Pasar al contenido principal

INVESTIGACION EN ETICA DE LA DONACION Y EL TRASPLANTE DE ORGANOS

FFI2017-88913-P

•
Nombre agencia financiadora Agencia Estatal de Investigación
Acrónimo agencia financiadora AEI
Programa Programa Estatal de Fomento de la Investigación Científica y Técnica de Excelencia
Subprograma Subprograma Estatal de Generación de Conocimiento
Convocatoria Proyectos de I+D (Excelencia / Generación de Conocimiento)
Año convocatoria 2017
Plan Estatal 2017-2020 Plan Estatal de Investigación Científica y Técnica y de Innovación
Centro beneficiario UNIVERSIDAD DE GRANADA

Resultados relacionados

Resultados totales (Incluyendo duplicados): 14
Encontrada(s) 1 página(s)

RUA. Repositorio Institucional de la Universidad de Alicante
Publicación Otros (Other)

European and comparative law study regarding family’s legal role in deceased organ procurement, Estudio de derecho comparado europeo acerca del papel de la familia en la obtención de órganos de fallecidos para trasplante

  • Morla González, Marina
  • Moya Guillem, Clara
  • Delgado Rodríguez, Janet
  • Molina Pérez, Alberto
  • Moya Guillem, Clara|||/items/a380e3ef-1802-46eb-a05d-918d42776877
Several European countries are approving legislative reforms moving to a presumed consent system in order to increase organ donation rates. Nevertheless, irrespective of the consent system in force, family’s decisional capacity probably causes a greater impact on such rates. In this contribution we have developed a systematic methodology in order to analyse and compare European organ procurement laws, and we clarify the weight given by each European law to relatives’ decisional capacity over individual’s preferences (expressed or not while alive) regarding the destination of his or her organs after death. In this sense, the results constitute the first comprehensive and comparative legislative mapping on European transplantation laws.
RUA. Repositorio Institucional de la Universidad de Alicante
Publicación Otros (Other)

La confiscación de órganos a la luz del derecho constitucional a la protección de la salud, Organ conscription in the light of the constitutional right to health protection

  • Moya Guillem, Clara
  • Rodríguez-Arias, David
  • Morla González, Marina
  • De Miguel Beriain, Íñigo
  • Molina Pérez, Alberto
  • Ortega-Deballon, Iván
  • Moya Guillem, Clara|||/items/a380e3ef-1802-46eb-a05d-918d42776877
En este trabajo analizamos los argumentos a favor y en contra del que hemos denominado modelo de obtención automática en relación con los órganos de fallecidos. Para ello aportamos datos empíricos que permiten valorar su potencial impacto en las cifras de donación y en la opinión pública. Específicamente, por un lado, examinamos las razones que lo respaldan, haciendo especial referencia a aquellas relativas a la utilidad y la justicia. Por otro lado, estudiamos las manifestaciones que se oponen a este modelo teórico fundadas en la vulneración de intereses pre mortem y post mortem, y en el rechazo que generaría en la población. Por último, a modo de conclusión, subrayamos los aspectos que, a nuestro juicio, deberían regularse exhaustivamente si se implantase. En particular, nos referimos al estatuto jurídico del cuerpo humano, al trato al paciente en la última etapa de su vida, a los incentivos para los profesionales sanitarios y al reconocimiento del derecho a la objeción de conciencia.
RUA. Repositorio Institucional de la Universidad de Alicante
Publicación Otros (Other)

La difusa frontera entre la vida y la muerte. Reflexiones sobre el objeto material de los delitos contra la vida humana independiente, The diffuse border between life and death. Reflections on the material object of crimes against independent human life

  • Moya Guillem, Clara
  • Moya Guillem, Clara|||/items/a380e3ef-1802-46eb-a05d-918d42776877
Este trabajo tiene dos objetivos fundamentales: por un lado, poner de manifiesto los problemas que suscita el concepto legal de muerte que adoptan la doctrina y la jurisprudencia penales; y, por otro lado, explorar la necesidad y la oportunidad de definirlo de un modo distinto. Para ello, en primer lugar, se señalan sucintamente las limitaciones del concepto legal de muerte que han subrayado los expertos. En segundo lugar, se indican sus alternativas y consecuencias jurídico-penales. Finalmente, a fin de solventar estos problemas, se construye una propuesta de lege ferenda y otra, de lege lata sobre el concepto legal de muerte que debería operar como término de la vida humana penalmente amparada.
RUA. Repositorio Institucional de la Universidad de Alicante
Publicación Otros (Other)

