Skip to main content

Resultados relacionados

Resultados totales (Incluyendo duplicados): 8
Encontrada(s) 1 página(s)

Zaguán. Repositorio Digital de la Universidad de Zaragoza
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

How do farm and farmer attributes explain perceived resilience?

  • Prat-Benhamou, Alicia
  • Bernués, Alberto
  • Gaspar, Paula
  • Lizarralde, Joseba
  • Mancilla-Leytón, Juan Manuel
  • Mandaluniz, Nerea
  • Mena, Yolanda
  • Soriano, Bárbara
  • Ondé, Daniel
  • Martín-Collado, Daniel
CONTEXT: Uncertainty surrounds farming systems across Europe and strengthening their resilience lies at the centre of the European policy agenda. Although farming systems´ resilience has been widely conceptualised, no consensus has been reached about assessing the contribution of farm and farmer attributes to farmers´ perceived resilience by quantitative approaches. OBJECTIVE: The aim of this study was to understand what farm(er) attributes and principles contribute to explain farmers´ perceived resilience. Our specific objectives are to: i) develop a conceptual framework composed of attributes, principles and capacities to assess farms' resilience, including farmer personal resilience as a resilience principle; ii) quantify links between farm attributes and resilience principles with farmers´ perceived resilience capacities. METHODS: We developed a framework that includes different farm and farmer attributes grouped into resilience principles. We designed and conducted a structured survey to allow small ruminant farmers in Spain to self-assess their resilience attributes and capacities. We used structural equation modelling to assess to what extent resilience attributes and principles explain perceived robustness, adaptability, transformability capacities and overall resilience. RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS: Farmers´ perceived resilience can be explained by several resilience attributes and principles, including farmers' personal resilience. Some attributes contribute similarly to robustness, adaptability and transformability, while others contribute particularly to each capacity. Farm diversity, tightness of feedbacks and farmers´ personal resilience were key for explaining farmers´ perceived resilience for small ruminant farming systems in Spain. In particular, farmer optimism, and farms' ability to respond in different ways to challenges and to overcome difficulties in the past, were the attributes that most influenced resilience perceptions. Our results highlight the importance of farmer personality, in addition to farm characteristics, for understanding farmers' resilience perceptions. SIGNIFICANCE: This study contributes to the development of quantitative farm resilience assessments by considering multiple farm attributes and also several farmers' psychological attributes. Our framework provides a list of attributes and principles that can be applied to different farming systems. We provide a specific approach to identify the most relevant attributes and principles that drive perceived resilience in a large set of them that could guide farm and stakeholders' decision making.
Zaguán. Repositorio Digital de la Universidad de Zaragoza
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

The importance of the messenger in climate change communication to farmers

  • Muñoz-Ulecia, Enrique
  • Bernués, Alberto
  • Carabaño, María Jesús
  • Joy, Margalida
  • Martín-Collado, Daniel
Agriculture needs to mitigate its impacts and adapt to new environmental conditions. To this end, communicating climate change to farmers is essential but remains a challenge, since many stakeholders (e.g. public administration, sectoral stakeholders, environmentalists) engage with farmers, conveying diverse messages about climate change and the role of agriculture. Here we aim to analyse farmers’ perceptions of climate change and how these relate to their trust in different stakeholders. We conducted a survey with 167 livestock farmers across Spain, gathering data about their perceptions on climate change severity and origin, and to what extent its importance has been exaggerated. We also analysed farmers’ trust in different information sources, including farmers associations (i.e. breed associations, farmer organisations and cooperatives), agricultural organisations, technical publications, veterinarians, agricultural firms, government agencies, scientists, environmentalists, animal activists, and the media. Our results show that farmers believe climate change exists but a high proportion are sceptical about its origin and severity. Farmers’ trust in information sources influences their perception of climate change. Farmers who trust public institutions, environmentalists, animal activists, and the media are more likely to view climate change as human-driven and perceive its impacts as severe, rejecting claims of exaggeration. In contrast, those who trust veterinarians, cooperatives, agricultural firms, and farmer organisations tend to see climate change as a hybrid human-natural process and believe its impacts are overstated. The results highlight the need to improve the science-policy-farmers dialogue to make farmers more aware of the potential consequences of climate change on farming and trigger adaptation.
Zaguán. Repositorio Digital de la Universidad de Zaragoza
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

