Skip to main content

ENTENDIENDO COMO EL FEEDBACK RECIBIDO EN LAS REDES SOCIALES AFECTA AL CAMBIO DE CREENCIAS Y ACTITUDES A NIVEL INDIVIDUAL Y COLECTIVO

PID2019-105249GB-I00

•
Funding agency name Agencia Estatal de Investigación
Funding agency acronym AEI
Program Programa Estatal de I+D+i Orientado a los Retos de la Sociedad
Call Proyectos de I+D+i (Generación de Conocimiento y Retos Investigación)
Call year 2019
State Plan 2017-2020 Plan Estatal de Investigación Científica y Técnica y de Innovación
Beneficiary centre UNIVERSITAT POMPEU FABRA CCT

Resultados relacionados

Resultados totales (Incluyendo duplicados): 26
Encontrada(s) 1 página(s)

Repositorio Digital de la UPF
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Justification aversion: the road to more effective defaults

  • Banki, Daniel
  • Navarro-Martinez, Daniel
Default options are one of the most frequently used tools of choice architecture, yet the factors that influence their effectiveness remain imperfectly understood. As a way to improve the effectiveness of defaults, this paper explores the idea of adding a justification requirement if people want to switch away from the default. Across six pre-registered studies, we find a consistent justification aversion effect: Depending on the context, the requirement to justify one's choice results in a 22% to 58% increase in default adherence relative to comparable (non-justification) requirements. This effect is robust to different decision contexts and alternative switching requirements. We test various potential mechanisms, and the evidence is most consistent with image concerns associated with having to justify a socially undesirable deviation from the default. Importantly, image concerns do not appear to undermine socially desirable deviations from defaults., This research was supported by Fundación BBVA (BBVAEI-2019-D. Navarro), Fundación Ramón Areces (2019-Navarro), Ministerio de Ciencia e Innovación (PID2019-105249GB-I00; PID2022-137908NB- I00), and ICREA (Academia 2024-Daniel Navarro-Martinez).
Repositorio Digital de la UPF
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

The common behavior effect in norm learning: when frequent observations override the behavior of the majority

  • Woiczyk, Thomas Karl Alfred
  • Hosseini, Rahil
  • Le Mens, Gaël
Prior research suggests that descriptive norms correspond to what most people do-the "behavior of the majority." We examine norm perception in situations where the behavior of the majority differs from the most frequently observed behavior-the "common behavior." In environments where individuals learn descriptive norms through repeated observations of a reference group, we propose that perceived norms align more closely with the common behavior than with the behavior of the majority. Consequently, individuals are more likely to follow the common behavior, even when it differs from what most people do. We argue that this 'common behavior effect' arises from a combination of two factors: the structure of the information environments in which the behavior of the majority and the common behavior differ, and imperfect source memory of the observed behaviors. We provide evidence for the basic phenomenon and test two moderators in four studies reported in the body of the article and two ancillary studies reported in the appendix. These findings are important for our understanding of social norms, because they challenge the assumption that norms simply reflect the behavior of the majority. They also cast light on phenomena such as pluralistic ignorance, majority illusions in online and offline environments or the spread of misinformation on social media. Finally, they have practical implications for how to shape norms in organizations., This work was sup-ported by the European Commission (grants 772268 and MCIN/AEI/10.13039/501100011033 to G.L.M.), the Agencia Estatal de Investigación, Spain (grants PID2019-105249GB-I00 and PID2022-137908NB-I00 to G.L.M.; PID2023-152226NB-I00 to T.K.A.W; PID2022-140026NB-I00 to R.H), the Fundación BBVA, Spain (Grant G999088Q to G.L.M.), the Barcelona School of Economics (grant CEX2019-000915-S to G.L.M.), the Instituto Nacional de Ciberseguridad (Grant INCIBE-CYBERTHREAT C115/23 to R.H.) and the ICREA Academia (grant to G.L.M). Guillem Pros Rius provided excellent research assistance with programming for Study 2.
Repositorio Digital de la UPF
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

How politicians learn from citizens' feedback: the case of gender on Twitter

  • Schöll, Nikolas
  • Gallego Dobón, Aina
  • Le Mens, Gaël
Includes supplementary materials: online appendix; replication file., This article studies how politicians react to feedback from citizens on social media. We use a reinforcement-learning framework to model how politicians respond to citizens’ positive feedback by increasing attention to better received issues and allow feedback to vary depending on politicians’ gender. To test the model, we collect 1.5 million tweets published by Spanish MPs over 3 years, identify gender-issue tweets using a deep-learning algorithm (BERT) and measure feedback using retweets and likes. We find that citizens provide more positive feedback to female politicians for writing about gender, and that this contributes to their specialization in gender issues. The analysis of mechanisms suggests that female politicians receive more positive feedback because they are treated differently by citizens. To conclude, we discuss implications for representation, misperceptions, and polarization., The research leading to these results has received financial support from the project “Local politicians: selection and performance (LEADERS)” (CSO2016-79569-P) to Aina Gallego and from the grants AEI/FEDER UE-PSI201675353, PID2019-105249GB-I00/AEI/10.13039/501100011033, #RYC-2014-15035 to Gaël Le Mens, funded by the Spanish Ministry for the Economy, Industry and Competitiveness. It also benefited from funding from ERC Consolidator Grant #772268 and BBVA Foundation Grant G999088Q to Gaël Le Mens.
Repositorio Digital de la UPF
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Income and boredom: evidence from 30 countries

