Skip to main content

MODELO DE FACIES EN CONTORNITAS ARENOSAS DEL GOLFO DE CADIZ (IODP EXPEDICION 339): CARACTERIZACION E IMPLICACIONES EN LA EXPLORACION DE HIDROCARBUROS

CGL2016-80445-R

•
Funding agency name Agencia Estatal de Investigación
Funding agency acronym AEI
Program Programa Estatal de I+D+i Orientado a los Retos de la Sociedad
Call Proyectos I+D+i Retos de Investigación
Call year 2016
State Plan 2013-2016 Plan Estatal de Investigación Científica y Técnica y de Innovación
Beneficiary centre INSTITUTO GEOLOGICO Y MINERO DE ESPAÑA - CSIC

Resultados relacionados

Resultados totales (Incluyendo duplicados): 19
Encontrada(s) 1 página(s)

Investigo. Repositorio Institucional de la Universidade de Vigo
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Textural characteristics and facies of sand‐rich contourite depositional systems

  • Brackenridge, Rachel E.
  • Stow, Dorrik A. V.
  • Hernández Molina, Francisco Javier
  • Jones, Claudia
  • Mena Rodríguez, Angel
  • Alejo Flores, Irene
  • Ducassou, Emmanuelle
  • Llave, Estefanía
  • Ercilla, Gemma
  • Nombela Castaño, Miguel Ángel
  • Pérez Arlucea, Marta Maria
  • Francés Pedraz, Guillermo
This work presents a detailed study of CONTOURIBER and Integrated Ocean Drilling Program 339 sediment data targeting sand‐rich contourites in the Eastern Gulf of Cadiz. All of the collected sediments are interpreted as contourites (deposited or reworked by bottom currents) on the basis of oceanographic setting, seismic and morphometric features, and facies characteristics. A variety of sandy and associated facies are found across the study area including: (i) bioturbated muddy contourites; (ii) mottled silty contourites; (iii) very fine mottled and fine‐grained bioturbated sandy contourites; (iv) massive and laminated sandy contourites; and (v) coarse sandy/gravel contourites. The thickest sands occur within contourite channels and there is a marked reduction in sand content laterally away from channels. Complementary to the facies descriptions, grain‐size analysis of 675 samples reveals distinctive trends in textural properties linked to depositional processes under the action of bottom currents. The finest muddy contourites (<20 μ m) show normal grain‐size distributions, poor to very poor sorting, and zero or low skewness. These are deposited by settling from weak bottom currents with a fine suspension load. Muddy to fine sandy contourites (20 to 200 μ m) trend towards better sorting and initially finer and then coarser skew. These are typical depositional trends for contourites. As current velocity and carrying capacity increase, more of the finest fraction remains in suspension and bedload transport becomes more important. Clean sandy contourites (>200 μ m) are better sorted. They result from the action of dominant bedload transport and winnowing at high current speeds. The results highlight the importance of bottom current velocity, sediment supply and bioturbational mixing in controlling contourite facies. Despite growing interest in their hydrocarbon exploration potential, contourite sands have remained poorly understood. This research therefore has important implications for developing current understanding of these deposits and aiding the correct interpretation of deep marine sands and depositional processes., Ministerio de Economía y Competitividad | Ref. CTM 2012-39599-C03, Agencia Estatal de Investigación | Ref. CGL2016-80445-R, Agencia Estatal de Investigación | Ref. CTM2016-75129-C3-1-R
Investigo. Repositorio Institucional de la Universidade de Vigo
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Quantitative characterisation of contourite deposits using medical CT

  • Vandorpe, Thomas
  • Collart, Tim
  • Cnudde, Veerle
  • Lebreiro, Susana
  • Hernández Molina, Francisco Javier
  • Alonso, Belén
  • Mena Rodríguez, Angel
  • Antón, Laura
  • Rooij, David van
Five sediment cores, retrieved from four different depositional contouritic morphological settings (a sheeted drift, a confined mounded drift, a mounded elongated drift and a plastered drift) from the Northern Gulf of Cadiz and the Alboran Sea have been analysed using medical X-ray computed tomography (medical CT). A quantitative approach has been used, resulting in a workflow that delineates several radio-density ranges based on the Hounsfield Unit (HU) histogram of each core and tracks these ranges throughout the cores. In order to derive the geological significance, the radio-density ranges of all cores have been compared to non-destructive, continuous chemical and physical proxies as well as grain size measurements. The highest correlations occurred between high HU and proxies indicating elevated bottom currents, such as Zr/Al and sortable silt. Additionally, a continuous increase in average HU and inferred bottom current velocities, needed for the creation of the specific contourite setting, could be observed throughout the five cores. Despite imperfections and the requirement of additional research, promising results have been obtained which could improve the detection of diagnostic criteria for contourites. Moreover, the CT data can give more conclusive evidence on the nature of the (contourite) sedimentary sequence boundaries., Royal Holloway University of London | Ref. 1.5.247.13N, Ministerio de Ciencia e Innovación | Ref. CTM 2012-39599-C03, Ministerio de Economía | Ref. CGL2016-80445-R, Ministerio de Economía | Ref. CTM2016-75129-C3-1-R, Ministerio de Ciencia e Innovación | Ref. CTM2008-06399-CO4-02/MAR
Investigo. Repositorio Institucional de la Universidade de Vigo
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Contourite characterization and its discrimination from other deep‐water deposits in the Gulf of Cadiz contourite depositional system

