Pasar al contenido principal

Resultados relacionados

Resultados totales (Incluyendo duplicados): 9
Encontrada(s) 1 página(s)

Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Redes discursivas en el debate sobre experimentación animal en prensa española sobre el caso Vivotecnia, Discursive networks in the animal experimentation debate in the Spanish press regarding the Vivotecnia case

  • Moreno, Jose A.|||0000-0003-3781-5644
  • Fernandez Gomez-Recuero, Laura|||0000-0002-4818-1125
  • Almiron, Núria|||0000-0002-2482-0666
La experimentación con animales ha sido objeto de amplios debates políticos, sociales y científicos. En 2021, Cruelty Free International publicó vídeos que mostraban abusos a animales empleados para experimentación en el laboratorio Vivotecnia en la Comunidad de Madrid. En esta investigación abordamos el debate reflejado en la prensa española a raíz de este caso utilizando una metodología de análisis de redes discursivas. Del análisis de 84 textos de diez diarios españoles se desprende que, a pesar de la unánime condena a los hechos, se representan claramente dos coaliciones discursivas, una que cuestiona y otra que no cuestiona la experimentación con animales, ambas equilibradas en número de actores. En el estudio identificamos además cómo se organiza el debate en la prensa en torno a diez ideas principales. Este estudio contribuye al conocimiento de cómo se construyen y representan los debates públicos a través de los medios de comunicación., Animal experimentation has been the subject of extensive political, social and scientific debate. In 2021, Cruelty Free International published videos showing abuse of animals used for experimentation at the Vivotecnia laboratory in the Community of Madrid. In this research, we address the debate reflected in the Spanish press in the wake of this case using a discourse network analysis methodology. The analysis of 84 texts from ten Spanish newspapers shows that, despite unanimous condemnation of the events, there are clearly two discursive coalitions, one that questions and one that does not question animal experimentation, both balanced in terms of the number of actors. In the study, we also identify how the debate in the press is organised around ten main ideas. This study contributes to our understanding of how public debates are constructed and represented through the media.
Repositorio Digital de la UPF
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Redes discursivas en el debate sobre experimentación animal en prensa española sobre el caso Vivotecnia

  • Moreno, Jose A.
  • Fernández, Laura
  • Almiron, Núria, 1967-
La experimentación con animales ha sido objeto de amplios debates políticos, sociales y científicos. En 2021, Cruelty Free International publicó vídeos que mostraban abusos a animales empleados para experimentación en el laboratorio Vivotecnia en la Comunidad de Madrid. En esta investigación abordamos el debate reflejado en la prensa española a raíz de este caso utilizando una metodología de análisis de redes discursivas. Del análisis de 84 textos de diez diarios españoles se desprende que, a pesar de la unánime condena a los hechos, se representan claramente dos coaliciones discursivas, una que cuestiona y otra que no cuestiona la experimentación con animales, ambas equilibradas en número de actores. En el estudio identificamos además cómo se organiza el debate en la prensa en torno a diez ideas principales. Este estudio contribuye al conocimiento de cómo se construyen y representan los debates públicos a través de los medios de comunicación., Esta publicación es parte del proyecto de I+D+i COMPASS (PID2020-118926RB-100) financiado por el Ministerio de Ciencia e Innovación y por la Agencia Estatal de Investigación (MICIU/AEI/10.13039/501100011033). La coautora Laura Fernández ha contado conun contrato postdoctoral Juan de la Cierva (FJC2021-046861-I), financiado por MCIN/AEI/10.13039/501100011033 y por la Unión Europea NextGenerationEU/PRTR.
Repositorio Digital de la UPF
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Commodifying compassion: a critical discourse analysis of Spanish zoo, aquarium and animal theme parks' lobbies