  • Pirla, Sergio
  • Navarro-Martinez, Daniel
  • Pfattheicher, Stefan
  • Quoidbach, Jordi
For decades, researchers, governments, and policymakers have sought to understand how financial scarcity affects people's well-being and quality of life. In this paper, we show that past studies have overlooked a fundamental psychological aspect of being poor: boredom. Using data from over 60,000 individuals across 30 countries, we find a robust negative association between income and daily experiences of boredom. In fact, compared with high-income earners, low-income individuals not only feel bored more often, but their experience of boredom is more closely linked to other negative states such as loneliness, worry, and anxiety. While the relationship between income and boredom does not differ between white- and blue-collar occupations, it is significantly stronger among individuals whose primary source of income consists of social transfers, such as unemployment benefits or pensions. Our results pave the way for future research and policies that take boredom into account and address the full extent of the psychological tax exerted by financial hardship., This research was funded by the Velux Foundations (PN38727), the BBVA Foundation, Spain (Fundacion BBVAEI-2019-D.Navarro), the Ramon Areces Foundation (Fundacion Ramon Areces 2019-Navarro), the Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation (Ministerio de Ciencia e Innovacion, Gobierno de España, Grants PID2019-105249GB-I00, PID2022-137908NB-I00), ICREA, Spain (ICREA Academia 2024-Daniel Navarro), and the Spanish Ministry of Economy, Industry, and Competitiveness (Ministerio de Economia, Industria y Competitividad, Gobierno de España, Grant RYC-2016-21020).
Repositorio Digital de la UPF
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Social media feedback and extreme opinion expression

  • Konovalova, Elizaveta
  • Le Mens, Gaël
  • Schöll, Nikolas
On popular social media platforms such as Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, or Tiktok, the quantitative feedback received by content producers is asymmetric: counts of positive reactions such as 'likes,' or 'retweets,' are easily observed but similar counts of negative reactions are not directly available. We study how this design feature of social media platforms affects the expression of extreme opinions. Using simulations of a learning model, we compare two feedback environments that differ in terms of the availability of negative reaction counts. We find that expressed opinions are generally more extreme when negative reaction counts are not available than when they are. We rely on analyses of Twitter data and several online experiments to provide empirical support for key model assumptions and test model predictions. Our findings suggest that a simple design change might limit, under certain conditions, the expression of extreme opinions on social media., G. Le Mens benefited from financial support from ERC Consolidator Grant \#772268 from the European Commission, an ICREA Academia grant, the Fundación BBVA Grant G999088Q, and the Agencia Estatal de Investigación (AEI), through grant PID2019-105249GB-I00/AEI/10.13039/501100011033. G. Le Mens also acknowledge financial support from the Severo Ochoa Programme for Centres of Excellence in R\&D (Barcelona School of Economics CEX2019-000915-S), funded by MCIN/AEI/10.13039/501100011033.
Repositorio Digital de la UPF
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Evaluating categories from experience: the simple averaging heuristic

  • Woiczyk, Thomas Karl Alfred
  • Le Mens, Gaël
Includes experimental data and R scripts used to create the analyses, figures, and tables of the experiments., We analyze how people form evaluative judgments about categories based on their experiences with category members. Prior research suggests that such evaluative judgments depend on some experience average, but is unclear about the specific kind of average. We hypothesized that evaluations of categories could be driven either by the ‘simple average’ of experiences with the category or by the ‘member average’ (the average of the evaluations of the category members, where the evaluation of a category member is the average of experiences with this particular member). Understanding whether evaluations of categories are driven by the ‘simple average’ or the ‘member average’ is important in settings where people obtain unbalanced numbers of observations about category members such as when people form opinions about a social group and predominantly interact with just a few members of this group. Across 9 studies (N=1,966), we consistently found that evaluative judgments about categories were better explained by the simple average than by the member average. We call the underlying cognitive strategy the ‘simple averaging heuristic.’ Collected evidence indicates that participants relied on simple averaging even in settings where normative principles required avoiding the use of this cognitive strategy, leading to systematic mistakes. Our findings contribute to several areas of social cognition such as research on redundancy biases, information aggregation, social sampling, and norm perceptions., G. Le Mens benefited from financial support from grants #AEI/FEDER UE-PSI2016-75353, PID2019-105249GB-I00/AEI/10.13039/501100011033 and RYC-2014-15035 from the Spanish Ministerio de Ciencia, Innovacion y Universidades (MCIU) and the Agencia Estatal de Investigacion (AEI), ERC Consolidator Grant #772268 from the European Commission and BBVA Fundation Grant G999088Q. T. Woiczyk benefited from financial support from grant BES-2015-073750 from the Spanish MINECO.
Repositorio Digital de la UPF
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

