Skip to main content

Resultados relacionados

Resultados totales (Incluyendo duplicados): 20
Encontrada(s) 1 página(s)

DAU Arxiu Digital de la Universitat Ramon Llull
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Conducting co-creation for public health in low and middle-income countries: a systematic review and key informant perspectives on implementation barriers and facilitators

  • Longworth, Giuliana R.
  • Erikowa-Orighoye, Oritseweyinmi
  • Miracle Anieto, Ebuka
  • Agnello, Danielle Marie
  • Zapata-Restrepo, Jorge Raul
  • Masquillier, Caroline
  • Giné-Garriga, Maria
Background There has been an increase in the use of co-creation for public health because of its claimed potential to increase an intervention’s impact, spark change and co-create knowledge. Still, little is reported on its use in low-and-middle-income countries (LMICs). This study offers a comprehensive overview of co-creation used in public-health-related interventions, including the interventions’ characteristics, and reported implementation barriers and facilitators. Methods We conducted a systematic review within the Scopus and PubMed databases, a Google Scholar search, and a manual search in two grey literature databases related to participatory research. We further conducted eight interviews with first authors, randomly selected from included studies, to validate and enrich the systematic review findings. Results Through our review, we identified a total of twenty-two studies conducted in twenty-four LMIC countries. Majority of the interventions were designed directly within the LMIC setting. Aside from one, all studies were published between 2019 and 2023. Most studies adopted a co-creation approach, while some reported on the use of co-production, co-design, and co-development, combined either with community-based participatory research, participatory action research or citizen science. Among the most reported implementation barriers, we found the challenge of understanding and accounting for systemic conditions, such as the individual’s socioeconomic status and concerns related to funding constraints and length of the process. Several studies described the importance of creating a safe space, relying on local resources, and involving existing stakeholders in the process from the development stage throughout, including future and potential implementors. High relevance was also given to the performance of a contextual and/or needs assessment and careful tailoring of strategies and methods. Conclusion This study provides a systematic overview of previously conducted studies and of reported implementation barriers and facilitators. It identifies implementation barriers such as the setting’s systemic conditions, the socioeconomic status and funding constrains along with facilitators such as the involvement of local stakeholders and future implementors throughout, the tailoring of the process to the population of interest and participants and contextual assessment. By incorporating review and interview findings, the study aims to provide practical insights and recommendations for guiding future research and policy., info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion
DAU Arxiu Digital de la Universitat Ramon Llull
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Exploring age-friendly urban design through co-creation: insights from EngAGE4Change, a Health CASCADE study

  • Zapata-Restrepo, Jorge Raul
  • Longworth, Giuliana R.
  • Chin A Paw, Mai
  • Dall, Philippa
  • Skelton, Dawn A.
  • Morejón, Sacra
  • Giné-Garriga, Maria
This study showcases a co-creative approach to urban design spe-cifically tailored to meet the physical activity and socializationneeds of older adults in Barcelona, Spain. It explores how olderadults can be involved in the planning process of spaces that fostertheir physical and social activities. Utilizing a mixed-methodsapproach, the research facilitated a collaborative design effortthat engaged older adults, community stakeholders, and research-ers to ensure a wide range of perspectives and inclusivity. Thesefindings underscore the feasibility of a co-creative process in urbandesign and planning, revealing older adults’ preferences for publicspaces that promote healthy ageing and social well-being., info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion
DAU Arxiu Digital de la Universitat Ramon Llull
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

EngAGE4Change: Co-creating outdoor community spaces with care home residents and community-dwelling older adults to improve movement behaviour and reduce social isolation - A Health CASCADE study protocol

  • Zapata-Restrepo, Jorge Raul
  • Longworth, Giuliana R.
  • Dall, Philippa
  • Skelton, Dawn A.
  • Chin A Paw, Mai
  • Morejón, Sacra
  • Giné-Garriga, Maria
Objectives: To present and structure the use of co-creation as an overarching approach to position older adults—particularly care home residents and community-dwellers—and other key stakeholders as active decision-makers in an urban design and spatial planning project aimed at creating inclusive outdoor spaces. Study design: A multi-step, context-based, iterative protocol using co-creation for designing public spaces with older adults. Methods: A structured co-creation process engaged 20 older adults (both care home residents and communitydwellers), along with 3 family members, 2 health professionals, 2 caregivers, 1 researcher, and 2 urban designers. The process included three phases: (1) exploratory stage for context assessment, (2) planning through a needs assessment, and (3) a co-creation core for public space ideation and prototyping. AR and VR technologies were used to support spatial visualization and immersive prototyping. A mixed-methods evaluation assessed the co-creation process, including participant engagement and outcomes. Results: As a protocol paper, no empirical results are reported. However, the structure of the co-creation process, participant roles, and evaluation framework are detailed to guide implementation and inspiration for planning future projects using co-creation for urban design and healthy ageing. Conclusions: This protocol offers a transferable model for integrating co-creation into urban design and planning with older adults. It supports inclusive design and adds to the growing evidence on participatory methods for addressing complex urban health challenges., info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion
DAU Arxiu Digital de la Universitat Ramon Llull
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Scoping review of needs for digital technology in co-creation: a health CASCADE study

