Skip to main content

INTERACCIONES ENTRE MICROORGANISMOS DEL SUELO Y PROCESOS ECOLOGICOS: ANTICIPANDO LOS IMPACTOS DEL CAMBIO GLOBAL

CGL2017-84515-R

•
Funding agency name Agencia Estatal de Investigación
Funding agency acronym AEI
Program Programa Estatal de I+D+i Orientado a los Retos de la Sociedad
Call Proyectos I+D+i Retos de Investigación
Call year 2017
State Plan 2017-2020 Plan Estatal de Investigación Científica y Técnica y de Innovación
Beneficiary centre AGENCIA ESTATAL CONSEJO SUPERIOR DE INVESTIGACIONES CIENTIFICAS (CSIC)

Resultados relacionados

Resultados totales (Incluyendo duplicados): 12
Encontrada(s) 1 página(s)

DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Facilitation mediates species presence beyond their environmental optimum

  • O'Brien, Michael J.
  • Tavares de Menezes,Luis Fernando
  • Bråthen,Kari Anne
  • Losapio, Gianalberto
  • Pugnaire, Francisco I.
Species distributions are driven by abiotic conditions that filter species with specific traits and physiological tolerances and match them with their suitable environment. Plant–plant interactions can constrict (through competition) or loosen (through facilitation) the strength of these environmental filters, which in turn inhibit or enhance establishment and recruitment of plant species at a finer spatial scale. Although competition is often the focus of community assembly processes that further impede the entry of plant species into a site, facilitation is also important for potentially loosening environmental filters (especially climatic filters such as temperature and precipitation), ultimately enhancing species occurrence beyond their physiological optimum. We used multiple data sets from the arid site of Rambla del Saltador Valley to test the hypothesis that facilitation by a nurse-plant promotes the presence of herbaceous, beneficiary species beyond their environmental optimum relative to open sites. Furthermore, we propose that the median elevation and community composition of herbaceous species expands with the age of the nurse-plant, and we tested this hypothesis by examining 105 beneficiary species under 50 nurse-plant shrubs varying in age from 6 to 48 years old. We found nurse-plants both facilitate herbaceous species occurrence beyond their median elevation and support more diverse and a distinctly different composition of species in contrast to open sites. Specifically, herbaceous species that originate from a median elevation more than 600 to 700 m above the site only existed beneath nurse-plants, and below this median elevation, half the species only occurred below the nurse-plant. Moreover, the richness and elevation provenance of the herbaceous species increased with increasing nurse-plant age. Our results highlight the importance of facilitation for alleviating physiological strain (in support of the strain hypothesis) and mediating regional species distributions, which has implications for understanding species movements and community assembly at larger-scales under hotter and drier climates., This work was funded by the Spanish Research Agency (AEI) (CGL2017-84515-R). MOB was supported by the Swiss National Science Foundation through an Advanced Postdoc Mobility Fellowship (P300PA_167758). This work contributes to the University of Zurich Research Priority Program on Global Change and Biodiversity (URPP-GCB)., Peer reviewed
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Research data Set de datos (Dataset)

Photodegradation Data [Dataset]

  • Prado López, Miguel
  • Moya-Laraño, Jordi
  • Pugnaire, Francisco I.
This study was supported by the Office of Secretary of Public Education of Mexico through the program Further Education Programme for Teachers (UNICACH-110). Further support was provided by the Spanish Research Agency (grant CGL2017-84515-R to FIP and grant CGL2015-66192-R to JML). We thank the Cabo de Gata-Níjar Nature Park for support during field work (permit: 2016-101-657)., UV radiation UV radiation exposition with two levels: UV+ and UV- Biocides Exposition of biocides with two levels: biocides+ and biocides- Species Identity Leaf litter species identity with three levels: S. tenacissima, C. humilis and R. sphaerocarpa Mixtures Plant diversity treatments with four levels (three monospecific plus the mixture) Isopods Isopod presence with two levels: Isopods+ and Isopods- Mortality Total number of dead isopods after 80 days of experiment w_inic Litter initial dry weight (g) w_uv Litter mass after 200 days of UV exposition during the first stage of the experiment; dry weight (g) w_iso Litter mass after 80 days of exposition to isopods during second stage of the experiment; dry weight (g), Peer reviewed
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Research data Set de datos (Dataset)

