Skip to main content

Resultados relacionados

Resultados totales (Incluyendo duplicados): 20
Encontrada(s) 1 página(s)

Minerva. Repositorio Institucional de la Universidad de Santiago de Compostela
Publication Estudio, informe, memoria (Report)

PHILIPS SMARTPATH: A Circular Economy Business Model Case

  • Smith-Gillespie, Aleyn
  • Morwood, Doug
  • Aries, Tiphaine
This report presents the case study of Philips’ SmartPath business model for MRI scanners. SmartPath for MRI was chosen as the focus for the case study because: MRI systems have been a key focus for the implementation of circular economy models within Philips, and are an important line of business for the company. The SmartPath portfolio of upgrades focus on keeping products at their highest value throughout their lifetime, which is a core principle relevant to the circular economy. The SmartPath portfolio contains a number of circular business model patterns – some of which have been operational for many years at Philips. Nevertheless it is a model which is improving and evolving, and thus offers insights for Philips as well as other businesses. Insights for business guidelines This case study highlights the following key insights relevant to companies in similar industries or sharing a similar context: Significant value can be created by taking a lifecycle and service-centric approach to serving customers. This requires re-balancing priorities from focusing on new product sales towards maximising the value for customers from products already installed (the installed base). With this new focus, the installed base becomes a key resource to be ‘cultivated’ over its entire lifecycle. This creates the foundation for developing solutions and services that are consistent with the principles of circular economy: o Enhancing the utility and value of products at different stages of their lifecycle o Enabling the upgrade and life-extension of products o Establishing mechanisms to incentivise the take-back of products at end-of-cycle so that their value can be re-captured – for example through refurbishment and re-sale Product development and design needs to be consistent with a lifecycle approach, for example ensuring that future solutions are backward-compatible with systems already installed, and that these are equally upgradeable when new hardware or applications become available. This requires additional investment, however creates significant benefits including: o Ensuring systems in the installed base can maintain or enhance their value over the lifecycle o Improving customer experience and satisfaction o Creating opportunities for new and recurring revenue streams Transitioning from a product focus to a service/solutions focus (a form of ‘servitisation’) is a key enabler for circular business models. Offering products as a service creates a focus on value generation and customer satisfaction based on delivering overall performance and outcomes, rather than on the specifications of a product
Minerva. Repositorio Institucional de la Universidad de Santiago de Compostela
Publication Estudio, informe, memoria (Report)

INDITEX A Circular Economy Business Model Case

  • Pereira Sánchez, Ángeles
  • Vence Deza, Xavier
  • Alcalde García, Xosé Miguel
  • Carballo Penela, Adolfo
This report presents the case study corresponding to the textile company Inditex, which has been selected by the R2PI project given its importance in the world fashion market. The adoption of a circular model by fashion companies is extremely important, given the relevant environmental impact of this industry. Based on the common methodology of the R2PI project, this report presents the analysis of the “Circular Sourcing" CEBM, although it also highlights other activities of circularity that complement the aforementioned and that the Inditex Group is partly implementing, such as "Co-product recovery" and "Resource-recovery", the latter in collaboration with non-profit organisations in Spain and other markets. The objective of the report is, therefore, to offer a general view of how Inditex is facing the challenge of circularity, taking into account both contextual and internal factors, as well as to assess the level of circularity, the outcomes obtained and the SWOT. Finally, the report tries to offer key insights with regards to the “Circular Sourcing” CEBM pattern. The analysis of the context indicates that there are certain factors in the policy framework that are conditioning the development of circularity in fashion, especially the regulations that affect garments trade, its labelling, and textile waste trade –and will do so even more in the future. The market situation and competition reveal important elements of influence, such as the general race among leading fashion companies towards more sustainable and circular business models. In addition, still uncertain economic factors, such as the evolution of raw materials, water and energy prices and wages, are pointing to the need to adopt measures towards a circular change. As far as the factors of the technological framework are concerned, there is a clear commitment to developing new raw materials and more environmentally friendly processes; likewise, developments in recycling technologies and other advances may change the face of the textile industry in a few years. Finally, while the fast-fashion consumer model continues to be very successful, there is already an increasing demand for healthier and environmentally friendly clothing. The characteristics of Inditex's business model centred on circular sourcing are analysed in detail. This model is based on the group power along the value chain. Thus, a value network is formed in which some suppliers are key partners, because they share Inditex vision and are doing strong efforts towards a more circular sourcing, while also supporting the development of the local textile recycling industry. At the heart of the business model, Inditex continues offering fashion at competitive prices, but the group is increasingly searching for the environmentally friendliness attribute. The analysis of the circularity of Inditex Group indicates that it is currently limited in the sense that it is still focused on the sale of a product, and the revenues and costs are clearly linked to the sale and manufacture of that product, not to added services, for example. Although garments are manufactured with more sustainable raw materials, the industry might become more circular yet if fashion companies decide to innovate the business model in more radical ways. With regard to the financial outcomes, the available data allows to indicate that the manufacturing costs of more sustainable garments are generally higher than those of conventional garments. It is important to remark that Inditex does not pass this higher cost on to end consumers through a price premium. Moreover, sustainable garments are increasing greatly in Inditex's fashion sales. Existing information points to important non-financial outcomes linked to circular sourcing: the reduction of environmental impacts, greater employment generated through social initiatives by means of projects linked to donated garments; and possibilities for the creation of a stronger industry and employment associated with textile recycling. In addition, technological innovation is very important to support this business model, with investments in R&D aimed at the development of new products (fibres) and processes (design, traceability, recycling). Using a SWOT tool, Inditex business model is assessed and put in relation to potential circularity. Weaknesses are identified, such as the dependence of the Inditex circular business model on its ability to influence suppliers and the success of the current dominant business model based on continuous and quick sales. There are also strengths, such as the design skills and the ability to anticipate the market, the power to influence suppliers and to play an intermediary role in the fashion industry. As far as external aspects are concerned, the greatest opportunity lies in taking advantage of the favourable state of opinion and the general movement of the fashion industry towards the Circular Economy. The threats may also be high competition, but they rely mainly in the challenges of regulation for the clothing and waste trade and in the current low cost scenario (raw materials, energy and water, and labour), which make sustainable manufacturing more expensive. Inditex's route towards the Circular Economy will be based on going deeper into the circular sourcing CEBM pattern, especially in the sense of trying to close the loops for some fibres; moreover, in the longer term, it is also part of its plans to explore other business models in which the services added to the product will take on greater relevance. The business model analysed is replicable and transferable. In fact, a large number of leading companies in the sector are already taking action in the same direction. However, there is a need for greater commitment from industry and consumers. Based on this research, some policy measures are highly recommended to further promote the uptake of the circular business model, including: the establishment of clear objectives for garments reuse and recycling; regulation for favouring the implementation of eco-design, durability and quality of garments; and incentives and education for consumers to change towards more responsible and sustainable patterns of fashion consumption
Minerva. Repositorio Institucional de la Universidad de Santiago de Compostela
Publication Estudio, informe, memoria (Report)

