- Hawkes, Jeffrey A.
- D'Andrilli, Juliana
- Agar, Jeffrey N.
- Barrow, Mark P.
- Berg, Stephanie M.
- Catalán, Núria
- Chen, Hongmei
- Chu, Rosalie K.
- Cole, Richard B.
- Dittmar, Thorsten
- Gavard, Rémy
- Gleixner, Gerd
- Hatcher, Patrick G.
- He, Chen
- Hess, Nancy J.
- Hutchins, Ryan H. S.
- Ijaz, Amna
- Jones, Hugh E.
- Kew, William
- Khaksari, Maryam
- Palacio Lozano, Diana Catalina
- Lv, Jitao
- Mazzoleni, Lynn R.
- Noriega-Ortega, Beatriz E.
- Osterholz, Helena
- Radoman, Nikola
- Remucal, Christina K.
- Schmitt, Nicholas D.
- Schum, Simeon K.
- Shi, Quan
- Simon, Carsten
- Singer, Gabriel
- Sleighter, Rachel L.
- Stubbins, Aron
- Thomas, Mary J.
- Tolic, Nikola
- Zhang, Shuzhen
- Zito, Phoebe
- Podgorski, David C.
High-resolution mass spectrometry (HRMS) has become a vital tool for dissolved organic matter (DOM) characterization. The upward trend in HRMS analysis of DOM presents challenges in data comparison and interpretation among laboratories operating instruments with differing performance and user operating conditions. It is therefore essential that the community establishes metric ranges and compositional trends for data comparison with reference samples so that data can be robustly compared among research groups. To this end, four identically prepared DOM samples were each measured by 16 laboratories, using 17 commercially purchased instruments, using positive-ion and negative-ion mode electrospray ionization (ESI) HRMS analyses. The instruments identified ~1000 common ions in both negative- and positive-ion modes over a wide range of m/z values and chemical space, as determined by van Krevelen diagrams. Calculated metrics of abundance-weighted average indices (H/C, O/C, aromaticity, and m/z) of the commonly detected ions showed that hydrogen saturation and aromaticity were consistent for each reference sample across the instruments, while average mass and oxygenation were more affected by differences in instrument type and settings. In this paper we present 32 metric values for future benchmarking. The metric values were obtained for the four different parameters from four samples in two ionization modes and can be used in future work to evaluate the performance of HRMS instruments., J.H. held a grant from the Swedish Research Council VR (2018-04618). N.C. held a Beatriu de Pinos (2016-00215) grant and a Marie Sklodowska-Curie Action of the European Commission (CHROME-839709). C.R. and S.B. acknowledge the UW-Madison Human Proteomics Program Mass Spectrometry Facility (initially funded by the Wisconsin partnership funds) for support in obtaining mass spectrometry data, NIH S10OD018475 for the acquisition of ultrahigh resolution mass spectrometer. This work was also supported by the National Science Foundation (CBET 1802388 and DEB 1824723). P.Z. and D.C.P. were supported by Shell Global Solutions and the Award for Building Research or Artistic Development (ABROAD) provided by the University of New Orleans Office of Research and Sponsored Programs. Financial support from the French National FT-ICR network (FR 3624 CNRS) for conducting this research is also gratefully acknowledged. A.I., M.K., S.S., and L.M. acknowledge NSF MRI grant (AGS-1531454) and the Chemical Advanced Resolution Methods Laboratory for ultrahigh resolution mass spectrometry research support. N.R.'s contribution was funded through his PhD scholarship provided by the Department of Environmental Science and Analytical Chemistry (ACES), Stockholm University, Sweden. C.S. and G.G. acknowledge financial support from the Max-Planck-Gesellschaft (MPG) and the German Research Foundation (DFG, Deutsche Forschungs-Gemeinschaft) as part of the CRC 1076 “Aqua Diva.” CS received a Ph.D. stipend from the International Max Planck Research School for Global Biogeochemical Cycles (IMPRS-gBGC). D.C.P.L. and M.P.B. would like to thank the Newton Fund award (reference number 275910721), Research Agreement No. 5211770 UIS-ICP, and COLCIENCIAS (project No. FP44842-039-2015). R.G., H.E.J., M.J.T. thank EPSRC for a PhD studentship through the EPSRC Centre for Doctoral Training in Molecular Analytical Science, grant number EP/L015307/1. A portion of the research was performed using EMSL (grid.436923.9), a DOE Office of Science User Facility sponsored by the Office of Biological and Environmental Research. R.L.S., H.M.C., and P.G.H. were supported by the Old Dominion University Frank Batten Endowment. B.N.O. and G.S. were supported by the European Research Council (ERC-STG 716196). R.H. was supported by the Campus Alberta Innovates Program., Peer reviewed