Skip to main content

Resultados relacionados

Resultados totales (Incluyendo duplicados): 2
Encontrada(s) 1 página(s)

DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Reply to: Ecological variables for deep-ocean monitoring must include microbiota and meiofauna for effective conservation

  • Danovaro, Roberto
  • Fanelli, Emanuela
  • Aguzzi, Jacopo
  • Billett, David S.M.
  • Carugati, Laura
  • Corinaldesi, Cinzia
  • Dell’Anno, Antonio
  • Gjerde, Kristina
  • Jamieson, Alan J.
  • Kark, Salit
  • McClain, Craig R.
  • Levin, Lisa A.
  • Levin, Noam
  • Ramírez-Llodra, Eva
  • Ruhl, Henry A.
  • Smith, Craig R.
  • Snelgrove, Paul V. R.
  • Thomsen, Laurenz
  • Van Dover, Cindy L.
  • Yasuhara, Moriaki
2 pages.-- Reply to: Ecological variables for deep-ocean monitoring must include microbiota and meiofauna for effective conservation, J. Ingels et al. Nature Ecology & Evolution 5: 27-29 (2021), doi: 10.1038/s41559-020-01335-6, Meiofauna and microbes are key components of deep-sea ecosystem assessments and were included among the list of essential variables in our recent comprehensive assessment and prioritization of a global deep-ocean monitoring and conservation strategy1. Meiofauna ranked in the top three variables, whereas microbes (bacteria, and archaea) were reported as key variables for some aspects of monitoring the deep sea. However, larger components of the deep-sea fauna (such as macro- and megafauna) received the highest priority. In their Matters Arising, Ingels and co-workers2 criticized the ranking because, in their opinion, macro- and megafaunal components cannot be considered higher-priority variables than microbes and meiofauna. They concluded that this result reflects an unequal distribution of the competence of the authors and of the respondents to the elicitation survey. However, their criticisms are unjustified for conceptual, methodological and operational reasons. On semantic and theoretical grounds, Ingels et al. confused the concept of priority with that of relevance/importance. Ingels et al. seem also to confound the concept of monitoring and protecting with the importance of research for advancing scientific knowledge; these are two partly related, but distinct, objectives. Indeed, recognizing the ecological importance of one biological component is one thing, but identifying the monitoring variables where capacity to deliver for conservation management globally is well established, is quite another. We cannot apply the same monitoring and conservation approach to all biological components because small organisms, such as prokaryotes, protists and meiofauna encompass massive numbers of undescribed species with largely unknown ecologies3,4 and shorter turnover times, which may make them more resilient to disturbance than larger biota. Even an ocean completely depleted of large fauna, for example, sharks and all predators, would remain flush with meiofauna and microbes. Yet, a deep-sea system with abundant meiofauna and prokaryotes would almost certainly function poorly without higher trophic levels. This well-known ecological principle is certainly one of the reasons there was a wide consensus among the 112 experts (including the microbiologists and meiofauna experts who participated in the expert elicitation) on censusing larger species to protect vulnerable habitats they inhabit or create. The much more limited evidence for microbial and meiofaunal endemicity, the great proportion of unidentified species and the lack of life-history information, greatly compromise any proposal to use these components as proxies for monitoring and mapping conservation areas. Thus, the results of the expert elicitation, on the one hand, reflect the maturity of the disciplines and the capability to deliver indicator information and, on the other hand, recognize the role of larger organisms in current conservation priorities, while acknowledging fundamental roles of all groups., Another important aspect overlooked by Ingels et al. is that deep-sea biodiversity was only one of the five main research areas addressed by the study. In the second research area we considered, which was dedicated to ecosystem functions, benthic faunal biomass and benthic faunal production were ranked as top variables (see table 1 in Danovaro et al.1). Because meiofauna and microbes typically dominate benthic faunal biomass at abyssal depths5,6, we took care to emphasize the functional role of microbial components: “microbes (primarily bacteria followed by archaea) largely dominate overall biomass and production. These microscopic components, essential for deep-sea ecosystem functions … we stress microbial heterotrophic and chemoautotrophic C production as two essential ecological variables needed for understanding the key processes sustaining the functioning of deep-sea food webs and biogeochemical cycles”. We also strongly disagree with the methodological criticisms of Ingels et al. As scientists, we endeavour to remove all potential sources of bias in the framework of standard good practices for data evaluation. Our study is based on expert elicitation, which is a procedure to find consensus on priorities, not an experiment