Skip to main content

PROPUESTA DE INDICADORES PARA IMPULSAR EL DISEÑO DE UNA POLITICA ORIENTADA AL DESARROLLO DE INVESTIGACION E INNOVACION RESPONSABLE EN ESPAÑA

CSO2016-76828-R

•
Funding agency name Agencia Estatal de Investigación
Funding agency acronym AEI
Program Programa Estatal de I+D+i Orientado a los Retos de la Sociedad
Call Proyectos I+D+i Retos de Investigación
Call year 2016
State Plan 2013-2016 Plan Estatal de Investigación Científica y Técnica y de Innovación
Beneficiary centre UNIVERSITAT POLITÈCNICA DE VALÈNCIA

Resultados relacionados

Resultados totales (Incluyendo duplicados): 22
Encontrada(s) 1 página(s)

RiuNet. Repositorio Institucional de la Universitat Politécnica de Valéncia
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Addressing Climate Change in Responsible Research and Innovation: Recommendations for Its Operationalization

  • Ligardo-Herrera, Iván
  • Inigo, Edurne A.
  • Blok, Vincent
  • Gómez-Navarro, Tomás|||0000-0001-6114-2414
[EN] Responsible Research and Innovation (RRI) has only lately included environmental sustainability as a key area for the social desirability of research and innovation. That is one of the reasons why just a few RRI projects and proposals include environmental sustainability, and Climate Change (CC) in particular. CC is one of the grand challenges of our time and, thus, this paper contributes to the operationalization of CC prevention in RRI. To this end, the tools employed against CC were identified. Tools originated in corporate social responsibility and sustainable innovation which help to operationalize strategies against CC in RRI practice. Complementarily, the latest proposals by RRI projects and actors related to CC were reviewed. The findings of the document analysis and the web review were arranged in a framework intended for research and innovation that has an indirect but relevant negative impact due to CC. Thus, four main strategies for CC prevention in RRI were determined: a voluntary integration of the aims, a life cycle perspective, open access databases and key performance indicators, and stakeholder management. The article is finished acknowledging diverse barriers hindering the operationalization of CC prevention in RRI, and we introduce future avenues for research in this area., This research has been funded by the Spanish Agencia Estatal de Investigacion within the project Propuesta de Indicadores para Impulsar el Diseno de Una Politica Orientada al Desarrollo de Investigacion e Innovacion Responsable en Espana. INPERRI. Grant number (CSO2016-76828-R), and by the "Bolivar Gana con Ciencia" program from the Gobernacion de Bolivar (Colombia).
RiuNet. Repositorio Institucional de la Universitat Politécnica de Valéncia
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Anticipating Environmental Burdens in Research and Innovation Projects. Application to the Case of Active and Healthy Ageing

  • Monsonís-Payá, Irene|||0000-0001-7140-6209
  • Gómez-Navarro, Tomás|||0000-0001-6114-2414
  • García-Melón, Mónica|||0000-0001-8101-4049
[EN] In this paper; for research and innovation projects without environmental goals; a procedure is proposed to operationalize the anticipation and reflexivity of environmental concerns in the initial phases. By using the expert knowledge of specialists; we have first conducted a study to identify the general environmental topics relevant in any kind of research and innovation project not addressing the environment. In a second phase; a strategy is proposed to rank order the topics in terms of environmental relevance by means of the Analytic Hierarchy Process. To illustrate it; the case of Information and Communication Technologies for Active and Healthy Ageing is used because of its increasing importance; and because normal environmental targets are not considered. Results show that; in this case; the most relevant topic to be considered is the primary energy consumption by sources; followed by hazardous solid waste and consumption of non-renewable and scarce materials. According to the experts; these should be the main issues to be considered regarding the environmental sustainability of the outputs of such research and innovation projects. In conclusion; this paper contributes to a better understanding of how to promote a wider integration of environmental sustainability in research and innovation when environmental goals are not initially included., This work was funded by Spanish Agencia Estatal de Investigacion under grants [CSO2016-76828-R and BES-2017-081141]; and the Generalitat Valenciana under grant [AICO/2018/270].
RiuNet. Repositorio Institucional de la Universitat Politécnica de Valéncia
Publication Tesis doctoral (DoctoralThesis)

Actors&apos, Engagement in Monitoring and Evaluation Mechanisms for Responsible Research and Innovation: an Explorative Study of the AHP Technique

