Pasar al contenido principal

Resultados relacionados

Resultados totales (Incluyendo duplicados): 12
Encontrada(s) 1 página(s)

Zaguán. Repositorio Digital de la Universidad de Zaragoza
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

How can Physical Education teachers’ high directiveness impact students’ experiences of enjoyment and boredom?

  • Diloy-Peña, Sergio
  • García-Cazorla, Javier
  • Mayo-Rota, Carlos
  • García-González, Luis
  • Villafaña-Samper, Zilia
  • Abós, Ángel
Based on Self-Determination Theory, a recent theory in the educational context introduces an integrative and detailed circumplex model that categorizes teaching styles into eight (de)motivating approaches, depending on their level of directiveness and support or threat to students’ needs. However, the evidence so far on how high directiveness approaches (i.e., guiding, clarifying, demanding, domineering) is limited regarding its potential connection to various (mal)adaptive outcomes in Physical Education, given that Physical Education teachers can adopt different high directiveness approaches for optimal classroom management. The present study aims to examine the differential impact of high directiveness leadership: structuring style (i.e., guiding and clarifying) versus controlling style (i.e., demanding and domineering), on students’ affective outcomes (i.e., enjoyment and boredom). A convenience sample of 697 students (51% girls; Mage = 14.52; SD = 1.45), aged between 12 and 17 years, participated in this cross-sectional study. The results show that enjoyment during Physical Education lessons was positively and significantly predicted by the guiding and clarifying approaches. In contrast, boredom was negatively and significantly predicted by the guiding approach, while the domineering approach positively and significantly predicted boredom. The results emphasized the importance of Physical Education teachers adopting structuring approaches (i.e., guiding and clarifying) and avoiding controlling approaches (i.e., demanding and domineering) to promote adaptive affective outcomes in students.
Zaguán. Repositorio Digital de la Universidad de Zaragoza
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Exploring (de-)motivating teaching profiles from a fine-grained directiveness approach: Differences in students’ need-based experiences

  • Diloy-Peña, Sergio
  • García-González, Luis
  • Haerens, Leen
  • De Cocker, Katrien
  • Burgueño, Rafael
  • Abós, Ángel
The aim was to examine how structuring and controlling approaches (high directiveness), and autonomy-supportive and chaotic approaches (low directiveness) were combined and related to students’ needs in physical education. In a sample of 1124 secondary school students, this cross-sectional study conducted two sets of profile analyses, respectively for high and low directiveness, were conducted. The latent profile analyses (LPA) revealed four high-directiveness profiles, with “very high structure-very high control” being the most adaptive and “low structure–low control” the most maladaptive in terms of need-based experiences. Four low directiveness profiles were identified, with “very high autonomy support-very low chaos” being the most adaptive and “low autonomy support-moderate chaos” the most maladaptive.
Zaguán. Repositorio Digital de la Universidad de Zaragoza
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Chaotic (laissez-faire) teaching: The most harmful style for students’ psychological needs?

  • Bouten, Arne
  • Diloy-Peña, Sergio
  • Abós, Ángel
  • García-González, Luis
  • Haerens, Leen
  • De Cocker, Katrien
Self-Determination Theory (SDT) has been widely used to understand how different teaching styles impact student outcomes. Previous research has mainly focused on the negative effects of controlling teaching, while the influence of chaotic (laissez-faire) teaching has been less explored. This study examines how students' perceptions of highly chaotic (i.e., abandoning) and highly controlling (i.e., domineering) teaching approaches are related to the satisfaction and frustration of student basic psychological needs in secondary physical education (PE). The study involved 916 students in Belgium (58% girls; 15.37 ± 1.62 years old) and 1124 students in Spain (52% girls; 14.60 ± 1.51 years old). Using linear mixed-effects models, we found that both abandoning and domineering teaching approaches were adversely associated with students' basic psychological needs. The abandoning approach showed the strongest positive association with overall need frustration in both samples. Moreover, the abandoning approach was most strongly associated with competence and relatedness frustration in both countries, as well as with lower competence satisfaction in Spain. Both approaches showed a similar positive relationship with autonomy frustration. This study expands our understanding of demotivating teaching by demonstrating the harmful potential of highly chaotic teaching, beyond the well-known harmful effects of controlling teaching. The consistency of the findings across both countries highlights the international relevance of this research. These findings suggests that reducing highly chaotic (i.e., laissez-faire) teaching should be a priority in international educational practices and policies. Future research could investigate the causes, effects, and potential moderators of chaotic teaching to further guide educational policy and practice in different cultural contexts.
Zaguán. Repositorio Digital de la Universidad de Zaragoza
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Study protocol of a non-randomized controlled trial on a circumplex model-based motivational training program for pre-service physical education teachers