with treatments and controls; thus, standard deviations cannot be treated as in ecological experimental designs. Our Perspective describes how we endeavoured to achieve an objective methodology (that is, coverage of different research fields and knowledge for each of the five main themes, scientists covered a broad range of geographic regions, different taxonomic expertise, academic qualifications and years of experience). These aspects, including statistical treatment, were discussed in detail using multiple rounds of enquiries, following rigorous procedures7, and were presented transparently in the supplementary information of our paper1. To our knowledge, the 112 scientists participating in this elicitation make this study the widest deep-sea community ever to participate in defining priorities based on standardized questions. Ingels et al. assumed that microbial and meiofaunal components were not prioritized because most of the respondents were macrofaunal or megafaunal experts. However, this is not evident in our data, because a large fraction of respondents covered multiple fields of expertise (note that the supplementary information1 reported only one main topic per scientist). Their criticism suggests that deep-sea scientists are divided into two groups: micro- meiofaunal experts competing against macro- megafaunal experts, fighting to prioritize their own work, rather than a community working together towards a common objective. Obtaining expert opinions for comprehensive deep-sea management, as we did, requires the involvement of scientists working in different sectors (such as deep-sea technologies, conservation biology, biological oceanography, biogeochemistry, policy and management), thus participants cannot simply be classified as experts by faunal size category. The fact that many scientists, in responding to the questionnaire, did not automatically prioritize their own research specialty for deep-ocean monitoring, conservation and impact assessment suggests that this is a false and non-productive dichotomy. Accordingly, we reaffirm that the expert elicitation reported in Danovaro et al.1 is robust, accurate and balanced, and simply reflects the prioritization of the groups of organisms/habitats and associated variables to monitor in light of anthropogenic impacts, conservation needs and currently available technology, feasibility and knowledge. In operational terms, environmental monitoring, especially in the deep sea, requires ready-to-use technologies and methods that are employable, which greatly influences the choice of monitoring priorities and rankings of the consulted experts. Our paper innovatively coupled this need with the readiness levels of the described technologies. We agree that the scientific community should do more to document the importance of small organisms, to establish and disseminate the best standardized practices for collecting such observations and to increase our knowledge of undescribed species and their ecological roles to use them more effectively in future monitoring plans, particularly in light of the ongoing effects of global change8,9,10. At the same time, no marine protected area (in both shallow waters and in the open ocean) or other conservation initiative anywhere targets the loss of meiofaunal or microbial diversity. The reference to the Marine Strategy Framework Directive (MSFD 2008/56/EC), designed to address the Good Environmental Status of marine ecosystems (including the deep sea), does not support the position of Ingels et al.2 as the analysis of deep-sea biodiversity in the MSFD is, at present, limited to species of commercial interest and deep-water corals. None of the European directives prioritize meiofauna or microbes. Moreover, to the best of our knowledge, there is no single ongoing, nor planned, monitoring strategy of a national agency based on or prioritizing microbial or meiofaunal diversity in their standard protocols. Given the current limitation in the use of high-throughput sequencing (for example, for the identification of meiofauna3), further efforts are thus necessary to better integrate microbes and meiofauna in future monitoring and conservation programmes. To do this, the global deep-sea community must encourage joint efforts, share common goals and use standardized tools, This work was supported by the H2020 projects MERCES (Grant agreement no. 689518), and IDEM (Grant agreement no. 11.0661/2017/750680/SUB/EN V.C2.), by the Norwegian Institute for Water Research, by the NSERC Canadian Healthy Oceans Network and CFREF Ocean Frontier Institute, by JPI Oceans2 and ONC, by ARIM (MartTERA ERA-Net Cofound), by NSF grant OCE 1634172, by DOOS from the Consortium for Ocean Leadership, by the EMSO-Link EU project (Grant agreement ID: 731036) and by the Faculty of Science RAE Improvement Fund of The University of Hong Kong, With the funding support of the ‘Severo Ochoa Centre of Excellence’ accreditation (CEX2019-000928-S), of the Spanish Research Agency (AEI)
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Deep-sea ecosystems of the North Atlantic Ocean: discovery, status, function and future challenges

  • Allcock, A. Louise
  • Amon, Diva J.