  • Monsonís-Payá, Irene|||0000-0001-7140-6209
[ES] La capacidad del ser humano de modificar las condiciones de vida en el planeta se ha incrementado de forma notable en el último siglo. Así, dos fenómenos aparentemente opuestos concurren respecto al potencial destructivo y constructivo de nuestras sociedades. Por un lado, la humanidad se enfrenta al reto de articular procesos que permitan gestionar con responsabilidad los productos resultantes del desarrollo de la ciencia e innovación y evitar el colapso social, económico y medioambiental que puede resultar de los mismos. Por otro lado, la humanidad mira a las ciencias y al potencial innovador para responder a los retos globales que requieren abordajes y coordinación entre diferentes niveles de acción y desde una perspectiva inter y transdisciplinar. En este marco, surge el término "Investigación e Innovación Responsable" (RRI por sus siglas en inglés) con el objetivo de integrar aspectos éticos y demandas de participación de diferentes actores en los procesos de investigación e innovación con el fin de que los productos resultantes de los mismos estén alineados con las expectativas de la sociedad. Bajo el paraguas del término RRI o Responsible Innovation (RI), se han articulado una serie de propuestas teóricas y esfuerzos empíricos para operacionalizar la necesidad de integrar una perspectiva ética y promover la participación de nuevos actores en los procesos de investigación e innovación que permitan modular el potencial constructivo y destructivo de los resultados de la ciencia y la innovación. Para la consolidación del interés por el término RRI ha sido determinante la inclusión del mismo en los programas de investigación de la Comisión Europea. El programa Horizonte 2020 impulsó el uso del término en Europa, destinando fondos de investigación para promover su operativización, desarrollo de herramientas para su fomento, así como de herramientas de evaluación y monitorización. En este trabajo exploraremos los procesos de diseño de herramientas de monitorización y evaluación de la RRI. Para ello, propondremos la ética cívica como teoría que se ajusta a la fundamentación filosófica del concepto RRI, revisaremos cómo se han incorporado los valores y expectativas de agentes ajenos al proceso científico e innovador en el desarrollo de herramientas de monitorización y evaluación de la RRI y exploraremos cómo la técnica AHP (Analytic Hierarchy Process) puede contribuir a los procesos de desarrollo de dichas herramientas alineando los mismos a los requerimientos de la ética cívica. El trabajo parte de la hipótesis de que los procesos de desarrollo de metodologías y herramientas para la evaluación y monitorización de la RRI pueden ser considerados como procesos de investigación e innovación en sí mismos. En consecuencia, este trabajo analizará los procesos de investigación e innovación hacia herramientas de evaluación y seguimiento de la RRI bajo la óptica propia de la RRI. Se centrará especialmente en explorar el papel de los actores en tales procesos de investigación e innovación y en la potencialidad de la técnica AHP para facilitar la integración de actores en los procesos de desarrollo de herramientas de evaluación y monitorización de la RRI., [CA] La capacitat de l'ésser humà de modificar les condicions de vida en el planeta ha incrementat de manera notable en l'últim segle. Així, dos fenòmens aparentment oposats concorren respecte al potencial destructiu i constructiu de les nostres societats. D'una banda, la humanitat s'enfronta al repte d'articular processos que permeten gestionar amb responsabilitat els productes resultants del desenvolupament de la ciència i innovació i evitar el col·lapse social, econòmic i mediambiental que pot resultar d'aquests. D'altra banda, la humanitat mira a les ciències i al potencial innovador per a respondre als reptes globals que requereixen abordatges i coordinació entre diferents nivells d'acció i des d'una perspectiva inter i transdisciplinar. En aquest marc, sorgeix el terme "Investigació i Innovació Responsable" (RRI per les seues sigles en anglés) amb l'objectiu d'integrar aspectes ètics i demandes de participació de diferents actors en els processos d'investigació i innovació amb la finalitat que els productes resultants dels mateixos estiguen alineats amb les expectatives de la societat. Sota el paraigua del terme RRI o Responsible Innovation (RI), s'han articulat una sèrie de propostes teòriques i esforços empírics per a operacionalizar la necessitat d'integrar una perspectiva ètica i promoure la participació de nous actors en els processos d'investigació i innovació que permeten modula el potencial constructiu i destructiu dels resultats de la ciència i innovació. Per a la consolidació de l'interés pel terme RRI ha sigut determinant la inclusió del mateix en els programes d'investigació de la Comissió Europea. El programa Horitzó 2020 impulsà l'ús del terme a Europa, destinant fons d'investigació per a promoure la seua operativizació, desenvolupament d'eines per al seu foment, així com d'eines d'avaluació i monitoratge. En aquest treball explorarem els processos de disseny d'eines de monitoratge i avaluació de la RRI. Per a això, proposarem l'ètica cívica com a teoria que s'ajusta a la fonamentació filosòfica del concepte RRI, revisarem com s'ha incorporat els valors i expectatives d'agents aliens al procés científic i innovador en el desenvolupament d'eines de monitoratge i avaluació de la RRI i explorarem com la tècnica AHP (Analytic Hierarchy Process) pot contribuir als processos de desenvolupament d'aquestes eines alineant els mateixos als requeriments de l'ètica cívica. El treball parteix de la hipòtesi que els processos de desenvolupament de metodologies i eines per a l'avaluació i monitoratge de la RRI poden ser considerats com a processos d'investigació i innovació en si mateixos. En conseqüència, aquest treball analitzarà els processos d'investigació i innovació cap a eines d'avaluació i seguiment de la RRI sota l'òptica pròpia de la RRI. Se centrarà especialment a explorar el paper dels actors en tals processos d'investigació i innovació i en la potencialitat de la tècnica AHP per a facilitar la integració d'actors en els processos de desenvolupament d'eines d'avaluació i monitoratge de la RRI., [EN] The capacity of humanity to modify the conditions of life on the planet has increased dramatically in the last century. Thus, two opposing phenomena concur concerning our societies' destructive and constructive potential. On the one hand, humanity faces the challenge of articulating processes to responsibly manage the products resulting from the development of science and innovation and to avoid the social, economic and environmental collapse that can result from them. On the other hand, humanity looks to the sciences and innovative potential to respond to global challenges that require approaches and coordination between different levels of action and from an inter- and transdisciplinary perspective. In this framework, the term "Responsible Research and Innovation" (RRI) arises intending to integrate ethical aspects and demands for the participation of different actors in research and innovation processes so that the resulting products are aligned with society's expectations. Under the umbrella of the term RRI or Responsible Innovation (RI), a series of theoretical proposals and practical efforts have been articulated to operationalise the need to integrate an ethical perspective and promote the participation of new actors in research and innovation processes to modulate the constructive and destructive potential of the results of science and innovation. Including the term RRI in the European Commission's research programmes has been decisive in consolidating interest in RRI. The Horizon 2020 programme has boosted its use in Europe, allocating research funds for its operationalisation, promotion, evaluation and monitoring tools. In this work, we will explore the design processes of RRI monitoring and evaluation tools. To do so, we will propose civic ethics as a theory that fits the philosophical foundation of the RRI concept, we will review how the values and expectations of agents outside the scientific and innovative process have been incorporated into the development of RRI monitoring and evaluation tools, and we will explore how the AHP (Analytic Hierarchy Process) technique can contribute to the development processes of these tools by aligning them with the requirements of civic ethics. The work stems from the hypothesis that developing methodologies and tools for RRI assessment and monitoring can be considered research and innovation processes. Consequently, this paper will analyse the processes of research and innovation towards RRI assessment and monitoring tools through the lens of RRI. It will primarily focus on exploring the role of actors in such research and innovation processes and on the potential of the AHP technique to facilitate the integration of actors in developing RRI assessment and monitoring tools., Esta tesis ha recibido financiación del Plan Nacional de Investigación del proyecto “Propuesta de indicadores para impulsar el diseño de una política orientada al desarrollo de Investigación e Innovación Responsable en España” (INPERRI) (ref.: CSO2016-76828-R). La concesión del proyecto de investigación permitió también mi contratación como investigadora predoctoral (ref.: BES-2017-081141).
RiuNet. Repositorio Institucional de la Universitat Politécnica de Valéncia
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Indicators for Responsible Research and Innovation: A Methodological Proposal for Context-Based Weighting

