DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publicación
Artículo científico (JournalArticle)
Why dignity is a troubling concept for AI ethics
We have argued that dignity is an overly
complex concept to be used loosely in
AI ethics. Dignity is open to different conceptualizations, so an unspecific use of
this notion is undesirable. Likewise, dignity is sometimes used as a mere slogan
and for inflammatory purposes to oppose
certain technological developments in a
way that is not necessarily rational. In
other situations, furthermore, appeals to
dignity are used as proxies for other
ethical arguments. And debates about
the moral status of AI may increasingly
co-opt the concept, perhaps forcing us
to rethink the foundations of human
dignity.
Other reasons may merit more attention
in the future. Especially, is dignity indispensable for the development of a global
approach to AI ethics? While human dignity is an important bedrock of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, the
concept of dignity has clear roots in Western philosophy and Christian tradition.10
There is cultural variation in the interpretations of human dignity too.12 So, in future
contributions, the potential of dignity as a
universal category for global AI ethics
should be reconsidered.
In closing, wording choice is not an
aseptic decision in AI ethics. Progress
in ethical discussions often requires
conceptual progress. To be sure, ethical
terms are open to various conceptualizations and there may be various legitimate uses. But vaguely using complex
terms that have multiple nuances, such
as dignity, may do a disservice to AI
ethics., J.R.'s work is funded by the European Commission – NextGenerationEU, through Momentum CSIC Programme: Develop Your Digital Talent. J.R., J.I.d.V., F.L., and J.L.A. thank the funding of the project AutAI (grant PID2022-137953OB-I00), supported by the State Research Agency of the Spanish Government (MICIU/AEI/10.13039/501100011033) and ERDF, EU. HORIZON-MSCA Doctoral Networks program (grant agreement 101168724) and empoderDAT: Empoderamiento del paciente, espacio de datos de salud e inteligencia artificial como pilares del nuevo sistema sanitario Fundación Séneca-Agencia de Ciencia y Tecnología de la Región de Murcia (grant number 22041/PI/22). B.L. and T.A. acknowledge funding from Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation through project VAE Value-Awareness Engineering TED2021-131295B-C31. J.L.A. has also benefited from a research contract FPU (FPU22/03178), funded by the Spanish Ministry of Science. H.M. has received funding from the European Research Council (ERC) under the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme (grant agreement no. 919841 . acknowledges the support of the Basque Government, Ayudas a grupos de investigación, Grupo de Investigación, IT 1541-22, and research project GODAS, PID2022-137140OB-I00, funded by MCIN/AEI/10.13039/501100011033/FEDER, UE. We also thank the audience of Rio de Janeiro for their insightful comments on a previous presentation of this work., Peer reviewed