The endowment effect in the future: how time shapes buying and selling prices

  • Yamamoto, Shohei
  • Navarro-Martinez, Daniel
Includes supplementary materials: replication file; experimental instructions., Previous research has focused on studying the endowment effect for transactions that take place in the present. Many real-world transactions, however, are delayed into the future (i.e., people agree to buy or sell, but the actual transaction does not materialize until a later time). Here we investigate how transaction timing affects the endowment effect. In five studies, we show that the endowment effect systematically increases as transactions are delayed into the future. Specifically, buying prices significantly decrease as the transaction is delayed, while selling prices remain constant, resulting in an amplified endowment effect (Experiment 1). This pattern is not produced by a discounting of the money involved in the transaction (Experiment 2), and it holds across different types of items (Experiment 3). We also show that the phenomenon cannot be explained by sellers anticipating becoming increasingly attached to the items over time (Experiment 4). Finally, we demonstrate that this increased endowment effect in the future holds in the field, in the context of a real market and with real transactions (Experiment 5)., The authors acknowledge financial support from the Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation (grant PID2019–105249GB–I00), the BBVA foundation (grant Fundacion BBVA–EI–2019-D.Navarro) and the Ramon Areces foundation (grant Fundacion Ramon Areces 2019-Navarro).
Repositorio Digital de la UPF
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Bridging the gap between the economics lab and the field: dictator games and donations

  • Wang, Xinghua
  • Navarro-Martinez, Daniel
There is growing concern about the extent to which economic games played in the laboratory generalize to social behaviors outside the lab. Here, we show that it is possible to make a game much more predictive of field behavior by bringing contextual elements from the field to the lab. We report three experiments where we present the same participants with different versions of the dictator game and with two different field situations. The games are designed to include elements that make them progressively more similar to the field. We find a dramatic increase in lab–field correlations as contextual elements are incorporated, which has wide-ranging implications for experiments on economic decision making., The authors gratefully acknowledge financial support from the Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation (grant PID2019-105249GB-I00), the BBVA Foundation (grant Fundacion BBVA-EI-2019-D.Navarro), and the Ramon Areces Foundation (grant Fundacion Ramon Areces 2019-Navarro).
Repositorio Digital de la UPF
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Does boredom affect economic risk preferences?

  • Ventura Pirla López, Sergio
  • Navarro-Martinez, Daniel
Includes supplementary materials: replication file; experimental instructions., Previous literature and conventional wisdom have led researchers to believe that boredom increases economic risk taking, but the evidence in support of this conclusion is limited and has important shortcomings. In four experiments (including more than 1,300 subjects), we systematically studied the effects of boredom on economic risk preferences. Across different risk elicitation tasks, boredom inductions, incentive schemes, subject pools, and using both reduced form and structural analyses, we consistently failed to find an effect of boredom on risky decisions. Our results disprove that boredom leads to even small increments in risk taking in one-shot elicitation tasks, and small to medium increases in multiple-choice elicitations. These findings question an important established belief, contribute to better understand the consequences of boredom, and have substantive implications for experiments on economic decision making., This research was funded by the BBVA Foundation (Fundacion BBVA-EI-2019-D.Navarro), Ramon Areces Foundation (Fundacion Ramon Areces 2019-Navarro), Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation (PID2019-105249GB-I00), and the Velux Foundations (PN38727).
Repositorio Digital de la UPF
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

The elusiveness of context effects in decision making

  • Spektor, Mikhail
  • Bhatia, Sudeep
  • Gluth, Sebastian
Contextual features influence human and non-human decision making, giving rise to preference reversals. Decades of research have documented the species and situations in which these effects are observed. More recently, however, researchers have focused on boundary conditions, that is, settings in which established effects disappear or reverse. This work is scattered across academic disciplines, and some results appear to contradict each other. We synthesize recent findings and resolve apparent contradictions by considering them in terms of three core categories of decision context: spatial arrangement, attribute concreteness, and deliberation time. We suggest that these categories could be understood using theories of choice representation, which specify how context shapes the information over which deliberation processes operate., M.S.S. gratefully acknowledges financial support from the Spanish State Research Agency (AEI) through the Severo Ochoa Programme for Centres of Excellence in R&D (CEX2019–000915–S), the Spanish Ministry of Economic Affairs and Digital Transformation (MINECO) through the Juan de la Cierva fellowship (FJC2019–040970–I), the Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation (MICINN; project PID2019–105249GB–I00), and the BBVA Foundation (project G999088Q). S.B. acknowledges support from the National Science Foundation (SES–1847794). S.G. acknowledges support from the European Research Council (ERC) under the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme (Grant agreement No. 948545)., info:eu-repo/grantAgreement/ES/2PE/PID2019-105249GB-I00
Repositorio Digital de la UPF
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Searching for the external validity of social preference games: a guide of field environments based on expert perceptions