VAUDE: A Circular Business Model Innovation Journey

Minerva. Repositorio Institucional de la Universidad de Santiago de Compostela
Publication Estudio, informe, memoria (Report)

GROUPE SEB: A Circular Economy Business Model Case

  • Smith-Gillespie, Aleyn
  • Meng, Juliana
  • Aries, Tiphaine
This case study highlights the following key insights relevant to companies in similar industries or sharing a similar context: System-level collaboration (and, where required, co-investment) is essential to develop effective and at-scale infrastructure for end-of-life collection of products, and the creation of recycling value chains producing high-value material streams for re-use. Increasing recycled content for certain plastics such as Polypropylene requires a full and coordinated approach to product design, which can be complex and requires not only changes to internal processes but also close collaboration with suppliers. This is especially important at the initial stages until a breakthrough is achieved and new processes enter ‘business as usual’. At the beginning, such initiatives need to be managed like a project and require dedicated attention and responsibility – for example a Project Lead that can work across functions and silos. The higher cost of virgin materials is often a key driver for efforts to substitute them with recycled materials. However, the risk of this price advantage being eroded due to price fluctuations and volatility means that the business case for doing so requires a long-term and holistic perspective. For example: creating brand value which can drive customer loyalty and indirect benefits through higher sales; and investing in the use of recycled material as a long-term hedge against rising virgin material prices. This is particularly important in cases where customers do not explicitly value or understand the use of recycled materials, or don’t see this as a significant differentiator when making buying decisions. Transitioning Circular Sourcing from a ‘breakthrough project’ into ‘business as usual’ requires development of key resource and activities, as well as cultural and behavioural change. This includes design guides and decisions-support tools for product designers; integration into end-to-end product development processes; and embedding into procurement and sourcing processes and supplier relationship management
Minerva. Repositorio Institucional de la Universidad de Santiago de Compostela
Publication Estudio, informe, memoria (Report)

CANON: A Circular Economy Business Model Case

  • Smith-Gillespie, Aleyn
  • Morwood, Doug
  • Chang, Hanah
  • Aries, Tiphaine
This report presents the case study of Canon’s EMEA business for Document Solutions (DS), with a focus on the business model for remanufacturing and refurbishment. It was chosen as it provided an example of a mature remanufacturing model, as well as potential for further circularity and business benefit through expansion of refurbishment activities. Canon EMEA has also been growing services such as Managed Print Service (MPS) – a service-based model for providing printer copiers – which, while not a focus of the case study, provides opportunities for both remanufacturing and refurbishment. Canon operates in a market which is currently in decline, with vendors competing intensely for market share. This is creating a stark contrast between a business model driven by new product sales, and one that emphasises the cultivation and reutilisation of existing deployed assets. In this context, it is important to emphasise that this case study focuses on the circular business models and potential for Canon EMEA, whose business is principally a combination of sales/marketing and service delivery. This is in contrast to Canon Inc. (Japan) who manufactures and supplies equipment for Canon EMEA to sell and integrate into its service offerings. This case study explores the opportunities, as well as enablers and barriers, to Canon expanding the role of remanufacturing and refurbishment within its circular business models. We believe this will have important positive implications for Canon given the broader strategic challenges it faces
Minerva. Repositorio Institucional de la Universidad de Santiago de Compostela
Publication Estudio, informe, memoria (Report)

CITY OF VENLO A Circular Economy Business Model Case, The newly built city hall Venlo, more than merely sustainable How City of Venlo creates positive impact for people and the environment with a profitable circular business model

  • Zwart, Tamara
  • van der Westerlo, Bas
This report presents a case study of the city of Venlo and its circular business model, selected by the R2π project along with 17 other cases, due to its position within the construction and building materials sector, which is one of the priority areas of the European Union’s circular economy strategy. The objective of the report is to analyse the contextual and business factors affecting the circular business model, as well as to assess the enablers and barriers to implementing such a model and to provide considerations for both business leaders and policy makers. The city of Venlo (NL) embraced the Cradle to Cradle® (C2C®) principles as first region in Europe. In 2008 Venlo decided to build their City Hall as shining example of C2C® design. The creation of a pleasant and healthy workplace for employees of the Municipality of Venlo has been the central theme: a building that offers a comfortable and healthy working environment, combined with sustainable innovation. Venlo considers the C2C® principles as a revolutionary economic concept and true driver for innovation, based on new circular economy business models and the use of materials in perpetually cycles. Based on these principles, Venlo applied a wide variety of circular measures within a circular economy business model, for which they invested €3.4 mln. This investment creates a net saving of € 16.8 mln over the use time of the building and a positive cash flow after year 1. Besides, the building has been realized within the budget and without dependency on subsidies. Since the building is in use (October 2016), the operational costs are significantly lower compared to former and traditional (linear) buildings. The above mentioned circular measures show that, during use time, indoor air quality is even better than outdoor air quality (while indoor air in offices is on average 4-8 times worse than outside). This is one of the results of the creation of a pleasant and healthy workspace being a central theme for the City Hall. Furthermore, due to its green roofs and facades, the building purifies a measurable 30% of the fine dust and CO2 level in an area of 500 meters around the city hall. Moreover, the building generates its own energy and a helophyte filter purifies grey water, which is reused in the building. Numerous C2C CertifiedTM products are used. The building is approached as a material bank for future valuable raw materials and designed for disassembly. Arrangements are made with suppliers about residual value and guaranteed take-back of materials. This resulted, for example for the furnishing concept, in a residual value of 18% with a maximal number of C2C CertifiedTM materials. In less than 1,5 years, after opening in October 2016, the city hall Venlo has seen over 25.000+ visitors with a special interest in the Cradle to Cradle® approach. Of these 60% are Dutch, 40% are international visitors. As a result of these visits, many organizations have been inspired to apply the circular principles within their own context. Also other developers in Venlo have been applying C2C® principles in their real estate project, such as primary schools, gyms, residential houses and companies. The circular principles even became part of Venlo’s strategy, facility management and procurement criteria. This case study describes Venlo’s vision and approach in realizing buildings with a positive impact. The municipality of Venlo wants to give an exemplary role in the transition towards a circular economy and strives to “do good rather than less bad”. The scope of this case study is the business model of Venlo’s newly built city hall. The uniqueness of this case study, compared to other case studies within the R2Pi project, is the fact that Venlo is a local government. As a consequence, this case study differs slightly from other case studies
Minerva. Repositorio Institucional de la Universidad de Santiago de Compostela
Publication Estudio, informe, memoria (Report)

