Skip to main content

Resultados relacionados

Resultados totales (Incluyendo duplicados): 8
Encontrada(s) 1 página(s)

RiuNet. Repositorio Institucional de la Universitat Politécnica de Valéncia
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

DEXi-Dairy: an ex post multicriteria tool to assess the sustainability of dairy production systems in various European regions

  • Wilfart, Aurelie
  • Baillet, Vincent
  • Balaine, Lorraine
  • Dragoni. Federico
  • Krol, Dominika Joanna
  • Fratczak-Müller, Joanna
  • Rychla, Anna
  • Rodriguez, Divina Gracia P.
  • Breen, James
  • Anestis, Vasilieos
  • Buckley, Cathal
  • Alem, Habtamu
  • Winiwarter, Wilfried
  • Akkal-Corfini, Nouraya
  • Amon, Barbara
  • Diaz de Otalora-Aguirre, Xabier|||0000-0003-4841-079X
[EN] Growing awareness of global challenges and increasing pressures on the farming sector, including the urgent requirement to rapidly cut greenhouse gases (GHG) emissions, emphasize the need for sustainable production, which is particularly relevant for dairy production systems. Comparing dairy production systems across the three sustainability dimensions is a considerable challenge, notably due to the heterogeneity of production conditions in Europe. To overcome this, we developed an ex post multicriteria assessment tool that adopts a holistic approach across the three sustainability dimensions. This tool is based on the DEXi framework, which associates a hierarchical decision model with an expert perspective and follows a tree shaped structure; thus, we called it the DEXi-Dairy tool. For each dimension of sustainability, qualitative attributes were defined and organized in themes, sub-themes, and indicators. Their choice was guided by three objectives: (i) better describe main challenges faced by European dairy production systems, (ii) point out synergies and trade-offs across sustainability dimensions, and (iii) contribute to the identification of GHG mitigation strategies at the farm level. Qualitative scales for each theme, sub-theme, and indicator were defined together with weighting factors used to aggregate each level of the tree. Based on selected indicators, a list of farm data requirements was developed to populate the sustainability tree. The model was then tested on seven case study farms distributed across Europe. DEXi-Dairy presents a qualitative method that allows for the comparison of different inputs and the evaluation of the three sustainability dimensions in an integrated manner. By assessing synergies and trade-offs across sustainability dimensions, DEXi-Dairy is able to reflect the heterogeneity of dairy production systems. Results indicate that, while trade-offs occasionally exist among respective selected sub-themes, certain farming systems tend to achieve a higher sustainability score than others and hence could serve as benchmarks for further analyses., The publication of this article was funded by the MilKey project [ID number 39288] laureate of the 2018 Joint Call of the Cofund ERA-Nets FACCE ERA-GAS [grant number 696356], SusAn [grant number 696231], and ICT-AGRI 2 [grant number 618123] on Novel technologies, solutions and systems to reduce greenhouse gas emissions in animal production systems. The authors would like to acknowledge the fnancial support of their national funding agencies: the French National Research Agency (Agence Nationale de la Recherche) [grant number ANR-19-SUGA-0003]; the Irish Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine [grant number 2019EN201]; the German Federal Ministry of Food and Agriculture (BMEL) through the Federal Ofce for Agriculture and Food (BLE) [grant number 2819ERA08A]; the Research Council of Norway [grant number 310430]; the Polish National Centre for Research and Development (Narodowe Centrum Badań i Rozwoju) [grant number SUSAN / II / MILKEY / 02/2020]; and the Greek General Secretariat for Research and Innovation [grant number: T11ΕΡΑ4-00074].