  • Navarro-Martinez, Daniel
  • Pirla Lopez, Sergio
The last couple of decades have witnessed a lively debate on the external validity of social preference games. Yet, scientific progress in this area has been restrained by the difficulty of delineating the field environments that social preference games should generalize to. Here we present three studies investigating the field environments and behaviors to which social preference games are expected to relate, according to specialist researchers. In Study 1, we systematically reviewed all the papers published in the top 5 economics journals that used social preference games, and we analyzed the field settings explicitly linked to the games by the authors. In Study 2, we used large language models to expand our analysis of the literature beyond the top 5. In Study 3, we conducted a survey among members of the Economic Science Association (ESA) mailing list to investigate the field environments they viewed as most closely associated with different social preference games. Overall, our results provide a rich guide to the types of field settings that are expected to relate to social preference games, according to the people who use them. This guide constitutes a useful reference to organize future research on external validity and make it more systematic., This research was funded by the BBVA Foundation, Spain (Fundacion BBVA-EI-2019-D.Navarro), the Ramon Areces Foundation (Fundacion Ramon Areces 2019-Navarro), the Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation (PID2019-105249GB-I00, PID2022-137908NB-I00), and ICREA (ICREA Academia 2024-Daniel Navarro).
Repositorio Digital de la UPF
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Violations of economic rationality due to irrelevant information during learning in decision from experience

  • Spektor, Mikhail
  • Seidler, Hannah
According to normative decision-making theories, the composition of a choice set should not affect people’s preferences regarding the different options. This assumption contrasts with decades of research that have identified multiple situations in which this principle is violated, leading to context effects. Recently, research on context effects has been extended to the domain of experience-based choices, where it has been shown that forgone outcomes from irrelevant alternatives affect preferences — an accentuation effect. More specifically, it has been shown that an option presented in a situation in which its outcomes are salient across several trials is evaluated more positively than in a context in which its outcomes are less salient. In the present study, we investigated whether irrelevant information affects preferences as much as relevant information. In two experiments, individuals completed a learning task with partial feedback. We found that past outcomes from non-chosen options, which contain no relevant information at all, led to the same accentuation effect as did counterfactual outcomes that provided new and relevant information. However, if the information is entirely irrelevant (from options that could not have been chosen), individuals ignored it, thus ruling out a purely perceptual account of the accentuation effect. These results provide further support for the influence of salience on learning and highlight the necessity of mechanistic accounts in decision-making research., The authors thank David Kellen for helpful comments and suggestions. Mikhail Spektor gratefully acknowledges financial support from the Spanish State Research Agency (AEI) through the Severo Ochoa Programme for Centres of Excellence in R&D (CEX2019–000915–S), the Spanish Ministry of Economic Affairs and Digital Transformation (MINECO) through the Juan de la Cierva fellowship (FJC2019–040970–I), the Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation (MICINN; project PID2019–105249GB–I00), and the BBVA Foundation (project G999088Q). Data of the reported experiments and model codes are available at https://osf.io/s52z8/. 1 Notably, the influence of distinctiveness is assumed to be sign-independent, so X would be chosen more often following a relatively bad-but-salient outcome than in a situation in which the same outcome is not as salient (e.g., when there are only two options available for choice).
Repositorio Digital de la UPF
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Using machine learning to uncover the semantics of concepts: how well do typicality measures extracted from a BERT text classifier match human judgments of genre typicality?

  • Le Mens, Gaël
  • Kovács, Balázs
  • Hannan, Michael T.
  • Pros Rius, Guillem
Includes data, material, and analysis code for all analyses., Social scientists have long been interested in understanding the extent to which the typicalities of an object in concepts relate to its valuations by social actors. Answering this question has proven to be challenging because precise measurement requires a feature-based description of objects. Yet, such descriptions are frequently unavailable. In this article, we introduce a method to measure typicality based on text data. Our approach involves training a deep-learning text classifier based on the BERT language representation and defining the typicality of an object in a concept in terms of the categorization probability produced by the trained classifier. Model training allows for the construction of a feature space adapted to the categorization task and of a mapping between feature combination and typicality that gives more weight to feature dimensions that matter more for categorization. We validate the approach by comparing the BERT-based typicality measure of book descriptions in literary genres with average human typicality ratings. The obtained correlation is higher than 0.85. Comparisons with other typicality measures used in prior research show that our BERT-based measure better reflects human typicality judgments., Pros received financial support from ERC Consolidator Grant #772268 from the European Commission. G. Le Mens also received financial support from grant PID2019-105249GB-I00/AEI/10.13039/501100011033 from the Spanish Ministerio de Ciencia, Innovacion y Universidades (MCIU) and the Agencia Estatal de Investigacion (AEI) and from the BBVA Foundation Grant G999088Q.
Zaguán. Repositorio Digital de la Universidad de Zaragoza
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Searching for the external validity of social preference games: A guide of field environments based on expert perceptions