  • Monsonís-Payá, Irene|||0000-0001-7140-6209
  • García-Melón, Mónica|||0000-0001-8101-4049
  • Lozano, José-Félix|||0000-0002-2715-8479
[EN] In the last decade, the term Responsible Research and Innovation (RRI) has rapidly attracted the attention of policy-makers and researchers of Europe, mainly due to its promotion by the European Commission (EC). The concretion of this framework of RRI has been articulated by the EC around six key areas: governance, public engagement, gender equality, science education, open access, and open science and ethics. The indicators to measure these dimensions have been proposed recently. In our opinion the set of indicators available so far has two weaknesses: a lack of context-based indicators and a need for hierarchical ordering. Our aim is to provide tools for policy-and decision-makers that might need to identify the more important indicators in a specific context. In this work, we explored how the multicriteria analysis technique Analytical Hierarchical Process (AHP) can be used to prioritize indicators for RRI by involving experts in the specific context. The AHP method allowed weighting indicators according to experts in the different areas and producing four different options to select indicators. The method of AHP can be an appropriated instrument to select the most suitable indicators for RRI policies and initiatives., This research work was realized under the project "Propuesta de indicadores para impulsar el diseno de una politica orientada al desarrollo de Investigacion e Innovacion Responsable en Espana" (INPERRI). This project is funded by the Spanish National Ministry of Economy, Industry, and Competitiveness (reference: CSO2016-76828-R). The funds received under this project covered the cost to publish in open access.
RiuNet. Repositorio Institucional de la Universitat Politécnica de Valéncia
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Participation in monitoring and evaluation for RRI: a review of procedural approaches developing monitoring and evaluation mechanisms