RiuNet. Repositorio Institucional de la Universitat Politécnica de Valéncia
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Profiles of small-scale dairy farms assessed by socioeconomic and farm management practices: a case study from Poland

  • Rychla, Anna
  • Fragoni, Federico
  • Fratczak-Müller, Joanna
  • Kieronczyk, Marek
  • Suchowska-Kisielewicz, Monika
  • Winiwarter, Wilfried
  • Amon, Barbara
  • Diaz de Otalora-Aguirre, Xabier|||0000-0003-4841-079X
  • Méndez-Reyes, Daniel Alexander|||0000-0001-6414-305X
[EN] Agricultural systems vary worldwide due to location, socioeconomic conditions, and management practices. Understanding the patterns and key factors that lead to differences between farms is crucial to providing the best support for their development. In our study, we interviewed farmers who operate small-scale dairy farms (with 1-5 cows) in a major agricultural region of Poland specifically, the voivodships Ma¿opolskie and Podkarpackie, to understand how socioeconomic factors and farm management practices shape the diversity of farm profiles, and we evaluated our results using cluster analysis. Our findings confirmed the diversity among small-scale farming systems, allowing the identification of three distinct farm profiles. One of these clusters reflects part-time farmers characterized by low agricultural incomes, another long-standing peasant or hobby farms, while the smallest cluster referred to more professionalized agricultural systems. The key factors that characterized the different farm profiles were related to animal production (i.e. grazing time), infrastructure (i.e. manure storage facilities), farm size (i.e. land area), farming practices (i.e. mineral fertiliser use) and farmer's experience. The analysis also identified various socioeconomic factors that influenced the prospects for the continuity of different farm profiles, pointing out the need to devise support policies very specifically addressing the respective needs., Research was funded under the 2018 Joint Call of the Cofund ERA-Nets FACCE ERA-GAS (Grant N° 696356), ICT-AGRI 2 (Grant N° 618123) and SusAn (Grant N° 696231) on Novel technologies, solutions and systems to reduce greenhouse gas emissions in animal production systems and under the 2021 the Joint Call of the Cofund ERA-Nets SusCrop (Grant N° 771134), FACCE ERA-GAS (Grant N° 696356), ICT-AGRI-FOOD (Grant N°862665) and SusAn (Grant N° 696231). The authors acknowledge the financial support of their national funding agencies, the Polish National Centre for Research and Development (grant numbers SUSAN/II/ MILKEY/02/2020 and CIRCULARITY/50/DairyMix/2022) and German Federal Ministry of Food and Agriculture (BMEL) through the Federal Office for Agriculture and Food (BLE) (grant numbers 2819ERA08A and 2822ERA15A). The authors would like to thank the anonymous reviewers for their insightful comments and suggestions, which helped improve the quality of this manuscript.
RiuNet. Repositorio Institucional de la Universitat Politécnica de Valéncia
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Modelling the effect of context-specific greenhouse gas and nitrogen emission mitigation options in key European dairy farming systems

  • Diaz de Otalora-Aguirre, Xabier|||0000-0003-4841-079X
  • Estellés, F.|||0000-0001-6774-6075
  • Del Prado, Agustín
  • Fragoni, Federico
  • Balaine, Lorraine
  • Pardo, Guillermo
  • Winiwarter, Wilfried
  • Sandrucci, Anna
  • Ragaglini, Giorgio
  • Kabelitz, Tina
  • Kieronczyk, Marek
  • Jørgensen, Grete
  • Amon, Barbara
[EN] Understanding the environmental consequences associated with dairy cattle production systems is crucial for the implementation of targeted strategies for emission reduction. However, few studies have modelled the effect of tailored emission mitigation options across key European dairy production systems. Here, we assess the single and combined effect of six emission mitigation practises on selected case studies across Europe through the Sustainable and Integrated Management System for Dairy Production model. This semi-mechanistic model accounts for the interacting flows from a whole-farm perspective simulating the environmental losses in response to different management strategies and site-specific conditions. The results show how reducing the crude protein content of the purchased fraction of the diet was an adequate strategy to reduce the greenhouse gas and nitrogen emission intensity in all systems. Furthermore, implementing an anaerobic digestion plant reduced the greenhouse gas emissions in all tested case studies while increasing the nitrogen emissions intensity, particularly when slurry was applied using broadcast. Regarding the productivity increase, contrasting effects were observed amongst the case studies modelled. Moreover, shallow slurry injection effectively mitigated the intensity of nitrogen losses from the fields due to strong reductions in ammonia volatilisation. When substituting urea with ammonium nitrate as mineral fertiliser, site-specific conditions