Pasar al contenido principal

Resultados relacionados

Resultados totales (Incluyendo duplicados): 22
Encontrada(s) 1 página(s)

RODIN. Repositorio de Objetos de Docencia e Investigación de la Universidad de Cádiz
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Fast–slow traits predict competition network structure and its response to resources and enemies

  • Daniel, Caroline
  • Allan, Eric
  • Saiz, Hugo
  • Godoy del Olmo, Oscar
Plants interact in complex networks but how network structure depends on resources, natural enemies and species resource-use strategy remains poorly understood. Here, we quantified competition networks among 18 plants varying in fast–slow strategy, by testing how increased nutrient availability and reduced foliar pathogens affected intra- and inter-specific interactions. Our results show that nitrogen and pathogens altered several aspects of network structure, often in unexpected ways due to fast and slow growing species responding differently. Nitrogen addition increased competition asymmetry in slow growing networks, as expected, but decreased it in fast growing networks. Pathogen reduction made networks more even and less skewed because pathogens targeted weaker competitors. Surprisingly, pathogens and nitrogen dampened each other's effect. Our results show that plant growth strategy is key to understand how competition respond to resources and enemies, a prediction from classic theories which has rarely been tested by linking functional traits to competition networks.
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Fast–slow traits predict competition network structure and its response to resources and enemies

  • Daniel, Caroline
  • Allan, Eric
  • Sáiz, Hugo
  • Godoy, Óscar
Plants interact in complex networks but how network structure depends on resources, natural enemies and species resource-use strategy remains poorly understood. Here, we quantified competition networks among 18 plants varying in fast–slow strategy, by testing how increased nutrient availability and reduced foliar pathogens affected intra- and inter-specific interactions. Our results show that nitrogen and pathogens altered several aspects of network structure, often in unexpected ways due to fast and slow growing species responding differently. Nitrogen addition increased competition asymmetry in slow growing networks, as expected, but decreased it in fast growing networks. Pathogen reduction made networks more even and less skewed because pathogens targeted weaker competitors. Surprisingly, pathogens and nitrogen dampened each other's effect. Our results show that plant growth strategy is key to understand how competition respond to resources and enemies, a prediction from classic theories which has rarely been tested by linking functional traits to competition networks., European Social Fund Plus (TASTE),Grant/Award Number: PID2021-127607OB-I00; Schweizerischer National fonds zur Förderung der Wissenschaftlichen Forschung, Grant/Award Number: 310030_185260; Ministerio de Economía y Competitividad, Peer reviewed
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Interaction network structure explains species' temporal persistence in empirical plant-pollinator communities

  • Domínguez-García, Virginia
  • Molina, Francisco P.
  • Godoy, Óscar
  • Bartomeus, Ignasi
Despite clear evidence that some pollinator populations are declining, our ability to predict pollinator communities prone to collapse or species at risk of local extinction is remarkably poor. Here, we develop a model grounded in the structuralist approach that allows us to draw sound predictions regarding the temporal persistence of species in mutualistic networks. Using high-resolution data from a six-year study following 12 independent plant-pollinator communities, we confirm that pollinator species with more persistent populations in the field are theoretically predicted to tolerate a larger range of environmental changes. Persistent communities are not necessarily more diverse, but are generally located in larger habitat patches, and present a distinctive combination of generalist and specialist species resulting in a more nested structure, as predicted by previous theoretical work. Hence, pollinator interactions directly inform about their ability to persist, opening the door to use theoretically informed models to predict species' fate within the ongoing global change., This research was funded through the 2017–2018 Belmont Forum and BiodivERsA joint call for research proposals, under the BiodivScen ERA-Net COFUND programme, and with the funding organisations AEI, NWO, ECCyT and NSF to I.B. and V.D.-G. This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2021 research and innovation programme under the Marie Skłodowska-Curie grant agreement No 101064340 to V.D.-G., TASTE Project (PID2021-127607OB-I00) to O.G, I.B. and V.D.-G., and BeeFUN project (PCIG 14-GA-2013-631653) to I.B., Peer reviewed
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Datos de investigación Set de datos (Dataset)

Fast-slow traits predict competition network structure and its response to resources and enemies

  • Daniel, Caroline
  • Allan, Eric
  • Sáiz, Hugo
  • Godoy, Óscar
Plants interact in complex networks but how network structure depends on resources, natural enemies, and species resource-use strategy remains poorly understood. Here, we quantified competition networks among 18 plants varying in fast-slow strategy, by testing how increased nutrient availability and reduced foliar pathogens affected intra- and inter-specific interactions. Our results show that nitrogen and pathogens altered several aspects of network structure, often in unexpected ways due to fast and slow-growing species responding differently. Nitrogen addition increased competition asymmetry in slow-growing networks, as expected, but decreased it in fast-growing networks. Pathogen reduction made networks more even and less skewed because pathogens targeted weaker competitors. Surprisingly, pathogens and nitrogen dampened each other’s effect. Our results show that plant growth strategy is key to understanding how competition responds to resources and enemies, a prediction from classic theories that has rarely been tested by linking functional traits to competition networks., European Commission : TASTE (PID2021-127607OB-I00), European Social Funds Plus; Ministerio de Economía y Competitividad, Ministerio de Universidades : María Zambrano; Swiss National Science Foundation : 310030_185260, Peer reviewed
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Pollinator asynchrony drives the temporal stability of flower visitation rates, but not of plant reproductive success

