Skip to main content

Resultados relacionados

Resultados totales (Incluyendo duplicados): 3
Encontrada(s) 1 página(s)

Biblos-e Archivo. Repositorio Institucional de la UAM
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Optimal inventorying and monitoring of taxonomic, phylogenetic and functional diversity

  • Cardoso, Pedro
  • Arnedo, Miquel A.
  • Macías Hernández, Nuria
  • Mustin Carvalho, William Douglas
  • Carvalho, José C.
  • Hilário, Renato
Comparable data is essential to understand biodiversity patterns. While assemblage or community inventorying requires comprehensive sampling, monitoring focuses on as few components as possible to detect changes. Quantifying species, their evolutionary history, and the way they interact requires studying changes in taxonomic (TD), phylogenetic (PD) and functional diversity (FD). Here we propose a method for the optimization of sampling protocols for inventorying and monitoring assemblages or communities across these three diversity dimensions taking sampling costs into account. We used Iberian spiders and Amazonian bats as two case-studies. The optimal combination of methods for inventorying and monitoring required optimizing the accumulation curve of α-diversity and minimizing the difference between sampled and estimated β-diversity (bias), respectively. For Iberian spiders, the optimal combination for TD, PD and FD allowed sampling at least 50% of estimated diversity with 24 person-hours of fieldwork. The optimal combination of six person-hours allowed reaching a bias below 8% for all dimensions. For Amazonian bats, surveying all the 12 sites with mist-nets and 0 or 1 acoustic recorders was the optimal combination for almost all diversity types, resulting in >89% of the diversity and <10% bias with roughly a third of the cost. Only for phylogenetic α-diversity, the best solution was less clear and involved surveying both with mist nets and acoustic recorders. The widespread use of optimized and standardized sampling protocols and regular repetition in time will radically improve global inventory and monitoring of biodiversity. We strongly advocate for the global adoption of sampling protocols for both inventory and monitoring of taxonomic, phylogenetic and functional diversity, PC has received funding from the European Union\u2019s Horizon 2020 and Horizon Europe research and innovation programmes under grant agreements No. 861924 (SustInAfrica) and 101081964 (BioMonitor4CAP) respectively. PC was also supported by the Centre for Ecology, Evolution and Environmental Changes (cE3c, https://doi.org/10.54499/UIDB/00329/2020) and the Global Change and Sustainability Institute (CHANGE, https://doi.org/10.54499/la/p/0121/ 2020). MA was supported by grant 485/2012 of the Organismo Aut\u00F3nomo de Parques Nacionales (Ministerio de Agricultura, Alimentaci\u00F3n y Medio Ambiente). NMH was supported by the H2020-MSCA-IF-2015 Programme (BIODIV ISLAND-CONT project, Grant no. 706482). WDC is supported by \u2018Ayudas Maria Zambrano\u2019 (CA3/ RSUE/2021-00197), funded by the Spanish Ministry of Universities. Open access funded by Helsinki University Library. We thank all the collectors of past and present studies that contributed to the dataset used in this paper: Luis Carlos Crespo, Rui Carvalho, Alberto de Castro, Cristina Fr\u00EDas-L\u00F3pez, Pedro Humberto Castro, Clara Gaspar, Ana Filipa Gouveia, S\u00E9rgio Henriques, Eva de Mas, Paola Mazzuca, Elisa Mora, Jordi Moya, Vera Opatova, Luis Carlos Pereira, Enric Planas, Carles Ribera, Marcos Roca-Cusachs, Dolores Ruiz, Nikolaj Scharff, Jesper Schmidt, Israel Silva, Ricardo Silva, Pedro Sousa, Tam\u00E1s Sz\u00FCts, Vanina Tonzo, Jo\u00E3o D. Miguel, Adri\u00E0 L\u00F3pez-Baucells, Ricardo Rocha, Jorge M. Palmeirim, Isa\u00ED Castro, Bruna S. Xavier, Karen Mustin, Daniela Rato, Cledinaldo Marques, Cremilson Marques, Gustavo Silveira, Joandro Pandilha, Jackson Souza, Lu\u00EDs Miguel Rosalino, Ma\u00EDra S. M. Godoy, Renan M. Dias, Carlos E. L. Esb\u00E9rard and Cristina H. Adania
UPCommons. Portal del coneixement obert de la UPC
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Building a solid foundation: advancing evidence synthesis in agri-food systems science