Reflexiones sobre la Ley Orgánica 1/2019 en materia de tráfico de órganos. Nuevos horizontes de interpretación, Reflections on Organic Law 1/2019 regarding organ trafficking. New horizons of interpretation

  • Moya Guillem, Clara
  • Moya Guillem, Clara|||/items/a380e3ef-1802-46eb-a05d-918d42776877
La Ley Orgánica 1/2019, de 20 de febrero, ha reformado el delito de tráfico de órganos humanos (art. 156 bis CP). En este trabajo se examinan, con carácter general, los efectos de dicha modificación penal, que fuerza a reinterpretar algunos de los principales elementos de esta figura delictiva. En primer lugar, se estudian las repercusiones relativas al bien jurídico protegido, a las conductas típicas y al objeto material. En segundo lugar, se analizan las circunstancias agravantes que han sido incorporadas al tipo penal. Y, en tercer lugar, a la vista de los solapamientos existentes entre el delito de tráfico de órganos y el de trata de seres humanos con fines de extracción de órganos, se ofrece una propuesta de resolución a los problemas concursales a partir del análisis precedente.
RUA. Repositorio Institucional de la Universidad de Alicante
Publicación Otros (Other)

La trata de seres humanos con fines de extracción de órganos. Análisis criminológico y jurídico-penal

  • Moya Guillem, Clara
  • Moya Guillem, Clara|||/items/a380e3ef-1802-46eb-a05d-918d42776877
A pesar de haber transcurrido ya diez años desde la incorporación del delito de trata de seres humanos con fines de extracción de órganos al Código penal mediante la Ley Orgánica 5/2010, todavía no se ha dictado ninguna sentencia condenatoria en aplicación de esta figura delictiva ni se ha publicado ningún estudio monográfico sobre la misma. En esta obra se evalúan, pues, por primera vez en España las dimensiones reales del fenómeno y las medidas adoptadas para hacerle frente. Al examen del delito ubicado en el artículo 177 bis.1.d) del Código penal se dedica gran parte de la monografía. Pero este no es el único tema abordado. Frente al problema de la trata de seres humanos con fines de extracción de órganos se proponen numerosas estrategias a nivel internacional, que también se analizan con detenimiento por su imprescindible función preventiva. Asimismo, se lleva a cabo un extenso estudio de Derecho comparado que pone de manifiesto las debilidades y las fortalezas de las distintas políticas criminales adoptadas en este ámbito. Y, finalmente, a modo de conclusión, se desarrolla una propuesta de lege ferenda que sugiere alterar la configuración actual de dos figuras delictivas muy relacionadas: la trata de seres humanos (art. 177 bis) y el tráfico de órganos (art. 156 bis).
RUA. Repositorio Institucional de la Universidad de Alicante
Publicación Otros (Other)

Addressing organ shortage: An automatic organ procurement model as a proposal

  • Morla González, Marina
  • Moya Guillem, Clara
  • Rodríguez-Arias, David
  • De Miguel Beriain, Íñigo
  • Molina Pérez, Alberto
  • Ortega-Deballon, Iván
  • Moya Guillem, Clara|||/items/a380e3ef-1802-46eb-a05d-918d42776877
Organ shortage constitutes an unsolved problem for every country that offers transplantation as a therapeutic option. Besides the largely implemented donation model and the eventually implemented market model, a theorized automatic organ procurement model has raised a rich debate in the legal, medical and bioethical community, since it could show a higher potential to solve organ shortage. In this paper, we study the main arguments for and against this model. We show how, in the light of empirical data extracted from countries with a universal health care system, its implementation could lead to a positive impact on organ procurement rates. Three factors are envisioned as fundamental in the comprehension and a possible regulation of the automatic organ procurement model: the lack of recognition of the conscientious objection, the preservation of the right to choose end of life conditions, and the need to avoid incentives for families or healthcare professionals.
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Should the family have a role in deceased organ donation decision-making? A systematic review of public knowledge and attitudes towards organ procurement policies in Europe

