Pasar al contenido principal

Resultados relacionados

Resultados totales (Incluyendo duplicados): 5
Encontrada(s) 1 página(s)

Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo de revisión (ReviewArticle)

Progress toward equitably managed protected areas in Aichi target 11, a global survey

  • Zafra-Calvo, Noelia|||0000-0003-3350-0784
  • Garmendía, Eneko|||0000-0001-7029-6343
  • Pascual, Unai|||0000-0002-5696-236X
  • Palomo, Ignacio|||0000-0002-4573-5989
  • Gross-Camp, Nicole
  • Brockington, Dan|||0000-0001-5692-0154
  • Cortes Vazquez, Jose Antonio|||0000-0003-3566-7924
  • Coolsaet, Brendan
  • Burgess, Neil David
The Convention on Biological Diversity Aichi Target 11 requires its 193 signatory parties to incorporate social equity into protected area (PA) management by 2020. However, there is limited evidence of progress toward this commitment. We surveyed PA managers, staff, and community representatives involved in the management of 225 PAs worldwide to gather information against 10 equity criteria, including the distribution of benefits and burdens, recognition of rights, diversity of cultural and knowledge systems, and processes of participation in decision-making. Our results show that more than half of the respondents indicated that there are still significant challenges to be addressed in achieving equitably managed PAs, particularly in ensuring effective participation in decision-making, transparent procedures, access to justice in conflicting situations, and the recognition of the rights and diversity of local people. Our findings are a first and fundamental contribution toward a global assessment of equitablemanagement in PAs to report on Aichi Target 11 in 2020 and help define the next set of PA targets from 2020-2030.
Addi. Archivo Digital para la Docencia y la Investigación
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Can existing assessment tools be used to track equity in protected area management under Aichi Target 11?

  • Moreaux, C.
  • Zafra-Calvo, N.
  • Vansteelant, N. G.
  • Wicander, S.
  • Burgess, N. D.
Aichi Target 11 (AT11) includes the commitment of 194 governments to equitably manage protected areas (PAs) by 2020. Here we evaluate whether existing PA Management Effectiveness (PAME) and social and governance assessment tools can be used to determine if AT11 meets equity goals. We find that PAME assessment conditions are insufficiently inclusive of relevant actors and do not satisfactorily allow for a diversity of perspectives to be expressed and accounted for, both of which are essential for equitable PA management. Furthermore, none of the analysed PAME tools fully cover multidimensional equity and thus they are inadequate for assessing progress towards equitable management in PAs. The available social and governance PA assessment tools stipulate more inclusive and participatory conditions within their guidelines, and the IUCN Governance Guidelines comprehensively capture equity dimensions in PA management, but results are not comparable across sites. We conclude that available assessment tools do not provide a reliable way to track equity in PAs at global scale. The IUCN Governance Guidelines could be adjusted to achieve this goal, providing that the information collected is made globally comparable, while ensuring transparency, accountability and room for contestation, including by communities whose livelihoods are directly implicated. Ultimately, developing and deploying globally comparable measures to evaluate equity is problematic, as the process of gathering comparable data inevitably obscures information that is highly relevant to resolving equity issues at local scales. This challenge must be met, however, if nations are to achieve and report on their success at meeting AT11 by 2020. © 2018 Elsevier Ltd, We thank Jens Friis Lund from the University of Copenhagen for his great support in the writing of this publication. We also thank the following for their assistance in the data collection and analysis: April Eassom, Lauren Coad, Kathryn Knights, Jonas Geldmann, Murielle Misrachi and Naomi Kingston from UNEP-WCMC, PA Solutions, University of Oxford and University of Copenhagen, Phil Franks, Kate Schreckenberg and Dilys Roe from IIED, Marc Hockings, Fiona Leverington from IUCN WCPA/University of Queensland. N.Z-C. and N.B. acknowledge the funding provided by the European Union's Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under the Marie Sklodowska-Curie grant agreement No 659881 to N.Z-C. and the Danish National Research Foundation for funding for the Centre for Macroecology, Evolution and Climate; grant number DNRF96 . We thank Jens Friis Lund from the University of Copenhagen for his great support in the writing of this publication. We also thank the following for their assistance in the data collection and analysis: April Eassom, Lauren Coad, Kathryn Knights, Jonas Geldmann, Murielle Misrachi and Naomi Kingston from UNEP-WCMC, PA Solutions, University of Oxford and University of Copenhagen, Phil Franks, Kate Schreckenberg and Dilys Roe from IIED, Marc Hockings, Fiona Leverington from IUCN WCPA/University of Queensland. N.Z-C. and N.B. acknowledge the funding provided by the European Union's Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under the Marie Sklodowska-Curie grant agreement No 659881 to N.Z-C. and the Danish National Research Foundation for funding for the Centre for Macroecology, Evolution and Climate; grant number DNRF96.
Addi. Archivo Digital para la Docencia y la Investigación
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Progress toward Equitably Managed Protected Areas in Aichi Target 11: A Global Survey

