Pasar al contenido principal

Resultados relacionados

Resultados totales (Incluyendo duplicados): 3
Encontrada(s) 1 página(s)

DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

The Complexity of Food Systems: Defining Relevant Attributes and Indicators for the Evaluation of Food Supply Chains in Spain

  • Gamboa, Gonzalo
  • Kovacic, Zora
  • Masso Tarditti, Marina Di
  • Mingorría, Sara
  • Gomiero, Tiziano
  • Rivera-Ferre, Marta G.
  • Giampietro, Mario
© 2016 by the authors., The wide-ranging literature on food systems provides multiple perspectives and world views. Various stakeholders define food and food systems in non-equivalent ways. The perception of the performance of food systems is determined by these specific perspectives, and a wide variety of policies responding to different aims are proposed and implemented accordingly. This paper sets out to demonstrate that the pre-analytical adoption of different narratives about the food system leads to non-equivalent assessments of the performance of food supply chains. In order to do so, we (i) identify a set of relevant narratives on food supply chains in Spanish and Catalan contexts; (ii) identify the pertinent attributes needed to describe and represent food supply chains within the different perspectives or narratives; and (iii) carry out an integrated assessment of three organic tomato supply chains from the different perspectives. In doing so, the paper proposes an analysis of narratives to enable the analyst to characterize the performance of food supply chains from different perspectives and to identify the expected trade-offs of integrated assessment, associating them with the legitimate-but-contrasting views found among the social actors involved., This work has been carried out within the framework of the EU FP7 research project “Global and Local food chain Assessment: a Multidimensional performance-based approach (GLAMUR)” (KBBE.2012.2.5-03—Grant Agreement No.: 311778). The European Union or the European Union Commission cannot be held responsible for results and opinions quoted in the text. The research of Gonzalo Gamboa is funded by the Spanish National project HAR2013-47182-C02-01 and the Catalan Research group 2014SGR591. Marta G. Rivera-Ferre is funded by the Ramon y Cajal fellowships program, Peer reviewed
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Are local food chains more sustainable than global food chains? Considerations for assessment

  • Brunori, Gianluca
  • Galli, Francesca
  • Barjolle, Dominique
  • van Broekhuizen, Rudolf
  • Colombo, Luca
  • Giampietro, Mario|||0000-0002-5569-7023
  • Kirwan, James
  • Lang, Tim
  • Mathijs, Erik
  • Maye, Damian
  • de Roest, Kees
  • Rougoor, Carin
  • Schwarz, Jana
  • Schmitt, Emilia
  • Smith, Julie
  • Stojanovic, Zaklina
  • Tisenkopfs, Talis
  • Touzard, Jean-Marc
This paper summarizes the main findings of the GLAMUR project which starts with an apparently simple question: is "local" more sustainable than "global"? Sustainability assessment is framed within a post-normal science perspective, advocating the integration of public deliberation and scientific research. The assessment spans 39 local, intermediate and global supply chain case studies across different commodities and countries. Assessment criteria cover environmental, economic, social, health and ethical sustainability dimensions. A closer view of the food System demonstrates a highly dynamic local-global continuum where actors, while adapting to a changing environment, establish multiple relations and animate several chain configurations. The evidence suggests caution when comparing "local" and "global" chains, especially when using the outcomes of the comparison in decision-making. Supply chains are analytical constructs that necessarily-and arbitrarily-are confined by system boundaries, isolating a set of elements from an interconnected whole. Even consolidated approaches, such as Life Cycle Assessment (LCA), assess only a part of sustainability attributes, and the interpretation may be controversial. Many sustainability attributes are not yet measurable and "hard" methodologies need to be complemented by "soft" methodologies which are at least able to identify critical issues and trade-offs. Aware of these limitations, our research shows that comparing local and global chains, with the necessary caution, can help overcome a priori positions that so far have characterized the debate between "localists" and "globalists". At firm level, comparison between "local" and "global" chains could be useful to identify best practices, benchmarks, critical points, and errors to avoid. As sustainability is not a status to achieve, but a never-ending process, comparison and deliberation can be the basis of a "reflexive governance" of food chains.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

The complexity of food systems, defining relevant attributes and indicators for the evaluation of food supply chains in Spain

  • Gamboa, Gonzalo|||0000-0003-0577-2934
  • Kovacic, Zora|||0000-0002-0911-9273
  • Di Masso, Marina|||0000-0002-3756-1333
  • Mingorría, Sara|||0000-0002-6948-3376
  • Gomiero, Tiziano|||0000-0002-4826-5070
  • Rivera-Ferre, Marta G..|||0000-0001-8183-8398
  • Giampietro, Mario|||0000-0002-5569-7023
The wide-ranging literature on food systems provides multiple perspectives and world views. Various stakeholders define food and food systems in non-equivalent ways. The perception of the performance of food systems is determined by these specific perspectives, and a wide variety of policies responding to different aims are proposed and implemented accordingly. This paper sets out to demonstrate that the pre-analytical adoption of different narratives about the food System leads to non-equivalent assessments of the performance of food supply chains. In order to do so, we (i) identify a set of relevant narratives on food supply chains in Spanish and Catalan contexts; (ii) identify the pertinent attributes needed to describe and represent food supply chains within the different perspectives or narratives; and (iii) carry out an integrated assessment of three orgànic tomato supply chains from the different perspectives. In doing so, the paper proposes an analysis of narratives to enable the analyst to characterize the performance of food supply chains from diferent perspectives and to identify the expected trade-offs of integrated assessment, associating them with the legitimate-but-contrasting views found among the social actors involved.