  • Mayo-Rota, Carlos
  • Abós, Ángel
  • García-Cazorla, Javier
  • Villafaña-Samper, Zilia
  • García-González, Luis
Physical Education Teacher Education is crucial, as it directly influences how pre-service Physical Education teachers will teach, motivate, and engage their future students. However, training programs that foster motivating teaching styles while minimizing demotivating ones remain scarce, particularly during initial teacher education. This study presents the protocol for a non-randomized controlled trial evaluating a motivational-based training program for pre-service Physical Education teachers, grounded in Self-Determination Theory and the circumplex model. The program, embedded in a Master’s in Physical Education Teacher Education, consists of theoretical and practical training to foster motivating teaching styles and minimize demotivating ones. The study will involve at least 38 pre-service teachers, divided into an experimental group (n = 19) and a control group (n = 19). The experimental group will participate in a 14-hour training program combining theoretical and practical components. The control group will follow the standard Physical Education Teacher Education curriculum. A quasi-experimental pre-post design with a mixed-methods approach will be used. Quantitative assessments will measure changes in perceived competence, motivation for teaching, and (de)motivating teaching styles, while qualitative focus groups will provide in-depth insights into participants’ experiences and program applicability. To ensure objectivity, independent researchers will conduct assessments, and external experts will moderate the focus groups. Findings will contribute empirical evidence on the effectiveness of Self-Determination Theory-based interventions in initial teacher education, informing curriculum development and supporting the advancement of evidence-based pedagogical training in Physical Education.Clinical trial registrationClinicalTrials.gov, identifier NCT06924554.
Zaguán. Repositorio Digital de la Universidad de Zaragoza
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

How pre-service physical education teachers’ motivational profiles shape their (de)motivating teaching profiles

  • Mayo-Rota, Carlos
  • Abós, Ángel
  • Haerens, Leen
  • De Cocker, Katrien
  • García-González, Luis
Following a cross-sectional design with 554 pre-service physical education teachers (Mage = 25.03 years-old; SD = ± 4.31; 67.8 % male), this study aimed to identify their motivational and teaching profiles and examine the relationships between them. Four distinct motivational profiles and four teaching profiles emerged. More self-determined motivational profiles were associated with more adaptive teaching profiles. Conversely, less self-determined motivational profiles were linked to less adaptive teaching profiles. These findings underscore the importance of fostering self-determined motivation in teacher education programs to promote more motivating teaching approaches and better student outcomes.
Zaguán. Repositorio Digital de la Universidad de Zaragoza
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

COMIENDOP: a protocol to improve the motivational teaching styles of pre-service primary physical education teachers