  • Tobajas, Estefanía
  • Domínguez-García, Virginia
  • Molina, Francisco P.
  • Bartomeus, Ignasi
The stability of ecological communities over time, often quantified using their aggregated abundance or biomass, is thought to be influenced by species richness and the asynchrony of species abundance fluctuations. However, the relationship between community stability and the stability of ecosystem functioning provided by this community has been little explored, especially for functions involving several trophic levels such as plant pollination. Understanding the mechanisms driving community stability and how this should be related to the stability of ecosystem functions is important to predict the resilience of communities in front of the increasing threats to biodiversity. Using a 5-year dataset across 13 Mediterranean shrublands and 12 plant species, we assessed the effect of pollinator richness and asynchrony as drivers of stability in plant visitation rates and plant reproductive success. Additionally, we analysed whether the effects of species richness and visitation rate on plant reproductive success were consistent over the years. The stability of plant visitation rates is driven by the asynchrony of pollinator species abundances, but the effect of pollinator species richness is only indirect, as richer communities also tend to have more asynchronous populations. In contrast, the stability of plant reproductive success is not related to the stability of pollinator visitation rates. A year-by-year analysis reveals that plants in the studied system are unlikely to be limited by pollinator abundance except in specific years, blurring any potential effect of visitation rate stability on reproductive success stability. Synthesis: We highlight the importance of asynchronous fluctuating species that are redundant in their function as an important factor for the stability of ecosystems. This is particularly important for pollinators with diverse responses to environmental fluctuations, as their asynchrony between years ensures stable levels of flower visitation rates. However, we warn that final ecosystem functions such as plant reproductive success, which depends not only on pollinators but on plant competition or resource availability, might be decoupled from first order ecosystem functions (i.e. visitation rates and pollen deposition) when pollination is not a limiting factor., This study was supported by the BeeFun project (PCIG14-GA-2013-631653). Estefanía Tobajas is co-financed by the European NextGenerationEU Fund, the Spanish Ministry of Universities and University of Salamanca (“Ayudas para la recualificacion del sistema universitario español 2021-2022). Ignasi Bartomeus acknowledges the financial support provided by the Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation (MICINN) and the European Social Fund through the TASTE Project (PID2021-127607OB-I00)., Peer reviewed
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

The assembly and dynamics of ecological communities in an ever-changing world

  • Godoy, Óscar
  • Soler Toscano, Fernando
  • Portillo, José R.
  • Langa, José A.
Alternative perspectives on the maintenance of biodiversity and the assembly of ecological communities suggest that both processes cannot be investigated simultaneously. In this concept and synthesis, we challenge this view by presenting major theoretical advances in structural stability and permanence theory. These advances, which provide complementary views, allow studying the short- and long-term dynamics of ecological communities as changes in species richness, composition, and abundance. Here, the global attractor, technically named informational structure (IS), is the central element to construct from information of species' intrinsic growth rates and their strength and sign of interactions. The global attractor has four main properties: (1) It contains all the limits of what is feasible and unfeasible of the dynamical behavior of an ecological system, therefore, (2) it provides a thorough characterization of all combinations of species' richness and composition in which species can coexist (i.e., feasible and stable equilibrium), (3) as well as all connections (paths) of assembly between coexisting communities. Importantly, (4) such topology of coexisting communities and their connections changes when environmental (abiotic and biotic) variation affects the ability of species to grow and interact with others. Overall, these four properties allow switching from a traditional evaluation of species coexistence at equilibrium to a much more realistic nonequilibrium perspective where changes in the structure of the global attractor underlie the transient ecological dynamics. Several fields in ecology can benefit from the study of an IS. For instance, it can serve to evaluate community responses after the end of a perturbation, to design restoration trajectories, to study the consequences of biological invasions on the persistence of native species within communities, or to assess ecosystem health status. We illustrate this latter possibility with empirical observations of 7 years in Mediterranean annual grasslands. We document that extremely wet or dry years generate ISs supporting few coexisting communities and few assembly paths. The remaining communities distinguish winners from losers of ongoing climate change and indicate the limits to future community assembly opportunities. A fully tractable operational framework is readily available to understand and predict the assembly and dynamics of ecological communities in an ever-changing world., Oscar Godoy acknowledges the financial support provided by the Spanish Ministry of Science, Innovation, and Universities (MICIU) and by the European Social Fund through the TASTE project (PID2021-127607OB-I00). José R. Portillo acknowledges the financial support provided by the Ecological and Digital Transition Projects 2021 of the Ministry of Science and Innovation in project TED2021-129748B-I00. José A. Langa and Fernando Soler-Toscano were partially supported by Fondo Europeo de Desarrollo Regional (FEDER) and Consejería de Economía, Conocimiento, Empresas y Universidad de la Junta de Andalucía, by Programa Operativo FEDER 2014-2020, reference P20-00592. José A. Langa and José R. Portillo were also partially supported by the Spanish Ministry of Science, Innovation, and Universities (MICIU) project PID2021-122991NB-C21., Peer reviewed
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Wild insects and honey bees are equally important to crop yields in a global analysis