  • Molina-Pérez, Alberto
  • Delgado, Janet
  • Frunza, Mihaela
  • Morgan, Myfanwy
  • Randhawa, Gurch
  • Reiger-Vande Wijdeven, Jeantine
  • Schicktanz, Silke
  • Schiks, Eline
  • Wöhlke, Sabine
  • Rodríguez Arias, D.
[Goal] To assess public knowledge and attitudes towards the family’s role in deceased organ donation in Europe., [Methods] A systematic search was conducted in CINHAL, MEDLINE, PAIS Index, Scopus, PsycINFO, and Web of Science on December 15th, 2017. Eligibility criteria were socio-empirical studies conducted in Europe from 2008 to 2017 addressing either knowledge or attitudes by the public towards the consent system, including the involvement of the family in the decision-making process, for post-mortem organ retrieval. Screening and data collection were performed by two or more independent reviewers for each record., [Results] Of the 1482 results, 467 studies were assessed in full-text form, and 33 were included in this synthesis. When the deceased has not expressed any preference, a majority of the public support the family's role as a surrogate decision-maker. When the deceased expressly consented, the respondents' answers depend on whether they see themselves as potential donors or as a deceased's next-of-kin. Answers also depend on the relationship between the deceased and the decision-maker(s) within the family, and on their ethnic or cultural background., [Conclusions] Public views on the authority of the family in organ donation decision-making requiere further research. A common conceptual framework and validated well-designed questionnaires are needed for future studies. The findings should be considered in the development of Government policy and guidance regarding the role of families in deceased organ donation., This work was supported by the Spanish government, [grant number FJCI-2017-34286] and [grant number MINECO FFI2017–88913-P]., Peer reviewed
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Differential impact of opt-in, opt-out policies on deceased organ donation rates: a mixed conceptual and empirical study

  • Molina-Pérez, Alberto
  • Rodríguez Arias, D.
  • Delgado, Janet
[Objectives] To increase postmortem organ donation rates, several countries are adopting an opt-out (presumed consent) policy, meaning that individuals are deemed donors unless they expressly refused so. Although opt-out countries tend to have higher donation rates, there is no conclusive evidence that this is caused by the policy itself. The main objective of this study is to better assess the direct impact of consent policy defaults per se on deceased organ recovery rates when considering the role of the family in the decision-making process. This study does not take into account any indirect effects of defaults, such as potential psychological and behavioural effects on individuals and their relatives., [Design] Based on previous work regarding consent policies, we created a conceptual model of the decision-making process for deceased organ recovery that included any scenario that could be directly influenced by opt-in or opt-out policies. We then applied this model to internationally published data of the consent process to determine how frequently policy defaults could apply., [Main outcome measures] We measure the direct impact that opt-in and opt-out policies have per se on deceased organ recovery., [Results] Our analysis shows that opt-in and opt-out have strictly identical outcomes in eight out of nine situations. They only differ when neither the deceased nor the family have expressed a preference and defaults therefore apply. The direct impact of consent policy defaults is typically circumscribed to a range of 0%–5% of all opportunities for organ recovery. Our study also shows that the intervention of the family improves organ retrieval under opt-in but hinders it under opt-out., [Conclusions] This study may warn policy makers that, by emphasising the need to introduce presumed consent to increase organ recovery rates, they might be overestimating the influence of the default and underestimating the power granted to families., This work was supported by the Spanish government, grant number [FJCI-2017- 34286] and [MINECO FFI2017-88913-P]., Peer reviewed
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Beyond the Altruistic Donor: Embedding Solidarity in Organ Procurement Policies

  • Martínez-López, María Victoria
  • Díaz-Cobacho, Gonzalo
  • Liedo Fernández, Belén
  • Rueda, Jon
  • Molina-Pérez, Alberto
Altruism and solidarity are concepts that are closely related to organ donation for transplantation. On the one hand, they are typically used for encouraging people to donate. On the other hand, they also underpin the regulations in force in each country to different extents. They are often used indistinctly and equivocally, despite the different ethical implications of each concept. This paper aims to clarify to what extent we can speak of altruism and solidarity in the predominant models of organ donation. It also raises the ethical question of whether these categories are adequate as a basis for such models, bearing in mind that organs are a scarce resource and that a shortage of them may mean that fewer lives are saved or improved., This research was funded by INEDyTO [Investigation on the Ethics of Organ Donation and Transplantation], funded by the Spanish Government (MINECO FFI2017-88913-P) and “Bioethics and end-of-life practices” (INEDyTOII) [MINECO PID2020-118729RB]. Belén Liedo receives funding from the Spanish Ministry of Universities [FPU19/06027] and Jon Rueda receives funding from La Caixa Foundation [LCF/BQ/DR20/11790005].
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publicación Otros (Other)