  • Sanz-Remacha, María
  • Julián-Clemente, José Antonio
  • Aibar, Alberto
Introduction: Pre-service primary teachers, especially primary Physical Education (PE) teachers, must acquire core teaching skills and effective classroom management strategies. The acquisition of motivating teaching styles in PE lessons has positive consequences for both teachers and students. Grounded in Self-Determination Theory and the Circumplex Model, the present study presents the first intervention program designed to foster motivating teaching styles (i.e., autonomy support and structure) and prevent (de)motivating teaching styles (i.e., control and chaos) among preservice primary PE teachers. Methods: The training program also strives to improve preservice primary PE teachers’ competence and motivation, which might increase motivation for PE and physical activity engagement in the students later under their charge. A quasi-experimental design was employed that took a mixedmethods approach. A total of 370 participants from the [anonymized peer review process] will participate in the study. Participants were divided into control and experimental groups. The intervention program is structured into two main phases (i.e., general and specific phases) and will last a total of 35 h. Theoretical and practical face-to-face sessions will be conducted by university PE specialist professors. Following the training program, participants will complete school placements to apply what they have learned. Findings and discussion: Pre-service primary PE teachers will learn to effectively use motivational strategies and teaching skills, whilst also adopting motivating teaching styles during practical sessions. Motivation, (de)motivating teaching styles, and perceptions of efficacy and competence will be assessed via questionnaires and focus groups. Findings represent an important first step towards improving motivational training programs for pre-service primary PE teachers and improving the quality of university teaching.
Zaguán. Repositorio Digital de la Universidad de Zaragoza
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Does it matter whether physical education teachers combine structure with autonomy support rather than control? Differences in motivation for teaching and work-related outcomes

  • García Cazorla, Javier
  • Abós, Ángel
  • Haerens, Leen
  • De Cocker, Katrien
  • Burgueño, Rafael
  • García-González, Luis
Background In the Physical Education (PE) lesson, structure is crucial, as its impact on students can vary depending on how the PE teacher combine it with other (de)motivating teaching styles, leading to either positive or negative outcomes. The circumplex approach to (de)motivating teaching sustains that PE teachers may combine the provision of structure in their lessons, with autonomy support and/or control, as structure is positioned in between. However, how these three teaching styles are combined has not been empirically examined via a person-centered approach so far. Purpose This study aims, therefore, to identify (de)motivating teaching profiles using structuring, autonomy-supportive, and controlling approaches, and to examine which profile is more (mal)adaptive in terms of teachers’ motivation to teach, job satisfaction, and professional performance. Method In a sample of 640 PE teachers (Mage = 36.70 ± 7.87; 63% male), four profiles were identified: 1 = ‘highly structuring – highly autonomy-supportive – lowly controlling’, 2 = ‘highly structuring – highly autonomy-supportive – highly controlling’, 3 = ‘moderately structuring – moderately autonomy-supportive – lowly controlling’, and 4 = ‘moderately structuring – lowly autonomy-supportive – moderately controlling’. Results Results showed that PE teachers providing structure in combination with predominantly autonomy-supportive teaching (i.e. profile 1), in general, reported the most adaptive pattern of motivation to teach and, consequently, achieved better work-related outcomes, such as job satisfaction and professional performance. The opposite was true for PE teachers who provide structure in combination with controlling teaching (i.e. profile 4). Between profiles 2 and 3, differences were less clear, except for controlled motivation, which was higher in profile 2, characterized by high levels of control. Conclusions Thus, it seems important to develop high-quality motivation for teaching, as it is closely linked to need-supportive teaching styles, and ultimately, to greater job satisfaction and professional performance. Likewise, findings also point toward the risks of providing control, especially in its predominant format, but also, yet to a lesser extent, when combined with needs support.
Zaguán. Repositorio Digital de la Universidad de Zaragoza
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Effects of Sport Education Model on Meaningful Experiences in Physical Education and (De)Motivating Teaching Approaches

