Skip to main content

Resultados relacionados

Resultados totales (Incluyendo duplicados): 24
Encontrada(s) 1 página(s)

Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Large inequalities in climate mitigation scenarios are not supported by theories of distributive justice

  • Millward-Hopkins, Joel|||0000-0003-4189-1658
  • Saheb, Yamina|||0000-0002-3167-8194
  • Hickel, Jason|||0000-0002-7490-9757
Existing global climate mitigation scenarios perpetuate large inequalities in energy and income between countries and regions for the rest of the century, and modellers have recently begun to assess these dynamics in light of distributive justice theories. However, these theories are intended to describe inequalities within nations and cannot straightforwardly be applied to inequalities between nations or world regions. Indeed, an analysis of key distributive justice theories suggests that, in contexts of international or interregional inequalities, moral justifications for inequality cannot be sustained, while arguments in favour of egalitarianism become stronger.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Corrigendum to "Large inequalities in climate mitigation scenarios are not supported by theories of distributive justice"

  • Millward-Hopkins, Joel
  • Saheb, Yamina|||0000-0002-3167-8194
  • Hickel, Jason Edward|||0000-0002-7490-9757
The author affiliations listed in the article as published were incorrect. Jason Hickel's second affiliation should have been listed as ICREA, Barcelona, as indicated here. Furthermore, the acknowledgments should have stated that JH's work is also supported by the María de Maeztu Unit of Excellence ( CEX2019-374 000940-M) grant from the Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation. The authors would like to apologise for any inconvenience caused.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Beyond the urban shift, towards a relational degrowth spatial politics

  • Varvarousis, Angelos|||0000-0003-4300-6456
  • Kallis, Giorgos|||0000-0003-0688-9552
  • Cattaneo, Claudio|||0000-0001-7049-9298
  • Sekulova, Filka Tsvetkova|||0000-0001-6827-5359
  • Tsagkari, Marula|||0000-0002-7925-3769
  • Slameršak, Aljoša|||0000-0001-5643-0331
  • Conde, Marta|||0000-0003-0220-6080
  • D'Alisa, Giacomo|||0000-0001-9472-2837
  • Hanacek, Ksenija|||0000-0001-5283-2309
  • Roy, Brototi|||0000-0002-5686-337X
Degrowth is coming of age, and its analysis of what can be called degrowth spatial politics is advancing rapidly. In this article, we attempt to unravel the history of spatial thought in the degrowth literature to reveal its tendencies, tipping points, and blank spots. We argue that the more recent degrowth spatial literature overly focuses on the big urban scale by reversing what has purportedly been one of the weak spots of degrowth scholarship: its focus and preference for small-scale, relocalization, and decentralized communities. While we see the merit of this shift, first, we try to contextualize it in the broader sustainability discourse, and second, we contend that it has not been without problems and omissions. We see three predicaments stemming from it: first, a deficit of the degrowth spatial literature in recognizing and engaging with unsustainable rural transformations such as rural depopulation and shrinkage, as well as rural dispossession and depeasantisation. Second, a difficulty to account for urban and rural interconnectedness and engage with new epistemological frames that emerge in urban studies, such as planetary urbanization. Third, the urban shift may affect the capacity of degrowth to remain pluriversal, anti-colonial, and grassroots-fueled, or what Chertkovskaya et al. (Towards a political economy of degrowth. Rowman & Littlefield, 2019. https://books.google.com/books?hl=en&lr=&id=PuXaDwAAQBAJ&oi=fnd&pg=PP1&dq=info:c45bQLgYCfYJ:scholar.google.com&ots=5LsDF9Y_Er&sig=buZn4ogpUN4octi3_WFJf1mO9Lg) called nomadic utopianism. Finally, in the concluding part, we set the stepstones for a relational degrowth spatial politics, focusing on a solidary connection of space and place across the urban and rural and in multiple scales. This approach avoids the pitfalls of both degrowth proposals for relocalization and those who put excessive trust in urban transformations alone.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Post-growth, the science of wellbeing within planetary boundaries

  • Kallis, Giorgos|||0000-0003-0688-9552
  • Hickel, Jason Edward|||0000-0002-7490-9757
  • O'Neill, Daniel W.
  • Jackson, Tim
  • Victor, Peter A.
  • Raworth, Kate
  • Schor, Juliet B.
  • Steinberger, Julia K.
  • Ürge-Vorsatz, Diana
There are increasing concerns that continued economic growth in high-income countries might not be environmentally sustainable, socially beneficial, or economically achievable. In this Review, we explore the rapidly advancing field of post-growth research, which has evolved in response to these concerns. The central idea of post-growth is to replace the goal of increasing GDP with the goal of improving human wellbeing within planetary boundaries. Key advances discussed in this Review include: the development of ecological macroeconomic models that test policies for managing without growth; understanding and reducing the growth dependencies that tie social welfare to increasing GDP in the current economy; and characterising the policies and provisioning systems that would allow resource use to be reduced while improving human wellbeing. Despite recent advances in post-growth research, important questions remain, such as the politics of transition, and transformations in the relationship between the Global North and the Global South.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Postfiguring degrowth, How traditional popular culture challenges growth-oriented common senses

