Pasar al contenido principal

REDES INALAMBRICAS DE BAJA LATENCIA PARA APLICACIONES INTERACTIVAS DE REALIDAD EXTENDIDA

PID2021-123995NB-I00

•
Nombre agencia financiadora Agencia Estatal de Investigación
Acrónimo agencia financiadora AEI
Programa Programa Estatal para Impulsar la Investigación Científico-Técnica y su Transferencia
Subprograma Subprograma Estatal de Generación de Conocimiento
Convocatoria Proyectos de I+D+i (Generación de Conocimiento y Retos Investigación)
Año convocatoria 2021
Plan Estatal 2021-2023 Plan Estatal de Investigación Científica y Técnica y de Innovación
Centro beneficiario UNIVERSITAT POMPEU FABRA CCT

Resultados relacionados

Resultados totales (Incluyendo duplicados): 23
Encontrada(s) 1 página(s)

Repositorio Digital de la UPF
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Wi-Fi: 25 Years and Counting

  • Geraci, Giovanni
  • Meneghello, Francesca
  • Wilhelmi Roca, Francesc
  • Lopez-Perez, David
  • Val, Iñaki
  • Giordano, Lorenzo Galati.
  • Cordeiro, Carlos
  • Ghosh, Monisha
  • Knightly, Edward
  • Bellalta, Boris
Today, Wi-Fi is over 25 years old. Yet, despite sharing the same branding name, today's Wi-Fi boasts entirely new capabilities that were not even on the roadmap 25 years ago. This article aims to provide a holistic and comprehensive technical and historical tutorial on Wi-Fi, beginning with Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers 802.11b (Wi-Fi 1) and looking forward to IEEE 802.11bn (Wi-Fi 8). This is the first tutorial article to span these eight generations. Rather than a generation-by-generation exposition, we describe the key mechanisms that have advanced Wi-Fi. We begin by discussing spectrum allocation and coexistence, and detailing the IEEE 802.11 standardization cycle. Second, we provide an overview of the physical layer (PHY) and describe key elements that have enabled data rates to increase by over 1000×. Third, we describe how Wi-Fi medium access control (MAC) has been enhanced from the original distributed coordination function (DCF) to now include capabilities spanning from frame aggregation to wideband spectrum access. Fourth, we describe how Wi-Fi 5 first broke the one-user-at-a-time paradigm and introduced multi-user (MU) access. Fifth, given the increasing use of mobile, battery-powered devices, we describe Wi-Fi's energy-saving mechanisms over the generations. Sixth, we discuss how Wi-Fi was enhanced to seamlessly aggregate spectrum across 2.4-, 5-, and 6-GHz bands to improve throughput, reliability, and latency. Finally, we describe how Wi-Fi enables nearby access points (APs) to coordinate in order to improve performance and efficiency. In the Appendix, we further discuss Wi-Fi developments beyond 802.11bn, including integrated millimeter-wave (IMMW) operations, sensing, security and privacy extensions, and the adoption of artificial intelligence (AI)/machine learning (ML)., This work was supported in part by Spanish Research Agency under Grant PID2021-123999OB-I00, Grant PID2021-123995NB-I00, Grant PID2024-156488OB-I00, Grant CEX2021-001195-M, Grant CNS2023-145384, Grant CNS2023-144333, Grant PID2024-155470NB-I00; in part by SGR 00955-2021 AGAUR; in part by ICREA Academia; in part by European Union-Next Generation EU through Italian National Recovery and Resilience Plan (NRRP), Mission 4, Component 2, Investment 1.2, CUP C93C24004880002, Project 'CAMELIA'; in part by the Generalitat Valenciana, Spain, under Grant CIDEXG/2022/17; in part by Nokia; in part by Cisco; in part by Intel; and in part by NSF under Grant 2433923, Grant 2402783, Grant 2211618, Grant 2346413, and Grant 2229387. (Corresponding author: Giovanni Geraci.)
Repositorio Digital de la UPF
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Rooms: a WebGPU-Based VR platform for intuitive 3D sculpting and animation

  • Marquerie Cordoba, Juan Sebastian
  • Rodríguez, Alejandro
  • García, Pablo L.
  • Marques, Ricardo
  • Blat, Josep
Data de publicació electrònica: 21-07-2026, We propose Rooms, an open-source XR content creation platform designed to democratize 3D modeling and animation by leveraging the intuitiveness of VR motion controls and the high-performance capabilities of the modern WebGPU API. Built on top of wgpuEngine, Rooms provides real-time, cross-platform immersive sculpting and animation tools directly accessible through XR-enabled web browsers and desktop systems. The system implements a Signed Distance Field (SDF) sculpting pipeline that enables smooth Constructive Solid Geometry (CSG) operations for clay-like modeling. This paper details the architecture, the XR-first user interaction workflow, and the technical implementation, which includes a GPU-driven, sparse SDF baking pipeline. User studies confirm that the immersive, motion-based interaction model successfully lowers the entry barrier for non-expert users. Rooms effectively paves the way for future web-based XR creation environments by guiding the development of accessible and intuitive tools that harness the full power of modern GPU APIs on the web., This project has received partial financial support from the MAX-R project (Mixed Augmented and eXtended Reality media pipeline, H2020-Digital, Industry and Space, Grant Agreement No.101070072) and from the Wi-XR project (MCIN/FEDER, PID2021-123995NB-I00). Ricardo Marques acknowledges the support of CNS2022-135480 (A-BMC) funded by MICIU/AEI/10.13039/501100 011033, by FEDER (UE), and by European Union NextGenerationEU/ PRTR. We thank the MAX-R partners, and especially UPF-WiNet and FABW for mutual support in user studies.
Repositorio Digital de la UPF
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

On the communication problems of virtual reality: responsiveness, timeliness, and effectiveness