  • Navarro-Martinez, Daniel
  • Pirla, Sergio
The last couple of decades have witnessed a lively debate on the external validity of social preference games. Yet, scientific progress in this area has been restrained by the difficulty of delineating the field environments that social preference games should generalize to. Here we present three studies investigating the field environments and behaviors to which social preference games are expected to relate, according to specialist researchers. In Study 1, we systematically reviewed all the papers published in the top 5 economics journals that used social preference games, and we analyzed the field settings explicitly linked to the games by the authors. In Study 2, we used large language models to expand our analysis of the literature beyond the top 5. In Study 3, we conducted a survey among members of the Economic Science Association (ESA) mailing list to investigate the field environments they viewed as most closely associated with different social preference games. Overall, our results provide a rich guide to the types of field settings that are expected to relate to social preference games, according to the people who use them. This guide constitutes a useful reference to organize future research on external validity and make it more systematic.
Recercat. Dipósit de la Recerca de Catalunya
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Using machine learning to uncover the semantics of concepts: how well do typicality measures extracted from a BERT text classifier match human judgments of genre typicality?

  • Le Mens, Gaël
  • Kovács, Balázs
  • Hannan, Michael T.
  • Pros Rius, Guillem
Includes data, material, and analysis code for all analyses., Social scientists have long been interested in understanding the extent to which the typicalities of an object in concepts relate to its valuations by social actors. Answering this question has proven to be challenging because precise measurement requires a feature-based description of objects. Yet, such descriptions are frequently unavailable. In this article, we introduce a method to measure typicality based on text data. Our approach involves training a deep-learning text classifier based on the BERT language representation and defining the typicality of an object in a concept in terms of the categorization probability produced by the trained classifier. Model training allows for the construction of a feature space adapted to the categorization task and of a mapping between feature combination and typicality that gives more weight to feature dimensions that matter more for categorization. We validate the approach by comparing the BERT-based typicality measure of book descriptions in literary genres with average human typicality ratings. The obtained correlation is higher than 0.85. Comparisons with other typicality measures used in prior research show that our BERT-based measure better reflects human typicality judgments., Pros received financial support from ERC Consolidator Grant #772268 from the European Commission. G. Le Mens also received financial support from grant PID2019-105249GB-I00/AEI/10.13039/501100011033 from the Spanish Ministerio de Ciencia, Innovacion y Universidades (MCIU) and the Agencia Estatal de Investigacion (AEI) and from the BBVA Foundation Grant G999088Q.
Recercat. Dipósit de la Recerca de Catalunya
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Does boredom affect economic risk preferences?

  • Ventura Pirla López, Sergio
  • Navarro-Martinez, Daniel
Includes supplementary materials: replication file; experimental instructions., Previous literature and conventional wisdom have led researchers to believe that boredom increases economic risk taking, but the evidence in support of this conclusion is limited and has important shortcomings. In four experiments (including more than 1,300 subjects), we systematically studied the effects of boredom on economic risk preferences. Across different risk elicitation tasks, boredom inductions, incentive schemes, subject pools, and using both reduced form and structural analyses, we consistently failed to find an effect of boredom on risky decisions. Our results disprove that boredom leads to even small increments in risk taking in one-shot elicitation tasks, and small to medium increases in multiple-choice elicitations. These findings question an important established belief, contribute to better understand the consequences of boredom, and have substantive implications for experiments on economic decision making., This research was funded by the BBVA Foundation (Fundacion BBVA-EI-2019-D.Navarro), Ramon Areces Foundation (Fundacion Ramon Areces 2019-Navarro), Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation (PID2019-105249GB-I00), and the Velux Foundations (PN38727).
Recercat. Dipósit de la Recerca de Catalunya
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Evaluating categories from experience: the simple averaging heuristic

