- Alari, Anna
- Ballester, Joan
- Milà, Carles
- Benmarhnia, Tarik
- Sofiev, Mikhail
- Uppstu, Andreas
- Hänninen, Risto
- Tonne, Cathryn
Background: Fine particulate matter (PM2·5) from wildfire smoke could be more harmful to human health than that from other sources. Evidence of the short-term association between wildfire-related PM2·5 and mortality in Europe remains sparse, leading to uncertainties in the fire-related PM2·5 mortality burden. Methods: In this retrospective, multicountry epidemiological study, we used the EARLY-ADAPT database to obtain daily mortality records in 654 contiguous subnational regions from 32 European countries, representing a population of 541 million individuals. We combined these data with daily estimates of fire-related and non-fire-related PM2·5 from the System for Integrated Modelling of Atmospheric Composition model during 2004-22. Regional and pooled associations between daily fire-related PM2·5 and all-cause and cause-specific mortality were quantified using quasi-Poisson regression. We compared deaths attributable to fire-related PM2·5 using relative risks (RRs) specific to fire-related PM2·5 versus total PM2·5. Findings: Our study data included 95⸱3 million daily deaths for all-cause mortality, 19⸱5 million daily deaths for cardiovascular mortality, and 3⸱9 million daily deaths for respiratory mortality from Jan 1, 2004, until the latest available year in each country. Pooled cumulative (lags 0-7) RRs associated with a 1 μg per m3 increase in fire-related PM2·5 were 1⸱007 (95% CI 1⸱004-1⸱010) for all-cause mortality, 1⸱009 (1⸱006-1⸱013) for cardiovascular mortality, and 1⸱013 (1⸱008-1⸱019) for respiratory mortality. RRs were larger for fire-related PM2·5 than for non-fire-related PM2·5. Using RRs for total (fire-related and non-fire-related) PM2·5 underestimated the fire-related PM2·5 attributable mortality by 93%.Interpretation: Associations with all-cause and cause-specific mortality were larger for fire-related compared with non-fire-related PM2·5. Assuming wildfire PM2·5 has the same effect as total PM2·5 substantially underestimates the mortality burden of wildfire smoke., This work received funding from the EU Horizon Europe research and innovation programme (101057131), Climate Action To Advance Healthy Societies in Europe, EXHAUSTION (820655), European Research Council consolidator grant EARLY-ADAPT (https://early-adapt.eu), European Research Council proof-of-concept grants HHS-EWS and FORECAST-AIR (https://forecaster.health/), and the Research Council of Finland project VFSP-WASE (359421). We acknowledge support from the grant CEX2023-0001290-S funded by MCIN/AEI/ 10.13039/501100011033, and support from the Generalitat de Catalunya through the CERCA Program. We would like to acknowledge the following data providers of the EARLY-ADAPT mortality database: Statistics Austria, the Agency for Statistics of Bosnia and Herzegovina, Directorate-General Statistics—Statistics Belgium, the National Statistics Institute of Bulgaria, the Federal Statistical Office of Switzerland (data from causes of death statistics 1969–1994 / 1995–2020 / 2020 onwards), the Health Monitoring Unit of the Ministry of Health of Cyprus (The data used in this study was collected by the Health Monitoring Unit of the Ministry of Health of Cyprus. The ideas and opinions expressed herein are those of the authors. Endorsement of these ideas and opinions by the Ministry of Health of Cyprus is not intended nor should it be inferred.), the Institute of Health Information and Statistics of the Czech Republic, the German Federal Statistical Office (data licence Germany—attribution—version 2.0, “Statistischer Bericht—Sterbefälle nach Tagen, Wochen und Monaten - endgültige Daten—2000 bis 2019 and Statistischer Bericht—Sterbefälle nach Tagen, Wochen und Monaten—2020 bis 2024”), Statistics Denmark, the National Institute for Health Development of Estonia (Estonian Causes of Death Registry), the Hellenic Statistical Authority, the National Statistics Institute of Spain, Statistics Finland, the French National Institute for Statistics and Economic Studies, the Croatian Bureau of Statistics, the Hungarian Central Statistical Office (aggregated data on daily mortality for Hungary; datafile prepared upon individual request by the Hungarian Central Statistical Office [www.ksh.hu]), Central Statistics Office Ireland, the Italian National Institute of Statistics, the Institute of Hygiene of Lithuania, the Ministry of Health of Luxembourg, the Centre for Disease Prevention and Control of Latvia (Register of Causes of Death), the Statistical Office of Montenegro, Statistics Netherlands, the Norwegian Institute of Public Health (Norwegian Cause of Death Registry), Statistics Poland, the National Statistics Institute of Portugal (Number of deaths by place of residence, sex and age group; 1980–2018), the National Institute of Statistics of Romania (Statistical Survey on Mortality), the Statistical Office of the Republic of Serbia, the National Board of Health and Welfare of Sweden (Swedish Cause of Death Register), the National Institute of Public Health of Slovenia, the Statistical Office of the Slovak Republic, the Office for National Statistics of the UK, the Northern Ireland Statistics and Research Agency, and the National Records of Scotland.
Statistics Netherlands, the Norwegian Institute of Public Health (Norwegian Cause of Death Registry), Statistics Poland, the National Statistics Institute of Portugal (Number of deaths by place of residence, sex and age group; 1980-2018), the National Institute of Statistics of Romania (Statistical Survey on Mortality), the Statistical Office of the Republic of Serbia, the National Board of Health and Welfare of Sweden (Swedish Cause of Death Register), the National Institute of Public Health of Slovenia, the Statistical Office of the Slovak Republic, the Office for National Statistics of the UK, the Northern Ireland Statistics and Research Agency, and the National Records of Scotland.