- Perez-Gomez, Beatriz
- Ruiz, Franciso
- Martinez, Inmaculada
- Casals, Maria
- Miranda, Josefa
- Sanchez-Contador, Carmen
- Vidal, Carmen
- Pollan, Marina
- Salas, Dolores
- Llobet Azpitarte, Rafael|||0000-0002-8278-9740
Measurement of mammographic density (MD),
one of the leading risk factors for breast cancer, still relies
on subjective assessment. However, the consistency of MD
measurement in full-digital mammograms has yet to be
evaluated. We studied inter- and intra-rater agreement with
respect to estimation of breast density in full-digital
mammograms, and tested whether any of the women’s
characteristics might have some influence on them. After
an initial training period, three experienced radiologists
estimated MD using Boyd scale in a left breast craniocaudal
mammogram of 1,431 women, recruited at three
Spanish screening centres. A subgroup of 50 randomly
selected images was read twice to estimate short-term
intra-rater agreement. In addition, a reading of 1,428 of the
images, performed 2 years before by one rater, was used to
estimate long-term intra-rater agreement. Pair-wise
weighted kappas with 95% bootstrap confidence intervals
were calculated. Dichotomous variables were defined to
identify mammograms in which any rater disagreed with
other raters or with his/her own assessment, respectively.
The association between disagreement and women’s
characteristics was tested using multivariate mixed logistic
models, including centre as a random-effects term, and
taking into account repeated measures when required. All
quadratic-weighted kappa values for inter- and intra-rater
agreement were excellent (higher than 0.80). None of the
studied women’s features, i.e. body mass index, brassiere
size, menopause, nulliparity, lactation or current hormonal
therapy, was associated with higher risk of inter- or intrarater
disagreement. However, raters differed significantly
more in images that were classified in the higher-density
MD categories, and disagreement in intra-rater assessment
was also lower in low-density mammograms. The reliability
of MD assessment in full-field digital mammograms
is comparable to that for original or digitised images. The
reassuring lack of association between subjects’ MD-related
characteristics and agreement suggests that bias from
this source is unlikely., This study was supported by research grants from Fundacion Gent per Gent (EDEMAC Project); grants FIS PI09/1230 & PI060386 from Spain's Health Research Fund (Fondo de Investigacion Sanitaria); the EPY 1306/06 Collaboration Agreement between Astra-Zeneca and the Carlos III Institute of Health (Instituto de Salud Carlos III); and a grant from the Spanish Federation of Breast Cancer Patients (FECMA). We thank the participants of the study DDM-Spain for their contribution to breast cancer research. We wish also to acknowledge the collaboration from other DDM-Spain members: Pilar Moreo, Pilar Moreno and Soledad Abad (Aragon); Francisca Collado and Magdalena Moya (Baleares); Isabel Gonzalez, Carmen Pedraz and Francisco Casanova (Castilla-Leon); Merce Peris (Cataluna); Carmen Santamarina, Jose Antonio Vazquez Carrete, Montserrat Corujo and Ana Belen Fernandez (Galicia); Nieves Ascunce, Maria Ederra, Milagros Garcia and Ana Barcos (Navarra); Manuela Alcaraz, Jesus Vioque (C. Valenciana); Virginia Lope, Nuria Aragones, Anna Cabanes (Madrid).