  • Michaelides, Costas
  • Bellalta, Boris
In this article, we explore communication problems in virtual reality (VR) systems from the perspective of wireless networking. Our starting point is that the dynamics of real-time interaction between the physical and virtual worlds cannot be fully captured by the frame rate. Particularly, the frame rate can be very high, but the actual user experience can be disappointing. We argue that the key idea is to think of VR as the mediator of the senses, especially vision, rather than a conventional video streaming application. This is indeed a remarkable opportunity to recall Weaver's classification and define three fundamental problems in VR systems: i) responsiveness, ii) timeliness, and iii) effectiveness. Responsiveness refers to the delay between an action in the physical world and its display in the virtual world. Timeliness is related to the frequency of updates imposed by the frame rate. Effectiveness considers the visual content of a video frame and its likelihood of extrapolation. Our framework offers a concise and objective description of VR systems, that allows us to evaluate performance, identify potential issues, and design impactful solutions., This work was partially funded by Wi-XR PID2021-123995NB-I00 (MCIU/AEI/FEDER,UE), and by MCIN/AEI under the Maria de Maeztu Units of Excellence Programme (CEX2021-001195-M).
Repositorio Digital de la UPF
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Understanding the Wi-Fi and VR streaming interplay: a comprehensible simulation and experimental study

  • Bellalta, Boris
  • Casasnovas, Miguel
  • Maura, Ferran
  • Rodríguez, Alejandro
  • Marquerie Cordoba, Juan Sebastian
  • García, Pablo L.
  • Wilhelmi Roca, Francesc
  • Blat, Josep
This paper evaluates the performance of Wi-Fi networks for interactive Virtual Reality (VR) streaming with adaptive bitrate control. It focuses on the interaction between VR traffic characteristics and Wi-Fi link-layer mechanisms, studying how this relationship impacts key performance indicators such as throughput, latency, and user scalability. We begin by outlining the architecture, operation, traffic patterns, and performance demands of cloud/edge split-rendering VR systems. Then, using simulations, we investigate both single-user scenarios- examining the effects of modulation and coding schemes (MCSs) and user-to-access point (AP) distance on bitrate sustainability and latency -and multi-user scenarios, assessing how many concurrent VR users a single AP can support. Results show that the use of adaptive bitrate (ABR) streaming, as exemplified by our NeSt-VR algorithm, significantly outperforms constant bitrate (CBR) approaches, enhancing user capacity and resilience to changing channel propagation conditions. To validate the simulation findings, we conduct an experimental evaluation using Rooms, an open-source eXtended Reality (XR) content creation platform. The experimental results closely match the simulations, reinforcing the conclusion that adaptive bitrate control substantially improves Wi-Fi's ability to support reliable, multiuser interactive VR streaming., This work is partially funded by MAX-R (101070072) EU, Wi-XR PID2021-123995NB-I00 and TRUE-Wi-Fi PID2024-155470NB-I00 (MCIU/AEI/FEDER,UE), and by MCIN/AEI under the Maria de Maeztu Units of Excellence Programme (CEX2021-001195-M), and ICREA Academia 00077 (AGAUR) .
Repositorio Digital de la UPF
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Experimental evaluation of interactive edge/cloud virtual reality gaming over wi-fi using unity render streaming

  • Casanovas Bielsa, Miguel
  • Michaelides, Costas
  • Carrascosa Zamacois, Marc
  • Bellalta, Boris
Virtual Reality (VR) streaming enables end-users to seamlessly immerse themselves in interactive virtual environments using even low-end devices. However, the quality of the VR experience heavily relies on Wireless Fidelity (Wi-Fi) performance, since it serves as the last hop in the network chain. Our study delves into the intricate interplay between Wi-Fi and VR traffic, drawing upon empirical data and leveraging a Wi-Fi simulator. In this work, we further evaluate Wi-Fi’s suitability for VR streaming in terms of the Quality of Service (QoS) it provides. In particular, we employ Unity Render Streaming to remotely stream real-time VR gaming content over Wi-Fi 6 using Web Real-Time Communication (WebRTC), considering a server physically located at the network’s edge, near the end user. Our findings demonstrate the system’s sustained network performance, showcasing minimal round-trip time (RTT) and jitter at 60 and 90 frames per second (fps). In addition, we uncover the characteristics and patterns of the generated traffic streams, unveiling a distinctive video transmission approach inherent to WebRTC-based services: the systematic packetization of video frames (VFs) and their transmission in discrete batches at regular intervals, regardless of the targeted frame rate. This interval-based transmission strategy maintains consistent video packet delays across video frame rates but leads to increased Wi-Fi airtime consumption. Our results demonstrate that shortening the interval between batches is advantageous, as it enhances Wi-Fi efficiency and reduces delays in delivering complete frames., This work is partially funded by Wi-XR PID2021-123995NB-I00 (MCIU/AEI/FEDER,UE), MAX-R EU-HE2022 (101070072), by MCIN/AEI under the Maria de Maeztu Units of Excellence Programme (CEX2021-001195-M) and 2021-SGR-00955. We would like to acknowledge the insightful feedback received from the Editor, Prof. Damla Turgut, and the anonymous Reviewers to enhance the final quality of this work.
Repositorio Digital de la UPF
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Machine learning and Wi-Fi: unveiling the path toward AI/ML-Native IEEE 802.11 networks

  • Wilhelmi Roca, Francesc
  • Szott, Szymon
  • Kosek-Szott, Katarzyna
  • Bellalta, Boris
Artificial intelligence (AI) and machine learning (ML) are nowadays mature technologies considered essential for driving the evolution of future communications systems. Simultaneously, Wi-Fi technology has constantly evolved over the past three decades and incorporated new features generation after generation, thus gaining in complexity. As such, researchers have observed that AI/ML functionalities may be required to address the upcoming Wi-Fi challenges that will be otherwise difficult to solve with traditional approaches. This article discusses the role of AI/ML in current and future Wi-Fi networks, and depicts the ways forward. A roadmap toward AI/ML-native Wi-Fi, key challenges, standardization efforts, and major enablers are also discussed. An exemplary use case is provided to showcase the potential of AI/ ML in Wi-Fi at different adoption stages., This paper is supported by the CHIST-ERA Wireless AI 2022 call MLDR project (ANR-23-CHR4-0005), partially funded by AEI and NCN under projects PCI2023-145958-2 and 2023/05/Y/ST7/00004, respectively. B. Bellalta's contribution is supported by Wi-XR PID2021-123995NB-I00 (MCIU/AEI/FEDER,UE) and MdM CEX2021-001195-M/AEI/10.13039/501100011033.
Repositorio Digital de la UPF
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

