Pasar al contenido principal

PLASTICIDAD FENOTIPICA DEL RENDIMIENTO Y CALIDAD DE TRIGO EN RESPUESTA A ‘GOLPES DE CALOR’ EN FASES REPRODUCTIVAS DE GENOTIPOS CONTRASTANTES

RTI2018-096213-B-I00

•
Nombre agencia financiadora Agencia Estatal de Investigación
Acrónimo agencia financiadora AEI
Programa Programa Estatal de I+D+i Orientado a los Retos de la Sociedad
Convocatoria Proyectos I+D+i Retos de Investigación
Año convocatoria 2018
Plan Estatal 2017-2020 Plan Estatal de Investigación Científica y Técnica y de Innovación
Centro beneficiario UNIVERSIDAD DE LLEIDA

Resultados relacionados

Resultados totales (Incluyendo duplicados): 25
Encontrada(s) 1 página(s)

Repositori Obert UdL
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Are portable polyethylene tents reliable for imposing heat treatments in field-grown wheat?

  • Kim, Jinwook
  • Slafer, Gustavo A.
  • Savin, Roxana
Environmental variability has increased in recent decades and there are high expectations that heat waves will affect wheat productivity. Therefore, methods to quantify the effects of high temperature on wheat growth, yield, and yield-related traits under field conditions are greatly needed. In this opinion paper, we first describe the different approaches to quantify these effects, briefly highlighting their pros and cons. Portable polyethylene tents over the plots are cost-effective and convenient when relatively large plots are preferred and/or when there is no access to electricity in the field. This method shares a drawback with other approaches due to the tent reducing light intensity and altering other environmental factors like wind, humidity and evapotranspiration. We discuss to what degree there is an actual confounding effect (incorrectly assigning changes to heat effects that might be in part due to lower radiation). In that context, we not only discuss the issue theoretically, but also present results from a field experiment comparing a control (open uncovered plot), and a "roof-only" treatment (covering the plot with a polyethylene roof alone; thus impacting incoming radiation but not temperature). These treatments were imposed at either booting or the onset of grain filling, and testing two wheat cultivars having contrasting grain numbers per m2 and average grain weight. Supporting a theoretical framework that this reduced radiation would be compensated by increased radiation use efficiency, we show empirically that the roof-only treatment (which reduced incoming photosynthetically active radiation by 10.7 ± 0.2 % at noon on sunny days, but did not alter the temperature at any time of the day) did not result in any yield penalty with respect to the uncovered control plots. Thus, portable polyethylene tents are a reliable method to impose heat treatments in field experiments. Although other methods are more sophisticated and may be perceived as having fewer confounding factors, portable polyethylene tents are ideally suited to irrigated field experiments where electricity is not available, where relatively large plots are needed, and for research carried out on a limited budget., Funding was provided by project RTI2018-096213-B-100 funded by the Spanish State Research Agency (AEI). Jinwook Kim held a pre-doctoral research contract from AGAUR (the Agency for Management of University and Research Grants of Catalonia).
Repositori Obert UdL
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Weight of individual wheat grains estimated from high-throughput digital images of grain area

  • Kim, Jinwook
  • Savin, Roxana
  • Slafer, Gustavo A.
Average grain weight (AGW) is a major component of wheat yield. When attempting to elucidate mechanisms behind treatments effects on AGW, the distribution of the weight of individual grains may be critical. Determining the individual weight of thousands of grains in each sample would be unmanageable. Then, when individual sizes must be considered, researchers either weigh individually a very minor proportion of the grains or determine for the complete sample individual linear dimensions (length, width, area) through an image processing equipment. We aimed to generate a single model equation to trustworthily convert grain linear dimensions to grain weights. Firstly, we used a set of data to build and calibrate a model for the relationship between weight and linear dimensions of individual grains. Then, we validated the model calibrated with independent data. Grain area was a better predictor of grain weight than length and width of grains. Initially, we generated a single linear model but (i) the intercept was incongruently negative and therefore (ii) we forced the linear regression through the origin, but that consistently overestimated the weight of small grains and underestimated large grains. Finally, we fitted the data again with a power curve model and forced the intercept to zero (with the log-transformed data) obtaining the model (ŷ = x1.32) to estimate individual grain weight from grain area. The model was validated with (i) independent data from the same studies used to build the model, (ii) data from other completely independent experiments, and (iii) data from the literature. Considering the diversity of genotypes and environments in the model generation and validation, the proposed power curve model could be trustworthily used to estimate grain weights from measured areas., Funding was provided by projects AGL2015-69595R and RTI2018-096213-B-100 funded by the Agencia Estatal de Investigación (AEI) of Spain. Jinwook Kim held a pre-doctoral research contract from AGAUR (the Agency for Management of University and Research Grants of Catalonia).
Repositori Obert UdL
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Extreme treatments and data overinterpretation could lead to the unjustified conclusion that crop yield is source-limited during the effective grain filling

  • Savin, Roxana
  • Serrago, Román A.
  • Miralles, Daniel J.
  • Tamagno, Santiago
  • Calderini, Daniel F.
  • Sadras, Victor O.
  • Slafer, Gustavo A.
Understanding the physiology of crop yield is important to inform both agronomy and breeding. In grain crops, there is consensus in the interpretation of data, further supported by theory, to conclude that grain number is source-limited; this accounts for the strong correlation of yield and grain number, and the high phenotypic plasticity of grain number due to source limitation. However, whether grain weight during the effective grain filling period is source- or sink-limited remains debatable. This lack of consensus is commonly interpreted as variation associated with the interaction between genotype and environment. In this opinion paper, we argue that part of the inconsistency in the literature may stem from overinterpretation of experimental results, extreme treatments (e.g., 50–90 % shading), and the assumptions of linearity to conclude that grain weight is source-limited during the effective grain filling. A central flaw is the unjustified extrapolation of conclusions from manipulated plants to the unmanipulated real crop. We review the outcomes of both direct and indirect manipulations of source–sink ratios during the effective grain filling across grain crops with a focus on methods and interpretation of results. Indirect approaches that increase or reduce grain number to measure grain weight compensation (e.g., shading or thinning the plots during the critical period of grain number determination) are ill-suited because they influence potential grain size and grain size hierarchies, confounding interpretation of the grain weight–grain number relationship. Direct manipulations of source–sink ratio that do not alter grain weight (e.g., shading or de-graining plants during the effective grain filling), provide strong evidence that grain growth in the intact control is sink-limited. Conversely, when grain weight changes significantly in response to severe manipulation, the only valid conclusion is that the manipulated plants were source-limited; it is not justified to reach conclusions on the intact control crop. These considerations call for a more cautious interpretation of experimental data where direct manipulation of the source-sink ratio leads to a significant change in grain weight, and suggest a re-evaluation of experimental and analytical methods are needed to conclude on the nature of grain weight limitation., This work was done without specific funding, but it was based on long lasting research done by the authors on yield physiology of grain crops. Most recent grants on this field were provided by the State Research Agency of Spain (RTI2018-096213-B-100, PID2021-127415OB-I00, and TED2021-130466B-C21), GRDC in Australia (UOQ2402-010RTX, CSP2404-020RTX, and CSP2404-020RTX), ANID in Chile (Fondecyt 1170913, 1211040), Programa de Promoción de la Ciencia de la Universidad de Buenos Aires (Argentina) en el exterior (RECS-2024-1910 E-UBA-REC). ST held a Ramón y Cajal Fellowship (RYC2021-032713-I) co-funded by MICIU/AEI/10.13039/501100011033 and the European Union NextGenerationEU/PRTR.
Repositori Obert UdL
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