  • Zafra Calvo, Noelia
  • Garmendia Oleaga, Eneko
  • Pascual, Unai
  • Palomo, Ignacio
  • Gross Camp, Nicole
  • Brockington, Daniel
  • Cortés Vázquez, José Antonio
  • Coolsaet, Brendan
  • Burgess, Neil David
The Convention on Biological Diversity Aichi Target 11 requires its 193 signatory parties to incorporate social equity into protected area (PA) management by 2020. However, there is limited evidence of progress toward this commitment. We surveyed PA managers, staff, and community representatives involved in the management of 225 PAs worldwide to gather information against 10 equity criteria, including the distribution of benefits and burdens, recognition of rights, diversity of cultural and knowledge systems, and processes of participation in decision-making. Our results show that more than half of the respondents indicated that there are still significant challenges to be addressed in achieving equitably managed PAs, particularly in ensuring effective participation in decision-making, transparent procedures, access to justice in conflicting situations, and the recognition of the rights and diversity of local people. Our findings are a first and fundamental contribution toward a global assessment of equitable management in PAs to report on Aichi Target 11 in 2020 and help define the next set of PA targets from 2020-2030., We are thankful to Naomi Kingston, Phil Franks and Adrian Martin, who provided insightful comments on the manuscript, and to all respondents to this questionnaire and all organizations that helped us to distribute it, especially to Heather Bingham. This work is funded by the EU Horizon 2020 program under the MSCA grant agreement no. 659881 to NZ-C and supported by a JCFG from the Spanish MEC to IP (IJCI-2016-28475). NZ-C and NDB also acknowledge the DNRF for funding for CMEC, grant no. DNRF96.
Addi. Archivo Digital para la Docencia y la Investigación
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Protected areas to deliver biodiversity need management effectiveness and equity

  • Zafra-Calvo, N.
  • Geldmann, J.
It is widely recognized in science, policy, and practice that protected areas (PAs) that are equitably and effectively managed are essential for halting biodiversity loss. However, our understanding of the relationships between management effectiveness and equity remains weak. Here, we investigate potential synergies and trade-offs between management and equity as well as how they can work together to reduce human pressure in PAs. We then examine the potential of existing global datasets on effectiveness, equity, and human pressure to help inform international policy processes. Our preliminary findings show a negative association between well-defined and sound managed PAs and how satisfied are local people about the decisions related to the management of the PA, reinforcing study of cases that found conflicts in top-down established and managed PAs. We find, however, no association between management effectiveness and social equity with an increasing human pressure. We find only a limited overlap in global databases on management effectiveness, social equity, and human pressure (n = 33). Thus, our results highlight the need to increase the number of PAs with appropriate data about management effectiveness, equity and human pressure to inform policy processes. Without such data, it will be difficult to suggest in honest new quantitative targets for the quality of PAs and Other Effective Area-based Conservation Measures post-2020., We would like to thank Mike Mascia and Neil Burgess for useful discussions in early stages of the manuscript. This work is funded by the European Union Horizon 2020 program under the MSCA grant agreement no. 659881 to NZ-C and no. 676108 to JG; as well as VILLUM FONDEN ( VKR023371 ) to JG.
RUC. Repositorio da Universidade da Coruña
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Progress toward Equitably Managed Protected Areas in Aichi Target 11: A Global Survey

  • Zafra-Calvo, Noelia
  • Garmendia, Eneko
  • Pascual, Unai
  • Palomo, Ignacio
  • Gross-Camp, Nicole
  • Brockington, Dan
  • Cortés Vázquez, José Antonio
  • Coolsaet, Brendan
  • Burgess, Neil David
[Abstract]: The Convention on Biological Diversity Aichi Target 11 requires its 193 signatory parties to incorporate social equity into protected area (PA) management by 2020. However, there is limited evidence of progress toward this commitment. We surveyed PA managers, staff, and community representatives involved in the management of 225 PAs worldwide to gather information against 10 equity criteria, including the distribution of benefits and burdens, recognition of rights, diversity of cultural and knowledge systems, and processes of participation in decision-making. Our results show that more than half of the respondents indicated that there are still significant challenges to be addressed in achieving equitably managed PAs, particularly in ensuring effective participation in decision-making, transparent procedures, access to justice in conflicting situations, and the recognition of the rights and diversity of local people. Our findings are a first and fundamental contribution toward a global assessment of equitable management in PAs to report on Aichi Target 11 in 2020 and help define the next set of PA targets from 2020–2030., Danmark. Danmarks Grundforskningsfond; DNRF96, We are thankful to Naomi Kingston, Phil Franks and Adrian Martin, who provided insightful comments on the manuscript, and to all respondents to this questionnaire and all organizations that helped us to distribute it, especially to Heather Bingham. This work is funded by the EU Horizon 2020 program under the MSCA grant agreement no. 659881 to NZ-C and supported by a JCFG from the Spanish MEC to IP (IJCI-2016–28475). NZ-C and NDB also acknowledge the DNRF for funding for CMEC, grant no. DNRF96.