affected the mitigation potential observed, discouraging its application on sandy-loam soils. Rigid slurry covers effectively reduced the storage-related nitrogen emissions intensity while showing a minor effect on total greenhouse gas emission intensity. In addition, our results provide novel evidence regarding the advantages of cumulative implementation of adapted mitigation options to offset the negative trade-offs of single-option applications (i.e. slurry covers or anaerobic digestion and slurry injection). Through this study, we contribute to a better understanding of the effect of emission mitigation options across dairy production systems in Europe, thus facilitating the adoption of tailored and context-specific emission reduction strategies., Open Access funding enabled and organized by Projekt DEAL. This study was fnancially supported by the German Federal Ministry of Food and Agriculture (BMEL) through the Federal Ofce for Agriculture and Food (BLE) and other National Funding Agencies through the MilKey project (grant no. 2819ERA08A), funded under the Joint Call 2018 ERA-GAS (grant no. 696356), SusAn (grant no. 696231), and ICT-AGRI 2 (grant no. 618123) on Novel technologies, solutions and systems to reduce the greenhouse gas emissions in animal production systems ; and the DairyMix project (grant no. 2822ERA15A) under the Joint Call of the Cofund ERA-Nets SusCrop (grant no. 771134), FACCE ERA-GAS (grant no. 696356), ICT-AGRI-FOOD (grant no. 862665), and SusAn (grant no. 696231). BC3-Research is supported by the Spanish Government through María de Maeztu excellence 2023 2026 (ref. no. CEX2021- 001201-M, funded by MCIN/AEI/10.13039/501100011033 and by the Basque Government through the BERC 2022 2024 programme. Agustin del Prado is fnanced through the Ramon y Cajal programme by the Spanish Ministry of Economy, Industry, and Competitiveness (RYC-2017-22143). Agustin del Prado and Guillermo Pardo receive fnancial support through the CircAgric-GHG project funded by the 2nd 2021 call Programación conjunta internacional 2021 MCIN/ AEI/10.13039/501100011033 and Next Generation EU/PRTR (ref. no. PCI2021-122048-2A).
RiuNet. Repositorio Institucional de la Universitat Politécnica de Valéncia
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Influence of farm diversity on nitrogen and greenhouse gas emission sources from key European dairy cattle systems: A step towards emission mitigation and nutrient circularity

  • Diaz de Otalora-Aguirre, Xabier|||0000-0003-4841-079X
  • Estellés, F.|||0000-0001-6774-6075
  • Amon, B.
  • Balaine, L.
  • Dragoni. F.
  • Ragaglini, G.
  • Kieronczyk, M.
  • Jørgensen, G.H.M.
  • Del Prado, A.
[EN] CONTEXT: European dairy cattle production systems (DPS) are facing multiple challenges that threaten their social, economic, and environmental sustainability. In this context, it is crucial to implement options to promote the reconnection between crop and livestock systems as a way to reduce emissions and enhance nutrient circularity. However, given the sector's diversity, the successful implementation of these options lacks an evaluation framework that jointly considers the climatic conditions, farm characteristics, manure management and mineral fertilisation practices of DPS across Europe. OBJECTIVE: This study aims to develop a modelling and statistical framework to assess the effect of climatic conditions, farm characteristics, manure management and mineral fertilisation practices on the on-farm sources of greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions and nitrogen (N) losses from ten contrasting case studies for dairy production across Europe, identifying options for emissions mitigation and nutrient circularity. METHODS: Using the SIMSDAIRY deterministic whole-farm modelling approach, we estimated the GHG emissions and N losses from the ten case studies. SIMSDAIRY captures the effect of different farm management choices and site-specific conditions on nutrient cycling and emissions from different components of a dairy farm. In addition, we applied the Factor Analysis for Mixed Data multivariate statistical approach to quantitative and qualitative variables and identified relationships among emissions, nutrient losses, and the particular characteristics of the case studies assessed. RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS: The results showed how intensive case study farms in temperate climates were associated with lower enteric emissions but higher emissions from manure management (e.g. housing). In contrast, semi-extensive case study farms in cooler climates exhibited higher N losses and GHG emissions, directly linked to increased mineral fertilisation, excreta during grazing, and slurry application using broadcast. Furthermore, the results indicated opportunities to improve nutrient circularity and crop-livestock integration by toring context-specific emission mitigation options and nutrient circularity practices. By combining whole-farm modelling approaches and multivariate statistical methods, we enhance