DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publication
Artículo científico (JournalArticle)
Critical habitat thresholds for effective pollinator conservation in agricultural landscapes
Biodiversity in human-dominated landscapes is declining, but evidence-based conservation targets to guide international policies for such landscapes are lacking. We present a framework for informing habitat conservation policies based on the enhancement of habitat quantity and quality and define thresholds of habitat quantity at which it becomes effective to also prioritize habitat quality. We applied this framework to insect pollinators, an important part of agroecosystem biodiversity, by synthesizing 59 studies from 19 countries. Given low habitat quality, hoverflies had the lowest threshold at 6% semi-natural habitat cover, followed by solitary bees (16%), bumble bees (18%), and butterflies (37%). These figures represent minimum habitat thresholds in agricultural landscapes, but when habitat quantity is restricted, marked increases in quality are required to reach similar outcomes., This work was supported by the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programmes under grant agreement no. 862480, SHOWCASE project (https://showcase-project.eu/) (G.A.B., D.K., M.A., I. Bartomeus, S.G.P., J.S., A. Báldi, J.M.H.). This article reflects only the views of the authors. Any opinions, findings, conclusions, or recommendations expressed in this article are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of or imply endorsement by the funding sources. The funding sources had no role in the completion of the study or the creation of the article and are not responsible for any use that may be made of the information this article contains. Additional funding information is as follows: 017-2018 Belmont Forum and BiodivERsA joint call for research proposals, under the BiodivScen ERA-Net COFUND program, and with the funding organizations AEI, NWO, ECCyT and NSF (T.P.M.F.). Anne M. and Robert T. Bass Stanford Graduate Fellowship in Science and Engineering (B.J.B.). Basque Government through the Basque Excellence Research Centres (BERC) 2022-2025 (A.M.). Bayer Crop Science (V.vK., A.M.K.). BiodivERsA/FACCE-JPI joint call project ECODEAL, national funders Agence Nationale de la Recherche (ANR), Bundesministerium für Bildung und Forschung (BMBF) (01 LC1407A), Swedish Research Council for Environment (FORMAS) (2014-1783), Fonds zur Förderung der wissenschaftlichen Forschung (FWF) (contract I 2045-B25), Ministerio de Economía y Competitividad (MINECO) (PCIN-2014-048), Netherlands Organization for Scientific Research (NWO) (832.14.007), and Projektträger im Deutschen Zentrum für Luft- und Raumfahrt (PT-DLR) (I. Bartomeus, A.H., J.S., J.P.G.V., E.K., I.S.D., M.V., A.M., I. Badenhausser, J.K., R.B., D.K.). British Ecological Society (D.G.). British Ecological Society grant no. SEPG 1563/1968 (A.J.V.). British Entomology and Natural History Society (D.G.). Bundesministerium für Ernährung und Landwirtschaft, grant no. 281 5EPSO 16 (F.K., C.W., N. Beyer). Conservation Innovation Grant CIG-68-9104-6-101 (C.K., L.A.M.). Cornwall Area of Outstanding Natural Beauty Unit (B.B.P.). Council of Scientific & Industrial Research sanction no. 09/028(0882)/2012-EMR-I, date 21.08.2012 (P.B., S.L.). Darwin Initiative project 19-024 (P.B., S.L.). De Vlinderstichting (M.F.W.dV.). Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft grant no. BA 4438/2-1 “Biodiversity and associated ecosystem services in small- vs. large-scale agriculture” (J.I.P., A.L.H.). Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft grant no. 279374797 (I.G., T.T., G.M.). Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft grant nos. 493487387, 405945293, 289781364 (I.G., C.W.). Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft Priority Program 1374 “Infrastructure - Biodiversity Exploratories” grant nos. LI 150/20-1 and BL 960/2-1 (N. Blüthgen). Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft-Collaborative Research Center 1047 “Insect Timing” (A.H., I.S.D.). “DRUID project: Drivers and Repercussions of UK Insect Declines,” funded by the Natural Environment Research Council, grant no. NE/V006916/1 (W.E.K.). EU Seventh Framework Programme project BeeFun grant no. 631653 (I. Bartomeus). EU Seventh Framework Programme project SCALES (‘‘Securing the Conservation of biodiversity across Administrative Levels and spatial, temporal and Ecological Scales’’) grant no. 226852 (B.J., J.K., I.S.D.). EU-funded project EASY grant no. QLK5-CT-2002-01495 (A.H., I.S.D., T.T.). EU-funded project QUESSA grant no. 311879 (L.S., M.A.). EU Seventh Framework Programme project LIBERATION grant no. 311781 (D.K.). EU Seventh Framework Programme (FP7/2007–2013) project STEP grant no. 244090 (A.H., S.H., J.S., D.K., I.S.D., H.G.S., J.E., M.R., J.P.G.V., S.G.P., S.P.M.R., J.B.W., V.J.W., S.M.S., A.V., M.V., A.M., R.B., T.T.). European Regional Development Fund (ERDF) (J.M., J.L.G.A., J.I.). EU Sixth Framework Programme integrated project ALARM (Assessing Large scale environmental Risks for biodiversity with tested Methods), Pollinator Module, grant no. GOCE-CT-2003-506675 (B.J., J.K., I.S.D.). EU Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme project SAFEGUARD grant no. 101003476 (A.H., J.K., I.S.D.). EU Horizon framework programme project RestPoll grant no. 1010082101 (A.M.K., D.K., F.F., M.A., M.R.). FOCA Banco Galicia – Fundación Williams 2015 award (M.M., M.D.). Foundation for Food and Agriculture grant no. CA18-SS-0000000009 (L.C.P., H.C.). Foundation of the University of Marburg grant no. VB1.2-5.45.26 (J. Albrecht, I.G.). Grassland Heritage Foundation (B.L.F., K.R.D.). Helmholtz Association grant no. VH-NG-247 (A.H., I.S.D., T.T.). Ikerbasque research fellowship (A.M.). Iowa Science Foundation grant no. 19-17 (A.W.). Irish Department of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food Research Stimulus Fund (R.S.F.), funded under the National Development Plan (2007–2013) grant no. 07512 (E.F.P., J.C.S.). Juan de la Cierva program grant no. IJCI-2014-22558 (A.M.). Kansas Native Plant Society (B.L.F., K.R.D.). Kansas University Field Station (B.L.F., K.R.D.). Keren Kayemeth LeIsrael-Jewish National Fund Appelby program (Y.M., T.R.). Koret Foundation (B.J.B.). “Lendület” program of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences (A. Báldi, A.K.H.). Moore Family Foundation (B.J.B.). National Fund for Research of Argentina (FONCYT) grant no. PICT-2011-0582 (M.M., M.D.). National Geographic Society Research and Exploration (C.K., L.A.M.). National Science Foundation Graduate Research Fellowship grant no. DGE-1848739 (G.M.Q.). National Science Foundation grant no. DEB-0919128 (C.K., L.A.M.). National Science Foundation grant nos. DEB-1021158 and DEB-0950100 (B.L.F., K.R.D.). Natural England (N.I.W.). Natural Environment Research Council grant no. NE/L002434/1 (B.B.P.). Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada (NSERC) doctoral scholarship (J.M., J.L.G.A., J.I.). Natural Environment Research Council – UK Centre for Ecology & Hydrology National Capability grant no. NEC03463 (A.J.V.). Netherlands Organization for Scientific Research, NWO-ALW Biodiversity Works Program, grant no. 841.11.001 (J.S., D.K.). Norwegian Environment Agency grant no. 2012/16642 (E.P.K., J. Åström). Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada Postdoctoral Fellowship (L.A.M.). Operation Pollinator (T.J.W., R.I.). Peter and Helen Bing (B.J.B.). Prairie Biotic Research, Inc. (B.L.F., K.R.D.). Ramon y Cajal fellowship RYC2021-032251-I (A.M.). Research Council of Norway, BIOSMART project no. 244608/050 (E.P.K., J. Åström). Research Council of Norway, NINA – Strategic Institute Program 208434/F40 (E.P.K., J. Åström) Research Council of Norway, PolliClover project no. 225019 (E.P.K., J. Åström). Research programme NWO-Green, which is jointly funded by the Netherlands Organization for Scientific Research (NWO) and Nunhems Netherlands BV (BASF) under project number 870.15.030 (T.P.M.F.). Roy J. Carver Charitable