Pasar al contenido principal

LOS RESULTADOS DE LA INVESTIGACION UNIVERSIDAD-EMPRESA, LOS EFECTOS DESBORDAMIENTO DEL CONOCIMIENTO ACADEMICO Y LA CRISIS ECONOMICA

CSO2016-79045-C2-2-R

•
Nombre agencia financiadora Agencia Estatal de Investigación
Acrónimo agencia financiadora AEI
Programa Programa Estatal de I+D+i Orientado a los Retos de la Sociedad
Convocatoria Proyectos I+D+i Retos de Investigación
Año convocatoria 2016
Plan Estatal 2013-2016 Plan Estatal de Investigación Científica y Técnica y de Innovación
Centro beneficiario AGENCIA ESTATAL CONSEJO SUPERIOR DE INVESTIGACIONES CIENTIFICAS (CSIC)

Resultados relacionados

Resultados totales (Incluyendo duplicados): 15
Encontrada(s) 1 página(s)

RiuNet. Repositorio Institucional de la Universitat Politécnica de Valéncia
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

University-industry scientific production and the Great Recession

  • Azagra-Caro, Joaquín M.|||0000-0002-9598-0376
  • Tijssen, Robert J. W.
  • Tur, Elena M.
  • Yegros Yegros, Alfredo
[EN] R&D spending, be it university or industrial spending, has a positive impact on the scale of scientific production. However, the impact of R&D spending on joint university-industry scientific production, which may vary significantly according to the phase of macroeconomic cycles, is likely to be more complex than the impact on either within-university or within-industry production. We test this assumption in the context of the OECD countries and other economies against the backdrop of the Great Recession (2007-2013). Industry R&D spending dominated university-industry scientific production, but the crisis changed the impact of that spending source, which was negative during the previous expansion and became positive during the subsequent stagnation. The Great Recession had an absolute negative impact on university-industry scientific production, but also a moderating positive impact on industry R&D spending, to the extent that the few countries where this spending increased faster during the Great Recession saw university-industry scientific production rise. Positive effects were more pronounced with regards to 'domestic' university-industry scientific production, where collaborating universities and business companies were located in the same country., Another version of this paper was finalist for the VII UAM-Accenture Chair Award (2015). Joaquin's participation in this research was funded through project AICO/2016/A/107 of the Valencian Regional Government, project CSO2016-79045-C2-2-R of the Spanish Ministry of Economics and Competitiveness and the Salvador de Madariaga Mobility Stay Aid PRX14/00643 of the Spanish Ministry of Education, Culture and Sports, Spain. Elena acknowledges funding from the Broman Foundation. Previous versions of the paper were presented at a 2016 GREThA seminar, the Eurkind GCW 2016 Conference, the STI Conference 2016, and at 2017 CREIP and RIERC seminars, organized by Agusti Segarra-Blasco and Attila Varga, respectively. We thank attendants for their comments.
RiuNet. Repositorio Institucional de la Universitat Politécnica de Valéncia
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Academic artists&apos, engagement and commercialisation

  • Azagra-Caro, Joaquín M.|||0000-0002-9598-0376
  • Planells-Aleixandre, Ester|||0000-0003-0162-3181
  • Benito Amat, Carlos
[EN] Academic artists are researchers who create artistic work. They form part of the cultural life of cities and contribute to welfare not only through research but also through art. They may commercialise their art or use it to engage in scientifc knowledge difusion. We seek to understand the relationship between art, academic commercialisation and engagement, and detect barriers to academic art. The resources needed to develop and difuse art in addition to conducting research may be incompatible with a career focused on science quality or an organisational logic based on teaching and pure basic research. We study the responses to a survey of some 7,000 Spanish academics and compare university research ers to other researchers. More than half of the researchers surveyed create artistic work; however, whereas engagement is the norm rather than the exception, commercialisation is rare. Working in a university and producing good quality science run counter to being an artist. The detrimental efect of science quality on being a commercial or engaged artist turns positive after a certain threshold, which suggests polarisation among academic art ists. Among commercial artists, this polarisation seems to apply specifcally to university researchers. We discuss the implications for the valorisation of art across knowledge trans fer channels and in research evaluations., The Spanish Ministry of Science, Innovation and Universities funded this research through Project CSO2016-79045-C2-2-R of the Spanish National R&D&I Plan. We are grateful to Christopher S. Hayter and Einar Rasmussen for their constructive comments. Our special thanks go to the volunteers who pilot-tested the survey: David Barberá, Àngels Bernabeu, Joaquín Camps, Gérard Carat, María Ángeles Chavarría, Anabel Fernández, Ester Linde, Óscar Llopis, Francisco Rivas and Soberana Sáez. Thanks are due also to the survey respondents and, particularly, those who spontaneously provided supporting statements. Open Access funding provided thanks to the CRUE-CSIC agreement with Springer Nature.
RiuNet. Repositorio Institucional de la Universitat Politécnica de Valéncia
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

The steady effect of knowledge co-creation with universities on business scientific impact throughout the economic cycle