  • Bridges, Amelia E.H.
  • Colaço, Ana
  • Escobar-Briones, Elva
  • Hilário, Ana
  • Howell, Kerry L.
  • Mestre, Nélia C.
  • Muller-Karger, Frank
  • Priede, Imants G.
  • Snelgrove, Paul V. R.
  • Sealey, Kathleen Sullivan
  • Xavier, Joana R.
  • Addamo, Anna María
  • Amaro, Teresa
  • Bandara, Gayathra
  • Bax, Narissa
  • Braga-Henriques, Andreia
  • Brandt, Angelika
  • Brix, Saskia
  • Cambronero-Solano, Sergio
  • Cedeño-Posso, Cristina
  • Copley, Jonathan T.
  • Cordes, Erik
  • Cortés, Jorge
  • Croquer, Aldo
  • Cuvelier, Daphne
  • Davies, Jaime S.
  • Durden, Jennifer M.
  • Esquete, Patricia
  • Foster, Nicola L.
  • Frutos-Parralejo, María Inmaculada
  • Gasbarro, Ryan
  • Gates, Andrew R.
  • Gomes, Marta
  • Goodwin, Lucy V.M.
  • Horton, Tammy
  • Hourigan, Thomas
  • Hoving, Henk-Jan T.
  • Jones, Daniel O. B.
  • Joshi, Siddhi
  • Kingon, Kelly C.
  • Lörz, Anne Nina
  • Viéitez Martín, Ana María
  • Merten, Véronique
  • Metaxas, Anna
  • Milligan, Rosanna J.
  • Molodtsova, Tina N.
  • Morato, Telmo
  • Morrissey, Declan
  • Naranjo-Elizondo, Beatriz
  • Narayanaswamy, Bhavani E.
  • Olafsdottir, Steinunn H.
  • Parimbelli, Alexa
  • Peña Saenz, Marian
  • Piechaud, Nils
  • Ragnarsson, Stefan
  • Ramalho, Sofia
  • Rodrigues, Clara F.
  • Ross, Rebecca E.
  • Saeedi, Hanieh
  • Santos, Régis
  • Schwing, Patrick T.
  • Serpa, Tiago
  • Shantharam, Arvind K.
  • Stevenson, Angela
  • Yánez-Suárez, Ana Belén
  • Sutton, Tracey T.
  • Svavarsson, Jörundur
  • Taylor, Michelle L.