Public perception of organ donation and transplantation policies in Southern Spain

  • Díaz-Cobacho, Gonzalo
  • Cruz-Piqueras, Maite
  • Delgado, Janet
  • Hortal, Joaquín
  • Martínez-López, María Victoria
  • Molina-Pérez, Alberto
  • Padilla-Pozo, Álvaro
  • Ranchal Romero, Julia
  • Rodríguez Arias, D.
[Background] This research explores how public awareness and attitudes towards donation and transplantation policies may contribute to Spain’s success in cadaveric organ donation., [Materials and Methods] A representative sample of 813 people residing in Andalusia (Southern Spain) were surveyed by telephone or via Internet between October and December 2018., [Results] Most participants trust Spain’s donation and transplantation system (93%) and wish to donate their organs after death (76%). Among donors, a majority have expressed their consent (59%), while few non-donors have expressed their refusal (14%). Only a minority is aware of the presumed consent system in force (28%) and feel sufficiently informed regarding the requirements needed to be an organ donor (16%). Participants mainly consider that relatives should represent the deceased’s preferences and be consulted when the deceased’s wishes are unknown, as is the case in Spain., [Conclusions] Public trust in the transplant system may contribute to Spain’s high performance in organ donation. High levels of societal support towards organ donation and transplantation do not correspond in Spain with similar levels of public awareness of donation and transplantation policies., This research was carried out through Project INEDyTO [Research on the Ethics of Organ Donation and Transplantation], funded by the Spanish Government (MINECO FFI2017-88913-P) in collaboration with the Institute for Advanced Social Studies (IESA-CSIC), which sponsored the data collection and participated in the analysis and interpretation of data., No
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Mapping trust relationships in organ donation and transplantation: a conceptual model

  • Martínez-López, María Victoria
  • McLaughlin, Leah
  • Molina-Pérez, Alberto
  • Pabisiak, Krzysztof
  • Primc, Nadia
  • Randhawa, Gurch
  • Rodríguez Arias, D.
  • Suárez, Jorge
  • Wöhlke, Sabine
  • Delgado, Janet
The organ donation and transplantation (ODT) system heavily relies on the willingness of individuals to donate their organs. While it is widely believed that public trust plays a crucial role in shaping donation rates, the empirical support for this assumption remains limited. In order to bridge this knowledge gap, this article takes a foundational approach by elucidating the concept of trust within the context of ODT. By examining the stakeholders involved, identifying influential factors, and mapping the intricate trust relationships among trustors, trustees, and objects of trust, we aim to provide a comprehensive understanding of trust dynamics in ODT. We employ maps and graphs to illustrate the functioning of these trust relationships, enabling a visual representation of the complex interactions within the ODT system. Through this conceptual groundwork, we pave the way for future empirical research to investigate the link between trust and organ donation rates, informed by a clarified understanding of trust in ODT. This study can also provide valuable insights to inform interventions and policies aimed at enhancing organ donation rates., “Research in Ethics of Organ Donation and Transplantation” (INEDyTO) [MINECO FFI201 88913-P]. Open Access funding provided thanks to the CRUE-CSIC agreement with Springer Nature., Peer reviewed
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Inconsistency between the Circulatory and the Brain Criteria of Death in the Uniform Determination of Death Act

  • Molina-Pérez, Alberto
  • Bernat, James
  • Dalle Ave, Anne
The Uniform Determination of Death Act (UDDA) provides that “an individual who has sustained either (1) irreversible cessation of circulatory and respiratory functions or (2) irreversible cessation of all functions of the entire brain, including the brain stem, is dead.” We show that the UDDA contains two conflicting interpretations of the phrase “cessation of functions.” By one interpretation, what matters for the determination of death is the cessation of spontaneous functions only, regardless of their generation by artificial means. By the other, what matters is the cessation of both spontaneous and artificially supported functions. Because each UDDA criterion uses a different interpretation, the law is conceptually inconsistent. A single consistent interpretation would lead to the conclusion that conscious individuals whose respiratory and circulatory functions are artificially supported are actually dead, or that individuals whose brain is entirely and irreversibly destroyed may be alive. We explore solutions to mitigate the inconsistency, Peer reviewed
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Correction to: Mapping trust relationships in organ donation and transplantation: a conceptual model