  • Woiczyk, Thomas Karl Alfred
  • Le Mens, Gaël
Includes experimental data and R scripts used to create the analyses, figures, and tables of the experiments., We analyze how people form evaluative judgments about categories based on their experiences with category members. Prior research suggests that such evaluative judgments depend on some experience average, but is unclear about the specific kind of average. We hypothesized that evaluations of categories could be driven either by the ‘simple average’ of experiences with the category or by the ‘member average’ (the average of the evaluations of the category members, where the evaluation of a category member is the average of experiences with this particular member). Understanding whether evaluations of categories are driven by the ‘simple average’ or the ‘member average’ is important in settings where people obtain unbalanced numbers of observations about category members such as when people form opinions about a social group and predominantly interact with just a few members of this group. Across 9 studies (N=1,966), we consistently found that evaluative judgments about categories were better explained by the simple average than by the member average. We call the underlying cognitive strategy the ‘simple averaging heuristic.’ Collected evidence indicates that participants relied on simple averaging even in settings where normative principles required avoiding the use of this cognitive strategy, leading to systematic mistakes. Our findings contribute to several areas of social cognition such as research on redundancy biases, information aggregation, social sampling, and norm perceptions., G. Le Mens benefited from financial support from grants #AEI/FEDER UE-PSI2016-75353, PID2019-105249GB-I00/AEI/10.13039/501100011033 and RYC-2014-15035 from the Spanish Ministerio de Ciencia, Innovacion y Universidades (MCIU) and the Agencia Estatal de Investigacion (AEI), ERC Consolidator Grant #772268 from the European Commission and BBVA Fundation Grant G999088Q. T. Woiczyk benefited from financial support from grant BES-2015-073750 from the Spanish MINECO.
Recercat. Dipósit de la Recerca de Catalunya
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Violations of economic rationality due to irrelevant information during learning in decision from experience

  • Spektor, Mikhail
  • Seidler, Hannah
According to normative decision-making theories, the composition of a choice set should not affect people’s preferences regarding the different options. This assumption contrasts with decades of research that have identified multiple situations in which this principle is violated, leading to context effects. Recently, research on context effects has been extended to the domain of experience-based choices, where it has been shown that forgone outcomes from irrelevant alternatives affect preferences — an accentuation effect. More specifically, it has been shown that an option presented in a situation in which its outcomes are salient across several trials is evaluated more positively than in a context in which its outcomes are less salient. In the present study, we investigated whether irrelevant information affects preferences as much as relevant information. In two experiments, individuals completed a learning task with partial feedback. We found that past outcomes from non-chosen options, which contain no relevant information at all, led to the same accentuation effect as did counterfactual outcomes that provided new and relevant information. However, if the information is entirely irrelevant (from options that could not have been chosen), individuals ignored it, thus ruling out a purely perceptual account of the accentuation effect. These results provide further support for the influence of salience on learning and highlight the necessity of mechanistic accounts in decision-making research., The authors thank David Kellen for helpful comments and suggestions. Mikhail Spektor gratefully acknowledges financial support from the Spanish State Research Agency (AEI) through the Severo Ochoa Programme for Centres of Excellence in R&D (CEX2019–000915–S), the Spanish Ministry of Economic Affairs and Digital Transformation (MINECO) through the Juan de la Cierva fellowship (FJC2019–040970–I), the Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation (MICINN; project PID2019–105249GB–I00), and the BBVA Foundation (project G999088Q). Data of the reported experiments and model codes are available at https://osf.io/s52z8/. 1 Notably, the influence of distinctiveness is assumed to be sign-independent, so X would be chosen more often following a relatively bad-but-salient outcome than in a situation in which the same outcome is not as salient (e.g., when there are only two options available for choice).
Recercat. Dipósit de la Recerca de Catalunya
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Bridging the gap between the economics lab and the field: dictator games and donations

  • Wang, Xinghua
  • Navarro-Martinez, Daniel
There is growing concern about the extent to which economic games played in the laboratory generalize to social behaviors outside the lab. Here, we show that it is possible to make a game much more predictive of field behavior by bringing contextual elements from the field to the lab. We report three experiments where we present the same participants with different versions of the dictator game and with two different field situations. The games are designed to include elements that make them progressively more similar to the field. We find a dramatic increase in lab–field correlations as contextual elements are incorporated, which has wide-ranging implications for experiments on economic decision making., The authors gratefully acknowledge financial support from the Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation (grant PID2019-105249GB-I00), the BBVA Foundation (grant Fundacion BBVA-EI-2019-D.Navarro), and the Ramon Areces Foundation (grant Fundacion Ramon Areces 2019-Navarro).
Recercat. Dipósit de la Recerca de Catalunya
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

The elusiveness of context effects in decision making

  • Spektor, Mikhail
  • Bhatia, Sudeep
  • Gluth, Sebastian
Contextual features influence human and non-human decision making, giving rise to preference reversals. Decades of research have documented the species and situations in which these effects are observed. More recently, however, researchers have focused on boundary conditions, that is, settings in which established effects disappear or reverse. This work is scattered across academic disciplines, and some results appear to contradict each other. We synthesize recent findings and resolve apparent contradictions by considering them in terms of three core categories of decision context: spatial arrangement, attribute concreteness, and deliberation time. We suggest that these categories could be understood using theories of choice representation, which specify how context shapes the information over which deliberation processes operate., M.S.S. gratefully acknowledges financial support from the Spanish State Research Agency (AEI) through the Severo Ochoa Programme for Centres of Excellence in R&D (CEX2019–000915–S), the Spanish Ministry of Economic Affairs and Digital Transformation (MINECO) through the Juan de la Cierva fellowship (FJC2019–040970–I), the Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation (MICINN; project PID2019–105249GB–I00), and the BBVA Foundation (project G999088Q). S.B. acknowledges support from the National Science Foundation (SES–1847794). S.G. acknowledges support from the European Research Council (ERC) under the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme (Grant agreement No. 948545).
Recercat. Dipósit de la Recerca de Catalunya
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Searching for the external validity of social preference games: a guide of field environments based on expert perceptions

