Skip to main content

Resultados relacionados

Resultados totales (Incluyendo duplicados): 6
Encontrada(s) 1 página(s)

Zaguán. Repositorio Digital de la Universidad de Zaragoza
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Identifying the Evolution of Open Government Data Initiatives and Their User Engagement

  • Aziz, Abdul
  • Herrera-Murillo, Dagoberto José
  • Nogueras-Iso, Javier
  • Lacasta, Javier
  • Lopez-Pellicer, Francisco J.
Over the last decade, many Open Data initiatives have been launched by public administrations to promote transparency and reuse of data. However, it is not easy to assess the impact of data availability from the perspective of user communities. Although some Open Data portals provide mechanisms for user feedback through dedicated discussion forums or web forms, and some of the user experiences are reported directly in the portals, there is no consistent way to compare user feedback in different data initiatives. To overcome the difficulty of assessing user impact, this paper examines the activity generated by Open Data initiatives through the social network X (formerly Twitter): a forum used by all types of stakeholders and publicly available for consistent analysis. This work proposes a methodology for analysing the evolution of Open Government Data initiatives and their user engagement along a temporal period. First, a set of variables are collected to describe the main features of Open Data initiatives and their associated social network activity. Then, to analyse these collected data from a multidimensional and temporal perspective, we apply the well-known technique of self-organizing maps to find hidden correlations between the status of different initiatives in the analysed period. Finally, as the number of map nodes is still too big to identify clear levels of maturity, a clustering algorithm is applied to group initiatives with a similar evolution status. The feasibility of this methodology has been tested by analysing 27 European Open Government Data portals between 2017 and 2021.
Zaguán. Repositorio Digital de la Universidad de Zaragoza
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Roundtrip feedback in open data portals: analysis of input and output channels

  • Aziz, Abdul
  • Ali, Mohsan
  • Nogueras-Iso, Javier
  • Alexopoulos, Charalampos
  • Lopez-Pellicer, Francisco J.
Purpose Open Government Data (OGD) portals aim to enhance accountability and transparency by serving as central access points for all government data at local, regional and national levels. To enhance user engagement with OGD portals, it is essential to optimize feedback mechanisms within these portals. This work aims to analyse the current status of feedback mechanisms as a foundation for their future improvement to strengthen user engagement and to advance in accountability and transparency. Design/methodology/approach This research conceptualizes feedback mechanisms in OGD portals, followed by case studies and extrapolation through the analysis to a wider range of OGD portals by means of an automated detection of input channels, output channels and the connecting flows. Findings The study reveals significant variability in the structure and formality of input and output feedback channels. Feedback mechanisms range from highly informal channels, such as social media, to formal structured channels, such as dedicated feedback forms. Our data analysis identifies three distinct clusters of countries based on the characteristics of feedback mechanisms in their OGD portals. Originality/value While existing research highlights the importance of feedback in OGD portals, it mainly focuses on the flow from users to data publishers through input channels. The novelty of this work lies in examining not only input channels but also the return flow from data publishers to users through output channels.
Zaguán. Repositorio Digital de la Universidad de Zaragoza
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

A framework for the acceptance testing of geospatial search engines

  • Herrera-Murillo, Dagoberto José
  • Nogueras-Iso, Javier
  • Abad-Power, Paloma
  • Latre, Miguel Á.
  • Lopez-Pellicer, Francisco J.
Geospatial search engines are an essential component of spatial data infrastructures and enable a broad spectrum of environmental applications. The back-end implementation of these search engines has evolved from traditional text-based information retrieval systems into more specialised search engines. However, to assess the actual improvement brought by this evolution, thorough testing is needed. The aim of this work is to propose a framework for the acceptance testing of geospatial search engines that assesses their functionality, effectiveness, and user-friendliness. For each quality attribute, the framework proposes different testing design techniques and guidelines for their practical implementation. To demonstrate its feasibility, it has been applied to the evaluation of a geospatial semantic search engine of the Spanish National Geographic Institute. The evaluated search engine showed a sufficient level of functionality and effectiveness. However, the usability results were barely satisfactory due to perceived problems associated with complexity, inconsistency, and low learnability.
Zaguán. Repositorio Digital de la Universidad de Zaragoza
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Collective Intelligence in Humanitarian Voluntary Geographic Information: The Case of the HOT Tasking Manager

