Skip to main content

Resultados relacionados

Resultados totales (Incluyendo duplicados): 6
Encontrada(s) 1 página(s)

Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Updated recommendations, An assessment of NICE clinical guidelines

  • Martínez García, Laura|||0000-0003-0126-8706
  • McFarlane, Emma
  • Barnes, Steven
  • Sanabria, Andreu Juliana
  • Alonso-Coello, Pablo|||0000-0002-8001-8504
  • Alderson, Philip
Background: Updating is important to ensure clinical guideline (CG) recommendations remain valid. However, little research has been undertaken in this field. We assessed CGs produced by the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) to identify and describe updated recommendations and to investigate potential factors associated with updating. Also, we evaluated the reporting and presentation of recommendation changes.Methods: We performed a descriptive analysis of original and updated CGs and recommendations, and an assessment of presentation formats and methods for recording information. We conducted a case-control study, defining cases as original recommendations that were updated ('new-replaced' recommendations), and controls as original recommendations that were considered to remain valid ('not changed' recommendations). We performed a comparison of main characteristics between cases and controls, and we planned a multiple regression analysis to identify potential predictive factors for updating.Results: We included nine updated CGs (1,306 recommendations) and their corresponding original versions (1,106 recommendations). Updated CGs included 812 (62%) recommendations 'not reviewed', 368 (28.1%) 'new' recommendations, 104 (7.9%) 'amended' recommendations, and 25 (1.9%) recommendations reviewed but unchanged. The presentation formats used to indicate the changes in recommendations varied widely across CGs. Changes in 'amended', 'deleted', and 'new-replaced' recommendations (n = 296) were reported infrequently, mostly in appendices. These changes were recorded in 167 (56.4%) recommendations; and were explained in 81 (27.4%) recommendations. We retrieved a total of 7.1% (n = 78) case recommendations ('new-replaced') and 2.4% (n = 27) control recommendations ('not changed') in original CGs. The updates were mainly from 'Fertility CG', about 'gynaecology, pregnancy and birth' topic, and 'treatment' or 'prevention' purposes. We did not perform the multiple regression analysis as originally planned due to the small sample of recommendations retrieved.Conclusion: Our study is the first to describe and assess updated CGs and recommendations from a national guideline program. Our results highlight the pressing need to standardise the reporting and presentation of updated recommendations and the research gap about the optimal way to present updates to guideline users. Furthermore, there is a need to investigate updating predictive factors. © 2014 Martínez García et al.; licensee BioMed Central Ltd.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publication Reseña (Review)

Guidance for updating clinical practice guidelines, A systematic review of methodological handbooks

  • Vernooij, Robin W. M.|||0000-0001-5734-4566
  • Sanabria, Andrea Juliana
  • Solà Arnau, Ivan|||0000-0003-0078-3706
  • Alonso-Coello, Pablo|||0000-0002-8001-8504
  • Martínez García, Laura|||0000-0003-0126-8706
Background: Updating clinical practice guidelines (CPGs) is a crucial process for maintaining the validity of recommendations. Methodological handbooks should provide guidance on both developing and updating CPGs. However, little is known about the updating guidance provided by these handbooks.Methods: We conducted a systematic review to identify and describe the updating guidance provided by CPG methodological handbooks and included handbooks that provide updating guidance for CPGs. We searched in the Guidelines International Network library, US National Guidelines Clearinghouse and MEDLINE (PubMed) from 1966 to September 2013. Two authors independently selected the handbooks and extracted the data. We used descriptive statistics to analyze the extracted data and conducted a narrative synthesis.Results: We included 35 handbooks. Most handbooks (97.1%) focus mainly on developing CPGs, including variable degrees of information about updating. Guidance on identifying new evidence and the methodology of assessing the need for an update is described in 11 (31.4%) and eight handbooks (22.8%), respectively. The period of time between two updates is described in 25 handbooks (71.4%), two to three years being the most frequent (40.0%). The majority of handbooks do not provide guidance for the literature search, evidence selection, assessment, synthesis, and external review of the updating process.Conclusions: Guidance for updating CPGs is poorly described in methodological handbooks. This guidance should be more rigorous and explicit. This could lead to a more optimal updating process, and, ultimately to valid trustworthy guidelines. © 2014 Vernooij et al.; licensee BioMed Central Ltd.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

