping reviews on process evaluation for co-creation and evaluation of co-creation methods. The scoping review results were analysed and refined by a selected group of experts and through a three-round anonymous survey. Based on those findings, the framework visualisation was developed and designed through multiple design iterations. Results The PROcesS Evaluation framework for CO-creation, called the PROSECO framework, was developed to assist researchers and stakeholders in evaluating a co-creation process. The framework comprises a list of 37 components grouped under the five dimensions of Delivery, Participation, Experiential, Context, and Impact. Conclusions PROSECO is the first framework to offer a systematic approach to evaluating co-creation. By integrating a diverse set of evaluation components, encompassing delivery, participation, experiential, impact, and context, it offers a flexible and comprehensive approach to address the complex nature of co-creation., info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion
DAU Arxiu Digital de la Universitat Ramon Llull
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Principles and attributes of evidence-based co-creation: From naïve praxis toward a trustworthy methodology - A Health CASCADE study

  • Chastin, Sebastien F. M.
  • Smith, Niamh
  • Agnello, Danielle Marie
  • An, Qingfan
  • Altenburg, Teatske
  • Balaskas, George
  • de Boer, Janneke
  • Cardon, Greet
  • Chin A Paw, Mai
  • Chrifou, Rabab
  • Dall, Philippa
  • Davis, Aaron
  • Deforche, B.
  • Delfmann, Lea Rahel
  • Giné-Garriga, Maria
  • Goh, Kunshan
  • Hunter, Simon C.
  • Leask, C. F.
  • Lippke, Sonia
  • Loisel, Quentin Emile Armand
  • Longworth, Giuliana R.
  • McCaffrey, Lauren
  • Messiha, Katrina
  • Morejon, Sacra
  • Pappa, Dimitra
  • Papadopoulos, H.
  • Ryde, G. C.
  • Sandlund, Marlene
  • Schreier, Margrit
  • Steiner, Artur
  • Verloigne, Maïté
  • Vogelsang, Mira
  • Wadell, Karin
Objectives Co-creation is recognised as a promising methodology for addressing complex public health issues by leveraging the collective intelligence of multiple stakeholders to develop tailored solutions. However, there is a lack of clarity and significant fragmentation in the concept. This study aims to define the fundamental attributes and guiding principles of co-creation to establish it as a rigorous, evidence-based, and trustworthy methodology. Study design A participatory concept mapping process based on the Differentiae Principle was employed. Methods The study consisted of four stages: 1) systematic extraction of attributes and their definition from traditional scientific and participatory research methodological literature, 2) screening, 3) semantic analysis and clustering into principles using Natural Language Processing and Large Language Models and 4) selection of a final set of attributes and development of principles. The study involved 50 participants with diverse backgrounds within and outside the Health CASCADE Network over 18 months. Results The study identified 105 candidate attributes. A set of 38 was selected from which 10 key principles were derived (open access, recognised contribution, ethics and legal, transparency, rigorous evaluation, clear problem, plural evidence, critical reflection, diversity, and structured and flexible processes) across three domains: Governance, Scientific and Methodological Rigour, and Collective Intelligence Processes. Conclusions The attributes and guiding principles provide a comprehensive foundations for evidence-based co-creation, enhancing its trustworthiness, transparency, reliability, and impact in public health and other fields. Future research and practice should use these principles and attributes to refine and implement co-creation effectively., info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion
Recercat. Dipósit de la Recerca de Catalunya
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Principles and attributes of evidence-based co-creation: From naïve praxis toward a trustworthy methodology - A Health CASCADE study