  • Castro Cao, Sandra
  • Hernández Molina, Francisco Javier
  • Weger, Wouter
  • Jiménez Espejo, Francisco José
  • Rodríguez Tovar, Francisco Javier
  • Mena Rodriguez, Angel
  • Llave, Estefanía
  • Sierro, Francisco Javier
Despite numerous efforts to properly differentiate between contourites and other deep-water deposits in cores and outcrops, reliable diagnostic criteria are still lacking. The co-occurrence of downslope and along-slope sedimentary processes makes it particularly difficult to differentiate these relatively homogeneous deposits. The main aim of this paper is to identify differences in deep-water sediments based on Principal Component Analysis of grain size and geochemistry, sedimentary facies, and reinforced by microfacies and ichnofacies. The sediments studied were obtained from two International Ocean Drilling Program Expedition 339 sites in mounded and sheeted drifts in the Gulf of Cadiz. The statistical approach led to the discernment of hemipelagites, silty contourites, sandy contourites, bottom current reworked sands, fine-grained turbidites and debrites over a range of depositional and physiographic elements. These elements are linked to contourite drifts, the drift-channel transition, the contourite channel and distal upper slope. When bottom currents or gravity-driven flows are not the dominant depositional process, marine productivity and continental input settling forms the main depositional mechanism in deep-water environments. This is reflected by a high variability of the first principal component in hemipelagic deposits. The stacked principal component variability of these deposits evidences that the contourite drift and the adjacent contourite channel were influenced by the interrelation of hemipelagic, gravitational and bottom current induced depositional processes. This interrelation questions the paradigm that a drift is made up solely of muddy sediments. The interrelation of sedimentary processes is a consequence of the precession-driven changes in the intensity of the Mediterranean Outflow Water related to Mediterranean climate variability, which are punctuated by millennial-scale variability. Associated vertical and lateral shifts of the Mediterranean Outflow Water, and therefore of its interface with the East North Atlantic Central Water, controlled sediment input and favoured turbulent sediment transport in the middle slope. During, Ministerio de Economía | Ref. CTM 2012- 39599-C03, Ministerio de Economía | Ref. CGL2015-66835-P, Ministerio de Economía | Ref. CTM2016-75129- C3-1-R, Ministerio de Economía | Ref. CGL2016-80445-R, FEDER Andalucía | Ref. B-RNM-072-UGR18
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publication Contribución de congreso (ConferenceOutput)

Gravity flows and deep currents interaction in upper slope gullies: A high-resolution stratigraphic and sedimentological study

  • García, Marga
  • Mena, Anxo
  • Hernández-Molina, Francisco J.
  • Alonso, Belén
  • Ercilla, Gemma
  • Llave, Estefanía
  • Fernández-Salas, L. M.
  • Lobo, Francisco José
20th International Sedimentological Congress (ISC), 13-17 August 2018, Quebec City, Canada.-- 1 page, Gullies are ubiquitous erosive features in continental margins that are mainly related to downslope, low-density gravitational flows (turbidites), although mass transport and fluids migration may be involved in their genesis and evolution. A series of downslope-trending gullies have been identified on the relatively smooth, slightly concave-upward upper slope of the Gulf of Cadiz, close to the Strait of Gibraltar. They extend from 205-250 m (beyond the continental shelf) to 510-580 m water depth, at the Cadiz Channel northern flank along the middle slope. The occurrence of gullies in this region, characterized by active contouritic processes affected by diapiric ridges, suggests an interaction between bottom current processes and the downslope-trending gullies. This interaction is investigated in this work, based on the analysis of very high-resolution data including swath bathymetry, echo-sounder parametric profiles and sediment cores up to 310 cm long. The gullies are generally asymmetric, with steeper and higher NE walls. Overall, they are arranged in a dendritic, convergent pattern laterally spaced 0.4-2 km. Parametric profiles show that both the gullies and inter-gully areas are covered by a thin, low reflectivity sheet-like layer, up to 10 milliseconds (two-way travel time) thick, that become thicker in the gullies SE flank. Three sediment cores collected along the axis of one single gully exhibit vertically homogeneous muddy sand and sandy mud, but with clear occasional smaller coarsening-upward sequences. In contrast, two sediment cores collected in the adjacent undisturbed upper slope contain finer sediment (mud to sandy mud) that exhibit general and smaller-scale coarsening-upward trends. These results suggest that the upper slope is affected by an increasing effect of the Mediterranean flow and the gullies are inactive features at present. This may imply that the upper slope of the Gulf of Cadiz records changes in the oceanographic control and turbiditic activity probably related to changes in the vertical distribution of water masses with glacio-eustatic cyclicity, This work is supported by the Spanish Research Plan (TALUS Project CGL2015-74216-JIN, SCORE Project CGL2016-80445-R and INPULSE Project CTM2016-75129-C3-3-R). The dataset was obtained during the GRACO Cruise, funded by the Eurofleets2 Program (EC, Grant agreement 312762). The study is partially conducted in the framework of “TheDrifters Research Group” at the Royal Holloway University of London (UK), Peer Reviewed
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Quantitative characterisation of contourite deposits using medical CT

  • Vandorpe, Thomas
  • Collart, Tim
  • Cnudde, Veerle
  • Lebreiro, Susana M.
  • Hernández-Molina, Francisco J.
  • Alonso, Belén
  • Mena, Anxo
  • Antón López, Laura Ángela
  • Van Rooij, David
15 pages, 10 figures, 5 tables, Five sediment cores, retrieved from four different depositional contouritic morphological settings (a sheeted drift, a confined mounded drift, a mounded elongated drift and a plastered drift) from the Northern Gulf of Cadiz and the Alboran Sea have been analysed using medical X-ray computed tomography (medical CT). A quantitative approach has been used, resulting in a workflow that delineates several radio-density ranges based on the Hounsfield Unit (HU) histogram of each core and tracks these ranges throughout the cores. In order to derive the geological significance, the radio-density ranges of all cores have been compared to non-destructive, continuous chemical and physical proxies as well as grain size measurements. The highest correlations occurred between high HU and proxies indicating elevated bottom currents, such as Zr/Al and sortable silt. Additionally, a continuous increase in average HU and inferred bottom current velocities, needed for the creation of the specific contourite setting, could be observed throughout the five cores. Despite imperfections and the requirement of additional research, promising results have been obtained which could improve the detection of diagnostic criteria for contourites. Moreover, the CT data can give more conclusive evidence on the nature of the (contourite) sedimentary sequence boundaries, This research project was conducted in the framework of the FWO grant “Contourite 3D” (project number 1.5.247.13N) and was assisted by “The Drifters Research Group” of the Royal Holloway University of London (UK). The cores and the physical and geochemical analyses on them were acquired in the framework of the following projects: CTM 2012-39599-C03, CTM2008-06399-CO4-02/MAR, CTM2016-75129- C3-1-R and CGL2016-80445-R, Peer Reviewed
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publication Otros (Other)

