DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publicación
Artículo científico (JournalArticle)
How to average logarithmic retrievals?
Calculation of mean trace gas contributions from profiles obtained by retrievals of the logarithm of the abundance rather than retrievals of the abundance itself are prone to biases. By means of a system simulator, biases of linear versus logarithmic averaging were evaluated for both maximum likelihood and maximum a priori retrievals, for various signal to noise ratios and atmospheric variabilities. These biases can easily reach ten percent or more. As a rule of thumb we found for maximum likelihood retrievals that linear averaging better represents the true mean value in cases of large local natural variability and high signal to noise ratios, while for small local natural variability logarithmic averaging often is superior. In the case of maximum a posteriori retrievals, the mean is dominated by the a priori information used in the retrievals and the method of averaging is of minor concern. For larger natural variabilities, the appropriateness of the one or the other method of averaging depends on the particular case because the various biasing mechanisms partly compensate in an unpredictable manner. This complication arises mainly because of the fact that in logarithmic retrievals the weight of the prior information depends on abundance of the gas itself. No simple rule was found on which kind of averaging is superior, and instead of suggesting simple recipes we cannot do much more than to create awareness of the traps related with averaging of mixing ratios obtained from logarithmic retrievals., The authors like to thank the Toronto SPARC office and the International Space Science Institute (ISSI) in Berne for hosting team meetings where the issue of this paper became evident and for providing generous travel support. The authors would also like to thank the team members of the SPARC Data Initiative led by Michaela Hegglin and Susann Tegtmeier for triggering our interest in this interesting problem, and Charles Jackman for kindly providing WACCM model results. BF was supported by by the Spanish MICINN under project AYA2008-03498/ESP and project 200950I081 of CSIC., Peer reviewed, Peer Reviewed
Proyecto:
MICINN AYA2008-03498