Pasar al contenido principal

COGNICION, PARTICIPACION Y EMOCION EN LA TOMA DE DECISIONES MULTICRITERIO CON AHP. APLICACION A LA E-COGNOCRACIA

ECO2015-66673-R

•
Nombre agencia financiadora Ministerio de Economía y Competitividad
Acrónimo agencia financiadora MINECO
Programa Programa Estatal de I+D+i Orientado a los Retos de la Sociedad
Convocatoria Proyectos I+D+i Retos de Investigación
Año convocatoria 2015
Plan Estatal 2013-2016 Plan Estatal de Investigación Científica y Técnica y de Innovación
Unidad de gestión Dirección General de Investigación Científica y Técnica
Centro beneficiario UNIVERSIDAD DE ZARAGOZA
Identificador persistente http://dx.doi.org/10.13039/501100003329

Resultados relacionados

Resultados totales (Incluyendo duplicados): 11
Encontrada(s) 1 página(s)

RiuNet. Repositorio Institucional de la Universitat Politécnica de Valéncia
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

A systematic review of application of multi-criteria decision analysis for aging-dam management

  • Zamarrón-Mieza, Iván
  • Moreno-Jiménez, José María
  • Yepes, V.|||0000-0001-5488-6001
[EN] Decisions for aging-dam management requires a transparent process to prevent the dam failure, thus to avoid severe consequences in socio-economic and environmental terms. Multiple criteria analysis arose to model complex problems like this. This paper reviews specific problems, applications and Multi-Criteria Decision Making techniques for dam management. Multi-Attribute Decision Making techniques had a major presence under the single approach, specially the Analytic Hierarchy Process, and its combination with Technique for Order of Preference by Similarity to Ideal Solution was prominent under the hybrid approach; while a high variety of complementary techniques was identified. A growing hybridization and fuzzification are the two most relevant trends observed. The integration of stakeholders within the decision making process and the inclusion of trade-offs and interactions between components within the evaluation model must receive a deeper exploration. Despite the progressive consolidation of Multi-Criteria Decision Making in dam management, further research is required to differentiate between rational and intuitive decision processes. Additionally, the need to address benefits, opportunities, costs and risks related to repair, upgrading or removal measures in aging dams suggests the Analytic Network Process, not yet explored under this approach, as an interesting path worth investigating., This research was funded by the Spanish Ministry of Economy and Competitiveness along with FEDER funding (Projects BIA201456574-R and ECO2015-66673-R).
Zaguán. Repositorio Digital de la Universidad de Zaragoza
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Influencia de la Reputación en la Social Cognocracy Network

  • Turón Lanuza, Alberto
  • Moreno Jiménez, José María
La Social Cognocracy Network (SCN) es una red social de tres capas (informacio´n, discusio´n y decisio´n) que soporta el modelo de democracia cognitiva conocido como e-Cognocracia. El proceso decisional llevado a cabo en la tercera capa consta de dos rondas de votacio´n, en las que se incorporan las preferencias de los decisores, y una de discusio´n en la que los actores implicados en la toma de decisiones incorporan los argumentos que justifican y avalan las diferentes opiniones y decisiones. La red SCN busca y permite la identificacio´n de los li´deres sociales, esto es, aquellas personas que con sus opiniones inciden en la determinacio´n de las estructuras de preferencia de los ciudadanos. Para ello, proporciona medidas de la influencia y la reputacio´n de los actores implicados en las experiencias de e- participacio´n, la confianza entre ellos, y la relevancia e importancia de los mensajes emitidos durante la etapa de discusio´n. A partir de los datos recogidos en una experiencia real sobre movilidad urbana en Zaragoza llevada a cabo con la Social Cognocracy Network, este trabajo analiza la magnitud del cambio en las estructuras de preferencia de los actores y su relacio´n con las opiniones y preferencias manifestadas por aquellos cuya reputacio´n les acredita como li´deres.
Zaguán. Repositorio Digital de la Universidad de Zaragoza
Publicación Contribución de congreso (ConferenceOutput)