A 'Wiring Diagram' for sink-strength traits impacting wheat yield potential

  • Slafer, Gustavo A.
  • Foulkes, M. John
  • Reynolds, Matthew P.
  • Murchie, Erik
  • Carmo-Silva, Elizabete
  • Flavell, Richard B.
  • Gwyn, Jeff
  • Sawkins, Mark
  • Griffiths, Simon
Identifying traits for improving sink-strength is a bottleneck to increasing wheat yield. The interacting processes determining sink-strength and yield potential are reviewed and visualized in a set of 'Wiring Diagrams', covering critical phases of development (and summarizing known underlying genetics). Using this framework, we reviewed and assembled the main traits determining sink-strength and identified research gaps and potential hypotheses to be tested for achieving gains in sink-strength. In pre-anthesis grain number could be increased through: (i) enhanced spike growth associated with optimized floret development and/or a reduction in specific stem-internode lengths and (ii) improved fruiting efficiency through accelerated rate of floret development, improved partitioning between spike or optimized spike cytokinin levels. In post-anthesis grain sink-strength could be augmented through manipulation of grain size potential via ovary size and/or endosperm cell division and expansion. Prospects for improving spike vascular architecture to support all rapidly growing florets, enabling the improved flow of assimilate, are also discussed. Finally, we considered the prospects for enhancing grain weight realization in relation to genetic variation in stay-green traits as well as stem carbohydrate remobilization. The Wiring Diagrams provide a potential workspace for breeders and crop scientists to achieve yield gains in wheat and other field crops., Research of the authors on physiology and genetics of wheat yield potential has been funded by many different sources over the years. Most recent grants include the International Wheat Yield Partnership (IWYP) projects funded by the Biotechnology and Biological Research Council of the UK (e.g., IWYP48 BB/N021061/1, IWYP64 BB/ N020871/2, IWYP163 BB/S005072/1, and IWYP25FP), as well as projects funded by other donors (State Research Agency of Spain: AGL2015-69595-R and RTI2018-096213-B-100).
Repositori Obert UdL
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Yield and grain number formation as affected by pre- and post-anthesis heat waves and thinning in two contrasting wheat cultivars

  • Bicego, Breno
  • Kim, Jinwook
  • Savin, Roxana
  • Slafer, Gustavo A.
Context Wheat is essential to global food security however climate change threatens its yield. While the impacts of gradual temperature increases are known, the effects of heat waves (HW), which are becoming more frequent and severe, are less understood particularly under field conditions. This study explores the impact of pre- and post-anthesis (AN) HW on grain yield (GY), grain number (GN), average grain weight (AGW), and physiological determinants of GN. Objectives To quantify the pre- and post-AN HW effects on GY, GN and AGW of two cultivars with constitutive contrasting levels of GN and AGW; to determine whether a higher or lower sensitivity to a HW would be related to genotypic inherent characteristic; and to ascertain whether penalties in GN due to pre-AN HW are direct on reproductive output or indirect by affecting crop growth. Most details on AGW determination are offered in the companion paper. Methods Experiments were irrigated and carried out in two locations of NE Spain. Main treatments consisted in the factorial combination of two contrasting genotypes (Pistolo of high AGW and Sublim of high GN), and three HW that were imposed in the field using portable tents covered with transparent polyethylene films, but with the base opened to favour air circulation, during 9–11 continuous days, increasing temperatures during the day only, which resulted in average daily temperature 3–4 ºC warmer. The HW started either at booting (pre-AN HW) or 15 days after anthesis (post-AN HW). An additional HW (combination of pre- and post-AN HW) was imposed in one location while thinning treatment at the onset of stem elongation in the other. Results Under unheated conditions, both cultivars had similarly high yields. The increment of yield potential with thinning was lower in Pistolo (33 %) than Sublim (79 %). Both cultivars had similar spike number plasticity, but only Sublim showed spike fertility plasticity to added resources as well. HW significantly reduced GY: Pistolo was more sensitive to pre-AN HW, but not to post-AN HW. Yield losses were mainly due to reduced GN with pre-AN HW, and reduced AGW with post-AN HW. Pre-AN HW increased floret mortality mostly in central spikelets, while thinning boosted floret survival, especially in distal spikelets, restoring fertility even in typically sterile basal spikelets. Thinning reduced HW damage in Pistolo from 18 % to 1 %, but not in Sublim (c. 14 % in both conditions). This implies that HW effects could be mainly indirect, through affecting growth, or mainly direct, affecting floret developmental process (and not reversed when more assimilates become available), depending on the genotype. Post-AN HW caused greater GY penalties (24.8 %) than pre-AN HW (15.1 %), but this seemed related to environmental variation during treatments than a true greater sensitivity. More in depth analyses regarding AGW is provided in the companion paper. Conclusions The HW treatment consistently reduced yield, with GN mainly affected when applied pre-anthesis and AGW when imposed during grain filling. However, the magnitude of these penalties differed between genotypes and seemed to be resource driven in one but not in the other genotype. This indicates that a pre-AN HW can impair spike fertility and consequently grain yield, and that genotype-specific responses may reflect direct effects on reproduction or indirect effects via reduced source strength. Responses to HW seemed not to be a genotypic constitutive characteristic, as the response changes between cultivars depending on the timing of the HW and the GY strategies, making breeding for HW resilience less straightforward. Implication Breeding programs should not solely consider the particular yield component strategies when selecting for yield stability under stress. The plasticity to resource availability seemed unrelated to that for HW., Funding was provided by projects RTI2018–096213-B-100 and PID2021- 127415OB-I00 funded by the Spanish State Research Agency (AEI). BB held a FPI contract from the Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation and JK held a pre-doctoral research contract from AGAUR (the Agency for Management of University and Research Grants of Catalonia).
Repositori Obert UdL
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Quantifying pre- and post-anthesis heat waves on grain number and grain weight of contrasting wheat cultivars