  • Monsonís-Payá, Irene|||0000-0001-7140-6209
  • Iñigo, Edurne A.
  • Blok, Vincent
[EN] Three arguments support the involvement of actors in the design and implementation of the Monitoring and Evaluation (M&E) for Responsible Research and Innovation (RRI). First, it strengthens the evaluation; second, it allows taking advantage of the performative function; third, it is aligned with the concept of RRI. In Europe, the trend to institutionalize RRI triggered an interest in developing specific M&E methods and tools, but how actors participate in these processes is still being determined. This paper investigates the extent to which the participation of actors occurs or is expected to occur by using the three stages of translation proposed by Callon and colleagues ¿ problematization, development of the research, and transfer to a real setting. Through a systematic review of 25 approaches developing M&E mechanisms, our findings show that participation occurs or is foreseen mainly in the later stages and is specially linked with learning and trust-related purposes., This work was supported by the Ministry of Economy Industry and Competitiveness (Spain) under Grants CSO2016-76828-R and BES-2017-081141.
RiuNet. Repositorio Institucional de la Universitat Politécnica de Valéncia
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

A Multicriteria Model to Evaluate Strategic Plans for the Nautical and Naval Industry in Cartagena de Indias, Colombia

  • Gonzalez-Urango, Hannia
  • García-Melón, Mónica|||0000-0001-8101-4049
[EN] The evaluation of urban development plans is a key concern of the strategic planning of the city of Cartagena de Indias (Colombia) due to the pressure exerted by both public and private sectors. Any strategic planning requirement deserves the inclusion of clear terms of coordination and cooperation among sectors, including local communities and the scientific sector. In this paper, we present a methodology for the sustainable evaluation of strategic nautical and naval projects for the development of the city of Cartagena de Indias. The methodology is based on the multicriteria technique Analytic Network Process, which allows considering political, socio-cultural and environmental aspects. The aim is to provide answers and guide the decision makers towards the optimal selection of strategies. Results provide some important insights into the overall conception of what sustainable evaluation means for the experts consulted. The procedure enhances participation and transparency and becomes a support for their decisions., The authors would like to thank the "Bolivar Gana con Ciencia" project from the Gobernacion de Bolivar (Colombia) for the financial support. Special thanks are also extended to the experts for their enthusiastic cooperation, which made this study possible.
RiuNet. Repositorio Institucional de la Universitat Politécnica de Valéncia
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Adapting RRI Public Engagement indicators to the Spanish scientific and innovation context. A participatory methodology based on AHP and Content Analysis

  • García-Melón, Mónica|||0000-0001-8101-4049
  • Gómez-Navarro, Tomás|||0000-0001-6114-2414
  • Gonzalez-Urango, Hannia
  • CORONA-SOBRINO, CARMEN
[EN] The paradigm proposed by Responsible Research and Innovation in the European Commission policy discourse identifies Public Engagement as a key area for exchange and dialogue among multiple actors following an inclusive and participatory process. Two definite set of indicators have already arisen at European level to monitor Public Engagement activities in the Science and Innovation realm. Our study aims to propose a deliberative participatory process, which involves selected stakeholders, for the adaptation of the European indicators to the specific Spanish scientific and innovation context. The methodological procedure is of exploratory nature and will be based in a combination of, on the one hand qualitative content analysis techniques for the in-depth study of the deliberative process and the generation of indicators; and, on the other hand, a multicriteria decision analysis technique such as the Analytic Hierarchy Process for the prioritization of the indicators. The discussion will focus on the procedure to articulate stakeholders values and use them as the basis for creating a context-based improved list of indicators. Two types of research questions arise: (i) Is the proposed methodology adequate for the adaptation of the European indicators to the Spanish context? (ii) What are the main indicators to monitor and to expand reflection on the public engagement in the Spanish science and innovation?, Thisworkwas supported by the Spanish Agencia Estatal de Investigacion underGrant [CSO201676828-R]; and the Generalitat Valencia under Grant [AICO/2018/270].
RiuNet. Repositorio Institucional de la Universitat Politécnica de Valéncia
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Civic ethics as a normative framework for responsible research and innovation

  • Lozano, José-Félix|||0000-0002-2715-8479
  • Monsonís-Payá, Irene|||0000-0001-7140-6209
[EN] Responsible Research and Innovation (RRI) is a term used in Europe to advance in the consideration of societal and ethical dimensions of research and innovation. RRI involves two main challenges: its rationale its practical development. The legitimacy of RRI is based on its ethical foundation. Different ethical traditions, such as procedural ethics, have been identified as underpinning the RRI conceptualizations so far. The objective of this article is to examine the evolution of discursive ethics proposed by J. Habermas and K.O. Apel, and civic ethics as a normative framework for RRI, and to explore their development and feasibility and how they are affected by the tensions that such a paradigmatic change might imply., This work was supported by the Government of Spain through the 'Agencia Estatal de Investigacion' from the `Ministerio de Economia, Industria y Competitividad' [Grant Numbers CSO201676828-R and BES-2017-081141]
RiuNet. Repositorio Institucional de la Universitat Politécnica de Valéncia
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Business engagement in gender equality policy: roles, contributions, and expectations