XR streaming performance with wi-fi 7 multi-link operation

  • Jonsson, Anders
  • Carrascosa Zamacois, Marc
  • Galati Giordano, Lorenzo
  • Wilhelmi Roca, Francesc
  • Fontanesi, Gianluca
  • Geraci, Giovanni
  • Bellalta, Boris
Extended Reality (XR) has stringent throughput and delay requirements that are hard to meet with current wireless technologies. Missing these requirements can lead to worsened picture quality, perceived lag between user input and corresponding output, and even dizziness for the end user. In this paper, we study the capability of Wi-Fi 7, and its novel support for Multi-Link Operation (MLO), to cope with these tight requirements. Our study is based on simulation results extracted from an MLO-compliant simulator that realistically reproduces VR traffic. Results show that MLO can sustain Virtual Reality (VR) applications. By jointly using multiple links with independent channel access procedures, MLO can reduce the overall delay, which is especially useful in the uplink, as it has more stringent requirements than the downlink, and is instrumental in delivering the expected performance. We show that using MLO can support more users per Access Point (AP) than an equivalent number of links using Single Link Operation (SLO). We also show that, while maintaining the same overall bandwidth, a higher number of MLO links with narrower channels leads to lower delays than a lower number of links with wider channels. We also study the impact of Overlapping Basic Service Sets (OBSS) on performance of XR applications, showing how SLO struggles to maintain a low delay when OBSS activity increases, and how MLO can cope with this interference by using MLO-aware channel assignment strategies. Finally, we consider random positioning for the users, showcasing that MLO can support 5× more users than SLO., The work of Marc Carrascosa-Zamacois and Boris Bellalta was supported in part by Grant MAX-R under Grant HEu-CL4-MAX-R-101070072; in part by under Grant Wi-XR PID2021-123995NB-I00; and in part by MCIN/AEI through the Maria de Maeztu Units of Excellence Programme under Grant CEX2021-001195-M. The work of Lorenzo Galati-Giordano and Gianluca Fontanesi was supported in part by UNITY-6G Project, funded from European Union’s Horizon Europe Smart Networks and Services Joint Undertaking (SNS JU) Research and Innovation Programme under Grant 101192650. The work of Francesc Wilhelmi was supported in part by Wi-XR under Grant PID2021-123995NB-I00. The work of Giovanni Geraci was supported in part by the Spanish Research Agency under Grant PID2021-123999OB-I00, Grant CEX2021-001195-M, and Grant CNS2023-145384. The work of Boris Bellalta was supported by ICREA Academia under Grant 00077.
Repositorio Digital de la UPF
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Learning-based channel access in Wi-Fi: a multi-armed bandit approach

  • Casasnovas, Miguel
  • Wilhelmi Roca, Francesc
  • Combes, Richard
  • Wojnar, Marksymilian
  • Kosek-Szott, Katarzyna
  • Szott, Szymon
  • Jonsson, Anders, 1973-
  • Esteve-Elfau, Luis
  • Bellalta, Boris
Due to largely static protocol configurations, IEEE 802.11 (Wi-Fi) channel access offers limited adaptability to dynamic network conditions, particularly in dense and overlapping deployments, leading to inefficient spectrum utilization, increased contention, and packet collisions. This paper investigates reinforcement learning (RL) as a data-driven, decentralized, and online approach for adaptive Wi-Fi medium access control (MAC). In particular, we consider multi-armed bandit (MAB) strategies for the joint selection of the primary channel, channel width, and contention window (CW). In this setting, we systematically study key design choices, including the adoption of joint action spaces, where a single agent (SA) optimizes all parameters, or factorized action spaces, where multiple agents (MA) handle each parameter independently, as well as the incorporation of contextual information, evaluated through contextual and non-contextual MAB formulations. Simulation results provide insights into these design choices, showing that MA architectures converge faster than their SA counterparts due to smaller action spaces, and that using contextual information consistently improves performance in the considered scenarios. In multi-player settings, decentralized learners achieve implicit coordination; however, their greedy behavior may degrade the performance of coexisting networks and induce policy-chasing dynamics. Overall, our findings suggest that (contextual) MAB-based learning provides a lightweight and adaptive alternative to static IEEE 802.11 mechanisms, enabling more efficient and intelligent spectrum utilization, and provides practical insights for learning-driven, MAB-based MAC protocols., This work was supported in part by the Projects: Machine Learning-Driven Radio Interface (MLDR) [Chist-European Research Area (ERA) Wireless AI (WAI) 2022] through AEI, NCN, and ANR, Project PCI2023-145958-2 (MCIU/AEI/10.13039/501100011033/UE), Project 2023/05/Y/ST7/00004, and Project ANR-23-CHR4-0005; in part by Wi-XR under Grant PID2021-123995NB-I00 (MCIU/AEI/FEDER, UE); in part by TRUE Wi-Fi under Grant PID2024-155470NB-I00 (MICIU/AEI/10.13039/501100011033/FEDER, UE); in part by Institució Catalana de Recerca i Estudis Avançats (ICREA) Academia 2024 under Grant 00077 AGAUR; and in part by the Maria de Maeztu (MdM) Program under Grant CEX2021-001195-M (MICIU/AEI/10.13039/501100011033)
Repositorio Digital de la UPF
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Demystifying the peeker's advantage in multiplayer first-person shooter games