  • Grient, Jesse van der
  • Zwerschke, Nadescha
The North Atlantic is an ocean basin with a diversity of deep-sea ecosystems. Here we provide a summary of the topography and oceanography of the North Atlantic including the Gulf of Mexico and Caribbean Sea, provide a brief overview of the history of scientific research therein, and review the current status of knowledge of each of 18 pelagic and benthic deep-sea ecosystems, with a particular focus on knowledge gaps. We analyse biodiversity data records across the North Atlantic and highlight spatial data gaps that could provide important foci for future expeditions. We note particular data gaps in EEZs of nations within and bordering the Caribbean Sea. Our data provide a baseline against which progress can be tracked into the future. We review human impacts caused by fishing, shipping, mineral extraction, introduction of substances, and climate change, and provide an overview of international, regional and national measures to protect ecosystems. We recommend that scientific research in the deep sea should focus on increasing knowledge of the distribution and the connectivity of key species and habitats, and increasing our understanding of the processes leading to the delivery of ecosystem services. These three pillars - distribution, connectivity, ecosystem function - will provide the knowledge required to implement conservation and management measures to ensure that any deep-sea development in the future is sustainable. Infrastructure and capacity are unevenly distributed and implementation of strategies that will lead to more equitable deep-sea science is required to ensure that essential science can be delivered., Financial support to researchers was provided to: A-NL by Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft, Grant/Award LO2543/1-1; AB by PTJ (German Ministry for Science and Education), Grant 03G0227A; NZ by the Aage V. Jensen Charity Foundation; AP by Taighde Éireann – Research Ireland, Grant GOIPG/2022/765; EE-B by CIC and ICML UNAM, Grants ICML-410-UNAM and ICML-SS-2024-12/35–565; AC by Fundação para a Ciência e a Tecnologia (FCT) through national funds via CEEC contract CEECIND/00101/2021 (https://doi.org/10.54499/2021.00101.CEECIND/CP1669/CT0001) and FCT, I.P., under the project UIDB/05634/2025 and UIDP/05634/2025; DC by OP AZORES 2020 (01-0145-FEDER-000140 MarAZ Researchers: Consolidate a body of researchers in Marine Sciences in the Azores), FCT 2023.07867.CEECIND and funds attributed to Okeanos-UAç (UIDB/05634/2020, UIDP/05634/2020 and M1.1.A/REEQ.CIENTIFICOUI&D/2021/010); AH, CFR & PE, by financial support to CESAM by FCT/MCTES (UIDP/50017/2020, UIDB/50017/2020, LA/P/0094/2020) through national funds; NCM by FCT, Grants CEECIND005262017, CIMA UI/MAR/00350/2020, and LA/P/0069/2020; RS by FCT, Grant 2021.02789.CEECIND/CP1669/CT0002; SPR by FCT/MCTES through national funds in the scope of the CEEC contract (CEECIND/00758/2017) and funds attributed to CESAM (UIDP/50017/2020, UIDB/50017/2020 and LA/P/0094/2020); JRX by the European Union Horizon Europe Research and Innovation Framework Programme in scope of the TwinDEEPS project (GA 101160298) and Portuguese national funds through FCT Foundation for Science and Technology within the scope of UIDB/04423/2020, UIDP/04423/2020, and LA/P/0101/2020, as well as 2023.08132.CEECIND/CP2848/CT0008; TA by FCT via the CEEC contract (CEECIND/00830/2018/CP1559/CT0002) and funds attributed to CESAM (UIDP/50017/2020, UIDB/50017/2020 and LA/P/0094/2020); TM by the FCT-IP Program Stimulus of Scientific Employment (CCCIND/03345/2020), the H2020 programme MERCES (689518) and iAtlantic (818123), the HEurope programme MarinePlan (101059407), and the Azores Government under Contract number 18/DRPM/2022 and ACORES-14-62G4-FEDER-000001; TNM by Minobrnauki of RF, Theme No. FMWE-2024-0022; JMD, TH & ARG by the UK Natural Environment Research Council (NERC), as part of AtlantiS - Atlantic Climate and Environment Strategic Science (Grant Number NE/Y005589/1); DOBJ by NERC, as part of the Climate Linked Atlantic Section Science (CLASS) program (Grant Number NE/R015953/1)and Autonomous Techniques for anthropogenic Structure Ecological Assessment (AT-SEA) Project (NE/T010649/1); KLH & AEHB by the UKRI GCRF funded One Ocean Hub, Grant NE/S008950/1; DJA byUC Santa Barbara's Benioff Ocean Science Laboratory; FEMK by the Marine Biodiversity Observation Network (MBON: NASA grant 80NSSC22K1779 and NOAA IOOS grant NA19NOS0120199); AKS by NOAA, Award NA21OAR4320190 to the Northern Gulf Institute; RM and TTS by the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration's RESTORE Science Program under award NA19NOS4510193 to Nova Southeastern University; SJ by the Swedish Research Council (Vetenskaprsrådet) and FORMAS., Peer reviewed