  • Reilly, James
  • Bartomeus, Ignasi
  • Simpson, Dylan
  • Allen-Perkins, Alfonso
  • Garibaldi, Lucas A.
  • Winfree, Rachael
[Aim] Most of the world's food crops are dependent on pollinators. However, there isa great deal of uncertainty in the strength of this relationship, especially regarding therelative contributions of the honey bee (often a managed species) and wild insects tocrop yields on a global scale. Previous data syntheses have likewise reached differingconclusions on whether pollinator species diversity, or only the number of pollinatorvisits to flowers, is important to crop yield. This study quantifies the current state ofthese relationships and links to a dynamic version of our analyses that updates auto-matically as studies become available., [Location] Global., [Time Period] Present., [Taxa studied] Insect pollinators of global crops., [Methods] Using a newly created database of 93 crop pollination studies across six continents that roughly triples the number of studies previously available, we analysed the relationship between insect visit rates, pollinator diversity, and crop yields in a series of mixed-effects models., [Results] We found that honey bees and wild insects contribute roughly equal amounts to crop yields worldwide, having similar average flower visitation rates and producing similar increases in yield per visit. We also found that pollinator species diversity was positively associated with increased crop yields even when total visits from all species are accounted for, though it was less explanatory than the total number of visits itself., [Main conclusions] Our analysis suggests a middle ground where honey bees are not responsible for the vast majority of crop pollination as has often been assumed in the agricultural literature, and likewise wild insects are not vastly more important than honey bees, as recent global analyses have reported. We also conclude that while pollinator diversity is less important than the number of pollinator visits, these typically involve many species, underscoring the importance of conserving a diversity of wild pollinators., This research was funded through the 2017-2018 Belmont Forum and BiodivERsA joint call for research proposals, under the BiodivScen ERA-Net COFUND Programme, and with the funding organizations AEI, NWO, MINCyT and NSF. AA-P was funded by the Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation (MICINN) through the TASTE (PID2021-127607OB-I00), and ChaSisCOMA (PID2021-122711NB-C21) projects, and acknowledges financial support provided by the Comunidad de Madrid through the call Research Grants for Young Investigators from Universidad Politécnica de Madrid (APOYO-JOVENES-21-9K9EVJ-36-3VPZPJ)., Peer reviewed
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Comment on "Pollination supply models from a local to global scale": convolutional neural networks can improve pollination supply models at a global scale

  • Allen-Perkins, Alfonso
  • Giménez-García, Ángel
  • Magrach, Ainhoa
  • Galeano, Javier
  • Tarquis, Ana María
  • Bartomeus, Ignasi
Tools to predict pollinator activity at regional scales generally rely on land cover maps, combined with human-inferred mechanistic rules and/or expert knowledge. Recently, showed that, using large pollinator datasets, different environmental variables, and machine learning models, those predictions can be enhanced but at the cost of losing model interpretability. Here, we complement this work by exploring the potential of using advanced machine learning techniques to directly infer wild-bee visitation rates across different biomes only from land cover maps and available pollinator data while maintaining a mechanistic interpretation. In particular, we assess the ability of convolutional neural networks (CNNs), which are deep learning models, to infer mechanistic rules able to predict pollinator habitat use. At a global scale, our CNNs achieved a rank correlation coefficient of 0.44 between predictions and observations of pollinator visitation rates, doubling that of the previous human-inferred mechanistic models presented in (0.17). Most interestingly, we show that the predictions depend on both landscape composition and configuration variables, with prediction rules being more complex than those of traditional mechanistic processes. We also demonstrate how CNNs can improve the predictions of our previous data-driven models that did not use land cover maps by creating a new model that combined the predictions of our CNN with those of our best regression model based on environmental variables, a Bayesian ridge regressor. This new ensemble model improved the overall rank correlation from 0.56 to 0.64., This research was funded by the Comunidad de Madrid through the Research Grants for Young Investigators call from Universidad Politécnica de Madrid (APOYO-JOVENES-21-9K9EVJ-36-3VPZPJ). Alfonso Allen-Perkins was also funded by the Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation (MICINN) through the TASTE (PID2021-127607OB-I00) and ChaSisCOMA (PID2021-122711NB-C21) projects. Ainhoa Magrach acknowledges funding from a Ministry of Science and Innovation grant (PID2021-127900NB-I00), an Ikerbasque research professorship, and the Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation and the European Social Fund through the Ramón y Cajal Program (RYC2021-032351-I365). Research is co-funded by the European Union (ERC Consolidator Grant, GorBEEa 101086771). This research is part of the project PID2021-127900NB-I00 funded by the Ministry of Science and Innovation and supported by María de Maeztu Unit of Excellence 2023–2027, ref. CEX2021-001201-M, funded by MCIN/AEI /10.13039/501100011033., With funding from the Spanish government through the ‘María de Maeztu Unit of Excelence’ accreditation (CEX2021-001201-M), Peer reviewed
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Dense afforestation reduces plant–pollinator network diversity and persistence

