Minerva. Repositorio Institucional de la Universidad de Santiago de Compostela
Publication
Artículo científico (JournalArticle)
Competencias en el uso de pruebas en argumentación, Competencies in the use of evidence in argumentation
The relevance of the competence in the use of scientific evidence in argumentation is discussed
in the context of its prominence in PISA and policy. The paper outlines a proposal of two
dimensions of the competence: (1) metaknowledge, or knowledge about the use of evidence,
including nature of evidence, its role, and criteria for evaluating evidence; and (2) practice of
the use of evidence, including the use of evidence in different contexts and the operations
involved in it. The different elements in the proposal are discussed drawing from the literature,
and particularly from the authors’ studies with two tasks set in socio-scientific contexts:
evaluation of Watson’s claim about differences in intelligence between ‘races’, and decision
about the ecological efficiency of eating secondary versus tertiary carnivore fish. The difficulties
found, both in secondary school and in university students, point to the need to pay specific
attention to this dimension of argumentation