REVERTIA A Circular Economy Business Case

  • Pereira Sánchez, Ángeles
  • Vence Deza, Xavier
  • Carballo Penela, Adolfo
  • Alcalde García, Xosé Miguel
This report presents the results of the Revertia case study, selected in the framework of the R2PI project, among 17 other cases, because of its focus on an activity linked to priority areas of the Circular Economy, namely Plastics and Critical Raw Materials. The information contained in the report is based on the methodology designed within the framework of the R2PI project to understand the characteristics of the business model, evaluate its outcomes and identify the main barriers and enablers of the CEBM. Revertia is an authorised Waste Electrical and Electronic Equipment (WEEE) manager that combines e-waste management services with a circular value proposal consisting in the preparation of IT equipment for reuse. The company responsibly manages an e-waste flow and, by applying secure reconditioning processes, is able to extend the service life of IT equipment that has been discarded. Refurbished equipment, with a 1-year warranty, are sold in second-hand markets or donated. The activity of preparation for reuse also involves the utilization, to the extent possible, of used and recycled components. In addition, the business model is based on efficient logistics, avoiding e-waste transportation when reconditioning is not an option. The value proposition is based on the provision of high added value services to corporate IT equipment users, who need to manage their WEEE responsibly. The value network is thus formed by the origin-customer that generates e-waste and the EEE manufacturers represented through collective schemes. Downstream there are the destination-customers of second-hand and donated products, as well as the WEEE recycling companies to which Revertia's own waste is destined. Revertia's business model is clearly influenced at the context level by the WEEE Directive 2012/19/EU and the Spanish RD 110/2015, which regulate the industry and set targets for reuse and recycling of WEEE. In addition, the market context given by the rapid technological change in the EEE sector, the collective schemes derived from the implementation of the EPR obligation, the maturity of the WEEE recycling industry, the existence of illegal scrap metal agents, and some socio-cultural aspects such as the lack of awareness of WEEE's environmental costs are factors that strongly affect Revertia's activity. The report also presents an assessment of the circularity of the business model. The model corresponds to the Re-make pattern among the CEBM defined in the R2PI project. Its circularity lies in extending the useful life of a product, also integrating used and recycled components as far as possible. Current circularity is limited, since it is not based on services added to this second-hand product, nor is the organisation further able to act on the products manufacture or end of life. Therefore, Revertia takes opportunity of a gap left by other players in the sector (EEE manufacturers). Therefore the business model is dependent on the generation of an e-waste flow as well as on sales of refurbished computers. With regards to the outcomes assessment, the main advantages of the business model are found in the non-financial aspects: reuse of IT equipment for the same use demonstrates clear environmental benefits compared to recycling. In addition, it also allows for greater local employment generation linked to the management and preparation for reuse activity. In the socio-economic area, second-hand products provide access to quality equipment at very affordable prices. The SWOT analysis shows that the main strengths are the long-lasting and stable relationships with the origin-customers, the know-how and expertise of Revertia. The weaknesses point to its dependence on the linear model, therefore, to being able to capture waste streams, in competition with the mature recycling industry. The opportunities lie in the Spanish regulatory framework, which sets targets for the reuse of WEEE, as well as a state of opinion more favourable to responsible and sustainable consumption; however, there are also clear threats to the model, such as the possible entry of more competitors and the lack of sensitivity of EEE manufacturers towards reuse. Based on the analysis, it is concluded that the Re-make CEBM is replicable and transferable, especially as long as the linear economic paradigm is dominant. However, there are a number of business and policy recommendations that may support greater circularity: first, specific agreements with EEE manufacturers to extend circularity from the conception of EEE products until its final disposal after multiple lifetimes; second, at the policy level, tighter regulation, with inspection and sanction systems, incentives for eco-design and product life extension activities, transparent information and monitoring systems, as well as education and training measures are needed
Minerva. Repositorio Institucional de la Universidad de Santiago de Compostela
Publication Estudio, informe, memoria (Report)

REHAU AG + CO (& POLYSECURE GMBH): A Circular Economy Business Model Case

  • Figeac, Alexis
This report looks into the Circular Economy Business Model (CEBM) of Rehau AG’s window solutions division. This is, within the Rehau group, the business unit which manufactures PVC profiles which are used, later by their customers, to frame window glass in domestic and commercial buildings. The case-study has examined internal and external operations related to PVC profile production, usage and recycling; interviews with relevant managers took place. Given sustainability and cost considerations surrounding PVC, Rehau practices a circular sourcing CEBM involving the whole value-chain in particular downstream actors such as customers and recyclers. o PVC profiles are delivered to its customers, the window manufacturers, from whom it recovers the cuttings (the “post-industrial” waste / resource). This is financially incentivised and enables Rehau to melt, re-granulate and re-extrude, i.e. use as a secondary raw material in a circular sourcing process. o Due to a long-standing landfill ban in Germany of PVC, the recovery and recycling of “post-consumer” waste, is a well-organised business, in which, take-back of end-oflife PVC window frames, is financially incentivised. The recycler shreds, melts and regranulates this resource into a PVC-recyclate, i.e. a secondary raw material. Rehau, and other PVC extruders, are keen to purchase this recyclate since it is some 20% cheaper than virgin PVC. Apart from mild discolouring, properties of virgin PVC are practically maintained in the recyclate. o Rehau has innovated by introducing glass-fibre to reinforce PVC and thereby dispense with steel content in window profiles. Such glass-fibre PVC (GF-PVC) window profiles present a number of advantages in terms of lightness, thermal insulation and cost of installation. To recover this new type of PVC, a specific tracing and sorting technology has been implemented in cooperation with a technology provider. Indeed, Polysecure GmbH’s tracer-based sorting approach is an enabling technology which, thanks to a micrometric marker powder, is physically bonded to the raw material on a permanent basis, and enables identification and sorting at End-of-Life. Thus a glass-fibre PVC recyclate can be generated as a new pure segregated secondary raw material fraction
Minerva. Repositorio Institucional de la Universidad de Santiago de Compostela
Publication Estudio, informe, memoria (Report)