A practical approach to assess the resilience attributes of livestock farms

  • Prat-Benhamou, A.
  • Meuwissen, M.P.M.
  • Slijper, T.
  • Bernués, A.
  • Gaspar-García, P.
  • Lizarralde, J.
  • Mancilla-Leytón, J.M.
  • Mandaluniz, N.
  • Mena, Y.
  • Soriano, B.
  • Martín-Collado, D.
There is a growing interest in studying farm resilience. Typically, resilience assessments focus on crisis outcomes, with less attention paid to assess the system characteristics that contribute to building resilience, i.e. resilience attributes. This is partly due to a lack of practical approaches to assess these attributes. The objective of this paper is to develop a practical approach to assess and compare the status of livestock farms’ resilience attributes in different farming systems. We identified 21 resilience attributes that generally contribute to farm resilience based on a literature review. We operationalised resilience attributes into 85 indicators quantifiable through primary farm data, such percentage of feed produced on the farm. We assessed three small ruminant case studies in Spain: (i) meat sheep farms in Aragón; (ii) dairy sheep farms in the Basque Country and Navarre; (iii) dairy goat farms in Andalusia. We conducted farmer surveys (n = 144) to measure the indicators, and organised three workshops with farmers and other local stakeholders (n = 20) to assess the importance of the resilience attributes in the three case studies. We aggregated indicators into resilience attribute scores using a minimum–maximum normalisation procedure. Using stakeholders’ assessments, we calculated attribute weights by a budget allocation process. Attribute scores and weights were then used to calculate an overall resilience score (ranging from 0 to 100). The comparison of attribute scores revealed strengths and weaknesses for resilience in each case study. In the meat sheep system, honours legacy was a major strength, while work and quality of life was a weakness. In the dairy sheep system, sector organisation was a major strength, while the redundance of productive alternatives was a weakness. For dairy goat farms, the infrastructure of the areas where farmers live was a major strength, but feed autonomy and the attributes related to the access and use of natural resources were weaknesses. The perceived importance of attributes (weights) differed across cases. Particularly, human capital emerged as one of the most relevant ones across case studies. Farms’ overall resilience scores were significantly lower in the dairy goat system. Our approach allows to find what attributes build resilience in farms and to highlight areas of improvement to strengthen their resilience. Our findings are of importance to farmers, technicians and policymakers who are interested in assessing resilience as we provide a practical approach to quantify and compare resilience of farms.
Zaguán. Repositorio Digital de la Universidad de Zaragoza
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

What strategies would sheep farmers implement to respond to climate change? A cross-national comparison of sheep farming systems in the Mediterranean

  • Martin-Collado, D.
  • Tenza-Peral, A.
  • Casasús, I.
  • Joy, M.
  • Stark, F.
  • Lurette, A.
  • Mohamed-Brahmi, A.
  • Ameur, M.
  • Aboulnaga, A.
  • Elshafie, M.
  • Lobón, S.
How livestock systems respond to climate change (CC) will shape global food security and rural livelihoods. The Mediterranean region, a climate risk hotspot, hosts diverse livestock systems, including extensive meat sheep farming, where adaptation is critical to prevent economic and social decline. However, response measures are often identified through top-down approaches that overlook local conditions and farmers' perspectives. This study conducted 216 face-to-face surveys with farmers across 11 meat sheep systems in Egypt, France, Spain, and Tunisia to examine their beliefs about CC, perceived farm impacts, and preferred strategies to cope CC. Cluster analysis identified five strategies: i) infrastructure improvement, ii) feed intensification, iii) feed optimization, iv) diversified adjustments, and v) flock management with feed intensification. These strategies were present across all countries and systems. Farmers widely recognize CC and its effects but most attribute its causes a combination of natural and human factors or to natural processes, rather than exclusively to human activity. Their primary concern is feed security, addressed through grazing, indoor feeding, or both, with increased feed purchases playing a central role. Conversely, breed substitution and reproductive management changes are rarely considered. The emphasis on farm infrastructure improvement and feed intensification suggests farmers prioritize reducing exposure to CC impacts by decoupling their farms from local environmental conditions. This aligns with a ‘sustainable intensification’ approach, which presents socio-economic and environmental challenges, requiring greater technical support for farmers to implement effective responses to CC.
Zaguán. Repositorio Digital de la Universidad de Zaragoza
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Assessing resilience of small ruminant farms in Spain: A longitudinal analysis based on FADN

