Pasar al contenido principal

Resultados relacionados

Resultados totales (Incluyendo duplicados): 2
Encontrada(s) 1 página(s)

Helvia. Repositorio Institucional de la Universidad de Córdoba
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

The role of accounting in the assessment of knowledge production from a multi-stakeholder’s perspective

  • Senn, Juliette
  • Luque Vílchez, Mercedes
  • Larrinaga, Carlos
Purpose – The objective of this study is to provide insights into how accounting and accountability systems can contribute to transforming metrics employed thus far in research performance evaluation. New metrics are needed to increase research impact on the challenges addressed by science. In particular, we document and reflect about accounting transformations towards Responsible Research and Innovation (RRI). Design/methodology/approach – The study draws on the European H2020 MULTI-ACT research project that focuses on the development of a collective research impact framework in the area of health research. We document, analyze and report our engagement in this project, which also included research funders, patient organizations, health researchers, accounting practitioners and health care providers. Drawing on RRI, Mode 2 knowledge production and accounting performativity, we inquire into the potential of accounting technologies to foster knowledge production and increase research impact. Findings – The study shows how the engagement of accounting with other disciplines enables the development of new and relevant forms of research impact assessment. We document how accounting can be mobilised for the development of new forms of research impact assessment (i.e., indicators that evaluate key accountability dimensions in order to promote RRI) and how it helps to overcome the difficulties that can emerge during this process. We also show how the design of multiple accountabilities’ indicators, although chronically partial, produced a generative interrogation and discussion about how to translate RRI to research assessment in a workable setting, and the pivotal role of certain circumstances (e.g., the presence of authoritative actors) that appear during the knowledge production process for creating these generative opportunities. Practical implications – This study illustrates the key role of accounts in the generation of knowledge. It also shows the value of considering the stakes of all affected actors in devising fruitful accounting approaches. This collective perspective is timely in the accounting discipline and could foster the connection between academics and practice which is so far under-reported. This perspective should be useful for policymakers such as the European Union and managers in the design of new policies, initiatives and practices. Social implications– Discussing and devising appropriate research assessment frameworks is strategic for the maximization of the social impact of research results. Accounting has a key role to play in optimizing a sustainable return on investment in research. Originality/value– How to assess research impact in a more balanced way is in an early stage of development. The study provides empirical and practical material to advance further work and develop its potential to broaden the conceptualization of accountability.
Helvia. Repositorio Institucional de la Universidad de Córdoba
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Collective health research assessment: developing a tool to measure the impact of multistakeholder research initiatives

  • Kork, Anna-Aurora
  • Antonini, Carla
  • García-Torea, Nicolás
  • Luque Vílchez, Mercedes
  • Costa, Erika
  • Senn, Juliette
  • Larrinaga, Carlos
  • Bertorello, Deborah
  • Brichetto, Giampaolo
  • Zaratin, Paola
  • Andreaus, Michele
Background: The need to more collaboratively measure the impact of health research and to do so from multidimensional perspectives has been acknowledged. A scorecard was developed as part of the Collective Research Impact Framework (CRIF), to engage stakeholders in the assessment of the impacts of health research and innovations. The purpose of this study was to describe the developmental process of the MULTI-ACT Master Scorecard (MSC) and how it can be used as a workable tool for collectively assessing future responsible research and innovation measures. Methods: An extensive review of the health research impact literature and of multistakeholder initiatives resulted in a database of 1556 impact indicators. The MSC was then cocreated by engaging key stakeholders and conducting semi-structured interviews of experts in the field. Results: The MSC consists of five accountability dimensions: excellence, efficacy, economic, social and patientreported outcomes. The tool contains 125 potential indicators, classified into 53 impact measurement aspects that are considered the most relevant topics for multistakeholder research and innovation initiatives when assessing their impact on the basis of their mission and their stakeholders’ interests. The scorecard allows the strategic management of multistakeholder research initiatives to demonstrate their impact on people and society. The value of the tool is that it is comprehensive, customizable and easy to use. Conclusions: The MSC is an example of how the views of society can be taken into account when research impacts are assessed in a more sustainable and balanced way. The engagement of patients and other stakeholders is an integral part of the CRIF, facilitating collaborative decision-making in the design of policies and research agendas. In policy making, the collective approach allows the evaluation perspective to be extended to the needs of society and towards responsible research and innovation. Multidimensionality makes research and innovations more responsive to systemic challenges, and developing more equitable and sustainable health services.