  • Aranceta Reboredo, Olatz
  • Almiron, Núria, 1967-
The influence of the zoological park industry on public compassion remains an understudied area that is pivotal to understanding how public relations -specifically persuasive communication- attempts to shape public consent regarding the use of animals in entertainment. This paper addresses this issue by conducting a critical discourse analysis of the main interest groups in Spain's zoological park industry: AIZA, Grupo Parques Reunidos, and Loro Parque Fundación. The results show that despite these actors' compassionate self-representations, they use objectifying language, biological hierarchization, and commodification to represent nonhuman animals. In particular, they portray themselves as "advocates" for animal welfare and legitimize their efforts through a process akin to ethics washing. They use thematic elements and emotional engagement to convey the concept of the "modern zoo". Finally, they strategically acknowledge societal compassion and frame themselves as aligned with current societal values and attitudes. We conclude that the current discursive strategies of the main Spanish zoological park industry lobbies go beyond the typical arguments related to entertainment, science and conservation, instrumentalizing public compassion to justify the captivity, confinement and exhibition of nonhumans., The author(s) declare that financial support was received for the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article. This work was supported by the Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation and State Research Agency (Agencia Estatal de Investigación, AEI) under grant PID2020-118926RB-100/MICIN/AEI/10.13039/501100011033, and the associated grant for hiring a predoctoral researcher (PRE2021-099988) that one of the authors benefits from, as well as from funding from the UNIC Research group (2021 SGR 00921).
Repositorio Digital de la UPF
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Illusory authenticity: negotiating compassion in animal experimentation discourse

  • Almiron, Núria, 1967-
  • Fernández, Laura
  • Rodrigo i Alsina, Miquel
Society’s compassion towards nonhuman animals used in experimentation has grown exponentially. This paper adopts critical discourse analysis to examine how the animal experimentation industry negotiates this societal moral response. To this end, the discourse of the largest animal experimentation interest group in Spain has been studied. Our findings show that the industry, as represented by this interest group, does not negotiate compassion with authenticity but rather creates an illusion of it through opportunistic lexical choices and suppressions, including contradictions and incongruities. We conclude by defining such a discourse as illusory authenticity, a discourse with which the industry conveniently frames itself as altruistic and concerned about animal suffering while at the same time discouraging the public’s cultivation of compassion towards nonhuman animal suffering. This is done by means of perpetuating a logic that frames nonhuman animals as inferior beings whose existence is at the service of humanity., This research (within the project COMPASS, Lobbying and Compassion. Interest groups, discourse and nonhuman animals in Spain) was funded by the Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation and State Research Agency (Agencia Estatal de Investigación, AEI) under grant PID2020-118926RB-100/MICIN/AEI/10.13039/501100011033.
Repositorio Digital de la UPF
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Fighting breeds and athletes: how lobby groups frame animal-based entertainment in Spain

  • Aranceta Reboredo, Olatz
  • Morrás-Aranoa, Leire
  • Almiron, Núria, 1967-
Introduction: Despite growing moral concern over the use of animals in bullfighting, cockfighting, and horse and dog racing, these animal-based entertainment industries continue to exhibit significant resilience in Spain, driven largely by the strategic use of public relations. Aims/Objectives: To analyze the discourse disseminated by interest groups lobbying for the use of animals in these industries in Spain, with a focus on the representation of nonhuman animals, self-representation by the industries and representation of the public, to assess how these discursive practices affect the emergence of compassion. Methodology: A multimodal analysis from a Critical Animal Studies perspective. We examined a sample of texts, informative materials, videos and newspaper articles displayed and disseminated by four primary interest groups: Fundación Toro de Lidia (a foundation promoting and defending bullfighting culture in Spain), Asociación de Sociedades Organizadoras de Carreras de Caballos en España / Asociación de Hipódromos (the association of horse racing event organizers and racetracks in Spain), Federación Española de Galgos (the Spanish federation governing greyhound racing and breeding), and Unión de Criadores de Gallo Combatiente Español (the union of breeders of the Spanish fighting cock). Results: The main findings of this research highlight the interplay between spectacle, tradition, science and economic interest -mediated through the biologization and athleticization of animals- as well as the roles of Spanish nationalism, victimization narratives, and warlike framing. Discussion: The discourse incorporates fallacious reasoning alongside polarizing rhetoric, the instrumentalization of culture, science and tradition, and strategies of humane-washing and greenwashing. Conclusions: Compassion towards animals is reframed in ways that delegitimize the ethical concern expressed by citizens, while portraying the industries' own activities as the true expression of care and responsibility., This work is part of the COMPASS Research Project (Lobbying and Compassion: Interest Groups, Discourse and Nonhuman Animals in Spain), PID2020-118926RB-100. The research is funded by the grant for predoctoral contracts for the training of doctors PRE2021-099988, supported by the Ministry of Science, Innovation and Universities (Spain), and funded by MCIN/AEI/10.13039/501100011033 and the European Social Fund Plus (ESF+).
Recercat. Dipósit de la Recerca de Catalunya
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Commodifying compassion: a critical discourse analysis of Spanish zoo, aquarium and animal theme parks' lobbies