  • Navarro-Martinez, Daniel
  • Pirla Lopez, Sergio
The last couple of decades have witnessed a lively debate on the external validity of social preference games. Yet, scientific progress in this area has been restrained by the difficulty of delineating the field environments that social preference games should generalize to. Here we present three studies investigating the field environments and behaviors to which social preference games are expected to relate, according to specialist researchers. In Study 1, we systematically reviewed all the papers published in the top 5 economics journals that used social preference games, and we analyzed the field settings explicitly linked to the games by the authors. In Study 2, we used large language models to expand our analysis of the literature beyond the top 5. In Study 3, we conducted a survey among members of the Economic Science Association (ESA) mailing list to investigate the field environments they viewed as most closely associated with different social preference games. Overall, our results provide a rich guide to the types of field settings that are expected to relate to social preference games, according to the people who use them. This guide constitutes a useful reference to organize future research on external validity and make it more systematic., This research was funded by the BBVA Foundation, Spain (Fundacion BBVA-EI-2019-D.Navarro), the Ramon Areces Foundation (Fundacion Ramon Areces 2019-Navarro), the Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation (PID2019-105249GB-I00, PID2022-137908NB-I00), and ICREA (ICREA Academia 2024-Daniel Navarro).
Recercat. Dipósit de la Recerca de Catalunya
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

The common behavior effect in norm learning: when frequent observations override the behavior of the majority

  • Woiczyk, Thomas Karl Alfred
  • Hosseini, Rahil
  • Le Mens, Gaël
Prior research suggests that descriptive norms correspond to what most people do-the "behavior of the majority." We examine norm perception in situations where the behavior of the majority differs from the most frequently observed behavior-the "common behavior." In environments where individuals learn descriptive norms through repeated observations of a reference group, we propose that perceived norms align more closely with the common behavior than with the behavior of the majority. Consequently, individuals are more likely to follow the common behavior, even when it differs from what most people do. We argue that this 'common behavior effect' arises from a combination of two factors: the structure of the information environments in which the behavior of the majority and the common behavior differ, and imperfect source memory of the observed behaviors. We provide evidence for the basic phenomenon and test two moderators in four studies reported in the body of the article and two ancillary studies reported in the appendix. These findings are important for our understanding of social norms, because they challenge the assumption that norms simply reflect the behavior of the majority. They also cast light on phenomena such as pluralistic ignorance, majority illusions in online and offline environments or the spread of misinformation on social media. Finally, they have practical implications for how to shape norms in organizations., This work was sup-ported by the European Commission (grants 772268 and MCIN/AEI/10.13039/501100011033 to G.L.M.), the Agencia Estatal de Investigación, Spain (grants PID2019-105249GB-I00 and PID2022-137908NB-I00 to G.L.M.; PID2023-152226NB-I00 to T.K.A.W; PID2022-140026NB-I00 to R.H), the Fundación BBVA, Spain (Grant G999088Q to G.L.M.), the Barcelona School of Economics (grant CEX2019-000915-S to G.L.M.), the Instituto Nacional de Ciberseguridad (Grant INCIBE-CYBERTHREAT C115/23 to R.H.) and the ICREA Academia (grant to G.L.M). Guillem Pros Rius provided excellent research assistance with programming for Study 2.
Recercat. Dipósit de la Recerca de Catalunya
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

How politicians learn from citizens' feedback: the case of gender on Twitter

  • Schöll, Nikolas
  • Gallego Dobón, Aina
  • Le Mens, Gaël
Includes supplementary materials: online appendix; replication file., This article studies how politicians react to feedback from citizens on social media. We use a reinforcement-learning framework to model how politicians respond to citizens’ positive feedback by increasing attention to better received issues and allow feedback to vary depending on politicians’ gender. To test the model, we collect 1.5 million tweets published by Spanish MPs over 3 years, identify gender-issue tweets using a deep-learning algorithm (BERT) and measure feedback using retweets and likes. We find that citizens provide more positive feedback to female politicians for writing about gender, and that this contributes to their specialization in gender issues. The analysis of mechanisms suggests that female politicians receive more positive feedback because they are treated differently by citizens. To conclude, we discuss implications for representation, misperceptions, and polarization., The research leading to these results has received financial support from the project “Local politicians: selection and performance (LEADERS)” (CSO2016-79569-P) to Aina Gallego and from the grants AEI/FEDER UE-PSI201675353, PID2019-105249GB-I00/AEI/10.13039/501100011033, #RYC-2014-15035 to Gaël Le Mens, funded by the Spanish Ministry for the Economy, Industry and Competitiveness. It also benefited from funding from ERC Consolidator Grant #772268 and BBVA Foundation Grant G999088Q to Gaël Le Mens.
Recercat. Dipósit de la Recerca de Catalunya
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Income and boredom: evidence from 30 countries