  • Muñoz-Sueiro, Lucía|||0000-0002-6972-2648
  • Kallis, Giorgos|||0000-0003-0688-9552
Traditional customs and rituals that continue to exist in the rural peripheries of industrialized countries may contain living elements that 'postfigure' alternative ways of living. We propose a new line of inquiry on postfiguration, at the intersection between anthropology and degrowth and inspired by Antonio Gramsci's work on folklore. By 'postfiguration' we refer to real and existing popular practices with a long history that have elements that disrupt hegemonic growthist common senses. They help imagine alternative futures based on remnants of the past that continue to exist today. We follow a Gramscian understanding of traditional popular culture as a conception of the world and of life. Popular culture contains regressive and progressive elements that need to be analytically identified and separated as part of intentional postfiguration. To illustrate how specific traditions can challenge hegemonic common senses and fuel radical political imaginaries, we analyze three practices from rural Spain: "open councils", or bodies of direct democracy that have existed for centuries; "hacenderas", or traditional forms of work sharing; and long-existing, self-managed rural carnivals associated with convivial subversion. We propose analytics of such instances of 'postfiguration' and discuss the politics that can be built around them., Les coutumes et rituels traditionnels qui continuent d'exister dans les périphéries des pays industrialisés peuvent contenir des éléments vivants qui « postfigurent » des modes de vie alternatifs. Nous proposons une nouvelle ligne de recherche sur la postfiguration inspirée des travaux d'Antonio Gramsci sur le folklore, à l'intersection de l'anthropologie et de la décroissance. Par « postfiguration », nous désignons des pratiques populaires réelles et existantes qui comportent des éléments qui perturbent le sens commun apparent de la croissance hégémonique. Ces pratiques aident à imaginer des mondes futurs alternatifs basés sur le passé, et dont les vestiges continuent d'exister aujourd'hui. Nous suivons une compréhension gramsienne de la culture populaire traditionnelle en tant que conception du monde et de la vie. La culture populaire contient des éléments régressifs et progressistes qui doivent être analytiquement identifiés et séparés dans le cadre d'une postfiguration intentionnelle. Pour illustrer comment des traditions spécifiques peuvent remettre en cause les idées hégémoniques et alimenter des imaginaires politiques radicaux, nous analysons trois pratiques de l'Espagne rurale: les « conseils ouverts », ou organes de démocratie directe qui existent depuis des siècles, les « hacenderas », ou formes traditionnelles de partage du travail, et des carnavals ruraux autogérés de longue date associés à une subversion conviviale. Nous proposons une analyse de ces exemples de « postfiguration » et discutons de la manière dont le politique peut être construit autour d'elles., Las costumbres y rituales tradicionales que siguen existiendo en las periferias rurales de los países industrializados pueden contener elementos vivos que 'postfiguran' modos de vida alternativos a un futuro unilateral de crecimiento capitalista. Proponemos una nueva línea de investigación sobre la postfiguración en la intersección entre antropología y decrecimiento, inspirada en la obra de Antonio Gramsci sobre el folclore. Por 'postfiguración' nos referimos a prácticas populares reales y existentes con un largo pedigrí que tienen elementos que perturban los sentidos comunes hegemónicos del crecimiento. Estas prácticas populares ayudan a imaginar mundos futuros alternativos basados en vestigios del pasado que siguen existiendo en la actualidad. Seguimos aquí una concepción gramsciana de la cultura popular tradicional como una concepción del mundo y de la vida. Como tal, la cultura popular contiene elementos regresivos y progresivos que deben identificarse y separarse analíticamente como parte de una postfiguración intencionada. Para ilustrar cómo determinados legados tradicionales pueden alimentar imaginarios políticos radicales, analizamos tres prácticas de la España rural: los concejos abiertos, órganos de democracia directa que han existido durante siglos; las hacenderas, formas tradicionales de reparto del trabajo; y los carnavales rurales autogestionados, asociados a la subversión convivial, que han existido desde tiempos inmemoriales. Proponemos un análisis de estos ejemplos de postfiguración y debatimos cómo puede construirse lo político en torno a ellas.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Toward a post-growth industrial policy for Europe, navigating emerging tensions and long-term goals

  • Bärnthaler, Richard|||0000-0003-3595-2127
  • Mang, Sebastian
  • Hickel, Jason Edward|||0000-0002-7490-9757
Amid mounting geopolitical, socio-economic, and ecological crises, industrial policy has returned to the forefront of policy debates. However, the EU's industrial policy framework-centerd on Single Market Resilience, Strategic Autonomy, and Competitive Sustainability-contains self-undermining contradictions. While aiming for resilience, it fails to strengthen foundational non-market institutions; in seeking strategic autonomy, it exacerbates resource dependencies and eco-imperialist tensions; and in promoting competitive sustainability, it remains reliant on profit-driven private sector strategies that delay necessary transitions. This article critically examines these contradictions using immanent critique and conjunctural analysis, proposing an alternative post-growth framework based on Foundational Liveability, Peaceful Planetary Co-Existence, and Democratically Coordinated Sustainability. To bridge the gap between current constraints and transformative change, we use critical problem-solving to outline contested but feasible next best transition steps within the current politico-economic order. By integrating post-growth insights into industrial policy, this article offers a roadmap for aligning economic activity with planetary boundaries and social well-being.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

