Pasar al contenido principal

Resultados relacionados

Resultados totales (Incluyendo duplicados): 3
Encontrada(s) 1 página(s)

Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Urgency in energy justice, contestation and time in prospective shale extraction in the United States and United Kingdom

  • Partridge, Tristan|||0000-0003-3770-8494
  • Thomas, Merryn|||0000-0001-8529-8245
  • Pidgeon, Nick|||0000-0002-8991-0398
  • Harthorn, Barbara|||0000-0002-2635-4232
Changes to the material and social systems that underpin energy infrastructures are inextricably linked to energy justice concerns, and the timeframes of those changes significantly affect their outcomes. Temporal aspects of energy initiatives and their impacts are thus an important site for examining emergent public views on new energy proposals, inequality, and energy justice. We propose urgency is a particularly rich concept through which to study (i) the justice and socioenvironmental implications of energy systems and technological change and (ii) how people make sense of contested energy timeframes. Here, we present findings from a series of public deliberation workshops held in the United States and United Kingdom to discuss projected impacts of shale oil and gas extraction by hydraulic fracturing. We encountered critical similarities across sites, as in widespread public resistance to issue framings that foreground urgency-based claims in support of their objectives. Participants assessed energy initiatives with particular reference to temporality and urgency, and we argue these views raise justice concerns regarding distribution, the creation of environmental inequalities, public participation, and recognition. We also suggest a focus on urgency provides fresh perspectives on justice issues surrounding the speed and direction of technological development in general and of energy transitions in particular.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Health risk perception and shale development in the UK and US

  • Harthorn, Barbara|||0000-0002-2635-4232
  • Halcomb, Laura|||0000-0002-6717-7148
  • Partridge, Tristan|||0000-0003-3770-8494
  • Thomas, Merryn|||0000-0001-8529-8245
  • Enders, Catherine|||0000-0001-8754-4489
  • Pidgeon, Nick|||0000-0002-8991-0398
In this paper, we examine discourse in public deliberations in pre-development locales in the UK and US about advantages and disadvantages of future shale development ('fracking'). We aimed to understand how people anticipate potential health effects, broadly construed, of environmental toxicity and disturbance in the context of planned, but not yet implemented, energy development. In day-long deliberations with small, diverse groups in two cities in each country (London, Cardiff in the UK; Los Angeles, Santa Barbara in the US), participants discussed impacts on health and well-being using three main rubrics: 'It's money or health', 'Why take chances?' and 'Beyond the tipping point'. Throughout, participants framed health as an intrinsically moral issue, with collective responsibility as a dominant normative frame. We identify the concept of compound risk to underscore effects of multiple risks and hazards on people's sensibilities about anticipated future health and environmental harm. The findings demonstrate how and why diverse publics in pre-impact sites in both countries saw shale extraction as high stakes development that poses significant, often unacceptable, risks to human and environmental health and well-being. Risks extended beyond toxicity to broad threats to health, including, for some, the end of life as we know it on the planet. Overall, participants' discussions of health were more connected to social categories and their underlying moral principles than to technological details. This work contributes evidence of blurred boundaries between environment and health as well as the importance people place on social risks in the context of proposed energy system change.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Disturbed earth, conceptions of the deep underground in shale extraction deliberations in the US and UK

  • Partridge, Tristan|||0000-0003-3770-8494
  • Thomas, Merryn|||0000-0001-8529-8245
  • Pidgeon, Nick|||0000-0002-8991-0398
  • Harthorn, Barbara|||0000-0002-2635-4232
Hydraulic fracturing ('fracking') has enabled the recovery of previously inaccessible resources and rendered new areas of the underground 'productive'. While a number of studies in the US and UK have examined public attitudes toward fracking and its various impacts, how people conceptualise the deep underground itself has received less attention. We argue that views on resources, risk and the deep underground raise important questions about how people perceive the desirability and viability of subterranean interventions. We conducted day-long deliberation workshops (two in each country), facilitating discussions among diverse groups of people on prospective shale extraction in the US and UK. Themes that emerged in these conversations include seeing the Earth as a foundation; natural limits (a greater burden than the subsurface can withstand versus simply overuse of natural resources); and ideas about the fragility, instability and opacity of the deep underground. We find that concerns in both countries were not limited to specific, localised impacts but also addressed ecosystem links between surface and subsurface environments and broader questions about the use, identification and value of natural resources.