  • Villafaña-Samper, Zilia
  • Esteban-Torres, Diego
  • Capablo-Jal, Lorién
  • García-Cazorla, Javier
  • Mayo-Rota, Carlos
  • García-González, Luis
This study aimed to examine the effects of a basketball teaching unit based on the Sport Education Model on students’ meaningful experiences in Physical Education and their perceptions of (de)motivating teaching approaches used by their Physical Education teachers. A total of 102 secondary school students (49 girls; Mage = 13.66, SD = 0.72) participated in a pre-experimental, single group pretest-posttest design. Students completed the Meaningful Physical Education Scale and the Situation-in-School-Physical Education questionnaire before and after an eight-session intervention implemented by a pre-service teacher. Data were analyzed using mixed 2 (Time: pre, post) × 2 (Sex: male, female) MANOVAs and follow-up ANOVAs. The multivariate analyses revealed no significant overall Time × Sex interaction effects for either meaningful PE dimensions or (de)motivating teaching approaches. At the univariate level, significant improvements were observed in social interaction and challenge dimensions of meaningful PE, along with increased perceptions of autonomy-supportive and structuring teaching approaches and reduced controlling and awaiting approaches. However, univariate analyses showed specific sex-related differences: boys reported greater improvements in fun, challenge, and personally relevant learning, whereas girls perceived their teacher as displaying more clarifying behaviors. These findings suggest that the Sport Education Model fosters meaningful and motivating learning environments for both sexes, though the nature of these improvements may vary slightly between boys and girls.
Zaguán. Repositorio Digital de la Universidad de Zaragoza
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

How Need-Thwarting Teaching Styles Are Combined for Physical Education Teachers: Differences in Students´ Motivational Outcomes

  • García-Cazorla, Javier
  • Mayo-Rota, Carlos
  • Villafaña-Samper, Zilia
  • Esteban-Torres, Diego
  • García-González, Luis
  • Abós, Ángel
Grounded in the circumplex model, this study examined how need-thwarting teaching styles, control and chaos, are combined by Physical Education teachers (as perceived by students) and how these combinations differ in relation to students’ basic psychological needs and motivational outcomes within (experiences and perceived learning) and outside (intention to be physically active) the Physical Education context. A total of 431 Spanish secondary school students (Mage = 14.92; 53% girls) participated. Latent profile analysis identified three profiles: (1) high control—moderate chaos (35%), (2) moderate control—high chaos (9%), and (3) high demanding—low chaos (56%). Mean comparisons revealed that students in the “high demanding—low chaos” profile reported the most adaptive outcomes, including greater autonomy and competence satisfaction, more positive Physical Education experiences, higher perceived learning, and stronger intentions to be physically active. Conversely, the “moderate control—high chaos” profile was linked to the most maladaptive outcomes, characterized by greater basic psychological needs frustration and poorer experiences, learning, and physical activity intentions. The “high control—moderate chaos” profile yielded intermediate results. Overall, findings indicate that chaotic teaching, especially in its abandoning form, was associated with the worst quality of students’ motivation, while a demanding approach may be comparatively less harmful but still detrimental. Teacher training should therefore reduce controlling and chaotic practices and foster autonomy support and structure.
Zaguán. Repositorio Digital de la Universidad de Zaragoza
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Consecuencias del estilo docente en Educación Física: Diferencias entre Programas Bilingües y no Bilingües

  • García-Cazorla, Javier
  • Fernández-Miguel, Guillermo
  • Villafaña-Samper, Zilia
  • Mayo-Rota, Carlos
  • Diloy-Peña, Sergio
  • Abós, Ángel
Objetivo: El presente estudio tuvo dos objetivos. El primero, examinar la relación entre las percepciones de los estudiantes sobre los distintos estilos motivacionales utilizados por sus docentes de Educación Física (EF) y las experiencias en las clases, el aprendizaje percibido y la intención de ser activo. El segundo, examinar las posibles diferencias entre las variables del estudio, en función del programa educativo al que pertenecen los estudiantes (i.e., bilingüe o no bilingüe). Método: Es un estudio descriptivo transversal donde participaron 95 estudiantes de tercer y cuarto curso de Educación Secundaria (43 pertenecen al programa bilingüe). Resultados: Los resultados mostraron una relación positiva de los estilos apoyo a la autonomía y estructura con las experiencias y el aprendizaje percibido en EF, mientras que el estilo caótico se relacionó negativamente con las experiencias. Los estudiantes del programa bilingüe percibieron que sus docentes utilizaban mayor apoyo a la autonomía y menos control, así como unas mejores experiencias en comparación del programa no bilingüe Conclusiones: Se considera necesario crear programas formativos para docentes de EF que enseñen estrategias motivacionales que ayuden a fomentar estilos motivadores (i.e., apoyo autonomía y estructura) que aumenten el aprendizaje percibido, las experiencias y la intención de ser activo de los estudiantes, especialmente en aquellos grupos no bilingües.
Zaguán. Repositorio Digital de la Universidad de Zaragoza
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Perfiles de preferencias de aprendizaje social y diferencias en comportamientos prosociales en estudiantes de Educación Física