the understanding of the interactions between sources of N losses and GHG emissions. We expect our findings to inform the adoption of emissions reduction and circularity practices by fostering the recoupling between crop and livestock systems., This study was financially supported by the German Federal Ministry of Food and Agriculture (BMEL) through the Federal Office for Agriculture and Food (BLE) and other National Funding Agencies through the "MilKey" project (grant number 2819ERA08A) , funded under the Joint Call 2018 ERA-GAS (Grant No 696356) , SusAn (Grant No 696231) and ICT-AGRI 2 (Grant No 618123) on "Novel technologies, solutions and systems to reduce the greenhouse gas emissions in animal production systems", and the "DairyMix" project (grant number 2822ERA15A) under the Joint Call of the Cofund ERA-Nets SusCrop (Grant No 771134) , FACCE ERA-GAS (Grant No 696356) , ICT-AGRI-FOOD (Grant No 862665) and SusAn (Grant No 696231) . Agustin del Prado also receives financial support through the CircAgric-GHG project funded by the 2nd 2021 call "Programacion conjunta internacional 2021" MCIN/AEI/10.13039/501100011033 and Next Generation EU/PRTR (ref. no. PCI2021-122048-2A) . BC3-Research is supported by the Spanish Government through Maria de Maeztu Excellence 2023-2026 (ref. no. CEX2021-001201-M, funded by MCIN/AEI/10.13039/501100011033 and by the Basque Government through the BERC 2022-2024 Programme. Lorraine Balaine also acknowledges funding from the Irish Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine [grant number 2019EN201] . We thank Elisabeth Castellan, Anna Sandrucci, and Serena Bonizzi for their help in the data collection process. In addition, the first author would like to thank Lander Rodriguez Idiazabal (Basque Center for Applied Mathematics) for his contribution to the conceptualisation of the statistical analysis.
RiuNet. Repositorio Institucional de la Universitat Politécnica de Valéncia
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Influence of methodological choices in farm sustainability assessments: A word of caution from a case study analysis of European dairy farms

  • Balaine, L.
  • Buckley, C
  • Baillet, V
  • Fragoni. F
  • Wilfart, A
  • Amon, B.
  • Del Prado, A.
  • Fratczak-Müller, J
  • Krol, D
  • Diaz de Otalora-Aguirre, Xabier|||0000-0003-4841-079X
[EN] In a context where sustainability assessments are increasingly popular, this perspective article discusses the influence of methodological choices on measurements of farm sustainability. We build the argumentation on the premises that sustainability is a multi-dimensional concept that can be measured through an indicator approach and use examples from a case study analysis of seven European dairy farms. Specifically, the article demonstrates how and why indicator selection, estimation methods, and reporting frameworks can influence measured performance and thereby affect wider sustainability conclusions about production systems and practice change. Overall, we highlight that while in practical terms, methodological choices are necessary to conduct a farm sustainability assessment, important limitations can arise from the process. Of particular concern are farm conclusions and recommendations that lead to perverse outcomes and generate further sustainability issues outside of study scope. Practical guidance is provided to aid methodological choices with a more comprehensive and critical view of farm sustainability assessments. Importantly, we call for a more upfront recognition of methodological shortcomings in farm analyses., This research was funded under the 2018 Joint Call of the Cofund ERA-Nets FACCE ERA-GAS [grant number 696356], SusAn [grant number 696231], and ICT-AGRI 2 [grant number 618123] on Novel technologies, solutions and systems to reduce greenhouse gas emissions in animal production systems . The authors would like to acknowledge the financial support of their national funding agencies: the Irish Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine [grant number 2019EN201]; the French National Research Agency (Agence Nationale de la Recherche) [grant number ANR-19-SUGA-0003]; the German Federal Ministry of Food and Agriculture (BMEL) through the Federal Office for Agriculture and Food (BLE) [grant number 2819ERA08A]; and the Polish National Centre for Research and Development (Narodowe Centrum Badań i Rozwoju) [grant number SUSAN / II / MILKEY / 02/2020]. Agustín del Prado (BC3) is funded by the Ramon y Cajal programme from the Spanish Ministry of Economy and Competitiveness (RYC-2017-22143) and by Ikerbasque Basque Foundation for Science. BC3 acknowledges financial support by the Spanish Government through María de Maeztu excellence accreditation 2023-2026 (Ref. CEX2021-001201-M, funded by MCIN/AEI /10.13039/501100011033) and the Basque Government through the BERC 2022-2024 programme. Finally, the authors acknowledge the help of Elisabeth Castellan (IDELE), Habtamu Alem (NIBIO), and Grete Jørgensen (NIBIO) in collecting the data used in this article.