  • Gomez-Aguayo, Ana Maria
  • Benito-Amat, Carlos
  • Azagra-Caro, Joaquín M.|||0000-0002-9598-0376
[EN] Economic ups and downs condition science and innovation. The research strength of business firms and their cooperation with universities are important functions of science systems. The aim of this research is to analyse some of the links between business scientific output co-creation and impact throughout the economic cycle. Economic growth increases the probability of firms fostering both their scientific knowledge co-creation output and their scientific impact, until reaching an inflection point, after which those relationships become negative. Co-creation with universities intensifies the scientific impact of firms¿ output; however, although in theory this effect should vary according to the economic phase, the evidence shows that it remains steady. In this mixed-method study, the theory is grounded through interviews with key university and firm co-authors, and an empirical test is conducted on publications from 15,000 Spanish firms between 2000 and 2016 and their citations ¿ a period which includes the Spanish Great Recession (2008¿2014). The analysis suggests that policies to promote business co-creation output with universities should be more stable throughout the economic cycle: with high growth, governments should maintain the support for co-creation that is typical with low growth; with low growth, governments should not expect co-creation with universities to have an even greater positive effect on firms¿ scientific quality than it already has with high growth., The Spanish Ministry of Science, Innovation and Universities and the Valencian Government funded this research through Projects CSO2016-79045-C2-2-R of the Spanish National R&D&I Plan and AICO\2021\21, respectively. The Spanish Ministry of Economy and Competitiveness funded a pre-doctoral contract, BES-2017-082285, to develop the thesis within the framework of the same project. Open Access funding provided thanks to the CRUE-CSIC agreement with Springer Nature.
RiuNet. Repositorio Institucional de la Universitat Politécnica de Valéncia
Publicación Tesis doctoral (DoctoralThesis)

Dynamics of University-Industry Knowledge Co-creation: Coping with Economic Swings and Academic Managerialism