  • Loisel, Quentin Emile Armand
  • An, Qingfan
  • Anand Kumar, Vinayak
  • Balaskas, George
  • Papadopoulos, H.
  • Pappa, Dimitra
  • Giné-Garriga, Maria
  • Longworth, Giuliana R.
  • Chastin, Sebastien F. M.
Background Patient and public involvement (PPI) is increasingly recognised as essential for meaningful, equitable, and impactful health and social care research. Co-creation is a promising involvement approach, but it faces barriers to enable its optimal potential. Digital technologies have the potential to overcome these challenges and strengthen the participatory process, but the specific technology needs that underpin effective participation and engagement remain underexplored. Methods We conducted a comprehensive scoping review of 60 peer-reviewed studies to systematically map the digital technology needs supporting co-creation processes. Needs were extracted and thematically analysed, resulting in a structured synthesis. Results A total of 337 distinct digital technology needs were identified and organised into five thematic areas: Ensuring Integrity, Enabling Methodology, Cognitive Needs, Group Dynamics, and Process Management. While most needs focused on functional attributes, non-functional characteristics, such as usability, scalability, and inclusivity, emerged as critical for meaningful patient and public engagement. The review highlights the fragmented articulation of technology needs across disciplines and settings. It proposes a structured framework to make latent needs visible, align stakeholder perspectives, and guide the development of digital tools. The emerging role of artificial intelligence in supporting hybrid models of involvement, along with the associated ethical challenges, is also discussed. Conclusion This review provides the first thematic framework for understanding and addressing digital technology needs in co-creation. The findings offer a foundation for researchers, practitioners, and policy-makers within health and social care to develop and implement digital tools that enhance accessibility, engagement, and impact of participatory processes. Future research should validate and refine these insights in partnership with patients, service users, and diverse communities to ensure technological solutions foster truly inclusive and effective involvement. Plain English summary Involving patients, carers, and the public in health and social care research (often called patient and public involvement, or PPI) helps ensure that the research addresses real needs, is more useful in practice, and remains inclusive. Today, digital technologies, such as online meetings, apps, and artificial intelligence, can help more people become involved. But what do we really need from these technologies to make everyone’s involvement easier and better? In this study, we looked at 60 research articles to find out what kinds of digital tools are needed to support group work and co-creation in research. We discovered 337 different needs and grouped them into five main areas: making sure the process is open and equitable, so that everyone has a fair chance to contribute, supporting the methods, helping people understand and take part, working well in groups, and keeping everything organised. We found that while many tools focus on what they do, it’s just as important that they are easy to use, work well for lots of people, and help everyone join in, especially people who may find it harder to get involved. We also discuss how new technologies like artificial intelligence can help, but why they need to be used responsibly. Our findings can help researchers, organisations, and the public choose or design better digital tools for involving patients and the public in research. This way, everyone’s voice can be heard, and health and care research can become more inclusive and effective., info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion
DAU Arxiu Digital de la Universitat Ramon Llull
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Co-creation methods for public health research - characteristics, benefits, and challenges: a Health CASCADE scoping review

  • Agnello, Danielle Marie
  • Anand Kumar, Vinayak
  • An, Qingfan
  • de Boer, Janneke
  • Delfmann, Lea Rahel
  • Longworth, Giuliana R.
  • Loisel, Quentin Emile Armand
  • McCaffrey, Lauren
  • Steiner, Artur
  • Chastin, Sebastien F. M.
Background Co‑creation engages diverse stakeholders, including marginalized populations, in collaborative problem‑solving to enhance engagement and develop contextually appropriate solutions. It is increasingly recognized as a way to democratize research and improve the impact of interventions, services, and policies. However, the lack of synthesized evidence on co‑creation methods limits methodological rigor and the establishment of best practices. This review aimed to identify co‑creation methods in academic literature and analyze their characteristics, target groups, and associated benefits and challenges. Methods This scoping review follows the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta‑Analyses Extension for Scoping Reviews. The search was conducted in the Health CASCADE database v1.5 (including CINAHL, PubMed, and 17 additional databases via ProQuest) from January 1970 to March 2022. Data was aggregated and summarized, with qualitative data analyzed using Braun and Clarke’s six‑phase thematic analysis approach. Results The review included 266 articles, identifying 248 distinct co‑creation methods published between 1998 and 2022. Most methods were rooted in participatory paradigms (147 methods), with 49 methods derived from coapproaches like co‑creation, co‑design, and co‑production, and 11 from community‑based health promotion and action research. Methods were applied across 40 target populations, including children, adults, and marginalized groups. Many methods (62.3%) were delivered face‑to‑face, with 40 articles incorporating digital tools. Thematic analysis revealed nine benefits, such as enhanced creativity, empowerment, and improved communication, and six challenges, including resource constraints and systemic and structural barriers. Conclusion This review emphasizes the importance of robust documentation and analysis of co‑creation methods to inform their application in public health. Findings support the development of collaborative co‑creation processes that are responsive to the needs of diverse populations, thereby enhancing the overall effectiveness and cultural sensitivity of the outcomes. This review highlights the potential of co‑creation methods to promote equity and inclusion while emphasizing the importance of evaluating and selecting methods tailored to specific objectives, offering a critical resource for planning, conducting, and evaluating co‑creation projects., info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion
DAU Arxiu Digital de la Universitat Ramon Llull
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Navigating process evaluation in co-creation: a Health CASCADE scoping review of used frameworks and assessed components