  • Kim, Jinwook
  • Savin, Roxana
  • Slafer, Gustavo A.
Context or problem: Further increasing wheat productivity is more challenging due to consistently rising temperatures. Heat stress negatively affects both grain number per m2 (GN) and average grain weight (AGW). It is not clear whether the sensitivity of these components differ, nor whether it would be related to the relevance of the component for determining unstressed yield in the particular cultivar. Objective or research question: The aim of this study was to elucidate the plasticity of GN and AGW in response to heat waves at pre-anthesis; and post-anthesis under different source-sink ratios. Methods: The field experiments were carried out in two different locations of Catalonia (NE Spain). We selected two contrasting genotypes (Pistolo and Sublim) for the relevance of GN and AGW and analysed in detail (i) the causes for their differences in AGW and (ii) their GN and AGW responses to heat wave stress (HT). The HT treatments were imposed in the field using portable tents with transparent polyethylene films at either at booting (pre-AN HT) or 15 days after anthesis (post-AN HT) for 7 days, with a delta in maximum temperature of c. 5ºC. In addition, we increased source-sink ratios in the control and post-AN HT treatments by removing all spikelets on one side of the spike (de-graining) 14 days after anthesis. Results: Pistolo had always less but heavier grains than Sublim. The differences in AGW were constitutive, rather reflecting a trade-off with GN, as there was no scarcity of resources to satisfy the demands of the growing grains in any of the two cultivars. Exposing the crops to heat stress at pre- and post-anthesis resulted in yield penalties, but yield was more sensitive to pre-AN HT than to post-AN HT, consistently across both locations and genotypes. The reduction of GN per spike was mainly mediated through grain abortion rather than through mortality of floret primordia. The reduction of AGW caused by post-AN HT was not related to source strength changes, but due to a direct effect reducing potential grain weight (PGW) per se. There seemed to be a trend for the cultivar constitutively producing more grains having less sensitivity of GN to pre-AN HT, and for the cultivar constitutively having heavier grains having less sensitivity of AGW to post-AN HT. Conclusions: The reduction of AGW caused by post-AN HT was not related to source strength changes, but due to a direct effect reducing potential grain weight. The plasticity of a yield component in response to heat stress was inversely related to the relevance of that component for yield determination in unheated conditions. Implications or significance: Our result would open an opportunity for breeders to select for improved sink-strength through either higher GN or higher PGW depending on the timing and frequency of the most damaging heat waves., We thank Albert Morera at University of Lleida who provided advanced R coding for data analysis. Funding was provided by projects AGL2015-69595R and RTI2018-096213-B-100 funded by the Agencia Estatal de Investigación (AEI) of Spain. Jinwook Kim held a pre-doctoral research contract from AGAUR (the Agency for Management of University and Research Grants of Catalonia).
Repositori Obert UdL
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

A ‘wiring diagram’ for source strength traits impacting wheat yield potential

  • Murchie, Erik
  • Reynolds, Matthew P.
  • Slafer, Gustavo A.
  • Foulkes, M. John
  • Acevedo-Siaca, Liana
  • McAusland, Lorna
  • Sharwood, Robert
  • Griffiths, Simon
  • Flavell, Richard B.
  • Gwyn, Jeff
  • Sawkins, Mark
  • Carmo-Silva, Elizabete
Source traits are currently of great interest for the enhancement of yield potential; for example, much effort is being expended to find ways of modifying photosynthesis. However, photosynthesis is but one component of crop regulation, so sink activities and the coordination of diverse processes throughout the crop must be considered in an integrated, systems approach. A set of ‘wiring diagrams’ has been devised as a visual tool to integrate the interactions of component processes at different stages of wheat development. They enable the roles of chloroplast, leaf, and whole-canopy processes to be seen in the context of sink development and crop growth as a whole. In this review, we dissect source traits both anatomically (foliar and non-foliar) and temporally (pre- and post-anthesis), and consider the evidence for their regulation at local and whole-plant/crop levels. We consider how the formation of a canopy creates challenges (self-occlusion) and opportunities (dynamic photosynthesis) for components of photosynthesis. Lastly, we discuss the regulation of source activity by feedback regulation. The review is written in the framework of the wiring diagrams which, as integrated descriptors of traits underpinning grain yield, are designed to provide a potential workspace for breeders and other crop scientists that, along with high-throughput and precision phenotyping data, genetics, and bioinformatics, will help build future dynamic models of trait and gene interactions to achieve yield gains in wheat and other field crops., Research of the authors on physiology and genetics of wheat yield potential has been funded by many different sources over the years. Recent grants include the International Wheat Yield Partnership (IWYP) projects funded by the Biotechnology and Biological Research Council of the UK [BB/N021061/1, BB/ N020871/2, BB/S005072/1] (IWYP48, IWYP64, IWYP163 and IWYP25FP, respectively), as well as projects funded by other donors (State Research Agency of Spain: AGL2015-69595-R and RTI2018-096213-B-100).
Repositori Obert UdL
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Comparative performance of barley and wheat across a wide range of yielding conditions. Does barley outyield wheat consistently in low-yielding conditions?

  • Slafer, Gustavo A.
  • Savin, Roxana
There is a generalised belief that barley is more resilient to stress than wheat. Consequently, land allocation to wheat and barley is based on a presumed differential sensitivity to stresses between these species. Previous field experiments showed that yield of both crops tended to be similar under both low- and high-productivity conditions under Mediterranean environments, but in some particular studies barley advantages are reported. Therefore, the aim of this study was to determine the comparative performance of wheat and barley across a wide range of conditions through the literature published over the first 20 years of this century considering exclusively studies where both cereals had been grown side-by-side in field experiments. We compiled a rigorous database from papers of high-standard journals reporting actual yield data (we excluded simulated yields) measured in experiments under field conditions where both crops were grown side-by-side in the same experiment (excluding studies analysing wheat and barley grown separately). Yield distribution for both species across studies was symmetrical with an average of c. 440 g m−2 and a range from c. 50-900 g m−2. The yields of the lowest quartile ranged from 58 to 293 g m−2, being the comparison of performance in this quartile suitable for detecting differences in low-yielding conditions. Considering individual papers, it is possible to identify any possible outcome of the differential performance of these cereals. However, considering all papers together it was clear that there was not a consistent advantage of barley over wheat at most stressful conditions. Indeed, at very low yielding conditions wheat tended to outyield barley. The trends described above were not influenced by the data-points based on comparisons of barley with the tetraploid wheats, nor by our own experimental data-points. Thus, we confirm in this review that barley does not consistently outyield wheat under low yielding conditions, despite the generalised belief that it does., We are grateful to Prof Ignacio Romagosa (University of Lleida and AGROTECNIO) for generous advice on statistical procedures. Research of the authors on wheat and barley yield physiology has been funded along years by many different grants from different funding bodies; most recently mainly from the Spanish State Agency for Research (latest projects were RTI2018–096213-B-100 and PID2021–127415OB-I00 on wheat and PCI2019–103536 on barley).
Repositori Obert UdL
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Wheat yield is not causally related to the duration of the growing season.