ROLLS-ROYCE: A Circular Economy Business Model Case

  • Smith-Gillespie, Aleyn
  • Muñoz, Ana
  • Morwood, Doug
  • Aries, Tiphaine
This report presents the case study of Rolls-Royce’s ‘TotalCare’ business model for widebody aircraft aero engines. It was chosen due to the commercially successful development of a whole lifecycle, servitised value proposition and associated business model. Insights for business guidelines This case study highlights the following key insights relevant to companies in similar industries or sharing a similar context: Revenue mechanisms that align interests between a company and its customers can create powerful circular business models. Although Rolls-Royce engines are sold to the aircraft owner, the TotalCare service package means Rolls-Royce retains responsibility for ensuring the product performs to customer requirements. The power-by-the-hour charging mechanism (revenues generated per engine flight hour) keeps incentives aligned by rewarding Rolls-Royce when the product is working as needed, and penalising it when it is not. This mechanism and alignment between the OEM and its customers encourages continuous improvement and collaboration. This also drives the extension of asset lifetime while optimising/reducing repair and maintenance costs. This results in reduced waste, increased resource efficiency, and enhances the asset’s value over its lifetime. Service-focused offerings that enable manufacturers to gain insight and intelligence on the use and performance of their products can lead to better customer service, improved product/service design, and resource efficiency. TotalCare provides opportunities for constant insight and learning around customer requirements. This insight is enabled by the collection of engine usage and performance data, as well as through deep customer relationships. This produces ongoing improvements and evolution of the value proposition itself as well as expansion of value added services. This means that the customer is no longer buying ‘just’ a product, but gaining expanded value addressing a suite of needs and requirements. This provides greater flexibility for manufacturers to manage the underlying asset within a service contract, focusing on outcomes for the customer. Servitised performance-based models can be important enablers for ‘Resource Recovery’ as well as ‘Re-condition’ / ‘Re-make’ circular business model patterns. In the example of TotalCare, Rolls-Royce’s service contract includes the provision of maintenance services which it has the responsibility and flexibility to deliver in an optimal way. This ensures that the ‘life’ and utility of the engine product is kept at the right level over its lifetime. Furthermore, the service contract gives the manufacturer visibility of the product throughout its lifecycle. This is especially relevant at the end-of-cycle where it creates an opportunity for product take-back and recovery of high value materials through close-loop recycling. When transitioning from a product-focused to a service-focused business model, the installed base becomes a key asset and driver of revenue and profitability. In product-focused business models, revenue is driven by the product sales price, and potentially some recurring revenue from maintenance services and sale of consumables and add-ons. In a service-focused business model, the installed base of products in use can become the driver
Minerva. Repositorio Institucional de la Universidad de Santiago de Compostela
Publication Estudio, informe, memoria (Report)

LENTURA A Circular Economy Business Model Case

  • Pereira Sánchez, Ángeles
  • Santos Caruncho, Manuel
  • Vence Deza, Xavier
This report analyses one of the business case studies selected within the R2Pi Project: Lentura, an association of agro-ecological food growers located in Galicia, Spain. This study aims at obtaining a comprehensive knowledge of what an initiative based on a local and natural food supply implies in terms of circular business models. Lentura, whose origins date back more than a decade, has as its main goal to provide its customers with horticultural products, obtained through organic practices and marketed in proximity. In other words, the business model is based on growing natural food, free of synthetic chemicals, which is sold through proximity schemes that minimise the number of kilometres covered by the food products. For the latter, distribution is based on direct sales, around a geographical area that does not exceed 30 km between producers and consumers. This association is mainly characterized by organic farming practices. Taking this fact into account and the organic and proximate characteristics of its foodstuffs, Lentura's practices fit in well with a CEBM based on circular sourcing. However, Lentura also carries out activities that may be considered as co-product recovery, such as the utilization of animal excreta for fertilizing or reusing packaging employed in food deliveries. Concerning Lentura’s context, organic farming has been a growing market in Spain and Europe for more than a decade. Although the conventional food sector remains highly competitive, there is a growing demand for a natural and healthy diet, which visibly benefits Lentura’s model. Despite these developments, national and regional legislation does not benefit (or even hinder) the emergence and prosperity of organisations and activities like Lentura. They are characterised by very stringent hygiene requirements and production limitations. The assessment of the circularity of Lentura business model provides remarkable insights. The key aspects are related to the natural farming practices, to the organisation of activities in proximity (reducing the number of kilometres and making it possible for the products to be so natural) and to the take-back and reuse of packaging. These circular activities have given rise to a series of financial and non-financial benefits that range from cost and material savings through the reintegration of packaging, to the improvement of the farmers’ income and the sustainability of food products through the maintenance of proximity schemes. The close and highly relational environment generated by Lentura is the main strength of the organisation, together with the naturalness of its food products. However, the lack of flexibility that they impose on their proximity model leads to relevant problems in aspects such as the volume of supply. With regards to the environment, Lentura may be affected by the increasing competition from organic or eco-friendly products provided by conventional food suppliers. Moreover, this report also shows some potential opportunities for Lentura to go further in circularity and improve its business model, such as relaxing the criteria of proximity, intensifying its production or generating compost from food waste. Even despite the mentioned aspects, this is a circular model that is not difficult to replicate or transfer, since it is based on simple ideas and does not require large investments for its implementation. The critical point to overcome lies in the ability to coordinate a certain know-how together with the maintenance of customers who today have above-average levels of educational awareness on food-related topics. In short, the report shows how Lentura manages to create a small alternative food system with a high relational content, which is an interesting business model for a Circular Economy. Information flows simply and farmers are valued, while respecting to a large extent the natural cycles involved in farming processes. The conclusion section recommends to adapt the hygiene and marketing regulations in the area and to introduce measures to improve consumer’s food education in order to support more circular business models similar to Lentura case.
Minerva. Repositorio Institucional de la Universidad de Santiago de Compostela
Publication Estudio, informe, memoria (Report)

VIVENGE. A Circular Economy Business Model Case

  • Bukowski, Hubert
  • Rok, Boleslaw
One of the R2π project’s missions is to identify and develop sustainable business models and guidelines that will facilitate the circular economy implementation in new entities and markets. Having those objectives in mind Vivenge was chosen as one of the case organizations because of their circular ambitions and the long-term effort Vivenge was willing to put in the pursuit of sustainability of their business model. Vivenge is a Polish family company established in 1997. Since day one of their operations they are producing items for visual identification purposes. Currently the company is a one-stop-shop for durable visual identification as they provide both outdoor (outdoor signage, small architecture) and indoor visual identification (durable indoor signage, furniture, small architecture) as well as related services (e.g. installation, logistics). The company has experienced considerable growth since its inception. Currently its clients comprise of 48 brands in 9 countries. The visual identification industry is strictly cost-oriented and could not compromise yet profitability with a costly image of being environmentally friendly. Although rebranding waste is not a media-worth issue yet, Vivenge has started The Brandbility programme as a sustainable rebranding process based of selected recommendations. Currently they employ two circular business models, first of which is “resource recovery”. In every disassembly and utilization practice Vivenge recovers the resources from the products using their own sorting facility. Part of the reclaimed parts is reused once again without the need for recycling. This process could be described as a “re-make” business model as it returns the end-of-life parts into a new overall product. A detailed look at Vivenge’s circularity assessment indicates that the company is extremely heterogeneous when it comes to implementing circular economy elements in their business model. The visual identification products’ circularity is highly graded, mainly thanks to visual products’ characteristics. This fact is counterbalanced by Vivenge’s business model itself and the system it operates in. The business model is driven by assets sale, with a focus on the sale transaction. The system lacks circularity specifically in the end-of-life phase. Nevertheless, it seems that Vivenge’s business model has important traits that make it easily adaptable to incorporate circular elements beyond what has already been done. The Brandbility programme could be modified to incorporate more circularity elements and at the same time to influence demand for the new circular products and services. The main proposed approach concerns servitizing the industry and putting more effort on the end-of-life phase of the products life cycle. Furthermore, those two objectives could be attained simultaneously. The visual identification products could be offered as a service. In this arrangement it is the producer that is responsible for the whole lifecycle of the product. That way the customer pays only for the time the visual identification product is on display (with prearranged quality). The producer would have an incentive to design with durability, quickness of assembly and disassembly and standardization on his mind. The greater extend of reuse of parts could further diminish the costs of production. This approach could be easily replicable and transferable to other entities and markets.
Minerva. Repositorio Institucional de la Universidad de Santiago de Compostela
Publication Estudio, informe, memoria (Report)