  • Longworth, Giuliana R.
  • de Boer, Janneke
  • Goh, Kunshan
  • Agnello, Danielle Marie
  • McCaffrey, Lauren
  • Zapata-Restrepo, Jorge Raul
  • An, Qingfan
  • Castin, Sebastien
  • Davis, Aaron
  • Altenburg, Teatske
  • Verloigne, Maïté
  • Giné-Garriga, Maria
Background Co-creation is seen as a way to ensure all relevant needs and perspectives are included and to increase its potential for beneficial effects and uptake process evaluation is crucial. However, existing process evaluation frameworks have been built on practices characterised by top-down developed and implemented interventions and may be limited in capturing essential elements of co-creation. This study aims to provide a review of studies planning and/or conducting a process evaluation of public health interventions adopting a cocreation approach and aims to derive assessed process evaluation components, used frameworks and insights into formative and/or participatory evaluation. Methods We searched for studies on Scopus and the Health CASCADE Co-Creation Database. Co-authors performed a concept-mapping exercise to create a set of overarching dimensions for clustering the identified process evaluation components. Results 54 studies were included. Conceptualisation of process evaluation included in studies concerned intervention implementation, outcome evaluation, mechanisms of impact, context and the co-creation process. 22 studies (40%) referenced ten existing process evaluation or evaluation frameworks and most referenced were the frameworks developed by Moore et al (14%), Saunders et al (5%), Steckler and Linnan (5%) and Nielsen and Randall (5%). 38 process evaluation components were identified, with a focus on participation (48%), context (40%), the experience of co-creators (29%), impact (29%), satisfaction (25%) and fidelity (24%). 13 studies (24%) conducted formative evaluation, 37 (68%) conducted summative evaluation and 2 studies (3%) conducted participatory evaluation. Conclusion The broad spectrum of process evaluation components addressed in co-creation studies, covering both the evaluation of the co-creation process and the intervention implementation, highlights the need for a process evaluation tailored to co-creation studies. This work provides an overview of process evaluation components, clustered in dimensions and reflections which researchers and practitioners can use to plan a process evaluation of a co-creation process and intervention., info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion
DAU Arxiu Digital de la Universitat Ramon Llull
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

PRODUCES+: Guidance for co-creation in public health informed by evidence and user experience

  • Agnello, Danielle Marie
  • Longworth, Giuliana R.
  • Giné-Garriga, Maria
  • Chastin, Sebastien F. M.
  • Skelton, Dawn A.
  • Leask, Calum F
Objectives: Despite the growing popularity of co-creation to develop complex interventions, there is limited guidance on planning and implementing a co-creation process in public health. This study aims to critically review and update one such guidance, the PRODUCES framework, to develop a more comprehensive, user- friendly guide for public health researchers and practitioners. Study design: Evidence- and user-informed guideline development. Methods: A multi-method, evidence-informed approach was used to identify strengths, gaps, and areas for improvement. This included a snowballing review of peer-reviewed articles citing the PRODUCES framework, followed by in-depth interviews and a mixed-methods survey with lead authors identified through the review. Data from included studies, interviews, and survey responses were analysed thematically. Results: The search identified 96 studies, of which 21 were included. Four interviews and nine survey responses were obtained. Strengths included flexibility, clear foundational guidance, and practical applicability, while limitations related to clarity, overlapping stages, and terminology. Participants suggested strengthening implementation guidance and methods and highlighted the value of complementary frameworks. These findings informed the development of the PRODUCES+ guideline. Conclusions: Building on user input, the original framework, and contemporary co-creation literature, the PRODUCES+ Guideline provides an expanded, step-by-step resource for planning co-creation in public health., info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion
DAU Arxiu Digital de la Universitat Ramon Llull
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