  • Otero-Hermida, Paula
  • González-Urango, Hannia Karime
[EN] Businesses have traditionally been seen as reluctant participants in equality policy initiatives. However, emerging governance guidelines increasingly advocate for gender mainstreaming, encouraging active business engagement. Our research examines this potential transformation, focusing on the role of businesses adopting Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) practices compared to traditional equality policy actors - governments, equality organizations, and academia - within the Colombian context. Using a collaborative governance framework and participatory decision-making techniques, we identify potential role shifts toward proactivity and specific contributions from each actor group. Our findings highlight discordant mutual expectations, or "role mismatch", and divergent perceptions within the business sector, which may undermine traditional actors. These insights emphasize the risks inherent in business participation in equality policy. By delineating contributions and clarifying self-perceptions and mutual expectations, we offer a practical approach to designing participatory processes that foster mutual recognition, trust, and shared responsibility as foundations for advancing equality policies., We would like to thank Monica Garcia-Melon for her continuous support in our research work and Ingrith Rodriguez-Gutierrez for collaborating in collecting empirical material. Also, David Barbera-Tomas and Itziar Castello for their valuable feedback, and the reviewers for their recommendations. We especially want to thank all the people who have devoted their time and reflection to this piece of work, building the participatory model, answering the resulting questionnaire, and giving feedback on preliminary results. This work was supported by the Universitat Politecnica de Valencia [ADSIDEO 2017-2018]; Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation [CSO2016-76828-R; IJC2020-044013-I]; Generalitat Valenciana [APOSTD-2020].
RiuNet. Repositorio Institucional de la Universitat Politécnica de Valéncia
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Stakeholder engagement to evaluate tourist development plans with a sustainable approach

  • Gonzalez-Urango, Hannia
  • García-Melón, Mónica|||0000-0001-8101-4049
[EN] This study provides an evaluation of tourist development plans in the city of Cartagena de Indias (Colombia). Different stakeholders are involved in the search for solutions to this problem. The proposal is based on a model that combines two techniques, namely the analytic network process (ANP) and social network analysis (SNA). SNA is used to assess the relationships among stakeholders by identifying those who are most relevant and ANP is used to aggregate their opinions and evaluate tourist development plans of Cartagena to improve tourist experiences in a participatory way. The results suggest that the combination of SNA and ANP is a novel and suitable tool for strategic planning of a city., Bolivar Gana con Ciencia
RiuNet. Repositorio Institucional de la Universitat Politécnica de Valéncia
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Application of the ANP to the prioritization of project stakeholders in the context of responsible research and innovation

  • Ligardo-Herrera, Iván
  • Gonzalez-Urango, Hannia
  • Gómez-Navarro, Tomás|||0000-0001-6114-2414
[EN] This paper presents a methodology to assess the stakeholders¿ influence in a research project within the context of responsible research and innovation. The methodology is based on a combination of the multicriteria decision making technique analytic network process and the key areas of responsible research. The method allows ranking and ordering the project¿s stakeholders based on their influence upon its responsibility. The purpose of such an assessment is to help research teams to more efficiently devote their limited resources to stakeholder management. The procedure is applied to a case study of the Information and Communication Technology business sector. It is an ongoing project at an early phase of development. Influential stakeholders have been identified first, and have been further classified into groups based on their relative importance. The assessment of their influence has been based on up to 16 different criteria, mainly belonging to the framework of responsible research and innovation. In the case study, the most influential criterion was the Capability to promote public engagement, while Developers were found to be the stakeholders most contributing to the research project responsibility. However, as explained, this is a temporary situation, valid for the current project development situation. It may vary over time as criteria vary in weight and stakeholders vary in influence., The authors would like to thank to our anonymous referees for their constructive comments and suggestions that helped us to improve the quality of the paper. Also, to the “Bolívar Gana con Ciencia” program from the Gobernación de Bolívar (Colombia) for the financial support. For the same reason, the authors are grateful to the Spanish Agencia Estatal de Investigación for its support of the project Propuesta de Indicadores para Impulsar el Diseño de Una Política Orientada al Desarrollo de Investigación e Innovación Responsable en España (CSO2016-76828-R)
RiuNet. Repositorio Institucional de la Universitat Politécnica de Valéncia
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Gender Equality Indicators for Research and Innovation from a Responsible Perspective: The Case of Spain

