- Bejarano, C.
- Delhom i Latorre, A.
- Jiménez-Cano, Alejandro
- Olmo, Gonzalo J.
- Rubiera-García, D.
Projective invariance is a symmetry of the Palatini version of General Relativity which is not present in the metric formulation. The fact that the Riemann tensor changes nontrivially under projective transformations implies that, unlike in the usual metric approach, in the Palatini formulation this tensor is subject to a gauge freedom, which allows some ambiguities even in its scalar contractions. In this sense, we show that for the Schwarzschild solution there exists a projective gauge in which the (affine) Kretschmann scalar, K≡R R , can be set to vanish everywhere. This puts forward that the divergence of curvature scalars may, in some cases, be avoided by a gauge transformation of the connection., C. Bejarano et al. / Physics Letters B 802 (2020) 1352753which K( ̃)identically vanishes everywhere. From a physical per-spective, given the symmetries of the action (6), the choice of pro-jective gauge should be as irrelevant as the specific set of coordi-nates chosen to write the line element because the action and the field equations of the theory are invariant under arbitrary transfor-mations of both of them. There is nothing in the Palatini version of the theory that singles out the purely metric gauge ξμ=0over the others, as there is no preferred choice of coordinates to write the line element. Therefore, in the Schwarzschild solution of the Palatini formulation of GR, the curvature singularity of Kat r=0is an artifact that can be avoided by changing the projective gauge from ξμ=0to ξμ=(±√3/2M/r2, 0, 0, 0).Related to this, note that curing the Kretschmann by shifting from μαβto ̃μαβinduces divergences in the antisymmetric part of the corresponding Ricci tensor which, as shown above, lies in an unobservable (pure gauge) sector of the theory. The same applies to the associated torsion and non-metricity tensors induced by the projective transformation.One should note, however, that though the affine Kretschmann scalar, RαβμνRαβμν, is not really a scalar under projective trans-formations, there is another quadratic invariant of the affine Rie-mann tensor which is indeed a (diffeomorphism and projective) scalar, namely, P≡RαβμνRμναβ. In the Schwarzschild solution, this quantity becomes P=48M2/r6and diverges as r→0. The fact that the quadratic scalars Kand Pare degenerate in the met-ric formulation of GR but are radically different in the metric-affine formulation, puts into question the physical meaning of curvature invariants as proxies for pathological behaviors. In this sense, it is also worth noting that in nonvacuum space-times other types of projective-invariant curvature divergences associated to the Ricci and (symmetric) Ricci-squared scalars may arise. The insensitiv-ity of such quantities to the projective modes may be related in this case to the fact that minimally-coupled matter fields are pro-jectively invariant as well. This puts forward the different nature of such divergences (as compared to those of the Riemann ten-sor and the scalar K), which claims for a different approach for their regularization and/or interpretation. In the case of electrically charged black holes, for instance, the (symmetric) Ricci-squared scalar RμνRμνdiverges as ∼q4/r8if Maxwell electrodynamics is assumed. This divergence is inherited from the matter stress-energy tensor, which diverges as ∼q2/r4and, therefore, has infi-nite total energy. If nonlinear matter effects are considered, such as in Born-Infeld electrodynamics [19], the stress-energy divergence is weaker, ∼1/r2, which regularizes the total energy of the field but, nonetheless, generates a curvature divergence RμνRμν∼1/r4. Whether or not this curvature divergence should be interpreted as a pathological geometric effect, despite describing a matter sector with bounded total energy, is a question that should be further explored [20].4. Summary and discussionIn this work we have used the classical Schwarzschild solution to illustrate that the metric and the Palatini versions of GR are not geometrically equivalent. While in the metric formulation the Rie-mann tensor can be regarded as an observable associated to the (unique) Levi-Civita connection of the metric, in the Palatini ver-sion its physical status is more subtle because it is not invariant under all the symmetries of the theory. In fact, the existence of an extra symmetry associated to the connection implies that the affine Riemann curvature tensor in the Palatini version is subject to an additional gauge freedom which is not present in the standard metric approach. Although the existence