A review of implementation and evaluation frameworks for public health interventions to inform co-creation: a Health CASCADE study

  • Longworth, Giuliana R.
  • Goh, Kunshan
  • Agnello, Danielle Marie
  • Messiha, Katrina
  • Beeckman, Melanie
  • Zapata-Restrepo, Jorge Raul
  • Cardon, Greet
  • Chastin, Sebastien F. M.
  • Giné-Garriga, Maria
Background By including the needs and perspectives of relevant stakeholders, co-creation is seen as a promising approach for tackling complex public health problems. However, recommendations and guidance on how to plan and implement co-creation are lacking. By identifying and analysing existing implementation and evaluation frame‐ works for public health, this study aims to ofer key recommendations for professional stakeholders and researchers wanting to adopt a co-creation approach to public health interventions. Methods Firstly, PubMed and CINAHL databases were screened for articles introducing original implementa‐ tion and evaluation frameworks for public health interventions. Backwards snowballing techniques were applied to the included papers. Secondly, identifed frameworks were classifed and relevant data extracted, including steps and constructs present in the frameworks. Lastly, recommendations were derived by conducting thematic analysis on the included frameworks. Results Thirty frameworks were identifed and data related to their nature and scope extracted. The frameworks’ prominent steps and constructs were also retrieved. Recommendations related to implementation and evaluation in the context of co-creation were included. Conclusion When engaging in co-creation, we recommend including implementation considerations from an early stage and suggest adopting a systems thinking as a way to explore multiple levels of infuence, contextual settings and systems from an early planning stage. We highlight the importance of partnering with stakeholders and sug‐ gest applying an evaluation design that is iterative and cyclical, which pays particular attention to the experience of the engaged co-creators., info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion
DAU Arxiu Digital de la Universitat Ramon Llull
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Enriching the Existing Knowledge About Co-creation: Identifying Dimensions of Co-creation Using Explicit Theory in Various Research Fields

  • Messiha, Katrina
  • Altenburg, Teatske
  • Giné-Garriga, Maria
  • Chastin, Sebastien F. M.
  • Chin-A-Paw, Mai J.M.
Despite increasing popularity of co-creation approaches across various types of co-creation (e.g., value co-creation) and research fields, systematic and effective theory-building of co-creation research is generally lacking. We explored co-creation literature underpinned by explicit theory, taking a hybrid approach by combining a narrative literature review of studies in various research fields and a systematic literature review of studies in the field of public health. Subsequently, we identified common dimensions applied to the co-creation process across various types of co-creation and research fields, in performing an inductive thematic analysis. Across the total 27 articles included as part of the narrative and systematic review, we identified 5 dimensions related to the co-creation process applied across 9 research fields: (1) Multi-stakeholder collaborative action; (2) Process of co-learning towards innovation; (3) Contextual knowledge production; (4) Generating meaning; and, (5) Open, trustful and inclusive dialogue. The findings offer renewed insight into the common dimensions of the co-creation process, with underpinning explicit theories across various types of co-creation and research fields. A clear and consistent definition of co-creation was often lacking, especially in the field of public health. We strongly emphasise the need for research to adopt a multi-dimensional approach to the co-creation process—as well as to work towards developing a common language around co-creation, which involves operationalising these identified five dimensions., info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion
DAU Arxiu Digital de la Universitat Ramon Llull
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

A comparison of office workers’ co-creation experiences: A Health CASCADE multiple case study

  • McCaffrey, Lauren
  • de Boer, Janneke
  • Vogelsang, Mira
  • Giné-Garriga, Maria
  • McCann, Bryan
  • Dall, Philippa
Objectives Co-creation can used to develop public health interventions, improve their effectiveness, and increase intervention uptake through engaging stakeholders, but there is little in-depth exploration of the co-creators’ experience of taking part. Understanding the experience of taking part in a co-creation process can enhance future participation experiences, promote engagement and help design better co-creation processes in the future. The objective of this study was to explore the experiences of co-creators (i.e., office workers) involved in the co-creation process to address workplace sedentary behaviour. Study design Multiple case study. Methods Three small-to-medium sized enterprises participated in separate co-creation processes. Data were generated from observations during the workshops and semi-structured interviews (n = 31) employing elicitation techniques conducted after the co-creation process was completed. Each of the three cases were analysed separately (using thematic analysis), which then informed the cross-case comparison, the focus of this study. Results Comparison of co-creators' experiences across the three cases identified psychological, emotional, social and cognitive experiences which occurred before, during and after the co-creation process. The analysis identified both intended (e.g., sedentary behaviour awareness) and unintended (e.g., forming relationships) outcomes from these experiences. These experiences and outcomes were influenced by factors such as workplace environment and structure, design of the co-creation process and how it was facilitated, highlighting the interplay between the co-creation context and the broader work context. Conclusion This study contributes to the understanding of co-creation experience in the workplace setting. Recommendations were derived from using an iterative reflection process of the three cases., info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion
Recercat. Dipósit de la Recerca de Catalunya
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Scoping review of needs for digital technology in co-creation: a health CASCADE study