Decomposition fertility islands [dataset]

  • Prado López, Miguel
  • Pugnaire, Francisco I.
  • Moya-Laraño, Jordi
Litter decomposition in field experiment. A total of 280 mesocosms were settled under and away of 20 individuals of Z. lotus. The litter boxes thus contained either one single species of litter (20 litter boxes for each species and position treatment), 2-sp mixtures (20 litter boxes for each 2-species combination and position treatment) or 3-sp mixtures (20 litter boxes with the 3-species mixture and position treatment)., This study was supported by the Office of Secretary of Public Education of Mexico though the program Further Education Programme for Teachers (UNICACH-110). Further support was provided by the Spanish Research Agency (grant CGL2017-84515-R to FIP and grant CGL2015-66192-R to JML). We thank the Cabo de Gata-Níjar Nature Park for support during field work (permit: 2016-101-657)., Date Date of collection (1 - 07/13/2017, 2 - 01/13/2018, 3 -08/30/2018) Plant Plant (Ziziphus lotus fertility island) ID utmx Geographic Longitude for each plant utmy Geographic Latitude for each plant Box Mesocosm ID Island Location of the mesocosm (Away or Under shrub) Mixtures Litter plant diversity (species richness 1, 2, 3) Species Identity of the litter plant species with three levels: S. tenacissima, C. humilis and R. sphaerocarpa w_inic Litter initial dry mass (g) w_end Litter dry mass (g) after 184, 367 and 597 days in the field, Peer reviewed
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Soil micro‐organisms and competitive ability of a tussock grass species in a dry ecosystem

  • Lozano, Yudi M.
  • Hortal, Sara
  • Armas, Cristina
  • Pugnaire, Francisco I.
1. Drylands are among the most threatened ecosystems in the world because of the effects of global change and because they are not particularly resilient. Regeneration after disturbance is quite slow and secondary succession can be delayed to the point of nearly stop. This is exacerbated when the community is strongly dominated by a single species able to quickly respond after disturbance. One example of such monospecific dominance is the colonization of abandoned fields in SE Spain by an early successional and native tussock grass, Lygeum spartum, that seems to halt succession. 2. Here we tested the competitive ability of Lygeum against Salsola oppositifolia, a shrub species that can be found interspersed with Lygeum in mid‐successional stages, and assessed how plant–soil interactions mediate the outcome of plant– plant competition. To do so, we sowed seeds and grew plants of Lygeum and Salsola in either intra‐ or interspecific competition under controlled conditions using sterile field soils inoculated with either live (i.e., with micro‐organisms) or sterile soil extracts from the understories of either Lygeum or Salsola. Soil nutrient content, seed germination rate, and shoot mass growth were determined after 5 months, and soil bacterial communities were characterized by sequencing. 3. Lygeum soil micro‐organisms and soil properties, such as the high content of N and organic matter, enhanced seed germination rate of Lygeum individuals. By contrast, Salsola adults outperformed Lygeum when growing in interspecific competition. 4. Synthesis. The enhanced competitive ability of Lygeum, which was mediated by soil micro‐organisms, may lead to complete dominance of Lygeum in the plant community right after abandonment of agricultural fields. However, when the plant community is already developed, Lygeum would be unable to enforce such dominance. We conclude that positive plant–soil feedbacks combined with certain plant traits such as clonal growth support the strong resilience of Lygeum and allow for its dominance in extreme habitats., AEI, Grant/Award Number: CGL2017‐84515‐R; Junta de Andalucía Regional Government, Grant/Award Number: P09‐RNM‐4821, Peer reviewed
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Climate change effects on plant-soil feedbacks and consequences for biodiversity and functioning of terrestrial ecosystems