A methodological survey of the analysis, reporting and interpretation of Absolute Risk ReductiOn in systematic revieWs (ARROW), A study protocol

  • Alonso-Coello, Pablo|||0000-0002-8001-8504
  • Carrasco-Labra, Alonso|||0000-0003-3546-3526
  • Brignardello-Petersen, Romina|||0000-0002-6010-9900
  • Neumann, Ignacio|||0000-0001-8406-6880
  • Akl, Elie A.|||0000-0002-3444-8618
  • Sun, Xin
  • Johnston, Bradley C.|||0000-0001-8872-8626
  • Briel, Matthias|||0000-0002-2070-5230
  • Busse, Jason|||0000-0002-0178-8712
  • Glujovsky, Demian|||0000-0002-0586-9341
  • Granados, Carlos E.|||0000-0002-1663-4273
  • Iorio, Alfonso|||0000-0002-3331-8766
  • Irfan, Affan B.
  • Martínez García, Laura|||0000-0003-0126-8706
  • Mustafa, Reem|||0000-0002-2091-0875
  • Ramirez-Morera, Anggie
  • Solà Arnau, Ivan|||0000-0003-0078-3706
  • Tikkinen, Kari A. O.
  • Ebrahim, Shanil
  • Vandvik, Per Olav|||0000-0001-8958-2710
  • Zhang, Yuqing
  • Selva, Anna|||0000-0002-2754-3158
  • Sanabria, Andrea Juliana
  • Zazueta, Oscar E.|||0000-0001-5374-3906
  • Vernooij, Robin W. M.|||0000-0001-5734-4566
  • Schünemann, Holger J.
  • Guyatt, Gordon|||0000-0003-2352-5718
Background: Clinicians, providers and guideline panels use absolute effects to weigh the advantages and downsides of treatment alternatives. Relative measures have the potential to mislead readers. However, little is known about the reporting of absolute measures in systematic reviews. The objectives of our study are to determine the proportion of systematic reviews that report absolute measures of effect for the most important outcomes, and ascertain how they are analyzed, reported and interpreted. Methods/design: We will conduct a methodological survey of systematic reviews published in 2010. We will conduct a 1:1 stratified random sampling of Cochrane vs. non-Cochrane systematic reviews. We will calculate the proportion of systematic reviews reporting at least one absolute estimate of effect for the most patient-important outcome for the comparison of interest. We will conduct multivariable logistic regression analyses with the reporting of an absolute estimate of effect as the dependent variable and pre-specified study characteristics as the independent variables. For systematic reviews reporting an absolute estimate of effect, we will document the methods used for the analysis, reporting and interpretation of the absolute estimate. Discussion: Our methodological survey will inform current practices regarding reporting of absolute estimates in systematic reviews. Our findings may influence recommendations on reporting, conduct and interpretation of absolute estimates. Our results are likely to be of interest to systematic review authors, funding agencies, clinicians, guideline developers and journal editors.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Strategies to assess the validity of recommendations, A study protocol

