Pasar al contenido principal

Resultados relacionados

Resultados totales (Incluyendo duplicados): 13
Encontrada(s) 1 página(s)

Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo de revisión (ReviewArticle)

A social network analysis of an epistemic community studying neoliberal conservation

  • Bunce, Brittany Jane|||0000-0003-4872-4238
  • Apostolopoulou, Evangelia|||0000-0002-8166-4639
  • Maestre Andrés, Sara|||0000-0003-3971-5209
  • Choy, Alejandra Pizarro
  • Requena-i-Mora, Marina|||0000-0001-5519-3127
  • Brockington, Dan|||0000-0001-5692-0154
Researchers typically operate in epistemic communities: groups that share common approaches to research agendas and sociopolitical action and define areas of debate. Although productive in their own spheres, a lack of understanding among these communities can undermine scientific progress. Thus, analyzing epistemic communities is important for understanding the politics of knowledge production. Social network analysis sheds light on these dynamics by mapping the collaborative networks that shape academic output. We used 255 publications examined in Apostolopoulou et al.'s review of neoliberal conservation literature and 2135 additional publications in a social network analysis. We compiled a coauthorship network for 318 authors and found a dispersed and polycentric network with low connectivity and relatively small clusters of scholars collaborating within tightly knit groups. Although the structure is conducive to innovation and diversity, building new connections among dispersed coauthor groups could enrich knowledge sharing to drive novel approaches. We identified central actors in building collaborations among communities and communicating ideas across the network. We considered actor attributes, such as gender and geographic location, alongside centrality measures. We found that seventy percent of the 20 authors with the highest betweenness centrality were men, and only one male author was affiliated to an institution in the Global South. Our analysis of thematic clusters in the literature highlighted the spatial patchiness and partialness of the literature across different subfields. Scholars should undertake more work on identified themes in currently excluded geographic regions through effective interdisciplinary collaborations and with local communities of research and practice and grassroots movements. There is a need to strengthen the field's intellectual diversity and to have a deeper engagement with issues of class, gender, and race. This would allow neoliberal conservation to reimagine conservation in ways that are not only environmentally sustainable, but also socially just.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Eco-paradox USA, the relationships between economic growth and environmental concern generally, and by different income groups

  • Requena-i-Mora, Marina|||0000-0001-5519-3127
  • Brockington, Dan|||0000-0001-5692-0154
  • Fleischman, Forrest D.|||0000-0001-6060-4031
Environmental values are commonly explained through three theories: post-materialism suggests affluence enables environmental concern, materialism argues environmental harm drives concern, while disconnection theory posits economic growth creates both concern and degradation. We test these frameworks at two levels. First, using aggregate U.S. time-series data (1990-2021), and Vector Autoregression Analysis (VAR) analysis to examine how resource use and environmental impact, economic growth and concern are related. We show that these three theories can complement each other. Both material and carbon footprint growth lead to subsequent GDP growth, supporting materialist views. GDP growth then increases environmental concern, aligning with post-materialist predictions. This causal chain supports disconnection theory: the very process that generates environmental concern - economic growth - simultaneously intensifies environmental degradation. Second, at the individual level (2000-2023), we examine how income relates to environmental preferences and impacts. Contrary to post-materialist expectations of wealthy groups showing greater environmental concern, logistic regression analysis controlling for sociodemographic variables reveals lower-income groups consistently prioritize environmental protection over economic growth. Carbon emissions analysis reveals that carbon footprint inequality among income groups has been rapidly increasing, with the p99/p50 income ratio rising since 1990. By 2019, top1% of income emitted 250 COeq/t per capita and bottom 50 % only 10 COeq/t per capita, while lower-income groups consistently rate environmental conditions as poor and worsening, further supporting materialist theories linking environmental harm to concern. At the societal level, our findings reveal that environmental concern is structurally intertwined with economic growth-a process that simultaneously drives environmental degradation and poses significant challenges for degrowth transitions. In contrast, at the individual level, lower-income groups consistently prioritize environmental protection over economic growth while exhibiting a lower environmental impact. This pattern suggests the potential for a "degrowth from below," initiated by low-income individuals whose heightened preference for environmental protection directly reflects their experience of poor and worsening environmental conditions.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Coexistence beyond disciplinary silos, five dimensions of analysis for more convivial human-predator interactions