  • Gómez Aguayo, Ana María
[ES] La creación de conocimiento no solo es el núcleo del crecimiento económico, sino también la base del bienestar social. La cocreación de conocimiento hoy en día depende de una amplia colaboración entre diversos sectores de la sociedad, especialmente en los esfuerzos colaborativos entre universidades e industrias. Investigar la dinámica de la cocreación de conocimiento y su impacto es esencial, especialmente en un contexto donde las empresas están se han convertido en actores clave de la innovación. Este nivel de participación en I+D presenta varios beneficios, pero también plantea dudas sobre el impacto científico y la calidad de la investigación impulsada por empresas. El objetivo principal de esta tesis doctoral es abordar tres preguntas de investigación. Primero, investigar la influencia del crecimiento económico en los resultados de la cocreación de conocimiento científico de las empresas y su impacto científico. Segundo, examinar el papel de diferentes tipos de canales de transferencia de conocimiento, los canales formales, informales y cocreativos, en la relación entre crecimiento económico y su impacto científico. Tercero, explorar el aumento de las motivaciones centradas en el equipo para colaborar con la industria de los cocreadores en el contexto de las prácticas de gestión universitaria y la cultura de evaluación (lo que denominamos gerencialismo de la academia). El contexto del estudio es la cocreación de conocimiento en España. Durante el período de estudio, de 2000 a 2016, varias condiciones institucionales y socioeconómicas han cambiado la dinámica de la cocreación entre universidades e industria. El análisis empírico utiliza tres fuentes de datos. Primero, datos cualitativos de entrevistas semiestructuradas con investigadores universitarios e industriales. Segundo, un conjunto de datos de publicaciones de 15,500 empresas españolas que abarcan desde 2000 hasta 2016. Tercero, una encuesta realizada a los 3,338 autores correspondientes de estas publicaciones. En general, esta tesis explora cómo los aspectos de la cocreación universidad-industria y su impacto responden a los cambios en las condiciones institucionales y socioeconómicas. Primero, se proporciona evidencia empírica para confirmar una teoría del ciclo, que postula que el crecimiento económico mantiene una relación curvilínea con la cocreación de conocimiento científico de las empresas con las universidades y con su impacto científico. Segundo, muestra un efecto negativo de los canales informales sobre el impacto científico de la ciencia colaborativa, y un efecto moderador positivo de los canales informales y cocreativos en la relación entre el crecimiento económico y el impacto científico. Tercero, ilustra el impacto del gerencialismo académico en la evolución de motivaciones individuales hacia motivaciones centradas en el equipo para colaborar con la industria entre los cocreadores universitarios. Estos hallazgos sugieren que la creación de conocimiento y el impacto científico de las empresas españolas son vulnerables a las fluctuaciones económicas, lo que resulta en cierta inestabilidad para cocrear conocimiento científico de alta calidad. Por otro lado, esta tesis destaca la importancia del papel de los programas de colaboración impulsados por el gobierno en el avance de la ciencia empresarial. Al confirmar un efecto positivo de los canales cocreativos, muestra que los proyectos conjuntos financiados con fondos públicos apoyan la ciencia colaborativa y potencian los efectos del crecimiento económico en el impacto científico. Finalmente, al explorar las motivaciones en el contexto del gerencialismo académico, la tesis reflexiona sobre los riesgos de un control y una performatividad excesivos en ciertas condiciones laborales dentro de las universidades, que influyen en las motivaciones de los académicos para colaborar con las industrias., [CA] La creació de coneixement no només és el nucli del creixement econòmic, sinó també la base del benestar social. La cocreació de coneixement avui dia depèn d'una àmplia col·laboració entre diversos sectors de la societat, amb un èmfasi predominant en els esforços col·laboratius entre universitats i indústries. Investigar la dinàmica de la cocreació de coneixement i el seu impacte és essencial, especialment en un context on les corporacions estan progressivament convertint-se en actors clau en el panorama de la innovació, i la seva implicació planteja dubtes sobre l'impacte científic i la qualitat de la investigació impulsada per empreses. Aquest nivell de participació en R+D presenta diversos beneficis, però també planteja dubtes sobre l'impacte científic i la qualitat de la investigació impulsada per empreses. L'objectiu principal d'aquesta tesi doctoral és abordar tres conjunts de preguntes d'investigació. Primer, investigar la influència del creixement econòmic en els resultats de la cocreació de coneixement científic de les empreses i el seu impacte científic. Segon, examinar el paper de diferents tipus de canals de transferència de coneixement en la relació entre creixement econòmic i impacte científic. Es prova el paper dels canals formals, informals i cocreatius en particular. Tercer, explorar l'augment de les motivacions centrades en l'equip per col·laborar amb la indústria dels cocreadors en el context de les pràctiques de gestió universitària i la cultura d'avaluació (el que anomenem managerialisme de l'acadèmia). El context de l'estudi és la cocreació de coneixement a Espanya. Durant el període d'estudi, del 2000 al 2016, diverses condicions institucionals i socioeconòmiques han canviat la dinàmica de la cocreació entre universitats i indústria. L'anàlisi empíric es basa en tres fonts principals de dades. Primer, dades qualitatives d'entrevistes semiestructurades amb investigadors universitaris i industrials. Segon, un conjunt de dades de publicacions de 15.500 empreses espanyoles que abasten des del 2000 fins al 2016. Tercer, una enquesta realitzada als 3.338 autors corresponents d'aquestes publicacions. En general, aquesta tesi compleix el seu objectiu d'explorar com els aspectes de la cocreació universitat-indústria i el seu impacte en la ciència empresarial responen als canvis en les condicions institucionals i socioeconòmiques. Primer, aquesta tesi proporciona evidència empírica per confirmar una teoria del cicle universitat-indústria, que postula que el creixement econòmic manté una relació curvilínia amb la cocreació de coneixement científic de les empreses amb les universitats i el seu impacte científic. Segon, mostra un efecte negatiu dels canals informals sobre l'impacte científic de la ciència col·laborativa, i un efecte moderador positiu dels canals informals i cocreatius en la relació entre creixement econòmic i impacte científic. Tercer, il·lustra l'impacte del managerialisme acadèmic en l'evolució de motivacions autocentrades cap a motivacions centrades en l'equip per col·laborar. Aquests resultats suggereixen que la creació de coneixement i l'impacte científic de les empreses espanyoles són vulnerables a les fluctuacions econòmiques, resultant en una capacitat inestable per cocrear coneixement científic d'alta qualitat. D'altra banda, aquesta tesi destaca la importància del paper dels programes de col·laboració impulsats pel govern en l'avenç de la ciència empresarial. En confirmar un efecte positiu dels canals cocreatius, mostra que els projectes conjunts finançats amb fons públics donen suport a la ciència col·laborativa i potencien els efectes del creixement econòmic en l'impacte científic. Finalment, en explorar les motivacions en el context del managerialisme acadèmic, la tesi reflexiona sobre els riscos d'un control i una performativitat excessius en certes condicions laborals dins les universitats, que influeixen en les motivacions dels acadèmics per col·laborar amb les indústries., [EN] Knowledge creation is not only the core of economic growth, but also the basis of social welfare. Knowledge co-creation nowadays relies on extensive collaboration across diverse sectors of society, with a predominant emphasis on collaborative endeavours between universities and industries. Investigating the dynamics of knowledge co-creation and its impact is essential, particularly within a context where corporations are progressively becoming pivotal players in the innovation landscape and its involvement raises doubts regarding business scientific impact and its quality. This level of involvement in R&D present several benefits, but also raises doubts regarding the scientific impact and quality of business-driven research. The primary objective of this doctoral thesis is to address three sets of research questions. First, to investigate the influence economic growth on firms' scientific knowledge co-creation outputs and its scientific impact. Second, to examine the role of different types of knowledge transfer channels in the relationship of economic growth and scientific impact. The role of formal channels, informal channels, and cocreative channels in particular, is tested. Third, to explore the rise of team-centred motivations to collaborate with industry of co-creators in the context of university management practices, and assessment culture (what we denominate as managerialism of academia). The context of the study is Spanish co-creation of knowledge. Over the period of study from 2000 to 2016, several institutional and socio-economic conditions have changed the dynamics of co-creation between universities and industry. The empirical analysis relies on three main data sources. First, qualitative data from semi-structured interviews with university and industry researchers. Second, a dataset of publications from 15,500 Spanish firms spanning 2000 to 2016. Third, a survey conducted to the 3,338 corresponding authors of these publications. In general, this thesis fulfils its objective of exploring how aspects of university-industry co-creation and its impact on business science respond to changes in institutional and socio-economic conditions. First, this thesis provides empirical evidence to confirm a university-industry cycle theory, positing that economic growth maintains a curvilinear relationship with firms' co-creation of scientific knowledge with universities and its scientific impact. Second, it shows a negative effect of informal channels on the scientific impact of collaborative science, and a positive moderating effect of informal and cocreative channels on the relationship between economic growth and scientific impact. Third, it illustrates the impact of academic managerialism on the evolution of self-centred towards team-centred motivations to collaborate with industry among university co-creators. These findings suggest that knowledge creation and the scientific impact of Spanish firms are vulnerable to economic fluctuations, resulting in an unstable capacity to co-create high-quality scientific knowledge. On the other hand, this thesis highlights the importance of the role of government-driven collaboration programmes in advancing business science. By confirming a positive effect of co-creative channels, it shows that informal channels and joint projects financed by public funds support collaborative science and boost the effects of economic growth on scientific impact. Finally, when exploring the motivations within the context of academic managerialism, the thesis reflects on the risks of excessive control and performativity in certain working conditions within universities, which influence academics' motivations to collaborate with industries. The conclusions of this thesis offer valuable insights for policymakers and practitioners aiming to optimize strategies for promoting innovation and scientific impact of collaborative research., This thesis received funding from the Spanish Ministry of Science, Innovation and Universities, through Project CSO2016-79045-C2-2-R of the Spanish National R&D&I Plan. The Spanish Ministry of Economy and Competitiveness funded a pre-doctoral contract, BES-2017-082285, to develop the thesis within the framework of the same project
RiuNet. Repositorio Institucional de la Universitat Politécnica de Valéncia
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