RiuNet. Repositorio Institucional de la Universitat Politécnica de Valéncia
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Evaluating Three-Pillar Sustainability Modelling Approaches for Dairy Cattle Production Systems

  • Diaz de Otalora-Aguirre, Xabier|||0000-0003-4841-079X
  • Estellés, F.|||0000-0001-6774-6075
  • Del Prado, Agustín
  • Dragoni, Federico
  • Amon, Barbara
[EN] Milk production in Europe is facing major challenges to ensure its economic, environmental, and social sustainability. It is essential that holistic concepts are developed to ensure the future sustainability of the sector and to assist farmers and stakeholders in making knowledge-based decisions. In this study, integrated sustainability assessment by means of whole-farm modelling is presented as a valuable approach for identifying factors and mechanisms that could be used to improve the three pillars (3Ps) of sustainability in the context of an increasing awareness of economic profitability, social well-being, and environmental impacts of dairy production systems (DPS). This work aims (i) to create an evaluation framework that enables quantitative analysis of the level of integration of 3P sustainability indicators in whole-farm models and (ii) to test this method. Therefore, an evaluation framework consisting of 35 indicators distributed across the 3Ps of sustainability was used to evaluate three whole-farm models. Overall, the models integrated at least 40% of the proposed indicators. Different results were obtained for each sustainability pillar by each evaluated model. Higher scores were obtained for the environmental pillar, followed by the economic and the social pillars. In conclusion, this evaluation framework was found to be an effective tool that allows potential users to choose among whole-farm models depending on their needs. Pathways for further model development that may be used to integrate the 3P sustainability assessment of DPS in a more complete and detailed way were identified., This study was financially supported by the German Federal Ministry of Food and Agriculture (BMEL) through the Federal Office for Agriculture and Food (BLE) under grant number 2819ERA08A (MilKey project, funded under the Joint Call 2018 ERA-GAS, SusAn and ICT-AGRI 2 on Novel technologies, solutions and systems to reduce the greenhouse gas emissions in animal production systems). BC3-Research is supported by the Spanish Government through María de Maeztu excellence accreditation 2018-2022 (Ref. MDM-2017-0714) and by the Basque Government through the BERC 2018¿2021 program. Agustin del Prado is financed through the Ramon y Cajal program by the Spanish Ministry of Economy, Industry, and Competitiveness (RYC-2017-22143).
RiuNet. Repositorio Institucional de la Universitat Politécnica de Valéncia
Publication Tesis doctoral (DoctoralThesis)

Sustainability Assessment of Key European Dairy Cattle Production Systems: System Identification, Analysis, and Greenhouse Gas and Nitrogen Emission Mitigation

  • Diaz de Otalora-Aguirre, Xabier|||0000-0003-4841-079X
[ES] Durante las últimas décadas, múltiples retos han puesto en riesgo la sostenibilidad medioambiental, económica y social de los sistemas de producción de vacuno lechero (SPL). Esta Tesis Doctoral aborda algunos de los principales retos del sector en materia de sostenibilidad mediante el desarrollo de conceptos, metodologías y estrategias adaptadas a las necesidades particulares de un amplio abanico de SPL en Europa. Las investigaciones se centran en la evaluación de las herramientas de análisis de la sostenibilidad, el análisis de la diversidad de sistemas de producción existentes, así como en la mitigación adaptada de las emisiones de gases de efecto invernadero (GEI) y pérdidas de nitrógeno (N) a escala de granja. Esta Tesis Doctoral presenta un marco cuantitativo que permite un análisis exhaustivo de las herramientas existentes para la determinación de la sostenibilidad a escala de granja. Los resultados muestran como las herramientas evaluadas presentan un mayor número de indicadores asociados con el pilar medioambiental que con el pilar económico y social. En adición, se facilita la identificación de vías para el desarrollo futuro de los modelos, permitiendo una más completa y detallada evaluación de la sostenibilidad. Asimismo, los resultados obtenidos en materia de análisis de la diversidad de SPL, permiten la identificación, descripción y agrupación de las regiones europeas de acuerdo con diferentes tipologías de sistemas productivos. Las 16 tipologías representativas identificadas, combinan