  • Otero-Hermida, Paula
  • García-Melón, Mónica|||0000-0001-8101-4049
[EN] This article offers a Spanish national perspective that contributes to European Responsible Research and Innovation (RRI) monitoring initiatives. National experts involved in gender and science and technology issues, such as policymakers, gender experts, research institutions, and equality associations, among others, have proposed indicators based on participatory decision-making techniques. The results include a complete set of 52 indicators and a reduced panel of 23 indicators-the highest-ranked ones-to monitor relevant aspects that should be measured in gender dimension from an RRI perspective: differential and asymmetric socialization and education, organizational culture, substantive representation, vertical segregation, work relations, visibility of women researchers, gender perspective in research contents, gender expertise enhancement, and resources. The results offer new indicators that differ from previous indicator panels at the European and Spanish levels in relation to those aspects that should be measured and the typology of indicators preferred. Differences suggest the need for a more nuanced debate on the purpose of indicators, and the need for national contributions to RRI and to the debate on gender perspective in EU policy. Finally, the article suggests some specific traits observed in Spain that might add to the debate on the content of an RRI gender perspective in an already developed gender policy., The article was developed within the framework of INPERRI project, funded by the Spanish Ministry of Economy, Industry and Competitiveness. INPERRI Propuesta de Indicadores para Impulsar el Diseno de Una Politica Orientada al Desarrollo de Investigacion e Innovacion Responsable en Espana. INPERRI. Grant number (CSO2016-76828-R).
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Application of the ANP to the prioritization of project stakeholders in the context of responsible research and innovation

  • Ligardo-Herrera, Iván
  • Gómez Navarro, Tomás
  • Gonzalez-Urango, Hannia
This paper presents a methodology to assess the stakeholders’ influence in a research project within the context of responsible research and innovation. The methodology is based on a combination of the multicriteria decision making technique analytic network process and the key areas of responsible research. The method allows ranking and ordering the project’s stakeholders based on their influence upon its responsibility. The purpose of such an assessment is to help research teams to more efficiently devote their limited resources to stakeholder management. The procedure is applied to a case study of the Information and Communication Technology business sector. It is an ongoing project at an early phase of development. Influential stakeholders have been identified first, and have been further classified into groups based on their relative importance. The assessment of their influence has been based on up to 16 different criteria, mainly belonging to the framework of responsible research and innovation. In the case study, the most influential criterion was the Capability to promote public engagement, while Developers were found to be the stakeholders most contributing to the research project responsibility. However, as explained, this is a temporary situation, valid for the current project development situation. It may vary over time as criteria vary in weight and stakeholders vary in influence., Also, to the “Bolívar Gana con Ciencia” program from the Gobernación de Bolívar (Colombia) for the financial support. For the same reason, the authors are grateful to the Spanish Agencia Estatal de Investigación for its support of the project Propuesta de Indicadores para Impulsar el Diseño de Una Política Orientada al Desarrollo de Investigación e Innovación Responsable en España (CSO2016-76828-R).
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Gender mainstreaming in Spain: policy instruments, influencing factors, and the role of local government

  • Otero-Hermida, Paula
  • Bouzas Lorenzo, Ramón
In Press., This article investigates equality policies in relation to gender mainstreaming in local governments, prior to the dismantling of equality policies in the wake of the financial crisis that began in 2008. Data from 198 municipalities based on the use of mainstreaming instruments revealed limited implementation of mainstreaming as a policy strategy. Similarly, a qualitative study on mainstreaming as a vision showed that the local level tended to reproduce supra-municipal deficits without offering a differential contribution. Lack of consistency was also observed between the role assigned to local entities by supra-municipal authorities and the role they actually played. Important influencing factors included the gender of the mayor, political colour of the local government, existence of a separate equality council, and adoption of an equality plan. The study concludes with recommendations for redefining local gender mainstreaming in a post-crisis scenario., This work was supported by the Spanish Women´s Institute [grant number PN034] and the Ministry of Economy and Competitiveness [grant number CSO2016-76828-R].
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Anticipating environmental burdens in research and innovation projects—application to the case of active and healthy ageing