The Positive Effect of Social Support in the Relationship Between Emotion and Motivation of People in Science

  • Tur-Porcar, Ana María
  • Salas-Vallina, Andrés
  • Azagra-Caro, Joaquín M.|||0000-0002-9598-0376
[EN] This study explores the role of social support as a mediator in the relationship between self-emotional appraisal and motivation in people in science. It also examines the moderating role of self-deceptive enhancement in the relationship between self-emotional appraisal and social support. Survey responses from 6,943 people in science in Spain were analyzed (43% women), aged 20-96 (M = 48.8; SD = 9.94). Structural equation modeling was used to examine a moderated mediation model explaining the path between self-emotional appraisal and motivation. The analysis controlled for age, gender and organization type. The results show a positive link between self-emotional appraisal and motivation. Mediation by social support strengthens this link: For self-emotional appraisal to be effective, people in science need to feel others' support when tackling a problem. Moderation by self-deceptive enhancement strengthens the association of self-emotional appraisal with social support: The need to adapt one's self-image to others' expectations activates the pursuit of social support. The implications of self-emotional appraisal and social support for improving motivation are discussed, as is the role of self-deception in social support as perceived by people in science., The Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation funded this research through Project CSO2016-79045-C2-2-R of the Spanish National R & D & I Plan, and PID2022-141605NA-I00 funded by MCIN/AEI/10.13039/501100011033, ERDF, EU. The Valencian Government funded this research through Project AICO/2021/021 and Project CIAICO/2022/196.
RiuNet. Repositorio Institucional de la Universitat Politécnica de Valéncia
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Personality and emotional intelligence of researchers: The importance of affects

  • Hernando-Jorge, Laura
  • Fernández-Mesa, Anabel
  • Tur-Porcar, Ana M.
  • Azagra-Caro, Joaquín M.|||0000-0002-9598-0376
[EN] Researchers, who play a crucial role in knowledge production, deal with various emotions in their challenging work environment. Their personality might affect how well they manage their emotions, but their moods could help counteract these effects. This study aims to investigate whether researchers' moods influence the connection between their personality and emotional intelligence. 7,463 Spanish researchers replied to an online survey. Responses analysed through partial least squares structural equation modelling show significant positive relationships between the big five personality traits (openness to experience, conscientiousness, extraversion, agreeableness and emotional stability) and emotional intelligence. In addition, positive affect positively mediates the relationships between each of the personality traits and emotional intelligence, and negative affect mediates the same relationships but negatively. The importance of managing emotional states to regulate emotional experiences in the work of researchers is discussed., The Ministry of Science and Innovation funded this research through Project CSO2016-79045-C2-2-R of the Spanish National R&D&I Plan. Funding is also available from the Conselleria de Innovacion, Universidades, Ciencia y Sociedad Digital, Generalitat Valenciana, AICO/2021/021; and from Ministerio de Ciencia, Innovacion y Universidades, PID2022-137053NB-100. The funders had no role in the study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
RiuNet. Repositorio Institucional de la Universitat Politécnica de Valéncia
Publicación Tesis doctoral (DoctoralThesis)

How do Cooperation and Scientific Research Influence Drug Development? The Case of Cancer Disease