las características estructurales, productivas, socioeconómicas y medioambientales de los SPL con la distribución de cultivos forrajeros más relevantes para la producción láctea a escala NUTS2. Al analizar y agrupar la diversidad de sistemas productivos y evaluar su nivel de integración, esta Tesis Doctoral facilita la toma de decisiones basadas en el conocimiento, el diseño y la aplicación de medidas de mitigación de emisiones específicas y adaptadas, así como la promoción de sinergias económicas y sociales positivas. En adición, esta Tesis Doctoral pone de manifiesto la gran influencia de las condiciones climáticas, las características estructurales y las prácticas de manejo sobre las emisiones de N y GEI asociadas a la fermentación entérica, los cultivos, así como a toda la cadena de gestión del estiércol. Al identificar la magnitud y fuentes de emisión de los SPL, se facilita la aplicación de medidas específicas a cada contexto. En términos de mitigación de las emisiones, la reducción de la proteína bruta en la fracción comprada de la dieta es una estrategia eficaz a la hora de mitigar tanto las emisiones de GEI como las pérdidas de N. Además, la implantación de una planta de digestión anaerobia es efectiva a la hora de reducir la intensidad de GEI en todos los SPL evaluados, aumentando únicamente las pérdidas de N en el sistema mediterráneo intensivo. El impacto del incremento de la productividad a través de un mayor uso piensos sobre las pérdidas de N y las emisiones de GEI es variable entre los sistemas examinados. A este respecto, el sistema semi-extensivo centroeuropeo muestra un mayor potencial de reducción de GEI, mientras que el semi-extensivo atlántico obtiene mejores resultados en la reducción de las pérdidas de N. Del mismo modo, el uso de la inyección de purines reduce las pérdidas de N en campo, incrementando las emisiones de GEI en el sistema mediterráneo. La sustitución de urea por nitrato amónico tiene diferentes efectos sobre los GEI y la intensidad de N, observándose un mayor potencial de mitigación en el sistema semi-extensivo atlántico. Por último, las cubiertas rígidas de purines mitigan eficazmente las pérdidas de N durante el almacenamiento, con un impacto mínimo en las emisiones totales de GEI. Así mismo, a lo largo de esta Tesis Doctoral se demuestra como la aplicación cumulativa de medidas de mitigación, deriva en sinergias positivas a la hora de reducir las emisiones globales de la explotación., [CA] Durant les últimes dècades, múltiples reptes n'han posat en risc la sostenibilitat mediambiental, econòmica i social dels sistemes de producció de boví de llet (SPL). Aquesta Tesi Doctoral aborda alguns dels principals reptes del sector en termes de sostenibilitat mitjançant el desenvolupament de conceptes, metodologies i estratègies adaptades a les necessitats particulars d'un ampli ventall de SPL a Europa. Les investigacions se centren en l'avaluació de les eines per a la seua quantificació, l'anàlisi de la diversitat de sistemes de producció existents, així com en la mitigació adaptada de les emissions de gasos d'efecte d'hivernacle (GEH) i pèrdues de nitrogen (N) a escala de granja. Aquesta Tesi Doctoral presenta un marc quantitatiu que permet una anàlisi exhaustiu de les eines existents per a la determinació de la sostenibilitat a escala de granja. Els resultats obtinguts mostren com les eines avaluades presenten un major nombre d'indicadors associats amb el pilar mediambiental que amb el pilar econòmic i social. A més, aquest treball facilita la identificació de vies per al desenvolupament futur dels models i facilita una avaluació de la sostenibilitat més completa i detallada. Els resultats obtinguts en matèria d'anàlisi de la diversitat de SPL permeten la identificació, descripció i agrupació de les regions europees d'acord amb diferents tipologies de sistemes productius. Les 16 tipologies representatives identificades combinen les característiques estructurals, productives, socioeconòmiques i mediambientals dels SPL amb la distribució de conreus farratgers més rellevants per a la producció làctia a escala NUTS2. En addició, en analitzar i agrupar la diversitat de sistemes productius i avaluar el seu nivell d'integració, aquesta Tesi Doctoral facilita la presa de decisions basada en el coneixement, el disseny i l'aplicació de mesures de mitigació d'emissions específiques i adaptades, així com la promoció de sinergies econòmiques i socials positives. Així mateix, aquesta Tesi Doctoral indica la gran influència de les condicions climàtiques, les característiques estructurals i les pràctiques