BRIDGESTONE EUROPE: A Circular Business Model Innovation Journey

  • Esquival, Luis
  • Slaughter, Raymond
  • Morwood, Doug
  • Smith-Gillespie, Aleyn
This report provides an overview of the circular business model innovation journey guided by the R2π project team for Bridgestone EMEA (Europe, Middle East and Africa). The team customised an innovation process to suit the specific needs of the company in order to help them explore opportunities to become more sustainable and circular. Due to confidentiality agreements, this report does not provide details of Bridgestone strategy and internal business data, rather the purpose of the report is to describe the innovation journey and tools utilised. A key challenge of the company relates to end-of-life tyres (ELT), a problem that persists in all tyre companies and in society due to the negative environmental and social impacts that this waste could result in, if not properly collected and treated. According to the European Tyre and Rubber Manufacturing Association (2018), the global tyre output is estimated at 1.5 billion units per year, which will all eventually fall into the category of end-of-life tyres.1 Over the last 18 years, recovery rates for tyres have increased in Europe, and the cost of recycling has decreased due to both efficiency in management structures and new recovery routes. This shift shows that products derived from end-of-life tyres can be legitimately recognised as a valuable secondary material. About 2.6 million tonnes of end-of-life tyres (ELT) are recovered annually in Europe and 600,000 tonnes of used tyres are either reused or sent for re-treading, so the tyre industry has promoted promising economic activities that are beneficial to the environment while also creating over 10,000 jobs2, but there is still much more to be accomplished. Therefore, Bridgestone is seeking viable business models to continue improving this situation and to continue its mission, “Serving Society with Superior Quality”3. To that end, a cross-functional team from Bridgestone and R2π was brought together in workshops to gain a deeper understanding of the current business model and context within the market as well as to innovate new business models. Based on internal and external strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats identified within their current business model and context, they generated and explored multiple options for future circular business models. Thereafter, they further detailed these options and mapped out bold steps required to achieve the new business models. Team members identified their most critical assumptions and planned out roadmaps to allow them to test these assumptions and move forward towards implementing a more sustainable and circular business model
Minerva. Repositorio Institucional de la Universidad de Santiago de Compostela
Publication Estudio, informe, memoria (Report)

TERRACYCLE. A Circular Economy Business Model Case

  • Bukowski, Hubert
  • Rok, Boleslaw
This report presents the results of the TerraCycle case study, selected in the framework of the R2PI project, among 17 other cases. The information contained in the report is based on the methodology designed within the framework of the R2PI project to understand the characteristics of the business model, evaluate its outcomes and identify the main barriers and enablers. TerraCycle was chosen for the study to investigate their effort and evolution towards attaining the goal of “eliminating the idea of waste”. The company was founded in 2001 in Trenton, USA as an organic fertilizer producer, using waste as the resource for production. Throughout the years TerraCycle evolved into the world leader in the collection and recycling of waste streams that are traditionally considered not-recyclable. TerraCycle typically sets up collection platforms for the waste streams. This platform is usually funded by businesses that are looking to enhance their environmental performance. The waste collected by programme participants in return for a charitable donation is recycled and sold to manufacturers that make new products and materials using them. To date, over 80 million people in 21 countries have helped TerraCycle to divert approximately 5 billion pieces of waste from landfills and incineration and in result raise over 21 million dollars for charities and schools around the world. Those activities are enabled by the business context TerraCycle found itself in. Most importantly the company was capable to make use of the rising environmental awareness of final consumers and the growing level of corporate social responsibility among popular brands. TerraCycle became the world leader in the collection and recycling of waste streams that are traditionally considered non-recyclable. TerraCycle typically sets up national collection platforms for hard-to-recycle waste streams. This platform is usually funded by consumer product companies, retailers, cities, manufacturing facilities, distribution centres, small businesses that are looking to enhance their environmental performance. The waste collected by programme participants in return for a charitable donation is recycled and sold to manufacturers that make new products and materials using them. Where possible, TerraCycle and their partners focus on how to integrate reclaimed materials into specific products. By focusing on one of the collection programmes, i.e. writing instruments recycling programme, it has been established that there is a high level of circularity of their business models identified as resource recovery and circular sourcing. Although the scalability and replicability of those models is questionable as TerraCycle itself has not attained economies of scale itself it seems that it is mainly the result of the characteristics of items collected. This is further exacerbated by the need to thoroughly ascertain that each recycling process will meet the public opinion’s expectations. Adverse publicity could tarnish their reputation and reduce the value of the brand and in result reduce demand for their services. The publicity factor is also significant for replicability. It seems that without environmentally-friendly brand image such operations could not take place and establishing company’s reputation is a long-term process.
Minerva. Repositorio Institucional de la Universidad de Santiago de Compostela
Publication Estudio, informe, memoria (Report)