  • Li, Sihan
[ES] Más del 90 por ciento de los ensayos clínicos de medicamentos contra el cáncer fracasan. Por tanto, es necesario mejorar el conocimiento sobre los factores que aumentan el éxito del desarrollo de medicamentos. En esta tesis, se aborda esta cuestión desde la perspectiva de los Estudios de Innovación. Para ello, se revisa sistemáticamente 103 artículos relacionados con ensayos clínicos, publicados en revistas de innovación (1984-2021). Así se logra sintetizar los hallazgos existentes, clasificar los estudios por categorías y proporcionar algunas sugerencias teóricas y metodológicas para trabajos futuros. Se encuentra que las teorías del ciclo de vida del producto y de la innovación del usuario deberían ser aplicadas en la investigación futura para mejorar la compresión sobre el desarrollo de medicamentos. Se recomienda un mayor uso de los análisis causales, de regresión y de metodologías mixtas, especialmente en relación con los temas de la comercialización, la transferencia de conocimiento y los marcos institucionales, así como un mejor uso del aprendizaje automático y los lenguajes de programación por lo que se refiere a las herramientas informáticas de recogida de datos. De acuerdo con las lagunas de investigación identificadas en la revisión de la literatura, se explora el papel de la radicalidad, la formación de redes, la naturaleza básica y el impacto científico de la investigación en el éxito del desarrollo de fármacos a través de ensayos clínicos. Los resultados muestran que un mayor grado de radicalidad es menos susceptible de conducir al éxito. La relación entre densidad de la red y la tasa de éxito sigue una forma de U invertida. En redes de cooperación más densas, las organizaciones radicales tienen más posibilidades de éxito. El desarrollo radical de medicamentos implica que las organizaciones asuman más riesgos, lo que da lugar a más fracasos; sin embargo, una manera efectiva de incrementar la tasa de éxito del desarrollo radical de medicamentos es mediante la promoción de la densidad de las redes de cooperación. La investigación aplicada facilita que las organizaciones se involucren en el desarrollo de medicamentos, y la investigación básica es útil para incrementar la tasa de éxito del desarrollo de medicamentos. No obstante, la investigación aplicada de los cooperantes también incrementa la tasa de éxito a través de los efectos desbordamiento de la red. El impacto científico de la investigación juega un papel positivo tanto en involucrarse en el desarrollo de medicamentos como en conducirlo al éxito, directamente y través de los efectos desbordamiento de la red. Esta tesis proporciona algunas ideas para aumentar la tasa de éxito del desarrollo de medicamentos para organizaciones médicas y formuladores de políticas a través de estrategias de ciencia, cooperación e innovación., [CA] Més del 90 per cent dels assajos clínics de fàrmacs contra el càncer fracassen. Per tant, és necessari millorar el coneixement sobre els factors que augmenten l'èxit del desenvolupament de fàrmacs. En aquesta tesi, s'aborda aquesta qüestió des de la perspectiva dels Estudis d'Innovació. Per a això, es revisa sistemàticament 103 articles relacionats amb assajos clínics, publicats en revistes d'innovació (1984-2021). Així s'aconsegueix sintetitzar les troballes existents, classificar els estudis per categories i proporcionar alguns suggeriments teòrics i metodològics per a treballs futurs. Es troba que les teories del cicle de vida del producte i de la innovació de l'usuari haurien de ser aplicades en la investigació futura per a millorar la compressió sobre el desenvolupament de fàrmacs. Es recomana un major ús de les anàlisis causals, de regressió i de metodologies mixtes, especialment en relació amb els temes de la comercialització, la transferència de coneixement i els marcs institucionals, així com un millor ús de l'aprenentatge automàtic i els llenguatges de programació pel que fa a les eines informàtiques de recollida de dades. D'acord amb les llacunes d'investigació identificades en la revisió de la literatura, s'explora el paper de la radicalitat, la formació de xarxes, la naturalesa bàsica i l'impacte científic de la investigació en l'èxit del desenvolupament de fàrmacs a través d'assajos clínics. Els resultats mostren que un major grau de radicalitat és menys susceptible de conduir a l'èxit. La relació entre densitat de la xarxa i la taxa d'èxit segueix una forma d'U invertida. En xarxes de cooperació més denses, les organitzacions radicals tenen més possibilitats d'èxit. El desenvolupament radical de fàrmacs implica que les organitzacions assumisquen més riscos, la qual cosa dona lloc a més fracassos; no obstant això, una manera efectiva d'incrementar la taxa d'èxit del desenvolupament radical de fàrmacs és mitjançant la promoció de la densitat de les xarxes de cooperació. La investigació aplicada facilita que les organitzacions s'involucren en el desenvolupament de fàrmacs, i la investigació bàsica és útil per a incrementar la taxa d'èxit del desenvolupament de fàrmacs. No obstant això, la investigació aplicada dels cooperants també incrementa la taxa d'èxit a través dels efectes desbordament de la xarxa. L'impacte científic de la investigació juga un paper positiu tant a involucrar-se en el desenvolupament de fàrmacs com a conduir-lo a l'èxit, directament i través dels efectes desbordament de la xarxa. Aquesta tesi proporciona algunes idees per a augmentar la taxa d'èxit del desenvolupament de fàrmacs per a organitzacions mèdiques i formuladors de polítiques a través d'estratègies de ciència, cooperació i innovació., [EN] Over 90% of clinical trials for cancer disease drugs fail. It is therefore necessary to increase understanding about the factors that increase the success of drug development. In the present thesis, this issue is addressed from the perspective of Innovation Studies. To this end, 103 articles related to clinical trials, published in innovation journals (1984-2021), are revised systematically. The existing findings are summarised, the studies are classified into categories and some suggestions for potential theoretical and methodological advances in Innovation Studies are provided. It is found that product life cycle and user innovation theories should be applied in future research to improve understanding about drug development. Further use of causal, regression and mixed-methods analysis is also recommended, especially related to the topics of commercialisation, knowledge transfer and institutional frameworks, along with a better use of machine learning and programming languages with regards to data gathering computer tools. Based on the research gaps identified in the literature review, an exploration is made of the role of radicalness, network formation, and the basicness and scientific impact of research on the success of drug development through clinical trials. The results show that a greater degree of radicalness is less likely to achieve success. The relationship between network density and success rate follows an inverted U-shape. In denser cooperation networks, radical organisations have a greater possibility of achieving success. Radical drug development involves organisations taking more risks, which results in more failures; however, an effective way of increasing the success rate of radical drug development is by promoting cooperation network density. Applied research encourages organisations to engage in drug development, and basic research is useful for increasing the success rate of drug development. Nevertheless, the applied research of cooperators also increases the success rate through network spillovers. The scientific impact of research plays a positive role in both the engagement and success of drug development, directly and through network spillovers. This thesis provides some insights to increase the success rate of drug development for medical organisations and policymakers through science, cooperation and innovation strategies., I want to gratefully acknowledge the support from Spanish Ministry of Science, Innovation and Universities through Project CSO2016-79045-C2-2-R of the Spanish National R&D&I Plan, and Project AICO/2021/021 of the Valencian Government. The Universitat Politècnica de València funded my research through Contratos Pre-Doctorales UPV 2018 and Mobility Grants UPV 2019.
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