Selección Multicriterio de una Estrategia de Movilidad en la Ciudad de Zaragoza

  • Escobar Urmeneta, María Teresa
  • Aguarón Joven, Juan Alfredo
  • Moreno Jiménez, José María
El trabajo presenta la experiencia realizada en abril del año 2015 con los alumnos de Gobierno Electrónico y Decisiones Pu´blicas (4o curso de Economía), relativa a la selección de la mejor estrategia de movilidad en la ciudad de Zaragoza. Las opciones consideradas correspondían a las que los distintos partidos políticos proponían en sus programas electorales para las elecciones municipales que se celebraron en mayo de 2015. Esta experiencia se realizó siguiendo la propuesta de la e-Cognocracia distinguiendo dos rondas de votaciones electrónicas en las que los participantes emitieron sus preferencias sobre las alternativas consideradas. Entre las dos votaciones se implementó un foro en el que los alumnos incorporaron los argumentos que soportaban las distintas posiciones y decisiones. El soporte metodológico utilizado en las rondas de votación fue el Proceso Analítico Jerárquico (AHP). En el trabajo se presentan las prioridades obtenidas para cada individuo en las dos rondas de votación, así como las prioridades grupales calculadas a partir de los juicios y prioridades individuales. Para el cálculo de las prioridades del grupo se han utilizado distintos procedimientos propuestos en la literatura científica para la Toma de Decisiones en Grupo con AHP.
Zaguán. Repositorio Digital de la Universidad de Zaragoza
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

A systematic review of application of multi-criteria decision analysis for aging-dam management

  • Zamarrón-Mieza, Iván
  • Yepes, Víctor
  • Moreno-Jiménez, José María
Decisions for aging-dam management requires a transparent process to prevent the dam failure, thus to avoid severe consequences in socio-economic and environmental terms. Multiple criteria analysis arose to model complex problems like this. This paper reviews specific problems, applications and Multi-Criteria Decision Making techniques for dam management. Multi-Attribute Decision Making techniques had a major presence under the single approach, specially the Analytic Hierarchy Process, and its combination with Technique for Order of Preference by Similarity to Ideal Solution was prominent under the hybrid approach; while a high variety of complementary techniques was identified. A growing hybridization and fuzzification are the two most relevant trends observed. The integration of stakeholders within the decision making process and the inclusion of trade-offs and interactions between components within the evaluation model must receive a deeper exploration. Despite the progressive consolidation of Multi-Criteria Decision Making in dam management, further research is required to differentiate between rational and intuitive decision processes. Additionally, the need to address benefits, opportunities, costs and risks related to repair, upgrading or removal measures in aging dams suggests the Analytic Network Process, not yet explored under this approach, as an interesting path worth investigating.
Zaguán. Repositorio Digital de la Universidad de Zaragoza
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Cognitive Multiple Criteria Decision Making and the Legacy of the Analytic Hierarchy Process

  • Moreno-Jimenez, J.M.
  • Vargas, L.G.
This paper examines the concept, historical evolution and the different schools of thought regarding an aspect of one of the most productive and widely disseminated Operations Research disciplines of our time: Multiple Criteria Decision Making (MCDM). It analyses the development of the scientific method and new tendencies that have emerged in the context of the Knowledge Society. The work also considers future challenges in the field of MCDM, particularly in the context of one of the most popular approaches: the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP). Three fundamental problems envisioned for this school of thought by its creator need to be addressed as future challenges in the MCDM field. This article is dedicated to the memory of Professor Thomas L. Saaty, the originator of AHP and one of the most brilliant and ingenious mathematicians of the last 60 years; he passed away in August 2017 at the age of 91. Este trabajo recoge brevemente el concepto, la evolución histórica y las diferentes escuelas de una de las partes de la Investigación Operativa más fructífera y con mayor difusión de los últimos 45 años: la Decisión Multicriterio. Así mismo, analiza la evolución que el método científico ha seguido en este periodo de tiempo y cuáles son las nuevas orientaciones que presenta en el contexto de la Sociedad del Conocimiento. Finalmente, se incluyen una serie de ideas sobre cuáles pueden ser algunos de los retos futuros en el campo de la toma de decisiones multicriterio (TDMC), en particular en el contexto de una de las aproximaciones más populares: el Proceso Analítico Jerárquico (AHP). Tres problemas fundamentales, ya vislumbrados para esta escuela de pensamiento por su creador, necesitan ser abordados como futuros retos en el campo multicriterio. Este trabajo se ha dedicado a la memoria del profesor Thomas L. Saaty, el autor de AHP y uno de los matemáticos más brillantes e ingeniosos de los últimos 60 años, quien acaba de fallecer en agosto de 2017 a los 91 años de edad.
Zaguán. Repositorio Digital de la Universidad de Zaragoza
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