  • Krauss, Judith E.|||0000-0003-4593-0781
  • Fiasco, Valentina
  • Marchini, Silvio
  • McInturff, Alex|||0000-0002-4858-1292
  • Sandroni, Laila T.|||0000-0003-4632-5284
  • Alagona, Peter S.|||0000-0002-1030-0029
  • Brockington, Dan|||0000-0001-5692-0154
  • Büscher, Bram
  • Duffy, Rosaleen|||0000-0002-6779-7240
  • Ferraz, Katia Maria P.M. de Barros|||0000-0002-7870-8696
  • Fletcher, Rob
  • Kiwango, Wilhelm Andrew
  • Komi, Sanna|||0000-0001-8331-2701
  • Mabele, Mathew Bukhi|||0000-0002-2460-2415
  • Massarella, Kate|||0000-0001-6721-1281
  • Nygren, Anja|||0000-0001-9054-1801
Understanding human-predator interactions has been a central goal of conservation for decades, yet many previous efforts have approached this challenge from disciplinary perspectives focused on single case studies. There is a need for more transdisciplinary and multi-sited research to enrich our understandings of the complexity of human-nonhuman interactions and to design ways to make them more convivial. The multi-year CONVIVA "convivial conservation" research project addressed this gap, involving scholars from natural sciences, social sciences and humanities to promote coexistence, biodiversity and justice in conservation across four diverse case studies of apex predators: jaguars in Brazil, wolves in Finland, lions in Tanzania, and brown bears in California, United States. In this article, we set out two key contributions. First, we highlight how our project created iterative, dialogue-based reflections amongst different disciplines and perspectives to inform research questions, methods and units of analysis, fulfilling what we see as a key need in the literature. Second, we operationalise our collaboration beyond disciplinary silos into a novel framework of five interconnected dimensions of analysis, that characterise human-predator interactions, drawing on a range of lenses and including a series of guiding questions. We also showcase empirical material from our cases across wildlife, environment, interactions, institutions and justice dimensions. We present our approach, framework and findings with collective reflections and an invitation for adaptation and further research on their suitability to other contexts and species.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Prospects and perils in the geospatial turn of conservation

  • Sze, Jocelyne Shimin|||0000-0001-8183-766X
  • Sauls, Laura Aileen
Conservation has embraced advances in big data and related digital technologies as key to preventing biodiversity loss, especially in the identification of areas of conservation priority based on spatial data, which we call the big geospatial data turn. This turn has led to the proliferation of useful methods and tools, including global geospatial maps. But these methods may also undermine moves toward rights-based and inclusive conservation approaches that consider plural values and perspectives. We built on the burgeoning literature to call for greater attention to be paid to the datasets, methodological choices, and the assumptions global mapping for biodiversity conservation is based on. In increasingly prioritizing the use of big geospatial data, conservation professionals risk forgetting that maps show only partial information and limit the diversity of ways of seeing and representing the world. Big geospatial data collected through remotely sensed technologies must still be situated in time and place and provided with appropriate political-economic and sociocultural contexts. Further, global mapping efforts remain primarily the purview of Global North researchers, even given the push to make data open access. Instead of uncritically calling for more data, we urge conservationists to contextualize and situate big geospatial data carefully so as to build a field that achieves socially just and ecologically effective conservation outcomes.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Finding the ghosts, Snow leopard density and distribution in the multi-use region of Jammu and Kashmir, India