of this symmetry was al-ready well known in the literature [21– 25], to our knowledge its impact on curvature invariants had not been studied yet. The Pala-tini approach has received significant interest in the last decade in relation with extensions of Einstein’s theory of the f(R)or Born-Infeld types (see [26] and [27]for comprehensive reviews), which are particular cases of the so-called Ricci-based gravities [27– 33]. The relation between Palatini and metric formulations of f(R)has also been analyzed in many works [25, 34– 37].Exploiting the projective freedom, we have shown that the problems in the Schwarzschild metric (1)at r=2Mare as empty of physical significance as the blowup of the affine Kretschmann scalar Kat r=0, since both can be avoided by a suitable gauge choice of coordinates or of projective mode, respectively. The pro-jective freedom, however, does not help in removing neither met-ric divergences nor curvature divergences of projective-invariant quantities, such as that in the scalar P≡RαβμνRμναβin the Schwarzschild solution and others in the Ricci tensor in non-vacuum space-times. Indeed, notice that since the metric version of GR can be seen as a (projective) gauge fixed Palatini GR, all quantities invariant under diffeomorphisms and projective trans-formations in the latter will be in one-to-one correspondence with the corresponding invariants of the former. Nonetheless, the possi-bility of gauging away some geometric infinities by considering al-ternative representations of the classical theory with an enhanced symmetry group is an encouraging new result that motivates the exploration of alternative realizations of Einstein’s theory with ex-tra symmetries encoded in fields other than the metric. This sug-gests a novel research avenue that will be further considered in the future. In particular, the potential construction of nontrivial covariant derivatives (other than the purely metric) leading to dif-feomorphism and projective invariant quantities should be further explored.To conclude let us point out that, since projective transforma-tions neither change the form of the metric nor geodesic paths, they cannot cure the singular character of the Schwarzschild so-lution, which is geodesically incomplete. Geodesic completeness is essential to avoid the destruction of information or its creation out of nowhere (by naked singularities) and also for the very existence of observers, who are essential to perform measurements. Our findings about the possibility of removing some curvature diver-gences by means of symmetry transformations further reinforces the idea that the blowup of curvature scalars should not be seen as the reasonfor the geodesic incompleteness on which the sin-gularity theorems are based [38– 43](see [44, 45]for illuminating and in-depth discussions of the notion of a singular space-time). This has been recently verified in some explicit counter-examples in the Palatini formulation of modified theories of gravity [46, 47], in which curvature divergences do not prevent geodesic complete-ness. In light of this, any argument based on the blowup of affine curvature scalars to estimate the scale at which quantum gravity effects are relevant (see our introduction above) might be mislead-ing if the underlying space-time structure is not strictly Rieman-nian. A deeper understanding of this issue could help envisage new strategies in the search of an improved theory of matter and grav-ity free of the pathologies of the metric formulation of classical GR.AcknowledgementsC. B. is funded by the National Scientific and Technical Re-search Council (CONICET). AD and AJC are supported by a PhD contract of the program FPU 2015 (Spanish Ministry of Econ-omy and Competitiveness) with references FPU15/05406 and FPU15/02864, respectively. GJO is funded by the Ramon y Cajal contract RYC-2013-13019 (Spain). DRG is funded by the Atracción de Talento Investigadorprogramme of the Comunidad de Madrid No 4C. Bejarano et al. / Physics Letters B 802 (2020) 1352752018-T1/TIC-10431, and acknowledges support from the Fundação para a Ciência e a Tecnologia (FCT, Portugal) research grants Nos. PTDC/FIS-OUT/29048/2017 and PTDC/FIS-PAR/31938/2017. Thiswork is supported by the Spanish projects FIS2017-84440-C2-1-P, FIS2014-57387-C3-1-P (MINECO/FEDER, EU) and i-LINK1215 (CSIC), the project H2020-MSCA-RISE-2017 Grant FunFiCO-777740, the project SEJI/2017/042 (Generalitat Valenciana), the Consolider Program CPANPHY-1205388, and the Severo Ochoa grant SEV-2014-0398 (Spain). This article is based upon work from COST Action CA15117, supported by COST (European Cooperation in Sci-ence and Technology).