Skip to main content

Resultados relacionados

Resultados totales (Incluyendo duplicados): 2
Encontrada(s) 1 página(s)

DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Harmonizing methods to account for soil nitrous oxide emissions in Life Cycle Assessment of agricultural systems

  • Goglio, P.
  • Moakes, S.
  • Knudsen, M.T.
  • Van Mierlo, K.
  • Adams, N.
  • Maxime, F.
  • Maresca, A.
  • Romero-Huelva, Manuel
  • Waqas, M.A.
  • Smith, L.G.
  • Grossi, G.
  • Smith, W.
  • De Camillis, C.
  • Nemecek, T.
  • Tei, F.
  • Oudshoorn, F.W.
CONTEXT: Worldwide greenhouse gas emissions (GHG) reached 59 Gt of COeq in 2019 and agricultural soils are the primary source of NO emissions. Life cycle assessments (LCA) have been successful in assessing GHG from agricultural systems. However, no review and harmonization attempt has been focused on soil NO emissions, despite the need to improve LCA methodologies for assessing GHG in agricultural LCA. OBJECTIVE: We therefore undertook a review and harmonization of existing methods to account for soil NO emissions in LCA of agricultural systems and products: i) to compare current methods used in LCA; ii) to identify advantages and iii) disadvantages of each method in LCA; iv) to suggest recommendations for LCA of agricultural systems; v) to identify research needs and potential methodological developments to account for soil NO emissions in the LCA of agricultural systems. In this paper, we consider as soil NO emissions, those originated from soils in relation to fertilisers (organic and manufactured), crop residues, land use/land management change, grassland management, manure and slurry applications and from grazing animals. METHODS: The approach adopted was based on two anonymous expert surveys and a series of expert workshops (n = 21) to define general and specific criteria to review LCA methods for GHG emissions used in LCA of agricultural systems. A broad list of keywords and search criteria was used as the research involved GHG assessment in agricultural LCA. Reviewed papers and methodology were then assessed by LCA and soil NO emission experts (n = 14). RESULTS AND DISCUSSION: >25,000 scientific papers and reports were identified, 1175 were screened, 263 included in the final review and 31 scientific papers were related to soil NO emissions. The results showed that a high level of accuracy corresponded to a low level of applicability and vice versa, following the assessment framework developed in this work through participatory approaches. SIGNIFICANCE: The choice of LCA methods, critical for high quality LCA of agricultural systems, should be based on the assessment objectives, data availability and expertise of the LCA practitioner. However, it is preferable to use DNDC model after calibration and validation or direct field measurements, considering system effects. When necessary data are lacking, IPCC tier 2 methodology where available should be used, otherwise 2019 IPCC Tier 1 methodology. This LCA method development should be synchronous with improvements of quantification methods and the assessment of a wider range of agricultural management practices and systems., This research has been developed within the PATHWAYS project, funded by the European Union’s Horizon 2020 Research and Innovation Programme European Union through Horizon 2020 Research and Innovation Programme under grant agreement No 101000395.
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Harmonizing soil carbon simulation models, emission factors and direct measurements used in LCA of agricultural systems

  • Pelaracci, S.;
  • Goglio, P.
  • Moakes, S.
  • Knudsen, M.T.
  • Van Mierlo, K.
  • Adams, N.
  • Maxime, F.
  • Maresca, A.
  • Romero-Huelva, Manuel
  • Waqas, M.A.
  • Smith, L.G.
  • Oudshoorn, F.W.
  • Nemecek, T.
  • de Camillis, C.
  • Grossi, G.
  • Smith, W.
CONTEXT: The increasing demand for animal products, coupled with the need to reduce greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions from livestock production, highlights the urgency for effective mitigation strategies for livestock systems, including the cropping systems. Soil organic carbon (SOC) sequestration, a crucial approach for reducing atmospheric GHG concentrations, is often underrepresented in Life Cycle Assessments (LCA) of agricultural systems, largely due to methodological challenges in accurately accounting for soil carbon dynamics. OBJECTIVE: The objective of this study was to evaluate soil carbon simulation models, emission factors and direct measurements used in LCA, with the aim of developing a harmonized approach for including soil carbon change in agricultural LCAs. The goals were to: i) assess soil carbon simulation models, emissions factors and direct measurements used in LCAs of agricultural systems; ii) evaluate the strengths and weaknesses of these models; iii) provide recommendations for LCA practitioners; and iv) identify areas for future methodological improvements. METHODS: A systematic review of soil carbon simulation models, emission factors and direct measurements used in LCAs of agricultural systems was conducted, obtaining 263 relevant articles from an initial pool of 29,151. In addition to direct measurements, fifteen soil carbon simulation models and three methods based on emission factors were identified and categorized into three tiers based on complexity and data requirements. A modified Delphi participatory process was used to evaluate each method against established criteria through expert workshops. RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS: The results showed an inverse relationship between applicability and accuracy of methods, making the choice of methodology critical to achieving high-quality LCA results. Recommendations emphasize selecting methods based on objectives and data availability, while being aware of the effect of the initial soil carbon level and the assessment time period when using soil carbon simulation models. In addition, this study identified current methodological challenges in assessing soil C dynamics in LCA of agricultural systems. SIGNIFICANCE: This research provides a foundation for improving LCA practices and supports better decision-making in mitigating climate impacts of agricultural systems., This research has been developed within the PATHWAYS project, funded by the European Union's Horizon 2020 Research and Innovation Programme under grant agreement No 101000395.