Pasar al contenido principal

Resultados relacionados

Resultados totales (Incluyendo duplicados): 4
Encontrada(s) 1 página(s)

Repositori Obert UdL
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Evaluation of bed load transport formulae in a large regulated gravel bed river: The lower Ebro (NE Iberian Peninsula)

  • López Alonso, Raúl
  • Vericat Querol, Damià
  • Batalla, Ramon J.
This paper tests the predictive power of 10 bed load formulae against bed load rates obtained for a large regulated river (River Ebro) the armor layer of which is subject to repeated cycles of break-up and reestablishment. The theoretical principles of two of the 10 formulae explicitly include the effects of river bed armoring. The results obtained showed substantial differences in equation performance but no evident relationship between predictive power and theoretical approach (e.g., discharge, stream power and probability) was found. Overall, the predictive power of the tested formulae was relatively low. The average percentages of predicted bed load discharge that did not exceed factors of 2 (0.5 < r < 2) and 10 (0.1 < r < 10) in relation to the observed discharge were 19% and 57%, respectively (where r is the discrepancy ratio between the predicted and observed values). In particular, the formulae of Yang (1984) and Parker et al. (1982) presented the better levels of agreement with the observed bed load discharges. The bed load rating curve for the lower Ebro showed a similar degree of agreement to the best-performing formulae. However, its predictive power was limited because only flow discharge acts as an independent variable and river bed dynamics, such as armoring cycles, are not contemplated, This research was carried out within the framework of the research projects REN2001-0840-C02-01/HID, CGL2005-06989-C02-02/HID, CGL2006-11679-C02-01/HID, CGL2009-09770 (subprograma BTE), and SCARCE Consolider Ingenio 2010 CSD2009-00065, all funded by the Spanish Ministry of Science and Technology. The second author has benefit from a Juan de la Cierva Fellowship (JCI-2008-2910) funded by the Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation and a Ramon y Cajal Fellowship (RYC-2010-06264) funded by the Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation. Hydrological data were supplied by the Ebro Water Authorities. The Móra d'Ebre Town Council provided logistical support during fieldwork. Albert Rovira assisted during fieldwork and labwork.
Repositori Obert UdL
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Evaluación de fórmulas de transporte de fondo en un río de gravas acorazado

  • López Alonso, Raúl
  • Vericat Querol, Damià
  • Batalla, Ramon J.
El curso bajo del río Ebro (NE península Ibérica) presenta un cauce con lecho de gravas que discurre aguas abajo de un complejo de embalses. En dicho tramo, el lecho experimenta ciclos de rotura y restablecimiento de la capa superficial acorazada como consecuencia tanto de avenidas naturales como de crecidas de mantenimiento. En el citado contexto, el objetivo de la presente investigación fue doble. En primer lugar, la evaluación de la capacidad predictiva del transporte de fondo de tres fórmulas seleccionadas en condiciones de coraza rota o alterada. En segundo lugar, el análisis de la capacidad de dichas fórmulas para predecir el umbral de rotura o alteración de la coraza. Todo ello se fundamentó en la comparación entre predicciones y mediciones de carga de fondo en el tramo de estudio que abarcaron dos años hidrológicos. Conforme a los condicionantes del tramo de estudio, las fórmulas finalmente seleccionadas fueron las ecuaciones desarrolladas por Parker, Klingeman y McLean (1982) (P-K-M), Bathurst (2007) (B) y Recking (2010) (R). De acuerdo con los resultados, se recomiendan las fórmulas P-K-M y R para la predicción de la carga de fondo cuando se rompa o altere la coraza, y se desaconseja la fórmula B por su marcada tendencia a la infrapredicción. En cambio, para la predicción del umbral de rotura o alteración de la coraza se recomiendan las fórmulas B y R. Sin embargo, cabe advertir que en este caso ambas fórmulas tendieron a predecir umbrales bastante inferiores a los medidos., The lower Ebro River (NE Iberian peninsula) has a gravel bed which flows downstream from a reservoir complex. In this section of the river, the armoured surface of the bed undergoes cycles of breaking and reestablishment as a result of natural and control floods. The objective of the present work is two-fold. First, to evaluate the capacity of three formulas to predict bed load transport under conditions in which the armour is broken or disturbed. Second, to analyze the ability of the formulas to predict the breakage or disturbance threshold of the armour. This was all based on a comparison between predictions and measurements of the bed load transport in the study section for two hydrological years. Based on the characteristics of the study section, the formulas which were finally selected were the equations developed by Parker, Klingeman and McLean (1982) (P‑K‑M), Bathurst (2007) (B) and Recking (2010) (R). Given the results, the P‑K‑M and R formulas are recommended to predict bed load transport when there is breakage or disturbance of the amour, and not formula B because of its considerable tendency to underestimate. Formulas B and R are recommended to predict the breakage or disruption threshold of the armour. Nevertheless, it is worth cautioning that in this case both formulas tended to predict thresholds much lower than those measured., La presente investigación fue llevada a término en el marco de los proyectos REN2001-0840-C02-01/HID, CGL2005-06989-C02-02/HID, HID, CGL2009-09770 CGL2006-11679-C02-01/ (subprograma BTE), SCARCE Consolider Ingenio 2010 CSD2009-00065 y CGL2012- 36394, todos ellos concedidos por el Ministerio Ciencia y Tecnología de España. El segundo autor fue beneficiario de Ramón y Cajal (RYC-2010-06264), ambas otorgadas por el Ministerio de Ciencia e Innovación de España.
Recercat. Dipósit de la Recerca de Catalunya
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Evaluation of bed load transport formulae in a large regulated gravel bed river: The lower Ebro (NE Iberian Peninsula)