  • Pugnaire, Francisco I.
  • Morillo, José A.
  • Peñuelas, Josep
  • Reich, Peter B.
  • Bardgett, Richard D.
  • Gaxiola, Aurora
  • Wardle, David A.
  • Putten, Wim H. van der
Plant-soil feedbacks (PSFs) are interactions among plants, soil organisms, and abiotic soil conditions that influence plant performance, plant species diversity, and community structure, ultimately driving ecosystem processes. We review how climate change will alter PSFs and their potential consequences for ecosystem functioning. Climate change influences PSFs through the performance of interacting species and altered community composition resulting from changes in species distributions. Climate change thus affects plant inputs into the soil subsystem via litter and rhizodeposits and alters the composition of the living plant roots with which mutualistic symbionts, decomposers, and their natural enemies interact. Many of these plant-soil interactions are species-specific and are greatly affected by temperature, moisture, and other climate-related factors. We make a number of predictions concerning climate change effects on PSFs and consequences for vegetation-soil-climate feedbacks while acknowledging that they may be context-dependent, spatially heterogeneous, and temporally variable., F.I.P. was supported by the Spanish Research Agency (grant CGL2017-84515-R). J.P.’s research was funded by the European Research Council Synergy grant (ERC-SyG-2013-610028, IMBALANCE-P). A.G. was supported by FONDECYT-Chile 1160138 and CONICYT AFB 17008. P.B.R.’s research was supported by the National Science Foundation (NSF) grants DEB-1831944 and DEB-1753859
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Functional responses of four Sahelian tree species to resource availability

  • Dieme, Joseph Saturnin
  • Armas, Cristina
  • Rusch, Graciela M.
  • Pugnaire, Francisco I.
Plants experience a fluctuating environment in time and space that affects resource supply. As human impacts on the environment directly and indirectly alter resource availability, it is important to address plant responses to changing resources to be able to anticipate impacts of these changes on plant communities. We analyzed plant traits to assess responses to resource limitation in four Sahelian tree species of wide ecological and socio-economic importance. We used species already adapted to harsh conditions (high temperatures, low rainfall) to anticipate how climate change could affect their growth patterns and, indirectly, their spatial distribution and the services they provide. Seedlings grew under two levels of water and nutrient additions in a factorial design. Our results showed differences among species, watering regimes, and nutrient supply in three key functional traits related to the plant's resource-use strategy, relative growth rate (RGR), root-to-shoot ratio (R/S), and specific leaf area (SLA). On average, RGR was responsive to the amount of water and nutrients, with species with high RGR showing the largest response to resource supply. RGR in the species with a conservative resource-use strategy (evergreen leaves, lowest RGR) remained unchanged with different levels of water and nutrients. Overall, large RGR was supported by large SLA. All species allocated more biomass to roots than to shoots, particularly under low resource supply, reflecting adaptive strategies to keep RGR leveled to resource supply. Not all species showed similar plasticity in their functional traits responses; however, Acacia tortilis and Faidherbia albida showed the greatest plasticity, which may explain their large geographical distribution range in Africa. Our data suggest that the different Sahelian species will respond differently to future environmental changes, likely affecting their geographical distribution, the structure of plant communities, and the services they provide., This work was funded by the FUNCITREE Project within the EU 7th Framework Programme (grant KBBE-2272657FP). Additional funds were provided by AEI-MINECO (grants CGL2014-59010-R and CGL2017-84515-R). JSD received a PhD fellowship from the Spanish Agency of International Cooperation for Development (AECID). CA was supported by a postdoctoral contract from the FUNCITREE Project and currently holds a “Ramón y Cajal” Fellowship (RYC-2012-12277) from the Spanish Government.
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Plant life history stage and nurse age change the development of ecological networks in an arid ecosystem