  • Monsonís-Payá, Irene
  • Gómez Navarro, Tomás
  • García-Melón, Mónica
This article belongs to the Special Issue Applications of Multi-Criteria Techniques to Solve Agrifood and Environmental Problems., In this paper; for research and innovation projects without environmental goals; a procedure is proposed to operationalize the anticipation and reflexivity of environmental concerns in the initial phases. By using the expert knowledge of specialists; we have first conducted a study to identify the general environmental topics relevant in any kind of research and innovation project not addressing the environment. In a second phase; a strategy is proposed to rank order the topics in terms of environmental relevance by means of the Analytic Hierarchy Process. To illustrate it; the case of Information and Communication Technologies for Active and Healthy Ageing is used because of its increasing importance; and because normal environmental targets are not considered. Results show that; in this case; the most relevant topic to be considered is the primary energy consumption by sources; followed by hazardous solid waste and consumption of non-renewable and scarce materials. According to the experts; these should be the main issues to be considered regarding the environmental sustainability of the outputs of such research and innovation projects. In conclusion; this paper contributes to a better understanding of how to promote a wider integration of environmental sustainability in research and innovation when environmental goals are not initially included., This work was funded by Spanish Agencia Estatal de Investigación under grants [CSO2016-76828-R and BES-2017-081141]; and the Generalitat Valenciana under grant [AICO/2018/270]., Peer reviewed
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publication Contribución de congreso (ConferenceOutput)

Multicriteria approach to define Social Justice Indicators within the Responsible Research and Innovation framework

  • Miralles Insa, Cristóbal Javier
  • Monsonís-Payá, Irene
  • García-Melón, Mónica
Trabajo presentado en la 30th European Conference on Operational Research (EURO 2019), celebrada en Dublín (Irlanda) del 23 al 26 de junio de 2019., During the last decade, the Responsible Research and Innovation (RRI) concept is being promoted as an open dialogue for promoting the participation of civil society in the field of research and innovation, which is especially important in the actual disruptive scenario that new technologies are fostering. The RRI framework has been articulated by the European Commission around six areas: governance, public engagement, gender equality, science education, open access&science, and ethics; but still needs reflection and a broader debate regarding a key transversal topic: Social Justice. This exploratory research starts with the discussion of certain basic hypothesis and a critical&extensive review of the potential indicators initially useful to monitor this dimension in the Spanish context. Then, the multicriteria analysis technique Analytical Hierarchical Process (AHP) is used to prioritize indicators, weighting and selecting them according to the opinions of experts in different areas. Finally, some discussions arise on the strengths and challenges of this bottom-up approach, as normative proposals are necessary to apply these indicators within the decision making process both to assess and orientate public scientific policies., This research was funded by the Spanish Ministry of Economy, Industry and Competitiveness project INPERRI (CSO2016-76828-R), and by Generalitat Valenciana competitive project AICO/2018/270.
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Civic ethics as a normative framework for responsible research and innovation

  • Lozano, José-Félix
  • Monsonís-Payá, Irene
Responsible Research and Innovation (RRI) is a term used in Europe to advance in the consideration of societal and ethical dimensions of research and innovation. RRI involves two main challenges: its rationale its practical development. The legitimacy of RRI is based on its ethical foundation. Different ethical traditions, such as procedural ethics, have been identified as underpinning the RRI conceptualizations so far. The objective of this article is to examine the evolution of discursive ethics proposed by J. Habermas and K.O. Apel, and civic ethics as a normative framework for RRI, and to explore their development and feasibility and how they are affected by the tensions that such a paradigmatic change might imply., This work was supported by the Government of Spain through the ‘Agencia Estatal de Investigación’ from the ‘Ministerio de Economía, Industria y Competitividad’ [Grant Numbers CSO2016-76828-R and BES-2017-081141]
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Gender equality indicators for research and innovation from a responsible perspective: The case of Spain

  • Otero-Hermida, Paula
  • García-Melón, Mónica
© 2018 by the authors., This article offers a Spanish national perspective that contributes to European Responsible Research and Innovation (RRI) monitoring initiatives. National experts involved in gender and science and technology issues, such as policymakers, gender experts, research institutions, and equality associations, among others, have proposed indicators based on participatory decision-making techniques. The results include a complete set of 52 indicators and a reduced panel of 23 indicators—the highest-ranked ones—to monitor relevant aspects that should be measured in gender dimension from an RRI perspective: differential and asymmetric socialization and education, organizational culture, substantive representation, vertical segregation, work relations, visibility of women researchers, gender perspective in research contents, gender expertise enhancement, and resources. The results offer new indicators that differ from previous indicator panels at the European and Spanish levels in relation to those aspects that should be measured and the typology of indicators preferred. Differences suggest the need for a more nuanced debate on the purpose of indicators, and the need for national contributions to RRI and to the debate on gender perspective in EU policy. Finally, the article suggests some specific traits observed in Spain that might add to the debate on the content of an RRI gender perspective in an already developed gender policy., The article was developed within the framework of INPERRI project, funded by the Spanish Ministry of Economy, Industry and Competitiveness. INPERRI Propuesta de Indicadores para Impulsar el Diseño de Una Política Orientada al Desarrollo de Investigación e Innovación Responsable en España. INPERRI. Grant number (CSO2016-76828-R)
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publication Contribución de congreso (ConferenceOutput)

