UPCommons. Portal del coneixement obert de la UPC
Publicación
Artículo científico (JournalArticle)
The importance of accounting for stakeholder values, power relationships and language in constructing relevant and trustworthy climate information
Abstract Facing increasing risks from climate change, governments at all levels have started to mainstream the use of climate information. It has been widely acknowledged that the inclusion of stakeholder knowledge and needs, for example, in a co-design and co-production process, is important for producing user-relevant information. Here we start from a hypothetical example and two real-world case studies from South America and West Africa to discuss the role of user values, power relationships and language in the construction of climate information. While these aspects have been discussed individually in several papers, we focus on the mutual influences of these aspects in the information construction and argue that, therefore, they cannot be considered separately. We identify five dimensions?the level of risk, the complexity of the scientific problem, user values, power relationships and language?to characterize the complexity of a given user context. Analyzing these dimensions can guide the choice and design of user engagement in a given situation. In particular, even basic research may benefit from such an engagement. Regularly accounting for these aspects in research projects may require substantial changes in the way research funding is organized and how the work of researchers is rewarded., DM acknowledges the ACRP SPIRIT (KR18AC0K14748) and MoCCA (FO999913124) projects. SPS, DB and SS acknowledge the Impetus4Change project (HorizonEurope Grant 101081555). FJDR acknowledges the Climateurope2 project (Horizon Europe Grant 101056933). LD acknowledges funding from Agencia Nacional de Promoción de la Investigación, el Desarrollo Tecnológico y la Innovación (Agencia I+D+i), Argentina (PICT-2020-SERIEA-I-INVI-00540) and CONICET (PIBAA28720210100758CO). DB acknowledges the AI4S fellowship within the “Generación D” initiative by Red. es, Ministerio para la Transformación Digital. The authors want to thank Sokhna Thiam (African Population and Health Research Center, Senegal), Jacques-André Ndione (Regional Agency for Agriculture and Food, Togo), Amadou Thierno Gaye (University Cheikh Anta Diop, Senegal), Codou Badiane Mané and Ibrahima Sy (Ministry of Health and Social Action, Senegal) for their involvement in the health case study. For the SESA case, we thank the CLIMAX (http://www.climax-sa.org/) and CLIM. AR projects and Strategic Project on the Parana River of the Ministry of Science and Technology of Argentina and UBA, CONICET and PICT funds from Argentina. W.G. acknowledges partial support from U.S. Department of Energy Office of Science Award DE-SC0016438 and U.S. NOAA Grant NA23OAR4310629. SS acknowledges the funding from Agence Nationale de la Recherche - France 2030 as part of the PEPR TRACCS programme under Grant ANR-22-EXTR-0011 (LOCALISING). This manuscript contributes to the WCRP Lighthouse Activity My Climate Risk and to the WCRP Core project Regional Information for Society (RIfS): Robust Information Working Group. The information and views expressed are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the official opinion of the European Commission. Open Access funding provided by Universitat Graz/KEMÖ., Peer Reviewed, "Article signat per 18 autors/es: Douglas Maraun, Dragana Bojovic, Wendy Parker, Theodore G. Shepherd, Stefan Sobolowski, Cyril Caminade, Alessandro Dosio, William J. Gutowski, Anna Sörensson, Leandro B. Diaz, Ibrahima Diouf, Francisco J. Doblas-Reyes, Valeria Hernández, Christopher Jack, Laura Pereira, Juan A. Rivera, Federico Robledo, Samuel Somot."