  • Pirla, Sergio
  • Navarro-Martinez, Daniel
  • Pfattheicher, Stefan
  • Quoidbach, Jordi
For decades, researchers, governments, and policymakers have sought to understand how financial scarcity affects people's well-being and quality of life. In this paper, we show that past studies have overlooked a fundamental psychological aspect of being poor: boredom. Using data from over 60,000 individuals across 30 countries, we find a robust negative association between income and daily experiences of boredom. In fact, compared with high-income earners, low-income individuals not only feel bored more often, but their experience of boredom is more closely linked to other negative states such as loneliness, worry, and anxiety. While the relationship between income and boredom does not differ between white- and blue-collar occupations, it is significantly stronger among individuals whose primary source of income consists of social transfers, such as unemployment benefits or pensions. Our results pave the way for future research and policies that take boredom into account and address the full extent of the psychological tax exerted by financial hardship., This research was funded by the Velux Foundations (PN38727), the BBVA Foundation, Spain (Fundacion BBVAEI-2019-D.Navarro), the Ramon Areces Foundation (Fundacion Ramon Areces 2019-Navarro), the Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation (Ministerio de Ciencia e Innovacion, Gobierno de España, Grants PID2019-105249GB-I00, PID2022-137908NB-I00), ICREA, Spain (ICREA Academia 2024-Daniel Navarro), and the Spanish Ministry of Economy, Industry, and Competitiveness (Ministerio de Economia, Industria y Competitividad, Gobierno de España, Grant RYC-2016-21020).
Recercat. Dipósit de la Recerca de Catalunya
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Social media feedback and extreme opinion expression

  • Konovalova, Elizaveta
  • Le Mens, Gaël
  • Schöll, Nikolas
On popular social media platforms such as Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, or Tiktok, the quantitative feedback received by content producers is asymmetric: counts of positive reactions such as 'likes,' or 'retweets,' are easily observed but similar counts of negative reactions are not directly available. We study how this design feature of social media platforms affects the expression of extreme opinions. Using simulations of a learning model, we compare two feedback environments that differ in terms of the availability of negative reaction counts. We find that expressed opinions are generally more extreme when negative reaction counts are not available than when they are. We rely on analyses of Twitter data and several online experiments to provide empirical support for key model assumptions and test model predictions. Our findings suggest that a simple design change might limit, under certain conditions, the expression of extreme opinions on social media., G. Le Mens benefited from financial support from ERC Consolidator Grant \#772268 from the European Commission, an ICREA Academia grant, the Fundación BBVA Grant G999088Q, and the Agencia Estatal de Investigación (AEI), through grant PID2019-105249GB-I00/AEI/10.13039/501100011033. G. Le Mens also acknowledge financial support from the Severo Ochoa Programme for Centres of Excellence in R\&D (Barcelona School of Economics CEX2019-000915-S), funded by MCIN/AEI/10.13039/501100011033.
Recercat. Dipósit de la Recerca de Catalunya
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

The endowment effect in the future: how time shapes buying and selling prices

  • Yamamoto, Shohei
  • Navarro-Martinez, Daniel
Includes supplementary materials: replication file; experimental instructions., Previous research has focused on studying the endowment effect for transactions that take place in the present. Many real-world transactions, however, are delayed into the future (i.e., people agree to buy or sell, but the actual transaction does not materialize until a later time). Here we investigate how transaction timing affects the endowment effect. In five studies, we show that the endowment effect systematically increases as transactions are delayed into the future. Specifically, buying prices significantly decrease as the transaction is delayed, while selling prices remain constant, resulting in an amplified endowment effect (Experiment 1). This pattern is not produced by a discounting of the money involved in the transaction (Experiment 2), and it holds across different types of items (Experiment 3). We also show that the phenomenon cannot be explained by sellers anticipating becoming increasingly attached to the items over time (Experiment 4). Finally, we demonstrate that this increased endowment effect in the future holds in the field, in the context of a real market and with real transactions (Experiment 5)., The authors acknowledge financial support from the Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation (grant PID2019–105249GB–I00), the BBVA foundation (grant Fundacion BBVA–EI–2019-D.Navarro) and the Ramon Areces foundation (grant Fundacion Ramon Areces 2019-Navarro).