  • Herrera-Murillo, Dagoberto José
  • Ochoa-Ortiz, Héctor
  • Ahmed, Umair
  • Lopez-Pellicer, Francisco J.
  • Re, Barbara
  • Polini, Andrea
  • Nogueras-Iso, Javier
Voluntary Geographic Information initiatives are transforming the disaster response landscape. Our research provides insights into how the concept of collective intelligence is accomplished in humanitarian mapping initiatives. The main source originates from the data obtained in 746 mapping projects organised by the Humanitarian OpenStreetMap Team between December 2021 and November 2023, where 38,893 contributors completed 312,289 mapping tasks. These data include detailed attributes of the contributors and the states the tasks go through. The methodology adopts a quantitative approach, including descriptive and inferential statistics, and standard process mining techniques. Our results indicate that, in general terms, in humanitarian mapping, a group of contributors from outside the area of interest perform straightforward mapping tasks with limited collaboration among them. The ‘wisdom’ of advanced contributors is the cornerstone that sustains the system. The discussion section elaborates on (1) how these findings suggest that humanitarian mapping projects effectively meet their short-term mapping objectives but fall short if more sustainable mapping objectives are sought and (2) possible strategies for better harnessing the collective intelligence of these efforts.
Zaguán. Repositorio Digital de la Universidad de Zaragoza
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Applicability of process mining in usability tests: a case study for identifying user mental models in geospatial search engines

  • Herrera-Murillo, Dagoberto José
  • Abad-Power, Paloma
  • López-Pellicer, Francisco J.
  • Baldassarri, Sandra
  • Nogueras-Iso, Javier
A fundamental challenge in digital product design is ensuring that actual mental models of users align with the intended functionality of the system. When discrepancies arise, usability can suffer, leading to inefficient interactions and reduced adoption. Usability testing lets development teams identify design problems in digital products by collecting qualitative and quantitative information. However, this technique is often not able to provide a panoramic view of the interaction with the system, especially when dealing with complex interfaces such as those used in geospatial search engines and we need to analyse the quantitative data compiled during testing. This work proposes to actively incorporate process mining into usability testing. We discuss the implications of process mining on usability testing using a case study performed at the National Geographic Institute of Spain, where a new geospatial search engine was under development. Twenty-one participants, ranging from novice to expert users, were recruited to perform a search task using the new geospatial search engine. The findings reveal that the mental model of users leans towards the archetype of a regular search engine rather than fully utilising the geographic functionalities provided by the platform, as intended by its designers.
Zaguán. Repositorio Digital de la Universidad de Zaragoza
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Quality Issues in Crowdsourced Mapping: Microtask Aggregation in the Humanitarian OpenStreetMap Team Tasking Manager

  • Ochoa-Ortiz, Héctor
  • Herrera-Murillo, Dagoberto José
  • Re, Barbara
  • Lopez-Pellicer, Francisco J.
  • Nogueras-Iso, Javier
In crowdsourcing, dividing work into narrowly defined microtasks may affect the quality of the final product. This study examines this problem in the con text of humanitarian mapping initiatives coordinated using the Humanitarian OpenStreetMap Team Tasking Manager, analyzing 4619 projects and over 1.4 million microtasks. Using a combination of spatial statistical techniques and expert visual inspection, we identify two main issues derived from microtask aggregation: edge‐based and task‐wide distortions. Our findings reveal that the current microtasking model hinders the emergence of spatial collective intelligence, resulting in fragmented and inconsistent outputs that reduce the quality of the final data. Edge‐based issues are identified by observing differences in event distribution between edge and interior areas. Task‐wide issues are examined by computing the spatial autocorrelation of geometries within microtask areas. We propose actionable strategies to address these issues, including overlapping task boundaries and fostering implicit coordination among contributors.