  • Losapio, Gianalberto
  • Pugnaire, Francisco I.
  • O'Brien, Michael J.
  • Schöb, Christian
Understanding how ecological networks are organised over the course of an organism's lifetime is crucial for predicting the dynamics of interacting populations and communities across temporal scales. However, most studies so far considered only one life history stage at a time, such as adult, when studying networks of interacting species. Therefore, knowledge about how multiple life history stages affect the development and stability of plant–plant association networks is lacking. We measured the understory adult plant community and the soil seed bank across a plant age gradient of the nurse shrub Retama sphaerocarpa in an arid ecosystem in Spain. Using a multilayer network approach, we built adult understory–nurse and seed bank–nurse networks and analysed how network nestedness, species’ role, and species specificity varied between them and with nurse plant age. We found that seed bank and adult understory networks changed depending on nurse plant age in two different ways. With increasing nurse plant age, adult understory networks became significantly more nested than seed bank networks. The nested architecture of seed bank networks was therefore a poor predictor of adult understory network nestedness. The contribution and specificity of species to network nestedness increased with increasing nurse plant age more in the adult understory than in seed bank networks, despite high species turnover. Our data show that life history and ontogeny affect the development of plant–plant association networks. Niche construction and environmental filtering along nurse ontogeny seem pivotal mechanisms structuring adult understory networks while the assembly of seed bank networks seems rather stochastic. We highlight the importance of mature plant communities for maintaining rare species populations and supporting the stability of ecological communities through time., This study was supported by the Swiss National Science Foundation grants awarded to CS (PZ00P3_148261, PP00P3_170645). GL was supported by the ETH – Biocommunication group. FIP was supported by MICINN (grant CGL2017-84515-R). MJOB was supported by the Swiss National Science Foundation through an Advanced Postdoc Mobility Fellowship (P300PA_167758)., Peer reviewed
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

The balance of canopy and soil effects determines intraspecific differences in foundation species’ effects on associated plants

  • Pistón Caballero, Nuria
  • Michalet, Richard
  • Schöb, Christian
  • Macek, Petr
  • Armas, Cristina
  • Pugnaire, Francisco I.
The impact of plant–plant interactions on species diversity patterns has been broadly addressed in stressful environments, such as alpine ecosystems, where foundation species promote species richness by creating habitat for other species. However, foundation species with contrasting phenotypes might modify the microhabitat differently, which would alter the subordinate community composition, and coincide with distinct feedback effects of those subordinate species on the foundation species. However, the precise interaction mechanisms that facilitate species are not fully understood, especially the relative contribution of above- and below-ground compartments of foundation species to subordinate species and the potential feedbacks they receive. We explored whether two contrasted canopy phenotypes (tight and loose) of the shrub Cytisus galianoi differed in their effects on the microhabitat and on subordinate plant community composition in a dry subalpine system. We also experimentally distinguished the relative contribution of above- (canopy) and below-ground (soil) effects of C. galianoi on the most frequent subordinate species, Festuca indigesta, as well as the reciprocal effects of F. indigesta on C. galianoi. We performed observational and manipulative experiments to assess the influence of phenotypic differences of the shrub on understorey microhabitat and subordinate plant community composition. Reciprocal effects were assessed by removing either F. indigesta from the understorey of the two shrub phenotypes or the C. galianoi canopy from the immediate vicinity of F. indigesta. The two C. galianoi phenotypes differed in mean values of functional traits (like stem density or plant height), modified their understorey microhabitats differently and hosted distinct subordinate communities. Loose phenotypes had more positive effects on community composition and diversity than tight phenotypes. In addition, tight phenotypes simultaneously showed both more positive above-ground and more negative below-ground effects on F. indigesta than loose phenotypes. There were no significant feedback effects of F. indigesta on C. galianoi. The two phenotypes of the foundation species C. galianoi showed contrasting effects on the subordinate plant community: Compared to the tight phenotype, the loose phenotype had higher associated species diversity and reduced reciprocal interaction intensities above- and below-ground with the subordinate species F. indigesta. This highlights the impact of phenotypic variation for plant interactions and community-level diversity. A plain language summary is available for this article., This work was funded by the Organismo Autónomo Parques Nacionales (Grant Nos. 0002/9 and 1578/2015) and AEI- MINECO (CGL2014-59010-R and CGL2017-84515-R). N.P. was supported by a JAEPredoc CSIC and a Brazilian CAPES PVE Grant Number 88881.068053/2014; C.S. by the Swiss National Science Foundation (PZ00P3_148261, PP00P3_170645); P.M. by LINCGlobal, GACR 17-20839S and by a CzechPolar Grant Number MSMT LM2015083; and C.A. by a Spanish Government “Ramón y Cajal” contract (RYC-2012-12277)., Peer reviewed
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Azorella Cushion Plants and Aridity are Important Drivers of Soil Microbial Communities in Andean Ecosystems