  • Martínez García, Laura|||0000-0003-0126-8706
  • Sanabria, Andrea Juliana
  • Araya, Ignacio
  • Lawson, Jennifer
  • Haynes, R.Brian
  • Rigau, David|||0000-0003-0828-4872
  • Solà Arnau, Ivan|||0000-0003-0078-3706
  • Díaz del Campo, Petra
  • Estrada Sabadell, M. Dolors
  • Etxeandia-Ikobaltzeta, Itziar|||0000-0001-6606-649X
  • García Álvarez, Elvira
  • Gracia, Javier
  • Kotzeva, Anna
  • Louro González, Arturo|||0000-0002-8334-9210
  • Salcedo-Fernandez, Flavia
  • Trujillo-Martín, Maria Mar
  • Alonso-Coello, Pablo|||0000-0002-8001-8504
Background: Clinical practice guidelines (CPGs) become quickly outdated and require a periodic reassessment of evidence research to maintain their validity. However, there is little research about this topic. Our project will provide evidence for some of the most pressing questions in this field: 1) what is the average time for recommendations to become out of date?; 2) what is the comparative performance of two restricted search strategies to evaluate the need to update recommendations?; and 3) what is the feasibility of a more regular monitoring and updating strategy compared to usual practice?. In this protocol we will focus on questions one and two.Methods: The CPG Development Programme of the Spanish Ministry of Health developed 14 CPGs between 2008 and 2009. We will stratify guidelines by topic and by publication year, and include one CPG by strata.We will develop a strategy to assess the validity of CPG recommendations, which includes a baseline survey of clinical experts, an update of the original exhaustive literature searches, the identification of key references (reference that trigger a potential recommendation update), and the assessment of the potential changes in each recommendation.We will run two alternative search strategies to efficiently identify important new evidence: 1) PLUS search based in McMaster Premium LiteratUre Service (PLUS) database; and 2) a Restrictive Search (ReSe) based on the least number of MeSH terms and free text words needed to locate all the references of each original recommendation.We will perform a survival analysis of recommendations using the Kaplan-Meier method and we will use the log-rank test to analyse differences between survival curves according to the topic, the purpose, the strength of recommendations and the turnover. We will retrieve key references from the exhaustive search and evaluate their presence in the PLUS and ReSe search results.Discussion: Our project, using a highly structured and transparent methodology, will provide guidance of when recommendations are likely to be at risk of being out of date. We will also assess two novel restrictive search strategies which could reduce the workload without compromising rigour when CPGs developers check for the need of updating. © 2013 Martínez García et al.; licensee BioMed Central Ltd.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Efficiency of pragmatic search strategies to update clinical guidelines recommendations

  • Martínez García, Laura|||0000-0003-0126-8706
  • Sanabria, Andrea Juliana
  • Araya, Ignaci
  • Lawson, J.
  • Solà Arnau, Ivan|||0000-0003-0078-3706
  • Vernooij, Robin W. M.|||0000-0001-5734-4566
  • López, D.
  • García Álvarez, Elvira
  • Trujillo-Martín, Mar
  • Etxeandia-Ikobaltzeta, Itziar|||0000-0001-6606-649X
  • Kotzeva, Anna
  • Rigau, David|||0000-0003-0828-4872
  • Louro González, Arturo|||0000-0002-8334-9210
  • Barajas Nava, Leticia Andrea|||0000-0002-3040-7560
  • Díaz del Campo, Petra
  • Estrada Sabadell, M. Dolors
  • Gracia, J.
  • Salcedo-Fernandez, Flavia
  • Haynes, R. Brian
  • Alonso-Coello, Pablo|||0000-0002-8001-8504
  • Álvarez Ariza, M.
  • Argente Oliver, J.
  • Armario García, P.
  • Arrieta Antón, Enrique
  • Balaguer Santamaría, Albert|||0000-0002-5222-8635
  • Borque Fernando, A.
  • Buñuel Álvarez, J.C.
  • Cervera Álvarez, A.
  • Heras Liñero, María Elena de las
  • Dopico, L.
  • Eddy Ives, L.S.
  • Escó Barón, R.
  • Ferreira González, I.
  • Ferrer, F.
  • Gil Sanz, M.J.
  • Lago Deibe, F.I.
  • Martí Canales, J.C.
  • Martinez Rubio, Antoni|||0000-0002-2070-4617
  • Martos Moreno, G.A.
  • Mejuto Marti, T.
  • Morales Ortiz, Ana M.|||0000-0002-9211-2098
  • Rioja Sanz, L.A.
  • Rioja Zuazu, J.
  • Rodríguez González, A.
  • Rodríguez-Arias Palomo, J.L.
  • Sáenz Cusí, A.
Background: A major challenge in updating clinical guidelines is to efficiently identify new, relevant evidence. We evaluated the efficiency and feasibility of two new approaches: the development of restrictive search strategies using PubMed Clinical Queries for MEDLINE and the use of the PLUS (McMaster Premium Literature Service) database. Methods: We evaluated a random sample of recommendations from a national guideline development program and identified the references that would potentially trigger an update (key references) using an exhaustive approach. We designed restrictive search strategies using the minimum number of Medical Subject Headings (MeSH) terms and text words required from the original exhaustive search strategies and applying broad and narrow filters. We developed PLUS search strategies, matching Medical Subject Headings (MeSH) and Systematized Nomenclature of Medicine (SNOMED) terms with guideline topics. We compared the number of key references retrieved by these approaches with those retrieved by the exhaustive approach. Results: The restrictive approach retrieved 68.1 % fewer references than the exhaustive approach (12,486 versus 39,136), and identified 89.9 % (62/69) of key references and 88 % (22/25) of recommendation updates. The use of PLUS retrieved 88.5 % fewer references than the exhaustive approach (4,486 versus 39,136) and identified substantially fewer key references (18/69, 26.1 %) and fewer recommendation updates (10/25, 40 %). Conclusions: The proposed restrictive approach is a highly efficient and feasible method to identify new evidence that triggers a recommendation update. Searching only in the PLUS database proved to be a suboptimal approach and suggests the need for topic-specific tailoring.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Reporting, handling and assessing the risk of bias associated with missing participant data in systematic reviews, A methodological survey