  • Khanyari, Munib Sajad|||0000-0003-4624-5073
  • Shah, Tariq Ahmed
  • Bajaj, Deepti
  • Rao, Rajat
  • Sharma, Charu
  • Sharma, Neeraj
  • Tobge, Rinchen
  • Thuktan, Tanzin
  • Angrup, Dorje
  • Chunit, Kesang
  • Chhering, Tandup
  • Hameed, Shahid
  • Suryawanshi, Kulbhushansingh
Large carnivores occur in human-dominated landscapes globally, albeit with varying consequences for the animals and people involved. This lies in stark contrast to the belief that Protected Areas are the only means to conserve large carnivores, and in particular big cats. We aimed to assess snow leopard density and distribution in non-protected landscapes within Jammu and Kashmir, India. Using detection/non-detection records from 193 camera traps, we developed an ensemble species distribution model to identify important areas for snow leopard occurrence across J&K. To estimate population size in a non-protected, multi-use landscape, we applied spatially explicit capture-recapture (SECR) models to data from 47 camera traps deployed across five valleys covering 989 km2 in Paddar, Kishtwar Himalaya. Alongside, we conducted focus group discussions with local communities to understand land-use practices. The distribution model predicted high snow leopard suitability across the eastern region of Jammu and Kashmir, that is, the Kishtwar Himalaya. We estimated 0.35 (0.11-1.06) snow leopards100 km-2 with a realized abundance of 6 (6-11) individuals in Paddar. Land uses were local and migratory livestock grazing, religious pilgrimages and medicinal plant and fodder collection. Snow leopard were rarely seen by people, but livestock owners and herders faced livestock losses to snow leopards. Practical implication. Our approach provides the first integrated assessment of snow leopard occurrence in J&K, and density and land use in Paddar, offering insights for conservation planning outside formally protected areas. This underscores the urgent need to set up community-based conservation interventions as we confirm that the Kishtwar Himalaya, irrespective of protection status, needs to be managed as a snow leopard landscape. Our study adds to the evidence that snow leopards need landscape-level conservation strategies, rather than relying solely on Protected Areas.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Practical and Ethical Issues in Big Data and Machine Learning Forecasts of Zambian Community Forestry Engagement

  • Pienkowski, Thomas|||0000-0002-3803-7533
  • Mills, Morena|||0000-0001-9865-0770
  • Clark, Matt|||0000-0002-3217-1192
  • Moombe, Kaala|||0000-0002-6167-1057
  • Chilufya, Henry
  • Sfyridis, Alexandros|||0000-0002-3103-8437
  • Sze, Jocelyne Shimin|||0000-0001-8183-766X
  • Olsson, Erik|||0000-0002-8757-2647
  • Jørgensen, Andreas Christ Sølvsten|||0000-0003-2276-5779
Approaches integrating geospatial "big data" and machine learning will likely be increasingly used to predict conservation-related human behavior, such as patterns of local engagement, in socioecological systems. Yet, few studies evaluate both the technical and ethical aspects of such applications. Here, we provide a nation-scale worked example that combines machine learning and publicly available data to predict spatial patterns of Community Forestry establishment among 539,221 settlements across Zambia. Our model accurately predicted out-of-sample spatial establishment patterns three-quarters of the time (balanced accuracy = 76.5%, sensitivity = 64.0%, specificity = 89.1%), though it had a high false positive rate (precision = 24.3%). Accurately forecasting conservation establishment patterns for effective resource allocation requires better data on local preferences and programmatic decision-making, among other factors. Furthermore, such artificial intelligence applications risk making decision-making more technocratic, top-down, and opaque; therefore, they should only inform deliberation over possible future scenarios within wider, multistakeholder governance processes.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Evaluating decoupling Evidence, Examining Timeframes, geographic Scales, and planetary boundaries