Contourites along the Iberian continental margins: conceptual and economic implications

  • Llave, Estefanía
  • Hernández-Molina, Francisco J.
  • García, Marga
  • Ercilla, Gemma
  • Roque, Cristina
  • Juan, Carmen
  • Mena, Anxo
  • Preu, Benedict
  • Van Rooij, David
  • Rebesco, Michele
  • Brackenridge, Rachel E.
  • Jane, G.
  • Gómez-Ballesteros, María
  • Stow, Dorrik A. V.
34 pages, 14 figures, 3 tables, This work uses seismic records to document and classify contourite features around the Iberian continental margin to determine their implications for depositional systems and petroleum exploration. Contourites include depositional features (separated, sheeted, plastered and confined drifts), erosional features (abraded surfaces, channels, furrows and moats) and mixed features (contourite terraces). Drifts generally show high- to moderate-amplitude reflectors, which are cyclically intercalated with transparent layers. Transparent layers may represent finer-grained deposits, which can serve as seal rocks. High-amplitude reflectors (HARs) are likely to represent sandier layers, which could form hydrocarbon reservoirs. HARs occur on erosive features (moats and channels), and are clearly developed on contourite terraces and overflow features. Most of the contourite features described here are influenced by Mediterranean water masses throughout their Pliocene and Quaternary history. They specifically record Mediterranean Outflow Water, following its exit through the Gibraltar Strait. This work gives a detailed report on the variation of modern contourite deposits, which can help inform ancient contourite reservoir interpretation. Further research correlating 2D and 3D seismic anomalies with core and well-logging data is needed to develop better diagnostic criteria for contourites. This can help to clarify the role of contourites in petroleum systems, This contribution is a product of the IGCP-619 and INQUA-1204 projects, and is partially supported through the CTM 2008-06399-C04/MAR (CONTOURIBER), CGL2011-16057-E (MOW), CTM 2012-39599-C03 (MOWER), CGL2016-80445-R (SCORE), FCT-PTDC/GEO-GEO/4430/2012 (CONDRIBER), CTM2016-75129-C3-1-R and CGL2015-74216-JIN projects, Peer Reviewed
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Review of the late Quaternary stratigraphy of the northern Gulf of Cadiz continental margin: New insights into controlling factors and global implications

  • Mestdagh, Thomas
  • Lobo, Francisco José
  • Llave, Estefanía
  • Hernández-Molina, Francisco J.
  • Van Rooij, D.
Over the past decades, the northern Gulf of Cadiz has been the focus of a wide range of late Quaternary seismic and sequence stratigraphic studies, either addressing the slope contourite depositional system (CDS), or the development of the continental shelf. Yet, high-resolution seismic data bridging between these domains and age information have remained sparse. This study, based on new high-resolution reflection seismic profiles calibrated to IODP Expedition 339 sites U1386/U1387, now presents an updated stratigraphic framework, that integrates (for the first time) the late Quaternary records of the northern Gulf of Cadiz middle slope to shelf off the Guadiana River. Seismic stratigraphic analysis of the stacking, depocenter distribution, stratal architecture and facies of the seismic (sub-)units reveals the influence of ~100 kyr sea-level variations paced by Milankovitch (eccentricity) cycles, tectonics (manifesting as two pulses of uplift and margin progradation), sediment supply and bottom current activity. This work furthermore contributes to the application and understanding of high-resolution, late Quaternary sequence stratigraphy. Firstly, the proposed sequence stratigraphic interpretation shows that adaptations to the basic models are required to integrate the shelf and slope record, and to account for the presence of a significant alongslope (bottom current-controlled) component. Secondly, the results confirm that the sequences are dominantly composed of regressive deposits, whereas the preservation of transgressive to highstand deposits is more irregular. Significantly, the common assumption that successive major glacial lowstands are consistently recorded as well-marked, shelf-wide erosional unconformities, is demonstrated to be occasionally invalid, as tectonics can obliterate this one-to-one relationship., T. Mestdagh is supported by a doctoral scholarship of the Ghent University Special Research Fund (BOF), Belgium. This research was conducted in connection with ‘The Drifters Research Group’ of the Royal Holloway University of London (UK), and is related to projects funded by the Spanish government with project codes: CTM 2012-39599-C03, CGL2016-80445-R ‘SCORE’ (AEI/FEDER, UE), CTM2016-75129-C3-1-R, CGL2011-30302-C02-02 and CTM2017-88237-P. We wish to thank the captains, crews and scientific parties of research cruises COMIC 2013 on board of RV Belgica and LASEA 2013 on board of RV Ramón Margalef. Ship time on RV Belgica was provided by BELSPO - Belgian federal government (Belgium) and RBINS-OD Nature. Editor A. Negri, C. Pellegrini and one anonymous reviewer are kindly acknowledged for providing constructive reviews and feedback.
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Multiprocess interaction shaping geoforms and controlling substrate types and benthic community distribution in the Gulf of Cádiz