University-industry scientific production and the Great Recession

  • Azagra Caro, Joaquín
  • Tijssen, Robert J. W.
  • Tur, Elena M.
  • Yegros Yegros, Alfredo
R&D spending, be it university or industrial spending, has a positive impact on the scale of scientific production. However, the impact of R&D spending on joint university-industry scientific production, which may vary significantly according to the phase of macroeconomic cycles, is likely to be more complex than the impact on either within-university or within-industry production. We test this assumption in the context of the OECD countries and other economies against the backdrop of the Great Recession (2007-2013). Industry R&D spending dominated university-industry scientific production, but the crisis changed the impact of that spending source, which was negative during the previous expansion and became positive during the subsequent stagnation. The Great Recession had an absolute negative impact on university-industry scientific production, but also a moderating positive impact on industry R&D spending, to the extent that the few countries where this spending increased faster during the Great Recession saw university-industry scientific production rise. Positive effects were more pronounced with regards to 'domestic' university-industry scientific production, where collaborating universities and business companies were located in the same country., Joaquín's participation in this research was funded through project AICO/2016/A/107 of the Valencian Regional Government, project CSO2016-79045-C2-2-R of the Spanish Ministry of Economics and Competitiveness and the Salvador de Madariaga Mobility Stay Aid PRX14/00643 of the Spanish Ministry of Education, Culture and Sports, Spain. Elena acknowledges funding from the Broman Foundation.
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publicación Contribución de congreso (ConferenceOutput)

Use me when you need me: firms´ co-creation output with universities and the economic cycle

  • Gómez-Aguayo, Ana M.
  • Azagra Caro, Joaquín
Trabajo presentado en DRUID Academy Conference, celebrado en Odense (Dinamarca) del 16 al 17 de enero de 2020., Background: In this paper, we explore two phenomena involved in the influence of the economic cycle on firms¿ scientific knowledge co-creation output. First, according to our University-Industry (U-I) cycle theory, economic growth will either encourage or discourage firms to co-create with universities. The second covers the scientific impact of U-I co-creation output in the economic cycle. Based on the assumption that collaboration with universities may result in successful knowledge cocreation output, we explore the impact of the economic cycle on U-I scientific knowledge co-creation output and its scientific impact. Our study raises the following hypotheses: (1) Economic growth increases the probability of firms¿ scientific knowledge co-creation output (during crises) until an inflection point after which that relationship becomes negative (during expansions). (2) Economic growth increases the scientific impact of firms¿ output (during crises) until an inflection point after which that relationship becomes negative (during expansions). (3) Collaboration with universities moderates (positively) the scientific impact of firms¿ output throughout the cycle. (4) The probability of U -I co-creation output flattens the curvilinear effect of economic growth on the scientific impact of that output., The Spanish Ministry of Science, Innovation and Universities funded this research through Project CSO2016-79045-C2-2-R of the Spanish National R&D&I Plan.
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publicación Otros (Other)

Public Research Organisations and Public Research Funding

  • Cruz Castro, Laura
  • Sanz Menéndez, Luis
This chapter addresses the relationship between public research organisations (PRO) and R&D public funding. The chapter focuses on the analysis of a diverse set of organisations that carry out R&D without having teaching as part of the core missions, which do not depend on companies or universities, and on which the Government exerts influence or control through various channels., The focus on which relevant dimension of government influence is relevant for categorisation has been changing from the administrative dependence or legal status, to their effective control, funding, or missions. Behind the PRO as a concept new dynamics are identifiable, especially the increasing diversity of sources of funding, the execution of public missions or the provision of public goods., The chapter examines the classifications of PRO, the role of funding in the typologies and the importance of considering the missions for understanding the increasing diversity of PRO. It also presents some plausible connections between different types of research funding and authority relations in different types of PRO., We knowledge funding from the Spanish Funding Agency (AEI) grant (CSO2016-79045-C2-1-R)., No
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Dynamic perspectives on technology transfer: introduction to the special section

  • Barberá Tomás, David
  • Azagra Caro, Joaquín
  • D'Este Cukierman, Pablo
Theoretical frameworks acknowledge the dynamic and evolving nature of technology transfer. However, there is a scarcity of empirical work in the field incorporating a dynamic and longitudinal perspective. Several literature reviews call for technology transfer research agendas to include longitudinal studies. In response to such calls, this special section comprises selected contributions to the 2018 Technology Transfer Society (T2S) Conference which address this gap from different angles. The three qualitative and three quantitative works chosen contain research questions and methodologies related to dynamic aspects of technology transfer. We argue that historical and processual studies offer additional new directions., The Spanish Ministry of Science, Innovation, and Universities funded Joaquín M. Azagra-Caro’s and Pablo D’Este’s contribution to the special section as part of the CSO2016-79045-C2-2-R and the RTI2018-101232-B-100 Projects of the Spanish National R&D&I Plan, respectively.
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

The Positive Effect of Social Support in the Relationship Between Emotion and Motivation of People in Science