  • Slafer, Gustavo A.
  • Savin, Roxana
  • Sadras, Víctor O.
A common conceptual model for crop growth analysis assumes biomass is proportional to the accumulation of radiation intercepted by the canopy during the growing season, and yield is the product of biomass and harvest index. This model assumes that biomass and harvest index are independent, and that biomass has the same value for yield across developmental stages; here we focus on the latter assumption. A corollary of this model is that yield and duration of the growing season are causally related. In this article, we analyse the evidence for and against this causal relationship. We use both a physiological perspective and agronomic evidence to challenge this causality. An alternative, phenology-focused model is outlined that is based on the following principles: crops accommodate environmental variation through grain number, grain number is defined in a species-specific critical developmental period, and grain number is a function of three traits in the critical period: duration, growth rate, and partitioning to reproduction. Against this framework, we analyse dual purpose wheat, where a substantial part of the biomass is removed, effectively shortening the growing season, with little or no effect on yield; timing of nitrogen fertilisation, where delayed application reduces the growth rate early in the season, with little or no effect on yield; and the correlation between season length and yield of winter wheat and spring wheat - wheat yield in Southern Chile, with a sowing-to-maturity season of ∼ 5 months, could be as high as that of winter wheat in the UK, with a sowing-to-maturity season of ∼ 10 months. Physiological principles and agronomic evidence support the conclusion that the duration of, and growth rate and partitioning during the critical period, rather than the duration of the growing season, are the drivers of wheat yield., This study had not specific funding, but many sources have funded the research of the authors on yield physiology over the years. Most recent grants include projects funded by the State Research Agency of Spain (RTI2018–096213-B-100, PID2021–127415OB-I00) and by SARDI-GRDC bilateral (DAS00166_BA).
Repositori Obert UdL
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Awned versus awnless wheat spikes: does it matter?

  • Sanchez-Bragado, Rut
  • Molero, Gemma
  • Araus Ortega, José Luis
  • Slafer, Gustavo A.
Awnless and awned wheat is found across the globe. Archeological and historical records show that the wheat spike was predominantly awned across the many millennia following domestication. Thus, ancient farmers did not select against awns at least until the last millennium. Here, we describe the evolution and domestication of wheat awns, quantifying their role in spike photosynthesis and yield under contrasting environments. Awns increase grain weight directly (increasing the size of all grains) or indirectly (increasing the failure of distal grains), but not as a consequence of additional spike photosynthesis. However, a trade-off is produced through decreasing grain number. Thus, favorable effects of awns on yield are not consistently found across environments., The authors’ research on wheat yield physiology has been funded by many different sources and we are grateful to all of them. The latest projects on wheat yield physiology were RTI2018-096213-B-100 and PID2019-106650RB-C21 (both funded by the State Agency for Research of Spain). J.L.A. also acknowledges the support of ICREA Acadèmia Generalitat de Catalunya, Spain.
Repositori Obert UdL
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Physiological drivers of responses of grains per m(2) to environmental and genetic factors in wheat

  • Slafer, Gustavo A.
  • García, Guillermo A.
  • Serrago, Román A.
  • Miralles, Daniel J.
Most of the required increases in food production over the next decades are expected to be achieved through increases in crop yield. As wheat is essential for food security it is worrying that its yield gains over the last two decades were small. To achieve further yield increases it is critical to continue increasing number of grains per unit area (GN m(-2)), the trait best related to yield. In this context, it is relevant to identify the main determinants of GN m(-2) in response to genetic and environmental factors as well as the trade-offs between them. In the present study we compiled a large database across the literature to analyse the relative importance of components when affected by genetic or environmental factors, producing small or large changes in GN m(-2) and its components, either numerical (the number of spikes per m(2), SN m(-2); and the number of grains per spike, GN spike(-1)) or physiological (spike dry weight at anthesis, SDWa; and fruiting efficiency, FE) determinants. The database included 367 papers published in: (i) Field Crop Research (FCR), (ii) European Journal of Agronomy (EJA), (iii) Crop Science (CS) and (iv) Crop and Pasture Science (CPS, formerly Australian Journal of Agricultural Research) between 1990 and 2020. The complete dataset was split into classes, depending on the source of experimental variation, environment or genotype and was normalised to remove the differences between experiments and determine the environmental and genotypic effects within each experiment. Normalised data showed that the responsiveness of GN m(-2)was similarly explained by changes in both SN m(-2) and GN spike(-1), but in terms of physiological components SDWa was more relevant than FE for explaining the variations in GN m(-2). Considering the numerical components of GN m(-2) genotypic and environmental factors modified more GN spike(-1) than in SN m(-2). On the other hand, physiological components were differently modified by genotype and environment: for genotypic effects FE was more critical than SDWa and the other way around for environmental factors. A tradeoff between numerical and physiological components was observed although was greater between physiological than between numerical components., Research of the authors on wheat yield physiology has been funded along years by many different grants from different funding bodies; most recently mainly from (i) the International Wheat Yield Partnership (IWYP25FP) , (ii) , the Spanish State Agency for Research (latest project was RTI2018-096213-B-100) , and (iii) Argentine Fund for Scientific and Technological Research (latest project PICT RAICES 2019-04333) .
Repositori Obert UdL
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Sense in sensitivity: difference in the meaning of photoperiod insensitivity between wheat and barley

  • Slafer, Gustavo A.
  • Casas, Ana M.
  • Igartua, Ernesto
The description of long photoperiod sensitivity in wheat and barley is a cause of confusion for researchers working with these crops, usually accustomed to free exchange of physiological and genetic knowledge of such similar crops. Indeed, wheat and barley scientists customarily quote studies of either crop species when researching one of them. Among their numerous similarities, the main gene controlling the long photoperiod sensitivity is the same in both crops (PPD1; PPD-H1 in barley and PPD-D1 in hexaploid wheat). However, the photoperiod responses are different: (i) the main dominant allele inducing shorter time to anthesis is the insensitive allele in wheat (Ppd-D1a) but the sensitive allele in barley (Ppd-H1) (i.e. sensitivity to photoperiod produces opposite effects on time to heading in wheat and barley); (ii) the main ‘insensitive’ allele in wheat, Ppd-D1a, does confer insensitivity, whilst that of barley reduces the sensitivity but still responds to photoperiod. The different behaviour of PPD1 genes in wheat and barley is put in a common framework based on the similarities and differences of the molecular bases of their mutations, which include polymorphism at gene expression levels, copy number variation, and sequence of coding regions. This common perspective sheds light on a source of confusion for cereal researchers, and prompts us to recommend accounting for the photoperiod sensitivity status of the plant materials when conducting research on genetic control of phenology. Finally, we provide advice to facilitate the management of natural PPD1 diversity in breeding programmes and suggest targets for further modification through gene editing, based on mutual knowledge on the two crops., Research by the authors on the physiology and genetics of wheat and barley has been funded by many different sources over the years. Most recent grants include the PRIMA project GENDIBAR (PCI2019-103536 and PCI2019-103538), and projects funded by the State Research Agency of Spain (AEI) RTI2018-096213-B-100, PID2019 111621 RB-100, and AGL2016-81855-REDT), and grant A08_20R from the government of Aragón
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Sense in sensitivity: difference in the meaning of photoperiod insensitivity between wheat and barley