  • Akl, Elie A.|||0000-0002-3444-8618
  • Carrasco-Labra, Alonso|||0000-0003-3546-3526
  • Brignardello-Petersen, Romina|||0000-0002-6010-9900
  • Neumann, Ignacio|||0000-0001-8406-6880
  • Johnston, Bradley C.|||0000-0001-8872-8626
  • Sun, Xin
  • Briel, Matthias|||0000-0002-2070-5230
  • Busse, Jason|||0000-0002-0178-8712
  • Ebrahim, Shanil
  • Granados, Carlos E.|||0000-0002-1663-4273
  • Iorio, Alfonso|||0000-0002-3331-8766
  • Irfan, Affan B.
  • Martínez García, Laura|||0000-0003-0126-8706
  • Mustafa, Reem|||0000-0002-2091-0875
  • Ramírez-Morera, Anggie|||0000-0003-0793-4626
  • Selva, Anna|||0000-0002-2754-3158
  • Solà Arnau, Ivan|||0000-0003-0078-3706
  • Juliana Sanabria, Andrea
  • Tikkinen, Kari A. O.
  • Vandvik, Per Olav|||0000-0001-8958-2710
  • Vernooij, Robin W. M.|||0000-0001-5734-4566
  • Zazueta, Oscar E.|||0000-0001-5374-3906
  • Zhou, Qi
  • Guyatt, Gordon|||0000-0003-2352-5718
  • Alonso-Coello, Pablo|||0000-0002-8001-8504
Objectives: To describe how systematic reviewers are reporting missing data for dichotomous outcomes, handling them in the analysis and assessing the risk of associated bias. Methods: We searched MEDLINE and the Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews for systematic reviews of randomised trials published in 2010, and reporting a meta-analysis of a dichotomous outcome. We randomly selected 98 Cochrane and 104 non-Cochrane systematic reviews. Teams of 2 reviewers selected eligible studies and abstracted data independently and in duplicate using standardised, piloted forms with accompanying instructions. We conducted regression analyses to explore factors associated with using complete case analysis and with judging the risk of bias associated with missing participant data. Results: Of Cochrane and non-Cochrane reviews, 47% and 7% (p<0.0001), respectively, reported on the number of participants with missing data, and 41% and 9% reported a plan for handling missing categorical data. The 2 most reported approaches for handling missing data were complete case analysis (8.5%, out of the 202 reviews) and assuming no participants with missing data had the event (4%). The use of complete case analysis was associated only with Cochrane reviews (relative to non-Cochrane: OR=7.25; 95% CI 1.58 to 33.3, p=0.01). 65% of reviews assessed risk of bias associated with missing data; this was associated with Cochrane reviews (relative to non-Cochrane: OR=6.63; 95% CI 2.50 to 17.57, p=0.0001), and the use of the Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development and Evaluation (GRADE) methodology (OR=5.02; 95% CI 1.02 to 24.75, p=0.047). Conclusions: Though Cochrane reviews are somewhat less problematic, most Cochrane and non-Cochrane systematic reviews fail to adequately report and handle missing data, potentially resulting in misleading judgements regarding risk of bias.