  • Lozano, Pablo
  • Fernández-Salas, L. M.
  • Hernández-Molina, Francisco J.
  • Sánchez-Leal, Ricardo Félix
  • Sánchez-Guillamón, Olga
  • Palomino, Desirée
  • Farias, Carlos
  • Mateo-Ramírez, Ángel
  • López-González, Nieves
  • García, Marga
  • Vázquez, Juan Tomás
  • Vila, Yolanda
  • Rueda, José Luis
The Iberian margin in the Gulf of Cádiz hosts a fluid venting area embedded into a contourite depositional drift and is a natural laboratory to study how multiple interacting processes shape the seafloor. A high-resolution morpho-sedimentary analysis, based on geophysical data, sediment samples and submarine imagery, has been carried out; the onset and evolution of the main geoforms are discussed; and the influence of geological, oceanographic and biogenic processes conditioning substrate types and benthic community distribution are evaluated. The interplay of geological (e.g., salt and shale diapirism, mud volcanism), oceanographic (e.g., water mass circulation, secondary circulation, vertical eddies, internal waves) and biogenic (e.g., methane derived authigenic carbonates formation, coral mound aggradations) processes drive the formation of a large variety of geoforms including, among others, contourite drifts, channels, diapiric ridges, mud volcanoes, pockmarks, and coral mounds. At a smaller scale, the interaction between massive and fluid extrusive, biogenic, and bottom current-related processes (both depositional and erosive) determines the distribution of substrate types and benthic communities, which have been classified as belonging to different biotopes., The authors thank colleagues, captains and crew members who participated in the data acquisition during the 2010–2019 expeditions aboard R/V Emma Bardán, R/V Cornide de Saavedra, R/V Ramón Margalef, and R/V Ángeles Alvariño. We are also grateful for the comments provided by the two anonymous reviewers, which significantly improved this manuscript. This work has been supported by LIFE+ INDEMARES/CHICA (LIFE 07/NAT/E/000732), ISUNEPCA (FB FEP/AC1 20123118_2014; IEO/2015-2017), LIFE IP PAF INTEMARES (LIFE15/IPE/ES/000012), INPULSE (CTM2016 75129 C3 1 R MINECO) and TALUS (CGL2015-74216-JIN) projects. Part of the research was also conducted within the framework of “The Drifters Research Group” at Royal Holloway, University of London (UK), and is related to the projects CTM 2012-39599-C03 and CGL2016-80445-R.
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Sedimentary evolution of the Le Danois contourite drift systems (southern Bay of Biscay, NE Atlantic): A reconstruction of the Atlantic Mediterranean Water circulation since the Pliocene

  • Liu, Shan
  • Hernández-Molina, Francisco J.
  • Ercilla, Gemma
  • Van Rooij, David
19 pages, 11 figures, 1 table, The evolution of the Le Danois contourite depositional systems (CDS) during the Pliocene and Quaternary was investigated based on high-resolution seismic reflection data. From old to young, six seismic units (U1–U6) bounded by major discontinuities (H1–H6) were identified. Regarding variations of the bottom-current circulation, four evolution stages of the Le Danois CDS were identified, including onset (~5.3 to 3.5–3.0 Ma), initial (3.5–3.0 to 2.5–2.1 Ma), intermediate (2.5–2.1 to 0.9–0.7 Ma) and drift-growth (0.9–0.7 Ma to present day) stages. The CDS associated with the Atlantic Mediterranean Water (AMW) along the middle continental slope initiated at ~3.5–3 Ma and was widely built after the Mid-Pleistocene Transition (MPT; 0.9–07 Ma). At a shallower water depth, a second CDS associated with the Eastern North Atlantic Central Water (ENACW) started to develop from the late Quaternary (~0.47 Ma) onwards. In the AMW-related drift system, the Le Danois Drift was generated both under glacial and interglacial climatic oscilations. Repeated internal structures in unit 5 that consist of acoustically transparent lower parts, moderate amplitude upper parts and high amplitude erosional surfaces at the top, are compared with interglacial/glacial cycles since the middle Pleistocene to the present day. These cyclic features suggest coarsening-upward sequences of the Le Danois Drift and processes related to enhanced AMW during glacial stages. The estimated sedimentation rate of the Le Danois CDS reached a maximum during the MPT (at least ~27 cm/ky) and then decreased until present-day (~5 cm/ky). Variations of sedimentary stacking patterns and processes of the Le Danois CDS imply full domination of the intermediate water mass along the central Atlantic and southwest European continental slopes from the late Pliocene (~3.5–3.0 Ma) onwards, This study was carried out within the framework of a Chinese Scholarship Council “CSC Grant” (201506410062). This study built on achievements of project ESF Euromargins MOUNDFORCE, EC FP5 RTN EURODOM and EC FP6 HERMES 626 (GOCE-CT-2005-511234-1). The research cruises namely framed within the ECOMARG (REN2002-624 00916/MAR) and MARCONI (REN2001-1734 C03-01/M) projects. Shiptime RV Belgica was provided by BELSPO and RBINS–OD Nature. This study was conducted in collaboration with “The Drifters” Research Group of the Royal Holloway University of London (UK) and it is related to the projects CTM 2012-39599-C03, CGL2016-80445-R, and CTM2016-75129-C3-1-R (REN2001-1734 C03-01/M). It was also carried out in collaboration with the Continental Margins Group-GMC from ICM-CSIC (Spain) and its related Spanish projects (CTM2008-06399-C04-04/MAR; CTM2012-39599-CO3-O3; CMT2015- 65461-C2-R (MINEICO/FEDER), With the funding support of the ‘Severo Ochoa Centre of Excellence’ accreditation (CEX2019-000928-S), of the Spanish Research Agency (AEI)
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

The role of late Quaternary tectonic activity and sea-level changes on sedimentary processes interaction in the Gulf of Cadiz upper and middle continental slope (SW Iberia)

  • García, Marga
  • Llave, Estefanía
  • Hernández-Molina, Francisco J.
  • Lobo, Francisco José
  • Ercilla, Gemma
  • Alonso, Belén
  • Casas, David
  • Mena, Anxo
  • Fernández-Salas, L. M.
21 pages, 13 figures, supplementary data https://doi.org/10.1016/j.marpetgeo.2020.104595.-- The datasets used in this work are still being used for further research, A morphological and seismic-stratigraphic analysis of the Gulf of Cadiz area near the Strait of Gibraltar is presented in this work, focused on the sedimentary evolution of the upper and proximal middle-continental slope since the Mid-Pleistocene. Based on the analysis of seismic reflection profiles and swath bathymetry data, this work analyses the close influence of the activity of buried and outcropping diapiric ridges and late Quaternary sea-level changes on the evolution of contouritic features related to the Mediterranean Outflow Water (MOW) and Eastern North Atlantic Central Water (ENACW), gravitational features and fluid-escape structures. The stratigraphic architecture reveals that, under active diapiric deformation, the upper slope plastered drift grew during low sea-level stages, when sediment supply was high and the ENACW swept the upper slope, contrasting with the present-day highstand situation dominated by northwest-trending MOW flow. The south-estward ENACW flow forced asymmetry and lateral migration of gullies incised in the plastered drift. Two evolutionary stages have been established: 1) After the Mid Pleistocene, activity of diapirs with a NE trend determined the location of the deepest depressions which were infilled by plastered contouritic drifts; 2) Between Late Quaternary and present, a drastic change of buried diapirs growth pattern and orientation to a NW trend enhanced slope-derived gravitational processes affecting the bottom current dynamics. Adjustments to tectonic changes led to a phase of plastered drift growth on the upper slope during which depocenters varied their distribution and orientation. In a long-term the structural control on sedimentation shows a northwestward displacement of deformation, resulting in an overall extension of the contourite depositional system to the NW. In a short-term, sea-level changes favored drift deposition, gullies incision and the strengthening of water masses. This work evidences the importance of tectonic deformation in sedimentation at recent time scales, and the two-directional interplay between recent tectonic activity and bottom current dynamics, This work has been possible thanks to funding provided by the following projects funded by the Spanish Ministry of Economy and Competitivity: TALUS (CGL2015-74216-JIN), INPULSE (CTM2016-75129-C3-1-R), CONTOURIBER (CTM2008-06399-04-04), MOWER (CTM-2012-395599-C03), SCORE (CGL2016-80445-R; AEI/FEDER, UE), and FAUCES (CTM2015-65461-C2-1-R), With the funding support of the ‘Severo Ochoa Centre of Excellence’ accreditation (CEX2019-000928-S), of the Spanish Research Agency (AEI), Peer reviewed
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Late Quaternary multi-genetic processes and products on the northern Gulf of Cadiz upper continental slope (SW Iberian Peninsula)