A progressive framework for green industrial policy

  • Hauge, Jostein
  • Hickel, Jason Edward|||0000-0002-7490-9757
In the age of ecological breakdown, there is a growing need for 'green' industrial policy. However, existing frameworks for green industrial policy fail to address unsustainable growth in energy and resource use in high-income economies. In this sense, they are not adequate to achieve core ecological objectives. This paper fills a gap in the literature by offering a progressive framework for green industrial policy that combines traditional green industrial policy perspectives with insights from ecological economics and literature on post-growth and degrowth. The framework has three key pillars: (1) scale down ecologically harmful industries and sectors to directly reduce energy and resource use; (2) organise production more around public benefit, with greater democratic control and guidance over investment and production; and (3) work towards global ecological justice and enable greater 'ecological policy space' for the global South to pursue industrial development. The paper argues that this progressive approach to green industrial policy is necessary due to the scale and urgency of the ecological crisis. The framework shows how productive capacity can be liberated and redirected towards more socially and environmentally beneficial ends, while also democratising control over the economy.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Is growth in consumption occurring where it is most needed?, an empirical analysis of current energy and material trends

  • Millward-Hopkins, Joel
  • Hickel, Jason Edward|||0000-0002-7490-9757
  • Nag, Suryadeepto|||0000-0002-0427-7475
Background: Increasing global use of energy and materials is breaching planetary boundaries, but large inequalities mean that billions of people still cannot meet basic needs. Researchers have estimated minimum energy and material requirements to secure human wellbeing. However, it remains unclear whether countries with shortfalls in energy and material use are increasing their consumption towards sufficient levels, and whether countries with surplus consumption are reducing theirs to sustainable levels. Methods: In this empirical modelling study, we compared large datasets of national energy and material footprints with estimates of the energy and material required for each country to bring its poorest populations up to decent living standards (DLS). We then estimated the share of countries that are in shortfall and in surplus, for both energy and material consumption, and assessed to what degree countries are moving in the right direction, given existing growth rates. For countries with consumption shortfalls, we calculated the time it will take, at current growth rates, to reach energy and material use sufficient for DLS. Findings: The world currently uses more energy and materials than is required to achieve DLS for all (approximately 2·5 times more), even with existing within-country distributions (approximately 1·5 times more). However, 50% of nations currently have energy shortfall, and 46% have material shortfall. For most of these countries, growth in energy and material use is too slow to achieve DLS by 2050. Indeed, with current growth rates and national inequalities, at least one in five countries will remain in shortfall in 2100. By contrast, the growth rates of countries in surplus are four times higher than the growth rates of countries in shortfall, exacerbating ecological pressures. Interpretation: Currently, the world is not moving towards a just and ecological future for all. Growth in energy and material use is occurring primarily in countries that do not need it and is not occurring fast enough (or is declining) in countries that do need it. A substantial redistribution of energy and material use is needed-both within countries and between them-to achieve faster progress on DLS with less ecological pressure. Indeed, this redistribution is imperative if we are to achieve DLS for all while also achieving the Paris Agreement objectives. Convergence between the Global North and South is necessary but is not occurring fast enough. At current rates, convergence will not occur within the next 100 years.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Increasing inequality in agri-food value chains, global trends from 1995-2020

  • Goyal, Meghna|||0000-0003-3231-5827
  • Hickel, Jason Edward|||0000-0002-7490-9757
  • Jha, Praveen
Agri-food systems are increasingly globalised. In the last three decades, as national food systems have become more interdependent, the distribution of productive activities and economic value between different actors and countries has changed. Prior research on domestic agri-food value chains has shown that the farm share of food-system income has declined consistently, while post-farmgate sectors capture the majority of income. Market concentration in post-farmgate sectors is high in industrialised economies and is driving food-system transformations in developing economies. Here, we extend this analysis to assess the global distributional consequences of food-system transformations for the first time. We use multi-regional input-output data to disaggregate food expenditures between different countries and sectors across agri-food value chains, from 1995 to 2020. We arrive at several main findings: 1) agricultural production for food and industrial inputs has increasingly shifted to the global South, 2) global food-system income is increasingly captured by post-farm activities in the global North, and 3) a substantial share of food-system income is captured in low-tax jurisdictions with low agricultural production. These findings demonstrate that the contemporary agri-food system and agricultural trade are skewing the distribution of economic returns away from agricultural producers in the global South.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Where's the data? Challenges in characterizing the sustainability of socioecological systems