  • Tur-Porcar, Ana
  • Salas-Vallina, Andrés
  • Azagra Caro, Joaquín
This study explores the role of social support as a mediator in the relationship between self-emotional appraisal and motivation in people in science. It also examines the moderating role of self-deceptive enhancement in the relationship between self-emotional appraisal and social support. Survey responses from 6,943 people in science in Spain were analyzed (43% women), aged 20–96 (M = 48.8; SD = 9.94). Structural equation modeling was used to examine a moderated mediation model explaining the path between self-emotional appraisal and motivation. The analysis controlled for age, gender and organization type. The results show a positive link between self-emotional appraisal and motivation. Mediation by social support strengthens this link: For self-emotional appraisal to be effective, people in science need to feel others’ support when tackling a problem. Moderation by self-deceptive enhancement strengthens the association of self-emotional appraisal with social support: The need to adapt one’s self-image to others’ expectations activates the pursuit of social support. The implications of self-emotional appraisal and social support for improving motivation are discussed, as is the role of self-deception in social support as perceived by people in science., The Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation funded this research through Project CSO2016-79045-C2-2-R of the Spanish National R&D&I Plan, and PID2022-141605NA-I00 funded by MCIN/AEI/10.13039/501100011033, ERDF, EU. The Valencian Government funded this research through Project AICO/2021/021 and Project CIAICO/2022/196., Peer reviewed
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

The steady effect of knowledge co-creation with universities on business scientific impact throughout the economic cycle

  • Gómez-Aguayo, Ana M.
  • Azagra Caro, Joaquín
  • Benito-Amat, C.
Economic ups and downs condition science and innovation. The research strength of business firms and their cooperation with universities are important functions of science systems. The aim of this research is to analyse some of the links between business scientific output co-creation and impact throughout the economic cycle. Economic growth increases the probability of firms fostering both their scientific knowledge co-creation output and their scientific impact, until reaching an inflection point, after which those relationships become negative. Co-creation with universities intensifies the scientific impact of firms’ output; however, although in theory this effect should vary according to the economic phase, the evidence shows that it remains steady. In this mixed-method study, the theory is grounded through interviews with key university and firm co-authors, and an empirical test is conducted on publications from 15,000 Spanish firms between 2000 and 2016 and their citations—a period which includes the Spanish Great Recession (2008–2014). The analysis suggests that policies to promote business co-creation output with universities should be more stable throughout the economic cycle: with high growth, governments should maintain the support for co-creation that is typical with low growth; with low growth, governments should not expect co-creation with universities to have an even greater positive effect on firms’ scientific quality than it already has with high growth., The Spanish Ministry of Science, Innovation and Universities and the Valencian Government funded this research through Projects CSO2016-79045-C2-2-R of the Spanish National R&D&I Plan and AICO\2021\21, respectively. The Spanish Ministry of Economy and Competitiveness funded a pre-doctoral contract, BES-2017-082285, to develop the thesis within the framework of the same project., Peer reviewed
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Personality and emotional intelligence of researchers: The importance of affects

  • Hernando-Jorge, Laura
  • Fernández-Mesa, Anabel
  • Azagra Caro, Joaquín
© 2024 Hernando-Jorge et al., Researchers, who play a crucial role in knowledge production, deal with various emotions in their challenging work environment. Their personality might affect how well they manage their emotions, but their moods could help counteract these effects. This study aims to investigate whether researchers’ moods influence the connection between their personality and emotional intelligence. 7,463 Spanish researchers replied to an online survey. Responses analysed through partial least squares structural equation modelling show significant positive relationships between the big five personality traits (openness to experience, conscientiousness, extraversion, agreeableness and emotional stability) and emotional intelligence. In addition, positive affect positively mediates the relationships between each of the personality traits and emotional intelligence, and negative affect mediates the same relationships but negatively. The importance of managing emotional states to regulate emotional experiences in the work of researchers is discussed., The Ministry of Science and Innovation funded this research through Project CSO2016-79045-C2-2-R of the Spanish National R&D&I Plan. Funding is also available from the Conselleria de Innovación, Universidades, Ciencia y Sociedad Digital, Generalitat Valenciana, AICO/2021/021; and from Ministerio de Ciencia, Innovación y Universidades, PID2022-137053NB-100. The funders had no role in the study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript., Peer reviewed
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publicación Tesis doctoral (DoctoralThesis)

Dynamics of university-industry knowledge co-creation: Coping with economic swings and academic managerialism