  • García-Cazorla, Javier
  • Mayo-Rota, Carlos
  • Santed, Mónica
  • Abós, Ángel
  • Escolano-Pérez, Elena
  • García-González, Luis
Desde hace mucho tiempo, se reconoce que las clases de Educación Física (EF) no solo promueven el desarrollo de las habilidades y conductas motoras de los estudiantes, sino que también brindan un valioso contexto para fomentar el aprendizaje social y emocional. A pesar de ello, existe poca investigación que haya explorado las preferencias de aprendizaje social de los estudiantes de EF y su relación con las conductas prosociales. Este estudio tenía por objetivo identificar perfiles diferenciados de estudiantes basados en cuatro preferencias de aprendizaje social en EF (competitiva, cooperativa, afiliativa e individualista) y examinar cómo difieren estos perfiles en conductas prosociales como la empatía, el respeto, la vinculación y el liderazgo. Se administraron cuestionarios validados a 299 adolescentes españoles (50 % chicos; Medad = 13.76). Un análisis de clúster en dos etapas (método de Ward + medias de K) reveló cuatro perfiles diferenciados: (1) preferencia destacadamente competitivacooperativa-afiliativa, (2) preferencia moderadamente cooperativa, (3) preferencia moderadamente competitiva-individualista, y (4) preferencia individualista. Una MANCOVA (con el sexo como covariable) mostró que los perfiles que enfatizaban la cooperación y la afiliación exhibieron el nivel más alto de empatía, vinculación y liderazgo, incluso cuando también estaba presente la competitividad. En cambio, el perfil individualista obtuvo las puntuaciones más bajas en todas las dimensiones prosociales. Estos hallazgos destacan el potencial de las actividades de EF cooperativas y afiliativas para fomentar el desarrollo prosocial de los adolescentes. Se anima a los profesores de EF a diseñar tareas que mejoren la colaboración entre iguales y el sentido de pertenencia, al tiempo que minimizan enfoques excesivamente individualistas.
Zaguán. Repositorio Digital de la Universidad de Zaragoza
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Evaluating longitudinal, reciprocal, and cross-sectional effects of (de)motivating teaching styles on students’ psychological and educational outcomes in physical education

  • García-Cazorla, Javier
  • Abós, Ángel
  • Matos, Lennia
  • Gargurevich, Rafael
  • García-González, Luis
Grounded in Self-Determination Theory and the circumplex model of teaching behaviors, this three-wave study (N = 637 secondary students) analyzed longitudinal, reciprocal, and cross-sectional relations among (de)motivating teaching styles, basic psychological needs (BPN), and student outcomes using a structural equation model. Perceived autonomy-supportive and structuring styles at Time 1 (T1) predicted higher BPN satisfaction at Time 2 (T2), which, in turn, related to more positive experiences and perceived learning in class and greater intention for physical activity beyond class at Time 3 (T3). Conversely, controlling and chaotic styles at T1 were linked to BPN frustration at T2 and poorer outcomes at T3. BPN satisfaction (frustration) at T2 also showed a longitudinal associations with higher (lower) perceptions of autonomy-supportive/structuring, and lower (higher) controlling/chaotic styles at T3. Findings highlight long-term, bidirectional dynamics with implications for teacher education. The findings indicate that teacher training programs should foster autonomy-supportive and structuring styles while reducing controlling and chaotic ones to promote adaptive motivational patterns and improve student outcomes.