- Yue, Kai
- Vangansbeke, Pieter
- Myers-Smith, Isla H
- Waller, Donald M
- Verheyen, Kris
- Bernhardt-Römermann, Markus
- Baeten, Lander
- Staude, Ingmar R
- Bjorkman, Anne D
- Hédl, Radim
- Andrews, Christopher
- Barni, Elena
- Becker, Thomas
- Becker-Scarpitta, Antoine
- Benito-Alonso, José-Luis
- Bennie, Jonathan
- Berki, Imre
- Blüml, Volker
- Brunet, Jörg
- Bullock, James M
- Van Calster, Hans
- Carbognani, Michele
- Chudomelová, Markéta
- Closset-Kopp, Déborah
- Dan Turtureanu, Pavel
- Daskalova, Gergana N
- Decocq, Guillaume
- Dick, Jan
- Diekmann, Martin
- Dirnböck, Thomas
- Durak, Tomasz
- Eriksson, Ove
- Erschbamer, Brigitta
- Graae, Bente Jessen
- Heinken, Thilo
- Hermy, Martin
- Horchler, Peter
- Jandt, Ute
- Jaroszewicz, Bogdan
- Kanka, Róbert
- Kollár, Jozef
- Kopecký, Martin
- Kudernatsch, Thomas
- Lamprecht, Andrea
- Lenoir, Jonathan
- Macek, Martin
- Malicki, Marek
- Máliš, František
- Michelsen, Ottar
- Mitchell, Fraser
- Naaf, Tobias
- Nagel, Thomas A
- Newman, Miles
- Newton, Adrian C
- Nicklas, Lena
- Oddi, Ludovica
- Orczewska, Anna
- Orsenigo, Simone
- Ortmann-Ajkai, Adrienne
- Ouden, Jan den
- Pauli, Harald
- Peterken, George
- Petřík, Petr
- Pielech, Remigiusz
- Puşcaş, Mihai
- Randin, Christophe
- Reczyńska, Kamila
- Rixen, Christian
- Schei, Fride Høistad
- Schmidt, Wolfgang
- Šebesta, Jan
- Stachurska-Swakon, Alina
- Standovár, Tibor
- Świerkosz, Krzysztof
- Teleki, Balázs
- Theurillat, Jean-Paul
- Ursu, Tudor-Mihai
- Vanneste, Thomas
- Vellend, Mark
- Vergeer, Philippine
- Vild, Ondřej
- Villar Pérez, Luis
- Vittoz, Pascal
- Winkler, Manuela
- Wipf, Sonja
- Wu, Fuzhong
- Zhang, Shengmin
- De Frenne, Pieter
Climate warming is shifting biological communities, with warmth-demanding species being favoured at the expense of cold-adapted species in a process referred to as thermophilization1-4. Because biodiversity responses often lag behind climate warming, climatic debts are accumulating in many ecosystems across the world5-7. Although we might expect that thermophilization and climatic debts will vary among habitats, standardized quantification across ecosystems is lacking. Here we analysed multidecadal data from 6,067 resurveyed vegetation plots over 12-78 years in forests, grasslands and on alpine summits across Europe. We demonstrate that forest understory and grassland plant communities experienced positive thermophilization, although not significantly different from zero. By contrast, alpine summit vegetation showed much stronger (up to five times) and significant thermophilization. Thermophilization was driven largely by increases in warmth-demanding species in grasslands, by declines in cold-adapted species on alpine summits and by both processes in forests. Significant climatic debts have accumulated in forests and alpine summits, but less so in grasslands, with debts positively correlated with macroclimate temperature changes. Our findings uncover divergent thermophilization trajectories and increasing climatic debts across ecosystems. Moreover, we highlight the mechanisms that enable some communities to track climate change more closely than others and provide a basis for projecting future shifts in plant communities under accelerating climate warming., K.Y. thanks Y. Peng for her personal and professional support and K. Guo for his help with data analyses. K.Y. acknowledges support from the National Natural Science Foundation of China (32271633 and 32011530426), the National Key Research and Development Program of China (2023YFF1305500), the Central-guided Local Science and Technology Development Fund Projects of Fujian Province (2023L3005) and the Alexander von Humboldt Research Fellowship for Experienced Researchers. P.D.F. and P. Vangansbeke acknowledge support by the European Research Council (ERC) under the Horizon 2020 research and innovation program (ERC Starting Grant FORMICA 757833 and ERC Consolidator Grant CanopyChange 101124948) and from the Research Foundation–Flanders (FWO) by funding the scientific research network FLEUR (W000322N, www.fleur.ugent.be). I.H.M.-S. was funded by the Canada Excellence Research Chairs Program, the Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada (NSERC) and the European Union’s Horizon Europe–European Research Council programme under ERC-2022-SYG grant agreement number 101071417–RESILIENCE. A.D.B. was supported by the Knut and Alice Wallenberg Foundation (WAF KAW 2019.0202). M.K. and M. Macek were supported by the Czech Science Foundation (project GACR 23-06614S). R.H., M. Chudomelová and O.V. were supported by the Czech Science Foundation (project 21-11487S). M.K., M. Macek., R.H., M. Chudomelová, P.P. and O.V. were funded by the Czech Academy of Sciences long-term development project (RVO 67985939). A.B.-S. was supported by the European Union: Agricultural Fund for Rural Development (EAFRD), the Conseil Départemental de La Réunion and the Centre de Coopération internationale en Recherche agronomique pour le Développement (CIRAD). T.-M.U. acknowledges support from the Ministry of Research, Innovation and Digitization of Romania through the Core Project BioClimpact no. 7/30.12.2022, code 23020401. P.D.T. was funded by the GreenMount project PN-IV-P2-2.1-TE-2023-0726 from UEFISCDI Romania. F. Máliš was supported by project VEGA 1/0245/25. This study is an outcome of the sREplot working group supported by sDiv, the Synthesis Centre of the German Centre for Integrative Biodiversity Research (iDiv) Halle-Jena-Leipzig (DFG FZT 118)., Peer reviewed