DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publicación
Artículo científico (JournalArticle)
Normative monism and radical deflationism
For helpful comments on the material of this paper, I am grateful to the participants to the Book Symposium held at Glasgow University, School of Law. Special thanks are due to George Pavlakos and Scott Hershovitz for particularly insightful feedback., Scott Hershovitz's Law is a Moral Practice develops a bold, novel, and comprehensive account of law: the moral practice picture. Its central thesis is that legal relations (rights, duties, powers, etc.) are moral. They are real, full-fledged normative relations, connected to genuine reasons for action, and endowed with robust normativity. Nothing less than ordinary moral relations. The account is compounded with a deflationary view of theories in general jurisprudence and of the debates about them. In this vein, Hershovitz recommends that we move away from theorising about law (understood as a set of legal norms), and focus on the nature of legal relations instead. In this paper, I pursue two interrelated objectives. First, I address Hershovitz's main arguments for the view that legal relations are moral. Second, I take the issue with the asymmetry between the deflationary and inflationary stances he advocates for legal norms and relations, respectively, arguing that this different treatment is unwarranted, because the deflationary stance is, and because this very combination of attitudes is unstable. Properly understood, questions about the nature and determination of legal norms and relations can't but be seen as complementary aspects of a unified legal metaphysics., This work has been supported by the Ramón y Cajal fellowship ‘The Metaphysical Structure of Normative Explanation' (ref.: RYC2021-032064-I) at the Institute of Philosophy (IFS) of the Spanish National Research Council (CSIC), funded by the Spanish Government (MCIN/AEI/10.13039/501100011033) and by the EU (NextGenerationEU/PRTR). It has also been supported by the project ‘Razón Pública Global’ (ref.: PID2020-115041GB-I00) at Pompeu Fabra University, funded by the Spanish Government (MCIN/AEI/10.13039/501100011033)., Peer reviewed