PHENIX A Circular Economy Business Model Case

  • Acquier, Aurélien
  • Carbone, Valentina
  • Ouahab, Alban
The aim of the R2π project is to find and analyze sustainable business models for circular economy in a variety of industrial sectors. Then, it aims to develop propositions that will support such business models. This report develops the case of Phenix, a French company in the food sector, illustrative of a successful circular business model. Phenix was created in 2014 by two entrepreneurs, Jean Moreau and Baptiste Corval and went through a steady growth, now having 18 regional offices in France and 3 international ones in Copenhagen, Lisbon and Madrid. The company’s global mission is to “unleash the potential of waste”. With an initial focus on food-waste, Phenix has set up a digital platform that works as an intermediary connecting waste “suppliers” (mainly retailers) and waste receivers (mostly charities). Through this service, Phenix prevents food close to expiration date from being wasted, and turns such waste into food donations. Beyond its matchmaking platform, Phenix also provides partners with a secured supply chain. Phenix achieves ‘triple bottom line’ value creation, by helping retailers to reduce the cost of food waste (economic benefit), enabling charities to get free access to food donations (social benefit), and helping society to reduce the overall amount of food waste produced in our economic system (environmental & circular economy benefit). It is, therefore, an example of a “mission-driven platform”, built on a hybrid model that combines business, social and environmental value creation. Presently, Phenix works with more than a thousand supermarket clients, has 100 full-time employees and helps to distribute over 40 000 meals per day. Phenix business model is circular by design. The organization offers a service to secure the recovery of unsold food products. Doing so, it organizes a circular sourcing for charities and helps retailers managing their products end-of-life. Because Phenix acts as a service provider, it does not generate waste but rather helps other organizations reduce their own. As a multisided platform, Phenix has developed a distinct pricing scheme to address each side of the platform. Phenix revenue model is based on monetizing the supply-side of the platform, through a fixed commission on the waste-management gains achieved by distributors using the platform. On the other side of the platform (demand side), Phenix organizes free access to food for social charities, thus achieving a social benefit and facilitating the growth of the platform. The French legal framework offered a favorable context for the development of a profitable business model for Phenix. As part of this regulatory framework, an existing tax incentive introduced in 1981 under the “Coluche law” providing for a 60% tax deduction for food retailers and producers who donate foodstuffs instead of generating waste. Through its secured supply chain, Phenix organizes traceability, secures savings for retailers and can charge a commission on the total savings on waste management, making the business model viable. As a fast growing and profitable start-up, the company is currently exploring different opportunities for geographical diversification in other European and non-European countries. The company is also currently engaged in processes of horizontal diversification to expand its services to new types of waste, and explores how to improve its current offer through digital solutions. While the company strategic position appears quite robust, few points of attention need to be considered: the business model remains dependent on favorable regulations, it remains labor intensive and new market acquisitions require large investments. Yet, new technology such as big data or IoT can radically improve the model’s cost-efficiency. Lobbying skills and network effects can protect the regulatory framework and diversification strategy to other resources (non-food wastes) and new skills (consulting) can strengthen the business model. Beyond the strategic analysis of the company, this case study has significant implications for public regulators. It first highlights the central role of public regulation in the innovation process. And it illustrates the hypothesis of Porter and Van der Linde, according to which properly crafted environmental regulations not only help to reduce environmental externalities, but they can also lead to profits for innovative companies (Porter & Linde, 1995). Overall our results points toward a mix between a regulatory framework and private dynamics of innovation to create successful circular business model. On the innovation side, the case shows how mission-driven platforms can reconfigure stakeholder relations in a given business ecosystem and improve operational efficiency of these relations in order to decrease waste and increase re-use
Minerva. Repositorio Institucional de la Universidad de Santiago de Compostela
Publication Estudio, informe, memoria (Report)

MUD JEANS. A Circular Economy Business Model Case

  • Wijnen, Roland
  • Tiel Groenestege, Moniek
  • Business Models Inc BV
This report presents the case study corresponding to the retail company MUD Jeans, which has been selected by the R2π project given its importance in the world fashion market. The adoption of a circular model by fashion companies is extremely important, given the huge social, economic, and environmental impact of this industry. This report presents the analysis of the MUD Jeans business model. The objective of the report is to offer a holistic view of how the MUD Jeans circular business model creates, delivers, and captures value. We obtained this holistic view through analysis and synthesis of the business context in which MUD Jeans operates and their business model, followed by an assessment of the circularity of their business model. MUD Jeans is a company with a truly circular ambition: a world without waste. They have a clear and specific vision about circular value creation and are acting on it. Their business model is a circular business model designed from scratch and implements a variety of circular business model patterns. They implement the Circular Sourcing pattern using both recycled jeans (40%) and bio-organic cotton (60%). They implement the Recondition pattern by turning worn and leased jeans into vintage jeans. They implement the Performance pattern by offering a long-lasting and stylish product making people look good while contributing to a sustainable lifestyle. Customers of MUD Jeans are conscious men and women. Initially their customers were confined to a small niche, vegans. Currently, more and more people are wearing their jeans, either by buying (75%) or leasing them (25%). Customers get free repairs if required. Besides that, MUD Jeans offers customer service like any other fashion company. Many customers like their fashionable and modern jeans so much that they actively share why and what they buy or lease from MUD Jeans. This active community leads to word of mouth that grows the customer base as well as sharing the story about their vision and mission. In everything they do, there is the drive to further decouple growth from social and environmental impact. MUD Jeans received several awards for their innovative approach in the fashion industry. At the core of how they organize value creation is their circular design approach, which is implemented and executed with a number of strong partners, who share a similar vision about changing the fashion industry. The report contains an in-depth analysis and assessment of the MUD Jeans business model in order to better understand the design and dynamics of their circular value creation. We also provide a detailed look at the business context in which MUD Jeans operates. Important contextual factors are the explosion of production and the associated negative effects, consumer awareness of the negative effects of fast fashion, and the growing need of personalized and customized products and experiences. The business model is presented visually using the Business Model Canvas, both the big picture and at a more detailed level. The MUD Jeans business model is consistently designed and implemented, with clearly defined strategic choices underpinning their model. They have a very strong value network with partners that share a similar vision and help each other succeed in bringing circular fashion to the market. We also include an assessment of the strengths and weaknesses of the building blocks of the business model as well as an assessment of the opportunities and threats for the business as a whole. Three options for future business models are also identified: 1) a shift towards a new customer segment, 2) a shift in the value proposition, and 3) shift in using new materials. MUD Jeans has traction in the market and is a serious circular company now. They are on a growth trajectory both in terms of increasing customers and revenues as well as decreasing socio-environmental impacts. Their loyal and active customers and strong partnerships work as an enabler in this. The media these days is also paying close attention to these new ways of creating, delivering, and capturing value. There are still some barriers to overcome. Circular business models are treated in the same way as traditional business models with respect to taxes. Another barrier is the financial evaluation of leased jeans, without much recognition of the value of materials that is retained for the long term. It is also difficult for MUD Jeans to find the right investor to double down on growth. The report concludes with guidelines for entrepreneurs to make better strategic choices as well as recommendations for policy makers to accelerate circular value creation.
Minerva. Repositorio Institucional de la Universidad de Santiago de Compostela
Publication Estudio, informe, memoria (Report)