AHP-group decision making based on consistency

  • Aguarón, J.
  • Escobar, M.T.
  • Moreno-Jiménez, J.M.
  • Turón, A.
The Precise consistency consensus matrix (PCCM) is a consensus matrix for AHP-group decision making in which the value of each entry belongs, simultaneously, to all the individual consistency stability intervals. This new consensus matrix has shown significantly better behaviour with regards to consistency than other group consensus matrices, but it is slightly worse in terms of compatibility, understood as the discrepancy between the individual positions and the collective position that synthesises them. This paper includes an iterative algorithm for improving the compatibility of the PCCM. The sequence followed to modify the judgments of the PCCM is given by the entries that most contribute to the overall compatibility of the group. The procedure is illustrated by means of its application to a real-life situation (a local context) with three decision makers and four alternatives. The paper also offers, for the first time in the scientific literature, a detailed explanation of the process followed to solve the optimisation problem proposed for the consideration of different weights for the decision makers in the calculation of the PCCM.
Zaguán. Repositorio Digital de la Universidad de Zaragoza
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Homogeneous groups of actors in an AHP-local decision making context: A Bayesian analysis

  • Altuzarra, A.
  • Gargallo, P.
  • Moreno-Jiménez, J.M.
  • Salvador, M.
The two procedures traditionally followed for group decision making with the Analytical Hierarchical Process (AHP) are the Aggregation of Individual Judgments (AIJ) and the Aggregation of Individual Priorities (AIP). In both cases, the geometric mean is used to synthesise judgments and individual priorities into a collective position. Unfortunately, positional measures (means) are only representative if dispersion is reduced. It is therefore necessary to develop decision tools that allow: (i) the identification of groups of actors that present homogeneous and differentiated behaviours; and, (ii) the aggregation of the priorities of the near groups to reach collective positions with the greatest possible consensus. Following a Bayesian approach to AHP in a local context (a single criterion), this work proposes a methodology to solve these problems when the number of actors is not high. The method is based on Bayesian comparison and selection of model tools which identify the number and composition of the groups as well as their priorities. This information can be very useful to identify agreement paths among the decision makers that can culminate in a more representative decision-making process. The proposal is illustrated by a real-life case study.
Zaguán. Repositorio Digital de la Universidad de Zaragoza
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Relevant aspects for an EF3-Evaluation of e-cognocracy

  • Moreno-Jiménez, José María
  • Pérez-Espés, Cristina
  • Rivera-Torres, Pilar
The search for an appropriate response to the new challenges and needs posed by the Knowledge Society in the area of public decisions has led to the development of a number of participation models whose value must be assessed and analysed in an integral manner. Using a theoretical model based on structural equations, the present work identifies the relevant factors for an EF3-approach to the democracy model named e-Cognocracy: it comprises a conjoint evaluation of its effectiveness (doing what is right), efficacy (achieving goals) and efficiency (doing things correctly). The model was applied to a real-life e-Cognocracy experience undertaken in the municipality of Cadrete, Zaragoza. The evaluation resulted in the extraction and identification of a series of relationships that allow the advancement of an EF3-participation acceptance model, in line with the TAM model of Davis and the work of Delone and MacLean, which can be used for the integral evaluation of any e-participation model.
Zaguán. Repositorio Digital de la Universidad de Zaragoza
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Identification and selection of ICTs for freight transport in product service supply chain diversification