  • Martínez-López, María Victoria
  • McLaughlin, Leah
  • Molina-Pérez, Alberto
  • Pabisiak, Krzysztof
  • Primc, Nadia
  • Randhawa, Gurch
  • Rodríguez-Arias, David
  • Suárez, Jorge
  • Wöhlke, Sabine
  • Delgado, Janet
The organ donation and transplantation (ODT) system heavily relies on the willingness of individuals to donate their organs. While it is widely believed that public trust plays a crucial role in shaping donation rates, the empirical support for this assumption remains limited. In order to bridge this knowledge gap, this article takes a foundational approach by elucidating the concept of trust within the context of ODT. By examining the stakeholders involved, identifying influential factors, and mapping the intricate trust relationships among trustors, trustees, and objects of trust, we aim to provide a comprehensive understanding of trust dynamics in ODT. We employ maps and graphs to illustrate the functioning of these trust relationships, enabling a visual representation of the complex interactions within the ODT system. Through this conceptual groundwork, we pave the way for future empirical research to investigate the link between trust and organ donation rates, informed by a clarified understanding of trust in ODT. This study can also provide valuable insights to inform interventions and policies aimed at enhancing organ donation rates, This research has been conducted as part of the following projects: “Research in Ethics of Organ Donation and Transplantation” (INEDyTO) [MINECO FFI201 88913-P]; “Epistemological and bioethical analysis of the criteria for determining death” (ABCDm) MICINN: PID2020-119717GA-I00]; “Moral science and institutional design lab” (MSIDLab) [PID2020-119791RAI00].” to “The authors thank Maite Cruz Piqueras, Anja Marie Bornø Jensen, Eva Martín Nieto, Jorge Ruiz Ruiz and Silke Schicktanz for their contribution. MVML also thanks the philosophy doctoral students of the University of Granada for their contribution. This research has been conducted as part of projects: INEDyTO 2 (PID2020-118729RB-I00), ABCDm (PID2020-119717GA-I00), and MSIDLab (PID2020-119791RAI00) funded by MCIN/AEI 10.13039/501100011033.” Also, there is change in the funding section. So, the text will read from “Research in Ethics of Organ Donation and Transplantation” (INEDyTO) [MINECO FFI201 88913-P]. Open Access funding provided thanks to the CRUE-CSIC agreement with Springer Nature.” to “Research in Ethics of Organ Donation and Transplantation” (INEDyTO) [MINECO FFI201 88913-P]. Grant PID2020-118729RB-I00 funded by MCIN/AEI 10.13039/501100011033. Open Access funding provided thanks to the CRUE-CSIC agreement with Springer Nature., Peer reviewed
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Por una salud pública feminista, otra lectura sobre la pandemia, Feminist public health, another view on the pandemic

  • Parra Jounou, Iris|||0000-0003-0172-111X
  • Triviño Caballero, Rosana|||0000-0003-2431-9916
  • Martínez-López, María Victoria|||0000-0002-1101-1413
Las teóricas de las éticas y políticas del cuidado, con sus análisis en clave feminista e interseccional, llevan décadas intentando dejar huella en la práctica clínica y en las estructuras políticas . En ellas, se requieren amplios procesos de humanización de la relación entre profesionales y personas que necesitan su atención, sin dejar de lado las desigualdades por motivos de género, clase social o pertenencia a colectivos vulnerables minoritarios que atraviesan las vivencias de salud y enfermedad en la sociedad. Es evidente que nuestras instituciones deben ser ampliamente repensadas en sus fundamentos; desde las residencias de ancianos a las UCI altamente tecnologizadas; desde la saturación de la atención primaria a la falta de personal especializado. En ámbitos como la enfermería se hace gran hincapié en los modelos basados en la interdependencia y el contexto particular para generar otro marco de asistencia, a la vez que se lucha por las jerarquías e invisibilidades relacionadas con las profesiones altamente feminizadas. No en vano las reflexiones que siguen las firman tres mujeres con perfiles híbridos que hemos dedicado parte de nuestra vida laboral al ámbito de la atención primaria y hospitalaria (tanto en enfermería como en fisioterapia) y, a su vez, a la investigación y la docencia en bioética, filosofía y humanidades. Hemos vivido en nuestras carnes las contradicciones entre una voluntad de servicio y unos ejes de opresión connaturales a las instituciones.