  • Boucher, Jean Léon|||0000-0001-9089-8093
  • Alfonso Becares, Diana|||0000-0003-1264-1967
  • Larrabeiti-Rodríguez, J. J.|||0000-0001-5419-6780
  • Marcos Valls, Alejandro|||0000-0003-4349-9828
  • Parra, Rony|||0000-0003-2942-7449
  • Ripa, Maddalena|||0000-0002-2720-0585
  • Taghdisian, Alireza|||0000-0002-1448-9316
  • Velasco-Fernández, Raúl|||0000-0002-5438-1158
  • Matthews, Keith|||0000-0001-8472-8872
In an era of great need regarding nexus-type research and assessments, this study investigates the challenges of missing data encountered by ten (N = 10) societal metabolism scholars who use MuSIASEM (Multi-Scale Integrated Analysis of Societal and Ecosystem Metabolism)-a rigorous nexus-type research method. We explore how these scholars tried to overcome data challenges, their reflections on data availability, and how governments and other institutions might benefit if they had the missing data the scholars sought. Additionally, the study delves into the scholars' interpretations of why the data is missing in the first place. Using a grounded approach, this qualitative study examines interview texts and reveals a range of issues that scholars faced, including an excess of aggregated data-a lack of disaggregated data-problems with data categorization, and other issues. On the whole, respondents' reflections align with the foundational arguments of MuSIASEM's developers, suggesting that more comprehensive, granular, and therefore effective approaches are needed to address socioecological challenges, sustainability issues, and net-zero goals. Respondents also noted that much of the missing data could be attributed to a dominance of economic logics and conceptual frames that often obfuscate the material and biophysical foundations of those economic systems themselves. This study advocates for revisiting and enhancing those conceptual frameworks that shape "what data is collected" and how it is made available in order to enhance analyses and broaden collective deliberations toward more informed sustainability and related policy decisions.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Assessing public support for degrowth, survey-based experimental and predictive studies

  • Krpan, Dario|||0000-0002-3420-4672
  • Basso, Frédéric|||0000-0003-3709-8331
  • Hickel, Jason Edward|||0000-0002-7490-9757
  • Kallis, Giorgos|||0000-0003-0688-9552
Background Degrowth argues that high-income economies should reduce harmful production and prioritise wellbeing. Although degrowth is increasingly seen as essential to tackling climate change, the extent of public support for this economic approach remains unclear. In this study, we aimed to investigate public support for the full degrowth proposal in the UK and USA—high-income, growth-oriented nations with substantial climate responsibility and political resistance to degrowth. Our objectives were to distinguish support for the proposal itself from perceptions of the degrowth label and to examine the role of participants’ individual differences. Methods Our objectives were examined in two studies, Study 1 and Study 2, administered online via Qualtrics. For both studies, participants in the USA and UK were recruited via Prolific (an online pool of participants) to be representative of the respective populations in age, gender, and ethnicity. Participants had to pass several attention and quality checks to qualify for analyses. Study 1 used a within-subjects design whereby all participants rated their support for the full degrowth proposal (summarising the key ideas, practices, and goals of degrowth) without any label and for eight economic approaches presented by label only (ie, degrowth, ecomodernism, ecosocialism, green capitalism, green growth, green market economy, post growth, and wellbeing economy) on a 7-point scale (from 1 [strongly oppose] to 7 [strongly support]). Study 2 used a between-subjects design whereby participants were randomly assigned using the randomiser function in Qualtrics, to one of seven economic approaches (the full degrowth proposal; a label referring to either degrowth, ecosocialism, or wellbeing economy without a description; or a combination of the full degrowth proposal with one of these three labels), for which they rated their support on the same 7-point scale. Mean support for each approach was classified on the basis of 95% CIs, meaning that similar means could be classified differently across studies and samples due to variations in these intervals. To identify key predictors of support, we also measured 74 individual differences, including various psychological and socioeconomic characteristics, and analysed them using an approach combining widely used machine learning models with multiple linear regression analyses; a variable was considered a key predictor only if it ranked among the most predictive in the machine learning models and was also statistically significant in the regression analyses. Findings Data were collected from study participants between Oct 10, 2023, and Dec 1, 2023. 6228 participants from the UK and USA were initially recruited, of whom 5454 were eligible for analyses. When presented without a label, in the UK, the full degrowth proposal received support from 736 (81%) of 910 participants in Study 1 and 210 (82%) of 255 in Study 2. In the USA, it received support from 683 (73%) of 941 participants in Study 1 and 187 (72%) of 260 in Study 2. On the 7-point scale, in Study 1, support was 5⋅37 in the UK and 5⋅07 in the USA (both corresponding to somewhat support), whereas, in Study 2, support was 5⋅34 in the UK (corresponding to somewhat support to support) and 4⋅97 in the USA (corresponding to somewhat support). When degrowth was presented as a label alone, it received support from 237 (26%) of 910 participants in Study 1 and 50 (20%) of 250 participants in Study 2 in the UK and 266 (28%) of 941 participants in Study 1 and 34 (13%) of 270 participants in Study 2 in the USA. In Study 2, the degrowth label accompanied by the full proposal was supported by 184 (74%) of 248 participants in the UK and 177 (68%) of 260 participants in the USA. In addition, 188 (75%) of 250 participants in the UK and 176 (67%) of 264 participants in the USA supported the full degrowth proposal plus ecosocialism label, and 209 (84%) of 250 participants in the UK and 179 (72%) of 249 participants in the USA supported the full degrowth proposal plus wellbeing economy label. Key individual difference predictors of support were people’s drive to address global challenges and belief in ecosystem integrity. Interpretation Contrary to concerns from politicians and commentators that degrowth is broadly unpopular, the core degrowth proposal received substantial support from UK and US participants in this study, regardless of whether the full proposal was accompanied by the degrowth label. Therefore, negative perceptions of the degrowth label appear surmountable once people learn about the main principles behind degrowth. Fostering proactive engagement with global challenges and awareness of nature’s fragility could further enhance the public’s acceptance of degrowth. Funding London School of Economics and Political Science.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Encountering degrowth