  • Prat-Benhamou, Alicia
  • Bernués, Alberto
  • Soriano, Bárbara
  • Olaizola, Ana M.
  • Martín-Collado, Daniel
In the last decades, increasingly complex challenges are threatening the viability of European small ruminant farming systems. Thus, studying the resilience of small ruminant farms is key to strengthen their ability to face the current global scenario and guarantee their long-term viability. This study uses FADN (Farm Accountancy Data Network) data from 2014 to 2022 to explore how the three resilience capacities (i.e., robustness, adaptation and transformation) contribute to the resilience of Spanish small ruminant farms and examines which farm characteristics are associated with higher resilience outcomes. Each resilience capacity is quantified by considering changes over time in a set of selected indicators. We defined best and worst performers per year for each resilience capacity and used Elastic Net regression models to understand the probability of farms to belong to the best and worst performers based on a set of farm indicators. Overall, farms were more robust than adaptable or transformable, and that their adaptation and transformation was limited. The probability to belong the best performing group was variable in the case studies. Still, some indicators increased farms probability of belonging to the best performing group: Production efficiency for robustness, and Hectares per livestock and On-farm feed ratio for adaptation. By contrast, Family labour ratio was negatively related to the best performers in terms of adaptation. In these regards, strengthening the resilience of small ruminant farms would require strategies building adaptation and transformation considering the farm indicators that contribute to perform better in these capacities.
Zaguán. Repositorio Digital de la Universidad de Zaragoza
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Explaining the decline of Mediterranean meat sheep farming through system dynamics modelling

  • Prat-Benhamou, Alicia
  • Kopainsky, Birgit
  • Bernués, Alberto
  • Martín-Collado, Daniel
  • Tenza-Peral, Alicia
Context Farming systems are complex social-ecological systems in which social, economic, and ecological factors interact shaping their performance and evolution. Among different farming systems in Europe, sheep farming has experienced a marked and sustained decline over the past decades. Objective This paper uses a system dynamics model to investigate the decline of sheep farming systems in Mediterranean areas and to quantify the influence of different drivers on their dynamics. Methods The model SHEEPSES was developed to simulate the meat sheep farming system in Aragon (Spain) from 2000 to 2022. It incorporates the social, economic and environmental components that determine its functioning. First, we simulated the historical trends in the number of ewes, farms and net income per farmer. Second, we performed experimental simulations to understand what would have had happened if the effect of some drivers were removed. Results and conclusions Social and economic drivers drove the decline in the number of farms and sheep. This was caused by a lack of generational renewal, which was a consequence of poor quality of life and low attractiveness of rural areas. The system would have collapsed without the subsidies of the Common Agricultural Policy. However, our results suggest that policies have proven insufficient to reverse the declining trend in sheep and farm numbers. Policies focused on farmers quality of life, attractiveness of rural areas and decreasing dependence on subsidies would be needed to improve the system resilience in the long term. Significance SHEEPSES was helpful to understand past dynamics and could be a tool to support policy design aiming at slowing the decline of the system.
Zaguán. Repositorio Digital de la Universidad de Zaragoza
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Supporting pollinators, resisting policy: The role of environmental attitudes and psychological reactance among farmers

