- Rodríguez Martínez, María Sol
[EN] Organisms can respond to changes in environmental conditions by modulating gene expression through the action of epigenetic modifications to maintain cellular homeostasis. This adaptive response can lead to phenotypic plasticity and thus avoid the oxidative stress that environmental changes may induce. In that sense, the evolution of phenotypic traits may be mediated by environmental oxidative stress. Pigmentation phenotypes, in particular, are regulated by genes whose expression may be modulated by environmental conditions, helping organisms to deal with stressful environments. Therefore, understanding
environmental influences on gene expression that may be adaptive is key to obtain a comprehensive view of pigmentation phenotype evolution. Melanin is the most common pigment in animals. The synthesis of melanin is a physiological process intimately related to oxidative stress. Particularly, the synthesis of the yellow-reddish form of the melanin is dependent on the concentration of the main antioxidant in the cell, glutathione. Therefore, the consumption of a valuable antioxidant makes pheomelanin synthesis a constraining process when antioxidants are required for other vital processes. However, in the absence of environmental oxidative stress, pheomelanin synthesis may contribute to cysteine homeostasis, which is toxic if in excess. In that sense, it seems that pheomelanin synthesis is a physiological mechanism intimately related to oxidative stress that may help organisms to adapt to stressful environments. If the genes that regulate pheomelanin synthesis are susceptible to epigenetic modifications, their expression, and that of the associated pigmentation phenotype, may be modified according to environmental conditions and thus drive adaptive responses. Here I used a multidisciplinary and integrative approach to get a better understanding of the evolution of melanin-based traits. In particular, the aim of this thesis is to determine if the synthesis of melanin is susceptible to epigenetic modifications that provide birds phenotypic plasticity to adjust pigmentation phenotypes to the prevailing environmental conditions (Section 1) and thus obtain a comprehensive view of plumage diversity evolution (Section 2). To determine if birds adjust the pigmentation phenotype to the prevailing environmental conditions, experiments in captivity and natural populations under varying environmental conditions were conducted (Section 1). Environmental conditions that induce oxidative stress modulated the expression of genes involved in pheomelanin synthesis (Chapter III) through the action of epigenetic modifications (Chapters I and II), and this avoided the expected oxidative damage. Phenotypes resulting from a genetic predisposition to produce large amounts of pheomelanin creates weak physiological conditions but also more lability in pigment production, making pheomelanin-based coloration
phenotypically plastic (Chapter IV). Thus, it seems that although pheomelanin synthesis induces chronic oxidative damage in birds with plumage profusely covered by this pigment, its plastic regulation under stress can even decrease damage levels. Dealing with stressful environments can then have consequences for both physiology and the pigmentation phenotype. To avoid changes in the pigmentation phenotype, however, the expression of the main gene involved in pheomelanin synthesis can be reversed after stress disappearance (Chapter V)., This makes the regulation of pheomelanin synthesis an adaptive strategy to avoid the evolutionary consequences of external phenotypic changes, as mating preferences can be based on the intensity of pheomelanin-based plumage coloration (Chapter VI). Therefore, pheomelanin synthesis seems to represent an adaptive physiological mechanism that allows animals (birds) to deal with environmental stress and maintain cellular homeostasis, which may or may not result in a modification of the pigmentation phenotype. A comprehensive view of the evolution of melanin-based plumage was obtained by developing phylogenetic analyses (Section 2). At an interspecific level, a negative association between color heterogeneity and the level of expression of different melanin forms seems to provide a physiological solution to obtain diverse plumage coloration (Chapter VII). This is because producing several forms of melanin, which is required
to generate several colors, is more physiologically constraining than producing a single or few melanin forms. However, differences in plumage coloration do not only occur between species of birds, but also through different life stages within the same species. In particular, during juvenile stages, organisms suffer less relative physiological stress than adults and are more prone to experience systemic excess cysteine, as they may have lower requirements for antioxidant protection. Thus, juvenile pheomelanin-based plumage coloration has evolved more frequently in birds with strictly carnivorous diets, which may make them
more susceptible to experience excess cysteine, likely as a detoxifying strategy (Chapter VIII). Pheomelanin pigmentation is not only favored under certain physiological conditions, but also under exposure to certain environmental factors. The exposure to high levels of elemental sulfur in the soil favors the production of pheomelanin in the plumage of different species of birds, likely by an influence of increased intracellular thiols during plumage development, at least in areas with high volcanic activity such as Iceland (Chapter IX). Together, these three final chapters provide novel views of melanin-based pigmentation in a phylogenetic context, thus helping to understand how bird phenotypic diversity has evolved. In sum, this thesis provides an integrative approach to the
evolution of melanin-based traits. In particular, pheomelanin synthesis seems to have evolved as a physiological mechanism that provides phenotypic plasticity to birds and allows them to adjust the pigmentation phenotype to environmental conditions, which can be mediated by epigenetic modifications. This thesis thus contributes to a better understanding of bird phenotypic diversity by adopting a multidisciplinary approach that integrates phylogenetic analyses and
experimental procedures conducted in natural and experimental populations., María Sol Rodríguez Martínez received funding for her pre-doctoral felowship from “Programa de Ayudas de Contratos Predoctorales para la Formación de Doctores 2016” (BES-2016-077112) from the Ministerio de Ciencia e Innovación (MINECO) and co-financed by the European Social Fund (ESF). This thesis was supported by Spain´s Ministry of Science, Innovation and Universities project CGL2015-67796-P.