  • Pérez-Gómez, Álvaro
  • Godoy, Óscar
  • Ojeda, Fernando
  • Repeto Deudero, Irene
  • Kaiser-Bunbury, Christopher N.
  • Simmons, Benno I.
Tree plantations are considered as a solution to reduce the impacts of climate change and can enhance biodiversity. Consequently, many tree planting schemes around the world have been started to achieve these dual objectives. However, many of these tree plantations are being implemented without proper design or post-plantation management, often overlooking potential long-term effects on biodiversity. Therefore, it is essential to identify which aspects of tree plantations can negatively impact biodiversity. Such knowledge is vital to design new plantations and manage existing ones, such that they do not pose threats or additional costs to the conservation of natural ecosystems. To this end, we conducted an observational study in the Mediterranean heathland habitat of the southwestern Iberian Peninsula. This treeless habitat, locally known as herriza, has been planted with pine trees until the onset of the 21st century. This historical tree plantation presents a unique natural experiment to assess the long-term effect of tree cover, measured as canopy openness, on several community properties of plant, pollinators and their network of interactions. Our results reveal a strong positive relationship between canopy openness and floristic diversity and abundance. This means that, as we increase tree cover, plant diversity is reduced. We found this has consequences for pollinator diversity and plant–pollinator networks, the latter exhibiting declines in stability. Furthermore, we reveal the importance of woody blooming plants in comparison to non-woody ones which, despite their greater importance for pollinators, they are the most impacted. These findings underscore the importance of tree cover for severely affecting multiple properties of plant–pollinator networks at different levels of organization. Overall, this knowledge indicates that high tree cover in plantations conducted 50 years ago is incompatible with maintaining and conserving plant–pollinator networks in natural treeless habitats, at least in the herriza. Actions that want to avoid negative long-term effects of tree plantations on plant–pollinator communities should consider existing biodiversity before planting and refrain from achieving high tree cover values. Read the free Plain Language Summary for this article on the Journal blog., APG, FO and IRD acknowledge financial support provided by FORPES project (PID2019-106908RA-I00/AEI/10.13039/501100011033) provided by the Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation (MICINN). APG and FO acknowledge for the POLINHER project (CA_BT2019) provided by the Fundación Biodiversidad. BIS was supported by a Royal Commission for the Exhibition of 1851 Research Fellowship. OG acknowledges financial support provided by the Spanish Ministry of Science, Innovation and Universities (MICIU) and by the European Social Fund through the TASTE (PID2021-127607OB-I00) and BIOTA (EUR2023-143472) projects. APG and IRD also acknowledge Universidad de Cádiz (Plan Propio UCA 2021-2023) for funding short research stays and other activities that significantly improved the quality of the study., Peer reviewed
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publicación Otros (Other)

A Continuum From Positive to Negative Interactions Drives Plant Species' Performance in a Diverse Community

  • Buche, Lisa
  • Shoemaker, Lauren G.
  • Hallett, Lauren M.
  • Bartomeus, Ignasi
  • Vesk, Peter
  • Weiss-Lehman, Christopher
  • Mayfield, Margaret M.
  • Godoy, Óscar
With many species interacting in nature, determining which interactions describe community dynamics is nontrivial. By applying a computational modeling approach to an extensive field survey, we assessed the importance of interactions from plants (both inter- and intra-specific), pollinators and insect herbivores on plant performance (i.e., viable seed production). We compared the inclusion of interaction effects as aggregate guild-level terms versus terms specific to taxonomic groups. We found that a continuum from positive to negative interactions, containing mostly guild-level effects and a few strong taxonomic-specific effects, was sufficient to describe plant performance. While interactions with herbivores and intraspecific plants varied from weakly negative to weakly positive, heterospecific plants mainly promoted competition and pollinators facilitated plants. The consistency of these empirical findings over 3 years suggests that including the guild-level effects and a few taxonomic-specific groups rather than all pairwise and high-order interactions, can be sufficient for accurately describing species variation in plant performance across natural communities., This work was supported by Ministerio de Asuntos Económicos y Transformación Digital, Gobierno de España. National Science Foundation NSF, 2019528, 2047239. Wyoming NASA EPSCoR, 80NSSC19M0061. European Social Fund Plus, PID2021- 127607OB- I00. Australian Research Council, DP210100913., Peer reviewed
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Neighbor density-dependent facilitation promotes coexistence and internal oscillation

  • Buche, Lisa
  • Shoemaker, Lauren G.
  • Vesk, Peter
  • Hallett, Lauren M.
  • Godoy, Óscar
  • Mayfield, Margaret M.
The ability of species to form diverse communities is not fully understood. Species are known to interact in various ways with their neighborhood. Despite this, common phenomenological models of species coexistence assume that per capita interactions are constant and competitive, even as the environment changes. In this study, we investigate how neighbor density-dependent variation in the strength and sign of species interactions changes species and community dynamics. We demonstrate that incorporating these sources of variation significantly improves predictions of ecological dynamics compared to the outcomes of typical models, which hold interaction strengths constant. We compared the performance of models based on different functions of neighbor density and identity in describing population trajectories (i.e., persistence over time) and community dynamics (i.e., temporal stability, synchrony, and degree of oscillation) in simulated two-species communities and a real, diverse annual plant system. In our simulated communities, we observed the highest level of coexistence between species pairs when species interactions varied from competitive to facilitative, depending on neighbor density (i.e., following a sigmoid function). Introducing within-guild facilitation through a nonlinear bounded function allowed populations, both simulated and empirical, to avoid extinction or runaway growth. In fact, nonlinear bounded functions (i.e., exponential and sigmoid functions) accurately predicted population trends over time within the range of abundances observed over the last 10 years. With the sigmoid function, the simulated communities of two species exhibited a higher probability of synchrony and oscillation compared to other functional forms. These simulated communities did not always show temporal stability, even when they were predicted to coexist. Overall, varying species interactions lead to realistic ecological trajectories and community dynamics when bounded by asymptotes based on neighbor density. These findings are crucial for advancing our understanding of how diverse communities are sustained and for applying ecological theory to real-world studies., Oscar Godoy acknowledges financial support provided by the European Social Fund through the TASTE project (PID2021-127607OB-I00). Lauren G. Shoemaker was supported by NSF grants (233292 and 2019528). Lauren M. Hallett was supported by NSF grant (2047239). Margaret Mayfield was supported by the Australian Research Council Discovery (DP210100913)., Peer reviewed
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Generalized plant–pollinator phenological climate-driven advances still lead to a decline in phenological overlap