  • Michaelides, Costas
  • Bellalta, Boris
We study the peeker's advantage in first-person shooters, a classic problem in multiplayer games. A player, the peeker, who first observes another player, the defender, has a strategic advantage. The peeker has the opportunity to aim and shoot first, as the defender is not aware of the peeker's presence for a short amount of time. Formally, the peeker's advantage is the length of time that the peeker sees the defender without being seen. This is an inherent problem of multiplayer games, where each player runs their own instance of the game and relies on updates from an authoritative game server to get informed about the global game state. In this article, we explore the peeker's advantage with extensive simulations, by varying the system delays, the network delays, and the reaction times of the players. First, we present our multiplayer abstraction that captures the essence of first-person shooters, including client and server logic as well as the exchanged messages. Next, we show that the game frame rate is the most influential factor, while the game server tick rate and network delays have minimal impact. Specifically, we show that by using 120 fps in the game and 60 ticks/s on the game server, the peeker's advantage can be dropped below 100 ms. Finally, using realistic, standards-compliant simulations, we show that this advantage is consistent across multiple configurations, both in local area networks and over the Internet., This work was supported in part by Wi-XR PID2021-123995NB-I00 and TRUE-Wi-Fi PID2024-155470NB-I00 (MCIU/AEI/FEDER,UE), in part by MCIN/AEI under the Maria de Maeztu Units of Excellence Program under Grant CEX2021-001195-M, and in part by AGAUR ICREA Academia 000777. Recommended by Associate Editor R. Thawonmas. (Corresponding author: Costas Michaelides.)
Repositorio Digital de la UPF
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Lessons learned from a large-scale virtual reality experience over Wi-Fi

  • Michaelides, Costas
  • Casasnovas, Miguel
  • Núñez Cuadrado, David
  • Bellalta, Boris
Large-scale virtual reality (VR) enables novel art forms in large physical environments. A key technical solution in such cases is to split the rendering process between a client and a streamer. In this article, we focused on the peculiarities of VR split rendering and particularly on the performance of Wi-Fi. First, we calculated the network delay budget and then conducted a set of experiments to evaluate the single-user and multi-user performance of VR split rendering systems over Wi-Fi in terms of latency. Our findings were summarized as recommendations on: i) the frame rate, ii) the encoding bitrate, iii) the signal strength, iv) the channel bandwidth, and v) the multiple access techniques. In particular, our multi-user tests highlighted cases where using the highest settings or latest features of Wi-Fi can compromise performance. Finally, we applied our recommendations to a large-scale multi-user case study that took place physically in the multi-purpose hall of our university campus and virtually in the Turret Singers environment of SteamVR Home. This article serves as a reference to the critical aspects of VR split rendering systems over Wi-Fi., This work was supported in part by the Projects MAX-R HE2022 [European Union (EU)] under Grant 101070072, in part by Wi-XR [Ministerio de Ciencia, Innovación y Universidades (MCIU)/Agencia Estatal de Investigación (AEI)/Fondo Europeo de Desarrollo Regional [Ministerio de Ciencia, Innovación y Universidades (MCIU)/Agencia Estatal de Investigacion (AEI)/Fondo Europeo de Desarrollo Regional (FEDER), EU] under Grant PID2021-123995NB-I00, and in part by MCIN/AEI through Maria de Maeztu Strategic Research Program (MdM) under Grant CEX2021-001195-M. (Corresponding author: Costas Michaelides.)
Repositorio Digital de la UPF
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Lessons learned from a large-scale virtual reality experience over wi-fi

  • Michaelides, Costas
  • Casanovas Bielsa, Miguel
  • Núñez Cuadrado, David
  • Bellalta, Boris
Large-scale virtual reality (VR) enables novel art forms in large physical environments. A key technical solution in such cases is to split the rendering process between a client and a streamer. In this article, we focused on the peculiarities of VR split rendering and particularly on the performance of Wi-Fi. First, we calculated the network delay budget and then conducted a set of experiments to evaluate the single-user and multi-user performance of VR split rendering systems over Wi-Fi in terms of latency. Our findings were summarized as recommendations on: i) the frame rate, ii) the encoding bitrate, iii) the signal strength, iv) the channel bandwidth, and v) the multiple access techniques. In particular, our multi-user tests highlighted cases where using the highest settings or latest features of Wi-Fi can compromise performance. Finally, we applied our recommendations to a large-scale multi-user case study that took place physically in the multi-purpose hall of our university campus and virtually in the Turret Singers environment of SteamVR Home. This article serves as a reference to the critical aspects of VR split rendering systems over Wi-Fi., This work was supported in part by the Projects MAX-RHE2022 [European Union (EU)] under Grant 101070072, in part by Wi-XR [Ministerio de Ciencia, Innovación y Universidades (MCIU)/Agencia Estatal de Investigación (AEI)/Fondo Europeo de Desarrollo Regional [Ministerio de Ciencia, Innovación y Universidades (MCIU)/Agencia Estatal de Investigación (AEI)/Fondo Europeo de Desarrollo Regional (FEDER), EU] under Grant PID2021-123995NB-I00, and in part by MCIN/AEI through Maria de Maeztu Strategic Research Program (MdM) under Grant CEX2021-001195-M.
RiuNet. Repositorio Institucional de la Universitat Politécnica de Valéncia
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Wi-Fi: 25 Years and Counting