  • López Alonso, Raúl
  • Vericat Querol, Damià
  • Batalla, Ramon J.
This paper tests the predictive power of 10 bed load formulae against bed load rates obtained for a large regulated river (River Ebro) the armor layer of which is subject to repeated cycles of break-up and reestablishment. The theoretical principles of two of the 10 formulae explicitly include the effects of river bed armoring. The results obtained showed substantial differences in equation performance but no evident relationship between predictive power and theoretical approach (e.g., discharge, stream power and probability) was found. Overall, the predictive power of the tested formulae was relatively low. The average percentages of predicted bed load discharge that did not exceed factors of 2 (0.5 < r < 2) and 10 (0.1 < r < 10) in relation to the observed discharge were 19% and 57%, respectively (where r is the discrepancy ratio between the predicted and observed values). In particular, the formulae of Yang (1984) and Parker et al. (1982) presented the better levels of agreement with the observed bed load discharges. The bed load rating curve for the lower Ebro showed a similar degree of agreement to the best-performing formulae. However, its predictive power was limited because only flow discharge acts as an independent variable and river bed dynamics, such as armoring cycles, are not contemplated, This research was carried out within the framework of the research projects REN2001-0840-C02-01/HID, CGL2005-06989-C02-02/HID, CGL2006-11679-C02-01/HID, CGL2009-09770 (subprograma BTE), and SCARCE Consolider Ingenio 2010 CSD2009-00065, all funded by the Spanish Ministry of Science and Technology. The second author has benefit from a Juan de la Cierva Fellowship (JCI-2008-2910) funded by the Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation and a Ramon y Cajal Fellowship (RYC-2010-06264) funded by the Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation. Hydrological data were supplied by the Ebro Water Authorities. The Móra d'Ebre Town Council provided logistical support during fieldwork. Albert Rovira assisted during fieldwork and labwork.
Recercat. Dipósit de la Recerca de Catalunya
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Evaluación de fórmulas de transporte de fondo en un río de gravas acorazado

  • López Alonso, Raúl
  • Vericat Querol, Damià
  • Batalla, Ramon J.
El curso bajo del río Ebro (NE península Ibérica) presenta un cauce con lecho de gravas que discurre aguas abajo de un complejo de embalses. En dicho tramo, el lecho experimenta ciclos de rotura y restablecimiento de la capa superficial acorazada como consecuencia tanto de avenidas naturales como de crecidas de mantenimiento. En el citado contexto, el objetivo de la presente investigación fue doble. En primer lugar, la evaluación de la capacidad predictiva del transporte de fondo de tres fórmulas seleccionadas en condiciones de coraza rota o alterada. En segundo lugar, el análisis de la capacidad de dichas fórmulas para predecir el umbral de rotura o alteración de la coraza. Todo ello se fundamentó en la comparación entre predicciones y mediciones de carga de fondo en el tramo de estudio que abarcaron dos años hidrológicos. Conforme a los condicionantes del tramo de estudio, las fórmulas finalmente seleccionadas fueron las ecuaciones desarrolladas por Parker, Klingeman y McLean (1982) (P-K-M), Bathurst (2007) (B) y Recking (2010) (R). De acuerdo con los resultados, se recomiendan las fórmulas P-K-M y R para la predicción de la carga de fondo cuando se rompa o altere la coraza, y se desaconseja la fórmula B por su marcada tendencia a la infrapredicción. En cambio, para la predicción del umbral de rotura o alteración de la coraza se recomiendan las fórmulas B y R. Sin embargo, cabe advertir que en este caso ambas fórmulas tendieron a predecir umbrales bastante inferiores a los medidos., The lower Ebro River (NE Iberian peninsula) has a gravel bed which flows downstream from a reservoir complex. In this section of the river, the armoured surface of the bed undergoes cycles of breaking and reestablishment as a result of natural and control floods. The objective of the present work is two-fold. First, to evaluate the capacity of three formulas to predict bed load transport under conditions in which the armour is broken or disturbed. Second, to analyze the ability of the formulas to predict the breakage or disturbance threshold of the armour. This was all based on a comparison between predictions and measurements of the bed load transport in the study section for two hydrological years. Based on the characteristics of the study section, the formulas which were finally selected were the equations developed by Parker, Klingeman and McLean (1982) (P‑K‑M), Bathurst (2007) (B) and Recking (2010) (R). Given the results, the P‑K‑M and R formulas are recommended to predict bed load transport when there is breakage or disturbance of the amour, and not formula B because of its considerable tendency to underestimate. Formulas B and R are recommended to predict the breakage or disruption threshold of the armour. Nevertheless, it is worth cautioning that in this case both formulas tended to predict thresholds much lower than those measured., La presente investigación fue llevada a término en el marco de los proyectos REN2001-0840-C02-01/HID, CGL2005-06989-C02-02/HID, HID, CGL2009-09770 CGL2006-11679-C02-01/ (subprograma BTE), SCARCE Consolider Ingenio 2010 CSD2009-00065 y CGL2012- 36394, todos ellos concedidos por el Ministerio Ciencia y Tecnología de España. El segundo autor fue beneficiario de Ramón y Cajal (RYC-2010-06264), ambas otorgadas por el Ministerio de Ciencia e Innovación de España.