  • Chastin, Sebastien F. M.
  • Smith, Niamh
  • Agnello, Danielle Marie
  • An, Qingfan
  • Altenburg, Teatske
  • Balaskas, George
  • de Boer, Janneke
  • Cardon, Greet
  • Chin A Paw, Mai
  • Chrifou, Rabab
  • Dall, Philippa
  • Davis, Aaron
  • Deforche, B.
  • Delfmann, Lea Rahel
  • Giné-Garriga, Maria
  • Goh, Kunshan
  • Hunter, Simon C.
  • Leask, C. F.
  • Lippke, Sonia
  • Loisel, Quentin Emile Armand
  • Longworth, Giuliana R.
  • McCaffrey, Lauren
  • Messiha, Katrina
  • Morejon, Sacra
  • Pappa, Dimitra
  • Papadopoulos, H.
  • Ryde, G. C.
  • Sandlund, Marlene
  • Schreier, Margrit
  • Steiner, Artur
  • Verloigne, Maïté
  • Vogelsang, Mira
  • Wadell, Karin
Objectives Co-creation is recognised as a promising methodology for addressing complex public health issues by leveraging the collective intelligence of multiple stakeholders to develop tailored solutions. However, there is a lack of clarity and significant fragmentation in the concept. This study aims to define the fundamental attributes and guiding principles of co-creation to establish it as a rigorous, evidence-based, and trustworthy methodology. Study design A participatory concept mapping process based on the Differentiae Principle was employed. Methods The study consisted of four stages: 1) systematic extraction of attributes and their definition from traditional scientific and participatory research methodological literature, 2) screening, 3) semantic analysis and clustering into principles using Natural Language Processing and Large Language Models and 4) selection of a final set of attributes and development of principles. The study involved 50 participants with diverse backgrounds within and outside the Health CASCADE Network over 18 months. Results The study identified 105 candidate attributes. A set of 38 was selected from which 10 key principles were derived (open access, recognised contribution, ethics and legal, transparency, rigorous evaluation, clear problem, plural evidence, critical reflection, diversity, and structured and flexible processes) across three domains: Governance, Scientific and Methodological Rigour, and Collective Intelligence Processes. Conclusions The attributes and guiding principles provide a comprehensive foundations for evidence-based co-creation, enhancing its trustworthiness, transparency, reliability, and impact in public health and other fields. Future research and practice should use these principles and attributes to refine and implement co-creation effectively., info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion
Recercat. Dipósit de la Recerca de Catalunya
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

The pitfalls of co-creation: reflections from Health CASCADE facilitators on critical events, consequences and preventive and mitigating strategies

  • Verloigne, Maïté
  • Chastin, Sebastien F. M.
  • An, Qingfan
  • Anand Kumar, Vinayak
  • de Boer, Janneke
  • Dall, Philippa
  • Delfmann, Lea Rahel
  • Giné-Garriga, Maria
  • Goh, Kunshan
  • Lippke, Sonia
  • McCaffrey, Lauren
  • Pappa, Dimitra
  • Schreier, Margrit
  • Vogelsang, Mira
  • Wadell, Karin
  • Altenburg, Teatske
Objectives Co-creation is increasingly applied in public health research, particularly to develop solutions. Due to the unpredictable and ‘messy’ nature of co-creation, co-creation processes often do not go as planned. To inform facilitators of co-creation research, we aimed to identify critical events in planning, conducting, evaluating and reporting of co-creation and to provide strategies to prevent or mitigate them, by reflecting on co-creation projects within the Health CASCADE project. Study design Qualitative study design. Methods Online or in-person reflection sessions were held with facilitators of six co-creation projects, across various sectors, in different populations, and addressing diverse topics. Facilitators were asked to reflect on critical events in their project that could have negatively impacted the co-creators, the co-creation process, or the co-created solution, and to identify preventive and mitigating measures. Two researchers analysed meeting summaries using inductive thematic analysis. Results We identified 16 overarching themes, representing critical events from planning to reporting, including not recruiting the 'right' participants, low engagement, lack of motivation for implementation, and biased evaluations. These can result in insufficient inclusion of diverse opinions and reduced co-creation time, which in turn can lead to less effective solutions and lack of trust in co-creation. We identified various preventive (e.g., scheduling reflection meetings beforehand) and mitigating (e.g., having a co-facilitator in case of difficulties) strategies. Conclusions The results highlight the crucial role of facilitators in making co-creation an effective approach in public health. Allocating ample time for facilitator training beforehand and ongoing reflection during the co-creation project is essential., info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion
Recercat. Dipósit de la Recerca de Catalunya
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Cocreating a digital patient preparedness tool for international students accessing primary care in Germany: A convergent methods study within the health CASCADE network