  • Loisel, Quentin Emile Armand
  • An, Qingfan
  • Anand Kumar, Vinayak
  • Balaskas, George
  • Papadopoulos, H.
  • Pappa, Dimitra
  • Giné-Garriga, Maria
  • Longworth, Giuliana R.
  • Chastin, Sebastien F. M.
Background Patient and public involvement (PPI) is increasingly recognised as essential for meaningful, equitable, and impactful health and social care research. Co-creation is a promising involvement approach, but it faces barriers to enable its optimal potential. Digital technologies have the potential to overcome these challenges and strengthen the participatory process, but the specific technology needs that underpin effective participation and engagement remain underexplored. Methods We conducted a comprehensive scoping review of 60 peer-reviewed studies to systematically map the digital technology needs supporting co-creation processes. Needs were extracted and thematically analysed, resulting in a structured synthesis. Results A total of 337 distinct digital technology needs were identified and organised into five thematic areas: Ensuring Integrity, Enabling Methodology, Cognitive Needs, Group Dynamics, and Process Management. While most needs focused on functional attributes, non-functional characteristics, such as usability, scalability, and inclusivity, emerged as critical for meaningful patient and public engagement. The review highlights the fragmented articulation of technology needs across disciplines and settings. It proposes a structured framework to make latent needs visible, align stakeholder perspectives, and guide the development of digital tools. The emerging role of artificial intelligence in supporting hybrid models of involvement, along with the associated ethical challenges, is also discussed. Conclusion This review provides the first thematic framework for understanding and addressing digital technology needs in co-creation. The findings offer a foundation for researchers, practitioners, and policy-makers within health and social care to develop and implement digital tools that enhance accessibility, engagement, and impact of participatory processes. Future research should validate and refine these insights in partnership with patients, service users, and diverse communities to ensure technological solutions foster truly inclusive and effective involvement. Plain English summary Involving patients, carers, and the public in health and social care research (often called patient and public involvement, or PPI) helps ensure that the research addresses real needs, is more useful in practice, and remains inclusive. Today, digital technologies, such as online meetings, apps, and artificial intelligence, can help more people become involved. But what do we really need from these technologies to make everyone’s involvement easier and better? In this study, we looked at 60 research articles to find out what kinds of digital tools are needed to support group work and co-creation in research. We discovered 337 different needs and grouped them into five main areas: making sure the process is open and equitable, so that everyone has a fair chance to contribute, supporting the methods, helping people understand and take part, working well in groups, and keeping everything organised. We found that while many tools focus on what they do, it’s just as important that they are easy to use, work well for lots of people, and help everyone join in, especially people who may find it harder to get involved. We also discuss how new technologies like artificial intelligence can help, but why they need to be used responsibly. Our findings can help researchers, organisations, and the public choose or design better digital tools for involving patients and the public in research. This way, everyone’s voice can be heard, and health and care research can become more inclusive and effective., info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion
Recercat. Dipósit de la Recerca de Catalunya
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Conducting co-creation for public health in low and middle-income countries: a systematic review and key informant perspectives on implementation barriers and facilitators

  • Longworth, Giuliana R.
  • Erikowa-Orighoye, Oritseweyinmi
  • Miracle Anieto, Ebuka
  • Agnello, Danielle Marie
  • Zapata-Restrepo, Jorge Raul
  • Masquillier, Caroline
  • Giné-Garriga, Maria
Background There has been an increase in the use of co-creation for public health because of its claimed potential to increase an intervention’s impact, spark change and co-create knowledge. Still, little is reported on its use in low-and-middle-income countries (LMICs). This study offers a comprehensive overview of co-creation used in public-health-related interventions, including the interventions’ characteristics, and reported implementation barriers and facilitators. Methods We conducted a systematic review within the Scopus and PubMed databases, a Google Scholar search, and a manual search in two grey literature databases related to participatory research. We further conducted eight interviews with first authors, randomly selected from included studies, to validate and enrich the systematic review findings. Results Through our review, we identified a total of twenty-two studies conducted in twenty-four LMIC countries. Majority of the interventions were designed directly within the LMIC setting. Aside from one, all studies were published between 2019 and 2023. Most studies adopted a co-creation approach, while some reported on the use of co-production, co-design, and co-development, combined either with community-based participatory research, participatory action research or citizen science. Among the most reported implementation barriers, we found the challenge of understanding and accounting for systemic conditions, such as the individual’s socioeconomic status and concerns related to funding constraints and length of the process. Several studies described the importance of creating a safe space, relying on local resources, and involving existing stakeholders in the process from the development stage throughout, including future and potential implementors. High relevance was also given to the performance of a contextual and/or needs assessment and careful tailoring of strategies and methods. Conclusion This study provides a systematic overview of previously conducted studies and of reported implementation barriers and facilitators. It identifies implementation barriers such as the setting’s systemic conditions, the socioeconomic status and funding constrains along with facilitators such as the involvement of local stakeholders and future implementors throughout, the tailoring of the process to the population of interest and participants and contextual assessment. By incorporating review and interview findings, the study aims to provide practical insights and recommendations for guiding future research and policy., info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion
Recercat. Dipósit de la Recerca de Catalunya
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Co-creation methods for public health research - characteristics, benefits, and challenges: a Health CASCADE scoping review