Trust (A.W.). Royal Society for the Protection of Birds (N.I.W.). Rural and Environment Science and Analytical Services Division (RESAS) of the Scottish Government, Theme C - 2022-2027 (L.J.C., D.I.M.). Scottish Government Rural Affairs and the Environment Strategic Research Programme 2016–2021, Theme 2: Productive and Sustainable Land Management and Rural Economies (L.J.C., D.I.M.). Scottish Government’s Strategic Research Programme 2011–2016, Programme 1: Environment (L.J.C., D.I.M.). Sherwood Foundation (BJB) SIMBIOSYS Project (https://www.tcd.ie/research/simbiosys/, 2007-B-CD-1-S1) as part of the Science, Technology, Research and Innovation for the Environment (STRIVE) Programme, financed by the Irish Government under the National Development Plan 2007–2013, administered on behalf of the Department of the Environment, Heritage and Local Government by the Irish Environmental Protection Agency (D.A.S., J.C.S.). SITA Environmental Trust (J.O., S.T.). Spanish Ministry of Economy and Competitiveness project FLORMAS no. CGL 2012-33801 (J.P.G.V., M.V.) Spanish Ministry of Economy and Competitiveness projects AGL2012-33736 and AGL2015-64130-R (J.M., J.L.G.A., J.I.). Spanish Severo Ochoa Program SEV-2012-0262 (J.P.G.V., A.M.). Spanish State Research Agency María de Maeztu Excellence Unit accreditation (MDM-2017-0714 and CEX2021-001201-M) funded by MCIN/AEI /10.13039/501100011033 (A.M.). Stanford University Field Studies and Human Biology Research Experiences for Undergraduates Programs (B.J.B.). Swedish Government Strategic Research Initiative Biodiversity and Ecosystem Services in a Changing Climate BECC (J.E., H.G.S., M.R.). Swedish Research Council FORMAS grant no. 2005-788 (H.G.S., J.E., M.R.). Swedish Research Council FORMAS grant no. 2016-00361 (A. Berggren, L.G.A.R.). Swedish Research Council FORMAS grant no. 2019-01524 (A.S.P.). Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences (SLU) through the research program EkoForsk (R.B., S.A.M.L.). Syngenta (J.S., D.K.). Syngenta-CONICET grant no. RD298/14 (M.M., M.D.). Teresa Heinz Scholarship for Environmental Research (B.J.B.). The Leverhulme Trust (D.G.). The Nature Conservancy (B.L.F., K.R.D.). UK Insect Pollinator Initiative project “AgriLand: Linking agriculture and land use change to pollinator populations,” funded under the Living with Environmental change programme, a collaboration between Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council (BBSRC), the Wellcome Trust, Scottish Government, Department of Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (DEFRA) and Natural Environment Research Council (NERC): grant BB/H014934/1 (M.A.K.G., S.G.P., D.S., W.E.K., S.P.M.R.). UK Landfill Tax Credit Scheme (J.O., S.T.). University Fund Wageningen (T.P.M.F.). University of Buenos Aires grant no. 20020130200230BA (M.M., M.D.). University of Northern Iowa Biology Department, College of Humanities, Arts and Sciences, and Tallgrass Prairie Center (A.W.). USDA Farm Service Agency grant no. AG-3151-C-17-0013 (A.W.). USDA Farm Service Agency Inter-agency Agreement 16IAMRECRPHBTA1 (G.M.Q.). USDA-NIFA Specialty Crop Research Initiative award 2012-51181-20105 (Developing Sustainable Pollination Strategies for U.S. Specialty Crops) (T.J.W., R.I.). Winslow Foundation (B.J.B.). Women’s League for Israel (Y.M., T.R.)., With funding from the Spanish government through the "Maria de Maeztu Centre of Excellence" accreditation (CEX2021-001201-M)., Peer reviewed
Project:
EC / H2020 862480
,
MINECO / FP7 PCIN-2014-048
,
EC / FP7 631653
,
EC / FP7 226852
,
EC / FP7 311879
,
EC / H2020 311781
,
EC / Plan Estatal de Investigación Científica y Técnica y de Innovación 2021-2023 101003476
,
MINECO IJCI-2014-22558
,
MINECO RYC2021-032251-I
,
MINECO SEV-2012-0262
,
AEI CGL2012-33801
,
AGL2012-33736
,
MDM-2017-0714
,
CEX2021-001201-M
DOI: http://hdl.handle.net/10261/405892, https://api.elsevier.com/content/abstract/scopus_id/105016996427
HANDLE: http://hdl.handle.net/10261/405892, https://api.elsevier.com/content/abstract/scopus_id/105016996427