  • Montes Pérez, Nerea
  • Molina, Francisco P.
  • Bartomeus, Ignasi
Climate change is altering the phenology of interacting species, potentially leading to mismatches in the timing of their interactions. This may affect the delivery of key ecosystem services such as pollination. Temperature-mediated phenological variation has been widely studied at the species level, showing that increased temperatures lead to earlier activity periods for both plant flowering and pollinator emergence. However, some classic examples of tracked interacting pairs show that phenological mismatches can occur between plants and pollinators. Even though plants and pollinators are embedded in complex interaction networks, it remains unclear how phenological shifts scale up to the community level and what role biodiversity may play in buffering negative outcomes. We analyzed an 8-year time series of plant and pollinator seasonal abundances across 12 Mediterranean scrublands increasingly affected by drought and extreme temperatures, focusing on the subset of common species whose phenology could be reliably described each year. Our aim is to understand how climate change has altered plant–pollinator interactions from the species to the community level. We found that plants and pollinators have been advancing their phenologies over time at similar rates, with an average advance of 5 days per decade. Changes in rainfall and temperature patterns are key drivers of these advances. Despite the congruent shifts and no consistent change in pairwise phenological overlap, total overlap between each species and its potential partners has slightly declined over time. While more diverse communities show higher potential overlap, biodiversity is not directly buffering the reduction in interaction overlap in the studied rich communities. However, in silico experiments show that the buffering effect of biodiversity becomes apparent at lower diversity levels (i.e., fewer than 10 species). In the context of ongoing climate change, protecting diverse communities with high interaction overlap is crucial, as phenological shifts may gradually erode network structure in Mediterranean plant–pollinator systems. Sustained long-term data collection is also essential to understand the fate of most species, including those whose low abundances may conceal early signs of biodiversity loss., Fieldwork has been funded by the FP7 People: Marie-Curie Actions (PCIG 14-GA-2013-631653) to Ignasi Bartomeus. Nerea Montes-Perez is funded through the European Union's Horizon 2020 research and innovation program SAFEGUARD under grant agreement number 101003476. This work was also funded by the Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation through the TASTE project (PID2021-127607OB-I00), as part of the “Proyectos de Generación de Conocimiento” program., Peer reviewed
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

A practical guide to characterising ecological coexistence

  • Clark, Adam T.
  • Shoemaker, Lauren G.
  • Arnoldi, Jean-François
  • Barabás, György
  • Germain, Rachel
  • Godoy, Óscar
  • Hallett, Lauren M.
  • Karakoç, Canan
  • Saavedra, Serguei
  • Schreiber, S.
Coexistence is simultaneously one of the most fundamental concepts of ecology, and one of the most difficult to define. A particular challenge is that, despite a well-developed body of research, several different schools of thought have developed over the past century, leading to multiple independent, and largely isolated, branches of literature with distinct methodologies. Here, we provide a broad overview of the most common concepts and metrics currently used to detect and characterise ecological coexistence. We first introduce four classes of behaviour, which jointly describe the ways in which community dynamics can unfold: (i) the existence of a feasible steady state (or invariant set), i.e. where all coexisting species retain positive abundances in the long-term in the absence of interference by external forces; (ii) the existence of a local attractor that draws the community towards a feasible steady state from within a restricted set of starting conditions; (iii) the existence of a global attractor that draws the community towards feasible steady states from any non-zero starting condition; and (o) a null transient state, where species abundances vary over time irrespective of steady states and attractors. Next, we explain how these classes of behaviour relate to commonly used metrics for identifying and characterising coexistence, including analyses of parameter sensitivity, asymptotic return rates, invasion growth rates, and time to extinction. We then discuss the scope and limitations of each of these behavioural classes and corresponding metrics, with a particular focus on applications in empirical systems. Finally, we provide a potential workflow for matching empirical questions to theoretical tools, and present a brief prospectus looking forward to opportunities for advancing and integrating research on coexistence., Spanish Ministry of Science, Innovation, and Universities (MICIU). Grant Number: PID2021-127607OB-100; National Science Foundation. Grant Number: 2019528; Grantová Agentura České Republiky. Grant Number: 24-14299L; Austrian Science Fund. Grant Number: I 6578; European Social Fund. Open Access funding provided by Universitat Graz/KEMÖ., Peer reviewed
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publicación Otros (Other)

Plant-Pollinator Interaction Rewiring Boosts Year-to-Year Community Persistence

  • Domínguez-García, Virginia
  • Molina, Francisco P.
  • Allen-Perkins, Alfonso
  • Godoy, Óscar
  • Bartomeus, Ignasi
Despite widespread recognition of the dynamic nature of ecological interactions, the consequences for community persistence of the observed year-to-year changes in species interactions have remained overlooked. Our research bridges this gap, leveraging a uniquely high-quality dataset spanning 8 years and 12 independent sites—offering unparalleled resolution to examine plant-pollinator interactions. Here, we characterise year-to-year variation in plant-pollinator interactions and compare their structural stability (a robust theoretical measure describing species persistence) with that of null models simulating random rewiring. We discover that although most interaction changes (80%) are caused by species turnover, it is the temporal rewiring among permanent species that primarily enhances pollinator persistence. This interaction rewiring is not random and effectively boosts pollinator persistence despite being primarily determined by changes in the phenologies and abundances of the permanent pollinator species. While not fully optimised, these adaptive responses underscore the vital role of rewiring in fostering ecological stability amid a changing world., This project has received funding from the European Union's Horizon 2021 research and innovation programme under the Marie Skłodowska-Curie grant agreement No 101064340, and from the Emergia grant agreement DGP_EMEC_2023_00146 to Virginia Domínguez-Garcia, TASTE Project (PID2021-127607OB-I00) to Oscar Godoy, Ignasi Bartomeus, Alfonso Allen-Perkins, and Virginia Domínguez-Garcia, and BeeFUN project (PCIG 14-GA-2013-631653) to Ignasi Bartomeus., Peer reviewed
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Datos de investigación Set de datos (Dataset)

