Pasar al contenido principal

EVALUACION DEL RIESGO COSTERO BAJO DIFERENTES ESCENARIOS DE CAMBIO CLIMATICO Y DE SUS IMPLICACIONES SOCIECONOMICAS

PID2019-109143RB-I00

•
Nombre agencia financiadora Agencia Estatal de Investigación
Acrónimo agencia financiadora AEI
Programa Programa Estatal de I+D+i Orientado a los Retos de la Sociedad
Convocatoria Proyectos de I+D+i (Generación de Conocimiento y Retos Investigación)
Año convocatoria 2019
Plan Estatal 2017-2020 Plan Estatal de Investigación Científica y Técnica y de Innovación
Centro beneficiario UNIVERSIDAD DE CADIZ

Resultados relacionados

Resultados totales (Incluyendo duplicados): 13
Encontrada(s) 1 página(s)

RiuNet. Repositorio Institucional de la Universitat Politécnica de Valéncia
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Assessing Satellite-Derived Shoreline Detection on a Mesotidal Dissipative Beach

  • Cabezas-Rabadán, Carlos|||0000-0002-0596-4920
  • Palomar-Vázquez, Jesús|||0000-0001-5438-8950
  • Pardo Pascual, Josep Eliseu|||0000-0003-0471-9795
  • Almonacid-Caballer, Jaime
  • Benavente, Javier
  • Castelle, Bruno
  • Del Río, Laura
  • Montes, Juan
[EN] The accuracy and robustness of the shoreline definition from satellite imagery on different coastal types are crucial to adequately characterising beach morphology and dynamics. However, the generic and widespread application of satellite-derived shoreline algorithms is limited by the lack of robust methods and parameter assessments. This work constitutes a quantitative and comprehensive assessment of the satellite-derived waterlines from Sentinel-2 by using the novel SAET tool (Shoreline Analysis and Extraction Tool) on the exposed and mesotidal beach of La Victoria (Cádiz, SW Spain). The diverse parameters available in SAET, such as water indexes, thresholding methods, morphological filters, and kernel sizes, were combined to define water/land interface positions that were compared against coincident video-derived waterlines. Satellite-derived waterline errors are found to be affected by extraction parameters, as well as by the oceanographic and morphological conditions at the time of the image acquisition. The application of a morphological erosion filter on the water mask, which tends to shift the extracted waterline seawards and reduce bias, is the best solution at the dissipative site of La Victoria Beach. Moreover, using a 3 × 3 kernel size consistently shows higher accuracies than a larger kernel. Although there was no parameter combination showing the best skill for all dates, the employment of the Automated Water Extraction Index for images with no shadows (AWEInsh) with a threshold = 0, erosion morphological filter, and 3 × 3 kernel was, overall, the best combination of extraction parameters for this beach (average waterline RMSE of 5.96 m). The combination of the Modified Normalised Difference Water Index (MDNWI) with the Otsu thresholding also led to similar positions of the resulting waterlines and offered good accuracies. In line with other recent research efforts, our work stresses the lack of generic shoreline extraction solutions that can be applied automatically at a global level and the necessity to adapt and validate the extraction methodologies to the different types of coastlines., This research was funded by the projects MONOBESAT (PID2019-111435RB-I00) by the Spanish Ministry of Science, Innovation and Universities; CRISIS (Coastal Risk Evaluation Under Climate Change Scenarios), by the Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation (PID2019-109143RBI00); the grants PAID-06-22 (CCR) by the Vicerrectorado de Investigación de la Universitat Politècnica de València (UPV), and PR-2023-032 (JM) by Universidad de Cádiz (UCA); CCR and JM were funded by MS contracts within the Re-qualification programme by the Spanish Ministry of Universities also financed by the EU¿NextGenerationEU; BC by Agence Nationale de la Recherche (ANR) grant number ANR-21-CE01-0015.
RODIN. Repositorio de Objetos de Docencia e Investigación de la Universidad de Cádiz
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Development of a Bayesian network-based early warning system for storm-driven coastal erosion