BIOELEKTRA. A Circular Economy Business Model Case

  • Boleslaw, Rok
  • Stanny, Dominik
This report presents the results of the Bioelektra case study, selected in the framework of the R2PI project, among 17 other cases. The mission of this company is to change the way people think of waste management, by using advanced technology. The information contained in the report is based on the methodology designed within the framework of the R2PI project to understand the characteristics of the business model, evaluate its outcomes and identify the main barriers and enablers. Bioelektra has developed and utilized the innovative technology for municipal solid waste as a complementary solution to waste management. The activity of the company is based on a mechanical-heat waste treatment (MHT) called RotoSteril, different from traditional technology of municipal waste treatment. Waste is sterilized at high temperature and pressure, which kills all microorganisms in waste and makes it odourless. Subsequently sterilized waste is sorted into usable fractions of different secondary raw materials, organic fraction and RDF. These fractions can be further used to other processes and products. Usually these fractions are sold to recyclers. The identified business model of Bioelektra is resource recovery. The contribution of Bioelektra to the closed loop is primarily based on a very high recycling rate - up to 96% of municipal solid waste stream with no need of separate collection. At the municipal level in different countries one can still find a significant amount of waste without separate collection. This innovative technology enables lower “gate fee” for municipalities (and finally for residents) and high revenue from fractions. The report also presents an assessment of the circularity of the business model. Traditionally, the waste management sector in the EU was described as a “collect and dispose” operation: collecting mixed waste streams from municipal and commercial sources and disposing of the waste to landfill or through incineration. The waste management system in the circular economy will have to go beyond such an end-of-pipe approach to become an integral part of an economy, closely linked to patterns of production and consumption. Circular product design should be based on the feedback from the waste management sector concerning the ways to remanufacture, dismantle and recycle. At the same time the waste management sector should become a partner in developing circular business models focused on waste prevention and turning waste into resources. Activity of Bioelektra Group is based on the improving circular economy model since the very beginning. The aim of establishing the company was to implement and deliver the technology of waste treatment allowing recovery every material from waste. Bioelektra was focused on reducing the negative impact on the environment in waste management. The company was involved in the process that allow to obtain clean secondary raw materials and organic fraction, ideal for recycling purposes. It has now the full control concerning the composition of final products – recyclates - that they obtain. Those products can circulate in the economy for longer. But Bioelektra is not a manufacturer, so real circularity is out of their business model. Bioelektra fulfils its own function towards the circularity of the economy by addressing some of the challenges, but they don’t have complete control over their remanufactured products. As shown in the report, Bioelektra has created a waste treatment technology that can unveil resource potential in waste. It allows for simple methods of waste management in the cases where there is no segregation-at-source. The technology respects local community by making waste odourless. It is also the most financially viable waste treatment technology – according to managers from the company, as municipal solid waste is sterilised and turned into resources. It creates new opportunities for local economies in different parts of the world by delivering streams of recycled resources as secondary raw materials to the market by achieving a diversion rate of over 96% from landfill. Crucial for the business success of Bioelektra is the legal framework. Some provisions of EU law, especially in Directive on Waste, creates many opportunities for Bioelektra to expand. The constant increase of recycling level, which is declared by EU can create much bigger market for Bioelektra services. Limiting the biodegradable municipal waste going to landfills can create another possible opportunity, as well as a radical decrease in the amount of waste disposed in landfills, while increase of recycling and the recovery of waste. Based on the analysis, it is concluded that the resource recovery CEBM is replicable and transferable, especially that Bioelektra’s technology is fully scalable to the size of the waste stream and can be adjusted up and down in scale during its operations by adding or taking out autoclaves. Autoclaves are easy to transport, and installation is rather fast. Most of the investment cost is machinery and equipment which makes it ideal for external financing (bank or leasing). The construction costs are usually 10-20% of the total CAPEX. Technology is 100% environmentally friendly – it is odourless, there is no leakage, fumes and sewage system needed thus public acceptance and support can be expected. All these requirements are easy to meet thanks to Bioelektra technology – which creates many possibilities for strategic development of the company. However, the regulatory framework on the national level is now the biggest threat for Bioelektra, especially different interpretation of the EU legal requirement in different countries
Minerva. Repositorio Institucional de la Universidad de Santiago de Compostela
Publication Estudio, informe, memoria (Report)

PARK 2020 A Circular Economy Business Model Case

  • Zwart, Tamara
R2π – Transition from Linear to Circular is a European Union Horizon 2020 project focused on enabling organisations and their value chains to transition towards a more viable, sustainable and competitive economic model in order to support the European Union’s strategy on sustainability and competitiveness. A core part of this project is to work with organisations who are on the journey towards developing circular economy business models, therefore the project has conducted case studies of 18 selected organisations. This report is about the ‘Elevator as a Service’ (M-Use®) business model, as implemented by Delta Development Group at Park 20|20 (Hoofddorp, the Netherlands). Park 2020 is the first full-service Cradle to Cradle® office park in the world. The R2π project choose to conduct this case study because this shows building circular is already possible. In the autumn of 2015, the CEO of Delta Development Group (developer of Park 2020) came to the conclusion that in fact, buildings do not require elevators: the real need is vertical transport available at all times. Mitsubishi, in collaboration with Delta Development Group and the building owner, developed the ‘Elevator as a Service’-model, called M-Use®. In this new circular business model, the elevator is leased (full service operational lease) instead of sold/bought, hence leaving the ownership of the product with Mitsubishi during the contract term. Consequently, suppliers are incentivized to minimize maintenance needs, to build products for long-term durability, and to reuse and recycle components. The value proposition of the M-Use® business model is to offer high quality vertical transport with a high level of availability and complete maintenance in exchange for a monthly fee. This monthly fee is based on full service operational lease in which the ownership of the elevator lies with Mitsubishi. The M-Use® increased the quality level of the elevator, while decreasing the Total Cost of Usage. This is because the remote monitoring of the M-Use® enables Mitsubishi to plan the maintenance based on actual use. Hence, this drives the circularity of the elevator since this optimizes material usage and increases the lifespan. This study analysed categories of contextual dimensions and factors characterising the M-Use® business model, e.g. rules and regulations, economy, and customer needs. Rules and regulations can be enablers as well as barriers for the CEBM. On the one hand, if take-back were to become mandatory by law, this would very likely increase the number of ‘product as a service’ contracts closed, since Mitsubishi supports and offers take-back already. On the other hand, the current law regarding ownership in The Netherlands poses a risk to Mitsubishi since the elevator is permanently attached to a building, which is owned by a third party. Fortunately, Mitsubishi is avoiding this risk by establishing a so-called “building right”. The most important current financial barrier for ‘product as a service’ is the financing of this new business model. With M-Use®, Mitsubishi no longer sells the products but receives a monthly fee from the users of their elevators. Hence, a new financing need arises. Most bankers currently do not want to finance that because their current calculation methods can hardly evaluate the risk of M-Use® and the residual value the elevator has. Therefore, funding opportunities are important in order to drive the scale up phase of the M-Use®. Currently, customer needs regarding elevators are not based on circularity. Explaining the M-Use® model in a way that potential customers understand and agree with implementing the elevator as a service is a challenge. Their consideration regarding elevators is still mostly cost driven and their evaluation is based on principles of the linear economy (e.g. investment costs), while the M-Use® model offers more than a reduction in the cost over time (see True Value analyses made by KPMG) and should be valued based on the principles of the circular economy (e.g. Total Cost of Usage and reuse of components). A few key learnings derive from conducting this case study. Firstly, the intrinsic motivation of stakeholders helps to develop a new CEBM. Secondly, limitations of traditional business models can enable new ways of thinking and doing business. Thirdly, collaboration within the supply chain is key. Fourthly, creating a safe environment in which the stakeholders can try to develop a new CEBM without any risk supports the development of a CEBM. Finally, it takes time to explain the new CEBM to all stakeholders in such a way they understand and accept this new model. To finalize, looking at the discussed strengths, weaknesses, drivers and barriers of M-Use®, it is interesting to replicate this ‘product-as-a-service’ to other industries and products. In the Netherlands, there already exist some other ‘products-as-a-service’ CEBM’s.
Minerva. Repositorio Institucional de la Universidad de Santiago de Compostela
Publication Estudio, informe, memoria (Report)