  • Muerza, V.
  • Larrodé, E.
  • Moreno-Jiménez, J.M.
Purpose - Following the methodology designed for selecting the best industrial and technological diversification strategy, one of the best methods for achieving the long-Term sustainability of companies, the purpose of this paper is to describe its application in the service supply chains (SSCs) sector, specifically, in freight transport in product service supply chains. Design/methodology/approach - The methodology used in diversification processes comprises four stages: Evaluation of the technological diversification suitability; selection of the technological diversification strategy; implementation of the diversification strategy; and evaluation of the process. Findings - The main contributions of the paper are: The proposal of a taxonomy or functional inventory for information and communication technologies (ICTs) in the freight transport industry (FTI); the introduction of a new concept, the technological shrub, a variant of the technological tree that allows interdependencies between the functionality systems; the construction of a technological shrub for ICTs in a standard FTI firm; and the multicriteria selection, based on the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP), of the best diversification strategy that can be incorporated by this standard firm for improving competitiveness. This selection utilises a "bottom-up" approach. Originality/value - The paper deals with the long-Term sustainability of companies by means of technological diversification strategies. Based on the taxonomy constructed for ICTs in the SSC sector and the identification of key technologies for a particular firm, a technological shrub is constructed and a multicriteria procedure is developed in order to select the best diversification strategy.
Zaguán. Repositorio Digital de la Universidad de Zaragoza
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

The economic valuation of social aspects: A multicriteria approach based on input–output models1

  • Sanaú, Jaime
  • Gómez-Bahillo, Carlos
  • Moreno-Jiménez, José María
Decision making on the suitability of public investment projects has traditionally been based on the study of their economic feasibility. Since the end of the 1970s, this has been complemented by a more holistic vision of reality in which social and environmental aspects are explicitly considered alongside economic factors. This paper proposes a new evaluation methodology that allows for the valuation of social and environmental factors in economic terms. The methodology is based on use values (direct, indirect, and potential) and nonuse values (bequest and existence) that are usually studied for an environmental evaluation. The resulting economic value is obtained by the utilization of (a) input–output models to calculate the direct use value in monetary terms and (b) multicriteria techniques (especially the analytic hierarchy process) and comparative models to estimate the remaining use (indirect and potential) and nonuse values (bequest and existence). The methodology is applied to a real-life problem in Aragon.
Zaguán. Repositorio Digital de la Universidad de Zaragoza
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

A decision support system and visualisation tools for AHP-GDM

  • Turón, A.
  • Aguarón, J.
  • Escobar, M.T.
  • Moreno-Jiménez, J.M.
The Precise Consistency Consensus Matrix (PCCM) is a decisional tool for AHP-Group Decision Making (AHP-GDM). Based on the initial pairwise comparison matrices of the individuals, the PCCM constructs a consensus matrix for the group using the concept of consistency. This paper presents a decision support system (PRIOR-PCCM) that facilitates the construction of the PCCM in the context of AHP-GDM, and the calculus of four indicators that allows comparison of the behaviour of group consensus matrices. PRIOR-PCCM incorporates the possibility of considering different weights for the decision makers and includes a module that permits the extension of the initial PCCM which can achieve the minimum number of non-null entries required for deriving priorities or establishing a complete PCCM matrix. It also includes two cardinal indicators for measuring consistency and compatibility and two ordinal indicators for evaluating the number of violations of consistency and priority. The paper introduces some new visualisation tools that improve comprehension of the process followed for obtaining the PCCM matrix and allow the cognitive exploitation of the results. These original contributions are illustrated with a case study.