  • Aranceta Reboredo, Olatz
  • Almiron, Núria, 1967-
The influence of the zoological park industry on public compassion remains an understudied area that is pivotal to understanding how public relations -specifically persuasive communication- attempts to shape public consent regarding the use of animals in entertainment. This paper addresses this issue by conducting a critical discourse analysis of the main interest groups in Spain's zoological park industry: AIZA, Grupo Parques Reunidos, and Loro Parque Fundación. The results show that despite these actors' compassionate self-representations, they use objectifying language, biological hierarchization, and commodification to represent nonhuman animals. In particular, they portray themselves as "advocates" for animal welfare and legitimize their efforts through a process akin to ethics washing. They use thematic elements and emotional engagement to convey the concept of the "modern zoo". Finally, they strategically acknowledge societal compassion and frame themselves as aligned with current societal values and attitudes. We conclude that the current discursive strategies of the main Spanish zoological park industry lobbies go beyond the typical arguments related to entertainment, science and conservation, instrumentalizing public compassion to justify the captivity, confinement and exhibition of nonhumans., The author(s) declare that financial support was received for the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article. This work was supported by the Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation and State Research Agency (Agencia Estatal de Investigación, AEI) under grant PID2020-118926RB-100/MICIN/AEI/10.13039/501100011033, and the associated grant for hiring a predoctoral researcher (PRE2021-099988) that one of the authors benefits from, as well as from funding from the UNIC Research group (2021 SGR 00921).
Recercat. Dipósit de la Recerca de Catalunya
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Fighting breeds and athletes: how lobby groups frame animal-based entertainment in Spain