  • Gilbert, David Edward|||0000-0003-3394-0050
  • Gasparro, Donatella|||0009-0001-2695-7068
  • Kallis, Giorgos|||0000-0003-0688-9552
  • Muñoz Sueiro, Lucia|||0000-0002-6972-2648
  • Grosinger, Julia|||0000-0001-7255-3745
  • Tsagkari, Marula|||0000-0002-7925-3769
  • Khan, Feroz Mohamed|||0009-0002-3163-4770
  • Wright, Grace
  • Varvarousis, Angelos|||0000-0003-4300-6456
Degrowth theory and movements aim to find ways of living well while downscaling the economy, heal the many metabolic rifts that threaten global ecologies with capitalist exploitation of the earth, and end injustice and violence. While degrowth transformations may not ever be wholly achievable, we nevertheless propose that degrowth exists as lived experiences and practices. These practices take territorial expression and can be understood through ethnographic encounters. We consider geographies that involve people living well with less; downscaling and decarbonizing the economy; and seeking to undoing inequalities and injustices. We argue that all of these degrowth phenomena are necessarily expressed in and through territories. To show how these degrowth ideas, practices, and processes take territorial expression, we ground our analysis in ethnographic encounters with individuals living in the Southern Italy uplands, the Greek island of Ikaria, and the plantation-lands of Sumatra, Indonesia. Ethnographies of encounter allow us to perceive the world in ways not previously considered, giving insight into languages and understandings of lived degrowth experience and politics. Our approach allows us to nuance and ground degrowth political economic theorizing while addressing relational questions of cultural, political, and environmental change. We find learning from kindred territorialized practices of degrowth to be a way to understand degrowth as it is lived and experienced. We describe and analyze degrowth territorializing processes and practices that contribute to spaces co-constituted through broader political economies of capitalist territorialization and depeasantization, material conditions of land, and contextualized degrowth epistemologies. We conclude with a consideration of our ethnographic encounters as points of overlap and departure for understanding lived experiences of degrowth from disparate, "out of the way" places of the world from the uplands and islands, from the Mediterranean to Southeast Asia.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Defining growth dependence

  • Janischewski, Anja|||0009-0007-8756-7964
  • Bohnenberger, Katharina
  • Kranke, Matthias
  • Vogel, Tobias|||0000-0003-0720-0681
  • Driouich, Riwan|||0009-0001-3824-9384
  • Froese, Tobias
  • Gerold, Stefanie
  • Kaufmann, Raphael
  • Keyßer, Lorenz
  • Niethammer, Jannis
  • Olk, Christopher
  • Schmelzer, Matthias
  • Yürük, Aslı
  • Lange, Steffen
Many socio-economic systems require positive economic growth rates to function properly. These growth dependencies pose serious challenges given uncertainty about future growth rates and the role of economic growth as a driver of environmental crises. Thus, identifying and transforming socio-economic systems that currently rely on growth for their adequate functioning is a crucial step towards effective sustainability transformations. To facilitate conceptual clarity, we propose a general definition and framework for operationalizing the concept of "growth dependence" through four elements: (1) the system under investigation, (2) the unit of growth measurement, (3) the meaning of "growth", and (4) the functions or properties of the system relevant for human well-being. We illustrate the impact of varieties in definitions on assessment outcomes by applying the framework to areas widely seen as growth-dependent: labor markets, social insurance and public finance. Our framework helps researchers to develop a more coherent understanding of growth dependence, a prerequisite for assessing policy options towards growth independence.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

"Made in Germany"?, Labour, wages and carbon footprints of consumption and production of the motor vehicles industry

  • Pérez-Sánchez, Laura|||0000-0002-6772-8456
  • Aguilar-Hernandez, Glenn A.
Production is fragmented in global production networks, and consumption relies on global markets. Their impacts and profits are unevenly distributed in the international division of labour. Such complexity and entanglement call for footprint approaches that capture these regional and sectoral distributions. We calculate through Multi-Regional Input-Output Analysis (MRIOA) the working time, compensation of employees, and GHG emissions and their regional and sectoral distribution in two global value chains related to the Motor vehicles industry in Germany (1995-2020): (1) the Supply system of global Motor Vehicles Industry to Germany, which provides vehicles and replacement parts to Germany and (2) the German Final production system of Motor Vehicles Industry, which manufactures "made in Germany" vehicles sold in global markets. This unravels the uneven distribution of profits and impacts through global trade and enables different perspectives on social and environmental responsibility of consumers and producers. In both systems, but more intensively in the Final production system, Germany kept most of the compensation of employees while generating less than half of GHG emissions and less than a third of employment. The whole supply-chain production of "made in Germany" vehicles generated 73% of salaries in Germany, while it relied on 63% of emissions and 54% of working time in upstream processes abroad in 2018. In terms of sectors, the Motor vehicles industry obtained about half of the salaries with 5% of emissions in both systems. Producing a vehicle in Germany requires approximately 1400 working hours, the equivalent of one year of labour by a German worker.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Structural adjustment, damages, reparations and pathways to non-recurrence

