Pasar al contenido principal

Resultados relacionados

Resultados totales (Incluyendo duplicados): 1
Encontrada(s) 1 página(s)

DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

When to add a new process to a model - and when not: A marine biogeochemical perspective

  • Martin, Adrian P.
  • Bahamondes Dominguez, Ángela
  • Baker, Chelsey A.
  • Baumas, Chloé M. J.
  • Bisson, Kelsey M.
  • Cavan, Emma
  • Freilich, Mara
  • Galbraith, Eric D.
  • Galí, Martí
  • Henson, Stephanie
  • Kvale, Karin F.
  • Lemmen, Carsten
  • Luo, Jessica Y.
  • McMonagle, Helena
  • Melo Viríssimo, Francisco de
  • Möller, Klas Ove
  • Richon, Camile
  • Suresh, Iyyappan
  • Wilson, Jamie D.
  • Woodstock, Matthew S.
  • Yool, Andrew
11 pages, 7 figures, 2 tables.-- Data availability: All data discussed in the manuscript is presented in the manuscript, Models are critical tools for environmental science. They allow us to examine the limits of what we think we know and to project that knowledge into situations for which we have little or no data. They are by definition simplifications of reality. There are therefore inevitably times when it is necessary to consider adding a new process to a model that was previously omitted. Doing so may have consequences. It can increase model complexity, affect the time a model takes to run, impact the match between the model output and observations, and complicate comparison to previous studies using the model. How a decision is made on whether to add a process is no more objective than how a scientist might design a laboratory experiment. To illustrate this, we report on an event where a broad and diverse group of marine biogeochemists were invited to construct flowcharts to support making the decision of when to include a new process in a model. The flowcharts are used to illustrate both the complexity of factors that modellers must consider prior to making a decision on model development and the diversity of perspectives on how that decision should be reached. The purpose of this paper is not to provide a definitive protocol for making that decision. Instead, we argue that it is important to acknowledge that there is no objectively “best” approach and instead we discuss the flowcharts created as a means of encouraging modellers to think through why and how they are doing something. This may also hopefully guide observational scientists to understand why it may not always be appropriate to include a process they are studying in a model, APM acknowledges support from CLASS (NE/R015953/1) and ATLANTIS (NE/Y005589/1) NC projects, NERC CUSTARD (NE/P021247/2) and EU SUMMER (817806) grants. KFK acknowledges support from the New Zealand Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment (MBIE) within the Antarctic Science Platform, grant ANTA1801. KFK also acknowledges support from the New Zealand Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment through the Global Change through Time programme (Strategic Science Investment Fund, contract C05X1702). SAH was supported by a European Research Council Consolidator grant (GOCART, agreement number 724416), co-funding from the European Union, Horizon Europe Funding programme and UK Research and Innovation (OceanICU, agreement number 101083922). MG acknowledges support from the Spanish government through the OPERA project (PID2019-107952GA-I00) and a “Severo Ochoa” Centre of Excellence grant to ICM-CSIC (CEX2019–000928-S). FdMV acknowledges support from an European Research Council Consolidator grant (GOCART, agreement number 724416), a Large Grant from the UK Natural Environment Research Council (COMICS, agreement numbers NE/M020835/1 and NE/M020835/2), a UK Natural Environment Research Council RoSES programme grant (CUSTARD, agreement number NE/P021247/2), and a UK Natural Environment Research Council grant (ODESSS, agreement number NE/V011790/1). C.R. acknowledges support from the Institut des Sciences du Calcul et des Données (ISCD) of Sorbonne University (IDEX SUPER 11-IDEX-0004) through the support of the sponsored project-team FORMAL (From ObseRving to Modelling oceAn Life). H.M. was supported by the National Science Foundation’s Graduate Research Fellowship Program. C.A.B. was supported by the Natural Environment Research Council (NERC) funding for the CLASS project through grant NE/R015953/1. MSW is supported by a Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution Postdoctoral Scholarship. K.O.M and C.L. were supported by the Changing Coasts programme of the Helmholtz Association of German Research Centers; C.L. received support through the MuSSeL grant 03F0862A by the German Ministry of Education and Research (BMBF). JYL acknowledges funding from the NOAA Marine Ecosystems Tipping Points initiative, and we thank Xiao Liu for her internal review of this manuscript, Peer reviewed