  • Garzon, J. L.
  • Ferreira, O.
  • Plomaritis, Theocharis
  • Zózimo, A. C.
  • Fortes, C. J. E. M.
  • Pinheiro, L. V.
Coastal hazards such as flooding and erosion can cause large economic and human losses. Under this threat, early warning systems can be very cost-effective solutions for disaster preparation. The goal of this study was to develop, test, and implement an operational coastal erosion early warning system supported by a particular method of machine learning. Thus, the system combines Bayesian Networks, and state-of-the-art numerical models, such as XBeach and SWAN, to predict storm erosion impacts in urbanized areas. This system was developed in two phases. In the development phase, all information required to apply the machine learning method was generated including the definition of hundreds of oceanic synthetic storms, modeling of the erosion caused by these storms, and characterization of the impact levels according to a newly defined eerosion iimpact index. This adimensional index relates the distance from the edge of the dune/beach scarp to buildings and the height of that scarp. Finally, a Bayesian Network that acted as a surrogate of the previously generated information was built. After the training of the network, the conditional probability tables were created. These tables constituted the ground knowledge to make the predictions in the second phase. This methodology was validated (1) by comparing 6-h predictions obtained with the Bayesian Network and with process-based models, the latest considered as the benchmark, and (2) by assessing the predictive skills of the Bayesian Network through the unbiased iterative k-fold cross-validation procedure. Regarding the first comparison, the analysis considered the entire duration of three large storms whose return periods were 10, 16, and 25 years, and it was observed that the Bayesian Network correctly predicted between 64% and 72% of the impacts during the course of the storms, depending on the area analyzed. Importantly, this method was also able to identify when the hazardous conditions disappeared after predicting potential consequences. Regarding the Regarding the second validation approach, second validation approach, the k-fold cross-validation procedure was applied to the peak of a set of varying storms and it demonstrated that the predictive skills were maximized (63%–72%) when including three nodes as input conditions of the Bayesian Network. In the operational phase, the system was integrated into the architecture of a forecast and early warning system that predicts emergencies in coastal and port zones in Portugal, and the alerts are issued to authorities every day. This study demonstrated that the two-phase approach developed here can provide fast and high-accuracy predictions of erosion impacts. Also, this methodology can be easily implemented on other sandy beaches constituting a powerful tool for disaster management.
RODIN. Repositorio de Objetos de Docencia e Investigación de la Universidad de Cádiz
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Modeling of Coastal Erosion in Exposed and Groin-Protected Steep Beaches

  • Garzon, Juan L.
  • Ferreira, Óscar
  • Plomaritis, Theocharis
Process-based models are suitable tools for reproducing storm-driven erosion. However, their performance has been mainly examined on mild-slope sandy beaches and their use on steep beaches still represents a challenge. Here, open-source process-based model XBeach experiments were combined with topographical measurements collected for two storms (16- and 5-year return period) to obtain a reliable model. The model parameters "facua"(parameterized wave asymmetry and skewness sediment transport component), "bermslope"(upslope transport term for semireflective beaches), and "wetslope"(critical avalanching submerged slope) were utilized for calibration and validation. The 16-year storm simulations on an exposed beach revealed that whether bermslope increased and "facua"must be reduced, and vice versa, to properly simulate erosion. Adding bermslope provided excellent results for these storms when using facua and wetslope values close to the recommended values. In a groin-protected site, XBeach was successfully calibrated and validated for the tested storms using these parameters, although with different values. These experiments demonstrated that the appropriate use of these parameters can satisfactorily simulate morphological changes on steep beaches for different hydrodynamic conditions and coastal settings (exposed and groin protected). © 2022 This work is made available under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International license.
RODIN. Repositorio de Objetos de Docencia e Investigación de la Universidad de Cádiz
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Assessing Satellite-Derived Shoreline Detection on a Mesotidal Dissipative Beach