  • Agnello, Danielle Marie
  • Anand Kumar, Vinayak
  • An, Qingfan
  • de Boer, Janneke
  • Delfmann, Lea Rahel
  • Longworth, Giuliana R.
  • Loisel, Quentin Emile Armand
  • McCaffrey, Lauren
  • Steiner, Artur
  • Chastin, Sebastien F. M.
Background Co‑creation engages diverse stakeholders, including marginalized populations, in collaborative problem‑solving to enhance engagement and develop contextually appropriate solutions. It is increasingly recognized as a way to democratize research and improve the impact of interventions, services, and policies. However, the lack of synthesized evidence on co‑creation methods limits methodological rigor and the establishment of best practices. This review aimed to identify co‑creation methods in academic literature and analyze their characteristics, target groups, and associated benefits and challenges. Methods This scoping review follows the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta‑Analyses Extension for Scoping Reviews. The search was conducted in the Health CASCADE database v1.5 (including CINAHL, PubMed, and 17 additional databases via ProQuest) from January 1970 to March 2022. Data was aggregated and summarized, with qualitative data analyzed using Braun and Clarke’s six‑phase thematic analysis approach. Results The review included 266 articles, identifying 248 distinct co‑creation methods published between 1998 and 2022. Most methods were rooted in participatory paradigms (147 methods), with 49 methods derived from coapproaches like co‑creation, co‑design, and co‑production, and 11 from community‑based health promotion and action research. Methods were applied across 40 target populations, including children, adults, and marginalized groups. Many methods (62.3%) were delivered face‑to‑face, with 40 articles incorporating digital tools. Thematic analysis revealed nine benefits, such as enhanced creativity, empowerment, and improved communication, and six challenges, including resource constraints and systemic and structural barriers. Conclusion This review emphasizes the importance of robust documentation and analysis of co‑creation methods to inform their application in public health. Findings support the development of collaborative co‑creation processes that are responsive to the needs of diverse populations, thereby enhancing the overall effectiveness and cultural sensitivity of the outcomes. This review highlights the potential of co‑creation methods to promote equity and inclusion while emphasizing the importance of evaluating and selecting methods tailored to specific objectives, offering a critical resource for planning, conducting, and evaluating co‑creation projects., info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion
Recercat. Dipósit de la Recerca de Catalunya
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

A comparison of office workers’ co-creation experiences: A Health CASCADE multiple case study

  • McCaffrey, Lauren
  • de Boer, Janneke
  • Vogelsang, Mira
  • Giné-Garriga, Maria
  • McCann, Bryan
  • Dall, Philippa
Objectives Co-creation can used to develop public health interventions, improve their effectiveness, and increase intervention uptake through engaging stakeholders, but there is little in-depth exploration of the co-creators’ experience of taking part. Understanding the experience of taking part in a co-creation process can enhance future participation experiences, promote engagement and help design better co-creation processes in the future. The objective of this study was to explore the experiences of co-creators (i.e., office workers) involved in the co-creation process to address workplace sedentary behaviour. Study design Multiple case study. Methods Three small-to-medium sized enterprises participated in separate co-creation processes. Data were generated from observations during the workshops and semi-structured interviews (n = 31) employing elicitation techniques conducted after the co-creation process was completed. Each of the three cases were analysed separately (using thematic analysis), which then informed the cross-case comparison, the focus of this study. Results Comparison of co-creators' experiences across the three cases identified psychological, emotional, social and cognitive experiences which occurred before, during and after the co-creation process. The analysis identified both intended (e.g., sedentary behaviour awareness) and unintended (e.g., forming relationships) outcomes from these experiences. These experiences and outcomes were influenced by factors such as workplace environment and structure, design of the co-creation process and how it was facilitated, highlighting the interplay between the co-creation context and the broader work context. Conclusion This study contributes to the understanding of co-creation experience in the workplace setting. Recommendations were derived from using an iterative reflection process of the three cases., info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion
Recercat. Dipósit de la Recerca de Catalunya
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

A review of implementation and evaluation frameworks for public health interventions to inform co-creation: a Health CASCADE study