  • Rodríguez-Echeverría, Susana
  • Delgado-Baquerizo, Manuel
  • Morillo, José A.
  • Gaxiola, Aurora
  • Manzano, Marlene
  • Marquet, Pablo A.
  • González, Leticia
  • Cavieres, Lohengrin A.
  • Pugnaire, Francisco I.
  • Armas, Cristina
15 páginas.- 4 figuras.- 2 tablas.- 96 referencias.- Supplementary information: The online version contains supplementary material available at (https://doi.org/10.1007/s10021-021- 00603-1), Cushion plants are specialized keystone species of alpine environments that can have a positive effect on ecosystem structure and function. However, we know relatively little about how cushion plants regulate the diversity and composition of soil microbial communities, major drivers of soil processes and ecosystem functioning. Identifying what factors drive the diversity and composition of soil microbial communities in high-elevation ecosystems is also fundamental to predict how global changes will affect their conservation and the services and functions they provide. Thus, we sampled four sites along the southern Andes following the vegetation belt of Azorella cushion species. The field sites spread along a latitudinal gradient and had contrasting levels of aridity, UV-B radiation, mean temperature and soil properties. Overall, Azorella, as well as aridity and UV-B radiation, were the major drivers of the distribution, composition and diversity of soil microbial communities in the studied ecosystems of the Chilean Andes. UV-B radiation affected particularly soil fungi, while soil properties such as pH, total C and N content, essential predictors of microbial diversity globally, had a much lower effect on the composition of soil microbial communities. Understanding the factors driving the structure and composition of microbial communities, particularly the role of cushion plants and the feedbacks between plant, climate and soil is of uttermost importance for the preservation of the functionality of high-elevation ecosystems threatened by climate change. © 2021, The Author(s), under exclusive licence to Springer Science+Business Media, LLC part of Springer Nature., S.R-E. was supported by a Research Grant from the Portuguese Foundation for Science and Technology–FCT (IF/00462/2013) and by a scholarship from the program “Bolsas Iberoamericanas—Santander Universidades” from Banco Santander-Totta. C.A. was supported by the Spanish Government under a Ramón y Cajal contract (RYC-2012-12277) and work in Chile was funded by the LincGlobal program. Further support was provided by the Spanish AEI (grants CGL2014-59010-R to C.A. and F.I.P. and CGL2017-84515-R to F.I.P). M.D-B. was supported by a Ramón y Cajal grant from the Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation (RYC2018-025483-I). A.G., L.A.C. and P.A.M acknowledge support from CONICYT-Associative Research Program AIC-37 and AFB170008 from Instituto de Ecología y Biodiversidad. A.G. and L.A.C were also supported by Fondecyt 1110063 and Fondecyt 1171005, respectively. We also thank Dr. Luis Javier Martinez and Belén Martínez García for the implementation of protocols for molecular microbial analysis at GENYO (Granada, Spain)., Peer reviewed
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Network motifs involving both competition and facilitation predict biodiversity in alpine plant communities