  • Cabezas Rabadán, Carlos
  • Almonacid Caballer, Jaime
  • Benavente González, Javier
  • Castelle, Bruno
  • Río Rodríguez, Laura del
  • Montes Pérez, Juan Bautista
  • Palomar Vázquez, Jesús
  • Pardo Pascual, Josep E.
The accuracy and robustness of the shoreline definition from satellite imagery on different coastal types are crucial to adequately characterising beach morphology and dynamics. However, the generic and widespread application of satellite-derived shoreline algorithms is limited by the lack of robust methods and parameter assessments. This work constitutes a quantitative and comprehensive assessment of the satellite-derived waterlines from Sentinel-2 by using the novel SAET tool (Shoreline Analysis and Extraction Tool) on the exposed and mesotidal beach of La Victoria (Cádiz, SW Spain). The diverse parameters available in SAET, such as water indexes, thresholding methods, morphological filters, and kernel sizes, were combined to define water/land interface positions that were compared against coincident video-derived waterlines. Satellite-derived waterline errors are found to be affected by extraction parameters, as well as by the oceanographic and morphological conditions at the time of the image acquisition. The application of a morphological erosion filter on the water mask, which tends to shift the extracted waterline seawards and reduce bias, is the best solution at the dissipative site of La Victoria Beach. Moreover, using a 3 × 3 kernel size consistently shows higher accuracies than a larger kernel. Although there was no parameter combination showing the best skill for all dates, the employment of the Automated Water Extraction Index for images with no shadows (AWEInsh) with a threshold = 0, erosion morphological filter, and 3 × 3 kernel was, overall, the best combination of extraction parameters for this beach (average waterline RMSE of 5.96 m). The combination of the Modified Normalised DifferenceWater Index (MDNWI) with the Otsu thresholding also led to similar positions of the resulting waterlines and offered good accuracies. In line with other recent research efforts, our work stresses the lack of generic shoreline extraction solutions that can be applied automatically at a global level and the necessity to adapt and validate the extraction methodologies to the different types of coastlines.
RODIN. Repositorio de Objetos de Docencia e Investigación de la Universidad de Cádiz
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

The Influence of Camera Calibration on Nearshore Bathymetry Estimation from UAV Videos

  • Simarro, Gonzalo
  • Calvete, Daniel
  • Plomaritis, Theocharis
  • Moreno-Noguer, Fransec
  • Giannoukakou-Leontsini, Ifigeneia
  • Montes, Juan
  • Durán, Ruth
Measuring the nearshore bathymetry is critical in coastal management and morphodynamic studies. The recent advent of Unmanned Aerial Vehicles (UAVs), in combination with coastal video monitoring techniques, allows for an alternative and low cost evaluation of the nearshore bathymetry. Camera calibration and stabilization is a critical issue in bathymetry estimation from video systems. This work introduces a new methodology in order to obtain such bathymetries, and it compares the results to echo-sounder ground truth data. The goal is to gain a better understanding on the influence of the camera calibration and stabilization on the inferred bathymetry. The results show how the proposed methodology allows for accurate evaluations of the bathymetry, with overall root mean square errors in the order of 40 cm. It is shown that the intrinsic calibration of the camera, related to the lens distortion, is the most critical aspect. Here, the intrinsic calibration that was obtained directly during the flight yields the best results.
RODIN. Repositorio de Objetos de Docencia e Investigación de la Universidad de Cádiz
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

SCShores: A comprehensive shoreline dataset of Spanish sandy beaches from a citizen-science monitoring programme

  • González Villanueva, Rita
  • Soriano González, Jesús
  • Alejo, Irene
  • Criado Sudau, Francisco
  • Plomaritis, Theocharis
  • Fernàndez Mora, Àngels
  • Benavente González, Javier
  • Río Rodríguez, Laura del
  • Nombela, Miguel Ángel
  • Sánchez García, Elena
Sandy beaches are ever-changing environments, as they experience constant reshaping due to the external forces of tides, waves, and winds. The shoreline position, which marks the boundary between water and sand, holds great significance in the fields of coastal geomorphology, coastal engineering, and coastal management. It is crucial to understand how beaches evolve over time, but high-resolution shoreline datasets are scarce, and establishing monitoring systems can be costly. To address this, we present a new dataset of the shorelines of five Spanish sandy beaches located in contrasting environments that is derived from the CoastSnap citizen-science shoreline monitoring programme. The use of citizen science within environmental projects is increasing, as it allows both community awareness and the collection of large amounts of data that are otherwise difficult to obtain. This dataset includes a total of 1721 individual shorelines composed of 3 m spaced points alongshore, accompanied by additional attributes, such as elevation value and acquisition date, allowing for easy comparisons. Our dataset offers a unique perspective on how citizen science can provide reliable datasets that are useful for management and geomorphological studies.
RODIN. Repositorio de Objetos de Docencia e Investigación de la Universidad de Cádiz
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Video-Monitoring Tools for Assessing Beach Morphodynamics in Tidal Beaches

