DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publication
Tesis doctoral (DoctoralThesis)
Investigating venom composition and variation in West European vipers University do Porto
306 p, imágenes y tablas, The application in recent years of the high-throughput methodologies constituting
snake venomics has provided snake venom research with renewed interest and enthusiasm,
leading to the rapid production of a remarkable amount of information on a multitude of snake
venoms, and providing a comprehensive view of their compositions and properties. This has
allowed to obtain a detailed insight into some of the processes underlying snake venom origin
and evolution, and has led to the identification of compounds of potential medicinal relevance,
and to the development of powerful therapeutic tools to mitigate the global burden of
snakebite. Nonetheless, considerable knowledge gaps exist in snake venom research,
especially concerning the attention paid to certain topics and snake species. The main goal of
this thesis is to contribute to this research field, increasing the current knowledge on the
venoms produced by European vipers, focusing on species of the genus Vipera from the
Iberian Peninsula.
Aiming to provide the first qualitative and quantitative estimate of the trends and biases
in snake venom research, we reviewed a total of 267 snake venom studies published between
1964 and 2021. While our analysis showed an overall positive trend in the number of articles
published yearly, it also underlined severe neglect of snake families of supposedly minor
medical relevance (e.g., Atractaspididae), underrepresentation of some of the areas most
impacted by snakebite (i.e., Indomalayan and Afrotropic realms), and limited interest in the
ecological and functional context of snake venom. Indeed, snakes of the family Viperidae were
significantly more represented than any other snake taxon retrieved, the Neotropics were the
most represented biogeographic realm for number of studied species, and the vast majority of
the publications focused on snake venom characterisation, whereas more ecology-related
topics were rarely considered.
Although snakes of the family Viperidae were the most studied overall, the subfamily
Crotalinae (i.e., pit vipers) was twice as represented than Viperinae (i.e., true vipers), of critical
medical relevance across the Old World. In Europe, most snakebite accidents are caused by
true vipers of the genus Vipera, comprising more than 20 species. Amongst these, the species
of major medical relevance due to their greater diffusion across Europe and the high number
of registered snakebites are six, namely Vipera ammodytes, Vipera aspis, Vipera berus,
Vipera latastei, Vipera seoanei and Vipera ursinii. Generally not trained to identify snakebites,
recognise their clinical manifestations, and apply appropriate treatment, European physicians
need tools to help them with the management of European Vipera envenomations. To this
end, we defined taxonomic keys for the identification of the abovementioned six Vipera
species, and to distinguish them from European non-viperid snakes. We then reviewed and
resumed the data currently available on the composition of their venoms and the symptoms
Abstract
FCUP
Investigating venom composition and variation in West European vipers
xi
they can cause. We were able to retrieve several information concerning composition and
activities of the venoms of V. ammodytes, V.aspis, V. berus and V. ursinii, which appear to be
characterised by few very abundant toxin families accounting for most of their compositions
(i.e., SVMP, PLA2, SVSP, CTL) together with several less abundant components (e.g., DISI,
CRISP, LAAO). This is concordant with the compositional pattern generally reported for true
viper venoms, and with the mainly haemorrhagic and cytotoxic effects of viperid
envenomations. Indeed, when reviewing the clinical manifestations caused by the Vipera
species in question, we found these to range from local and only requiring topical treatment
(e.g., algesia, swelling) to systemic, potentially lethal, and requiring antivenom therapy (e.g.,
renal failure, haematological alterations). Finally, we defined a standardised protocol for the
clinical management of Vipera snakebite, addressing in detail the treatment of local and
systemic symptoms and antivenom administration procedures.
Notably, information available on composition and activity of V. latastei and V. seoanei
venoms was extremely reduced, and did not allow the development of a comprehensive
assessment for this two inadequately studied species. We thus aimed to fill this knowledge
gap by providing the first detailed investigation on composition and variation of V. latastei and
V. seoanei venoms, performed by the application of bottom-up proteomics. Concerning V.
latastei, we analysed the venoms of juvenile and adult specimens from two environmentally
different localities from northern Portugal. We thus produced six venom proteomes (three per
population) from vipers belonging to both age classes (i.e., two juveniles and four adults), and
RP-HPLC profiles of 54 venoms collected from wild specimens. Venoms from juveniles and
adults differed in their chromatographic profiles and relative abundances of their toxins,
suggesting the occurrence of ontogenetic changes in venom composition. Specifically, snake
venom metalloproteinase (SVMP) was the most abundant toxin family in juvenile venoms,
while snake venom serine proteinases (SVSPs), phospholipases A2 (PLA2s), and C-type
lectin-like proteins (CTLs) were the main toxins comprising adult venoms. The RP-HPLC
venom profiles were found to vary significantly between the two sampled localities, indicating
geographic variability. Furthermore, the presence/absence of certain peaks in the venom
chromatographic profiles appeared to be significantly correlated also to factors like body size
and sex of the vipers. Our findings show that V. latastei venom is a variable phenotype, with
intraspecific differences in its composition likely mirroring changes in the feeding ecology of
this species, taking place during different life stages and under different environmental
pressures.
Concerning V. seoanei, we analysed the venoms of 49 adult specimens from 20
localities across the species’ Iberian distribution. We used a pool of all individual venoms to
generate a V. seoanei venom reference proteome, produced SDS-PAGE profiles of all venom
xii FCUP
Investigating venom composition and variation in West European vipers
samples, and visualised patterns of variation using Non-metric Multidimensional Scaling
(NMDS). By applying linear regression, we then assessed presence and nature of venom
variation between localities, and investigated the effect of 14 predictors (biological, ecogeographic, genetic) on its occurrence. The venom comprised at least 12 different toxin
families, of which five (i.e., PLA2, SVSP, DISI, CTL, SVMP) accounted for about 75% of the
whole proteome. The comparative analyses of the SDS-PAGE venom profiles found them to
be remarkably similar across the sampled localities, suggesting low geographic variability.
Regression analyses suggested significant effects of biological and habitat predictors on the
little variation we detected across the analysed V. seoanei venoms. Other factors were also
significantly associated with the presence/absence of individual bands in the SDS-PAGE
profiles. The low levels of venom variability we detected within V. seoanei might be the result
of a recent population expansion, or of other processes than directional positive selection
acting to maintain a conserved venom phenotype.
The analysis of trends and biases in snake venom studies allowed to detect the
consistent neglect of some research topics and snake taxa. Similarly, reviewing the data
currently available on the six Vipera species of major medical importance in Europe uncovered
a severe lack of information on some of them, especially in terms of venom composition and
intraspecific variation. The development of bottom-up venomics on the venoms of V. latastei
and V. seoanei made it possible to make a first step towards filling this knowledge gap. Indeed,
the results of these analyses led to the characterisation of these greatly overlooked viper
venoms, detecting intraspecific venom variation at different levels (i.e., ontogenetic variation
in V. latastei; geographic variation of different magnitude in V. latastei and V. seoanei), and
paved the way for investigating the occurrence of venom variation in these two species.
Expanding the performed proteomic analyses to other so far neglected Vipera species,
together with the implementation of genomic, transcriptomic, and functional analyses, would
certainly provide a more complete insight into evolution and variation of European viper
venoms, The candidate was financially supported by FCT – Fundação para a Ciência e Tecnologia
(Portugal) through the award of PhD grants SFRH/BD/137797/2018 and
COVID/BD/152929/2023. Laboratory analyses at the Institute of Biomedicine of Valencia were
partially financed by Ministerio de Ciencia e Innovación (Spain), through grant
BFU2020_PID2020-119593GB-I00., Peer reviewed