  • Geraci, Giovanni
  • Meneghello, Francesca
  • Wilhelmi, Francesc
  • Val, Inaki
  • Giordano, Lorenzo Galati
  • Cordeiro, Carlos
  • Ghosh, Monisha
  • Knightly, Edward
  • Bellalta, Boris
  • López-Pérez, David
[EN] Today, Wi-Fi is over 25 years old. Yet, despite sharing the same branding name, today's Wi-Fi boasts entirely new capabilities that were not even on the roadmap 25 years ago. This article aims to provide a holistic and comprehensive technical and historical tutorial on Wi-Fi, beginning with Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers 802.11b (Wi-Fi 1) and looking forward to IEEE 802.11bn (Wi-Fi 8). This is the first tutorial article to span these eight generations. Rather than a generation-by-generation exposition, we describe the key mechanisms that have advanced Wi-Fi. We begin by discussing spectrum allocation and coexistence, and detailing the IEEE 802.11 standardization cycle. Second, we provide an overview of the physical layer (PHY) and describe key elements that have enabled data rates to increase by over 1000 & times;. Third, we describe how Wi-Fi medium access control (MAC) has been enhanced from the original distributed coordination function (DCF) to now include capabilities spanning from frame aggregation to wideband spectrum access. Fourth, we describe how Wi-Fi 5 first broke the one-user-at-a-time paradigm and introduced multi-user (MU) access. Fifth, given the increasing use of mobile, battery-powered devices, we describe Wi-Fi's energy-saving mechanisms over the generations. Sixth, we discuss how Wi-Fi was enhanced to seamlessly aggregate spectrum across 2.4-, 5-, and 6-GHz bands to improve throughput, reliability, and latency. Finally, we describe how Wi-Fi enables nearby access points (APs) to coordinate in order to improve performance and efficiency. In the Appendix, we further discuss Wi-Fi developments beyond 802.11bn, including integrated millimeter-wave (IMMW) operations, sensing, security and privacy extensions, and the adoption of artificial intelligence (AI)/machine learning (ML)., This work was supported in part by Spanish Research Agency under Grant PID2021-123999OB-I00, Grant PID2021-123995NB-I00, Grant PID2024-156488OB-I00, Grant CEX2021-001195-M, Grant CNS2023-145384, Grant CNS2023-144333, Grant PID2024-155470NB-I00; in part by SGR 00955-2021 AGAUR; in part by ICREA Academia; in part by European Union-Next Generation EU through Italian National Recovery and Resilience Plan (NRRP), Mission 4, Component 2, Investment 1.2, CUP C93C24004880002, Project "CAMELIA"; in part by the Generalitat Valenciana, Spain, under Grant CIDEXG/2022/17; in part by Nokia; in part by Cisco; in part by Intel; and in part by NSF under Grant 2433923, Grant 2402783, Grant 2211618, Grant 2346413, and Grant 2229387.
Recercat. Dipósit de la Recerca de Catalunya
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Lessons learned from a large-scale virtual reality experience over wi-fi

  • Michaelides, Costas
  • Casanovas Bielsa, Miguel
  • Núñez Cuadrado, David
  • Bellalta, Boris
Data de publicació electrònica: 26-06-2025, Large-scale virtual reality (VR) enables novel art forms in large physical environments. A key technical solution in such cases is to split the rendering process between a client and a streamer. In this article, we focused on the peculiarities of VR split rendering and particularly on the performance of Wi-Fi. First, we calculated the network delay budget and then conducted a set of experiments to evaluate the single-user and multi-user performance of VR split rendering systems over Wi-Fi in terms of latency. Our findings were summarized as recommendations on: i) the frame rate, ii) the encoding bitrate, iii) the signal strength, iv) the channel bandwidth, and v) the multiple access techniques. In particular, our multi-user tests highlighted cases where using the highest settings or latest features of Wi-Fi can compromise performance. Finally, we applied our recommendations to a large-scale multi-user case study that took place physically in the multi-purpose hall of our university campus and virtually in the Turret Singers environment of SteamVR Home. This article serves as a reference to the critical aspects of VR split rendering systems over Wi-Fi., This work was supported in part by the Projects MAX-RHE2022 [European Union (EU)] under Grant 101070072, in part by Wi-XR [Ministerio de Ciencia, Innovación y Universidades (MCIU)/Agencia Estatal de Investigación (AEI)/Fondo Europeo de Desarrollo Regional [Ministerio de Ciencia, Innovación y Universidades (MCIU)/Agencia Estatal de Investigación (AEI)/Fondo Europeo de Desarrollo Regional (FEDER), EU] under Grant PID2021-123995NB-I00, and in part by MCIN/AEI through Maria de Maeztu Strategic Research Program (MdM) under Grant CEX2021-001195-M.
Recercat. Dipósit de la Recerca de Catalunya
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Learning-based channel access in Wi-Fi: a multi-armed bandit approach

  • Casasnovas, Miguel
  • Wilhelmi Roca, Francesc
  • Combes, Richard
  • Wojnar, Marksymilian
  • Kosek-Szott, Katarzyna
  • Szott, Szymon
  • Jonsson, Anders, 1973-
  • Esteve-Elfau, Luis
  • Bellalta, Boris
Due to largely static protocol configurations, IEEE 802.11 (Wi-Fi) channel access offers limited adaptability to dynamic network conditions, particularly in dense and overlapping deployments, leading to inefficient spectrum utilization, increased contention, and packet collisions. This paper investigates reinforcement learning (RL) as a data-driven, decentralized, and online approach for adaptive Wi-Fi medium access control (MAC). In particular, we consider multi-armed bandit (MAB) strategies for the joint selection of the primary channel, channel width, and contention window (CW). In this setting, we systematically study key design choices, including the adoption of joint action spaces, where a single agent (SA) optimizes all parameters, or factorized action spaces, where multiple agents (MA) handle each parameter independently, as well as the incorporation of contextual information, evaluated through contextual and non-contextual MAB formulations. Simulation results provide insights into these design choices, showing that MA architectures converge faster than their SA counterparts due to smaller action spaces, and that using contextual information consistently improves performance in the considered scenarios. In multi-player settings, decentralized learners achieve implicit coordination; however, their greedy behavior may degrade the performance of coexisting networks and induce policy-chasing dynamics. Overall, our findings suggest that (contextual) MAB-based learning provides a lightweight and adaptive alternative to static IEEE 802.11 mechanisms, enabling more efficient and intelligent spectrum utilization, and provides practical insights for learning-driven, MAB-based MAC protocols., This work was supported in part by the Projects: Machine Learning-Driven Radio Interface (MLDR) [Chist-European Research Area (ERA) Wireless AI (WAI) 2022] through AEI, NCN, and ANR, Project PCI2023-145958-2 (MCIU/AEI/10.13039/501100011033/UE), Project 2023/05/Y/ST7/00004, and Project ANR-23-CHR4-0005; in part by Wi-XR under Grant PID2021-123995NB-I00 (MCIU/AEI/FEDER, UE); in part by TRUE Wi-Fi under Grant PID2024-155470NB-I00 (MICIU/AEI/10.13039/501100011033/FEDER, UE); in part by Institució Catalana de Recerca i Estudis Avançats (ICREA) Academia 2024 under Grant 00077 AGAUR; and in part by the Maria de Maeztu (MdM) Program under Grant CEX2021-001195-M (MICIU/AEI/10.13039/501100011033)
Recercat. Dipósit de la Recerca de Catalunya
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Lessons learned from a large-scale virtual reality experience over Wi-Fi