  • Montes Pérez, Juan Bautista
  • Del Río Rodríguez, Laura
  • Plomaritis, Theocharis
  • Benavente González, Javier
  • Puig Fuentenebro, María
  • Simarro, Gonzalo
Beach behaviour and evolution are controlled by a large number of factors, being susceptible to human-derived pressures and the impacts of climate change. In order to understand beach behaviour at different scales, systematic monitoring programs that assess shoreline and volumetric changes are required. Video-monitoring systems are widely used in this regard, as they are costeffective and acquire data automatically and continuously, even in bad weather conditions. This work presents a methodology to use the basic products of low-cost IP video cameras to identify both the cross-shore and long-shore variability of tidal beaches. Shorelines were automatically obtained, digital elevation models (DEMs) were generated and validated with real data, and the outputs were combined to analyse beach behaviour from a morphodynamic perspective. The proposed methodology was applied to La Victoria Beach (SW Spain) for the analysis of beach variations over a 5-year period. The combination of shoreline position analysis and data from DEMs facilitates understanding and provides a complete overview of beach behaviour, revealing alongshore differences in an apparently homogeneous beach. Furthermore, the methods used allowed us to inter-relate the different processes occurring on the beach, which is difficult to achieve with other types of techniques.
RODIN. Repositorio de Objetos de Docencia e Investigación de la Universidad de Cádiz
Publicación Otros (Other)

Editorial: Coastal environment in a changing world

  • Benavente González, Javier
  • Ruiz de Alegría-Arzaburu, A.
  • Plomaritis, Theocharis
  • Sedrati, M.
  • Ariffin, E.H.
The aim of this Research Topic was to provide insights into some of the most prevalent processes that currently endanger our coasts and to assist in improving coastal management in the future. To achieve a comprehensive understanding of these problems, it is essential to conduct sustainable coastal monitoring activities and research that provide continuous information. This Research Topic consists of 10 papers that underscore the importance of addressing multiscale issues using a multidisciplinary approach that highlights crucial physical and environmental factors, 3 páginas
RODIN. Repositorio de Objetos de Docencia e Investigación de la Universidad de Cádiz
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

High-Resolution Interannual Evolution of the Dune Toe at a Mesotidal Barrier (Camposoto Beach, SW Spain)

  • Montes, Cristina
  • Benavente González, Javier
  • Puig Fuentenebro, María
  • Montes Pérez, Juan Bautista
  • Talavera Madrigal, Lara
  • Plomaritis, Theocharis
Over recent years, processes related to marine storms, sediment shortages and human intervention have caused the global retreat of many coastal systems and the degradation of their dunes. In this context, changes in the dune toe are commonly used as a proxy to study the interannual shoreline evolution, and it is usually analyzed using orthophotography, while high temporal- and spatial-scale resolution studies of dune toe evolution are not frequent. In this work, a quasi-monthly study of dune toe data was carried out between 2008 and 2018. These data, taken from the RTK-DGPS and UAS systems, were subjected to shoreline analysis, and they showed an average regression rate of −2.30 m/year, a higher value than the one registered until 2008 (1 m/year). This suggests an acceleration in the erosion suffered within the system, which was revealed to be more intense in the northern sector of the study area. Dune toe variability increased over the years, probably due to the presence of washover fans breaking the foredune that were reactivated and expanded during storm events. The ephemeral progradation of the dune toe was also noted, which could be explained with reference to wind events and/or beach nourishment that had been carried out over the studied period. From the analysis of the dune toe elevation, a decrease in this variable was obtained, especially in the areas affected due to washover fans. This finding is supported by the significant correlation of the dune toe elevation and erosion trend, suggesting that the areas where the dune toe was lower are prone to suffering a greater retreat. This correlation provides insight into the future evolution of the barrier, suggesting a state of degradation and a transition to a lower-resilience state.
Investigo. Repositorio Institucional de la Universidade de Vigo
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Morphodynamics and management challenges for beaches in modified estuaries and bays