ROCKWOOL GROUP: A Circular Economy Business Model Case

  • Mertens, Marius
  • Slaughter, Raymond
This report presents a case study of the ROCKWOOL Group and its circular business model, selected by the R2π project along with 17 other cases, due to its position within the construction and building materials sector, which is one of the priority areas of the European Union’s circular economy strategy. The objective of the report is to analyse the contextual and business factors affecting the circular business model, as well as to assess the enablers and barriers to implementing such a model and to provide considerations for both business leaders and policy makers. The construction industry is a rapidly growing and important sector for future global development and yet is currently one of the most resource-intensive and wasteful, accounting for 25-30% of all waste generated in the EU1. ROCKWOOL, as a major global player in the industry, was chosen particularly for its “RockCycle” take-back and recycle programme for building insulation materials. ROCKWOOL provides customers with fire resilient thermal insulation for buildings and houses. The product is made of a natural stone material and has high fire resistance, good thermal properties, long durability and is fully recyclable. During renovation, old insulation material would typically be considered waste and would be discarded in landfills, however, with the RockCycle programme, it is recovered and recycled. Today, RockCycle is offered in 5 countries, and the company has set goals to replicate the service to 30 countries by 2030. Currently, it is a small part of ROCKWOOL’s business with estimates in Germany of roughly 5% of the volume of flat roof insulation sold during 2017 being recovered and recycled. This is, nevertheless, a significant improvement, as the majority of all companies’ used insulation is still sent to landfill. The take-back programme is characterised primarily by three circular economy business model patterns in different parts of the value chain. At end-of-cycle, the material taken back from customers is “resource recovery”, and during production, this is combined also with the “co-product recovery” of secondary materials originating from other products or industries to enter a “re-make” process and recycle them back into new insulation material. This combined circular model results in positive environmental and economic impacts over the typical linear model. Outcomes include: reduced materials ending in landfill, lower consumption of virgin materials, financial benefits to customers, revenue to the company as well as image enhancement for the company
Minerva. Repositorio Institucional de la Universidad de Santiago de Compostela
Publication Estudio, informe, memoria (Report)

VAN DER VALK HOTEL: A Circular Business Model Innovation Journey

  • van der Westerlo, Bas
  • Zwart, Tamara
  • McDermott, Shona
  • Morwood, Doug
This report provides an overview of the circular business model innovation journey guided by the R2π project team for Van der Valk Hotel Venlo (The Netherlands). The team customised an innovation process to suit the specific needs of the company in order to help them explore opportunities to become more sustainable and circular. Due to confidentiality agreements, this report does not provide details of Van der Valk’s strategy and internal business data, rather the purpose of the report is to describe the innovation journey and tools utilised. A key challenge of the company relates to the daily business of running the hotel, a problem that persists in all hotel companies and can have an important role in eliminating negative environmental and social impacts. For over 10 years, there has been a strong sustainability ambition in the region of Venlo. From the moment the city of Venlo embraced the Cradle to CradleR principles, its motto has been ‘Realizing economic growth by boosting innovation that goes beyond conventional sustainability’. The cradle to cradleR inspired city hall of Venlo inspired the Van der Valk Hotel in Venlo. The circular principles will be embedded in rebuilding the hotel, both in the construction as well as in the interior concepts. However, the management also seeks ways how these principles can be implemented in the daily business and operation of the hotel. Therefore, Van der Valk Hotel Venlo is seeking viable business models to continue improving this situation and to create a process to continuously contribute to a circular transition. To that end, a cross-functional team from Van der Valk and R2π was brought together in workshop to gain a deeper understanding of the current business model and context within the market as well as to innovate new business models. Based on internal and external strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats identified within their current business model and context, they generated and explored multiple options for future circular business models. Thereafter, they further detailed these options and mapped out bold steps required to achieve the new business models. Team members identified their most critical assumptions and planned out roadmaps to allow them to test these assumptions and move forward towards implementing a more sustainable and circular business model. During this innovation process, facilitated design thinking methods and tools were used to identify opportunities on how Van der Val Hotel can innovate circular business models that increase business value while simultaneously reducing – or completely eliminate - negative impacts on the environment. Throughout the innovation journey, business opportunities were identified and explored, seeking to develop action plans that can take these ideas into practical activities and products for the company to become more circular
Minerva. Repositorio Institucional de la Universidad de Santiago de Compostela
Publication Estudio, informe, memoria (Report)

ECF FARMSYSTEMS: a Circular Economy Business Model Case

  • Figeac, Alexis
ECF is a very Small-and-Medium sized Enterprise which operates an aquaponic urban farm o Aquaponic food production is an industrial symbiosis within its own operations, exchanging material flows between the aquaculture and the hydroponic one. This may be considered as a co-product recovery business model pattern § The circularity is retained within ECF’s own operations and there is little value exchange among parties other than commercial ones o Socio-demographic factors such as growing population, growing urbanisation, alongside environmental ones such as competition for arable land, biodiversity loss, over-fishing, agro-chemicals in food production and others are the contextual drivers for aquaponics as a successful CEBM. o Characteristics of ECF’s industrial symbiosis/co-product recovery CEBM pattern: § Enables ECF to deliver its value proposition, namely to offer resource-efficient food on a B2B basis as an urban farm as well as a high level of transparency through story-telling around sourcing for its customers § Technology and know-how play a role in achieving the symbiosis § A significant socio-environmental impact is achieved through displacement of food miles and inherent resource-efficiency of aquaponics § Fish feed faces its own sustainability challenges; to be answered if ECF is to aspire to greater circularity § ECF as a successful pioneer of aquaponic farms is leveraging its know-how to design, plan and build turnkey farms for 3rd parties, thereby demonstrating the replicability of the CEBM. o Support for traditional (unsustainable) farming and fishing (including fuel subsidies) is impacting the competitiveness of aquaponics, as is the lack of transparency on ‘food miles’. o Whereas urban communities wish to become greener, urban farming such as aquaponics faces many planning and permissioning hurdles, despite growing demand from B2B and B2C consumers