  • Slafer, Gustavo A.
  • Casas Cendoya, Ana María
  • Igartua Arregui, Ernesto
19 Pags.- 2 Figs., The description of long photoperiod sensitivity in wheat and barley is a cause of confusion for researchers working with these crops, usually accustomed to free exchange of physiological and genetic knowledge of such similar crops. Indeed, wheat and barley scientists customarily quote studies of either crop species when researching one of them. Among their numerous similarities, the main gene controlling the long photoperiod sensitivity is the same in both crops (PPD1; PPD-H1 in barley and PPD-D1 in hexaploid wheat). However, the photoperiod responses are different: (i) the main dominant allele inducing shorter time to anthesis is the insensitive allele in wheat (Ppd-D1a) but the sensitive allele in barley (Ppd-H1) (i.e. sensitivity to photoperiod produces opposite effects on time to heading in wheat and barley); (ii) the main ‘insensitive’ allele in wheat, Ppd-D1a, does confer insensitivity, whilst that of barley reduces the sensitivity but still responds to photoperiod. The different behaviour of PPD1 genes in wheat and barley is put in a common framework based on the similarities and differences of the molecular bases of their mutations, which include polymorphism at gene expression levels, copy number variation, and sequence of coding regions. This common perspective sheds light on a source of confusion for cereal researchers, and prompts us to recommend accounting for the photoperiod sensitivity status of the plant materials when conducting research on genetic control of phenology. Finally, we provide advice to facilitate the management of natural PPD1 diversity in breeding programmes and suggest targets for further modification through gene editing, based on mutual knowledge on the two crops., Research by the authors on the physiology and genetics of wheat and barley has been funded by many different sources over the years. Most recent grants include the PRIMA project GENDIBAR (PCI2019-103536 and PCI2019- 103538), and projects funded by the State Research Agency of Spain (AEI) RTI2018-096213-B-100, PID2019 111621 RB-100, and AGL2016-81855- REDT), and grant A08_20R from the government of Aragón., Peer reviewed
Recercat. Dipósit de la Recerca de Catalunya
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Weight of individual wheat grains estimated from high-throughput digital images of grain area

  • Kim, Jinwook
  • Savin, Roxana
  • Slafer, Gustavo A.
Average grain weight (AGW) is a major component of wheat yield. When attempting to elucidate mechanisms behind treatments effects on AGW, the distribution of the weight of individual grains may be critical. Determining the individual weight of thousands of grains in each sample would be unmanageable. Then, when individual sizes must be considered, researchers either weigh individually a very minor proportion of the grains or determine for the complete sample individual linear dimensions (length, width, area) through an image processing equipment. We aimed to generate a single model equation to trustworthily convert grain linear dimensions to grain weights. Firstly, we used a set of data to build and calibrate a model for the relationship between weight and linear dimensions of individual grains. Then, we validated the model calibrated with independent data. Grain area was a better predictor of grain weight than length and width of grains. Initially, we generated a single linear model but (i) the intercept was incongruently negative and therefore (ii) we forced the linear regression through the origin, but that consistently overestimated the weight of small grains and underestimated large grains. Finally, we fitted the data again with a power curve model and forced the intercept to zero (with the log-transformed data) obtaining the model (ŷ = x1.32) to estimate individual grain weight from grain area. The model was validated with (i) independent data from the same studies used to build the model, (ii) data from other completely independent experiments, and (iii) data from the literature. Considering the diversity of genotypes and environments in the model generation and validation, the proposed power curve model could be trustworthily used to estimate grain weights from measured areas., Funding was provided by projects AGL2015-69595R and RTI2018-096213-B-100 funded by the Agencia Estatal de Investigación (AEI) of Spain. Jinwook Kim held a pre-doctoral research contract from AGAUR (the Agency for Management of University and Research Grants of Catalonia).
Recercat. Dipósit de la Recerca de Catalunya
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Comparative performance of barley and wheat across a wide range of yielding conditions. Does barley outyield wheat consistently in low-yielding conditions?

  • Slafer, Gustavo A.
  • Savin, Roxana
There is a generalised belief that barley is more resilient to stress than wheat. Consequently, land allocation to wheat and barley is based on a presumed differential sensitivity to stresses between these species. Previous field experiments showed that yield of both crops tended to be similar under both low- and high-productivity conditions under Mediterranean environments, but in some particular studies barley advantages are reported. Therefore, the aim of this study was to determine the comparative performance of wheat and barley across a wide range of conditions through the literature published over the first 20 years of this century considering exclusively studies where both cereals had been grown side-by-side in field experiments. We compiled a rigorous database from papers of high-standard journals reporting actual yield data (we excluded simulated yields) measured in experiments under field conditions where both crops were grown side-by-side in the same experiment (excluding studies analysing wheat and barley grown separately). Yield distribution for both species across studies was symmetrical with an average of c. 440 g m−2 and a range from c. 50-900 g m−2. The yields of the lowest quartile ranged from 58 to 293 g m−2, being the comparison of performance in this quartile suitable for detecting differences in low-yielding conditions. Considering individual papers, it is possible to identify any possible outcome of the differential performance of these cereals. However, considering all papers together it was clear that there was not a consistent advantage of barley over wheat at most stressful conditions. Indeed, at very low yielding conditions wheat tended to outyield barley. The trends described above were not influenced by the data-points based on comparisons of barley with the tetraploid wheats, nor by our own experimental data-points. Thus, we confirm in this review that barley does not consistently outyield wheat under low yielding conditions, despite the generalised belief that it does., We are grateful to Prof Ignacio Romagosa (University of Lleida and AGROTECNIO) for generous advice on statistical procedures. Research of the authors on wheat and barley yield physiology has been funded along years by many different grants from different funding bodies; most recently mainly from the Spanish State Agency for Research (latest projects were RTI2018–096213-B-100 and PID2021–127415OB-I00 on wheat and PCI2019–103536 on barley).
Recercat. Dipósit de la Recerca de Catalunya
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Sense in sensitivity: difference in the meaning of photoperiod insensitivity between wheat and barley

  • Slafer, Gustavo A.
  • Casas, Ana M.
  • Igartua, Ernesto
The description of long photoperiod sensitivity in wheat and barley is a cause of confusion for researchers working with these crops, usually accustomed to free exchange of physiological and genetic knowledge of such similar crops. Indeed, wheat and barley scientists customarily quote studies of either crop species when researching one of them. Among their numerous similarities, the main gene controlling the long photoperiod sensitivity is the same in both crops (PPD1; PPD-H1 in barley and PPD-D1 in hexaploid wheat). However, the photoperiod responses are different: (i) the main dominant allele inducing shorter time to anthesis is the insensitive allele in wheat (Ppd-D1a) but the sensitive allele in barley (Ppd-H1) (i.e. sensitivity to photoperiod produces opposite effects on time to heading in wheat and barley); (ii) the main ‘insensitive’ allele in wheat, Ppd-D1a, does confer insensitivity, whilst that of barley reduces the sensitivity but still responds to photoperiod. The different behaviour of PPD1 genes in wheat and barley is put in a common framework based on the similarities and differences of the molecular bases of their mutations, which include polymorphism at gene expression levels, copy number variation, and sequence of coding regions. This common perspective sheds light on a source of confusion for cereal researchers, and prompts us to recommend accounting for the photoperiod sensitivity status of the plant materials when conducting research on genetic control of phenology. Finally, we provide advice to facilitate the management of natural PPD1 diversity in breeding programmes and suggest targets for further modification through gene editing, based on mutual knowledge on the two crops., Research by the authors on the physiology and genetics of wheat and barley has been funded by many different sources over the years. Most recent grants include the PRIMA project GENDIBAR (PCI2019-103536 and PCI2019-103538), and projects funded by the State Research Agency of Spain (AEI) RTI2018-096213-B-100, PID2019 111621 RB-100, and AGL2016-81855-REDT), and grant A08_20R from the government of Aragón
Recercat. Dipósit de la Recerca de Catalunya
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Yield and grain number formation as affected by pre- and post-anthesis heat waves and thinning in two contrasting wheat cultivars

