DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publicación
Artículo científico (JournalArticle)
Feed additives for methane mitigation: Recommendations for testing enteric methane-mitigating feed additives in ruminant studies
There is a need for rigorous and scientifically-based testing standards for existing and new enteric methane mitigation technologies, including antimethanogenic feed additives (AMFA). The current review provides guidelines for conducting and analyzing data from experiments with ruminants intended to test the antimethanogenic and production effects of feed additives. Recommendations include study design and statistical analysis of the data, dietary effects, associative effect of AMFA with other mitigation strategies, appropriate methods for measuring methane emissions, production and physiological responses to AMFA, and their effects on animal health and product quality. Animal experiments should be planned based on clear hypotheses, and experimental designs must be chosen to best answer the scientific questions asked, with pre-experimental power analysis and robust post-experimental statistical analyses being important requisites. Long-term studies for evaluating AMFA are currently lacking and are highly needed. Experimental conditions should be representative of the production system of interest, so results and conclusions are applicable and practical. Methane-mitigating effects of AMFA may be combined with other mitigation strategies to explore additivity and synergism, as well as trade-offs, including relevant manure emissions, and these need to be studied in appropriately designed experiments. Methane emissions can be successfully measured, and efficacy of AMFA determined, using respiration chambers, the sulfur hexafluoride method, and the GreenFeed system. Other techniques, such as hood and face masks, can also be used in short-term studies, ensuring they do not significantly affect feed intake, feeding behavior, and animal production. For the success of an AMFA, it is critically important that representative animal production data are collected, analyzed, and reported. In addition, evaluating the effects of AMFA on nutrient digestibility, animal physiology, animal health and reproduction, product quality, and how AMFA interact with nutrient composition of the diet is necessary and should be conducted at various stages of the evaluation process. The authors emphasize that enteric methane mitigation claims should not be made until the efficacy of AMFA is confirmed in animal studies designed and conducted considering the guidelines provided herein., The authors acknowledge the financial support of the Global Dairy Platform (Rosemont, IL) through its Pathways to Net Zero initiative. A. N. Hristov was supported by the USDA (Washington, DC) National Institute of Food and Agriculture Federal Appropriations under Project PEN 04539 and Accession Number 1000803. A. Bannink was supported by the Ministry of Agriculture, Nature and Food Quality under the project Global Research Alliance (BO-43.10-001-001; the Hague, the Netherlands). A. Belanche is funded by the Spanish State Research Agency (AEI; Madrid, Spain) through a Ramón y Cajal research contract (RYC2019-027764-I) and the project (PID2021-12306OB-100). M. C. Cajarville was supported by the Veterinary Faculty of the Uruguayan Public University (IPAV, FVet – UdelaR, Montevideo, Uruguay), under the INNOVAGRO project (FSA_1_2018_1_152588; Rosemont, IL). F. Garcia was supported by the Global Dairy Platform. D. Meo Zilio is supported by CREA under the AGRIDIGIT project (D.M.36507/7305/2018), funded by the Italian Ministry of Agriculture (MASAF; Rome, Italy). A. Schwarm was supported by the Research Council of Norway (Oslo, Norway), FRIMEDBIO programme, project number 316157 (ViableCow). S. Stergiadis was supported by the University of Reading (Reading, UK), and the European Union's Horizon Europe research and innovation programme under the grant agreement no. 01059609 (Re-Livestock project; Brussels, Belgium). K. Theodoridou was supported by Queen's University (Belfast, UK) and the European Union's Horizon Europe research and innovation programme under the grant agreement no. 01059609 (Re-Livestock project). D. R. Yáñez-Ruiz was supported by the European Union's Horizon Europe research and innovation programme under the grant agreement no. 01059609 (Re-Livestock project). E. M. Ungerfeld was supported by Agencia Nacional de Investigación y Desarrollo, Santiago, Chile, Project Fondecyt 1240264. P. Lund was supported by the Ministry of Food, Agriculture, and Fisheries under the project “Flagship projects related to Global Research Alliance” (Copenhagen, Denmark).