  • Hickel, Jason Edward|||0000-0002-7490-9757
  • Keshavjee, Salmaan A.
  • Burkett, Maxine
  • Richardson, Eugene T.|||0000-0001-8437-0671
Beginning in the 1980s and 1990s, the International Monetary Fund (IMF) and the World Bank implemented neoliberal structural adjustment programmes (SAPs) across most countries in Asia, Africa and Latin America. SAPs imposed austerity, privatisation and economic deregulation and have been associated with severe negative impacts on human welfare, including (a) declining real wages and working-class consumption, (b) increased rates of poverty and basic-needs deprivation, (c) increased neonatal and maternal mortality and (d) reduced health system access. Structural adjustment also created conditions for increased financial outflows and drain from the global South through unequal exchange. This paper reviews evidence of these damages and proposes possible options for reparations and distributive justice. We argue that the IMF and the World Bank should be democratised and restructured-or otherwise replaced by alternative institutions-to prevent further harm.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Open veins, drain from Latin America through ecologically unequal exchange

  • Hanbury Lemos, Mariana Morena|||0000-0001-5339-2085
  • Hickel, Jason Edward|||0000-0002-7490-9757
In Open Veins of Latin America (1971), Eduardo Galeano argued that colonial interventions in Latin America organised the regional economy around raw material exports and drained the continent of valuable resources and labour, producing conditions of underdevelopment. Scholars have argued that this dynamic continues today, where the suppression of prices and input costs in peripheral regions enables the global North to appropriate resources and value through 'unequal exchange'. Building on this analysis and grounded in the Marxist tradition of dependency theory, this study empirically assesses Latin America's position with respect to unequal exchange of natural resources and labour embodied in trade. We use environmentally extended multi-regional input-output (EEMRIO) analysis to measure net flows of embodied materials (biomass, fossil fuels, minerals, and metals), land, and labour between Latin America, the global North, China, and the rest of the global South (1995 to 2020) across seven sectors, along with wage compensation against the labour flows. We find that Latin America has suffered a large drain of all resources to the North over the period. In 2020, the North net-appropriated 935 million tons of materials (including biomass, minerals, metals, and fossil fuels), 4 million km2 of land, and 53 billion hours of labour (worth €816 billion in Northern wages) from Latin America, mostly consumed as manufactured goods and services. We find that Latin America's position in the world economy is increasingly 'peripheral' in character. It remains a major supplier of primary commodities to the North, experiences a greater per capita drain of biomass, metals, and land than China or the rest of the global South, and disproportionately suffers the ecological damages of Northern consumption.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Translating system-level change to individuals, Experimental evidence on avenues to communicate about degrowth and green growth

  • O'Dell, Dallas|||0009-0003-1432-0777
  • Basso, Frédéric|||0000-0003-3709-8331
  • Shreedhar, Ganga
Degrowth is gaining scholarly attention as a means of transforming affluent societies, by downscaling production and consumption whilst guaranteeing a good life for all within planetary boundaries, through collectively defined self-limitation. However, little empirical research has investigated communication and framing techniques to translate degrowth's system-level focus into individual consumption decisions and self-limitation practices. There is also little critical reflection on the role of the messenger, that is, how commercial versus non-commercial messengers may effectively promote sufficiency or support the degrowth agenda. In two online experiments and subsequent regression analyses, we explored how framing messages around degrowth versus green growth influenced intentions, values, and behaviors to act more sustainably amongst U.K. millennial respondents (N1 = 969, N2 = 933). In Study 1, comparing the effect of sufficiency-promoting marketing (SPM) messages expressing self-orientation without (green growth) or with (degrowth) limits uncovered little difference in consumption attitudes and behaviors between conditions. SPM appeared ineffective at making degrowth values relevant to individuals or promoting widespread self-limitation, making it incompatible with any degrowth agenda. Study 2 tested whether Degrowth- or Green-Growth-framed communications from a non-commercial messenger affected civic-oriented values and policy support for collective limitations. Green Growth framing garnered higher environmental policy support, whilst Degrowth framing increased the likelihood of choosing degrowth or a-growth positions in the growth-versus-environment debate. These findings suggest degrowth framing inspires values whilst green growth spurs policy support. Further, degrowth messaging focused on system-level problems and solutions based on reductions may disengage individuals from mobilizing for societal change. This research exposes the paradoxical nature of sufficiency-promoting marketing. However, it also reveals potentially counterproductive psychological implications of degrowth messaging that can guide advocates developing communication strategies in non-commercial contexts.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Energy, surplus and the economic process