  • Michaelides, Costas
  • Casasnovas, Miguel
  • Núñez Cuadrado, David
  • Bellalta, Boris
Large-scale virtual reality (VR) enables novel art forms in large physical environments. A key technical solution in such cases is to split the rendering process between a client and a streamer. In this article, we focused on the peculiarities of VR split rendering and particularly on the performance of Wi-Fi. First, we calculated the network delay budget and then conducted a set of experiments to evaluate the single-user and multi-user performance of VR split rendering systems over Wi-Fi in terms of latency. Our findings were summarized as recommendations on: i) the frame rate, ii) the encoding bitrate, iii) the signal strength, iv) the channel bandwidth, and v) the multiple access techniques. In particular, our multi-user tests highlighted cases where using the highest settings or latest features of Wi-Fi can compromise performance. Finally, we applied our recommendations to a large-scale multi-user case study that took place physically in the multi-purpose hall of our university campus and virtually in the Turret Singers environment of SteamVR Home. This article serves as a reference to the critical aspects of VR split rendering systems over Wi-Fi., This work was supported in part by the Projects MAX-R HE2022 [European Union (EU)] under Grant 101070072, in part by Wi-XR [Ministerio de Ciencia, Innovación y Universidades (MCIU)/Agencia Estatal de Investigación (AEI)/Fondo Europeo de Desarrollo Regional [Ministerio de Ciencia, Innovación y Universidades (MCIU)/Agencia Estatal de Investigacion (AEI)/Fondo Europeo de Desarrollo Regional (FEDER), EU] under Grant PID2021-123995NB-I00, and in part by MCIN/AEI through Maria de Maeztu Strategic Research Program (MdM) under Grant CEX2021-001195-M. (Corresponding author: Costas Michaelides.)
Recercat. Dipósit de la Recerca de Catalunya
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Wi-Fi: 25 Years and Counting

  • Geraci, Giovanni
  • Meneghello, Francesca
  • Wilhelmi Roca, Francesc
  • Lopez-Perez, David
  • Val, Iñaki
  • Giordano, Lorenzo Galati.
  • Cordeiro, Carlos
  • Ghosh, Monisha
  • Knightly, Edward
  • Bellalta, Boris
Today, Wi-Fi is over 25 years old. Yet, despite sharing the same branding name, today's Wi-Fi boasts entirely new capabilities that were not even on the roadmap 25 years ago. This article aims to provide a holistic and comprehensive technical and historical tutorial on Wi-Fi, beginning with Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers 802.11b (Wi-Fi 1) and looking forward to IEEE 802.11bn (Wi-Fi 8). This is the first tutorial article to span these eight generations. Rather than a generation-by-generation exposition, we describe the key mechanisms that have advanced Wi-Fi. We begin by discussing spectrum allocation and coexistence, and detailing the IEEE 802.11 standardization cycle. Second, we provide an overview of the physical layer (PHY) and describe key elements that have enabled data rates to increase by over 1000×. Third, we describe how Wi-Fi medium access control (MAC) has been enhanced from the original distributed coordination function (DCF) to now include capabilities spanning from frame aggregation to wideband spectrum access. Fourth, we describe how Wi-Fi 5 first broke the one-user-at-a-time paradigm and introduced multi-user (MU) access. Fifth, given the increasing use of mobile, battery-powered devices, we describe Wi-Fi's energy-saving mechanisms over the generations. Sixth, we discuss how Wi-Fi was enhanced to seamlessly aggregate spectrum across 2.4-, 5-, and 6-GHz bands to improve throughput, reliability, and latency. Finally, we describe how Wi-Fi enables nearby access points (APs) to coordinate in order to improve performance and efficiency. In the Appendix, we further discuss Wi-Fi developments beyond 802.11bn, including integrated millimeter-wave (IMMW) operations, sensing, security and privacy extensions, and the adoption of artificial intelligence (AI)/machine learning (ML)., This work was supported in part by Spanish Research Agency under Grant PID2021-123999OB-I00, Grant PID2021-123995NB-I00, Grant PID2024-156488OB-I00, Grant CEX2021-001195-M, Grant CNS2023-145384, Grant CNS2023-144333, Grant PID2024-155470NB-I00; in part by SGR 00955-2021 AGAUR; in part by ICREA Academia; in part by European Union-Next Generation EU through Italian National Recovery and Resilience Plan (NRRP), Mission 4, Component 2, Investment 1.2, CUP C93C24004880002, Project 'CAMELIA'; in part by the Generalitat Valenciana, Spain, under Grant CIDEXG/2022/17; in part by Nokia; in part by Cisco; in part by Intel; and in part by NSF under Grant 2433923, Grant 2402783, Grant 2211618, Grant 2346413, and Grant 2229387. (Corresponding author: Giovanni Geraci.)
Recercat. Dipósit de la Recerca de Catalunya
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Rooms: a WebGPU-Based VR platform for intuitive 3D sculpting and animation