Stably coexisting communities deliver higher ecosystem multifunctionality

  • Daniel, Caroline
  • Godoy, Óscar
  • Pichon, Noémie A.
  • Gheno, Mathis
  • Allan, Eric
Linking the processes determining species coexistence and effects of biodiversity on ecosystem functioning is important for a mechanistic understanding of how species loss impacts ecosystems. There are good theoretical reasons to expect stably coexisting communities to deliver higher ecosystem functioning, as niche differences should promote coexistence and complementarity, however, there is still little empirical evidence to demonstrate this relationship. We present a novel experimental approach to tackle this question, in which we first measured interaction coefficients and intrinsic growth rates for 12 grassland species and used population models to estimate coexistence5. We then assembled 48 three-species communities, predicted to differ in their degree of coexistence and measured seven above and belowground functions. Here we extend findings demonstrating that biodiversity increases multifunctionality to show that amongst communities with the same initial diversity, multifunctionality is higher when all the species are predicted to coexist. Decomposing coexistence into the influence of niche and fitness differences showed that multifunctionality was high in niche differentiated communities but also in those with a single highly competitive species. We further examined the effect of indirect interactions, which provide an alternative mechanism of coexistence in multispecies communities, and found that they also provided an alternative route to high multifunctionality. Our results point the way to a unification of coexistence and biodiversity theory and to a more mechanistic understanding of the functional effects of biodiversity change., Swiss National Science Foundation: 31003A_160212, 310030_185260, 310030_215442; Ministerio de Ciencia, Innovación y Universidades: PID2021-127607OB-I00, EUR2023-143472, Peer reviewed
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Datos de investigación Set de datos (Dataset)

Pine afforestation alters the ground-dwelling arthropod fauna of the Mediterranean heathland

  • Pérez-Gómez, Álvaro
  • Ojeda, Fernando
  • Repeto Deudero, Irene
  • Godoy, Óscar
Treeless habitats have historically been undervalued and extensively afforested. While these afforestation programs aim to deliver economic and ecological benefits, they can negatively impact biodiversity, particularly of ground-dwelling arthropods, due to changes in microhabitat conditions and food resources. This study examines the effects of pine afforestation on the diversity of ground-dwelling arthropods in the Mediterranean heathland (herriza), a unique treeless habitat in the western Mediterranean Basin, subject to extensive afforestation in the second half of the 20th century. We assessed alpha diversity (taxonomic richness, abundance, and inverse Simpson index) and beta diversity (changes in taxonomic composition) of ground-dwelling arthropods (identified at the family level), and the group of spiders (identified at the species level). We also explored changes in functional traits (functional beta diversity) in spiders. Field observations were conducted over five seasonal periods within one year, using pitfall traps in five sites, each with adjacent open and afforested herriza plots. While afforestation had no significant effect on the alpha diversity or abundance of ground-dwelling arthropod families and spider species within individual seasons, pooled analyses revealed distinct trends. Specifically, afforested plots exhibited higher overall arthropod abundance at the family level, yet significantly lower spider species richness and abundance. In contrast, beta diversity analyses showed significant shifts in taxonomic composition between open and afforested herriza plots for both groups. Despite these compositional shifts and high functional beta diversity, overall functional diversity indices for spiders did not significantly change with afforestation., Open Access funding provided thanks to the CRUE-CSIC agreement with Springer Nature. APG, FO and IRD acknowledge financial support provided by FORPES project (PID2019-106908RA-I00/AEI/https://doi.org/10.13039/501100011033) funded by the Ministry of Science and Innovation (MICINN) including EU FEDER funds. OG acknowledges financial support provided by the Spanish Ministry of Science, Innovation and Universities (MICIU) and by the European Social Fund through the TASTE (PID2021-127607OB-I00, including EU FEDER funds) and BIOTA (EUR2023-143472) projects. IRD is supported by an FPI-UCA contract (UCA-REC13VPCT-2020). APG and IRD also acknowledges funding from Plan Propio UCA (2021–2023). Finally, OG and APG acknowledge financial support provided by UCCO (CNS2023-144337) provided by the Spanish Ministry of Science, Innovation and Universities., Peer reviewed
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