  • Mestdagh, Thomas
  • Lobo, Francisco José
  • Llave, Estefanía
  • Hernández-Molina, Francisco J.
  • García Ledesma, Antonio
  • Puga-Bernabéu, Ángel
  • Fernández-Salas, L. M.
  • Van Rooij, D.
On continental margins, the upper slope to shelf break environment forms a critical region where sediment supply, hydrographic activity and gravitational processes determine how and when sediments are partitioned between the shallow- and deep-marine realm. On the SW Iberian margin, relatively few studies have addressed the dynamics of this region, although it holds key information regarding the link between the sedimentary evolution of the continental shelf and the contourite depositional system on the middle slope. This work therefore presents a high-resolution analysis of the morphological and stratigraphic expressions of late Quaternary (dominantly last glacial and present-day interglacial) sedimentary processes on the upper slope and shelf margin sector between 7° and 7°30’ W. The integration of seismic, bathymetric and hydrographic data reveals the presence of alongslope processes and products (a bottom current-related plastered drift, moat, erosional surface and terrace, an internal wave-/tide-controlled sediment wave field), downslope (gravitational) processes and products (an upper slope – shelf margin valley system, slumps, debrites, gullies), neotectonic elements (diapirs) and fluid flow features (pockmarks, bright spots). The spatial distribution of these features indicates that the study area becomes increasingly alongslope-dominated towards the W, and oppositely, more downslope-dominated towards the E, because sediment supply to the latter area is enhanced under the dominant eastward dispersal of fluvially supplied sediments on the shelf. In addition, glacial-interglacial variations in the amount of sediments supplied to the shelf edge and the intensity of oceanographic processes in the study area also generate a distinct temporal variability, with glacial and interglacial intervals respectively recording principally downslope- and alongslope-controlled morphological elements. Finally, regardless of these overall spatial and temporal patterns, diapirism and fluid flow are inferred to locally destabilize sediments and induce small-scale mass wasting in the study area. These findings are not only relevant to the northern Gulf of Cadiz, but also to the general understanding of sedimentary dynamics and controls in mixed downslope- and alongslope-controlled upper slope to shelf margin settings worldwide., T. Mestdagh is funded through a doctoral scholarship of the Ghent University Special Research Fund (BOF). We would like to thank the captains, crews and scientists involved in research campaigns COMIC 2013 on board of RV Belgica and LASEA 2013 on board of RV Ramón Margalef. Ship time on RV Belgica was provided by BELSPO and RBINS-OD Nature. This research was performed in collaboration with ”The Drifters” Research Group of the Royal Holloway University of London (UK), and is associated to projects CTM 2012-39599-C03 , CGL2016-80445-R ‘SCORE’ ( AEI/FEDER , UE), CTM2016-75129-C3-1-R , CGL2011-30302-C02-02 and CTM2017-88237-P . Editor Michele Rebesco and two anonymous reviewers are kindly acknowledged for providing constructive feedback.
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Contourite characterization and its discrimination from other deep-water deposits in the Gulf of Cadiz contourite depositional system