  • Marquerie Cordoba, Juan Sebastian
  • Rodríguez, Alejandro
  • García, Pablo L.
  • Marques, Ricardo
  • Blat, Josep
Data de publicació electrònica: 21-07-2026, We propose Rooms, an open-source XR content creation platform designed to democratize 3D modeling and animation by leveraging the intuitiveness of VR motion controls and the high-performance capabilities of the modern WebGPU API. Built on top of wgpuEngine, Rooms provides real-time, cross-platform immersive sculpting and animation tools directly accessible through XR-enabled web browsers and desktop systems. The system implements a Signed Distance Field (SDF) sculpting pipeline that enables smooth Constructive Solid Geometry (CSG) operations for clay-like modeling. This paper details the architecture, the XR-first user interaction workflow, and the technical implementation, which includes a GPU-driven, sparse SDF baking pipeline. User studies confirm that the immersive, motion-based interaction model successfully lowers the entry barrier for non-expert users. Rooms effectively paves the way for future web-based XR creation environments by guiding the development of accessible and intuitive tools that harness the full power of modern GPU APIs on the web., This project has received partial financial support from the MAX-R project (Mixed Augmented and eXtended Reality media pipeline, H2020-Digital, Industry and Space, Grant Agreement No.101070072) and from the Wi-XR project (MCIN/FEDER, PID2021-123995NB-I00). Ricardo Marques acknowledges the support of CNS2022-135480 (A-BMC) funded by MICIU/AEI/10.13039/501100 011033, by FEDER (UE), and by European Union NextGenerationEU/ PRTR. We thank the MAX-R partners, and especially UPF-WiNet and FABW for mutual support in user studies.
Recercat. Dipósit de la Recerca de Catalunya
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

XR streaming performance with wi-fi 7 multi-link operation

  • Jonsson, Anders
  • Carrascosa Zamacois, Marc
  • Galati Giordano, Lorenzo
  • Wilhelmi Roca, Francesc
  • Fontanesi, Gianluca
  • Geraci, Giovanni
  • Bellalta, Boris
Extended Reality (XR) has stringent throughput and delay requirements that are hard to meet with current wireless technologies. Missing these requirements can lead to worsened picture quality, perceived lag between user input and corresponding output, and even dizziness for the end user. In this paper, we study the capability of Wi-Fi 7, and its novel support for Multi-Link Operation (MLO), to cope with these tight requirements. Our study is based on simulation results extracted from an MLO-compliant simulator that realistically reproduces VR traffic. Results show that MLO can sustain Virtual Reality (VR) applications. By jointly using multiple links with independent channel access procedures, MLO can reduce the overall delay, which is especially useful in the uplink, as it has more stringent requirements than the downlink, and is instrumental in delivering the expected performance. We show that using MLO can support more users per Access Point (AP) than an equivalent number of links using Single Link Operation (SLO). We also show that, while maintaining the same overall bandwidth, a higher number of MLO links with narrower channels leads to lower delays than a lower number of links with wider channels. We also study the impact of Overlapping Basic Service Sets (OBSS) on performance of XR applications, showing how SLO struggles to maintain a low delay when OBSS activity increases, and how MLO can cope with this interference by using MLO-aware channel assignment strategies. Finally, we consider random positioning for the users, showcasing that MLO can support 5× more users than SLO., The work of Marc Carrascosa-Zamacois and Boris Bellalta was supported in part by Grant MAX-R under Grant HEu-CL4-MAX-R-101070072; in part by under Grant Wi-XR PID2021-123995NB-I00; and in part by MCIN/AEI through the Maria de Maeztu Units of Excellence Programme under Grant CEX2021-001195-M. The work of Lorenzo Galati-Giordano and Gianluca Fontanesi was supported in part by UNITY-6G Project, funded from European Union’s Horizon Europe Smart Networks and Services Joint Undertaking (SNS JU) Research and Innovation Programme under Grant 101192650. The work of Francesc Wilhelmi was supported in part by Wi-XR under Grant PID2021-123995NB-I00. The work of Giovanni Geraci was supported in part by the Spanish Research Agency under Grant PID2021-123999OB-I00, Grant CEX2021-001195-M, and Grant CNS2023-145384. The work of Boris Bellalta was supported by ICREA Academia under Grant 00077.
Recercat. Dipósit de la Recerca de Catalunya
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Machine learning and Wi-Fi: unveiling the path toward AI/ML-Native IEEE 802.11 networks

  • Wilhelmi Roca, Francesc
  • Szott, Szymon
  • Kosek-Szott, Katarzyna
  • Bellalta, Boris
Artificial intelligence (AI) and machine learning (ML) are nowadays mature technologies considered essential for driving the evolution of future communications systems. Simultaneously, Wi-Fi technology has constantly evolved over the past three decades and incorporated new features generation after generation, thus gaining in complexity. As such, researchers have observed that AI/ML functionalities may be required to address the upcoming Wi-Fi challenges that will be otherwise difficult to solve with traditional approaches. This article discusses the role of AI/ML in current and future Wi-Fi networks, and depicts the ways forward. A roadmap toward AI/ML-native Wi-Fi, key challenges, standardization efforts, and major enablers are also discussed. An exemplary use case is provided to showcase the potential of AI/ ML in Wi-Fi at different adoption stages., This paper is supported by the CHIST-ERA Wireless AI 2022 call MLDR project (ANR-23-CHR4-0005), partially funded by AEI and NCN under projects PCI2023-145958-2 and 2023/05/Y/ST7/00004, respectively. B. Bellalta's contribution is supported by Wi-XR PID2021-123995NB-I00 (MCIU/AEI/FEDER,UE) and MdM CEX2021-001195-M/AEI/10.13039/501100011033.
Recercat. Dipósit de la Recerca de Catalunya
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Experimental evaluation of interactive edge/cloud virtual reality gaming over wi-fi using unity render streaming