  • Ellssel, Pierre
  • Küstner, Georg
  • Kaczorowska Dolowy, Magdalena
  • Vázquez García, Eduardo
  • Di Bene, Claudia
  • Li, Honghong
  • Brizuela Torres, Diego
  • Elangovan Vennila, Elansurya|||0009-0009-9884-2911
  • Vicente Vicente, José Luis
  • Ávila Ortega, Daniel Itzamna
Enhancing the reliability of literature reviews and evidence synthesis is crucial for advancing the transformation of agriculture and food (agri-food) systems as well as for informed decisions and policy making. In this perspective, we argue that evidence syntheses in the field of agri-food systems research often suffer from a suite of methodological limitations that substantially increase the risk of bias, i.e., publication and selection bias, resulting in unreliable and potentially flawed conclusions and, consequently, poor decisions (e.g., policy direction, investment, research foci). We assessed 926 articles from the Collaboration for Environmental Evidence Database of Evidence Reviews (CEEDER) and recent examples from agri-food systems research to support our reasoning. The analysis of articles from CEEDER (n¿=¿926) specifically indicates poor quality (Red) in measures to minimize subjectivity during critical appraisal (98% of all reviews), application of the eligibility criteria (97%), cross-checking of extracted data by more than one reviewer (97%), critical appraisal of studies (88%), establishment of an a priori method/protocol (86%), and transparent reporting of eligibility decisions (65%). Additionally, deficiencies (Amber) were found in most articles (>50%) regarding the investigation and discussion of variability in study findings (89%), comprehensiveness of the search (78%), definition of eligibility criteria (72%), search approach (64%), reporting of extracted data for each study (59%), consideration and discussion of the limitations of the synthesis (56%), documentation of data extraction (54%) and regarding the statistical approach (52%). To enhance the quality of evidence synthesis in agri-food science, review authors should use tried-and-tested methodologies and publish peer-reviewed a priori protocols. Training in evidence synthesis methods should be scaled, with universities playing a crucial role. It is the shared duty of research authors, training providers, supervisors, reviewers, and editors to ensure that rigorous and robust evidence syntheses are made available to decision-makers. We argue that all these actors should be cognizant of these common mistakes to avoid publishing unreliable syntheses. Only by thinking as a community can we ensure that reliable evidence is provided to support appropriate decision-making in agri-food systems science., The author(s) declare that financial support was received for the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article. PE received funding through the EU Horizon 2020 Research and Innovation Programme under grant agreement 861924 (SustInAfrica). DIA-O received funding through the Swedish Research Council for Sustainable Development under FORMAS grant number 2020–00371 and the Erling-Persson Family Foundation. DB-T is funded by: the German Centre for Integrative Biodiversity Research (iDiv) – 2021 Flexpool project DeForESG – Deforestation explained by social-ecological dynamics and governance shifts., Peer Reviewed
Recercat. Dipósit de la Recerca de Catalunya
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Building a solid foundation: advancing evidence synthesis in agri-food systems science

  • Ellssel, Pierre
  • Küstner, Georg
  • Kaczorowska Dolowy, Magdalena
  • Vázquez García, Eduardo
  • Di Bene, Claudia
  • Li, Honghong
  • Brizuela Torres, Diego
  • Elangovan Vennila, Elansurya
  • Vicente Vicente, José Luis
  • Ávila Ortega, Daniel Itzamna
Enhancing the reliability of literature reviews and evidence synthesis is crucial for advancing the transformation of agriculture and food (agri-food) systems as well as for informed decisions and policy making. In this perspective, we argue that evidence syntheses in the field of agri-food systems research often suffer from a suite of methodological limitations that substantially increase the risk of bias, i.e., publication and selection bias, resulting in unreliable and potentially flawed conclusions and, consequently, poor decisions (e.g., policy direction, investment, research foci). We assessed 926 articles from the Collaboration for Environmental Evidence Database of Evidence Reviews (CEEDER) and recent examples from agri-food systems research to support our reasoning. The analysis of articles from CEEDER (n¿=¿926) specifically indicates poor quality (Red) in measures to minimize subjectivity during critical appraisal (98% of all reviews), application of the eligibility criteria (97%), cross-checking of extracted data by more than one reviewer (97%), critical appraisal of studies (88%), establishment of an a priori method/protocol (86%), and transparent reporting of eligibility decisions (65%). Additionally, deficiencies (Amber) were found in most articles (>50%) regarding the investigation and discussion of variability in study findings (89%), comprehensiveness of the search (78%), definition of eligibility criteria (72%), search approach (64%), reporting of extracted data for each study (59%), consideration and discussion of the limitations of the synthesis (56%), documentation of data extraction (54%) and regarding the statistical approach (52%). To enhance the quality of evidence synthesis in agri-food science, review authors should use tried-and-tested methodologies and publish peer-reviewed a priori protocols. Training in evidence synthesis methods should be scaled, with universities playing a crucial role. It is the shared duty of research authors, training providers, supervisors, reviewers, and editors to ensure that rigorous and robust evidence syntheses are made available to decision-makers. We argue that all these actors should be cognizant of these common mistakes to avoid publishing unreliable syntheses. Only by thinking as a community can we ensure that reliable evidence is provided to support appropriate decision-making in agri-food systems science., The author(s) declare that financial support was received for the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article. PE received funding through the EU Horizon 2020 Research and Innovation Programme under grant agreement 861924 (SustInAfrica). DIA-O received funding through the Swedish Research Council for Sustainable Development under FORMAS grant number 2020–00371 and the Erling-Persson Family Foundation. DB-T is funded by: the German Centre for Integrative Biodiversity Research (iDiv) – 2021 Flexpool project DeForESG – Deforestation explained by social-ecological dynamics and governance shifts., Peer Reviewed, Postprint (published version)