de maneig sobre les emissions de N i GEH associades a la fermentació entèrica, els conreus, així com tota la cadena de gestió del fem. A més, en identificar la magnitud i fonts d'emissió dels SPL, es facilita l'aplicació de mesures específiques a cada context. En aquest sentit, la reducció de la proteina bruta en la porció comprada de la dieta és una estratègia eficaç per a mitigar tant les emissions de GEH com les de N. A més, la implantació d'una planta de digestió anaeròbia va reduir la intensitat de GEH en totes les SPL avaluades, augmentant únicament les emissions de N en el sistema mediterrani intensiu. L'impacte de l'increment de la productivitat a través d'un major use pinsos sobre les pèrdues de N i les emissions de GEH va variar entre els sistemes d'explotació examinats. Referent a això, el sistema semi-extensiu centreeuropeu va mostrar un major potencial de reducció de GEH, mentre que el semi-extensiu atlàntic va obtindre millors resultats en la reducció de les pèrdues de N. De la mateixa manera, l'ús de la injecció de purins va reduir les emissions de N a nivell de camp, incrementant les emissions de GEH en el sistema mediterrani. La substitució d'urea per nitrat d'amoni va tindre diferents efectes sobre els GEH i la intensitat de N, observant-se un major potencial de mitigació en el sistema semi-extensiu atlàntic. Finalment, les cobertes rígides de purins van reduir eficaçment les pèrdues de N durant l'emmagatzematge amb un impacte mínim en les emissions totals de GEH. Així mateix, al llarg d'aquesta Tesi Doctoral es demostra com l'aplicació cumulativa de mesures de mitigació deriva en sinergies positives a l'hora de reduir les emissions globals de l'explotació., [EN] During the last decades, multiple challenges have put the environmental, economic, and social sustainability of dairy cattle production systems (DPS) at risk. This Ph.D. Thesis tackles some of the sector's main challenges in terms of sustainability by developing concepts, methodologies, and strategies adapted to the particular needs of a wide range of European DPS. In particular, special emphasis is placed on evaluating the tools for sustainability assessments, the analysis and clustering of the diversity of existing production systems, and the adapted mitigation of greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions and nitrogen (N) losses at the farm scale. This Ph.D. Thesis presents a quantitative framework that comprehensively evaluates whole-farm tools and models. The obtained results show how the models considered incorporate more indicators from the environmental pillar than those related to the economic or social sphere. In addition, this work facilitates the identification of avenues for future model developments, allowing for a more complete and detailed assessment of sustainability. Furthermore, the results obtained allow for the identification, description, and clustering of European regions according to different typologies of production systems. The 16 representative typologies identified combine DPS's structural, productive, socio-economic, and environmental characteristics with the level of overlap with the most relevant fodder crops for dairy production at the NUTS2 scale. Furthermore, by analyzing and clustering the diversity of production systems and assessing their level of integration, this Ph.D. Thesis facilitates knowledge-based decision-making, the design and implementation of targeted and adapted emission mitigation measures, as well as the promotion of positive economic and social synergies. Moreover, this Ph.D. Thesis highlights the strong influence of climatic conditions, structural characteristics, and management practices on N and GHG emissions associated with enteric fermentation, fields, and manure management. In terms of emission mitigation, reducing the amount of crude protein in the purchased fraction of the diet is an effective strategy to mitigate both GHG and N emissions. Additionally, implementing an anaerobic digestion plant reduces GHG emissions in all assessed DPS but increases N losses only in the intensive Mediterranean DPS. The impact of increased productivity through larger use of concentrates on N losses and GHG emissions varied depending on the farming systems examined. In this sense, the Central European semi-extensive system shows a higher potential for GHG reduction, while the Atlantic semi-extensive system accounts for better results when lowering the N losses. Similarly, shallow slurry injection effectively decreases N losses at the field level, although it increases GHG emissions in