A general framework for invasion cycles in ecology

  • Calleja Solanas, Violeta
  • Moura, Rafael O.
  • Langa, José A.
  • Portillo, José R.
  • Soler Toscano, Fernando
  • Godoy, Óscar
Theory predicts that indirect interactions in ecological networks sustain species diversity through oscillatory dynamics. However, a framework linking interaction structure to the presence, type, and complexity of these cycles is lacking. Here, we develop an analytical toolbox combining invasion graphs with a mathematical decomposition of interaction matrices into symmetric and antisymmetric components. We find that invasion cycles-closed loops of species invasions-are suppressed when symmetric interactions dominate, reflecting strong self-limitation. Conversely, antisymmetric dominance, indicating competitive asymmetries, leads to the well-known cycles of single-species invasion such as rock-paper-scissors as well as novel multispecies invasion patterns, in which several species simultaneously invade each transition of the cycle. As asymmetries increase, more complex cycles involving both sequential and simultaneous invasions emerge. Yet this potential for cycles is suppressed as variability in intrinsic growth rates increases. Our work clarifies when interactions drive cycles and introduces a simple ratio that assesses symmetric versus antisymmetric contributions in the interaction matrix, constraining cycle emergence and the number of species they can sustain., The authors would like to express their gratitude for the financial support received. JAL, FS-T, and JRP acknowledge partial support from the Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation, under Grant #PID2024-156228NB-100. JAL and JRP thank IMUS-Maria de Maeztu grant CEX2024-001517-M – Apoyo a Unidades de Excelencia María de Maeztu for supporting this research, funded by MICIU/AEI/10.13039/501100011033. ROM acknowledges the support from the Sao Paulo Research Foundation ˜ (FAPESP) through Grants #2022/04886-2 and #2023/ 11798-5. VCS and OG acknowledge the financial support provided by the Spanish Ministry of Innovation, Science, and Universities and the European Social Fund through grants TASTE (#PID2021-127607OB-I00) and BIOTA (#EUR2023-143472)., Peer reviewed
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Environmental heterogeneity promotes regional coexistence through shifts in local competitive dominance

  • Hurtado, María
  • García-Callejas, David
  • Bartomeus, Ignasi
  • Godoy, Óscar
Understanding plant competitive outcomes, driven by niche and fitness differences, requires exploring these differences across simultaneous changes in abiotic and biotic conditions, such as soil properties, mutualisms and natural enemies. Here, we combined coexistence theory with detailed field observations in an annual grassland over two consecutive years and in silico simulations to assess changes in competitive outcomes, from coexistence to competitive exclusion, and from exclusion to priority effects. Our analysis shows that competitive exclusion is the most common outcome but with marked changes in the identity of the superior competitor under abiotic and biotic variation, highlighting the potential for regional coexistence. Herbivores were identified as the factor with the largest effect on the sensitivity of species pairs to shifts between coexistence and exclusion, although the effect size reflects sensitivity rather than the direction of change. Additionally, herbivores strongly influence the identity of the superior competitor, which can promote coexistence at larger spatial scales. Local coexistence was rarely predicted in our system. Finally, priority effects were mostly observed in the absence of a deterministic driver, as expected. Overall, our results suggest that while local coexistence is limited, species diversity can be maintained across larger spatial scales through shifts in competitive dominance mediated by multiple abiotic and biotic drivers., MH was supported by Ministerio de Ciencia e Innovación (grant no. PRE 2019-088280). DGC was funded by the New Zealand's Biological Heritage National Science Challenge and by the Austrian Science Fund (project ESP-671). OG and IB were supported by the Spanish Ministry of Science, Innovation and Universities and by the European Social Fund through the TASTE project (PID2021-127607OB- I00), Peer reviewed
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Trait-mediated interactions drive local diversity

  • Buche, Lisa
  • Godoy, Óscar
  • Shoemaker, Lauren G.
  • Vesk, Peter
  • Hallett, Lauren M.
  • Taylor, Courtney G.
  • Siu, Wing Man
  • Sevenello, Manuel
  • Mayfield, Margaret M.
Identifying overarching processes that maintain biodiversity in natural communities remains a challenge in ecology. Although functional traits help explain regional species distributions, they often fall short at the local community level. We investigate whether traits can offer mechanism-based insights into local diversity maintenance due to associations with the sign and strength of plant interactions. We examine the effect of 12 plant functional traits on the sign and strength of pairwise species interactions across two Mediterranean annual plant communities. Results show that traits mediate a spectrum from facilitative to competitive interactions and are influenced by neighbor density and identity. At low densities, species with conservative resource-use traits are consistently stronger facilitators than acquisitive species. The traits of the focal species, however, explain facilitation at low densities better than the traits of neighbors or the pairwise differences in traits. When neighbor density increases, facilitation switches to competition, a pattern we hypothesize reflects a density-mediated reduction in how much neighbors’ traits drive interactions. Moreover, species frequently receiving heterospecific facilitation also display traits associated with self-competition and low intrinsic population growth rate. This study of community-level trait sorting provides insights into the persistence of co-occurring populations, showing trait-based generalizable insights into the local context dependency of species interactions., L.B. acknowledges financial support provided by the Dr. Albert Shimmins Fund. L.B. and M.S. acknowledge financial support provided by the Holsworth Wildlife Research Endowment—Equity Trustees Charitable Foundation & the Ecological Society of Australia. O.G. acknowledges financial support provided by the Spanish Ministry of Economy and Competitiveness and by the European Social Fund through the “The effect of Temporal vAriability of Species inTEractions on the stability of ecosystems” project (PID2021-127607OB-I00). L.G.S. was supported by NSF Grants 2-33292 and 2019528. L.M.H. was supported by NSF, Grant #2047239. M.M.M., L.B., and W.M.S. were supported by the Australian Research Council Discovery (DP210100913–DP1094413). M.M.M. and C.G.T. were supported by the Australian Research Council Discovery (DP23100522)., Peer reviewed
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Species Accumulation Stabilizes the Synchronous Responses to the Environment of Vertebrate Communities Worldwide