  • Anand Kumar, Vinayak
  • Schreier, Margrit
  • Giné-Garriga, Maria
  • Ortmann, Maria
  • Belmokhtar, Fatima
  • Grineviciute, Simona
  • Quan, Tran Ngoc-Huong
  • Aluru, Likhita
  • Lippke, Sonia
Digital health interventions (DHIs) are a potential tool to address communication challenges in primary care medicine by improving patient participation, treatment adherence, and self-management of chronic diseases. However, Germany’s digital health infrastructure remains underdeveloped compared to other Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) countries. Designing tailored, context-sensitive tools requires a deep understanding of patient needs, particularly for underserved populations navigating complex health care systems. Participatory approaches that actively involve end-users and stakeholders can help ensure that digital health tools are responsive to these needs. Behavioral science frameworks such as the Behavior Change Wheel (BCW), which incorporates the Capability, Opportunity, Motivation–Behavior (COM-B) model, can further support this process. Such technologies, developed using cocreation and behavior change frameworks, may improve health outcomes for underserved patient populations by addressing context-specific needs. This study explores how cocreation and behavioral science can inform the adaptation of a digital patient preparedness tool for international students accessing primary care in Germany. Objective: This study aimed to gain insight into international students’ experiences with primary care in Germany and explore whether adapting an existing digital patient preparedness intervention could address communication challenges and improve the standard of care. Using cocreation methods and the Behavior Change Wheel (BCW), we identified key design specifications and behavior change levers to inform tool development. Methods: A mixed methods design was used to identify design specifications for a DHI across 4 cocreation workshops with 12 students at an international university in Germany. Quantitative data were used for descriptive insights, and qualitative data were analyzed using qualitative content analysis. Workshops were informed by the BCW and the Health CASCADE cocreation methods selector tool. Results: Cocreators reported feeling misunderstood, anxious, and ill-informed during primary care interactions, with system-level barriers compounding communication difficulties. Despite this, many engaged in preparatory behaviors (eg, note-taking) to manage uncertainty and structure their consultations. Feedback on an existing digital intervention was mixed: while cocreators appreciated its intent, structured lesson formats were seen as too time-consuming. Cocreators preferred a concise, interactive design. Communication prompts, appointment scheduling, and personalized feedback were frequently requested features, though tool adoption was seen as contingent on addressing broader system-level frustrations. Conclusions: International students’ negative health care experiences, often stemming from unclear communication, perceived indifference, and difficulty navigating an unfamiliar medical system, may be mitigated through codesigned, personalized digital interventions. Frequently requested features, such as appointment scheduling, clinic directories, test result access, and interactive tools like chatbots, may help address barriers related to system navigation, communication, and access. This study demonstrates how cocreation methods can be integrated with the BCW to inform the development of context-sensitive digital health tools for specific target groups., info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion
Recercat. Dipósit de la Recerca de Catalunya
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Evaluating the co-creation process in public health interventions: the PROSECO framework

  • Longworth, Giuliana R.
  • Agnello, Danielle Marie
  • Chastin, Sebastien F. M.
  • Davis, Aaron
  • Senabre Hidalgo, Enric
  • Villanueva Baselga, Sergio
  • McCaffrey, Lauren
  • Zapata-Restrepo, Jorge Raul
  • Coll-Planas, Laura
  • Giné-Garriga, Maria
Objectives To date, there is a lack of evaluation frameworks to guide the planning and conducting of the evaluation of co-creation in public health. This study aims to identify and set the components of the PROSECO framework (PROcesS Evaluation framework for CO-creation) to support the evaluation of co-creation processes in public health interventions. Study design A multi-step, iterative approach combining the outcomes of two scoping reviews, expert validation, and design refinement. Methods The PROSECO framework was developed in three steps. Firstly, collecting results from two scoping reviews on process evaluation for co-creation and evaluation of co-creation methods. The scoping review results were analysed and refined by a selected group of experts and through a three-round anonymous survey. Based on those findings, the framework visualisation was developed and designed through multiple design iterations. Results The PROcesS Evaluation framework for CO-creation, called the PROSECO framework, was developed to assist researchers and stakeholders in evaluating a co-creation process. The framework comprises a list of 37 components grouped under the five dimensions of Delivery, Participation, Experiential, Context, and Impact. Conclusions PROSECO is the first framework to offer a systematic approach to evaluating co-creation. By integrating a diverse set of evaluation components, encompassing delivery, participation, experiential, impact, and context, it offers a flexible and comprehensive approach to address the complex nature of co-creation., info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion