Pasar al contenido principal

Resultados relacionados

Resultados totales (Incluyendo duplicados): 3
Encontrada(s) 1 página(s)

Docta Complutense
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Biomedicine, deliberative democracy and childhood: the limits of children and young people’s involvement in health research

  • Murano, María Cristina
In recent years, children and young people (CYP) have been increasingly included in patient and public involvement (PPI) in health research and innovation. Such initiatives intend to give a voice to CYP in such matters. Given that it is debated whether PPI in health care fosters the values of participation, public discussion and decision making put forward by deliberative democracy, this article examines three sets of challenges concerning the involvement of CYP by focusing on age biases. After describing some existing initiatives, the paper critically examines why CYP are involved, how the CYP group is constituted and then investigates the moral status of CYP in biomedical settings. It shows that the rationale for involving CYP in PPI is mainly top-down and adult-centric, thereby questioning the authentic participation in decision making. It also suggests that to ensure democratic inclusion, the CYP group should be constituted by considering both age and politics. Lastly, the article indicates that, despite the increasing recognition of child-specific rights, the sociocultural norms and power dynamics in pediatrics undermine their moral status and challenge political equality. These three sets of considerations offer a preliminary theoretical contribution toward improving democratic legitimacy and representation of CYP in health research and innovation.
Docta Complutense
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

La ausencia de la infancia en la ética de la investigación pediátrica, The absence of childhood in the ethics of pediatric research

  • Murano, María Cristina
El enfoque tradicional de los debates sobre ética de la investigación se centra en proporcionar algunas normas y directrices para llevar a cabo investigaciones biomédicas con seres humanos. Este trabajo propone un enfoque diferente: va al “terreno” para interrogar cuáles son las cuestiones éticas que surgen a partir de las relaciones asistenciales que se despliegan en los ensayos clínicos desarrollados con menores en un hospital público. De este modo, este artículo pretende ir más allá de las teorías de la ética de la investigación para revelar las cuestiones éticas que son más relevantes para las personas implicadas.
Docta Complutense
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

From vulnerable subjects to research partners: a critical policy analysis of biomedical research ethics guidelines and regulations

  • Murano, María Cristina
Over the last three quarters of a century, international guidelines and regulations have undergone significant changes in how children are problematised as participants in biomedical research. While early guidelines enacted children as vulnerable subjects with diminished autonomy and in need of special protection, beginning in the early 2000s, international regulatory frameworks defined the paediatric population as vulnerable due to unaddressed public health needs. More recently, ethical recommendations have promoted the active engagement of minors as research partners. In this paper, I adopt a post-structuralist approach to policy analysis to examine deep-seated assumptions and presuppositions underlying the changes in the problematisation of children as biomedical research participants over time. While biomedical research ethics focuses on the autonomy and vulnerability of minors, ethical guidelines are situated in specific sociocultural contexts, shaped, among other things, by contingent public health needs and changing conceptions of the value of research and science for society. In the process, I demonstrate the challenge of moving away from an approach that in taking adults as the model overshadows the complexity of children’s lived experiences as well as their personal, cultural, and social lives. The lack of acknowledgement of this complexity makes children vulnerable to epistemic injustice, which is particularly crucial to address in public involvement initiatives.