  • Muñoz-Ulecia, Enrique
  • Uldemolins, Pilar
  • Bernués, Alberto
  • Magistris, Tiziana de
  • Martín-Collado, Daniel
Understanding how psychological constructs shape farmers' views on agri-environmental policy and the role of pollinators in agriculture can help design effective and legitimate agricultural policies. While farmers are key actors in pollinator conservation, recent farmer protests indicate that their support for agri-environmental policies such as the EU Common Agricultural Policy eco-schemes is uneven and contested. This study examines how two psychological constructs—environmental attitudes and psychological reactance—relate to farmers' views on the role of pollinators for agriculture and agri-environmental policies. We conducted face-to-face surveys with 248 farmers in Spain and analysed the effect of the psychological constructs and farming variables using multiple linear regression. Farmers generally acknowledged the importance of pollinators for nature and agriculture and were aware of the impacts of agriculture on pollinators. Many rejected the idea that their own farming practices contribute to pollinators' decline. Views on the Common Agricultural Policy and eco-schemes were ambivalent. While some farmers valued the Common Agricultural Policy and eco-schemes' potential to promote sustainability, others viewed them as economically harmful, too rigid and designed without considering their opinion. Positive environmental attitudes were associated with the recognition of the value of pollinators and support for agri-environmental policy. In contrast, psychological reactance was negatively associated with agri-environmental policy but unrelated to the recognition of pollinators' value. These findings suggest that awareness of pollinator contribution and resistance to top-down regulations operate as distinct forces shaping farmers' responses to agri-environmental policy. These effects held across multiple analytical methods and were robust to sociodemographic and farming system covariates. Our results highlight the importance of addressing both positive (environmental attitudes) and negative (psychological reactance) psychological constructs when designing agri-environmental policies. Farmers' reactance may undermine engagement with agri-environmental policies, even if they agree with the importance of pollinator conservation, suggesting that policy acceptance depends not only on what environmental goals are pursued but also on how they are designed and implemented.
citaREA. Repositorio Institucional del CITA
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

What strategies would sheep farmers implement to respond to climate change? A cross-national comparison of sheep farming systems in the Mediterranean

  • Martín Collado, Daniel
  • Tenza Peral, Alicia
  • Casasús Pueyo, Isabel
  • Joy Torrens, Margalida
  • Stark, Fabien
  • Lurette, Amandine
  • Mohamed Brahmi, Aziza
  • Ameur, Mehrez
  • Aboulnaga, Adel
  • Elshafie, M.
  • Lobón Ascaso, Sandra
How livestock systems respond to climate change (CC) will shape global food security and rural livelihoods. The Mediterranean region, a climate risk hotspot, hosts diverse livestock systems, including extensive meat sheep farming, where adaptation is critical to prevent economic and social decline. However, response measures are often identified through top-down approaches that overlook local conditions and farmers' perspectives. This study conducted 216 face-to-face surveys with farmers across 11 meat sheep systems in Egypt, France, Spain, and Tunisia to examine their beliefs about CC, perceived farm impacts, and preferred strategies to cope CC. Cluster analysis identified five strategies: i) infrastructure improvement, ii) feed intensification, iii) feed optimization, iv) diversified adjustments, and v) flock management with feed intensification. These strategies were present across all countries and systems. Farmers widely recognize CC and its effects but most attribute its causes a combination of natural and human factors or to natural processes, rather than exclusively to human activity. Their primary concern is feed security, addressed through grazing, indoor feeding, or both, with increased feed purchases playing a central role. Conversely, breed substitution and reproductive management changes are rarely considered. The emphasis on farm infrastructure improvement and feed intensification suggests farmers prioritize reducing exposure to CC impacts by decoupling their farms from local environmental conditions. This aligns with a ‘sustainable intensification’ approach, which presents socio-economic and environmental challenges, requiring greater technical support for farmers to implement effective responses to CC., La investigación que condujo a estos resultados fue financiada por la convocatoria PRIMA 2018 - proyecto AdaptHerd (PRIMA 1811-2). El estudio realizado en España fue apoyado por el Ministerio de Ciencia e Innovación (PCI2019-103533) y el Gobierno de Aragón (Fondos para Grupos de Investigación A25_23R y A26_23R)., Si