the Mediterranean DPS. Substituting urea with ammonium nitrate has different effects on GHG and N emission intensity, with greater potential for mitigation in the Atlantic semi-extensive system. Lastly, rigid slurry covers effectively reduces N losses during storage with minimal impact on GHG emissions. Furthermore, this Ph.D. Thesis shows how the cumulative application of mitigation measures leads to positive synergies in reducing the overall emissions of the farm., All studies conducted in the course of this Ph.D. Thesis were funded by the German Federal Ministry of Food and Agriculture (BMEL) through the Federal Office for Agriculture and Food (BLE) within the framework of the project "MilKey" (grant number 2819ERA08A), funded by the joint call 2018 ERA-GAS (grant no. 696356), SusAn (grant no. 696231) and ICT-AGRI 2 (grant no. 618123) on "New technologies, solutions, and systems to reduce greenhouse gas emissions in animal production systems". BC3-Research is supported by the Spanish Government through María de Maeztu excellence accreditation 2018–2022 (Ref. MDM-2017-0714) and María de Maeztu excellence accreditation 2023-2026 (Ref. CEX2021-001201-M, funded by MCIN/AEI/10.13039/501100011033) and by the Basque Government through the BERC 2018–2021 program. Agustin del Prado is financed through the Ramon y Cajal program by the Spanish Ministry of Economy, Industry, and Competitiveness (RYC-2017-22143).
Addi. Archivo Digital para la Docencia y la Investigación
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Influence of methodological choices in farm sustainability assessments: A word of caution from a case study analysis of European dairy farms

  • Balaine, L.
  • Buckley, C.
  • Baillet, V.
  • Díaz de Otálora, X.
  • Dragoni, F.
  • Wilfart, A.
  • Amon, B.
  • del Prado, A.
  • Frątczak-Müller, J.
  • Krol, D.
In a context where sustainability assessments are increasingly popular, this perspective article discusses the influence of methodological choices on measurements of farm sustainability. We build the argumentation on the premises that sustainability is a multi-dimensional concept that can be measured through an indicator approach and use examples from a case study analysis of seven European dairy farms. Specifically, the article demonstrates how and why indicator selection, estimation methods, and reporting frameworks can influence measured performance and thereby affect wider sustainability conclusions about production systems and practice change. Overall, we highlight that while in practical terms, methodological choices are necessary to conduct a farm sustainability assessment, important limitations can arise from the process. Of particular concern are farm conclusions and recommendations that lead to perverse outcomes and generate further sustainability issues outside of study scope. Practical guidance is provided to aid methodological choices with a more comprehensive and critical view of farm sustainability assessments. Importantly, we call for a more upfront recognition of methodological shortcomings in farm analyses., This research was funded under the 2018 Joint Call of the Cofund ERA-Nets FACCE ERA-GAS [grant number 696356], SusAn [grant number 696231], and ICT-AGRI 2 [grant number 618123] on \u201CNovel technologies, solutions and systems to reduce greenhouse gas emissions in animal production systems\u201D. The authors would like to acknowledge the financial support of their national funding agencies: the Irish Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine [grant number 2019EN201]; the French National Research Agency (Agence Nationale de la Recherche) [grant number ANR-19-SUGA-0003]; the German Federal Ministry of Food and Agriculture (BMEL) through the Federal Office for Agriculture and Food (BLE) [grant number 2819ERA08A]; and the Polish National Centre for Research and Development (Narodowe Centrum Bada\u0144 i Rozwoju) [grant number SUSAN / II / MILKEY / 02/2020]. Agust\u00EDn del Prado (BC3) is funded by the Ramon y Cajal programme from the Spanish Ministry of Economy and Competitiveness (RYC-2017-22143) and by Ikerbasque \u2013 Basque Foundation for Science. BC3 acknowledges financial support by the Spanish Government through Mar\u00EDa de Maeztu excellence accreditation 2023-2026 (Ref. CEX2021-001201-M, funded by MCIN/AEI /10.13039/501100011033) and the Basque Government through the BERC 2022-2024 programme. Finally, the authors acknowledge the help of Elisabeth Castellan (IDELE), Habtamu Alem (NIBIO), and Grete J\u00F8rgensen (NIBIO) in collecting the data used in this article.