  • Bicego, Breno
  • Kim, Jinwook
  • Savin, Roxana
  • Slafer, Gustavo A.
Context Wheat is essential to global food security however climate change threatens its yield. While the impacts of gradual temperature increases are known, the effects of heat waves (HW), which are becoming more frequent and severe, are less understood particularly under field conditions. This study explores the impact of pre- and post-anthesis (AN) HW on grain yield (GY), grain number (GN), average grain weight (AGW), and physiological determinants of GN. Objectives To quantify the pre- and post-AN HW effects on GY, GN and AGW of two cultivars with constitutive contrasting levels of GN and AGW; to determine whether a higher or lower sensitivity to a HW would be related to genotypic inherent characteristic; and to ascertain whether penalties in GN due to pre-AN HW are direct on reproductive output or indirect by affecting crop growth. Most details on AGW determination are offered in the companion paper. Methods Experiments were irrigated and carried out in two locations of NE Spain. Main treatments consisted in the factorial combination of two contrasting genotypes (Pistolo of high AGW and Sublim of high GN), and three HW that were imposed in the field using portable tents covered with transparent polyethylene films, but with the base opened to favour air circulation, during 9–11 continuous days, increasing temperatures during the day only, which resulted in average daily temperature 3–4 ºC warmer. The HW started either at booting (pre-AN HW) or 15 days after anthesis (post-AN HW). An additional HW (combination of pre- and post-AN HW) was imposed in one location while thinning treatment at the onset of stem elongation in the other. Results Under unheated conditions, both cultivars had similarly high yields. The increment of yield potential with thinning was lower in Pistolo (33 %) than Sublim (79 %). Both cultivars had similar spike number plasticity, but only Sublim showed spike fertility plasticity to added resources as well. HW significantly reduced GY: Pistolo was more sensitive to pre-AN HW, but not to post-AN HW. Yield losses were mainly due to reduced GN with pre-AN HW, and reduced AGW with post-AN HW. Pre-AN HW increased floret mortality mostly in central spikelets, while thinning boosted floret survival, especially in distal spikelets, restoring fertility even in typically sterile basal spikelets. Thinning reduced HW damage in Pistolo from 18 % to 1 %, but not in Sublim (c. 14 % in both conditions). This implies that HW effects could be mainly indirect, through affecting growth, or mainly direct, affecting floret developmental process (and not reversed when more assimilates become available), depending on the genotype. Post-AN HW caused greater GY penalties (24.8 %) than pre-AN HW (15.1 %), but this seemed related to environmental variation during treatments than a true greater sensitivity. More in depth analyses regarding AGW is provided in the companion paper. Conclusions The HW treatment consistently reduced yield, with GN mainly affected when applied pre-anthesis and AGW when imposed during grain filling. However, the magnitude of these penalties differed between genotypes and seemed to be resource driven in one but not in the other genotype. This indicates that a pre-AN HW can impair spike fertility and consequently grain yield, and that genotype-specific responses may reflect direct effects on reproduction or indirect effects via reduced source strength. Responses to HW seemed not to be a genotypic constitutive characteristic, as the response changes between cultivars depending on the timing of the HW and the GY strategies, making breeding for HW resilience less straightforward. Implication Breeding programs should not solely consider the particular yield component strategies when selecting for yield stability under stress. The plasticity to resource availability seemed unrelated to that for HW., Funding was provided by projects RTI2018–096213-B-100 and PID2021- 127415OB-I00 funded by the Spanish State Research Agency (AEI). BB held a FPI contract from the Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation and JK held a pre-doctoral research contract from AGAUR (the Agency for Management of University and Research Grants of Catalonia).
Recercat. Dipósit de la Recerca de Catalunya
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Quantifying pre- and post-anthesis heat waves on grain number and grain weight of contrasting wheat cultivars

  • Kim, Jinwook
  • Savin, Roxana
  • Slafer, Gustavo A.
Context or problem: Further increasing wheat productivity is more challenging due to consistently rising temperatures. Heat stress negatively affects both grain number per m2 (GN) and average grain weight (AGW). It is not clear whether the sensitivity of these components differ, nor whether it would be related to the relevance of the component for determining unstressed yield in the particular cultivar. Objective or research question: The aim of this study was to elucidate the plasticity of GN and AGW in response to heat waves at pre-anthesis; and post-anthesis under different source-sink ratios. Methods: The field experiments were carried out in two different locations of Catalonia (NE Spain). We selected two contrasting genotypes (Pistolo and Sublim) for the relevance of GN and AGW and analysed in detail (i) the causes for their differences in AGW and (ii) their GN and AGW responses to heat wave stress (HT). The HT treatments were imposed in the field using portable tents with transparent polyethylene films at either at booting (pre-AN HT) or 15 days after anthesis (post-AN HT) for 7 days, with a delta in maximum temperature of c. 5ºC. In addition, we increased source-sink ratios in the control and post-AN HT treatments by removing all spikelets on one side of the spike (de-graining) 14 days after anthesis. Results: Pistolo had always less but heavier grains than Sublim. The differences in AGW were constitutive, rather reflecting a trade-off with GN, as there was no scarcity of resources to satisfy the demands of the growing grains in any of the two cultivars. Exposing the crops to heat stress at pre- and post-anthesis resulted in yield penalties, but yield was more sensitive to pre-AN HT than to post-AN HT, consistently across both locations and genotypes. The reduction of GN per spike was mainly mediated through grain abortion rather than through mortality of floret primordia. The reduction of AGW caused by post-AN HT was not related to source strength changes, but due to a direct effect reducing potential grain weight (PGW) per se. There seemed to be a trend for the cultivar constitutively producing more grains having less sensitivity of GN to pre-AN HT, and for the cultivar constitutively having heavier grains having less sensitivity of AGW to post-AN HT. Conclusions: The reduction of AGW caused by post-AN HT was not related to source strength changes, but due to a direct effect reducing potential grain weight. The plasticity of a yield component in response to heat stress was inversely related to the relevance of that component for yield determination in unheated conditions. Implications or significance: Our result would open an opportunity for breeders to select for improved sink-strength through either higher GN or higher PGW depending on the timing and frequency of the most damaging heat waves., We thank Albert Morera at University of Lleida who provided advanced R coding for data analysis. Funding was provided by projects AGL2015-69595R and RTI2018-096213-B-100 funded by the Agencia Estatal de Investigación (AEI) of Spain. Jinwook Kim held a pre-doctoral research contract from AGAUR (the Agency for Management of University and Research Grants of Catalonia).
Recercat. Dipósit de la Recerca de Catalunya
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