  • Requena-i-Mora, Marina|||0000-0001-5519-3127
  • Brockington, Dan|||0000-0001-5692-0154
Plans for green growth require that economies can decouple from material resource use. Previous research into this issue using Material Footprint has found some evidence of absolute decoupling. But the data used were limited, as were the geographical and historical frames within which change was assessed. This study systematically examines methodological biases that may inflate perceived "green growth" success and evaluates decoupling evidence across multiple analytical dimensions to determine whether economic growth can detach from material resource demands. We analysed Material Footprint data from 105 countries (1970-2022) using a three-stage approach: (1) second-degree-polynomial, nonparametric-kernel, and neural-network models to identify apparent decoupling patterns; (2) panel regressions comparing national trajectories with lower-income nations and sustainability-limit scenarios; and (3) historical reconstruction analysis extending the UK's Material Footprint back to 1875 to examine long-term trends. Stage 1 identified 25 countries demonstrating apparent GDP-material use decoupling during 1970-2022. However, Stage 2 panel analysis revealed that focusing on individual countries in isolation systematically overstates decoupling achievements when trajectories are compared against sustainability-limit scenarios and international benchmarks. Year-by-year regressions consistently showed positive quadratic coefficients indicating accelerating resource use at higher income levels throughout the entire period. Stage 3 demonstrated that the UK's recent apparent decoupling represents temporary fluctuations rather than structural change, with 147 years of data showing persistent long-term growth in resource consumption relative to GDP. This study demonstrates that methodological choices-particularly short timeframes, geographic isolation, and absence of sustainability-limits-create systematic biases that misrepresent unsustainable change as progress. Our findings challenge green growth narratives by showing that apparent decoupling success recede when examined more critically. Our findings mean that, longer historical perspectives and explicit integration of sustainability limits are required to evaluate economic-environmental relationships.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Disentangling the drivers of vegetation change in a mobility-constrained pastoral landscape in Laikipia Kenya

  • Unks, Ryan R.|||0000-0002-8216-7570
  • King, Elizabeth|||0000-0003-1104-3199
  • Wachira, N. P.
  • Hepinstall-Cymerman, Jeffrey|||0000-0003-2087-850X
  • Isbell, Forest|||0000-0001-9689-769X
Dryland ecosystems around the world support high biodiversity and extensive pastoralism, but the drivers of landscape change are often poorly understood. Reductionistic understandings have tended to overemphasize livestock impacts and support restrictive interventions, which can ironically undermine synergistic relationships between pastoralism and biodiversity. Within a collectively-titled pastoralist landscape in Laikipia, Kenya, we built on long-term research to examine spatial relationships between locally-varying livestock use intensity and patterns of vegetation change over a 26 year period. We integrated remote sensing, field vegetation measurements, and pastoralist expert accounts of vegetation change to map vegetation transitions and their spatial distribution. We triangulated between multiple lines of inference, including classifications of vegetation community types and transitions, maps of varying livestock use zones and topography, qualitative analysis of expert explanations of vegetation change, and NDVI time series, to infer the contributions of grazing intensity and other drivers to the observed vegetation transitions. First, the most salient landscape change was the loss of two Euphorbia spp. in ∼22% of the study area; with elephants largely driving the loss of one species, and climate being a probable driver of loss of the other. Second, approximately 40% of the area experienced some degree of shrub encroachment. Spatial comparisons with livestock use zones indicated that shrub encroachment was more likely driven by fire suppression and/or climate. Third, there was ∼26% decrease of area supporting moderate or dense herbaceous vegetation cover. These decreases were primarily associated with increasing temperature, woody encroachment, and higher livestock pressure in areas that both formerly supported Euphorbia spp. canopies and also experienced year-round livestock use imposed through a conservation intervention. We recommend integrative triangulation between multiple epistemologies to understand how landscape changes in dryland ecosystems are driven by complex, interacting drivers such as spatio-temporal climate variability, megaherbivores, fire suppression, sedentarization, and changing livelihoods.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Centering geospatial data uncertainty and the potential for injustice in pastoralist rangeland conservation prioritization

  • Unks, Ryan R.|||0000-0002-8216-7570
Procedural, distributional, recognitional, and epistemic justice aspects of conservation interventions are well documented in contexts where pastoralism is a key livelihood and way of life. Geospatial analyses and representations of wildlife conservation and restoration that are increasingly applied in pastoralist rangeland socioecological systems create the potential to make these injustices invisible. Current global-extent publicly-available data and analysis methods cannot be used to accurately characterize or produce generalizations about diverse, variable pastoralist practices or their relations with rangeland ecosystems. In particular, these geospatial data do not adequately represent complex livestock mobility practices or pastoralists' diverse ways of relating to land and wildlife. When they are used to provide evidence for conservation interventions, the inherent uncertainties and limitations of geospatial data and analyses, coupled with ongoing political marginalization of pastoralists, creates a high risk of perpetuating historical injustices and extending new injustices. Epistemic injustices will likely remain a concern even with technological advancement because conservation science itself lacks a sufficient conceptual basis to adequately recognize pastoralists' land use, ecological relations, decision-making processes, and knowledges. When geospatial analysis is used to inform conservation policy and practical applications in pastoralist rangelands, its use should be critically examined with respect to: whether it can technically account for ecological and social variability; how compound uncertainties arise when multiple data layers are used to produce knowledge about socioecological interactions; and how uncertainties become masked by epistemic biases, creating a deceptive sense of certainty and generalizability.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Social implications of the 30×30 global conservation target