El proceso de definición de indicadores para la investigación e innovación responsable: una propuesta desde la ética cívica

  • Monsonís-Payá, Irene
  • Lozano, José-Félix
Trabajo presentado en el V Congreso Internacional de Bioética: Neuroeducación moral y Desarrollo Humano, celebrado en Valencia (España) el 14 de noviembre de 2018., Presentar una aproximación preliminar cómo la ética cívica podría ser un marco normativo para procesos de desarrollo de indicadores de la Investigación e Innovación Responsable (RRI):¿Ofreciendo legitimidad normativa de acuerdo con los presupuestos de la ética del discurso (Apel, 1988) ¿Apoyando una discusión coherentey que involucre a los diferentes agentes implicados., This project is funded by the Spanish National Ministry of Economy, Industry and Competitiveness (reference: CSO2016-76828-R).
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Adapting RRI public engagement indicators to the Spanish scientific and innovation context: a participatory methodology based on AHP and content analysis

  • García-Melón, Mónica
  • Gómez Navarro, Tomás
  • Gonzalez-Urango, Hannia
  • Corona-Sobrino, Carmen
The paradigm proposed by Responsible Research and Innovation in the European Commission policy discourse identifies Public Engagement as a key area for exchange and dialogue among multiple actors following an inclusive and participatory process. Two definite set of indicators have already arisen at European level to monitor Public Engagement activities in the Science and Innovation realm. Our study aims to propose a deliberative participatory process, which involves selected stakeholders, for the adaptation of the European indicators to the specific Spanish scientific and innovation context. The methodological procedure is of exploratory nature and will be based in a combination of, on the one hand, qualitative content analysis techniques for the in-depth study of the deliberative process and the generation of indicators; and, on the other hand, a multi-criteria decision analysis technique such as the Analytic Hierarchy Process for the prioritization of the indicators. The discussion will focus on the procedure to articulate stakeholders’ values and use them as the basis for creating a context-based improved list of indicators. Two types of research questions arise: (i) Is the proposed methodology adequate for the adaptation of the European indicators to the Spanish context? (ii) What are the main indicators to monitor and to expand reflection on the public engagement in the Spanish science and innovation?, This work was supported in part by the European Union under the grant (H2020-SWAFS/0467-Grant-agreement no 824671FPU2016/00962) and by the regional public administration of Valencia under the grant (AICO/2021/133). This work was supported by the Spanish Agencia Estatal de Investigación under Grant [CSO2016-76828-R]; and the Generalitat Valencia under Grant [AICO/2018/270].
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Participation in monitoring and evaluation for RRI: a review of procedural approaches developing monitoring and evaluation mechanisms

  • Monsonís-Payá, Irene
  • Iñigo, Edurne A.
  • Blok, Vincent
Three arguments support the involvement of actors in the design and implementation of the Monitoring and Evaluation (M&E) for Responsible Research and Innovation (RRI). First, it strengthens the evaluation; second, it allows taking advantage of the performative function; third, it is aligned with the concept of RRI. In Europe, the trend to institutionalize RRI triggered an interest in developing specific M&E methods and tools, but how actors participate in these processes is still being determined. This paper investigates the extent to which the participation of actors occurs or is expected to occur by using the three stages of translation proposed by Callon and colleagues – problematization, development of the research, and transfer to a real setting. Through a systematic review of 25 approaches developing M&E mechanisms, our findings show that participation occurs or is foreseen mainly in the later stages and is specially linked with learning and trust-related purposes., This work was supported by the Ministry of Economy Industry and Competitiveness (Spain) under Grants CSO2016-76828-R and BES-2017-081141., Peer reviewed
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Research data Set de datos (Dataset)

Participation in monitoring and evaluation for RRI: a review of procedural approaches developing monitoring and evaluation mechanisms [Dataset]

  • Monsonís-Payá, Irene
  • Iñigo, Edurne A.
  • Blok, Vincent
Three arguments support the involvement of actors in the design and implementation of the Monitoring and Evaluation (M&E) for Responsible Research and Innovation (RRI). First, it strengthens the evaluation; second, it allows taking advantage of the performative function; third, it is aligned with the concept of RRI. In Europe, the trend to institutionalize RRI triggered an interest in developing specific M&E methods and tools, but how actors participate in these processes is still being determined. This paper investigates the extent to which the participation of actors occurs or is expected to occur by using the three stages of translation proposed by Callon and colleagues – problematization, development of the research, and transfer to a real setting. Through a systematic review of 25 approaches developing M&E mechanisms, our findings show that participation occurs or is foreseen mainly in the later stages and is specially linked with learning and trust-related purposes., This work was supported by the Ministry of Economy Industry and Competitiveness (Spain) under Grants CSO2016-76828-R and BES-2017-081141., Peer reviewed