Skip to main content

RESPONSABILIDAD CAUSAL DE LA COMISION POR OMISION: UNA DILUCIDACION ETICO-JURIDICA DE LOS PROBLEMAS DE LA INACCION INDEBIDA

FFI2014-53926-R

•
Funding agency name Ministerio de Economía y Competitividad
Funding agency acronym MINECO
Program Programa Estatal de I+D+i Orientado a los Retos de la Sociedad
Call Proyectos I+D+i Retos de Investigación
Call year 2014
State Plan 2013-2016 Plan Estatal de Investigación Científica y Técnica y de Innovación
Management unit Secretaría de Estado de Educación, Formación Profesional y Universidades
Beneficiary centre AGENCIA ESTATAL CONSEJO SUPERIOR DE INVESTIGACIONES CIENTIFICAS (CSIC)

Resultados relacionados

Resultados totales (Incluyendo duplicados): 6
Encontrada(s) 1 página(s)

DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Buenas Prácticas (Códigos de)

  • Ausín, Txetxu
[EN] The codes of best practices collect in an orderly and systematic way those experiences that are advisable in a certain field because they have yielded positive results and have shown their success and usefulness so that they are worth repeating and sharing. Especially relevant in the realm of public sector organizations, they move between tradition and innovation and among their functions are the recognition of the mission of the activity, the generation of knowledge, learning and innovation about it, protection against external pressures, the prevention of bad practices, trust, and exemplariness. There is discussion about their assessment but, at a minimum, they should respond to a series of requirements: participation, flexibility, adhesion, accessibility, monitoring and dissemination., [ES] Los códigos de buenas prácticas recogen de manera ordenada y sistemática aquellas experiencias que resultan aconsejables en un determinado ámbito porque han arrojado resultados positivos y han demostrado su éxito y utilidad, de modo que merece la pena que se repitan y sean compartidas. Especialmente relevantes en el ámbito de las organizaciones del sector público, se mueven entre la tradición y la innovación y entre sus funciones están el reconocimiento de la misión de la actividad, la generación de conocimiento, el aprendizaje e innovación sobre la misma, la protección frente a presiones externas, la prevención de malas prácticas, la confianza y la ejemplaridad. Hay discusión sobre su valoración pero, como mínimo, deberían responder a un serie de requisitos: Participación, flexibilidad, adhesión, accesibilidad, monitorización y difusión., Este trabajo se realiza en el marcos de los proyectos de investigación KONTUZ! “Responsabilidad causal de la comisión por omisión” (MINECO FFI2014-53926-R) y NEW TRUST-CM “Programa interuniversitario en cultura de la legalidad” (CONSEJERÍA DE EDUCACIÓN, COMUNIDAD DE MADRID S2015/HUM-3466), Peer Reviewed
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Cripwashing: the abortion debates at the crossroads of gender and disability in the Spanish media

  • Moscoso Pérez, Melania
  • Platero Méndez, R. Lucas
On 11 September 2015, the Spanish Senate passed the second reform of the Abortion Act, promoted by a Conservative Government. It was the last step in the parliamentary process of a law that bans 16- and 17-year-old girls from accessing abortion without parental consent. In this article, we explore how the debates between physicians, the Catholic Church, disability activists and pro-choice activists reached the Spanish media. We focus on the use the Conservative Government has made of disability rights movement (DRM) discourse to undermine the reproductive rights of women in force in the country since the 1986 Law on VoluntaryTermination of Pregnancy. We unveil the intricacies of the voices of a minority group in justifying agendas against women’s rights, stressing the challenges that dismantling the Spanish public health system poses for people with disabilities. We suggest that the Conservative Government was using the DRM to undermine women’s rights, and we call this operation cripwashing. Similar to the term ‘pinkwashing’ used by the LGBT community, cripwashing refers to the practice of using the rights protections of one group to conceal abuses towards other groups. In the following three sections, we explore how the budget cuts imposed on the Spanish national healthcare system pose a greater danger to disabled people than the abortion laws that allow the termination of pregnancy on the basis of congenital malformations. We then focus on how the Conservative Party capitalized on the discourse of the DRM in order to undermine women’s reproductive rights., Peer Reviewed
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Ética pública para generar confianza, Public ethics to build trust