  • De Castro, Sandra
  • Hernández-Molina, Francisco J.
  • De Weger, Wouter
  • Rodríguez-Tovar, Francisco Javier
  • Jiménez-Espejo, Francisco J.
  • Mena, Anxo
  • Llave, Estefanía
  • Sierro, Francisco Javier
Despite numerous efforts to properly differentiate between contourites and other deep-water deposits in cores and outcrops, reliable diagnostic criteria are still lacking. The co-occurrence of downslope and along-slope sedimentary processes makes it particularly difficult to differentiate these relatively homogeneous deposits. The main aim of this paper is to identify differences in deep-water sediments based on Principal Component Analysis of grain size and geochemistry, sedimentary facies, and reinforced by microfacies and ichnofacies. The sediments studied were obtained from two International Ocean Drilling Program Expedition 339 sites in mounded and sheeted drifts in the Gulf of Cadiz. The statistical approach led to the discernment of hemipelagites, silty contourites, sandy contourites, bottom current reworked sands, fine-grained turbidites and debrites over a range of depositional and physiographic elements. These elements are linked to contourite drifts, the drift-channel transition, the contourite channel and distal upper slope. When bottom currents or gravity-driven flows are not the dominant depositional process, marine productivity and continental input settling forms the main depositional mechanism in deep-water environments. This is reflected by a high variability of the first principal component in hemipelagic deposits. The stacked principal component variability of these deposits evidences that the contourite drift and the adjacent contourite channel were influenced by the interrelation of hemipelagic, gravitational and bottom current induced depositional processes. This interrelation questions the paradigm that a drift is made up solely of muddy sediments. The interrelation of sedimentary processes is a consequence of the precession-driven changes in the intensity of the Mediterranean Outflow Water related to Mediterranean climate variability, which are punctuated by millennial-scale variability. Associated vertical and lateral shifts of the Mediterranean Outflow Water, and therefore of its interface with the East North Atlantic Central Water, controlled sediment input and favoured turbulent sediment transport in the middle slope. During the interglacial precession maxima/insolation minima, a more vigorous upper core of the Mediterranean Outflow Water and the enhanced impact of the East North Atlantic Central Water – Mediterranean Outflow Water interface allowed for the development of the sandier contourite deposits., his project was funded through the Joint Industry Project supported by BP, ENI, ExxonMobil, TOTAL, Wintershall Dea and TGS, within the framework of “The Drifters” Research Group at Royal Holloway University of London (RHUL), in conjunction with the projects CTM 2012‐39599‐C03, CGL2015‐66835‐P, CTM2016‐75129‐C3‐1‐R, CGL2016‐80445‐R (AEI/FEDER, UE) and B‐RNM‐072‐UGR18. This research used data and samples collected by IODP Expedition 339 aboard the Joides Resolution. Data was acquired at the XRF Core Scanner Lab at MARUM – Center for Marine Environmental Sciences, University of Bremen, Germany. Our thanks to Dr Javier Dorador (RHUL, UK) for the high‐resolution core imaging treatment, to Dr David Roque (ICMAN‐CSIC, Spain) for his help in the hydrographic panels from Fig. 2 , and to Dr Ángel Puga‐Bernabéu (University of Granada, Spain) for revision that helped to improve the original version of the manuscript before submission. This study significantly benefited from discussions with all who attended the IODP Exp. 339 MOW meeting in Heidelberg (Germany) in January 2019. We would like to thank Associate Editor Dr Adam McArthur and the three reviewers, Dr Rachel Brackenridge, Dr Giancarlo Davoli and Dr Adriano Viana, for their positive and constructive comments that helped us improve the manuscript.
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publication Contribución de congreso (ConferenceOutput)

Gravitational and oceanographic processes interaction in the upper slope gullies of the Gulf of Cadiz, Interacción entre procesos gravitacionales y oceanográficos en los valles submarinos del talud superior del Golfo de Cádiz

  • García, Marga
  • Mena, Anxo
  • Hernández-Molina, Francisco J.
  • Alonso, Belén
  • Ercilla, Gemma
  • Casas, David
  • Llave, Estefanía
  • Fernández-Salas, L. M.
  • Lobo, Francisco José
X Congreso Geológico de España, 5-7 de julio 2021, Vitoria-Gasteiz.-- 4 pages, 4 figures, [EN] The Gulf of Cadiz upper slope in the area close to the Strait of Gibraltar is covered by a plastered drift deposited by the activity of the Mediterranean Outflow Water (MOW) and the North Atlantic Central Water (NACW). A number of small gullies are incised across the plastered drift, due to the interaction between gravitational and contouritic processes. The study of parametric sounder profiles and sedimentological analyses of nine sediment cores obtained from the axes of two gullies and from the undisturbed upper slope, giving a Holocene age frame, has allowed analyzing the recent sedimentary processes and their spatial and temporal variability. The upper slope shows a general increase in grain size towards the NW, suggesting bottom current intensification and/or the occurrence of gravity flows from the continental shelf and shelf-edge. The two studied upper slope gullies display significant differences in their recent activity and dominant processes. The one located to the SE seems to have been inactive since about 5.9 ka, and it has been draped by contouritic deposits. In contrast, the gully located to the NW has been a sediment transport conduit for the entire time span recorded in the sediment cores, [ES] El talud superior del margen Ibérico del Golfo de Cádiz en las proximidades del Estrecho de Gibraltar está ocupado por un depósito contornítico adosado resultado de la circulación del Agua Mediterránea de Salida (Mediterranean Outflow Water, MOW) y de la Masa de Agua Central Noratlántica (North Atlantic Central Water, NACW). En él se encajan pequeños valles submarinos (gullies) debido a la interacción entre los procesos gravitacionales y contorníticos. Mediante el estudio de perfiles de sonda paramétrica y el análisis sedimentológico de nueve testigos obtenidos en el área del talud superior no afectada por gullies y en los ejes de dos gullies, cuya datación corresponde al Holoceno, este estudio analiza los procesos sedimentarios recientes y su variabilidad espacial y temporal. El talud superior muestra un incremento general del tamaño de grano hacia el NO, indicativo de intensificación de las corrientes y/o el aporte sedimentario de origen gravitacional desde la plataforma continental y borde de plataforma. Los dos gullies estudiados muestran una gran variabilidad en los procesos predominantes. El gully más meridional, dominado actualmente por la sedimentación contornítica, parece haber sido inactivo desde unos 5.9 ka. En cambio, el gully localizado más al NW ha canalizado flujos gravitacionales durante todo el intervalo registrado por los testigos, We acknowledge funding from the Talus (CGL2015-74216-JIN), Inpulse (CTM2016-75129-C3-1-R), Contouriber (CTM2008-06399-C04/MAR), Mower (CTM2012-39599-C03), Fauces (CTM2015-65461-C2-1-R) and Score (CGL2016-80445-R) projects. This work has benefited from the collaborations within the Drifters” Research Group (RHUL)
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Recent deformational state from morphological analysis of mud volcanoes in the Gulf of Cadiz (southwestern part of the Iberian Atlantic Margin)

  • Maestro González, Adolfo
  • Bohoyo, Fernando
  • Corral, Rubén
[EN] Information gathered from multibeam echosounders and seismic profiles in the Gulf of Cadiz show several morphological reliefs having circular to sub-circular shape having been associated to mud volcanoes. The distribution of mud volcanoes in this area can be related to fluids escapes (gases and water), comprising mud and rock blocks from a pressurized deep unit through structural discontinuities of the upper crust. They are located in a complex tecto-sedimentary wedge named Accretionary Wedge of the Gulf of Cadiz formed by African-Eurasian convergence and the westward Rifean-Gibraltar-Betic Arc. They are most frequent in four sectors: the Moroccan, the Guadalquivir Diapiric Ridge, the TASYO and Deep South Portuguese fields. They differ in size, shape, and presence of the mud flows. Statistical analysis of the regional-scale distribution and shape of the mud volcanoes provides new information about present-day stress filed. The volcano strain indicators show a robust recent direction of two main regional maximum horizontal stress SH striking N132E and N149E to N160E, as well as a three secondary stress field with a N050E, N090E and N175E to N045E trends. The analysis of mud volcano alignments indicates two main trends, N125E and N150E, and two secondary orientations, N070E and N095E. These results are congruent with the stress field established from focal mechanisms, borehole breakouts and mesofault population data., This research was funded by the CONTOURIBER Project (CTM2008-06399-C04-01/MAR) and the SCORE Project (CGL2016-80445-R, AEI/FEDER, UE)., Peer reviewed
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Echo-character distribution in the Cantabrian Margin and the Biscay Abyssal Plain