  • Vila Concejo, Ana
  • Fellowes, Thomas E.
  • Gallop, Shari
  • Alejo Flores, Irene
  • Angnuureng, Donatus B.
  • Benavente, Javier
  • Bosma, Jorn W.
  • Brempong, Emmanuel K.
  • Dissanayake, Pushpa
  • Gazi, Md Yousuf
  • González Villanueva, Rita
  • Guimarães, Ricardo
  • Kennedy, David M.
  • Largier, John L.
  • van der Lugt, Marlies A.
  • Montes, Juan
  • Orescanin, Mara
  • Pattiaratchi, Charitha B.
  • Cajueiro Carneiro Pereira, Luci
  • Marinho da Costa Pereira, Remo Luan
  • Price, Timothy
  • Rahbani, Maryam
  • del Río, Laura
  • Rosenthal, Michael
  • de Schipper, Matthieu
  • Ton, Anne M.
  • WinklerPrins, Lukas
  • Chen, Zhongyuan
There is a relative lack of research, targeted models and tools to manage beaches in estuaries and bays (BEBs). Many estuaries and bays have been highly modified and urbanised, for example port developments and coastal revetments. This paper outlines the complications and opportunities for conserving and managing BEBs in modified estuaries. To do this, we focus on eight diverse case studies from North and South America, Asia, Europe, Africa and Australia combined with the broader global literature. Our key findings are as follows: (1) BEBs are diverse and exist under a great variety of tide and wave conditions that differentiate them from open-coast beaches; (2) BEBs often lack statutory protection and many have already been sacrificed to development; (3) BEBs lack specific management tools and are often managed using tools developed for open-coast beaches; and (4) BEBs have the potential to become important in “nature-based” management solutions. We set the future research agenda for BEBs, which should include broadening research to include greater diversity of BEBs than in the past, standardising monitoring techniques, including the development of global databases using citizen science and developing specific management tools for BEBs. We must recognise BEBs as unique coastal features and develop the required fundamental knowledge and tools to effectively manage them, so they can continue providing their unique ecosystem services., Ministerio de Economía y Competitividad | Ref. CGL2014–53153-R, Agencia Estatal de Investigación | Ref. PID2019-109143RB-I00, Xunta de Galicia
Investigo. Repositorio Institucional de la Universidade de Vigo
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

SCShores: a comprehensive shoreline dataset of Spanish sandy beaches from a citizen-science monitoring programme

  • González Villanueva, Rita
  • Soriano González, Jesús
  • Alejo Flores, Irene
  • Criado Sudau, Francisco
  • Plomaritis, Theocharis
  • Fernàndez Mora, Àngels
  • Benavente, Javier
  • Del Río, Laura
  • Nombela Castaño, Miguel Ángel
  • Sánchez García, Elena
Sandy beaches are ever-changing environments, as they experience constant reshaping due to the external forces of tides, waves, and winds. The shoreline position, which marks the boundary between water and sand, holds great significance in the fields of coastal geomorphology, coastal engineering, and coastal management. It is crucial to understand how beaches evolve over time, but high-resolution shoreline datasets are scarce, and establishing monitoring systems can be costly. To address this, we present a new dataset of the shorelines of five Spanish sandy beaches located in contrasting environments that is derived from the CoastSnap citizen-science shoreline monitoring programme. The use of citizen science within environmental projects is increasing, as it allows both community awareness and the collection of large amounts of data that are otherwise difficult to obtain. This dataset includes a total of 1721 individual shorelines composed of 3 m spaced points alongshore, accompanied by additional attributes, such as elevation value and acquisition date, allowing for easy comparisons. Our dataset offers a unique perspective on how citizen science can provide reliable datasets that are useful for management and geomorphological studies. The shoreline dataset, along with relevant metadata, is available at https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.8056415, Agencia Estatal de Investigación | Ref. PID2019-109143RB-I00, Fundación Española para la Ciencia y la Tecnología | Ref. FCT-20-15835, Xunta de Galicia, Universidad de Cádiz | Ref. PR2019-022
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

