Pasar al contenido principal

Resultados relacionados

Resultados totales (Incluyendo duplicados): 2
Encontrada(s) 1 página(s)

RiuNet. Repositorio Institucional de la Universitat Politécnica de Valéncia
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Developing a composite indicator to assess agricultural sustainability: Influence of some critical choices

  • Sinisterra-Solis, Nelson Kevin
  • Sanjuán, N.|||0000-0001-9413-0268
  • Ribal, Javier|||0000-0002-9355-0145
  • Estruch-Guitart, Vicente|||0000-0002-7838-8899
  • Clemente Polo, Gabriela|||0000-0003-1173-9903
  • Rozakis, Stelios
[EN] Assessing the sustainability of agriculture is a relevant methodological issue with practical implications. In this study, a systematic approach is followed to develop a composite indicator that ranks the sustainability performance of Spanish reference farms at the NUTS 2 level. The classical three-dimension approach is considered under a deductive point of view to represent sustainability. Multicriteria techniques suitable to model the tradeoffs between individual attributes are used to weigh and aggregate the three dimensions' attributes, allowing for different normative standpoints to be expressed. The sensitivity and uncertainty arising from the methodological choices are assessed using a variance-based technique. The ordinary least squares technique is applied to evaluate the sensitivity of the composite indicator to shifts in the consumption of relevant inputs. The results show that the trade-off level does not leverage most analysed units. In addition, the ranking obtained made it possible to discriminate the herbaceous farms as those with the worst sustainability performance. Methodologically, the most influential parameters in the indicator are related to the ethical complexity of evaluating overall sustainability. In addition, the indicator shows a high sensitivity to shifts in the consumption of machinery fuel and irrigation resources. In short, the indicator developed represents a relevant input to improve the interpretation of the sustainability performance of agriculture as a multidimensional issue, emphasising its normative character., The authors gratefully acknowledge the Universitat Politecnica de Valencia for providing the funds for Sinisterra-Solis's research through Subprogram 1 (PAID-01-18), ADSIDEO - COOPERACION 2020 Program [AD2011], and by the funds provided for a research stay during three months at the Bioeconomy and Biosystems Economics Laboratory of the Technical University of Crete (Chania, Greece). To Erasmus+programme of the European Union that supported the student mobility for traineeships. To the Colombian Government for funding Sinisterra-Solis's research through COLCIENCIAS. The authors would also like to thank Jose David Prieto Campo and Gentil Andres Collazos-Escobar for their statistics support, specifically in multivariate and back to detail steps.
RiuNet. Repositorio Institucional de la Universitat Politécnica de Valéncia
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

From farm accountancy data to environmental indicators: Assessing the environmental performance of Spanish agriculture at a regional level

  • Sinisterra-Solis, Nelson Kevin
  • Sanjuán, N.|||0000-0001-9413-0268
  • Ribal, Javier|||0000-0002-9355-0145
  • Estruch-Guitart, Vicente|||0000-0002-7838-8899
  • Clemente Polo, Gabriela|||0000-0003-1173-9903
[EN] Understanding the environmental impacts of current agricultural practices is a starting point for transitioning towards sustainable agriculture, which is a goal to be achieved by the European Union. This study aims to provide a set of environmental impact indicators with which to assess and compare the environmental performance of a broad group of agricultural reference holdings at the Spanish NUTS 2 level. A life cycle assessment approach based on statistical data on farm accountancy is applied. The unit of analysis is a reference holding on which a specific crop is grown in a NUTS 2 and follows a specific management system (open-field irrigated, open-field rainfed, or greenhouse). The system boundaries are set at the farm gate, and the impact results are expressed per 1 euro of net value added. For most reference holdings, the EF scores per net value added are similar regardless of their EF scores per kg commodity, suggesting a correspondence between the use of resources and the economic results. The environmental footprint is clustered into four groups. The first one accounts for 78 % of the sample and represents the holdings with the lowest impact (between 9.7 & BULL;10-5 and 2.88 & BULL;10-3 EF score & BULL;NVAfc-1); the second cluster groups seven reference holdings (3 herbaceous and 4 Mediterranean perennial crops) with an environmental footprint of between 3.04 & BULL;10-3 and 9.01 & BULL;10-3 EF score & BULL;NVAfc -1; the third group comprises four irrigated herbaceous crops holdings with the highest impact (between 1.37 & BULL;10-2 and 2.13 & BULL;10-2 EF score & BULL;NVAfc -1); and the last group corresponds to the holdings with economic losses (mostly herbaceous and two Mediterranean perennial crops). This research highlights the challenge of improving the competitiveness and profitability of Spanish farming. In this way, agricultural practices that generate environmental impacts without achieving their economic goals would be avoided., The authors gratefully acknowledge the Universitat Politecnica de Valencia for providing the funds for N.K. Sinisterra-Solis's research contract through Subprogram 1 (PAID-01-18), ADSIDEO - COOPERACION 2020 Program (AD2011), and the Colombian Government for funding through COLCIENCIAS.