  • Longworth, Giuliana R.
  • Goh, Kunshan
  • Agnello, Danielle Marie
  • Messiha, Katrina
  • Beeckman, Melanie
  • Zapata-Restrepo, Jorge Raul
  • Cardon, Greet
  • Chastin, Sebastien F. M.
  • Giné-Garriga, Maria
Background By including the needs and perspectives of relevant stakeholders, co-creation is seen as a promising approach for tackling complex public health problems. However, recommendations and guidance on how to plan and implement co-creation are lacking. By identifying and analysing existing implementation and evaluation frame‐ works for public health, this study aims to ofer key recommendations for professional stakeholders and researchers wanting to adopt a co-creation approach to public health interventions. Methods Firstly, PubMed and CINAHL databases were screened for articles introducing original implementa‐ tion and evaluation frameworks for public health interventions. Backwards snowballing techniques were applied to the included papers. Secondly, identifed frameworks were classifed and relevant data extracted, including steps and constructs present in the frameworks. Lastly, recommendations were derived by conducting thematic analysis on the included frameworks. Results Thirty frameworks were identifed and data related to their nature and scope extracted. The frameworks’ prominent steps and constructs were also retrieved. Recommendations related to implementation and evaluation in the context of co-creation were included. Conclusion When engaging in co-creation, we recommend including implementation considerations from an early stage and suggest adopting a systems thinking as a way to explore multiple levels of infuence, contextual settings and systems from an early planning stage. We highlight the importance of partnering with stakeholders and sug‐ gest applying an evaluation design that is iterative and cyclical, which pays particular attention to the experience of the engaged co-creators., info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion
Recercat. Dipósit de la Recerca de Catalunya
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

EngAGE4Change: Co-creating outdoor community spaces with care home residents and community-dwelling older adults to improve movement behaviour and reduce social isolation - A Health CASCADE study protocol

  • Zapata-Restrepo, Jorge Raul
  • Longworth, Giuliana R.
  • Dall, Philippa
  • Skelton, Dawn A.
  • Chin A Paw, Mai
  • Morejón, Sacra
  • Giné-Garriga, Maria
Objectives: To present and structure the use of co-creation as an overarching approach to position older adults—particularly care home residents and community-dwellers—and other key stakeholders as active decision-makers in an urban design and spatial planning project aimed at creating inclusive outdoor spaces. Study design: A multi-step, context-based, iterative protocol using co-creation for designing public spaces with older adults. Methods: A structured co-creation process engaged 20 older adults (both care home residents and communitydwellers), along with 3 family members, 2 health professionals, 2 caregivers, 1 researcher, and 2 urban designers. The process included three phases: (1) exploratory stage for context assessment, (2) planning through a needs assessment, and (3) a co-creation core for public space ideation and prototyping. AR and VR technologies were used to support spatial visualization and immersive prototyping. A mixed-methods evaluation assessed the co-creation process, including participant engagement and outcomes. Results: As a protocol paper, no empirical results are reported. However, the structure of the co-creation process, participant roles, and evaluation framework are detailed to guide implementation and inspiration for planning future projects using co-creation for urban design and healthy ageing. Conclusions: This protocol offers a transferable model for integrating co-creation into urban design and planning with older adults. It supports inclusive design and adds to the growing evidence on participatory methods for addressing complex urban health challenges., info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion
Recercat. Dipósit de la Recerca de Catalunya
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

PRODUCES+: Guidance for co-creation in public health informed by evidence and user experience

  • Agnello, Danielle Marie
  • Longworth, Giuliana R.
  • Giné-Garriga, Maria
  • Chastin, Sebastien F. M.
  • Skelton, Dawn A.
  • Leask, Calum F
Objectives: Despite the growing popularity of co-creation to develop complex interventions, there is limited guidance on planning and implementing a co-creation process in public health. This study aims to critically review and update one such guidance, the PRODUCES framework, to develop a more comprehensive, user- friendly guide for public health researchers and practitioners. Study design: Evidence- and user-informed guideline development. Methods: A multi-method, evidence-informed approach was used to identify strengths, gaps, and areas for improvement. This included a snowballing review of peer-reviewed articles citing the PRODUCES framework, followed by in-depth interviews and a mixed-methods survey with lead authors identified through the review. Data from included studies, interviews, and survey responses were analysed thematically. Results: The search identified 96 studies, of which 21 were included. Four interviews and nine survey responses were obtained. Strengths included flexibility, clear foundational guidance, and practical applicability, while limitations related to clarity, overlapping stages, and terminology. Participants suggested strengthening implementation guidance and methods and highlighted the value of complementary frameworks. These findings informed the development of the PRODUCES+ guideline. Conclusions: Building on user input, the original framework, and contemporary co-creation literature, the PRODUCES+ Guideline provides an expanded, step-by-step resource for planning co-creation in public health., info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion
Recercat. Dipósit de la Recerca de Catalunya
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Exploring age-friendly urban design through co-creation: insights from EngAGE4Change, a Health CASCADE study