  • Kallis, Giorgos|||0000-0003-0688-9552
  • Cattaneo, Claudio|||0000-0001-7049-9298
  • Varvarousis, Angelos|||0000-0003-4300-6456
  • Tsagkari, Marula|||0000-0002-7925-3769
  • Conde, Marta|||0000-0003-0220-6080
  • D'Alisa, Giacomo|||0000-0001-9472-2837
  • Hanacek, Ksenija|||0000-0001-5283-2309
  • Nogué-Algueró, Borja|||0000-0003-3376-9564
  • Sekulova, Filka Tsvetkova|||0000-0001-6827-5359
  • Slameršak, Aljoša|||0000-0001-5643-0331
This paper analyses the economic process through the concept of surplus, combining insights from ecological economics, Marxist political economy and anthropology. Humans, we argue, appropriate surplus energy with their labor from nature and apply it to transform matter into goods and services, with entropy increasing along the way. How societies distribute and expend their surpluses gives them some of their signature features. In hierarchical societies, the ruling classes control a great share of the surplus and expend it in ways that reproduce their power. Economic growth, a distinctive feature of capitalist civilization, is the result of the ruling capitalist class investing surplus in the means of production in order to make more surplus. Surplus is extracted both via technological innovation that increases productivity and by social domination that reduces the share of surplus that goes back to workers or nature. Growth, however, is not only a material process but also a hegemonic story told by the capitalist class to dress its private interest as general interest, legitimating control over the destiny of surplus. Our framework proposes a political, ecological-economic theory of growth, provides a foundation for analyzing degrowth, and sheds new light on longstanding debates between ecological economists and Marxists.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

The myth of catch-up development, trends in core-periphery inequality from 1960 to 2023

  • Hickel, Jason Edward|||0000-0002-7490-9757
  • Sullivan, Dylan Jake|||0009-0008-9114-5243
The conventional narrative in international development holds that poorer countries are "catching up" with richer countries through the process of capitalist growth. This paper assesses this claim using data on inequality in GDP per capita for 1960-2023, processed using three different methods for currency comparison. We find that convergence narratives are not supported by empirical evidence. In fact, the opposite is occurring: the absolute income gap between the core ('advanced economies') and the periphery ('emerging and developing economies') has increased since 1960, by 170-270% depending on the currency concept. The core has captured 4-10x more income than the periphery over this period. Even in relative terms, convergence is not occurring; for most regions and most countries in the periphery their relative position vis-à-vis the core has deteriorated. Core-periphery inequality worsened particularly during the period of market liberalisation in the 1980s and 1990s. China is the only peripheral region that has meaningfully improved its relative position, but its income remains just 22-38% of the core level. While some peripheral countries have been integrated into the core for geopolitical reasons, an increasing majority of the world population is peripheralised. These results support the insights of world-systems analysts who argue that convergence is unlikely to occur within the existing structure of the capitalist world economy. Real development in the South will require strategies of industrial policy and planning to increase economic sovereignty, develop South-South trade, and delink from the imperial core.
Repositorio Digital de la UPF
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Perceptions of degrowth in the European Parliament

  • Kallis, Giorgos
  • Mastini, Riccardo
  • Zografos, Christos
Degrowth is a sustainability strategy that is attracting increasing scientific interest, but is seen as too radical for politicians to accept, especially when compared with 'green growth'. Here we use Q methodology to investigate viewpoints of political elites on degrowth and green growth by inquiring the views of 41 elected members of the European Parliament. We find opinions clustered around three distinct discourses: a 'Post-growth Deal', closer to degrowth, an 'Ecosocialist Green New Deal' and finally a 'Liberal Green Deal', linked to green growth. Green growth opinions are found in the centre-right of the political spectrum while two distinct centre-left/left discourses (post-growth and eco-socialism) are respectively critical and agnostic towards growth and coalesce on public investment, environmental justice, and working-hours reduction. Radical sustainability opinions therefore exist among elected policy makers, and consensus does not necessarily build on supposedly win-win options that combine growth and sustainability. Questions remain over when and how such radical opinions may find expression in concrete policies., We acknowledge support by the 'María de Maeztu' Unit of Excellence (MDM-2015-0552) grant. G.K.: this work was supported by the European Research Council REAL-ERC-2022-SYG REAL reference number 101071647. R.M.: the PhD project that gave rise to the results of this study received the support of a fellowship from 'la Caixa' Foundation (ID100010434) with code LCF/BQ/IN18/11660059. C.Z.: acknowledges support by the GRES research project (contract number CNS2022-136115) funded by the Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation MCIN/AEI/10.13039/501100011033 and the European Union Next Generation/PRTR programme. We acknowledge R. Sorensen for her help with editing and E. Karafilli for her help with the visuals.
Recercat. Dipósit de la Recerca de Catalunya
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Perceptions of degrowth in the European Parliament