  • Fajardo Nolla, Francisco Javier
  • Bingham, Heather C.|||0000-0003-0177-7666
  • Brockington, Dan|||0000-0001-5692-0154
  • Chaplin-Kramer, Rebecca|||0000-0002-1539-5231
  • Fitzsimons, James A.|||0000-0003-4277-8040
  • Fleischman, Forrest D.|||0000-0001-6060-4031
  • Frechette, Alain|||0000-0002-5521-0668
  • Garrett, Rachael|||0000-0002-6171-263X
  • Hazin, Carolina|||0009-0002-3059-384X
  • Kuemmerle, Tobias|||0000-0002-9775-142X
  • Lessmann, Janeth|||0000-0002-1502-625X
  • Nuvunga, Milagre O. F.
  • O’Donnell, Brian
  • Onyai, Fred
  • Pinto, Ruth
  • Pfeifer, Marion|||0000-0002-6775-3141
  • Pritchard, Rose|||0000-0002-6174-3460
  • Ryan, Casey|||0000-0002-1802-0128
  • Shyamsundar, Priya|||0000-0001-8368-8581
  • Cariño Tauli, Josefa|||0000-0002-0257-3908
  • Tumusiime, David Mwesigye|||0000-0003-0171-5027
  • Upton, Jasmin|||0000-0002-6848-1301
  • Watmough, Gary R.|||0000-0002-0657-2208
  • Zaehringer, Julie Gwendolin|||0000-0002-3253-5128
  • Sandbrook, Chris|||0000-0002-9938-4934
Target 3 of the Kunming-Montreal Global Biodiversity Framework aims to increase global protected and conserved area coverage to at least 30% by 2030. The impact on people, whether positive or negative, will depend on the social context of additional areas and how they are governed and managed. Here, we show that Target 3 could affect large and socially diverse populations under different implementation scenarios. Nearly half the human population lives within 10 km of areas included in a scenario maximising biodiversity representation. Four percent live near areas included in an Indigenous and traditional territories-based scenario, including many in areas with low Human Development Index scores (74%) and high participation in wild harvesting (91%). A scenario prioritising nature's contributions to people is intermediate on all measures. Our results demonstrate that Target 3 is a highly ambitious social as well as ecological target, requiring an equally ambitious commitment to development funding and support for local residents.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Spatial variation of perceived equity and its determinants in a gateway community of Giant Panda National Park, China

  • Li, Qingyu
  • Huang, Junlong
  • Zhang, Yin
  • Gu, Guangcan
  • Brockington, Dan|||0000-0001-5692-0154
Social equity is essential in the governance of protected areas (PAs), as ignoring such consideration can lead to resistance and jeopardize conservation objectives. However, more research is required to understand the spatial heterogeneity of perceived social equity and its underlying spatial factors. Using a survey of 361 respondents, we presented spatial distribution patterns of perceived equity by kernel density estimation (KDE) in Giant Panda National Park, China. The regression analysis showed that local residents who live closer to the PA boundary are more likely to develop negative responses and those who with easy access to tourism spots have more positive procedural and distributional perceptions. Notably, the proximity to the PA authority decreases locals' perceptions of fairness in all aspects, which is potentially due to the opaque participative channels provided by the PA authority. We argue that those spatial differentials in fairness perceptions are driven by the intrinsic discrepancy of biodiversity protection requirements and the unevenly distributed consequences of management policies. Key steps to advance social equity considerations include multi-industry guidance, extending participative channels, and co-producing better compensation plans. Herein, this study appeals to a greater focus on the spatial aspect of social equity issues in PAs.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Governance and Conservation Effectiveness in Protected Areas and Indigenous and Locally Managed Areas