  • Ausín, Txetxu
[EN] We live a deep crisis of «trust». In a context of public disaffection with politics and profound demoralization in public life, it is more necessary than ever to reflect on the moral dimensions of public service which is accountable for its actions and omissions as a general interest-focused activity. To this end, public ethics understood as applied ethics aimed towards matters of government and public administration, has developed a series of instruments such as international agreements, institutions of control and surveillance and codes of good practices. But if social control of government policies and practices is essential, to the extent that the malpractices and corruption arise as well as citizen disaffection, the fact remains that the tools of public ethics can become an end in themselves, without contributing to the improvement of public service and promoting a sort of widespread public distrust and «defensive administration.» On the contrary, the strengthening of public ethics should be aimed at building trust, strengthening convictions, habits and culture change. Trust is an inherent element of professional work, which generates social capital and without which a complex society cannot be maintained., [ES] Vivimos una profunda crisis de «crédito». En un contexto de desafección ciudadana hacia la política y de profunda desmoralización en la vida pública, es más necesario que nunca recapitular sobre la dimensión moral del servicio público, que debe rendir cuentas de sus acciones y omisiones como actividad orientada al interés general. Para ello, la ética pública, como ética aplicada a los asuntos del gobierno y de la administración pública, ha desarrollado una serie de instrumentos como los acuerdos internacionales, las entidades de control y vigilancia y los códigos de buenas prácticas. Pero si es fundamental el control social de las prácticas políticas y gubernamentales, en la medida en que las malas prácticas originan la corrupción y, por ende, la desafección ciudadana, no es menos cierto que las herramientas de ética pública pueden convertirse en un fin en sí mismas, sin contribuir a una mejora del servicio público y favoreciendo una suerte de desconfianza pública generalizada y de «administración defensiva». Por el contrario, el robustecimiento de la ética pública debe orientarse a generar confianza, reforzando convicciones, hábitos y cambio de cultura. La confianza es un elemento inherente al quehacer profesional, que genera capital social y sin la cual no puede mantenerse una sociedad compleja., [EU]«Sinesgarritasunaren» krisi sakon batean murgilduta gaude. Herritarrek politikarekiko estimurik eza erakusten duten honetan, bizitza publikoarekin erabat etsita dauden honetan, oso da beharrezkoa zerbitzu publikoaren dimentsio moralari buruzko gogoeta egitea; izan ere, zerbitzu publikoak kontu eman behar du bere egintza eta ez-egintzen gainean, interes orokorrari begira. Horretarako, etika publikoak, gobernuaren eta administrazio publikoaren gaiei aplikatutako etika den aldetik, tresna batzuk garatu ditu; besteak beste, nazioarteko akordioak, zaintza eta kontrolerako entitateak eta jardunbide egokien kodeak. Badakigu funtsezkoa dela politika- eta gobernu-praktiken kontrol sozial bat egitea, praktika okerrek ustelkeria baitakarte eta horrek politikarekiko estimurik eza sortzen baitu herritarrengan. Baina gerta daiteke etika publikorako tresnek euren buruarentzako helburu soila izatea, zerbitzu publikoaren alde egin gabe, eta horrek jendeak, oro har, konfiantzarik ez izatea eta «defentsiban dagoen administrazio bat» izatea eragiten du. Aitzitik, etika publikoaren sendotze horrek konfiantza-sortzaile izan behar du, eta, horretarako, indartu egin behar dira uste sendoak, ohiturak eta kultura-aldaketa. Zeregin profesionalari atxikitako elementu bat da konfiantza, kapital soziala sortzen duena, eta hori gabe, ezinezkoa da gizarte konplexu bati eustea., Peer Reviewed
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publication Otros (Other)

The Public Dimension of Care: Towards a Public Ethics of Care

  • Ausín, Txetxu
As essentially social beings, we humans are fragile and dependent on what is outside ourselves—others, institutions and sustained and sustainable environments—. Vulnerability acquires for us a social role (not a mere contingency or a subjective disposition) and hence the positive social obligations arise to minimize instability and its differential distribution, to demand basic support (food, shelter, work, healthcare, education, mobility, expression) and to reduce avoidable damage. We are a social species, with reciprocal links (rights and duties), built on the interdependence; not a group of solitary individuals whose mutual obligations are limited to not invading other people’s space. Care-related obligations by the (social) state come into play here, as in the case of healthcare systems. These can be characterized as “due cares” (due actions) because the action is an expected event within a social context of values and guidelines. In that context, the omission that causes or enables harm, as in exclusion from healthcare, qualifies as an “undue inaction”. In the criminal legal sense, the idea of “nonfeasance” refers to bringing about a result by not avoiding it, by violating a special duty, which equates with its causation—the prototypical example is the crime of failing to assist. Here the question not only of intentional omission but of neglect and abandonment comes into play. One example is the exclusion from healthcare and drugs of wide sectors of the Spanish population, not only undocumented migrants but also poor and unemployed people. The State is shamelessly neglecting important segments of the population, and causing harm—especially to the most vulnerable—by an ethically reprehensible omission of care. This case illustrates the need for defining what we have called “a public ethics of care” combining public ethics obligations with the responsibilities of care—since the ethics of care shapes government., This work has been sponsored by the Spanish Ministry of Economy and Competitiveness through its research project KONTUZ! (FFI2014-53926-R): www.kontuz.weebly.com; INBOTS (EU-H2020 grant agreement 780073); and EXTEND (EU-H2020 grant agreement 779982)., Peer reviewed
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publication Otros (Other)

Vulnerability and Care as Basis for an Environmental Ethics of Global Justice

  • Ausín, Txetxu
In this chapter I argue in the context of contemporary authors (I.M. Young, Butler, Tronto, Puyol) that there is no justice without care, nor democracy without a public vision of care, that situates it between an ecological ceiling that we should not have exceeded and a minimum floor of necessities below which we cannot live. An environmental ethics and one that is for global justice must by necessity pay attention to care and our essential and supervening condition as vulnerable and eco-interdependent., This work was done during a MEC-Salvador de Madariaga stay at the University College of Cork (Ireland) within the framework of the KONTUZ! research project (MINECO FFI2014-53926-R), Scientific Cooperation Project UNAM/CCHS-CSIC: ‘The principles of environmental ethics and global justice’, and INBOTS (EU HORIZON 2020 agr. 780073)., Peer reviewed
Docta Complutense
Publication Capítulo o parte de un libro (BookPart)

Broadening conscience? Positive conscientious objection against migrant healthcare exclusion

  • Triviño Caballero, Rosana
This work is aimed to analyze the difficulty of establishing clear limits between conscientious objection and civil disobedience taken as example the specific case of those healthcare professionals opposed to the Spanish Royal Decree 16/2012. The approval of this law, directed to the sustainability of the National Health System, meant a change in the previous configuration of the constitutional right to healthcare, characterized by being public and freely accessible to all the inhabitants in the country. As a consequence, undocumented migrant people had no longer a universal access to healthcare. In this situation, some healthcare professionals expressed their opposition to the law providing their services to undocumented patients. Might this behavior be considered a form of conscientious objection? Was a case of civil disobedience? Was just an act of altruism? Plausible answers to these questions will be argued along this paper.