  • Losapio, Gianalberto
  • Schöb, Christian
  • Staniczenko, Phillip P. A.
  • Carrara, Francesco
  • Palamara, Gian Marco
  • De Moraes, Consuelo M.
  • Mescher, Mark C.
  • Brooker, Rob W.
  • Butterfield, Bradley J.
  • Callaway, Ragan M.
  • Cavieres, Lohengrin A.
  • Kikvidze, Zaal
  • Lortie, Christopher J.
  • Michalet, Richard
  • Pugnaire, Francisco I.
  • Bascompte, Jordi
Biological diversity depends on multiple, cooccurring ecological interactions. However, most studies focus on one interaction type at a time, leaving community ecologists unsure of how positive and negative associations among species combine to influence biodiversity patterns. Using surveys of plant populations in alpine communities worldwide, we explore patterns of positive and negative associations among triads of species (modules) and their relationship to local biodiversity. Three modules, each incorporating both positive and negative associations, were overrepresented, thus acting as "network motifs." Furthermore, the overrepresentation of these network motifs is positively linked to species diversity globally. A theoretical model illustrates that these network motifs, based on competition between facilitated species or facilitation between inferior competitors, increase local persistence. Our findings suggest that the interplay of competition and facilitation is crucial for maintaining biodiversity., G.L. was supported by the ETH Biocommunication group and by the Swiss National Science Foundation (Grant P2ZHP3_187938). C.S. and J.B. were supported by the Swiss National Science Foundation (Grant PPOOP3_170645, Grant 31003A_169671). R.W.B. was supported by the Rural and Environment Science and Analytical Services Division of the Scottish Government through the Strategic Research Programme 2016–2021. R.M.C. acknowledges support from the NSF Established Program to Stimulate Competitive Research Cooperative Agreement (Grant OIA-1757351). Z.K. is grateful to the Ilia State University Professor Research Programme. F.I.P. was supported by the Spanish Research Agency (Grant CGL2017-84515-R)., Peer reviewed
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Species identity improves soil respiration predictions in a semiarid scrubland

  • Estruch, Carme
  • Macek, Petr
  • Armas, Cristina
  • Pistón, Nuria
  • Pugnaire, Francisco I.
Soil respiration accounts for ca. three quarters of total ecosystem respiration and is sensitive to temperature and moisture. Plants can influence soil CO2 emissions through specific effects on soil humidity, soil temperature and soil microbial communities. These plant-soil effects mostly come via litter production and root exudates, enhancing soil autotrophic and heterotrophic respiration. We explored how plant species affected soil CO2 emissions in an arid environment. We altered soil temperature in bare soil and under the canopy of four plant species differing in functional type, and measured monthly fluxes to establish seasonal patterns of CO2 release along a 20-month period. We found that soil temperature explained 69% of the annual soil respiration (SR) variance, while soil water content explained 71% of SR variance. When we included plant species identity in the model, soil temperature and soil water content explained 76% and 81% of SR variance, respectively, exemplifying how plant species modulate SR responses as a function of temperature and water availability. Our results demonstrate that plant species influence soil carbon balance and emphasize that species identity matters in dry ecosystems. SR dynamics in dry ecosystems can be accurately modelled with soil water and temperature as predictors, but models are more efficient if plant species identity is considered., This work was funded by MINECO (grants CGL2014-59010-R and CGL2017-84515-R). CE was recipient of a FPI fellowship (BES2011-044322); PM was supported by MSMT LM 2015078; CA was recipient of a “Ramón y Cajal” contract (RYC-2012-12277); NP was supported by a JAE-Predoc CSIC grant and, currently, by a Brazilian PNPD/CAPES fellowship., Peer reviewed
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Climate change effects on plant-soil feedbacks and consequences for biodiversity and functioning of terrestrial ecosystems

  • Pugnaire, Francisco I.|||0000-0002-1227-6827
  • Morillo, José A.
  • Peñuelas, Josep|||0000-0002-7215-0150
  • Reich, Peter|||0000-0003-4424-662X
  • Bardgett, Richard D.
  • Gaxiola, Aurora
  • Wardle, David A.
  • van der Putten, Wim H.|||0000-0002-9341-4442
Plant-soil feedbacks (PSFs) are interactions among plants, soil organisms, and abiotic soil conditions that influence plant performance, plant species diversity, and community structure, ultimately driving ecosystem processes. We review how climate change will alter PSFs and their potential consequences for ecosystem functioning. Climate change influences PSFs through the performance of interacting species and altered community composition resulting from changes in species distributions. Climate change thus affects plant inputs into the soil subsystem via litter and rhizodeposits and alters the composition of the living plant roots with which mutualistic symbionts, decomposers, and their natural enemies interact. Many of these plant-soil interactions are species-specific and are greatly affected by temperature, moisture, and other climate-related factors. We make a number of predictions concerning climate change effects on PSFs and consequences for vegetation-soil-climate feedbacks while acknowledging that they may be context-dependent, spatially heterogeneous, and temporally variable.