  • Maestro González, Adolfo
  • Gallastegui, Alba
  • Moreta, Mercedes
  • Llave, Estefanía
  • Bohoyo, Fernando
  • Druet Vélez, María
  • Navas Madrazo, José Javier
  • Mink Proeck, Sandra Martina
  • Fernández Sáez, Fernando
  • Catalán Morollón, Manuel
  • Gómez-Ballesteros, María
  • Muñoz-Martín, Alfonso
  • Granja-Bruña, José Luis
[EN] In 2003, 2006–2009, 2014 and 2015, seven oceanographic cruises were carried out on board the Spanish R/V Hespérides in the Cantabrian Margin and the adjacent abyssal plains, covering an area of 219,124 km2. Based on the combined analysis and interpretation of the bathymetric and reflectivity data obtained with multibeam echo sounders (SIMRAD EM12, EM120 and EM1002), and ultra-high-resolution reflection seismic records acquired with the SIMRAD TOPAS PS18 parametric sounder, the mapping of the acoustic facies or echo-character at a scale of 1:1,200,000 has been carried out. Thirty types of echoes have been differentiated and gather into four main groups: Distinct, Irregular, Hyperbolic and Undulated. The echo-character depends on the acoustic response of the shallow sediment and the seabed morphology. Therefore, its analysis and characterization are basic for understanding recent and present-day sedimentary processes., This work was supported by the Instituto Geológico y Minero de España and the Spanish project SCORE (CGL2016-80445-R, AEI/FEDER, UE)., Peer reviewed
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Eocene to middle Miocene contourite deposits in Cyprus: A record of Indian Gateway evolution

  • Hernández-Molina, F. J.
  • Hüneke, H.
  • Rodríguez-Tovar, F. J.
  • Ng, Z. L.
  • Llave, Estefanía
  • Mena, A.
  • Gibb, A.
  • Chiarella, D.
  • Sammartino, S.
  • de la Vara, A.
Bottom current deposits (contourites) form in association with modern-day or ancient oceanic gateways. A paucity of examples in the ancient record and the lack of consensus on diagnostic criteria for differentiating them from other deepwater deposits limit our understanding of how they may record past global oceanic circulation, tectonic events and gateway evolution. This work describes an exceptional example of Eocene to middle Miocene deep-marine deposits located both onshore and offshore deepwater environments around the island of Cyprus. Multidisciplinary approaches were used to discriminate contourite facies associations, propose a sedimentary model, and interpret the relations with regional tectonics and the evolution of the nearby Indian Gateway. Contourite deposits appear in late Eocene to middle Miocene intervals interstratified with pelagic/hemipelagic sediments, turbidites and mass-transport deposits (MTDs). These deepwater deposits developed along a slope basin located on the upper plate of an active margin, evolving from a wide basin formed during a period of tectonic quiescent into a series of shallowing-upward, segmented sub-basins affected by compressional stress. The present study proposes a sedimentary model in which two contourite depositional systems developed: first in the Eocene (dominated by finer-grained contourites), and then during the latest Oligocene to middle Miocene (dominated by coarser-grained contourites). Both systems were buried by extensive marl deposits and record the respective influence of deep (circulating NW) and intermediate (circulating SE) water masses. The long-term evolution of the contourites reflects tectonic events that enhanced subduction processes south of Cyprus as well as exchange between the Neotethys Ocean and the Indian and Atlantic Oceans —until the final closure of the Indian Gateway by the end of the middle Miocene, when a new circulation pattern was established with the formation of the Mediterranean Sea. The contourites described here represent bi-gradational sequences that normally form in association with contouritic drifts, sometimes having the asymmetric top-cut sequence characteristics of plastered drifts and contourite terraces. The coarser (sandy) contourites, formed from the latest Oligocene to middle Miocene, consist of three packages associated with compressive and flexural phases. They pertain to I) Chattian (late Oligocene); II) Aquitanian/Burdigalian (early Miocene) and III) Langhian (middle Miocene). Evidence of enhanced bottom current episodes occurs toward the top of these packages before they are buried by later dominant marl deposits. The sandy contourites thus formed during the compressive phases, whereas the predominately finer-grained units formed during later flexural phases. The intermittent turbidites and MTDs (developed during compressional phases in combination with pelagic/hemipelagic sediments) represent the sediment supply for the contourite deposits after their winnowing and / or reworking. Our research found that the diagnostic criteria for discriminating ancient bottom current deposits from other deepwater deposits are related primarily to variations in sedimentary processes, current behaviour and its velocity, sedimentation rates and paleoenvironmental conditions. This highlights the importance of primary sedimentary structures, microfacies and ichnological features in making determinations at the sedimentary facies scale. Due to their common occurrence, sedimentary thickness (30-40 m), potential porosity and permeability, sandy contourites can form deepwater reservoirs for energy geosciences. In summary, this work demonstrates the role of plate tectonics and oceanic gateways in driving the paleo-oceanic circulation that, in turn, controls sedimentary processes and shapes the morphology of oceanic basins and continental margins. It also allows for comparison with other present-day and ancient continental margin deposits. Future high-resolution approaches and analyses of other geological settings could help resolve the sedimentary architectures of similar deepwater systems in terms of episodic tectonic processes —involving compressive-flexural stress variations. They control the Earth's surface environment (sea-level, climate and oceanic circulation) over time by influencing sediment supply, packages of strata and types of contourite deposits., This work was funded through the Joint Industry Project (JIP) supported by BP (United Kingdom), ENI (Italy), TOTAL (France), ExxonMobil (United States), Wintershall Dea (Germany) and TGS (United Kingdom) within the framework of “The Drifters” Research Group at Royal Holloway University of London (RHUL), and it is related to the projects CTM 2012-39599-C03, CGL2016-80445-R and CTM2016-75129-C3-1-R. Financial support of the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG) is gratefully acknowledged (HU 804/11-1). We thank the Cyprus Geological Survey for scientific collaboration and support, in particular Costas Constantinou and Efthymios Tsiolakis., Peer reviewed
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Large bedforms on contourite terraces: Sedimentary and conceptual implications