  • Gómez-Aguayo, Ana M.
[EN]: Knowledge creation is not only the core of economic growth, but also the basis of social welfare. Knowledge co-creation nowadays relies on extensive collaboration across diverse sectors of society, with a predominant emphasis on collaborative endeavours between universities and industries. Investigating the dynamics of knowledge co-creation and its impact is essential, particularly within a context where corporations are progressively becoming pivotal players in the innovation landscape and its involvement raises doubts regarding business scientific impact and its quality. This level of involvement in R&D present several benefits, but also raises doubts regarding the scientific impact and quality of business-driven research. The primary objective of this doctoral thesis is to address three sets of research questions. First, to investigate the influence economic growth on firms’ scientific knowledge co-creation outputs and its scientific impact. Second, to examine the role of different types of knowledge transfer channels in the relationship of economic growth and scientific impact. The role of formal channels, informal channels, and cocreative channels in particular, is tested. Third, to explore the rise of team-centred motivations to collaborate with industry of co-creators in the context of university management practices, and assessment culture (what we denominate as managerialism of academia). The context of the study is Spanish co-creation of knowledge. Over the period of study from 2000 to 2016, several institutional and socio-economic conditions have changed the dynamics of co-creation between universities and industry. The empirical analysis relies on three main data sources. First, qualitative data from semi-structured interviews with university and industry researchers. Second, a dataset of publications from 15,500 Spanish firms spanning 2000 to 2016. Third, a survey conducted to the 3,338 corresponding authors of these publications. In general, this thesis fulfils its objective of exploring how aspects of university-industry co-creation and its impact on business science respond to changes in institutional and socio-economic conditions. First, this thesis provides empirical evidence to confirm a university-industry cycle theory, positing that economic growth maintains a curvilinear relationship with firms’ co-creation of scientific knowledge with universities and its scientific impact. Second, it shows a negative effect of informal channels on the scientific impact of collaborative science, and a positive moderating effect of informal and cocreative channels on the relationship between economic growth and scientific impact. Third, it illustrates the impact of academic managerialism on the evolution of self-centred towards team-centred motivations to collaborate with industry among university co-creators. These findings suggest that knowledge creation and the scientific impact of Spanish firms are vulnerable to economic fluctuations, resulting in an unstable capacity to co-create high-quality scientific knowledge. On the other hand, this thesis highlights the importance of the role of government-driven collaboration programmes in advancing business science. By confirming a positive effect of co-creative channels, it shows that informal channels and joint projects financed by public funds support collaborative science and boost the effects of economic growth on scientific impact. Finally, when exploring the motivations within the context of academic managerialism, the thesis reflects on the risks of excessive control and performativity in certain working conditions within universities, which influence academics’ motivations to collaborate with industries. The conclusions of this thesis offer valuable insights for policymakers and practitioners aiming to optimize strategies for promoting innovation and scientific impact of collaborative research., [ES]: La creación de conocimiento no solo es el núcleo del crecimiento económico, sino también la base del bienestar social. La cocreación de conocimiento hoy en día depende de una amplia colaboración entre diversos sectores de la sociedad, especialmente en los esfuerzos colaborativos entre universidades e industrias. Investigar la dinámica de la cocreación de conocimiento y su impacto es esencial, especialmente en un contexto donde las empresas están se han convertido en actores clave de la innovación. Este nivel de participación en I+D presenta varios beneficios, pero también plantea dudas sobre el impacto científico y la calidad de la investigación impulsada por empresas. El objetivo principal de esta tesis doctoral es abordar tres preguntas de investigación. Primero, investigar la influencia del crecimiento económico en los resultados de la cocreación de conocimiento científico de las empresas y su impacto científico. Segundo, examinar el papel de diferentes tipos de canales de transferencia de conocimiento, los canales formales, informales y cocreativos, en la relación entre crecimiento económico y su impacto científico. Tercero, explorar el aumento de las motivaciones centradas en el equipo para colaborar con la industria de los cocreadores en el contexto de las prácticas de gestión universitaria y la cultura de evaluación (lo que denominamos gerencialismo de la academia). El contexto del estudio es la cocreación de conocimiento en España. Durante el período de estudio, de 2000 a 2016, varias condiciones institucionales y socioeconómicas han cambiado la dinámica de la cocreación entre universidades e industria. El análisis empírico utiliza tres fuentes de datos. Primero, datos cualitativos de entrevistas semiestructuradas con investigadores universitarios e industriales. Segundo, un conjunto de datos de publicaciones de 15,500 empresas españolas que abarcan desde 2000 hasta 2016. Tercero, una encuesta realizada a los 3,338 autores correspondientes de estas publicaciones. En general, esta tesis explora cómo los aspectos de la cocreación universidad-industria y su impacto responden a los cambios en las condiciones institucionales y socioeconómicas. Primero, se proporciona evidencia empírica para confirmar una teoría del ciclo, que postula que el crecimiento económico mantiene una relación curvilínea con la cocreación de conocimiento científico de las empresas con las universidades y con su impacto científico. Segundo, muestra un efecto negativo de los canales informales sobre el impacto científico de la ciencia colaborativa, y un efecto moderador positivo de los canales informales y cocreativos en la relación entre el crecimiento económico y el impacto científico. Tercero, ilustra el impacto del gerencialismo académico en la evolución de motivaciones individuales hacia motivaciones centradas en el equipo para colaborar con la industria entre los cocreadores universitarios. Estos hallazgos sugieren que la creación de conocimiento y el impacto científico de las empresas españolas son vulnerables a las fluctuaciones económicas, lo que resulta en cierta inestabilidad para cocrear conocimiento científico de alta calidad. Por otro lado, esta tesis destaca la importancia del papel de los programas de colaboración impulsados por el gobierno en el avance de la ciencia empresarial. Al confirmar un efecto positivo de los canales cocreativos, muestra que los proyectos conjuntos financiados con fondos públicos apoyan la ciencia colaborativa y potencian los efectos del crecimiento económico en el impacto científico. Finalmente, al explorar las motivaciones en el contexto del gerencialismo académico, la tesis reflexiona sobre los riesgos de un control y una performatividad excesivos en ciertas condiciones laborales dentro de las universidades, que influyen en las motivaciones de los académicos para colaborar con las industrias., This thesis received funding from the Spanish Ministry of Science, Innovation and Universities, through Project CSO2016-79045-C2-2-R of the Spanish National R&D&I Plan. The Spanish Ministry of Economy and Competitiveness funded a pre-doctoral contract, BES-2017-082285, to develop the thesis within the framework of the same project., Peer reviewed