  • Casanovas Bielsa, Miguel
  • Michaelides, Costas
  • Carrascosa Zamacois, Marc
  • Bellalta, Boris
Virtual Reality (VR) streaming enables end-users to seamlessly immerse themselves in interactive virtual environments using even low-end devices. However, the quality of the VR experience heavily relies on Wireless Fidelity (Wi-Fi) performance, since it serves as the last hop in the network chain. Our study delves into the intricate interplay between Wi-Fi and VR traffic, drawing upon empirical data and leveraging a Wi-Fi simulator. In this work, we further evaluate Wi-Fi’s suitability for VR streaming in terms of the Quality of Service (QoS) it provides. In particular, we employ Unity Render Streaming to remotely stream real-time VR gaming content over Wi-Fi 6 using Web Real-Time Communication (WebRTC), considering a server physically located at the network’s edge, near the end user. Our findings demonstrate the system’s sustained network performance, showcasing minimal round-trip time (RTT) and jitter at 60 and 90 frames per second (fps). In addition, we uncover the characteristics and patterns of the generated traffic streams, unveiling a distinctive video transmission approach inherent to WebRTC-based services: the systematic packetization of video frames (VFs) and their transmission in discrete batches at regular intervals, regardless of the targeted frame rate. This interval-based transmission strategy maintains consistent video packet delays across video frame rates but leads to increased Wi-Fi airtime consumption. Our results demonstrate that shortening the interval between batches is advantageous, as it enhances Wi-Fi efficiency and reduces delays in delivering complete frames., This work is partially funded by Wi-XR PID2021-123995NB-I00 (MCIU/AEI/FEDER,UE), MAX-R EU-HE2022 (101070072), by MCIN/AEI under the Maria de Maeztu Units of Excellence Programme (CEX2021-001195-M) and 2021-SGR-00955. We would like to acknowledge the insightful feedback received from the Editor, Prof. Damla Turgut, and the anonymous Reviewers to enhance the final quality of this work.
Recercat. Dipósit de la Recerca de Catalunya
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Understanding the Wi-Fi and VR streaming interplay: a comprehensible simulation and experimental study

  • Bellalta, Boris
  • Casasnovas, Miguel
  • Maura, Ferran
  • Rodríguez, Alejandro
  • Marquerie Cordoba, Juan Sebastian
  • García, Pablo L.
  • Wilhelmi Roca, Francesc
  • Blat, Josep
This paper evaluates the performance of Wi-Fi networks for interactive Virtual Reality (VR) streaming with adaptive bitrate control. It focuses on the interaction between VR traffic characteristics and Wi-Fi link-layer mechanisms, studying how this relationship impacts key performance indicators such as throughput, latency, and user scalability. We begin by outlining the architecture, operation, traffic patterns, and performance demands of cloud/edge split-rendering VR systems. Then, using simulations, we investigate both single-user scenarios- examining the effects of modulation and coding schemes (MCSs) and user-to-access point (AP) distance on bitrate sustainability and latency -and multi-user scenarios, assessing how many concurrent VR users a single AP can support. Results show that the use of adaptive bitrate (ABR) streaming, as exemplified by our NeSt-VR algorithm, significantly outperforms constant bitrate (CBR) approaches, enhancing user capacity and resilience to changing channel propagation conditions. To validate the simulation findings, we conduct an experimental evaluation using Rooms, an open-source eXtended Reality (XR) content creation platform. The experimental results closely match the simulations, reinforcing the conclusion that adaptive bitrate control substantially improves Wi-Fi's ability to support reliable, multiuser interactive VR streaming., This work is partially funded by MAX-R (101070072) EU, Wi-XR PID2021-123995NB-I00 and TRUE-Wi-Fi PID2024-155470NB-I00 (MCIU/AEI/FEDER,UE), and by MCIN/AEI under the Maria de Maeztu Units of Excellence Programme (CEX2021-001195-M), and ICREA Academia 00077 (AGAUR) .
Recercat. Dipósit de la Recerca de Catalunya
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Demystifying the peeker's advantage in multiplayer first-person shooter games

  • Michaelides, Costas
  • Bellalta, Boris
We study the peeker's advantage in first-person shooters, a classic problem in multiplayer games. A player, the peeker, who first observes another player, the defender, has a strategic advantage. The peeker has the opportunity to aim and shoot first, as the defender is not aware of the peeker's presence for a short amount of time. Formally, the peeker's advantage is the length of time that the peeker sees the defender without being seen. This is an inherent problem of multiplayer games, where each player runs their own instance of the game and relies on updates from an authoritative game server to get informed about the global game state. In this article, we explore the peeker's advantage with extensive simulations, by varying the system delays, the network delays, and the reaction times of the players. First, we present our multiplayer abstraction that captures the essence of first-person shooters, including client and server logic as well as the exchanged messages. Next, we show that the game frame rate is the most influential factor, while the game server tick rate and network delays have minimal impact. Specifically, we show that by using 120 fps in the game and 60 ticks/s on the game server, the peeker's advantage can be dropped below 100 ms. Finally, using realistic, standards-compliant simulations, we show that this advantage is consistent across multiple configurations, both in local area networks and over the Internet., This work was supported in part by Wi-XR PID2021-123995NB-I00 and TRUE-Wi-Fi PID2024-155470NB-I00 (MCIU/AEI/FEDER,UE), in part by MCIN/AEI under the Maria de Maeztu Units of Excellence Program under Grant CEX2021-001195-M, and in part by AGAUR ICREA Academia 000777. Recommended by Associate Editor R. Thawonmas. (Corresponding author: Costas Michaelides.)
Recercat. Dipósit de la Recerca de Catalunya
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

On the communication problems of virtual reality: responsiveness, timeliness, and effectiveness

  • Michaelides, Costas
  • Bellalta, Boris
Data de publicació electrònica: 09-09-2025, In this article, we explore communication problems in virtual reality (VR) systems from the perspective of wireless networking. Our starting point is that the dynamics of real-time interaction between the physical and virtual worlds cannot be fully captured by the frame rate. Particularly, the frame rate can be very high, but the actual user experience can be disappointing. We argue that the key idea is to think of VR as the mediator of the senses, especially vision, rather than a conventional video streaming application. This is indeed a remarkable opportunity to recall Weaver's classification and define three fundamental problems in VR systems: i) responsiveness, ii) timeliness, and iii) effectiveness. Responsiveness refers to the delay between an action in the physical world and its display in the virtual world. Timeliness is related to the frequency of updates imposed by the frame rate. Effectiveness considers the visual content of a video frame and its likelihood of extrapolation. Our framework offers a concise and objective description of VR systems, that allows us to evaluate performance, identify potential issues, and design impactful solutions., This work was partially funded by Wi-XR PID2021-123995NB-I00 (MCIU/AEI/FEDER,UE), and by MCIN/AEI under the Maria de Maeztu Units of Excellence Programme (CEX2021-001195-M).