  • Zhang, Yin
  • West, Paige
  • Thakholi, Lerato
  • Suryawanshi, Kulbhushansingh
  • Supuma, Miriam
  • Straub, Dakota
  • Sithole, Samantha S.
  • Sharma, Roshan
  • Schleicher, Judith
  • Ruli, Ben
  • Rodríguez-Rodríguez, David
  • Rasmussen, Mattias Borg
  • Ramenzoni, Victoria C.
  • Qin, Siyu|||0000-0001-6466-7400
  • Pugley, Deborah Delgado
  • Palfrey, Rachel
  • Oldekop, Johan
  • Nuesiri, Emmanuel O.
  • Nguyen, Van Hai Thi
  • Ndam, Nouhou
  • Mungai, Catherine
  • Milne, Sarah
  • Mabele, Mathew Bukhi|||0000-0002-2460-2415
  • Lucitante, Sadie
  • Lucitante, Hugo
  • Liljeblad, Jonathan
  • Kiwango, Wilhelm Andrew
  • Kik, Alfred
  • Jones, Nikoleta
  • Johnson, Melissa
  • Jarrett, Christopher
  • James, Rachel Sapery
  • Holmes, George
  • Gibson, Lydia N.
  • Ghoddousi, Arash
  • Geldmann, Jonas
  • Gebara, Maria Fernanda
  • Edwards, Thera
  • Dressler, Wolfram H.
  • Douglas, Leo R.
  • Dimitrakopoulos, Panayiotis G.|||0000-0002-8374-4392
  • Davidov, Veronica
  • Compaoré-Sawadogo, Eveline M.F.W.
  • Collins, Yolanda Ariadne
  • Cepek, Michael
  • Burow, Paul Berne
  • Brockington, Dan|||0000-0001-5692-0154
  • Balinga, Michael Philippe Bessike
  • Austin, Beau J.
  • Astuti, Rini
  • Ampumuza, Christine
  • Agyei, Frank Kwaku
Increased conservation action to protect more habitat and species is fueling a vigorous debate about the relative effectiveness of different sorts of protected areas. Here we review the literature that compares the effectiveness of protected areas managed by states and areas managed by Indigenous peoples and/or local communities. We argue that these can be hard comparisons to make. Robust comparative case studies are rare, and the epistemic communities producing them are fractured by language, discipline, and geography. Furthermore the distinction between these different forms of protection on the ground can be blurred. We also have to be careful about the value of this sort of comparison as the consequences of different forms of conservation for people and nonhuman nature are messy and diverse. Measures of effectiveness, moreover, focus on specific dimensions of conservation performance, which can omit other important dimensions. With these caveats, we report on findings observed by multiple study groups focusing on different regions and issues whose reports have been compiled into this article. There is a tendency in the data for community-based or co-managed governance arrangements to produce beneficial outcomes for people and nature. These arrangements are often accompanied by struggles between rural groups and powerful states. Findings are highly context specific and global generalizations have limited value.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Exploring the relationship between local participation and perceived Co-management performance, Evidence from China's Giant Panda National Park

  • Zhang, Yin
  • Hu, Fangbing|||0000-0001-5761-0588
  • Zhang, Yuqi
  • Du, Chunlan
  • Brockington, Dan|||0000-0001-5692-0154
Understanding local perceptions is essential to ensure the good functioning of co-management in protected areas (PAs). However, more research is required quantitatively to assess the extent locals are empowered. This paper seeks to investigate the effects of varied participation types and levels on perceived performance in a centralized co-management regime in Giant Panda National Park, China. Using 353 survey questionnaires, we identified six co-management subtypes that were classified into four empowerment levels: instruction, consultation, agreement, and cooperation. Notably, our analysis suggests that involvement at the cooperation level was not clearly linked with more favorable local perceptions of conservation. In contrast, local residents engaged in the instruction level of co-management (support, training, and employment subtypes) were more inclined to develop positive perceptions across the ecological, social, and livelihood dimensions. This study suggests the conclusion that merely empowering locals might not facilitate favorable perceptions of conservation. Instruction co-management intended to enhance social well-being if it is tailored to the needs of local residents.