  • Zapata-Restrepo, Jorge Raul
  • Longworth, Giuliana R.
  • ChinPaw
  • Dall, Philippa
  • Skelton, Dawn A.
  • Morejón, Sacra
  • Giné-Garriga, Maria
This study showcases a co-creative approach to urban design spe-cifically tailored to meet the physical activity and socializationneeds of older adults in Barcelona, Spain. It explores how olderadults can be involved in the planning process of spaces that fostertheir physical and social activities. Utilizing a mixed-methodsapproach, the research facilitated a collaborative design effortthat engaged older adults, community stakeholders, and research-ers to ensure a wide range of perspectives and inclusivity. Thesefindings underscore the feasibility of a co-creative process in urbandesign and planning, revealing older adults’ preferences for publicspaces that promote healthy ageing and social well-being., info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion
Recercat. Dipósit de la Recerca de Catalunya
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Enriching the Existing Knowledge About Co-creation: Identifying Dimensions of Co-creation Using Explicit Theory in Various Research Fields

  • Messiha, Katrina
  • Altenburg, Teatske
  • Giné-Garriga, Maria
  • Chastin, Sebastien F. M.
  • Chin-A-Paw, Mai J.M.
Despite increasing popularity of co-creation approaches across various types of co-creation (e.g., value co-creation) and research fields, systematic and effective theory-building of co-creation research is generally lacking. We explored co-creation literature underpinned by explicit theory, taking a hybrid approach by combining a narrative literature review of studies in various research fields and a systematic literature review of studies in the field of public health. Subsequently, we identified common dimensions applied to the co-creation process across various types of co-creation and research fields, in performing an inductive thematic analysis. Across the total 27 articles included as part of the narrative and systematic review, we identified 5 dimensions related to the co-creation process applied across 9 research fields: (1) Multi-stakeholder collaborative action; (2) Process of co-learning towards innovation; (3) Contextual knowledge production; (4) Generating meaning; and, (5) Open, trustful and inclusive dialogue. The findings offer renewed insight into the common dimensions of the co-creation process, with underpinning explicit theories across various types of co-creation and research fields. A clear and consistent definition of co-creation was often lacking, especially in the field of public health. We strongly emphasise the need for research to adopt a multi-dimensional approach to the co-creation process—as well as to work towards developing a common language around co-creation, which involves operationalising these identified five dimensions., info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion
Recercat. Dipósit de la Recerca de Catalunya
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Navigating process evaluation in co-creation: a Health CASCADE scoping review of used frameworks and assessed components

  • Longworth, Giuliana R.
  • de Boer, Janneke
  • Goh, Kunshan
  • Agnello, Danielle Marie
  • McCaffrey, Lauren
  • Zapata-Restrepo, Jorge Raul
  • An, Qingfan
  • Castin, Sebastien
  • Davis, Aaron
  • Altenburg, Teatske
  • Verloigne, Maïté
  • Giné-Garriga, Maria
Background Co-creation is seen as a way to ensure all relevant needs and perspectives are included and to increase its potential for beneficial effects and uptake process evaluation is crucial. However, existing process evaluation frameworks have been built on practices characterised by top-down developed and implemented interventions and may be limited in capturing essential elements of co-creation. This study aims to provide a review of studies planning and/or conducting a process evaluation of public health interventions adopting a cocreation approach and aims to derive assessed process evaluation components, used frameworks and insights into formative and/or participatory evaluation. Methods We searched for studies on Scopus and the Health CASCADE Co-Creation Database. Co-authors performed a concept-mapping exercise to create a set of overarching dimensions for clustering the identified process evaluation components. Results 54 studies were included. Conceptualisation of process evaluation included in studies concerned intervention implementation, outcome evaluation, mechanisms of impact, context and the co-creation process. 22 studies (40%) referenced ten existing process evaluation or evaluation frameworks and most referenced were the frameworks developed by Moore et al (14%), Saunders et al (5%), Steckler and Linnan (5%) and Nielsen and Randall (5%). 38 process evaluation components were identified, with a focus on participation (48%), context (40%), the experience of co-creators (29%), impact (29%), satisfaction (25%) and fidelity (24%). 13 studies (24%) conducted formative evaluation, 37 (68%) conducted summative evaluation and 2 studies (3%) conducted participatory evaluation. Conclusion The broad spectrum of process evaluation components addressed in co-creation studies, covering both the evaluation of the co-creation process and the intervention implementation, highlights the need for a process evaluation tailored to co-creation studies. This work provides an overview of process evaluation components, clustered in dimensions and reflections which researchers and practitioners can use to plan a process evaluation of a co-creation process and intervention., info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion