DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publicación
Artículo científico (JournalArticle)
The need for mechanistic explanations in (seed) ecology
The increasing availability of global-scale data on plant traits (e.g. Kattge et al., 2020), species distribution (e.g. GBIF.org), climate variables (e.g. Fick & Hijmans, 2017), sophisticated numerical methods (e.g. machine learning tools, R packages) and computing power (e.g. cloud computing) has enabled researchers to understand our biosphere in an unprecedented manner (Farley et al., 2018). However, these techno-scientific advances come with a cost. Researchers with sufficient technical skills in data management can now study global patterns and produce numerically sophisticated and apparently robust papers, without a clear hypothesis to test nor attempt to interpret any patterns from a mechanistic perspective. In addition, these broad-scale analyses tend to use the most readily available data rather than necessarily the most relevant data. This is further fuelled by the growing culture that values ‘fast’ science over research that may take years to complete (the publish-or-perish culture; Sarewitz, 2016). As a consequence, there is an increase in research based on correlating ‘everything’ to see if any patterns emerge, instead of a hypothesis-driven approach (see Calude & Longo, 2017 for examples of spurious correlations). An outcome for plant ecology is that key factors in determining plant fitness, such as fire regime, light availability, herbivory, pollinator availability and other biotic interactions, are underconsidered in broad-scale studies, as they are less available than climate information, in particular. This is exacerbated by the long-standing belief that climate is the major factor shaping ecological patterns (Pausas & Bond, 2019; Brown et al., 2023). Studying global-scale patterns also tends to hide biological mechanisms, as these act at local scales and may vary across environments; thus, broad-brush approaches may mask key local processes.
In this letter, we highlight the potential for broad-scale correlative studies that ignore mechanisms to hinder progress in ecology. We specifically focus on seed dormancy, but we also provide a few other recent examples to illustrate that this is currently a general problem in ecological studies., This research has been performed under the framework of the projects FocScales (Promteo/2021/040,
Generalitat Valenciana) and DISTEPIC (PID2022-141530NBC21, Ministerio de Ciencia e Innovaci on, Spain)., Peer reviewed