  • Aranceta Reboredo, Olatz
  • Morrás-Aranoa, Leire
  • Almiron, Núria, 1967-
Introduction: Despite growing moral concern over the use of animals in bullfighting, cockfighting, and horse and dog racing, these animal-based entertainment industries continue to exhibit significant resilience in Spain, driven largely by the strategic use of public relations. Aims/Objectives: To analyze the discourse disseminated by interest groups lobbying for the use of animals in these industries in Spain, with a focus on the representation of nonhuman animals, self-representation by the industries and representation of the public, to assess how these discursive practices affect the emergence of compassion. Methodology: A multimodal analysis from a Critical Animal Studies perspective. We examined a sample of texts, informative materials, videos and newspaper articles displayed and disseminated by four primary interest groups: Fundación Toro de Lidia (a foundation promoting and defending bullfighting culture in Spain), Asociación de Sociedades Organizadoras de Carreras de Caballos en España / Asociación de Hipódromos (the association of horse racing event organizers and racetracks in Spain), Federación Española de Galgos (the Spanish federation governing greyhound racing and breeding), and Unión de Criadores de Gallo Combatiente Español (the union of breeders of the Spanish fighting cock). Results: The main findings of this research highlight the interplay between spectacle, tradition, science and economic interest -mediated through the biologization and athleticization of animals- as well as the roles of Spanish nationalism, victimization narratives, and warlike framing. Discussion: The discourse incorporates fallacious reasoning alongside polarizing rhetoric, the instrumentalization of culture, science and tradition, and strategies of humane-washing and greenwashing. Conclusions: Compassion towards animals is reframed in ways that delegitimize the ethical concern expressed by citizens, while portraying the industries' own activities as the true expression of care and responsibility., This work is part of the COMPASS Research Project (Lobbying and Compassion: Interest Groups, Discourse and Nonhuman Animals in Spain), PID2020-118926RB-100. The research is funded by the grant for predoctoral contracts for the training of doctors PRE2021-099988, supported by the Ministry of Science, Innovation and Universities (Spain), and funded by MCIN/AEI/10.13039/501100011033 and the European Social Fund Plus (ESF+).
Recercat. Dipósit de la Recerca de Catalunya
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Redes discursivas en el debate sobre experimentación animal en prensa española sobre el caso Vivotecnia

  • Moreno, Jose A.
  • Fernández, Laura
  • Almiron, Núria, 1967-
La experimentación con animales ha sido objeto de amplios debates políticos, sociales y científicos. En 2021, Cruelty Free International publicó vídeos que mostraban abusos a animales empleados para experimentación en el laboratorio Vivotecnia en la Comunidad de Madrid. En esta investigación abordamos el debate reflejado en la prensa española a raíz de este caso utilizando una metodología de análisis de redes discursivas. Del análisis de 84 textos de diez diarios españoles se desprende que, a pesar de la unánime condena a los hechos, se representan claramente dos coaliciones discursivas, una que cuestiona y otra que no cuestiona la experimentación con animales, ambas equilibradas en número de actores. En el estudio identificamos además cómo se organiza el debate en la prensa en torno a diez ideas principales. Este estudio contribuye al conocimiento de cómo se construyen y representan los debates públicos a través de los medios de comunicación., Esta publicación es parte del proyecto de I+D+i COMPASS (PID2020-118926RB-100) financiado por el Ministerio de Ciencia e Innovación y por la Agencia Estatal de Investigación (MICIU/AEI/10.13039/501100011033). La coautora Laura Fernández ha contado conun contrato postdoctoral Juan de la Cierva (FJC2021-046861-I), financiado por MCIN/AEI/10.13039/501100011033 y por la Unión Europea NextGenerationEU/PRTR.
Recercat. Dipósit de la Recerca de Catalunya
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Illusory authenticity: negotiating compassion in animal experimentation discourse

  • Almiron, Núria, 1967-
  • Fernández, Laura
  • Rodrigo i Alsina, Miquel
Society’s compassion towards nonhuman animals used in experimentation has grown exponentially. This paper adopts critical discourse analysis to examine how the animal experimentation industry negotiates this societal moral response. To this end, the discourse of the largest animal experimentation interest group in Spain has been studied. Our findings show that the industry, as represented by this interest group, does not negotiate compassion with authenticity but rather creates an illusion of it through opportunistic lexical choices and suppressions, including contradictions and incongruities. We conclude by defining such a discourse as illusory authenticity, a discourse with which the industry conveniently frames itself as altruistic and concerned about animal suffering while at the same time discouraging the public’s cultivation of compassion towards nonhuman animal suffering. This is done by means of perpetuating a logic that frames nonhuman animals as inferior beings whose existence is at the service of humanity., This research (within the project COMPASS, Lobbying and Compassion. Interest groups, discourse and nonhuman animals in Spain) was funded by the Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation and State Research Agency (Agencia Estatal de Investigación, AEI) under grant PID2020-118926RB-100/MICIN/AEI/10.13039/501100011033.