  • Hernández-Molina, F. J.
  • Campbell, S.
  • Badalini, Gianluca
  • Thompson, P.
  • Walker, R.
  • Soto, M.
  • Conti, B.
  • Preu, B.
  • Thieblemont, A.
  • Hyslop, L.
  • Miramontes, E.
  • Morales, E.
While bedforms are increasingly being recognized and analyzed in bathymetric and seismic data sets, exact mechanisms for the formation of large bedforms are not well understood. This paper describes a suite of Paleocene to Miocene bedforms found along a series of contourite terraces that compose the Uruguayan continental slope. Results are compared with similar bedforms found along other continental margins. This study describes diagnostic, large-scale features associated with major discontinuities, including channels, scours, furrows, sand ribbons, and barchan dunes. These record periods of increased bottom current activity and thus represent distinct paleoceanographic markers within the basin. Sequences of layered, muddy two-dimensional dune-like bedforms also commonly occur between discontinuities. The vertical bedform distribution exhibits a repetitive pattern generated by bottom currents, with sediment supply from simultaneous downslope processes deposited primarily over discontinuous intervals. Sediment reworking and redistribution along slope by bottom currents generated thick, extensive sand-rich deposits concentrated at particular locations. These features raise fundamental questions concerning margin processes, morphologies, stratigraphic context, and bedform development in deep-marine environments. Given their role in paleoceanographic reconstructions and resource exploration, these deposits and the mechanisms that form them require more formal understanding., The authors would like to thank ANCAP, British Gas Group, and Shell for permission to use unpublished seismic data sets. The research was supported through the Spanish Ciencia y Tecnologías Marinas projects CTM 2012-39599-C03, CGL2016-80445-R, and CTM2016-75129-C3-1-R, and the Uruguayan ANCAP-UDELAR Nº 21 project; and conducted in the framework of “The Drifters” research group of the Royal Holloway University of London (RHUL)., Peer reviewed
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Evolution and morphology of a contourite depositional system based on new evidence from 3D-seismic data offshore Madagascar (Paleogene, Morondava Basin)

  • Hernández-Molina, F. J.
  • Tari, Gabor
  • Scarselli, Nicola
  • Raharisolofo, Hoby
  • Rahajarivelo, Sophie F.
  • Kirby, Adam
  • de Weger, Wouter
  • Llave, Estefanía
  • Mergnat, Adrien
Numerous bottom current-controlled depositional and erosional features, which together form Contourite Depositional Systems (CDS), have been recognized in deep-water settings over the past decade. Most of these systems are described based on two-dimensional (2D) seismic data, whereas only a few CDS have been characterised from high-resolution 3D data. Here we document a newly identified CDS that formed during the Paleocene within the Morondava Basin, offshore west Madagascar, through analysis of a depth-migrated 3D seismic survey, enhanced by the implementation of seismic attributes. Three seismic units (SU) mark the main evolutionary stages of the CDS: (a) the onset (SU1), (b) drift growth (SU2), and (c) burial (SU3) stages. The growth stage documents lateral upslope migration of a mounded drift and its associated moat. The increasing, long-term influence of bottom currents along the foot of the slope occurred simultaneously with plate tectonic, climatic and oceanographic changes. Evidence amassed from the CDS highly erosive bounding discontinuities, internal discontinuities, and moat architecture all indicate the intermittent behaviour of the currents over shorter time frames during its formation. Drift deposits form under the influence of weaker currents, while discontinuities appear to record the most vigorous currents, producing the large-scale morphology of the system., This research was conducted under the framework of ‘The Drifters Research Group ’ at Royal Holloway University of London (UK). It is related to projects CTM 2012-39599-C03, CGL2016-80445-R and CTM2016-75129-C3-1-R., Peer reviewed
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Deep-water circulation in the northeast Atlantic during the mid- and Late Cretaceous

  • Liu, Shan
  • Hernández-Molina, F. J.
  • Rodrigues, Sara
  • Van Rooij, David
The Cretaceous ocean was significantly different from its modern counterpart due to its ice-free condition. Deep waters were primarily sourced by evaporation at the ocean surface, although their circulation pattern and bottom-current dynamics have been largely unknown. Here we present a study of deeply buried contourite drifts in the southern proto-Bay of Biscay to unravel the circulation pattern of the mid- and Late Cretaceous deep waters across the northeast Atlantic. The generation of plastered drifts (120 Ma to 100-90 Ma) and a mounded drift (100-90 Ma to 65 Ma) suggests that a significant change in deep-water source regions from the Tethys to the high-latitude region occurred at ca. 100-90 Ma. These contourite drifts were buried after ca. 65 Ma when the Cretaceous ocean circulation transitioned to the Cenozoic style in the northeast Atlantic. Tectonic configurations of the Pyrenean and the Equatorial Atlantic gateways were moreover tied to significant changes in northeast Atlantic deep-water circulation at ca. 100-90 and ca. 65 Ma. Northeastern Spain and France might be potential sites for the detection of Late Cretaceous contourite outcrops. These outcrops could have fundamental implications for the sedimentary facies and sequence model of contourites as well as shed light on the paleoceanography and paleoclimate of Cretaceous Earth, This study was supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (42206044) and China Postdoctoral Science Foundation (2021M703668). This study was conducted in collaboration with “The Drifters” Research Group at Royal Holloway University of London (UK) and is related to projects CTM 2012-39599-C03, CGL2016-80445-R, and CTM2016-75129-C3-1-R (REN2001-1734 C03-01/M)., Peer reviewed