- Torres-Medina, Tomás
- Palancar, Carlos A.
- Díaz-Pérez, S.
- Motong-Asue, Olivia C.
- Rosas, Antonio
- García-Martínez, Daniel
During the 2023 and 2024 campaigns, two human metacarpals (RVH-9; RVH-22) were unearthed at the Ruidera site (dated to approximately 350 ka [1]). In the absence of a taxonomic association of the remains, we tried to identify taxonomical similarities through a classical anthropometric and a 3D geometric-morphometric (3DGM) study.
The study of classical measures was based on data obtained from 30 Homo sapiens and 4 Homo neanderthalensis individuals. In addition, classical measurements were obtained from the bibliography corresponding to the Skhul [2], Tabun [2], Shanidar [3], Sima de lo Huesos and Gran Dolina [4] sites (NMI=43). For the 3DGM study, 28 H. sapiens, 8 H. neanderthalensis, 1 H. sapiens fossil and 1 Homo naledi were measured (NMI=38).
RV-9: Fragmented right second metacarpal. The preservation of the diaphysis and the entire distal articular head is a notable feature. The bone exhibits a substantial, wide, and low head, a trait that is not typical in modern humans, Neanderthals or Sima de los Huesos individuals but shown in earlier Homo groups [5].
RV-22: Fragment of Metacarpus 2/3 right. It only preserves the distal articular surface, which has similar characteristics to RVH-9, the rest of the bone is missing.
RV has in its classic measurements a low and wide head similar to Homo antecessor and Skhul, a trait that does not appear in the rest of the species, proving a big difference with sapiens, neanderthals and Sima de los Huesos. The body of all the metacarpals studied is similar in shape and indexes, with no outlier in the sample. In general, RV stands out for its large size in bone measurements, which is confirmed by the study of centroid size, being this individual superior in size to the whole sample studied, except for some male sapiens individuals.
In shape space RVH-9 lies within the Neanderthal variation, close to the sapiens distribution. However, in form space RV-9 lies outside the Neanderthal variability, at the edge of the sapiens distribution. Applying a between groups PCA revealed a remarkable differentiation in the Neanderthal group, despite the significant variability of the populations and chronologies studied. The other species were associated with the sapiens group, characterized by a very homogeneous population studied.
This association between the species studied reflects how Neanderthals differs from the rest of the sample, where the most western and modern individuals are slightly distant from the eastern and ancient populations and from the rest of the species studied. RV-9 is outside this association, indicating that it does not present Neanderthal characteristics in its metacarpal. Ruidera, however, when applying a cluster of Procrustes distances, is located at the base of the speciation of both species, demonstrating the archaic characteristics it possesses.
In summary, we could consider Ruidera as an individual outside the purely Neanderthal characteristics and that presents differences with that species. The same occurs in other sites of the European Middle and Lower Pleistocene such as Gran Dolina, Petralona or Sima de los Huesos., Leakey Foundation; Fundación Palarq; Vecinos e instituciones de Ruidera; Junta de Comunidades de Castilla-La Mancha; Parque Natural de las Lagunas de Ruidera; Equipo de excavación; Ministerio de Ciencia e Innovación (España)