A ‘wiring diagram’ for source strength traits impacting wheat yield potential

  • Murchie, Erik
  • Reynolds, Matthew P.
  • Slafer, Gustavo A.
  • Foulkes, M. John
  • Acevedo-Siaca, Liana
  • McAusland, Lorna
  • Sharwood, Robert
  • Griffiths, Simon
  • Flavell, Richard B.
  • Gwyn, Jeff
  • Sawkins, Mark
  • Carmo-Silva, Elizabete
Source traits are currently of great interest for the enhancement of yield potential; for example, much effort is being expended to find ways of modifying photosynthesis. However, photosynthesis is but one component of crop regulation, so sink activities and the coordination of diverse processes throughout the crop must be considered in an integrated, systems approach. A set of ‘wiring diagrams’ has been devised as a visual tool to integrate the interactions of component processes at different stages of wheat development. They enable the roles of chloroplast, leaf, and whole-canopy processes to be seen in the context of sink development and crop growth as a whole. In this review, we dissect source traits both anatomically (foliar and non-foliar) and temporally (pre- and post-anthesis), and consider the evidence for their regulation at local and whole-plant/crop levels. We consider how the formation of a canopy creates challenges (self-occlusion) and opportunities (dynamic photosynthesis) for components of photosynthesis. Lastly, we discuss the regulation of source activity by feedback regulation. The review is written in the framework of the wiring diagrams which, as integrated descriptors of traits underpinning grain yield, are designed to provide a potential workspace for breeders and other crop scientists that, along with high-throughput and precision phenotyping data, genetics, and bioinformatics, will help build future dynamic models of trait and gene interactions to achieve yield gains in wheat and other field crops., Research of the authors on physiology and genetics of wheat yield potential has been funded by many different sources over the years. Recent grants include the International Wheat Yield Partnership (IWYP) projects funded by the Biotechnology and Biological Research Council of the UK [BB/N021061/1, BB/ N020871/2, BB/S005072/1] (IWYP48, IWYP64, IWYP163 and IWYP25FP, respectively), as well as projects funded by other donors (State Research Agency of Spain: AGL2015-69595-R and RTI2018-096213-B-100).
Recercat. Dipósit de la Recerca de Catalunya
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Extreme treatments and data overinterpretation could lead to the unjustified conclusion that crop yield is source-limited during the effective grain filling

  • Savin, Roxana
  • Serrago, Román A.
  • Miralles, Daniel J.
  • Tamagno, Santiago
  • Calderini, Daniel F.
  • Sadras, Victor O.
  • Slafer, Gustavo A.
Understanding the physiology of crop yield is important to inform both agronomy and breeding. In grain crops, there is consensus in the interpretation of data, further supported by theory, to conclude that grain number is source-limited; this accounts for the strong correlation of yield and grain number, and the high phenotypic plasticity of grain number due to source limitation. However, whether grain weight during the effective grain filling period is source- or sink-limited remains debatable. This lack of consensus is commonly interpreted as variation associated with the interaction between genotype and environment. In this opinion paper, we argue that part of the inconsistency in the literature may stem from overinterpretation of experimental results, extreme treatments (e.g., 50–90 % shading), and the assumptions of linearity to conclude that grain weight is source-limited during the effective grain filling. A central flaw is the unjustified extrapolation of conclusions from manipulated plants to the unmanipulated real crop. We review the outcomes of both direct and indirect manipulations of source–sink ratios during the effective grain filling across grain crops with a focus on methods and interpretation of results. Indirect approaches that increase or reduce grain number to measure grain weight compensation (e.g., shading or thinning the plots during the critical period of grain number determination) are ill-suited because they influence potential grain size and grain size hierarchies, confounding interpretation of the grain weight–grain number relationship. Direct manipulations of source–sink ratio that do not alter grain weight (e.g., shading or de-graining plants during the effective grain filling), provide strong evidence that grain growth in the intact control is sink-limited. Conversely, when grain weight changes significantly in response to severe manipulation, the only valid conclusion is that the manipulated plants were source-limited; it is not justified to reach conclusions on the intact control crop. These considerations call for a more cautious interpretation of experimental data where direct manipulation of the source-sink ratio leads to a significant change in grain weight, and suggest a re-evaluation of experimental and analytical methods are needed to conclude on the nature of grain weight limitation., This work was done without specific funding, but it was based on long lasting research done by the authors on yield physiology of grain crops. Most recent grants on this field were provided by the State Research Agency of Spain (RTI2018-096213-B-100, PID2021-127415OB-I00, and TED2021-130466B-C21), GRDC in Australia (UOQ2402-010RTX, CSP2404-020RTX, and CSP2404-020RTX), ANID in Chile (Fondecyt 1170913, 1211040), Programa de Promoción de la Ciencia de la Universidad de Buenos Aires (Argentina) en el exterior (RECS-2024-1910 E-UBA-REC). ST held a Ramón y Cajal Fellowship (RYC2021-032713-I) co-funded by MICIU/AEI/10.13039/501100011033 and the European Union NextGenerationEU/PRTR.
Recercat. Dipósit de la Recerca de Catalunya
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Are portable polyethylene tents reliable for imposing heat treatments in field-grown wheat?

  • Kim, Jinwook
  • Slafer, Gustavo A.
  • Savin, Roxana
Environmental variability has increased in recent decades and there are high expectations that heat waves will affect wheat productivity. Therefore, methods to quantify the effects of high temperature on wheat growth, yield, and yield-related traits under field conditions are greatly needed. In this opinion paper, we first describe the different approaches to quantify these effects, briefly highlighting their pros and cons. Portable polyethylene tents over the plots are cost-effective and convenient when relatively large plots are preferred and/or when there is no access to electricity in the field. This method shares a drawback with other approaches due to the tent reducing light intensity and altering other environmental factors like wind, humidity and evapotranspiration. We discuss to what degree there is an actual confounding effect (incorrectly assigning changes to heat effects that might be in part due to lower radiation). In that context, we not only discuss the issue theoretically, but also present results from a field experiment comparing a control (open uncovered plot), and a "roof-only" treatment (covering the plot with a polyethylene roof alone; thus impacting incoming radiation but not temperature). These treatments were imposed at either booting or the onset of grain filling, and testing two wheat cultivars having contrasting grain numbers per m2 and average grain weight. Supporting a theoretical framework that this reduced radiation would be compensated by increased radiation use efficiency, we show empirically that the roof-only treatment (which reduced incoming photosynthetically active radiation by 10.7 ± 0.2 % at noon on sunny days, but did not alter the temperature at any time of the day) did not result in any yield penalty with respect to the uncovered control plots. Thus, portable polyethylene tents are a reliable method to impose heat treatments in field experiments. Although other methods are more sophisticated and may be perceived as having fewer confounding factors, portable polyethylene tents are ideally suited to irrigated field experiments where electricity is not available, where relatively large plots are needed, and for research carried out on a limited budget., Funding was provided by project RTI2018-096213-B-100 funded by the Spanish State Research Agency (AEI). Jinwook Kim held a pre-doctoral research contract from AGAUR (the Agency for Management of University and Research Grants of Catalonia).
Recercat. Dipósit de la Recerca de Catalunya
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Physiological drivers of responses of grains per m(2) to environmental and genetic factors in wheat