The Influence of Camera Calibration on Nearshore Bathymetry Estimation from UAV Videos

  • Simarro, Gonzalo
  • Calvete, Daniel
  • Plomaritis, Theocharis A.
  • Moreno-Noguer, Francesc
  • Giannoukakou-Leontsini, Ifigeneia
  • Montes, Juan
  • Durán, Ruth
20 pages, 15 figures, 4 tables.-- Data Availability Statement: All data are available under request to the first auth, Measuring the nearshore bathymetry is critical in coastal management and morphodynamic studies. The recent advent of Unmanned Aerial Vehicles (UAVs), in combination with coastal video monitoring techniques, allows for an alternative and low cost evaluation of the nearshore bathymetry. Camera calibration and stabilization is a critical issue in bathymetry estimation from video systems. This work introduces a new methodology in order to obtain such bathymetries, and it compares the results to echo-sounder ground truth data. The goal is to gain a better understanding on the influence of the camera calibration and stabilization on the inferred bathymetry. The results show how the proposed methodology allows for accurate evaluations of the bathymetry, with overall root mean square errors in the order of 40 cm. It is shown that the intrinsic calibration of the camera, related to the lens distortion, is the most critical aspect. Here, the intrinsic calibration that was obtained directly during the flight yields the best results, This research was funded by the Spanish Government (MINECO/MICINN/FEDER) grant numbers RTI2018-093941-B-C32, and RTI2018-093941-B-C33, PID2019-109143RB-I00 and FEDER-UCA18-107062. G.S. and R.D. belong to CRG on Littoral and Oceanic Processes, supported by Grant 2017 SGR 863 of the Generalitat de Catalunya. Part of this work and I.G.-L. was supported by a grant funded by the European Commission under the Erasmus Mundus Joint Master Degree Programme in Water and Coastal Management (WACOMA; Project num. 586596-EPP-1-2017-1-IT-EPPKA1-JMD-MOB). With the funding support of the ‘Severo Ochoa Centre of Excellence’ accreditation (CEX2019-000928-S), of the Spanish Research Agency (AEI), Peer reviewed
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Video-monitoring tools for assessing beach morphodynamics in tidal beaches

  • Montes, Juan
  • Río, Laura del
  • Plomaritis, Theocharis A.
  • Benavente, Javier
  • Puig, María
  • Simarro, Gonzalo
Beach behaviour and evolution are controlled by a large number of factors, being susceptible to human-derived pressures and the impacts of climate change. In order to understand beach behaviour at different scales, systematic monitoring programs that assess shoreline and volumetric changes are required. Video-monitoring systems are widely used in this regard, as they are cost-effective and acquire data automatically and continuously, even in bad weather conditions. This work presents a methodology to use the basic products of low-cost IP video cameras to identify both the cross-shore and long-shore variability of tidal beaches. Shorelines were automatically obtained, digital elevation models (DEMs) were generated and validated with real data, and the outputs were combined to analyse beach behaviour from a morphodynamic perspective. The proposed methodology was applied to La Victoria Beach (SW Spain) for the analysis of beach variations over a 5-year period. The combination of shoreline position analysis and data from DEMs facilitates understanding and provides a complete overview of beach behaviour, revealing alongshore differences in an apparently homogeneous beach. Furthermore, the methods used allowed us to inter-relate the different processes occurring on the beach, which is difficult to achieve with other types of techniques, This work is a contribution to the ADACOSTA project (CGL2014-53153-R), funded by the Spanish MINECO; the CRUNCH project (FEDER-UCA18-107062), funded by European Union under the 2014-2020 ERDF Operational Programme and by the Department of Economic Transformation, Industry, Knowledge, and Universities of the Regional Government of Andalusia; and the CRISIS project (PID2019-109143RB-I00), funded by the Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation and the European Union. J.M. was supported by contract BES-2015-073218 and a postdoctoral contract from Margarita Salas at the University of Cadiz from the Ministry of Universities of Spain, funded by the European Union—NextGenerationEU, With the institutional support of the ‘Severo Ochoa Centre of Excellence’ accreditation (CEX2019-000928-S), Peer reviewed