  • Kallis, Giorgos
  • Mastini, Riccardo
  • Zografos, Christos
Degrowth is a sustainability strategy that is attracting increasing scientific interest, but is seen as too radical for politicians to accept, especially when compared with 'green growth'. Here we use Q methodology to investigate viewpoints of political elites on degrowth and green growth by inquiring the views of 41 elected members of the European Parliament. We find opinions clustered around three distinct discourses: a 'Post-growth Deal', closer to degrowth, an 'Ecosocialist Green New Deal' and finally a 'Liberal Green Deal', linked to green growth. Green growth opinions are found in the centre-right of the political spectrum while two distinct centre-left/left discourses (post-growth and eco-socialism) are respectively critical and agnostic towards growth and coalesce on public investment, environmental justice, and working-hours reduction. Radical sustainability opinions therefore exist among elected policy makers, and consensus does not necessarily build on supposedly win-win options that combine growth and sustainability. Questions remain over when and how such radical opinions may find expression in concrete policies., We acknowledge support by the 'María de Maeztu' Unit of Excellence (MDM-2015-0552) grant. G.K.: this work was supported by the European Research Council REAL-ERC-2022-SYG REAL reference number 101071647. R.M.: the PhD project that gave rise to the results of this study received the support of a fellowship from 'la Caixa' Foundation (ID100010434) with code LCF/BQ/IN18/11660059. C.Z.: acknowledges support by the GRES research project (contract number CNS2022-136115) funded by the Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation MCIN/AEI/10.13039/501100011033 and the European Union Next Generation/PRTR programme. We acknowledge R. Sorensen for her help with editing and E. Karafilli for her help with the visuals.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Compensation for atmospheric appropriation

  • Fanning, Andrew|||0000-0002-7929-3672
  • Hickel, Jason|||0000-0002-7490-9757
Research on carbon inequalities shows that some countries are overshooting their fair share of the remaining carbon budget and hold disproportionate responsibility for climate breakdown. Scholars argue that overshooting countries owe compensation or reparations to undershooting countries for atmospheric appropriation and climate-related damages. Here we develop a procedure to quantify the level of compensation owed in a 'net zero' scenario where all countries decarbonize by 2050, using carbon prices from IPCC scenarios that limit global warming to 1.5 °C and tracking cumulative emissions from 1960 across 168 countries. We find that even in this ambitious scenario, the global North would overshoot its collective equality-based share of the 1.5 °C carbon budget by a factor of three, appropriating half of the global South's share in the process. We calculate that compensation of US $1 92 trillion would be owed to the undershooting countries of the global South for the appropriation of their atmospheric fair shares by 2050, with an average disbursement to those countries of US $9 40 per capita per year. We also examine countries' overshoot of equality-based shares of 350 ppm and 2 °C carbon budgets and quantify the level of compensation owed using earlier and later starting years (1850 and 1992) for comparison.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Post-growth, A viable path to limiting global warming to 1.5°C

  • Slameršak, Aljoša|||0000-0001-5643-0331
  • Kallis, Giorgos|||0000-0003-0688-9552
  • O'neill, Daniel W.
  • Hickel, Jason|||0000-0002-7490-9757
Existing climate mitigation scenarios assume future rates of economic growth that are significantly higher than what has been experienced in the recent past. In this article we explore how assuming lower rates of growth, in line with the hypothesis of secular stagnation, changes the range of mitigation possibilities. We compare scenarios with moderate and strong policy ambition under both high-growth and low-growth assumptions. The results show that low growth makes it more feasible to decrease emissions in a way that is consistent with 1.5°C-2°C of warming. Moreover, low growth reduces the need to rely on unprecedented buildout of low-carbon energy infrastructure, and the unprecedented rates of energy-GDP decoupling that characterize existing scenarios. By contrast, pursuing higher growth rates, such as those represented in IMF projections, jeapordizes the Paris Agreement. The challenge is that lower growth is commonly associated with recession, which raises concerns about equity between and within countries, social stability, and the ability to finance a low-carbon energy transition. Recent literature on achieving a ''post-growth'' transition points to novel policies that could address these problems, which should be explored and evaluated in future mitigation scenarios.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Unequal exchange of labour in the world economy

  • Hickel, Jason|||0000-0002-7490-9757
  • Hanbury Lemos, Morena|||0000-0001-5339-2085
  • Barbour, Felix|||0000-0002-8979-2379
Researchers have argued that wealthy nations rely on a large net appropriation of labour and resources from the rest of the world through unequal exchange in international trade and global commodity chains. Here we assess this empirically by measuring flows of embodied labour in the world economy from 1995-2021, accounting for skill levels, sectors and wages. We find that, in 2021, the economies of the global North net-appropriated 826 billion hours of embodied labour from the global South, across all skill levels and sectors. The wage value of this net-appropriated labour was equivalent to €16.9 trillion in Northern prices, accounting for skill level. This appropriation roughly doubles the labour that is available for Northern consumption but drains the South of productive capacity that could be used instead for local human needs and development. Unequal exchange is understood to be driven in part by systematic wage inequalities. We find Southern wages are 87-95% lower than Northern wages for work of equal skill. While Southern workers contribute 90% of the labour that powers the world economy, they receive only 21% of global income.