  • Slafer, Gustavo A.
  • García, Guillermo A.
  • Serrago, Román A.
  • Miralles, Daniel J.
Most of the required increases in food production over the next decades are expected to be achieved through increases in crop yield. As wheat is essential for food security it is worrying that its yield gains over the last two decades were small. To achieve further yield increases it is critical to continue increasing number of grains per unit area (GN m(-2)), the trait best related to yield. In this context, it is relevant to identify the main determinants of GN m(-2) in response to genetic and environmental factors as well as the trade-offs between them. In the present study we compiled a large database across the literature to analyse the relative importance of components when affected by genetic or environmental factors, producing small or large changes in GN m(-2) and its components, either numerical (the number of spikes per m(2), SN m(-2); and the number of grains per spike, GN spike(-1)) or physiological (spike dry weight at anthesis, SDWa; and fruiting efficiency, FE) determinants. The database included 367 papers published in: (i) Field Crop Research (FCR), (ii) European Journal of Agronomy (EJA), (iii) Crop Science (CS) and (iv) Crop and Pasture Science (CPS, formerly Australian Journal of Agricultural Research) between 1990 and 2020. The complete dataset was split into classes, depending on the source of experimental variation, environment or genotype and was normalised to remove the differences between experiments and determine the environmental and genotypic effects within each experiment. Normalised data showed that the responsiveness of GN m(-2)was similarly explained by changes in both SN m(-2) and GN spike(-1), but in terms of physiological components SDWa was more relevant than FE for explaining the variations in GN m(-2). Considering the numerical components of GN m(-2) genotypic and environmental factors modified more GN spike(-1) than in SN m(-2). On the other hand, physiological components were differently modified by genotype and environment: for genotypic effects FE was more critical than SDWa and the other way around for environmental factors. A tradeoff between numerical and physiological components was observed although was greater between physiological than between numerical components., Research of the authors on wheat yield physiology has been funded along years by many different grants from different funding bodies; most recently mainly from (i) the International Wheat Yield Partnership (IWYP25FP) , (ii) , the Spanish State Agency for Research (latest project was RTI2018-096213-B-100) , and (iii) Argentine Fund for Scientific and Technological Research (latest project PICT RAICES 2019-04333) .
Recercat. Dipósit de la Recerca de Catalunya
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

A 'Wiring Diagram' for sink-strength traits impacting wheat yield potential

  • Slafer, Gustavo A.
  • Foulkes, M. John
  • Reynolds, Matthew P.
  • Murchie, Erik
  • Carmo-Silva, Elizabete
  • Flavell, Richard B.
  • Gwyn, Jeff
  • Sawkins, Mark
  • Griffiths, Simon
Identifying traits for improving sink-strength is a bottleneck to increasing wheat yield. The interacting processes determining sink-strength and yield potential are reviewed and visualized in a set of 'Wiring Diagrams', covering critical phases of development (and summarizing known underlying genetics). Using this framework, we reviewed and assembled the main traits determining sink-strength and identified research gaps and potential hypotheses to be tested for achieving gains in sink-strength. In pre-anthesis grain number could be increased through: (i) enhanced spike growth associated with optimized floret development and/or a reduction in specific stem-internode lengths and (ii) improved fruiting efficiency through accelerated rate of floret development, improved partitioning between spike or optimized spike cytokinin levels. In post-anthesis grain sink-strength could be augmented through manipulation of grain size potential via ovary size and/or endosperm cell division and expansion. Prospects for improving spike vascular architecture to support all rapidly growing florets, enabling the improved flow of assimilate, are also discussed. Finally, we considered the prospects for enhancing grain weight realization in relation to genetic variation in stay-green traits as well as stem carbohydrate remobilization. The Wiring Diagrams provide a potential workspace for breeders and crop scientists to achieve yield gains in wheat and other field crops., Research of the authors on physiology and genetics of wheat yield potential has been funded by many different sources over the years. Most recent grants include the International Wheat Yield Partnership (IWYP) projects funded by the Biotechnology and Biological Research Council of the UK (e.g., IWYP48 BB/N021061/1, IWYP64 BB/ N020871/2, IWYP163 BB/S005072/1, and IWYP25FP), as well as projects funded by other donors (State Research Agency of Spain: AGL2015-69595-R and RTI2018-096213-B-100).
Recercat. Dipósit de la Recerca de Catalunya
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Awned versus awnless wheat spikes: does it matter?

  • Sanchez-Bragado, Rut
  • Molero, Gemma
  • Araus Ortega, José Luis
  • Slafer, Gustavo A.
Awnless and awned wheat is found across the globe. Archeological and historical records show that the wheat spike was predominantly awned across the many millennia following domestication. Thus, ancient farmers did not select against awns at least until the last millennium. Here, we describe the evolution and domestication of wheat awns, quantifying their role in spike photosynthesis and yield under contrasting environments. Awns increase grain weight directly (increasing the size of all grains) or indirectly (increasing the failure of distal grains), but not as a consequence of additional spike photosynthesis. However, a trade-off is produced through decreasing grain number. Thus, favorable effects of awns on yield are not consistently found across environments., The authors’ research on wheat yield physiology has been funded by many different sources and we are grateful to all of them. The latest projects on wheat yield physiology were RTI2018-096213-B-100 and PID2019-106650RB-C21 (both funded by the State Agency for Research of Spain). J.L.A. also acknowledges the support of ICREA Acadèmia Generalitat de Catalunya, Spain.
Recercat. Dipósit de la Recerca de Catalunya
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Wheat yield is not causally related to the duration of the growing season.

  • Slafer, Gustavo A.
  • Savin, Roxana
  • Sadras, Víctor O.
A common conceptual model for crop growth analysis assumes biomass is proportional to the accumulation of radiation intercepted by the canopy during the growing season, and yield is the product of biomass and harvest index. This model assumes that biomass and harvest index are independent, and that biomass has the same value for yield across developmental stages; here we focus on the latter assumption. A corollary of this model is that yield and duration of the growing season are causally related. In this article, we analyse the evidence for and against this causal relationship. We use both a physiological perspective and agronomic evidence to challenge this causality. An alternative, phenology-focused model is outlined that is based on the following principles: crops accommodate environmental variation through grain number, grain number is defined in a species-specific critical developmental period, and grain number is a function of three traits in the critical period: duration, growth rate, and partitioning to reproduction. Against this framework, we analyse dual purpose wheat, where a substantial part of the biomass is removed, effectively shortening the growing season, with little or no effect on yield; timing of nitrogen fertilisation, where delayed application reduces the growth rate early in the season, with little or no effect on yield; and the correlation between season length and yield of winter wheat and spring wheat - wheat yield in Southern Chile, with a sowing-to-maturity season of ∼ 5 months, could be as high as that of winter wheat in the UK, with a sowing-to-maturity season of ∼ 10 months. Physiological principles and agronomic evidence support the conclusion that the duration of, and growth rate and partitioning during the critical period, rather than the duration of the growing season, are the drivers of wheat yield., This study had not specific funding, but many sources have funded the research of the authors on yield physiology over the years. Most recent grants include projects funded by the State Research Agency of Spain (RTI2018–096213-B-100, PID2021–127415OB-I00) and by SARDI-GRDC bilateral (DAS00166_BA).