  • Picó, Sergio
  • Almaraz, Pablo
  • Godoy, Óscar
Multiple drivers contribute to community stability measured as the temporal invariability of total abundance, density, or biomass. However, the direct and indirect effects of these drivers, such as number of species, synchrony between species, species' life strategies, and environmental conditions in communities of terrestrial vertebrates remain unclear. To address this gap, we compiled a worldwide dataset of time series corresponding to 124 natural communities of terrestrial vertebrates including mammals, birds, and reptiles. We found that communities tend to be more synchronous than expected under the theoretical scenario of weak covariance between species because, at the interannual level, shared responses to the environment predominate over compensatory dynamics. Furthermore, piecewise structural equation models reveal that the number of species had a consistent positive effect on stability (either directly or indirectly via synchrony), but the sign and magnitude of the paths involving synchrony changed depending on the metric used and whether detrending was applied or not. Interestingly, we did not find the expected decreasing latitudinal gradient in community stability towards the poles. Our results demonstrate that the synchrony metrics used are not interchangeable and thus, whenever we use multivariate methods to understand the relation between richness, synchrony, and stability, our results may depend on how we define synchrony and how we measure it. Put together, our results also reinforce the idea of the predominance of environmental forcing over compensatory dynamics and the key role of the accumulation of species (statistical averaging) for the temporal stability of ecological communities., S.P. acknowledges financial support provided by the University of Cádiz (UCA/R93REC/2019). O.G. acknowledges financial support provided by the Spanish Ministry of Economy and Competitiveness (MINECO) and by the European Social Fund through the TASTE (PID2021-127607OB-I00) project., Peer reviewed
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Cooperation Maximizes Biodiversity

  • Godoy, Óscar
  • Calleja Solanas, Violeta
  • Soler Toscano, Fernando
  • Portillo, José R.
  • Suárez, Antonio
  • Langa, José A.
[EN] Cooperation, the mutual benefit that individuals of different species obtain when interacting, is ubiquitous in nature. Despite their prevalence, we know little about the mechanisms particular to cooperation that maintain biodiversity. To address this gap, we introduce cooperation into structural stability, a general framework for understanding how species interactions determine the long-term persistence of species within communities. This approach allows the identification of three distinct processes. First, cooperation increases the opportunities for species to coexist more than interspecific competition does, improving species persistence across a wider range of environmental conditions. Second, cooperation creates intertwined biodiversity, where the existence of some species begets the presence of others. Third, cooperation promotes alternative structures of community assembly due to variations in species’ performance. These structures diversify the pathways to species coexistence. In conclusion, our work suggests that cooperation, relative to interspecific competition, maximizes the maintenance of biodiversity., [ES] La cooperación, el beneficio mutuo que las especies obtienen al interactuar, está siempre presente en la naturaleza. A pesar de su prevalencia, sabemos poco sobre las características únicas de la cooperación por las cuales mantiene la biodiversidad. Para abordar esta falta de conocimiento, introducimos la cooperación en la estabilidad estructural, un marco general para comprender cómo las interacciones entre especies y la variabilidad ambiental determinan la persistencia a largo plazo de las especies dentro de las comunidades. Este enfoque permite la identificación de tres procesos. Primero, la cooperación aumenta las oportunidades de coexistencia de las especies más que la competencia interespecífica, mejorando la persistencia de las especies en un espectro más amplio de condiciones ambientales. Segundo, la cooperación crea biodiversidad entrelazada donde la existencia de algunas especies ayuda a la presencia de otras. Tercero, la cooperación promueve estructuras alternativas de ensamblaje de comunidades debido a las variaciones en el rendimiento de las especies. Estas estructuras diversifican en conjunto las vías para la coexistencia de las especies. En conclusión, nuestro trabajo sugiere que la cooperación, en comparación con la competencia interespecífica, maximiza el mantenimiento de la biodiversidad., O.G. and V.C.-S. acknowledge the financial support provided by the Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation through the TASTE project PID2021-127607OB-I00. J.R.P. acknowledges the financial support provided by the Ecological and Digital Transition Projects 2021 of the Ministry of Science and Innovation in the project TED2021-129748B-I00. J.A.L. and F.S.-T. were partially supported by Fondo Europeo de Desarrollo Regional (FEDER) and Consejería de Economía, Conocimiento, Empresas y Universidad de la Junta de Andalucía, by Programa Operativo FEDER 2014-2020, reference P20-00592. J.A.L., F.S.-T., and J.R.P. were also partially supported by Ministry of Science and Innovation project PID2024-156228NB-100. F.S.-T. was partially supported by Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation project PID2020-117871GB-I00. J.A.L. and J.R.P. thank IMUS–Maria de Maeztu grant CEX2024-001517-M—Apoyo a Unidades de Excelencia María de Maeztu for supporting this research, funded by MICIU/AEI/10.13039/501100011033., With funding form the Spanish government through the “María de Maeztu Unit of Excellence” accreditation (CEX2024-001517-M)., Peer reviewed
Zaguán. Repositorio Digital de la Universidad de Zaragoza
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Fast–slow traits predict competition network structure and its response to resources and enemies

  • Daniel, Caroline
  • Allan, Eric
  • Saiz, Hugo
  • Godoy, Oscar
Plants interact in complex networks but how network structure depends on resources, natural enemies and species resource‐use strategy remains poorly understood. Here, we quantified competition networks among 18 plants varying in fast–slow strategy, by testing how increased nutrient availability and reduced foliar pathogens affected intra‐ and inter‐specific interactions. Our results show that nitrogen and pathogens altered several aspects of network structure, often in unexpected ways due to fast and slow growing species responding differently. Nitrogen addition increased competition asymmetry in slow growing networks, as expected, but decreased it in fast growing networks. Pathogen reduction made networks more even and less skewed because pathogens targeted weaker competitors. Surprisingly, pathogens and nitrogen dampened each other's effect. Our results show that plant growth strategy is key to understand how competition respond to resources and enemies, a prediction from classic theories which has rarely been tested by linking functional traits to competition networks.